The influence of females on the initiation of female-to-male sex change in a coral reef fish

In the protogynous coral reef fish Anthias squamipinnis (Peters), all males are sex-reversed females. A sexually mature female can be induced to change sex by removing a male from her social group. The influence of non-sex-changing females on the initiation of sex change was evaluated in 109 social groups in the Gulf of Eilat. When the male and largest female were removed from each of 12 single-male groups, the second-largest female changed sex in 9 groups. This result distinguished between two behavioral hypotheses suggested by previous work and made it tenable that a particular behavioral measure, the profile of behavior-received, that depends on adult females, is critical to the initiation of sex change. This species forms all-female groups as well as bisexual groups. All-female groups can be expected to have some mechanism for the production of a male. The removal of the largest female from each of 8 all-female groups failed to induce sex change in any group. The dominant female in these groups thus does not function in the same way as does the male in bisexual groups, at least in terms of the initiation of sex change. Following the removal of the male from each of 8 bisexual groups containing five or fewer adult females, a female changed sex in only 4 groups. This 50% incidence of sex reversal was lower than the 77–80% incidence in control groups containing more than five adult females. Data suggest that a minimum of four adult females is probably required for the probability of sex change after male removal to equal 75%.     

Distinguishing behavioral interactions from visual cues as causes of adult sex change in a coral reef fish

Two experiments tested the hypothesis that adult female-to-male sex reversal in protogynous fish is induced by the loss of close-contact behavioral interactions between males and females, and not by the loss of simple visual cues from the male. Twenty-six laboratory groups of Anthias squamipinnis were manipulated so that females within each group (1) retained chemical and acoustic access to a male, (2) were denied behavioral access to a male, and (3) were either allowed or denied visual access to a male alone or to a male interacting with another female. At least one female subsequently changed sex in each of 22 groups. While acoustic and chemical cues were not completely eliminated as possible causes, sex change is apparently induced by loss of male-female behavioral interaction in combination with continued interaction between females.     

Socially controlled male-to-female sex reversal in the protogynous orange-spotted grouper,Epinephelus coioides

Socially controlled sex change in teleosts is a dramatic example of adaptive reproductive plasticity. In many cases, the occurrence of sex change is triggered by a change in the social context, such as the disappearance of the dominant individual. The orange-spotted grouper Epinephelus coioides is a typical protogynous hermaphrodite fish that changes sex from female to male and remains male throughout its life span. In this study, male-to-female sex reversal in male Epinephelus coioides was successfully induced by social isolation. The body length and mass, gonadal change, serum sex steroid hormone levels and sex-related gene expression patterns during the process of socially controlled male-to-female sex reversal in E. coioides were systematically examined. This report investigates the physiological mechanisms of the socially controlled male-to-female sex reversal process in a protogynous hermaphrodite grouper species. The results enable us to study the physiological control of sex change, not only from female to male, but also from male to female.     

Field evidence for bi-directional sex change in the polygynous gobiid fish Trimma okinawae

The social condition of bi-directional sex change in the gobiid fish Trimma okinawae was investigated at Akamizu Beach, Kagoshima, Japan. Social groups of T. okinawae usually consisted of a large male and one or more smaller females. The number of females in the group was positively correlated with male body size and groups were usually separated from each other by 1–3 m. In total, 22 instances of female-to-male sex change and three instances of male-to-female sex change were observed during the 16 months that social groups were monitored. Two individuals changed sex twice: female to male and back to female. Female-to-male sex change occurred when the male disappeared from a group. Either the largest remaining female changed sex to male or a large female from another group immigrated and changed sex to male. Larger individuals appear to benefit from becoming male because they can monopolize the breeding opportunities with several females, as reported in other protogynous fishes. Sex change from male-to-female only occurred when a solitary male joined another group as a subordinate. Mortality rates are high in these small fish, therefore joining another group and reproducing as a female is likely to increase the reproductive value of a solitary male.     

