Retroviral vectors for human gene delivery

The potential for gene therapy to cure a wide range of diseases has lead to high expectations and a great increase in research efforts in this area. At present, viral vectors are the most efficient means of delivering a corrective gene into human cells. While a number of different viral vectors are under development, retroviral vectors are currently the most common type used in clinical trials today. However, the production of retroviral vectors for gene therapy applications faces a number of challenges. Of primary concern is the low titre of vector stocks produced by packaging cells in culture and the inherent instability of retroviral vector activity. The problems facing large-scale retroviral vector production are outlined in this review and the research efforts by a number of groups who have attempted to optimise production methods are presented.     

Gene therapy: progress and challenges.

Gene therapy is the delivery of new genetic material into a patient's somatic cells for the treatment of disease and is made possible through the development of viral and non-viral gene transfer vectors. In the first five years of gene therapy, clinical studies failed to yield efficacy data with the vectors available at that time. The lack of consistent clinical benefit prompted the United States National Institute of Health Recombinant DNA Advisory Committee to evaluate gene therapy research and conclude that substantial improvements in gene transfer vectors were needed in the areas of vector safety and control of the level and duration of gene expression, and to increase the understanding of the biological interaction of gene transfer vectors with the host. We will describe the progress in development of gene delivery technology, focusing on improvements in vector safety, analysis of vector biodistribution and GMP manufacturing of viral and non-viral gene transfer systems over the last six years since the report. Whereas 5 years ago, investigators tested every vector for every potential disease indication, the accumulated database now enables investigators to select a single vector based upon it's known performance in a wide number of animal models and human clinical studies. We will also highlight several directions investigators have taken to improve the safety and efficacy of gene therapy vectors.     

Development of hybrid viral vectors for gene therapy

Adenoviral, retroviral/lentiviral, adeno-associated viral, and herpesviral vectors are the major viral vectors used in gene therapy. Compared with non-viral methods, viruses are highly-evolved, natural delivery agents for genetic materials. Despite their remarkable transduction efficiency, both clinical trials and laboratory experiments have suggested that viral vectors have inherent shortcomings for gene therapy, including limited loading capacity, immunogenicity, genotoxicity, and failure to support long-term adequate transgenic expression. One of the key issues in viral gene therapy is the state of the delivered genetic material in transduced cells. To address genotoxicity and improve the therapeutic transgene expression profile, construction of hybrid vectors have recently been developed. By adding new abilities or replacing certain undesirable elements, novel hybrid viral vectors are expected to outperform their conventional counterparts with improved safety and enhanced therapeutic efficacy. This review provides a comprehensive summary of current achievements in hybrid viral vector development and their impact on the field of gene therapy.     

Gene therapy: the first two decades and the current state-of-the-art

The concept of gene therapy was envisioned soon after the emergence of restriction endonucleases and subcloning of mammalian genes in phage and plasmids. Over the ensuing decades, vectors were developed, including nonviral methods, integrating virus vectors (gammaretrovirus and lentivirus), and non-integrating virus vectors (adenovirus, adeno-associated virus, and herpes simplex virus vectors). Preclinical data demonstrated potential efficacy in a broad range of animal models of human diseases, but clinical efficacy in humans remained elusive in most cases, even after decades of experience in over 1000 trials. Adverse effects from gene therapy have been observed in some cases, often because of viral vectors retaining some of the pathogenic potential of the viruses upon which they are based. Later generation vectors have been developed in which the safety and/or the efficiency of gene transfer has been improved. Most recently this work has involved alterations of vector envelope or capsid proteins either by insertion of ligands to target specific receptors or by directed evolution. The disease targets for gene therapy are multiple, but the most promising data have come from monogenic disorders. As the number of potential targets for gene therapy continues to increase, and a substantial number of trials continue with both the standard and the later generation vector systems, it is hoped that a therapeutic niche for gene therapy will emerge in the coming decades.     

