Mechanisms of chromosomal aberration production I. Aberration induction by ultraviolet light

We have studied chromosomal aberration production in V-79 Chinese hamster tissue culture cells by UV light administered during the post-DNA-synthetic G₂ phase of the cell cycle. The treatment produced achromatic lesions and some chromatid deletions in the first post-irradiation mitosis, but no isochromatid deletions or chromatid exchange aberrations. In contrast, when G₂ UV-irradiated cells were examined in their second post-irradiation mitosis, there were significant yields of chromatid-type aberrations of all types, including isochromatid deletions and chromatid exchanges.

We have earlier reported²¹ that UV-irradiation during the pre-DNA-synthetic G₁ phase of the cell cycle induces only chromatid aberrations and also that most chromosomal aberration production by UV in G₁ can be photoreactivated in cells possessing the photoreactivating enzyme. We present here a model for chromosomal aberration production by UV. In the model all aberration production is enzymatically mediated, a consequence of the functioning of known molecular repair mechanisms. The important elements in the model are the following:

1. (1) The vertebrate chromosome is mononeme; i.e., contains but a single DNA double helix during the prereplication G₁ phase of the cell cycle.

2. (2) The UV-induced DNA lesion leading to the production of most aberrations is the cyclobutane dimer between adjacent pyrimidines in one polynucleotide strand.

3. (3) Single chain breaks appear at metaphase as achromatic lesions.

4. (4) Dimer removal sometimes leaves unrepaired single chain gaps, possibly as a result of incomplete excision repair.

5. (5) The single-stranded DNA opposite a single chain gap can be cleaved by a single-strand DNAase.

6. (6) Gaps are left in newly synthesized DNA polynucleotide chains opposite defective template chains (i.e., opposite dimers and chain breaks).

7. (7) Double-strand breaks present following local DNA replication may “spread” to the other chromatid by a recombinational process between template and new polynucleotide chains, one from each of the homologous double helices.

The model predicts the occurrence of isoachromatic lesions and of chromatid deletions paired (isolocus) with achromatic lesions. Though often not reported, both do, in fact, occur. In addition, the model accounts for the phenomenon of sister-chromatid exchange as a manifestation of a recombinational, or post-replication, repair mechanism. Finally, the model offers a simple interpretation of chromosomal aberration production by a variety of chemical agents.     

The induction of chromatid deletions in accord with the breakage-and-reunion hypothesis.

In the present experiments it has been possible to study large numbers of X-ray induced chromatid deletions, or breads, in Chinese hamster chromosomes and to discern whether or not a sister chromatid exchange also occurs at the point of breadage. Chromatid deletions are only infrequently associated with a sister chromatid exchange. This is contrary to the expectations derived from the exchange hypothesis of Revell. Pn the basis of this hypothesis, in which chromatid deletions are considered to be incomplete exchanges that occur in the necks of little loops in the chromosomes, 40% of the chromatid breaks are expected to be associated with sister chromatid exchanges. The present data are in accord with the conclusions drawn from the earlier autoradiographic experiments of HEDDLE AND BODYCOTE, and show that chromatide breaks can be accounted for on the basis of the breakage-and reunion hypothesis, with the majority being simple breaks and some being incomplete exchanges between two such breaks.     

Loss of heterozygosity in yeast can occur by ultraviolet irradiation during the S phase of the cell cycle

A CAN1/can1Δ heterozygous allele that determines loss of heterozygosity (LOH) was used to study recombination in Saccharomyces cerevisiae cells exposed to ultraviolet (UV) light at different points in the cell cycle. With this allele, recombination events can be detected as canavanine-resistant mutations after exposure of cells to UV radiation, since a significant fraction of LOH events appear to arise from recombination between homologous chromosomes. The radiation caused a higher level of LOH in cells that were in the S phase of the cell cycle relative to either cells at other points in the cell cycle or unsynchronized cells. In contrast, the inactivation of nucleotide excision repair abolished the cell cycle-specific induction by UV of LOH. We hypothesize that DNA lesions, if not repaired, were converted into double-strand breaks during stalled replication and these breaks could be repaired through recombination using a non-sister chromatid and probably also the sister chromatid. We argue that LOH may be an outcome used by yeast cells to recover from stalled replication at a lesion.     