Regulation of protogynous sex change by competition between corticosteroids and androgens: an experimental test using sandperch, Parapercis cylindrica

Cortisol, the dominant corticosteroid in fish, and 11-ketotestosterone (11KT), the most potent androgen in fish, are both synthesized and (or) deactivated by the same two enzymes, 11beta-hydroxylase and 11beta-hydroxysteroid dehydrogenase. Cortisol is synthesized in response to stress (such as that caused by interaction with a dominant conspecific), whereas 11KT is synthesized during protogynous sex change. It has been hypothesized that corticosteroids (such as cortisol) inhibit 11KT synthesis via substrate competition, thereby providing a mechanism for the regulation of socially mediated, protogynous sex change. We tested this hypothesis by administering cortisol (50 microg g(-1) body weight) to female sandperch (Parapercis cylindrica) under social conditions that were permissive to sex change (i.e. in the absence of suppressive male dominance). Twenty-one days later, mean physiological cortisol concentration in cortisol-treated fish was 4.2-fold greater than that in 'socially stressed' female fish maintained in a semi-natural system. Although the dosage of cortisol was therefore considered to be favorable for engendering competitive inhibition of 11KT synthesis, all cortisol-treated fish changed sex, as did all sham-treated and control fish (n=7 fish per treatment). In addition, there was no effect of cortisol treatment on the rate of sex change or on the pattern of steroidogenesis. Thus, our results refute the hypothesis that protogynous sex change is regulated by substrate competition between corticosteroids and androgens.     

Sexually dichromatic protogynous angelfish Centropyge ferrugata (Pomacanthidae) males can change back to females

Protogynous hermaphroditism, female-to-male sex change, is well known among reef fishes where large males monopolize harems of females. When the dominant male disappears from a harem, the largest female may change sex within a few weeks. Recently, from experiments with some protogynous haremic fishes in which two males' cohabitated, it was confirmed that sexual behavior and gonads were completely reversible according to individual social status. However, the ability to reverse secondary-developed sexual body coloration has never been examined in any protogynous fish. We conducted two male cohabitation experiments with the protogynous haremic angelfish, Centropyge ferrugata, which has conspicuous sexual dichromatism on the dorsal fin. Smaller males of C. ferrugata soon performed female-specific mating behaviors when they became subordinated after losing a contest. They then completed gonadal sex change to females 47 or 89 d (n=2) after beginning cohabitation. In the course of the reversed gonadal sex change, male-specific coloration on the dorsal fin changed to that of a female. Thus, the sex of C. ferrugata, including secondary developed sexually dichromatic characteristics, can be completely reversible in accord with their social status.     

Alternative Contexts of Sex Change with Social Control in the Bucktooth Parrotfish, Sparisoma radians

Social control of sex change occurs in a variety of hermaphroditic fishes; upon removal of the dominant individual, the largest individual of the opposite sex typically changes sex and acquires mating priority with the remaining members of the social group. Social control may allow a phenotypically plastic response to social situations that convey cues about the relative advantages of functioning as one sex or the other, and should be advantageous in highly heterogeneous habitats such as coral reefs. Parrotfishes (family Scaridae) are dominant members of herbivorous coral reef fish assemblages, and numerous histological examinations of gonads have demonstrated the hermaphroditic life history of many species in the family. However, social control of sex change has never been conclusively demonstrated in the parrotfishes. To test a new version of the size-advantage model for sex change, we conducted removal experiments of dominant male bucktooth parrotfish, Sparisoma radians, in St. Croix, U.S. Virgin Islands. A total of seven females from five different reefs changed sex following removals, clearly demonstrating social control of sex change. In addition, all but one of those individuals changing sex were smaller than the largest females remaining in the harems, and this contrasts with nearly all previous studies of sex change in fishes. Sex change proceeds via a novel sequence of events when compared with previous studies. Rather than behavioral sex change preceding morphological sex change, the appearance of male coloration is followed by the development of male behavior that is fully expressed approximately 20 days after removal. We show how differing arrival rates of bachelor males at our study sites may facilitate alternative contexts of sex change, with sex change occurring within social groups in some locations and with bachelor males filling harem vacancies in other locations. Alternative contexts of sex change further illustrate the astonishing phenotypic plasticity in the social and mating behavior of parrotfishes.     

Reversed Sex-Change in the Protogynous Reef Fish Labroides dimidiatus

Protogynous hermaphroditism, or female-to-male sex change, is known for many reef fishes including wrasses (family Labridae) in which large males monopolize mating. When the dominant male disappears from a polygynous group, the largest female may change sex within a few weeks. Such social control of sex change was first documented in harems of the cleaner wrasse Labroides dimidiatus almost 30 yr ago. To examine whether change of social status would induce males of L. dimidiatus to perform reversed sex-change, we conducted experiments: (i) releasing single males near lone males whose mates have been removed in the field; and (ii) keeping two males in a tank. Smaller males changed back to females when they became subordinate: it took 53–77 d (n=3) for them to complete gonadal sex change and release eggs in the aquarium. The male–male pairs performed spawning behavior, with the smaller male in the female role already 5–58 d before completion of gonadal sex change. This is the first report of reversed sex-change among protogynous wrasses. Moreover, we conducted another experiment, keeping a pair of a male and a larger female in a tank (n=1). We found sex change by both mates, which has not been reported from any fishes. Thus, the sex of L. dimidiatus is strictly determined by social status whenever it changes after mate loss.     

