Quantitative Analysis of Genetic Parameters in Populations of European (Capreolus capreolus L.) and Siberian (Capreolus pygargus Pall.) Roe Deer with RAPD Markers

A technique for obtaining unbiased estimates of genetic parameters (allelic frequencies of RAPD loci, heterozygosity (H), Wright's Fstatistic, and Nei's genetic distances) in populations of the European (Capreolus capreolus L.) and Siberian (Capreolus pygargus Pall.) roe deer is presented. The technique employs jackknifing and multiple comparative analysis based on a modified Holmes's procedure for Bonferroni's test. It was demonstrated that samples from local groups of roe deer in the Trans-Ural region did not differ significantly in allelic frequencies (0.8, 0.81, and 0.78; P > 0.447) or Nei's genetic distances (0.0056, 0.0273, and 0.0218; P = 0.26), but they could be differentiated based on Wright's F statistic (0.0346, 0.0519, and 0.0450; P = 10^–9). The parameters of within-population heterozygosity formed a gradient from the east to the west. Calibration estimates of molecular evolution rate in the family Cervidae obtained based on published data and Jukes–Cantor genetic distances estimated in this study demonstrated that the Siberian roe deer has split into two subspecies, C. pygargus pygargusPall. and C. pygargus tianschanicusSatunin in the interval between 229 and 462.3 thousand years ago. The species formation of the Siberian and European roe deer was dated between 1.375 and 2.75 Myr ago. Based on the results obtained we recommend the approaches used in the study for analysis of population genetic structure and phylogenetic relationships between populations, subspecies, species, and higher taxa.     

Skull variation in the Siberian roe deer <Emphasis Type="Italic">Capreolus pygargus</Emphasis> from the Far East: a revision of the distribution of the subspecies

Extremely widespread in the Palaearctic, roe deer are heterogeneous in many ways including their morphology. At present, two roe deer species and four basic subspecies are acknowledged. The taxonomic system of the Siberian roe deer is poorly developed compared to that of the European roe deer. One of the principal points of roe deer systematics is the determination of the boundaries of the ranges of the roe deer subspecies requiring a thorough study of the species’ diversity. By using craniometry, one of the most adequate systematics techniques, we have analyzed geographical distribution of the Suberian roe deer in the Russian Far East and adjacent areas. All studied specimens were separated into three groups, the distributions of craniometric parameters of two of which did not overlap. One of the groups corresponds to Capreolus pygargus pygargus Pallas, 1771, while the other two do not correspond to any of the Siberian roe deer subspecies presently acknowledged. We have shown that the C. pygargus pygargus range extends to the east to the Northern Primorye, i.e., it is 2,000 to 3,000 km wider than previously believed. The subspecies status of Capreolus pygargus tianschanicus Satunin, 1906 was not confirmed. The Southern Primorye and left bank of the Amur River are thus a part of the range of Capreolus pygargus melanotis Miller, 1911, penetrating here from the Northeastern China.     

Variability of multilocus DNA markers in populations of the Siberian (Capreolus pygargus Pall.) and European (C. capreolus L.) roe deer

Two types of nuclear DNA markers, M13 minisatellites and RAPD, were used to examine intraspecific and interspecific variation in closely related roe deer species, Capreolus capreolus L. and C. pygargus Pall. The roe deer populations studied were highly polymorphic for minisatellite DNA markers (S = 0.12-0.36). Heterozygosities of the RAPD loci were 0.185 (Russian Far East), 0.145, 0.131, 0.088 (Cis-Ural), and 0.06 (France). They correlated with karyotypic variation of B chromosomes (r = 0.975, P < 0.02; Spearman's correlation coefficient r = 1, P = 0.1 x 10(-5)), which indicated a contribution of microchromosomes to genetic variation of the species. The genetic distance D between the closely related species C. capreolus and C. pygargus was 50 times greater than the distance between populations within a species. The estimates of heterozygosity and genetic distance between local populations of Cis-Ural and the Far East suggest their specific spatial organization within this geographical range and reveal features of their historical development.     