Progress towards understanding the nature of chromatid breakage

The wide range of sensitivities of stimulated T-cells from different individuals to radiation-induced chromatid breakage indicates the involvement of several low penetrance genes that appear to link elevated chromatid breakage to cancer susceptibility. The mechanisms of chromatid breakage are not yet fully understood. However, evidence is accumulating that suggests chromatid breaks are not simply expanded DNA double-strand breaks (DSB). Three models of chromatid breakage are considered. The classical breakage-first and the Revell "exchange" models do not accord with current evidence. Therefore a derivative of Revell's model has been proposed whereby both spontaneous and radiation-induced chromatid breaks result from DSB signaling and rearrangement processes from within large looped chromatin domains. Examples of such rearrangements can be observed by harlequin staining whereby an exchange of strands occurs immediately adjacent to the break site. However, these interchromatid rearrangements comprise less than 20% of the total breaks. The rest are thought to result from intrachromatid rearrangements, including a very small proportion involving complete excision of a looped domain. Work is in progress with the aim of revealing these rearrangements, which may involve the formation of inversions adjacent to the break sites. It is postulated that the disappearance of chromatid breaks with time results from the completion of such rearrangements, rather than from the rejoining of DSB. Elevated frequencies of chromatid breaks occur in irradiated cells with defects in both nonhomologous end-joining (NHEJ) and homologous recombination (HR) pathways, however there is little evidence of a correlation between reduced DSB rejoining and disappearance of chromatid breaks. Moreover, at least one treatment which abrogates the disappearance of chromatid breaks with time leaves DSB rejoining unaffected. The I-SceI DSB system holds considerable promise for the elucidation of these mechanisms, although the break frequency is relatively low in the cell lines so far derived. Techniques to study and improve such systems are under way in different cell lines. Clearly, much remains to be done to clarify the mechanisms involved in chromatid breakage, but the experimental models are becoming available with which we can begin to answer some of the key questions.     

Mechanisms of chromosomal aberration production II. Aberrations induced by 5-bromodeoxyuridine and visible light

We have allowed synchronized V79B Chinese hamster tissue culture cells to incorporate 5-bromodeoxyuridine (BUdR) during one DNA synthetic (S) period of the cell cycle and then determined chromosomal aberration yields induced by illumination of the cells with visible light during the succeeding pre- and post-DNA-synthetic (G₁and G₂) phases of the cell cycle. At the level used, BUdR by itself induces no aberrations. Illumination during the G₁ phase following incorporation induces aberrations of the chromatid type, but none of the chromosome type. All types of chromatid aberrations are induced, including isochromatid deletions and exchange types. In contrast, when cells are illuminated during the immediately following G₂ phase, large numbers of achromatic lesions and chromatic deletions are seen at the first post-illumination mitosis, but no isochromatid deletions and few exchange-type aberrations occur. When G₂-illuminated cells are examined in their second mitosis, however, chromatid aberrations of all types are again seen.

These results are interpreted within the “repair” model of chromosomal aberration production by UV light presented earlier³. The model assumes that the vertebrate chromosome is mononeme, consisting of but a single DNA double helix during the prereplication G₁ phase. The initial lesions induced by illumination of BUdR-containing DNA are believed to be single-chain breaks, and the observation that G₁ illumination produces only chromatid-type aberrations is taken as additional evidence for the mononeme chromosome. Conversion of single-chain breaks into double chain breaks through the action of a single-strand nuclease is postulated to account for the production of chromatid deletions at the first mitosis of G₂-illuminated cells. The action of this enzyme, plus a recombinational or post-replication repair mechanism, are postulated to account for the production of isochromatid deletions in G₁-illuminated cells. A rapid decline in achromatic lesion frequency with increasing time between G₂ illumination and fixation of the cells is considered evidence for rapid rejoining of most of the initial chain breaks.     