Cation-exchange high-performance liquid chromatography of recombinant adeno-associated virus type 2

There has been much interest recently in the development of recombinant viruses as vectors for gene therapy applications. We have constructed a recombinant adeno-associated viral (AAV) vector containing the gene encoding CFTR (cystic fibrosis transmembrane chloride regulator). This vector is currently being used in clinical trials as a treatment for cystic fibrosis. In the course of scale-up and process optimization efforts, a variety of analyses have been developed to characterize yield and quality. Although these methods produce quantitative and highly reproducible results, most are very time intensive. For example, a standard bioassay requires a 72-h incubation period followed by an additional day of analysis. Other tests such as UV spectrophotometry are fast, but unable to distinguish between whole virus, free protein, and DNA. Here, we describe an analytical cation-exchange high-performance liquid chromatographic method utilizing a TSKgel SP-NPR strong cation-exchange column. Unlike the bioassay which requires a 96-h wait for information, this method yields data in less than 20 min. In addition to the quick assay turn-around, the material eluting in the single peak was found to be intact, infectious, nuclease resistant AAV particles. This offers a significant advantage over the limited information one gains from UV spectrophotometry. This demonstrates the utility of chromatography for analysis and purification of viral vectors.     

From the first to the third generation adenoviral vector: What parameters are governing the production yield?

Human adenoviral viral vector serotype 5 (AdV) is presently the primary viral vector used in gene therapy trials. Advancements in AdV process development directly contribute to the clinical application and commercialization of the AdV gene delivery technology. Notably, the development of AdV production in suspension culture has driven the increase in AdV volumetric and specific productivity, therefore providing large quantities of AdV required for clinical studies. This review focuses on detailing the viral, cell and cell culture parameters governing the productivity of the three generations of AdV vectors.     

Mouse Transplant Models for Evaluating the Oncogenic Risk of a Self-Inactivating XSCID Lentiviral Vector

Hematopoietic stem cell gene therapy requires the use of integrating retroviral vectors in order to stably transmit a therapeutic gene to mature blood cells. Human clinical trials have shown that some vector integration events lead to disrupted regulation of proto-oncogenes resulting in disordered hematopoiesis including T-cell leukemia. Newer vectors have been designed to decrease the incidence of these adverse events but require appropriate pre-clinical assays to demonstrate safety. We have used two distinct mouse serial transplant assays to evaluate the safety of a self-inactivating lentiviral vector intended for use in X-linked severe combined immunodeficiency (XSCID) gene therapy trials. These experiments entailed 28 months of total follow-up and included 386 mice. There were no cases in which the XSCID lentiviral vector clearly caused hematopoietic malignancies, although a single case of B cell malignancy was observed that contained the lentiviral vector as a likely passenger event. In contrast, a SFFV-DsRed γ-retroviral vector resulted in clonal transformation events in multiple secondary recipients. Non-specific pathology not related to vector insertions was noted including T cell leukemias arising from irradiated recipient cells. Overall, this comprehensive study of mouse transplant safety assays demonstrate the relative safety of the XSCID lentiviral vector but also highlight the limitations of these assays.     

Gene therapy for cancer and metastatic disease

Gene therapy has been applied to the treatment of cancer and metastatic disease for over ten years. Research in this area has utilised multiple gene therapy approaches including targeting tumour suppressor genes and oncogenes, stimulating the immune system, targeted chemotherapy, antiangiogenic strategies, and direct viral oncolysis. In recent years, gene delivery vectors have been developed that selectively target tumour cells through tumour-specific receptors, deletion of certain viral gene sequences, or incorporation of tumour-specific promoter sequences that drive gene expression. Preclinical models have produced promising results, demonstrating significant tumour regression and reduction of metastatic disease. Unfortunately, only limited responses have been observed in clinical trials. The main limitations in treating metastatic disease include poor vector transduction efficiencies and difficulties in targeting remote tumour cells with systemic vector delivery. Currently, various groups are investigating means to improve gene delivery and clinical responses by continuing to modify gene delivery vectors and by concentrating on combination gene therapy and multimodality therapy.     

Adeno-associated viral vectors for gene transfer and gene therapy.

Adeno-associated virus (AAV) is a defective, non-pathogenic human parvovirus that depends for growth on coinfection with a helper adenovirus or herpes virus. Recombinant adeno-associated viruses (rAAVs) have attracted considerable interest as vectors for gene therapy. In contrast to other gene delivery systems, rAAVs lack all viral genes and show long-term gene expression in vivo without immune response or toxicity. Over the past few years, many applications of rAAVs as therapeutic agents have demonstrated the utility of this vector system for long-lasting genetic modification and gene therapy in preclinical models of human disease. New production methods have increased rAAV vector titers and eliminated contamination by adenovirus. In addition, vectors for regulatable gene expression and vectors retargeted to different cells have been engineered. These advancements are expected to accelerate and facilitate further animal model studies, providing validation for use of rAAVs in human clinical trials.     