东北地区狍种群的遗传多样性研究

狍为我国重要的经济动物,并且是国家一级保护动物东北虎的主要猎物之一。因此,深入了解狍各地理单元内种群的遗传变异,可以为我们制定保护管理策略提供依据,进而使珍稀濒危物种得到有效的保护和管理。本文对88个不同狍个体(来自8个不同地点)的线粒体DNA控制区的部分序列进行了测定和群体分析,获得了463bp的片断,并检测到59个变异位点,占分析长度的7.84%,且这59个变异位点皆为碱基置换,未出现碱基插入或缺失的现象,定义了30种单倍型,核苷酸多样性平均值为0.02641,种群总体遗传多样性较高。从Tajima’sD和FuandLi’sD值的估算结果来看,这8个狍种群相对于中性进化的歧异度并没有明显的偏离(P0.1),没有明显的证据显示这8个狍种群间存在很强的平衡选择。30个单倍型整体上将东北狍种群分为3个亚群,分子变异分析表明3个亚群间基因流Nm均大于1,说明这3个狍亚群间存在着基因流。     

Genetic diversity and phylogeography of Siberian roe deer,Caproulus pygargus,in central and peripheral populations

Current understanding of phylogeographical structure and genetic diversity of Siberian roe deer remains limited mainly due to small sample size and/or low geographical coverage in previous studies. Published data suggest at least two phylogroups: western (Ural Mountains and Western Siberia) and eastern (east from lake Baikal, including the Korean peninsula), but their phylogenetic relationship remains unclear. Combined sequences of cytochrome b (1140 bp) and the mtDNA control region (963 bp) were analyzed from 219 Siberian roe deer from 12 locations in Russia, Mongolia, and South Korea, which cover a large part of its range, to assess genetic diversity and phylogeographical status. Special emphasis was placed on the demographic history and genetic features of central, peripheral, and isolated populations. Results of median‐joining network and phylogenetic tree analyses indicate that Siberian roe deer from the Urals to the Pacific Ocean are genetically diverse and that geographical distribution and composition of haplogroups coincide with previously described ranges of the subspecies Capreolus pygargus pygargus and Capreolus pygargus tianschanicus. We found that peripheral populations in the northwestern parts of the species range (Urals), as well as the isolated population from Jeju Island, are genetically distinct from those in the core part of the range, both in terms of genetic diversity and quantitative composition of haplogroups. We also found that northwestern (Urals) and northern (Yakutia) peripheral populations share the same haplogroup and fall into the same phylogenetic clade with the isolated population from Jeju Island. This finding sheds light on the taxonomic status of the Jeju Island population and leads to hypotheses about the discordance of morphological and genetic evolution in isolated populations and specific genetic features of peripheral populations.     

Genotyping of Capreolus pygargus fossil DNA from Denisova cave reveals phylogenetic relationships between ancient and modern populations

Background

The extant roe deer (Capreolus Gray, 1821) includes two species: the European roe deer (C. capreolus) and the Siberian roe deer (C. pygargus) that are distinguished by morphological and karyotypical differences. The Siberian roe deer occupies a vast area of Asia and is considerably less studied than the European roe deer. Modern systematics of the Siberian roe deer remain controversial with 4 morphological subspecies. Roe deer fossilized bones are quite abundant in Denisova cave (Altai Mountains, South Siberia), where dozens of both extant and extinct mammalian species from modern Holocene to Middle Pleistocene have been retrieved.

Methodology/Principal Findings

We analyzed a 629 bp fragment of the mitochondrial control region from ancient bones of 10 Holocene and four Pleistocene Siberian roe deer from Denisova cave as well as 37 modern specimen belonging to populations from Altai, Tian Shan (Kyrgyzstan), Yakutia, Novosibirsk region and the Russian Far East. Genealogical reconstructions indicated that most Holocene haplotypes were probably ancestral for modern roe deer populations of Western Siberia and Tian Shan. One of the Pleistocene haplotypes was possibly ancestral for modern Yakutian populations, and two extinct Pleistocene haplotypes were close to modern roe deer from Tian Shan and Yakutia. Most modern geographical populations (except for West Siberian Plains) are heterogeneous and there is some tentative evidence for structure. However, we did not find any distinct phylogenetic signal characterizing particular subspecies in either modern or ancient samples.