Chromatid lesions and chromatid core morphology

A silver-staining technique revealed the core morphology of metaphase chromosomes of irradiated CHO cells with chromatid lesions (breaks, gaps). These cells were photographed before and after silver staining. As a rule, the core was not continuous in chromatid gaps, suggesting that the chromatid is broken in many so-called gaps. Ten cytogeneticists who were asked to classify chromatid gaps and breaks from photographs of chromosome lesions before silver core staining agreed in only 19 of 53 cases.     

Induction of chromatid breaks by carbon K-shell ultrasoft X rays

Chromatid breaks have previously been shown to be induced in G2-phase cells after exposure to ionizing radiation (X and gamma rays) as a linear function of dose, consistent with a single-event mechanism. DNA double-strand breaks (DSBs) are thought to be the initiating lesion, and experiments with a genetically engineered cell line containing a single DSB site also indicate that a single DSB is sufficient to induce a chromatid break. Although the precise mechanism of conversion of an isolated DSB into a chromatid break is not yet understood, it is known that a proportion of chromatid breaks result from rearrangements between sister chromatids. Here we report further evidence for the single-event hypothesis for the formation of chromatid breaks. The evidence derives from experiments in which chromatid breaks have been induced by exposure of Chinese hamster cells to ultrasoft carbon K-shell X rays. Since the energy of carbon K-shell X rays is not sufficient for the secondary electrons to span more than one DNA double helix, we conclude that single traversals, and hence single (complex) DSBs, are responsible for the formation of chromatid breaks. We find that, as for 60Co gamma rays, around 10% of the carbon K-shell X-ray-induced chromatid breaks have associated color switches at breakpoints, indicating that they arise through sister chromatid rearrangements.     

Statistical Analysis of Chromatid Interference

The nonrandom occurrence of crossovers along a single strand during meiosis can be caused by either chromatid interference, crossover interference or both. Although crossover interference has been consistently observed in almost all organisms since the time of the first linkage studies, chromatid interference has not been as thoroughly discussed in the literature, and the evidence provided for it is inconsistent. In this paper with virtually no restrictions on the nature of crossover interference, we describe the constraints that follow from the assumption of no chromatid interference for single spore data. These constraints are necessary consequences of the assumption of no chromatid interference, but their satisfaction is not sufficient to guarantee no chromatid interference. Models can be constructed in which chromatid interference clearly exists but is not detectable with single spore data. We then extend our analysis to cover tetrad data, which permits more powerful tests of no chromatid interference. We note that the traditional test of no chromatid interference based on tetrad data does not make full use of the information provided by the data, and we offer a statistical procedure for testing the no chromatid interference constraints that does make full use of the data. The procedure is then applied to data from several organisms. Although no strong evidence of chromatid interference is found, we do observe an excess of two-strand double recombinations, i.e., negative chromatid interference.     

Influence of DNA repair gene polymorphisms of hOGG1, XRCC1, XRCC3, ERCC2 and the folate metabolism gene MTHFR on chromosomal aberration frequencies

We have studied the effect of genetic polymorphisms in the DNA repair genes hOGG1, XRCC1, XRCC3, ERCC2 and the MTHFR gene in the folate metabolism on the frequencies of cells with chromosomal aberrations (CA), chromosome-type aberrations (CSA), chromatid-type aberrations (CTA), chromatid breaks (CTB) and chromatid gaps (CTG) scored in peripheral blood lymphocytes from 651 Norwegian subjects of Caucasian descendant. DNA was extracted from fixed cell suspensions. The log-linear Poisson regression model was used for the combined data which included age, smoking, occupational exposure and genotype for 449 subjects.

