Isolation of genes required for hydrogenase synthesis in Escherichia coli

A mutant strain of Escherichia coli, strain AK23, is devoid of hydrogenase activity when grown anaerobically on glucose and cannot grow on H2 plus fumarate. From E. coli chromosomal DNA library, a plasmid, pAK23, was isolated which restored hydrogenase activity in this strain. Two smaller plasmids, pAK23C and pAK23S, containing different parts of the insert DNA fragment of plasmid pAK23, were isolated. The former plasmid restored activity in strain AK23 while the latter did not. The smallest active DNA fragment in plasmid pAK23C was 0.9 kb. This gene is designated hydE. Plasmids pAK23 and pAK23S restored activity in another hydrogenase-negative strain, SE-3-1 (hydB), while plasmid pAK23C did not, suggesting that plasmid pAK23 contains two genes required for hydrogenase expression. Strain AK23 was also devoid of formate hydrogenlyase and formate dehydrogenase activities and these activities were restored by some of the plasmids. Hydrogenase and formate-related activities in strain AK23 were restored by growth of cells in a high concentration of nickel. Plasmid pAK23C led to synthesis of a polypeptide of subunit molecular mass 36 kDa and plasmid pAK23S led to synthesis of polypeptides of subunit molecular masses 30 and 41 kDa.     

Differential expression of hydrogenase isoenzymes in Escherichia coli K-12: evidence for a third isoenzyme.

The cellular contents of the nickel-containing, membrane-bound hydrogenase isoenzymes 1 and 2 (hydrogenases 1 and 2) were analyzed by crossed immunoelectrophoresis. Their expression was differentially influenced by nutritional and genetic factors. Hydrogenase 2 content was enhanced after growth with either hydrogen and fumarate or glycerol and fumarate and correlated reasonably with cellular hydrogen uptake capacity. Hydrogenase 1 content was negligible under the above conditions but was enhanced by exogenous formate. Its expression was greatly reduced in a pfl mutant, which is unable to synthesise formate, but was restored to normal levels when the growth medium included formate. A mutation in the anaerobic regulatory gene, fnr, led to low overall hydrogenase activity and greatly reduced levels of both isoenzymes and abolished the formate enhancement of hydrogenase 1 content. Formate hydrogenlyase activity was similarly reduced in the fnr strain but, in contrast, was restored, as was overall hydrogenase activity, to normal levels by growth in the presence of formate. Low H2 uptake activity was found for the fnr strain under all growth conditions examined. Hydrogenase 1 content, therefore, does not correlate with formate hydrogenlyase activity and its role is unclear. A third hydrogenase isoenzyme, immunologically distinct from hydrogenases 1 and 2, whose expression is enhanced by formate, is present and forms part of the formate hydrogenlyase. We suggest that the effect of the fnr gene product on formate hydrogenlyase expression is mediated via internal formate.     

Isolation and characterization of mutant strains of Escherichia coli altered in H2 metabolism

A positive selection procedure is described for the isolation of hydrogenase-defective mutant strains of Escherichia coli. Mutant strains isolated by this procedure can be divided into two major classes. Class I mutants produced hydrogenase activity (determined by using a tritium-exchange assay) and formate hydrogenlyase activity but lacked the ability to reduce benzyl viologen or fumarate with H2 as the electron donor. Class II mutants failed to produce active hydrogenase and hydrogenase-dependent activities. All the mutant strains produced detectable levels of formate dehydrogenase-1 and -2 and fumarate reductase. The mutation in class I mutants mapped near 65 min of the E. coli chromosome, whereas the mutation in class II mutants mapped between srl and cys operons (58 and 59 min, respectively) in the genome. The class II Hyd mutants can be further subdivided into two groups (hydA and hydB) based on the cotransduction characteristics with cys and srl. These results indicate that there are two hyd operons and one hup operon in the E. coli chromosome. The two hyd operons are needed for the production of active hydrogenase, and all three are essential for hydrogen-dependent growth of the cell.     