An integrative approach to sex change: social, behavioural and neurochemical changes in Lythrypnus dalli (Pisces)

This study examined three aspects of protogynous sex change in Lythrypnus dalli (Gobiidae): (1) social influences on the rate of sex change, (2) the sequence of behavioural changes, and (3) neuroendocrine changes. Social groups consisted of either four females, or four females with a male who was subsequently removed. Sex change occurred most rapidly in male- removed groups when the sex changer was larger than other females. Sex changers in female only groups and sex changers not larger than other females in male-removed groups changed sex at similar rates. These differences may be explained by two factors that affect dominance: prior knowledge of the social group and greater size. Sex changers were dominant to other females prior to male removal, and larger sex changers increased displacement rates three-fold immediately after male removal. Sex changers in the other groups did not show this increase in displacements. This early establishment of dominance accounts for the overall difference in the rate of sex change. Prior to spawning, however, all sex changers increased displacements and performed male-typical displays. Arginine vasotocin-immunoreactive forebrain cells of sex changers were similar in size to field-collected males, and larger than field-collected females. Previously nesting males also changed sex in male-only groups, but at slow rates. These data are combined with those of existing studies to generate an integrative model of sex change in this goby. Received: 17 March 1999 / Received in revised form: 15 May 1999 / Accepted: 28 May 1999     

Spawning dynamics of orange roughy,Hoplostethus atlanticus,in mid-slope waters of New Zealand

Synopsis The social and reproductive biology of the sand tilefish,Malacanthus plumieri (Malacanthidae), was studied at Glover's Reef, Belize, where this species occurs in colonies over sand-rubble flats. Individuals each occupy a home burrow refuge and a surrounding home range. Home range overlap among adjacent fish of the same sex is low, and individuals defend exclusive use of much of their home range against all conspecifics except mates (i.e., territoriality). Areas defended by males overlap the territories of up to 6 females; and male territory area is positively related to the number of female residents. Males maintain dominance over females within their territories by aggression, including intervention into some female disputes. Females spawn pelagically-dispersed eggs as frequently as every day. Each female spawns near her burrow, almost exclusively with the male whose defended area encompasses her territory (harem polygyny). Tilefish colonies therefore consist of a mosaic of female territories over which adjacent male territories are superimposed. Histological evidence and observation of behavioral sex change in one female revealed thatM. plumieri is capable of protogynous sex reversal. Females did not change sex in response to removal of one male. Occurrence of small transitional fish indicates that the onset of sex change is controlled by factors other than size-related social hierarchies within harems or colonies.     

Growth acceleration,behaviour and otolith check marks associated with sex change in the wrasse <Emphasis Type="Italic">Halichoeres miniatus</Emphasis>

In protogynous sex-changing fishes, females are expected to compete for the opportunity to change sex following the loss of a dominant male and may exhibit growth and behavioural traits that help them maintain their dominant status after sex change. A male removal experiment was used to examine changes in female growth and behaviour associated with sex change in the haremic wrasse Halichoeres miniatus and to test whether any changes in growth associated with sex change were recorded in otolith microstructure. Dominant females began displaying male-characteristic behaviour almost immediately after the harem male was removed. The frequency of interactions between females increased following male removal. In contrast, feeding frequency of females decreased. The largest one to three females in each social group changed sex following male removal and exhibited an increase in growth associated with sex change. Sex changers grew more than twice as fast as non-sex changers during the experimental period. This growth acceleration may enable new sex-changed males to rapidly reach a size where they can defend the remaining harem from other males. An optical discontinuity (check mark) was present in the otoliths of sex-changed fish, and otolith accretion rate increased significantly after the check mark, corresponding with the increased growth rate of sex-changing females. Wild caught males, but not females, exhibited an analogous check mark in their otoliths and similar increases in otolith increment widths after the check. This indicates that an increase in growth rate is a regular feature of sex-change dynamics of H. miniatus. Communicated by Environment Editor Prof. Rob van Woesik     

Intragroup behavioural changes and the initiation of sex reversal in a coral reef fish in the laboratory