Our results suggest that individuals carrying the hOGG1 326Cys or the XRCC1 399Gln allele have an increased risk of chromosomal damage, while individuals carrying the XRCC1 194Trp or the ERCC2 751Gln allele have a reduced risk regardless of smoking habits and age.

Individuals carrying the XRCC1 280His allele had an increased risk of CSA which was only apparent in non-smokers. This was independent of age.

A protective effect of the XRCC3 241Met allele was only found in the older age group in non-smokers for CA, CSA and CTA, and in smokers for CSA. In the youngest age group, the opposite effect was found, with an increased risk for CA, CTA and CTG in smokers. Carrying the MTHFR 222Val allele gave an increased risk for chromosome and chromatid-type aberrations for both non-smokers and smokers, especially for individuals in the older age group, and with variable results in the youngest age group. The variables included in the different regression models accounted, however, for only 4–10% of the variation. The frequency ratio for CTG was significantly higher than for CTA and CTB for only 7 of the 43 comparisons performed. Some of the gap frequencies diverge from the trend in the CA, CSA, CTA and CTB results.     

The UV sensitivity of the bromodeoxyuridine-substituted chromosomes in the Chinese hamster

Chinese hamster cells with chromosomes differently substituted for BUdR (TT-TT, TT-TB, TB-TB, TB-BB, where T is thymidine containing chromatid and B is BUdR substituted chromatid) were exposed to UV-light in phase G2 and chromosome aberrations (mainly chromatid breaks) were analysed. Breaks frequency per chromosome was proportional to BUdR content. No breaks were found in TT-TT chromosomes. The frequency of breaks per TB chromatid was similar with TT-TB and TB-BB chromosomes. In TB-BB chromosomes, however, virtually no breaks occurred in TB chromatids whereas in BB chromatids, their frequency was much higher than was expected.     

Chromosome damage induced by decay of 3H and 125I incorporated into DNA of Chinese hamster cells

The present study was undertaken to compare the frequency of chromatid-type aberrations in Chinese hamster cells with previous results on accumulation of unrepaired DNA-strand breaks after incorporation of 3H-TdR or 125IUdR into DNA. A linear-quadratic function was fitted by the weighted-least-square method to the data on yield of chromatid aberrations at different dpm values. Based on a significant linear response at low doses, RBE for 125I in relation to 3H was calculated for (i) chromatid breaks (17 +/- 6), (ii) the sum of isochromatid breaks and chromatid exchanges (21 +/- 9), and (iii) the total number of chromatid aberrations (18 +/- 5). Analogously, the RBE for accumulation of DNA-strand breaks was determined (13 +/- 6). Our results are consistent with the assumption that chromosomal aberrations mainly originate from unrepaired DNA-strand breaks.     

Chronic exposure to sublethal doses of radiation mimetic Zeocin selects for clones deficient in homologous recombination

Research indicates that exposure to hypoxia is associated with oxidative stress. In this investigation, healthy subjects were exposed to hypoxia by inhalation of 10% oxygen for 2 h (corresponding to 5500 m above sea level). The levels of strand breaks and oxidatively damaged purine bases, measured by the comet assay, and the expression of genes involved in DNA repair of oxidatively damaged DNA were investigated in mononuclear blood cells (MNBC) at baseline, after 2 h of hypoxia, 2 h of reoxygenation, and 1 day and 8 days after the exposure. The level of strand breaks and oxidized purine bases in MNBC increased following both the 2 h of hypoxia and the 2 h reoxygenation period, whereas this effect was not observed in unexposed subjects. The expressions of oxoguanine DNA glycosylase 1 (OGG1), nucleoside diphosphate linked moiety X-type motif 1 (NUDT1), nei endonuclease VIII-like 1 (NEIL1), and mutY homolog (MUTYH) were unaltered throughout the experiment in both groups of subjects, indicating that DNA repair genes are not up-regulated by the hypoxia and reoxygenation treatment. Taken together, this report shows that inhalation of 10% oxygen for 2 h is associated with increased number of oxidized DNA lesions in MNBC, but acute hypoxia may not inflict upon the regulation of genes involved in repair of oxidized DNA.     