Conclusion/Significance

Analysis of mitochondrial DNA from both ancient and modern samples of Siberian roe deer shed new light on understanding the evolutionary history of roe deer. Our data indicate that during the last 50,000 years multiple replacements of populations of the Siberian roe deer took place in the Altai Mountains correlating with climatic changes. The Siberian roe deer represent a complex and heterogeneous species with high migration rates and without evident subspecies structure. Low genetic diversity of the West Siberian Plain population indicates a recent bottleneck or founder effect.     

Unexpected population genetic structure of European roe deer in Poland: an invasion of the mtDNA genome from Siberian roe deer

Introgressive hybridization is a widespread evolutionary phenomenon which may lead to increased allelic variation at selective neutral loci and to transfer of fitness‐related traits to introgressed lineages. We inferred the population genetic structure of the European roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) in Poland from mitochondrial (CR and cyt b) and sex‐linked markers (ZFX, SRY, DBY4 and DBY8). Analyses of CR mtDNA sequences from 452 individuals indicated widespread introgression of Siberian roe deer (C. pygargus) mtDNA in the European roe deer genome, 2000 km from the current distribution range of C. pygargus. Introgressed individuals constituted 16.6% of the deer studied. Nearly 75% of them possessed haplotypes belonging to the group which arose 23 kyr ago and have not been detected within the natural range of Siberian roe deer, indicating that majority of present introgression has ancient origin. Unlike the mtDNA results, sex‐specific markers did not show signs of introgression. Species distribution modelling analyses suggested that C. pygargus could have extended its range as far west as Central Europe after last glacial maximum. The main hybridization event was probably associated with range expansion of the most abundant European roe deer lineage from western refugia and took place in Central Europe after the Younger Dryas (10.8–10.0 ka BP). Initially, introgressed mtDNA variants could have spread out on the wave of expansion through the mechanism of gene surfing, reaching high frequencies in European roe deer populations and leading to observed asymmetrical gene flow. Human‐mediated introductions of C. pygargus had minimal effect on the extent of mtDNA introgression.     

Identification of European (Capreolus capreolus L.) and Siberian (C. pygargus Pall.) roe deer hybrids by microsatellite marker analysis

An analysis of 130 tissue specimens of the European (Capreolus capreolus) and the Siberian (C. pygargus) roe deer from nine regions of Russia and Ukraine using microsatellite loci analysis was conducted, aimed at the identification of hybrid animals. An optimized complex of 21 microsatellite loci was selected for the determination of species specificity and the search for interspecies hybrids. Hybrid animals were revealed in the Moscow and Volgograd regions. Their ratio in the total sample obtained in the European part of Russia was 11.9%.     

Temporal shifts of DNA‐microsatellite allele profiles in roe deer (Capreolus capreolus L.) within three decades

DNA‐microsatellite polymorphism (four loci) was studied in 56 male roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) from a 900‐ha hunting territory in the Vosges du Nord Mountains (France), culled over 34 years (1956–1990). Changed allele frequencies at two loci within this period, and increased allelic diversity, were traced to a phase of reduced population density and subsequent immigration. Decadic population samples collected within 900‐ha were distinguished by higher genetic variability measures than were certain geographical samples across Central Europe (4–900 km). On average, the decadic cohorts were distinguished by a gene diversity index of G_ST = 0.0286, and a genetic distance of D = 0.0938, which reflect 54% (G_ST) and 69% (D) of the respective geographic (350 km) differentiation indices of roe deer in Central Europe. The importance of demography and population ecology effects for microevolution in a large mammal is demonstrated, as is the risk of artefact by composing population samples of deer over several years. Population genetic screening should cover various demes of roe deer from the same general region, and be based on many unlinked polymorphic loci, to minimize the distorting effects of genetic dynamics at the small spatial scale.     