Mutants of Escherichia coli with altered hydrogenase activity

Mutant strains of Escherichia coli which expressed different levels of hydrogenase activity when grown anaerobically under a variety of conditions were obtained by mutagenesis and selective growth and screening procedures. Four classes of mutants were isolated, ranging from those devoid of enzyme activity to those expressing maximal activity under all growth conditions. One class of mutants (A) could not grow on fumarate plus H2 in the presence of active fumarate reductase. Since hydrogenase is essential for growth under these conditions some of these strains may be hydrogenase-negative. Three other classes of mutants were isolated which were all hydrogenase-positive and fully expressed this activity when grown on fumarate plus H2. They differed in the level of expression of hydrogenase activity when grown anaerobically on glucose, conditions which do not require hydrogenase for growth. Class B mutants expressed less activity, while class C mutants expressed more activity than the parental strain. Class D mutants fully expressed hydrogenase activity and were dependent on the enzyme for growth. The different strains were also assayed for reduction of dyes by hydrogen and for evolution of hydrogen from reduced methyl viologen. Some of the hydrogenase-positive strains showed altered activities in these assays suggesting that mutations may have occurred either in enzymes or proteins required for reaction with dyes or in the hydrogenase enzyme itself.     

Evidence for three distinct hydrogenase activities in Rhodospirillum rubrum

Inducer, inhibitor, and mutant studies on three hydrogenase activities of Rhodospirillum rubrum indicate that they are mediated by three distinct hydrogenase enzymes. Uptake hydrogenase mediates H2 uptake to an unknown physiological acceptor or methylene blue and is maximally synthesized during autotrophic growth in light. Formate-linked hydrogenase is synthesized primarily during growth in darkness or when light becomes limiting, and links formate oxidation to H2 production. Carbon-monoxide-linked hydrogenase is induced whenever CO is present and couples CO oxidation to H2 evolution. The enzymes can be expressed singly or conjointly depending on growth conditions, and the inhibitor or inducer added. All three hydrogenases can use methyl viologen as the mediator for both the H2 evolution and H2 uptake reactions while displaying distinct pH optima, reversibility, and sensitivity to C2H2 gas. Yet, we present evidence that the CO-linked hydrogenase, unlike the uptake hydrogenase, does not link to methylene blue as the electron acceptor. These differences allow conditions to be established to quantitatively assay each hydrogenase independently of the others both in vivo and in vitro.     

Inhibition of colicin synthesis by the antibiotic globomycin

Wolinella succinogenes can grow by anaerobic respiration with fumarate or polysulfide as the terminal electron acceptor, and H₂ or formate as the electron donor. A ΔhydABC mutant lacking the hydrogenase structural genes did not grow with H₂ and either fumarate or polysulfide. In contrast to the wild-type strain, the mutant grown with fumarate and with formate instead of H₂ did not catalyze the reduction of fumarate, polysulfide, dimethylnaphthoquinone, or benzyl viologen by H₂. Growth and enzymic activities were restored upon integration of a plasmid carrying hydABC into the genome of the ΔhydABC mutant. The ΔhydABC mutant was complemented with hydABC operons modified by artificial stop codons in hydA (StopA) or at the 5′-end of hydC (StopC). The StopC mutant lacked HydC, and the hydrophobic C-terminus of HydA was missing in the hydrogenase of the StopA mutant. The two mutants catalyzed benzyl viologen reduction by H₂. The enzyme activity was located in the membrane of the mutants. A mutant with both modifications (StopAC) contained the activity in the periplasm. The three mutants did not grow with H₂ and either fumarate or polysulfide, and did not catalyze dimethylnaphthoquinone reduction by H₂. We conclude that the same hydrogenase serves in the anaerobic respiration with fumarate and with polysulfide. HydC and the C-terminus of HydA appear to be required for both routes of electron transport and for dimethylnaphthoquinone reduction by H₂. The hydrogenase is anchored in the membrane by HydC and by the C-terminus of HydA. The catalytic subunit HydB is oriented towards the periplasmic side of the membrane. Received: 29 December 1997 / Accepted: 6 March 1998     

Hydrogen-dependent growth of Escherichia coli in anaerobic respiration and the presence of hydrogenases with different functions.