Drad21, a Drosophila rad21 homologue expressed in S-phase cells

Cohesin is an evolutionarily conserved multiprotein complex required to establish and maintain sister chromatid cohesion. Here, we report the cloning and initial characterization of the Drosophila homologue of the fission yeast rad21 cohesin subunit, called Drad21. The Drad21 coding region was localized to centromeric heterochromatin and encodes a 715 amino acid (aa) protein with 42% aa identity to vertebrate Rad21p-homologues, 25% with Scc1p/Mcd1p (S. cerevisiae) and 28% with Rad21p (S. pombe). Sequences with similarity to the sites of proteolytic cleavage identified in Scc1p/Mcd1p are not evident in DRAD21. Northern blot and mRNA in-situ studies show that Drad21 is developmentally regulated, with high levels of expression in early embryogenesis, in S-phase cells of proliferating imaginal tissues, and in the early endocycling cells of the embryonic gut.     

Mutations by near-ultraviolet radiation in Escherichia coli strains lacking superoxide dismutase

Om wild-type Escherichia coli, near-ultraviolet radiation (NUV) was only weakly mutagenic. However, in an allelic mutant strain (sodA sodB) that lacks both Mn- and Fe-superoxide dismutase (SOD) and assumed to have excess superoxide anion (O₂⁻), NUV induced a 9-fold increase in mutation above the level that normally occurs in this double mutant. When a sodA sodB double mutant contained a plasmid carrying katG⁺ HP-I catalase), mutation by NUV was reduced to wild-type (sodA⁺ sodB⁺) levels. Also, in the sodA sodB xthA triple mutant, which lacks exonuclease III (exoIII) in addition to SOD, the mutations frequency by NUV was reduced to wild-type levels. This synergistic action of NUV and O₂⁻ suggested that pre-mutational lesions occur, with exoIII converting these lesions to stable mutants. Exposure to H₂O₂ induced a 2.8 fold increase in mutations in sodA sodB double mutants, but was reduced to control levels when a plasmid carrying katG⁺ was introduced. These results suggest that NUV, in addition to its other effects on cells, increases mutations indirectly by increasing the flux of OH^. radicals, possibly by generating excess H₂O₂.     

5-Aza-2′-deoxycytidine causes replication lesions that require Fanconi anemia-dependent homologous recombination for repair

5-Aza-2′-deoxycytidine (5-azadC) is a DNA methyltransferase (DNMT) inhibitor increasingly used in treatments of hematological diseases and works by being incorporated into DNA and trapping DNMT. It is unclear what DNA lesions are caused by 5-azadC and if such are substrates for DNA repair. Here, we identify that 5-azadC induces DNA damage as measured by γ-H2AX and 53BP1 foci. Furthermore, 5-azadC induces radial chromosomes and chromatid breaks that depend on active replication, which altogether suggest that trapped DNMT collapses oncoming replication forks into double-strand breaks. We demonstrate that RAD51-mediated homologous recombination (HR) is activated to repair 5-azadC collapsed replication forks. Fanconi anemia (FA) is a rare autosomal recessive disorder, and deaths are often associated with leukemia. Here, we show that FANCG-deficient cells fail to trigger HR-mediated repair of 5-azadC-induced lesions, leading to accumulation of chromatid breaks and inter-chromosomal radial fusions as well as hypersensitivity to the cytotoxic effects of 5-azadC. These data demonstrate that the FA pathway is important to protect from 5-azadC-induced toxicity. Altogether, our data demonstrate that cytotoxicity of the epigenetic drug 5-azadC can, at least in part, be explained by collapsed replication forks requiring FA-mediated HR for repair.     