Mitochondrial DNA Distinction of Northeastern China Roe Deer, Siberian Roe Deer, and European Roe Deer, to Clarify the Taxonomic Status of Northeastern China Roe Deer

Partial sequences of the mitochondrial control region of northeastern China roe deer were analyzed to determine the degree of genetic diversity. Fourteen haplotypes were observed. The haplotype diversity was high (h = 0.872), nucleotide diversity was medium (p _i = 0.0108), and the average Tamura–Nei nucleotide distance among them was 1.9%, indicating that genetic diversity of roe deer from northeastern China was relatively high and that the effective population size was large historically. To clarify the northeastern China roe deer's taxonomic status, these 14 haplotypes were compared with 31 haplotypes published in Genbank from Europe, Siberia, and Korea. The average genetic distance between haplogroups of northeastern China and European roe deer (5.8%) was more than twice that between northeastern China and Siberian roe deer (2.7%), indicating sufficient variation to consider roe deer of northeastern China and Siberia as a single species (Capreolus pygargus), distinct from European roe deer (Capreolus capreolus). This is the first presentation of mtDNA data for roe deer in northeastern China, which will be helpful in investigations of genetic diversity and clarifications of the taxonomic status of roe deer in the whole of China.     

The genetic structure of natural and reintroduced roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) populations in the Alps and central Italy,with reference to the mitochondrial DNA phylogeography of Europe

The first hypervariable fragment (HVI) of the mitochondrial DNA control region was sequenced in 90 individuals of the European roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) from the Alps, central Italy and Spain. Pooling these data with 70 published sequences from several European regions, we were able to identify patterns of divergence within the Italian peninsula, and in Europe in general. The results we obtained can be summarized as follows. First, the genetic structure of European roe deer populations is substantial (PhiST values around 0.6). Second, the divergence between some central Italian populations, the Alpine group (which is genetically close to the French, the Spanish and the Norwegian samples) and the Eastern European populations seems to reflect Upper Pleistocene subdivisions, possibly related to three southern European refugia. Third, a different group of central Italian individuals probably diverged more recently from the Alpine group, and their attribution to the subspecies C. c. italicus does not appear justified. Fourth, the analysis of mitochondrial DNA in the roe deer can be used to identify recently reintroduced animals in the western Alps which clearly cluster within the Eastern European group, thus providing an important tool for conservation and management strategies for this species.     

Genetic diversity and genetic structure of the Siberian roe deer (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Capreolus pygargus</Emphasis>) populations from Asia

Background

The roe deer, Capreolus sp., is one of the most widespread meso-mammals of Palearctic distribution, and includes two species, the European roe deer, C. capreolus inhabiting mainly Europe, and the Siberian roe deer, C. pygargus, distributed throughout continental Asia. Although there are a number of genetic studies concerning European roe deer, the Siberian roe deer has been studied less, and none of these studies use microsatellite markers. Natural processes have led to genetic structuring in wild populations. To understand how these factors have affected genetic structure and connectivity of Siberian roe deer, we investigated variability at 12 microsatellite loci for Siberian roe deer from ten localities in Asia.

Results

Moderate levels of genetic diversity (H _E = 0.522 to 0.628) were found in all populations except in Jeju Island, South Korea, where the diversity was lowest?(H _E?= 0.386). Western populations showed relatively low genetic diversity and higher degrees of genetic differentiation compared with eastern populations (mean Ar = 3.54 (east), 2.81 (west), mean F _ST = 0.122). Bayesian-based clustering analysis revealed the existence of three genetically distinct groups (clusters) for Siberian roe deer, which comprise of the Southeastern group (Mainland Korea, Russian Far East, Trans-Baikal region and Northern part of Mongolia), Northwestern group (Western Siberia and Ural in Russia) and Jeju Island population. Genetic analyses including AMOVA (F _RT = 0.200), Barrier and PCA also supported genetic differentiation among regions separated primarily by major mountain ridges, suggesting that mountains played a role in the genetic differentiation of Siberian roe deer. On the other hand, genetic evidence also suggests an ongoing migration that may facilitate genetic admixture at the border areas between two groups.