E. coli K10 was found to grow anaerobically on molecular hydrogen by reducing nitrate, fumarate, and trimethylamine N-oxide when peptone was added to the culture medium. Molar growth yields based on consumed hydrogen estimated from the amounts of reduction products were all 7.8 g cells/mol, suggesting that 1 mol of ATP was produced in the oxidation of 1 mol of hydrogen. Hydrogenase activity measured in terms of hydrogen evolution was several times higher in cells grown on glucose than in cells grown on hydrogen in the presence of fumarate and trimethylamine N-oxide, while hydrogenase activity measured in terms of hydrogen uptake was unchanged in both cases. The ratio of hydrogenase activities measured in terms of hydrogen uptake and evolution was also high in the extract and centrifugal fractions from cells grown in hydrogen. The soluble fraction and trypsin digest of the precipitate at 100,000 X g were subjected to polyacrylamide disc gel electrophoresis and hydrogenase bands were stained by reduction of benzyl viologen with hydrogen and by oxidation of reduced methyl viologen. The resulting patterns suggest that multiple forms of hydrogenase are present and that the amounts of forms functioning in hydrogen evolution were greatly decresed in cells grown on hydrogen in the presence of acceptors.     

Genetic and physiological characterization of new Escherichia coli mutants impaired in hydrogenase activity

The Mu dl (ApR lac) bacteriophage was used to generate mutants of Escherichia coli which were defective in formate hydrogenlyase. Three mutants were chosen for further analysis: they lacked hydrogenase (hydrogen: benzyl viologen oxidoreductase) activity, but produced normal levels of fumarate reductase activity and two- to three-fold reduced levels of benzyl viologen (BV)-dependent formate dehydrogenase activity. Two of them (hydC) were shown to contain about 4-fold reduced amounts of formate hydrogenlyase and fumarate-dependent H2 uptake activities. The third one (hydD) was totally devoid of both activities. Their insertion sites were located at 77 min on the E. coli map. Subdivision of these mutants into two classes was subsequently based on the restoration capacity of hydrogenase activity with high concentration of nickel in the growth media. Addition of 500 microM NiCl2 led to a complete recovery of hydrogenase activity, and to the concomitant restoration of normal BV-linked formate dehydrogenase, formate hydrogenlyase and fumarate-dependent H2 uptake activities in the hydC mutants. The hydD mutant was insensitive to the effect of nickel. Expression of the lac operon in hydC and hydD mutants was induced by anaerobiosis. It was not increased by the addition of formate under anaerobic conditions. The presence of nitrate resulted in slightly reduced beta-galactosidase activities in the hydC mutants, whereas those found in the hydD mutant reached only one third of the level obtained in its absence. Fumarate had no effect on both classes. Moreover, in contrast to the hydD locus, the hydC::Mu dl fusions were found to be dependent upon the positive control exerted by the nirR gene product and were totally repressed by an excess of nickel. In addition, the low levels of overall hydrogenase-dependent activities found in a nirR strain were also relieved by the presence of nickel. Our results strongly suggest that the pleiotropic regulatory gene nirR is essential for the expression of a gene (hydC) involved in either transport or processing of nickel in the cell, whose alteration leads to a loss of hydrogenase activity.     

Enzyme activity of the formate hydrogenlyase complex in Citrobacter freundii

Citrobacter freundii 62 can grow in the absence of oxygen in media containing glucose, peptone, fumarate or malate. When the medium contained fumarate or malate, the culture could grow under anaerobic conditions only in the presence of molecular hydrogen, formate or nitrate. The highest activity of formatehydrogenlyase and hydrogenase was found when C. freundii grew in a medium with glucose and formate. The activity was lower in media with other organic substrates, particularly, in the absence of formate or H2. The activity of hydrogenase was very low in cells grown under aerobic conditions or in the presence of nitrates while the activity of formatehydrogenlyase was not found at all for all practical purposes. The activity of formate dehydrogenase assessed in the presence of methylene blue was rather high irrespective of the conditions under which the culture was grown. However, when the activity of formate dehydrogenase was determined in the presence of benzyl viologen, it was high only in cells grown in the medium with glucose and formate.     