Chromosome aberrations induced by X-ray therapy and myxovirus infection in human peripheral leukocytes

The dose-response relationships and the distribution of breaks induced by irradiation were studied in phytohemagglutinin-stimulated peripheral lymphocytes from female patients treated with X-rays for cancer of the breast. The yield of dicentrics and rings was expressed by the formula y = 0.0086 + 1.53 (± 0.15) · 10⁻⁵ D, and the yield of fragments by y = 0.022 + 1.68 (± 0.17) · 10⁻⁵ D, where D is the accumulated skin dose in rad. The percentage of damaged cells, however, reached a plateau of 22% at about 6000 rad. In all dose ranges, the distribution of cells with various numbers of breaks deviated significantly from a Poisson distribution, which should have been obtained if all cells in the blood had been exposed to irradiation. It was possible to calculate the number of undamaged cells present in excess and, when these were omitted, a close agreement with a Poisson distribution was obtained. The results suggested that almost 30% of the circulating lymphocytes had been exposed to irradiation with the fractionated partial body procedure utilized.

The effect of Newcastle disease, Sendai, measles and mumps virus infection in vitro on peripheral blood lymphocytes from irradiated patients was also studied. Virus treatment caused a decrease in the frequency of chromosome-type damage. No effect, or a slight decrease of chromatid-type damage, was seen as compared with controls treated with normal allantoic fluid.     

The Fanconi anemia pathway limits the severity of mutagenesis

Fanconi anemia (FA) is a developmental and cancer predisposition disorder in which key, yet unknown, physiological events promoting chromosome stability are compromised. FA cells exhibit excess metaphase chromatid breaks and are universally hypersensitive to DNA interstrand crosslinking agents. Published mutagenesis data from single-gene mutation assays show both increased and decreased mutation frequencies in FA cells. In this review we discuss the data from the literature and from our isogenic fancg knockout hamster CHO cells, and interpret these data within the framework of a molecular model that accommodates these seemingly divergent observations. In FA cells, reduced rates of recovery of viable X-linked hypoxanthine phosphoribosyltransferase (hprt) mutants are characteristically observed for diverse mutagenic agents, but also in untreated cultures, indicating the relevance of the FA pathway for processing assorted DNA lesions. We ascribe these reductions to: (1) impaired mutagenic translesion synthesis within hprt during DNA replication and (2) lethality of mutant cells following replication fork breakage on the X chromosome, caused by unrepaired double-strand breaks or large deletions/translocations encompassing essential genes flanking hprt. These findings, along with studies showing increased spontaneous mutability of FA cells at two autosomal loci, support a model in which FA proteins promote both translesion synthesis at replication-blocking lesions and repair of broken replication forks by homologous recombination and DNA end joining. The essence of this model is that the FANC protein pathway serves to restrict the severity of mutational outcome by favoring base substitutions and small deletions over larger deletions and chromosomal rearrangements.     

The repair of bleomycin-induced DNA damage and its relationship to chromosome aberration repair.

Previous studies using the technique of premature chromosome condensation indicated that nearly one-half of the bleomycin-induced chromatid breaks and gaps in CHO cells could be repaired within 1 h (repair starting at 30 min) after treatment. Cycloheximide and streptovitacin A (but not hydroxyurea or hycanthone) inhibited chromosome repair. The purpose of this study was to measure the kinetics of DNA repair after bleomycin treatment using the alkaline elution technique and to determine whether various inhibitors could block this repair. After bleomycin treatment, the major proportion of the repair of DNA damage occurred within 15 min, with significant repair evident by 2 min. This fast repair component was inhibited by 0.2% EDTA. A slower repair component was observed to occur up to 60 min after bleomycin treatment. None of the inhibitors tested were found to have a significant effect on the repair of bleomycin damage at the DNA level. Since chromosome breaks were observed not to begin repair until after 30 min while over 50% of the DNA was repaired by 15 min, these results suggest that the DNA lesions that are repaired quickly are not important in the formation of chromosome aberrations. Further, since cycloheximide and streptovitacin A blocked chromosome repair but had little measurable effect on DNA repair, these results suggest that the DNA lesions responsible for chromosome damage represent only a small proportion of the total DNA lesions produced by bleomycin.     