Conclusions

Our results reveal an apparent pattern of genetic differentiation among populations inhabiting Asia, showing moderate levels of genetic diversity with an east-west gradient. The results suggest at least three distinct management units of roe deer in continental Asia, although genetic admixture is evident in some border areas. The insights obtained from this study shed light on management of Siberian roe deer in Asia and may be applied in conservation of local populations of Siberian roe deer.

     

Siberian Roe Deer (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Capreolus pygargus</Emphasis> Pallas, 1771) in Ukraine: Analysis of the Mitochondrial and Nuclear DNA

A molecular-genetic analysis of the nucleotide sequences of the cytochrome b gene (1140 base pairs) of the mitochondrial DNA and 17 microsatellite loci of eight samples of roe deer from the Samara forest of Dnipropetrovsk oblast (Ukraine) was carried out. For comparison, 212 corresponding mtDNA sequences of the Siberian and European roe deer and data on the variability of microsatellite markers in 49 representatives of these species were included in the study. It was noted that all the analyzed mitochondrial sequences of individuals from the Samara forest are characteristic of the Siberian roe Capreolus pygargus Pallas, 1771. Four haplotypes were described, all of which belonged to the haplogroup typical for the western part of the range of C. pygargus. A fragment analysis of the microsatellite loci of nuclear DNA confirmed the identification of the investigated group with the Siberian species.     

Microsatellite investigation of roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) in Scandinavia reveals genetic differentiation of a Baltic Sea Island population

After a decline in the early 19th century, a remnant population of the Scandinavian roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) was protected in southern Sweden around 1840. The roe deer quickly recovered and recolonized most of the Scandinavian Peninsula. In this study, I analyze microsatellite variation in 14 roe deer populations in Scandinavia to (1) investigate if all Swedish roe deer trace their ancestry to southern Sweden, (2) define other areas where roe deer may have remained during the population decline, and (3) examine if the large geographic distances during the expansion phase have influenced the degree and sorting of genetic variation. The results show that the mainland roe deer most likely trace their ancestry to southern Sweden, but interestingly, the two neighboring populations Övedskloster and Wittskövle in the south are significantly different from each other (p<0.01). Furthermore, the population in Wittskövle and roe deer from Köpingsvik at the Baltic Sea Island Öland are significantly different from all other populations (p<0.1). Thus, potentially, there are more than one founder population that contributed to the current Swedish population. The particular differentiation of roe deer from Öland might be an effect of random population genetic processes during the population expansion phase, potentially in combination with introductions of roe deer from other areas than the Swedish mainland. The results are discussed in relation to management of roe deer in Sweden.     

First occurrence of Paramphistomum microbothrium (Fischoeder 1901) in roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) in Serbia

Paramphistomum parasites identified by histology as Paramphistomum microbothrium were found in 18 of 34 roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) intestines from central Serbia, examined between 1998 and 2004. This represents the first record of P. microbothrium in roe deer in Serbia.     

Polymorphism of a short fragment of the mitochondrial genome control region (D-loop) in the Siberian roe deer <Emphasis Type="Italic">Capreolus pygargus</Emphasis> Pallas, 1771 (Artiodactyla,Cervidae) from the Russian Far East

Genetic diversity of Siberian roe deer Capreolus pygargus, 1771 from the Russian Far East was studied based on polymorphism analysis of a mtDNA control region fragment (390 bp). Three phylogenetic lines were found in the animals examined. The trend for change of haplotypes of different phylogroups was shown to occur from north to south in Sikhote-Alin. The haplotype distribution of Siberian roe deer in the Russian Far East correlated with data on morphologiocal variability.     

On the Gene Pool of Roe Deer (<Emphasis Type="Italic">Capreolus</Emphasis>) of Eastern Europe: Analysis of the Cyt <Emphasis Type="Italic">b</Emphasis> Gene Sequence Variability

Sequence analysis of the mtDNA cytochrome b gene (974 bp) was performed using 139 roe deer specimens from different regions of the European part of Russia and Ukraine. The data obtained showed that, at present, both European and Siberian roe deer inhabit this part of the range with predominance of the later: about 60% of individuals carry various Siberian haplotypes, most of which are similar to those in the populations of Capreolus pygargus from the Urals, Siberia, and the Far East. A great variety of mtDNA haplotypes of Siberian roe deer in Eastern Europe is undoubtedly caused by the heterogeneity of founder individuals (immigrants) that were imported from different parts of Asia. Some problems of coexistence of closely related species are discussed.     