Restoration of hydrogenase activity in hydrogenase-negative strains of Escherichia coli by cloned DNA fragments from Chromatium vinosum and Proteus vulgaris

DNA fragments from Proteus vulgaris and Chromatium vinosum were isolated which restored hydrogenase activities in both hydA and hydB mutant strains of Escherichia coli. The hydA and hydB genes, which map near minute 59 of the genome map, 17 kb distant from each other, are not structural hydrogenase genes, but mutation in either of these genes leads to failure to synthesize any of the hydrogenase isoenzymes. The smallest DNA fragments which restored hydrogenase activity to both E. coli mutant strains were 4.7 kb from C. vinosum and 2.3 kb from P. vulgaris. These fragments were cleaved into smaller fragments which did not complement either of the E. coli mutations. The cloned heterologous genes also restored formate hydrogenlyase activity but they did not restore activity in hydE, hupA or hupB mutant strains of E. coli. The cloned genes, on plasmids, did not lead to the synthesis of proteins of sufficient size to be the hydrogenase catalytic subunit. The hydrogenase proteins synthesized by hydA and hydB mutant strains of E. coli transformed by cloned genes from P. vulgaris and C. vinosum were shown by isoelectric and immunological methods to be E. coli hydrogenase. Thus, these genes are not hydrogenase structural genes.     

Pleiotropic hydrogenase mutants of Escherichia coli K12: growth in the presence of nickel can restore hydrogenase activity

Anaerobic growth in the presence of 0.6 mM NiCl2 was able to restore hydrogenase and benzyl-viologen-linked formate dehydrogenase activities to a mutant (FD12), which is normally defective in these activities. This mutant carries a mutation located near minute 58 in the genome. Hydrogenase isoenzyme I and II activities were restored along with the hydrogenase activity that forms part of the formate hydrogen lyase system. A plasmid (pRW1) was constructed, containing a 4.8 kb chromosomal DNA insert, which was able to complement the lesion in mutant FD12. Further mutants with mutations near 58 minutes on the chromosome, and which lacked hydrogenase and formate dehydrogenase activities were isolated. These mutants were divided into three groups. Class I mutants were restored to the wild-type phenotype either by growth with 0.6 mM NiCl2 or following transformation with pRW1. Class II mutants were also complemented by pRW1 but were unaffected by growth with NiCl2. Class III mutants were unaffected by both pRW1 and growth with NiCl2. The cloned 4.8 kb fragment of chromosomal DNA therefore encodes two genes essential for hydrogenase activity. Restriction analysis indicates that the cloned DNA is the same as a fragment that has previously been cloned and which complements the hydB locus (Sankar et al. (1985) J. Bacteriol., 162, 353-360). None of the three classes of mutants possess mutations in hydrogenase structural genes.     

Studies on some characteristics of hydrogen production by cell-free extracts of rumen anaerobic bacteria

Hydrogen production was studied in the following rumen anaerobes: Bacteroides clostridiiformis, Butyrivibrio fibrisolvens, Enbacterium limosum, Fusobacterium necrophorum, Megasphaera elsdenii, Ruminococcus albus, and Ruminococcus flavefaciens. Clostridium pasteurianum and Escherichia coli were included for comparative purposes. Hydrogen production from dithionite, dithionite-reduced methyl viologen, pyruvate, and formate was determined. All species tested produced hydrogen from dithionite-reduce methyl viologen, but only C. pasteurianum, B. clostridiiformis, E. limosum, and M. elsdenii produced hydrogen from dithionite. All species except E. coli produced hydrogen from pyruvate, but activity was low or absent in extracts of E. limosum, F. necrophorum, R. albus, and R. flavefaciens unless methyl viologen was added. Hydrogen was produced from formate only by E. coli, B. clostridiiformis, E. limosum, F. necrophorum, and R. flavefaciens. Extracts were subjected to ultracentrifugation in an effort to determine the solubility of hydrogenase. The hydrogenase of all species except E. coli appeared to be soluble, although variable amounts of hydrogenase activity were detected in the pellet. Treatment of extracts of the rumen microbial species with DEAE-cellulose resulted in loss ofhydrogen production from pyruvate. Activity was restored by the addition of methyl viologen. It is concluded that hydrogen production in these rumen microorganisms is similar to that in the saccharolytic clostridia.     

Reconstitution of coupled fumarate respiration in liposomes by incorporating the electron transport enzymes isolated from Wolinella succinogenes.