Application of mFISH for the analysis of chemically-induced chromosomal aberrations: a model for the formation of triradial chromosomes

Using a human lymphoblastoid cell line WTK-1, we applied multicolor fluorescence in situ hybridization (mFISH) technique to analyze mitomycin C (MMC)-induced chromatid exchanges, focusing especially on the triradial chromosomes. It was found that the triradial chromosomes were formed with a specific rearrangement, "recipient and donor" relationship. The exchange sites of the recipient chromosomes were on single chromatid breaks and distributed randomly throughout the interstitial, pericentromeric, and terminal regions. In counterpart, donor chromosomes exchanged on isochromatid breaks of their telomeric and/or subtelomeric regions with the single chromatid breaks of recipient chromosomes. More than 80% of the scored triradial chromosomes were formed with such rearrangements, and few acentric chromosome fragments derived from the donor chromosomes could be detected in the metaphases observed. We therefore suggest that biological mechanisms of breakages between the recipient and donor chromosomes are different: the former due to direct DNA-damage by MMC, but the latter due to indirect DNA-damage depending on telomeric specific structure/function.     

Toxicity and mutagenicity of X-rays and [125I]dUrd or [3H]TdR incorporated in the DNA of human lymphoblast cells

We measured the toxicity and mutagenicity induced in human diploid lymphoblasts by various radiation doses of X-rays and two internal emitters. [¹²⁵I]iododeoxyuridine ([¹²⁵I]dUrd) and [³H]thymidine ([³H]TdR), incorporated into cellular DNA. [¹²⁵I]dUrd was more effective than [³H]TdR at killing cells and producing mutations to 6-thioguanine resistance (6TG^R). No ouabain-resistant mutants were induced by any of these agents. Expressing dose as total disintegrations per cell (dpc), the D₀ for cell killing for [¹²⁵I]dUrd was 28 dpc and for [³H]TdR was 385 dpc. The D₀ for X-rays was 48 rad at 37°C. The slopes of the mutation curves were approximately 75 × 10⁻⁸ 6TG^R mutants per cell per disintegration for [¹²⁵I]dUrd and 2 × 10⁻⁸ for [³H]TdR. X-Rays induced 8 × 10⁻⁸ 6TG^R mutants per cell per rad. Normalizing for survival, [¹²⁵I]dUrd remained much more mutagenic at low doses (high survival levels) than the other two agents. Treatment of the cells at either 37°C or while frozen at −70°C yielded no difference in cytotoxicity or mutation for [¹²⁵I]dUrd or [³H]TdR, whereas X-rays were 6 times less effective in killing cells at −70°C.

Assuming that incorporation was random throughout the genome, the mutagenic efficiencies of the radionuclides could be calculated by dividing the mutation rate by the level of incorporation. If the effective target size of the 6TG^R locus is 1000–3000 base pairs, then the mutagenic efficiency of [¹²⁵I]dUrd is 1.0–3.0 and of [³H]TdR is 0.02–0.06 total genomic mutations per cell per disintegration. ¹²⁵I disintegrations are known to produce localized DNA double-strand breaks. If these breaks are potentially lethal lesions, they must be repaired, since the mean lethal dose (D₀) was 28 dpc. The observations that a single dpc has a high probability of producing a mutation (mutagenic efficiency 1.0–3.0) would suggest, however, that this repair is extremely error-prone. If the breaks need not be repaired to permit survival, then lethal lesions are a subset of or are completely different from mutagenic lesions.