Quaternary history of the European roe deer Capreolus capreolus

• 1 The European roe deer Capreolus capreolus is a typical faunal element of the Holocene. It was already present in Europe at least 600 000 years ago and it has been known from both glacial and interglacial phases since then. With nearly 3000 fossil and subfossil records, it is one of the most frequent mammals in the Late Quaternary.
• 2 During the Middle and Late Weichselian Pleniglacial, the distribution of the roe deer was not restricted to the Mediterranean peninsulas but repeatedly reached regions of central Europe. In contrast to that, roe deer records from the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM, 21.0–14.5 ka ¹⁴C BP) are largely confined to the Mediterranean peninsulas – with the exception of south‐western France and the surroundings of the Carpathians where several records attest to its occurrence during the LGM.
• 3 During the Greenland Interstadial 1 (12.5–10.8 ka ¹⁴C BP), the species' distribution extended further north and the roe deer appeared north of the Alps and reached regions of central Germany. This seems to be correlated with the abrupt change to more favourable environmental conditions during this period. It is very likely that the roe deer disappeared north of the Alps during the Younger Dryas cooling (10.8–10.0 ka¹⁴C BP). The northern regions of the central European lowlands were recolonized by roe deer during the late Preboreal 9.7–9.5 ka ¹⁴C BP for the first time since the Weichselian Glacial.
• 4 The combined pattern of genetic data and fossil records of European roe deer suggests several regions in the Iberian peninsula, southern France, Italy and the Balkans as well as in the Carpathians and/or eastern Europe as glacial refugia. It further suggests that C. capreolus might have recolonized most parts of central‐northern Europe out of one or more eastern European (not Balkan) and/or Carpathian refugia. This recolonization wave might have blocked immigration from the traditional Mediterranean areas.

     

Irreversible microevolutionary changes in genotypic composition of sika deer <Emphasis Type="Italic">Cervus nippon</Emphasis> populations in response to vegetation degradation and food shortage

The present study deals with changes in important skull characteristics of the sika deer Cervus nippon Temminck, 1838 in response to changes in food supply. Moderate food shortage results mainly in a linear reduction in skull size, while severe food shortage results in changes in skull shape. In the deer that returned to habitats with sufficient food supply, some skull parameters recovered to, or even exceeded, normal values, whereas other parameters remained stressed resulting in retention or enhancement of skull distortions. Differences in skull parameters among the populations studied were comparable to those between some cervid species, eg, the Siberian roe deer Capreolus pigargus Pallas, 1771 and European roe deer Capreolus capreolus Linnaeus, 1758 and other deer subspecies. In the introduced sika deer populations, skull distortions were apparently caused by interspecific hybridization. Descendants of the escaped deer have not reverted to the normal phenotype, even over several generations, providing a recent case of true evolutionary changes. This occurred by a change in the ratio of different morphotypical groups, probably due to their different responses to food shortage. Thus sufficient food supply may account for changes in a population’s genotypic composition through selection of characteristics that favour passing on genetic material when food is limited.     

Fluctuating asymmetry in populations of British roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) following historical bottlenecks and founder events

The potential impact of population bottlenecks and founder events on genetic diversity and indirect measures of fitness (such as fluctuating asymmetry; FA) has important conservation implications. Here we take advantage of historical events that generated a remnant roe deer (Capreolus capreolus) population in the north of the British Isles that retained diversity, while populations in the south were apparently extirpated during the early mediaeval era. The southern population was later re-established from small founder populations of introduced European roe deer starting in the 19th century. We assess the impact of these events, using the northern remnant population as a reference, based on measures of FA at 16 bilateral cranial traits. Comparing the northern and southern populations we find evidence of differential impact on both the level of FA and the relationship between FA and levels of genetic diversity.