Common gene therapy viral vectors do not efficiently penetrate sputum from cystic fibrosis patients

Norwalk virus and human papilloma virus, two viruses that infect humans at mucosal surfaces, have been found capable of rapidly penetrating human mucus secretions. Viral vectors for gene therapy of Cystic Fibrosis (CF) must similarly penetrate purulent lung airway mucus (sputum) to deliver DNA to airway epithelial cells. However, surprisingly little is known about the rates at which gene delivery vehicles penetrate sputum, including viral vectors used in clinical trials for CF gene therapy. We find that sputum spontaneously expectorated by CF patients efficiently traps two viral vectors commonly used in CF gene therapy trials, adenovirus (d～80 nm) and adeno-associated virus (AAV serotype 5; d～20 nm), leading to average effective diffusivities that are ～3,000-fold and 12,000-fold slower than their theoretical speeds in water, respectively. Both viral vectors are slowed by adhesion, as engineered muco-inert nanoparticles with diameters as large as 200 nm penetrate the same sputum samples at rates only ～40-fold reduced compared to in pure water. A limited fraction of AAV exhibit sufficiently fast mobility to penetrate physiologically thick sputum layers, likely because of the lower viscous drag and smaller surface area for adhesion to sputum constituents. Nevertheless, poor penetration of CF sputum is likely a major contributor to the ineffectiveness of viral vector based gene therapy in the lungs of CF patients observed to date.     

Cell and viral regulatory elements enhance the expression and function of a human immunodeficiency virus inhibitory gene.

Regulated expression of recombinant genes in CD4+ cells is an important objective for gene therapy of AIDS, as these cells represent the principal target for viral replication of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV). We report here that specific combinations of CD4 cell-specific and viral regulatory elements can enhance expression of an antiviral gene product. Different viral regulatory elements were incorporated into a previously reported CD4 locus control region to increase the expression of reporter genes in T and monocytic cell lines. The CD4-specific regulatory elements were included to enhance expression in CD4 cells, and viral regulatory regions, including the cytomegalovirus immediate-early (CMV IE) upstream enhancer, which contains the kappa B and Ap1 regulatory elements and a Tat-responsive element of the HIV type 1 long terminal repeat, were used to increase gene expression and modulate its activity in response to viral infection. In transient transfection assays, this vector was 100- to 1,000-fold more active than the original CD4 regulatory elements alone. Expression of an inhibitory form of the Rev protein, Rev M10, was more effective than previously described vectors and protected against productive viral replication in CD4+ peripheral blood mononuclear cells. The combination of CD4 lineage-specific and viral regulatory elements will facilitate the development of more effective antiviral genetic strategies for AIDS.     

Effect of protease inhibitors on yield of HSV-1-based viral vectors

The ability to obtain high titer replication-defective herpes simplex virus (HSV) recombinant vectors will dramatically affect their use in gene therapy clinical trials. A variety of techniques and reagents have been employed to increase the overall yield of the vector. The effects of protease inhibitors on the yield of an HSV-1-based viral vector were examined. Experiments were conducted using a commercial protease inhibitor cocktail typically used in mammalian cell culture for protein production. Contrary to our expectation for enhanced vector yield, the results showed a dramatic reduction in vector yield. Moreover, it was found that AEBSF is the only component in the protease cocktail responsible for the low vector yield. On the basis of our hypothesis regarding the mode of action of AEBSF, we suggest that it should not be included in protease inhibitor cocktails designed for use in cultures aimed at production of viral vectors derived from HSV-1 or possibly several other vectors.     

Going non-viral: the Sleeping Beauty transposon system breaks on through to the clinical side

Molecular medicine has entered a high-tech age that provides curative treatments of complex genetic diseases through genetically engineered cellular medicinal products. Their clinical implementation requires the ability to stably integrate genetic information through gene transfer vectors in a safe, effective and economically viable manner. The latest generation of Sleeping Beauty (SB) transposon vectors fulfills these requirements, and may overcome limitations associated with viral gene transfer vectors and transient non-viral gene delivery approaches that are prevalent in ongoing pre-clinical and translational research. The SB system enables high-level stable gene transfer and sustained transgene expression in multiple primary human somatic cell types, thereby representing a highly attractive gene transfer strategy for clinical use. Here we review several recent refinements of the system, including the development of optimized transposons and hyperactive SB variants, the vectorization of transposase and transposon as mRNA and DNA minicircles (MCs) to enhance performance and facilitate vector production, as well as a detailed understanding of SB’s genomic integration and biosafety features. This review also provides a perspective on the regulatory framework for clinical trials of gene delivery with SB, and illustrates the path to successful clinical implementation by using, as examples, gene therapy for age-related macular degeneration (AMD) and the engineering of chimeric antigen receptor (CAR)-modified T cells in cancer immunotherapy.     