Hydrogenase and fumarate reductase isolated from Wolinella succinogenes were incorporated into liposomes containing menaquinone. The two enzymes were found to be oriented solely to the outside of the resulting proteoliposomes. The proteoliposomes catalyzed fumarate reduction by H2 which generated an electrical proton potential (Delta(psi) = 0.19 V, negative inside) in the same direction as that generated by fumarate respiration in cells of W. succinogenes. The H+/e ratio brought about by fumarate reduction with H2 in proteoliposomes in the presence of valinomycin and external K+ was approximately 1. The same Delta(psi) and H+/e ratio was associated with the reduction of 2,3-dimethyl-1,4-naphthoquinone (DMN) by H2 in proteoliposomes containing menaquinone and hydrogenase with or without fumarate reductase. Proteoliposomes containing menaquinone and fumarate reductase with or without hydrogenase catalyzed fumarate reduction by DMNH2 which did not generate a Delta(psi). Incorporation of formate dehydrogenase together with fumarate reductase and menaquinone resulted in proteoliposomes catalyzing the reduction of fumarate or DMN by formate. Both reactions generated a Delta(psi) of 0.13 V (negative inside). The H+/e ratio of formate oxidation by menaquinone or DMN was close to 1. The results demonstrate for the first time that coupled fumarate respiration can be restored in liposomes using the well characterized electron transport enzymes isolated from W. succinogenes. The results support the view that Delta(psi) generation is coupled to menaquinone reduction by H2 or formate, but not to menaquinol oxidation by fumarate. Delta(psi) generation is probably caused by proton uptake from the cytoplasmic side of the membrane during menaquinone reduction, and by the coupled release of protons from H2 or formate oxidation on the periplasmic side. This mechanism is supported by the properties of two hydrogenase mutants of W. succinogenes which indicate that the site of quinone reduction is close to the cytoplasmic surface of the membrane.     

Properties of Stable Hydrogenase from the Purple Sulfur Bacterium Lamprobacter modestohalophilus

Some properties of a hydrogenase from the recently isolated phototrophic sulfur bacterium Lamprobacter modestohalophilus strain Syvash and its resistance to a number of inactivating factors have been investigated. The enzyme consists of two subunits, 64 and 30 kD; pI = 4.5. The optimal pH was 8.5-9.5 for hydrogen uptake and 4.0 for H2 evolution. Hydrogenase preparations were resistant to the effects of O2, CO, and temperature, revealing high stability under storage. A considerable inactivation of the enzyme was observed at temperatures above 80 degrees C; the temperature optimum of methyl viologen reduction by H2 was 85 degrees C. Inhibitory effects of Ni2+, Cd2+, and Mg2+ on the hydrogenase activity were shown to be reversible and competitive with respect to methyl viologen in the hydrogen oxidation reaction.     

Periplasmic methacrylate reductase activity in Wolinella succinogenes

The cell homogenate and the soluble cell fraction of Wolinella succinogenes grown with formate and fumarate catalyzed the oxidation of benzyl viologen radical by methacrylate [apparent Km=0.23 mM, Vmax=1.0 U (mg cell protein) -1] or acrylate [apparent Km=0.50 mM, Vmax=0.77 U (mg cell protein) -1]. Crotonate did not serve as an oxidant. A mutant of W. succinogenes lacking the fccABC operon was unable to catalyze methacrylate or acrylate reduction. In contrast, the inactivation of fccC alone had no effect on these activities. Methacrylate reduction by benzyl viologen radical was not catalyzed by fumarate reductase isolated from the membrane of W. succinogenes. Cells grown with formate and fumarate did not catalyze methacrylate reduction by formate, and W. succinogenes did not grow with formate and methacrylate as catabolic substrates. The results suggest that the reduction of methacrylate or acrylate by benzyl viologen radical is most likely catalyzed either by the periplasmic flavoprotein FccA or by a complex consisting of FccA and the predicted c-type cytochrome FccB. The metabolic function of the fccABC operon remains unknown.     

Biodiversity of Hydrogenases in Frankia

Eighteen Frankia strains originally isolated from nine different host plants were used to study the biodiversity of hydrogenase in Frankia. In the physiological analysis, the activities of uptake hydrogenase and bidirectional hydrogenase were performed by monitoring the oxidation of hydrogen after supplying the cells with 1% hydrogen and the evolution of hydrogen using methyl viologen as an electron donor, respectively. These analyses were supported with a study of the immunological relationship between Frankia hydrogenase and other different known hydrogenases from other microorganisms. Uptake hydrogenase activity was recorded from all the Frankia strains investigated. A methyl-viologen-mediated hydrogen evolution was recorded from only four Frankia strains irrespective of the source of Frankia. From the immunological and physiological studies, we here report that there are at least three types of hydrogenases in Frankia: Ni-Fe uptake hydrogenase, hydrogen-evolving hydrogenase, and [Fe]-hydrogenase. An immunogold localization study, by cryosection technique, of the effect of nickel on the intercellular distribution of hydrogenase proteins in Frankia indicated that nickel affects the transfer of hydrogenase proteins into the membrane.     