Observations of the coral reef fish Anthias squamipinnis (Peters) suggest that the behavioural control of female-to-male sex reversal is more complex than a simple dependence on the presence or absence of a male or on simple aspects of aggression or aggressive dominance. When the behavioural interactions of all group members of small, bisexual social groups of this fish were examined before and after male removal, two behavioural features were identified as possible factors controlling the initiation of sex change: the profile for behaviours received from, and the percentage of rushes given to other group members. Males and females each showed characteristic profiles both for behaviours given and for behaviours received. On the basis of the behaviour-given profile I identified two types of female. Both types were capable of changing sex following the removal of the male. Two to four weeks were required by sex-reversing fish for the profiles for behaviour given to change to a completely male form. After male removal, the remaining females began to treat the sex-reversing fish as though she the behavioural and coloration changes of sex reversal in a female.     

Social status determines sexual phenotype in the bi-directional sex changing bluebanded goby Lythrypnus dalli

The behavioural mechanisms and patterns of protandrous sex change in bluebanded gobies Lythrypnus dalli were investigated and compared to the well-described behaviour patterns of protogynous sex change. To do this, unisex groups of males and females were established; behavioural and anatomical changes were recorded over a 42 day period as social status and sexual phenotype were determined. In all cases, social status, rather than the expression of a particular behaviour, accurately predicted final sexual phenotype. Rates of submissive behaviour, but not aggressive behaviour, were predictive of each discrete status class. Multiple individuals changed sex simultaneously if their sexual phenotype and social status were discordant, a novel finding suggesting that once a social hierarchy is established, individuals determined their sexual phenotype, regardless of initial sex, based on a simple operational principle: if subordinate express female, if dominant or not subordinate express male. This work demonstrates that similar mechanisms underlie sex change in both directions in L. dalli and potentially other sex changing species.     

Reproduction in context: Field testing a laboratory model of socially controlled sex change in Lythrypnus dalli (Gilbert)

Social interactions can have profound effects on reproduction and the proximate mechanisms involved are just beginning to be understood. Lythrypnus dalli, the bluebanded goby, is an ideal organism for analyzing the dynamics of socially controlled sex change both in the laboratory and field. As with most research species, the majority of its behavioural and physiologic study has been performed in the laboratory. The goal of our study was to induce sex change of L. dalli in a more natural environment and compare field dynamics with our laboratory-based model. Groups of L. dalli, composed of one large male and three females of varying sizes, were introduced into artificial habitats in the field. After male removal, the dominant, largest female underwent protogynous sex change in the majority of the groups. Within 15 days, 9 of 15 of the dominant females (focal fish) successfully fertilized eggs as males, compared to 13 of 17 in the laboratory. Focal fish displayed the distinctive temporal sequence of behaviour changes consisting of a dominance, quiescent, and courtship phase. In addition, focal fish had gonads, genital papillae, and accessory gonadal structures with morphology in between that of females and males. Those fish that fertilized eggs had this transitional morphology, but were functionally male. Steroids of focal fish were assayed by water sample, and morning samples of free 11-ketotestosterone (11-KT) positively correlated with the percent of male tissue in the gonad, with the size of the accessory gonadal structure but not the genitalia (genital papilla), and with aggressive displacement behaviour on the last day before the fish were sacrificed. These morphological, physiological, and behavioural patterns parallel those seen in the laboratory. Lower rates of behaviour and the dramatic effects of ambient temperature in the field provide insights as to how the environmental context modifies the behaviour and, subsequently, the reproductive function of individuals within a social group.     

Sex change of primary males in a diandric labrid Halichoeres trimaculatus: coexistence of protandry and protogyny within a species

In the threespot wrasse Halichoeres trimaculatus , sex change of primary males was observed in the field and confirmed by aquarium experiments. In other words, protandry and protogyny coexisted within this species. Moreover, male-to-female-to-male sex change and female-to-male-to-female sex change were observed in aquarium experiments; i.e . reversed sex change occurred in both protandrous and protogynous hermaphrodites. These results suggest that only the direction of sex differentiation before maturation may differ between the two sexual types that have been regarded as a primary male and a protogynous hermaphrodite.     

Does gonad structure reflect sexual pattern in all gobiid fishes?