Gene therapy in The Netherlands: highlights from the Low Countries

Gene therapy is an active research area in The Netherlands and Dutch scientists involved in fundamental and clinical gene therapy research significantly contribute to the progresses made in this field. This ranges from the establishment of the 293, 911 and PER.C6 cell lines, which are used worldwide for the production of replication-defective adenoviral vectors, to the development of targeted viral vectors and T lymphocytes as well as of non-viral vectors. Several milestones have been achieved in Dutch clinical gene therapy trials, including the first treatment worldwide of patients with adenosine deaminase deficiency with genetically corrected hematopoietic stem cells in collaboration with French and British scientists. Until now, about 230 patients with various diseases have been treated with viral and non-viral gene therapy in this country. Ongoing and upcoming Dutch clinical trials focus on the translation of new developments in gene therapy research, including the restoration of genetic defects other than SCID, and the use of oncolytic adenoviruses and targeted T cells for the treatment of cancer. The growing commercial interest in Dutch clinical gene therapy is reflected by the involvement of two Dutch companies in ongoing trials as well as the participation of Dutch clinical centres in large phase III international multicenter immuno-gene therapy trials on prostate cancer sponsored by an American company. Translational gene therapy research in The Netherlands is boosted at a governmental level by the Dutch Ministry of Health via a dedicated funding programme. This paper presents an overview on milestones in Dutch basic gene therapy research as well as on past, present and future clinical gene therapy trials in The Netherlands.     

Comparison of single regulated lentiviral vectors with rtTA expression driven by an autoregulatory loop or a constitutive promoter

Regulated expression of a therapeutic gene is crucial for safe and efficacious gene therapy. Many inducible regulatory systems use a constitutive promoter to express a regulatory protein, such as rtTA in the Tet-On system, which may restrict their use because of cytotoxicity and immunogenicity. Autoregulatory expression of rtTA provides extremely low levels of rtTA when transgene expression is off, with rapid transgene induction upon addition of doxycycline. Lentiviral vectors efficiently transfer genes to dividing and non-dividing cells with long-term gene expression both in vitro and in vivo. We compared regulatory function in a single lentiviral vector where rtTA was either expressed from a constitutive promoter or placed in an autoregulatory loop. Autoregulatory expression of rtTA was superior to constitutive promoter expression, resulting in higher viral titers, undetectable levels of both rtTA and transgene expression in the absence of doxycycline, improved induction kinetics and increased induction levels in all cells tested. We further expanded the utility of the autoregulatory vector by using an improved rtTA variant with an increased sensitivity to doxycycline. This lentiviral vector with doxycycline-regulated transgene expression may be useful for gene therapy applications and in experimental settings where strict temporal expression of a transgene is required.     

Development of Dual-Activity Vectors by Co-Envelopment of Adenovirus and SiRNA in Artificial Lipid Bilayers

Gene therapy with human adenovirus type 5 (Ad5) has been extensively explored for the treatment of diseases resistant to traditional therapies. Intravenous administration leads to rapid clearance from blood circulation and high liver accumulation, which restrict the use of Ad-based vectors in clinical gene therapy protocols that involve systemic administration. We have previously proposed that such limitations can be improved by engineering artificial lipid envelopes around Ad and designed a variety of artificial lipid bilayer envelopes around the viral capsid. In this study, we sought to explore further opportunities that the artificially enveloped virus constructs could offer, by designing a previously unreported gene therapy vector by simultaneous envelopment of Ad and siRNA within the same lipid bilayer. Such a dual-activity vector can offer efficacious therapy for different genetic disorders where both turning on and switching off genes would be needed. Dynamic light scattering, transmission electron microscopy and atomic force microscopy were used to characterize these vectors. Agarose gel electrophoresis, Ribo green and dot blot assays showed that siRNA and Ad virions can be enveloped together within lipid bilayers at high envelopment efficiency. Cellular uptake and in vitro transfection experiments were carried out to show the feasibility of combining siRNA-mediated gene silencing with viral gene transfer using these newly designed dual-activity vectors.