Enzymatic synthesis of formic acid from H2 and CO2 and production of hydrogen from formic acid

Whole cells of Alcaligenes eutrophus (as well as isolated P. oxalaticus formate dehydrogenase and A. eutrophus hydrogenase coupled via NAD(+) or methyl viologen) have been shown to produce H(2) from formic acid. Immobilization of the cells in kappacarrageenan gel greatly enhances their stability at room temperature. The rate of hydrogen production catalyzed by immobilized A. eutrophus has been studied as a function of the concentrations of the cells and formate and also pH. An inhibition by high concentrations of formate has been found. Immobilized cells were also capable of synthesizingformate from H(2) and bicarbonate. Yields of formate up to 30% have been obtained. The catalytic efficiency of immobilized A. eutrophus cells was compared with that of palladium adsorbed on activated carbon.     

Inhibition of Desulfovibrio gigas hydrogenase with copper salts and other metal ions

The effect of several transition metals on the activity of Desulfovibrio gigas hydrogenase has been studied. Co(II) and Ni(II) at a concentration of 1 mM did not modify the activity of the enzyme; nor did they affect the pattern of activation/deactivation. Cu(II) inhibited the active hydrogenase, prepared by treatment with hydrogen, but had little effect on the 'unready' enzyme unless a reductant such as ascorbate was present, in which case inactivation took place either in air or under argon. Hg(II) also inactivated the enzyme irreversible in the 'unready' state without the requirement for reductants. The reaction of H2 uptake with methyl viologen was much more sensitive to inhibition than the H2/tritium exchange activity. EPR spectra of this preparation showed that the rates of decline were [3Fe-4S] signal greater than H2-uptake activity greater than Ni-A signal. Similar results were obtained when the protein was treated with Hg(II). The results demonstrate that the [3Fe-4S] cluster is not essential for H2-uptake activity with methyl viologen, but the integrity of [4Fe-4S] clusters is probably necessary to catalyze the reduction of methyl viologen with hydrogen. D. gigas hydrogenase was found to be highly resistant to digestion by proteases.     

Utilization of electrically reduced neutral red by Actinobacillus succinogenes: physiological function of neutral red in membrane-driven fumarate reduction and energy conservation

Neutral red (NR) functioned as an electronophore or electron channel enabling either cells or membranes purified from Actinobacillus succinogenes to drive electron transfer and proton translocation by coupling fumarate reduction to succinate production. Electrically reduced NR, unlike methyl or benzyl viologen, bound to cell membranes, was not toxic, and chemically reduced NAD. The cell membrane of A. succinogenes contained high levels of benzyl viologen-linked hydrogenase (12.2 U), fumarate reductase (13.1 U), and diaphorase (109.7 U) activities. Fumarate reductase (24.5 U) displayed the highest activity with NR as the electron carrier, whereas hydrogenase (1.1 U) and diaphorase (0.8 U) did not. Proton translocation by whole cells was dependent on either electrically reduced NR or H2 as the electron donor and on the fumarate concentration. During the growth of Actinobacillus on glucose plus electrically reduced NR in an electrochemical bioreactor system versus on glucose alone, electrically reduced NR enhanced glucose consumption, growth, and succinate production by about 20% while it decreased acetate production by about 50%. The rate of fumarate reduction to succinate by purified membranes was twofold higher with electrically reduced NR than with hydrogen as the electron donor. The addition of 2-(n-heptyl)-4-hydroxyquinoline N-oxide to whole cells or purified membranes inhibited succinate production from H2 plus fumarate but not from electrically reduced NR plus fumarate. Thus, NR appears to replace the function of menaquinone in the fumarate reductase complex, and it enables A. succinogenes to utilize electricity as a significant source of metabolic reducing power.