Synopsis In immature and adult females of protogynous gobies, small distinctive masses of cells associated with the ovarian wall develop into testis-associated glandular structures during sex change. These precursive accessory gonadal structures, or pAGS, have been found in females of known protogynous goby species, but not among gonochoric goby species, suggesting that their presence can be used as a species-specific indicator of protogyny within the family. However, a detailed examination of a developmental series of ovaries in two gonochoric species,Gobiosoma illecebrosum andG. saucrum, revealed the presence of a gonadal feature previously thought to be restricted to protogynous gobies. Among immature females of both species, pAGS-like structures having a similar appearance and placement as functional pAGS of protogynous gobies were found. In femaleG. illecebrosum, the size of these structures among immatures progressively decreased with maturation and were absent in all but the smallest adult females. A similar pattern was evident in a small sample ofG. saucrum. Population demography based on field collections showed thatG. illecebrosum exhibits sex ratios and male and female size-frequency distributions typical of gonochores and laboratory experiments indicated that final sexual identity was unaffected by social environment during the juvenile period. Thus, the presence of pAGS in juvenile femaleG. illecebrosum is not related to an ability to change sex at that ontogenic interval. Whether the transient pAGS observed here are vestiges of an ancestral protogynous condition is unknown. Based on their presence among immatures in two gonochore gobies, however, only the presence of pAGS in adult females should be used to predict protogyny among gobies.     

Status-dependent behavioural sex change in a polygynous coral-reef fish, Halichoeres melanurus

To examine how a change in an individual's social status could influence its behavioural sex, we conducted male "removal-and-return" experiments in the polygynous wrasse, Halichoeres melanurus. This coral-reef fish is a protogynous hermaphrodite: the largest female (LF) living in a male's territory typically completes functional sex change within 2–3 weeks after the male's disappearance. In this experiment we removed males from their territories just prior to spawning time, about 1 h before sunset. In 12 of 30 trials, the resident LF spawned in the male role with smaller females, 21–98 min after male removal. Previous research suggests the LF should readily adopt male sexual behaviour to retain smaller females as future mates. However, the LFs of smaller body size were less likely to immediately perform male-role behaviour. This could be related to females' preference for larger mates: smaller LFs would be less likely to be chosen by other females, even if they could complete sex change and defend a territory. When a male was returned immediately after an occurrence of female–female spawning, the LF subsequently spawned in the female role with the returned male (6 of 12 trials). It could be adaptive for the LFs to accept a larger male as a mate rather than to fight against it. Thus, behavioural sex is reversible in H. melanurus, changing rapidly with social status. Electronic Publication     

Density-dependent protogynous sex change in territorial-haremic fishes: models and evidence

Several hypotheses of the proximate control of protogynous (female-to-male)sex change propose that social group composition triggers sexchange, but they do not address how proximate cues are alteredby population density. I present three mutually exclusive encounter-ratethreshold hypotheses that assume that population density determinesrates of contact between social group members and that ratesof contact are cues for sex change. Different densities arepredicted to induce sex change, depending on the encountersassumed to be important in the sex change process (e.g., encounterswith smaller and larger individuals). Tests of the models usea pomacanthid angelfish(Centropyge potten) to show that continuedpresence of a smaller (female) conspecific is needed for sexchange, and that continued presence of a larger (male) conspecificcan either inhibit sex change or prevent its behavioral stimulation.Using constant social group composition, sex change is preventedat higher density but not at a lower density. The absolute encounter-ratethreshold hypothesis, which predicts sex change under intermediate-densityconditions, is the most probable model of the social controlof sex change in C.potteri     

Increased H-Y antigen levels associated with behaviorally induced, female-to-male sex reversal in a coral-reef fish

It has been proposed that H-Y antigen is the synthetic product of sex-determining genes, and that H-Y antigen controls ontogenetic differentiation of the heterogametic sex throughout vertebrates. The coral-reef fish Anthias squamipinnis is a protogynous hermaphrodite in which all individuals mature initially as females. Males result when adult females change sex as a consequence of alterations in behavioral interactions within social groups. Three assay methods were used to measure H-Y antigen levels in the spleens, gonads, and epidermal tissue of 16 adult females and in 16 males that had been induced to change sex from a prior female phase by the removal of a pre-existing male from each of 16 social groups. In 15 male-female pairs, the H-Y antigen levels were higher in male than in female spleen, gonad, and epidermis tissues. The precise temporal relationship between the onset of sex change and the increase in the H-Y antigen level was not examined. If, as we strongly suspect, the temporal relationship proves to be close, the inference will be that the behavioral cues inducing sex change also influence the synthetic activity of genes controlling H-Y antigen production.