Kinetic chemiluminescence as a method for study of free radical reactions

The review gives concepts of analysis of kinetics of complex reactions with the participation of free radicals. The concepts are based on the comparison of kinetic curves of chemiluminescent reactions in the presence of a physical enhancer coumarin C-525 with the simulated kinetic functions. This method was applied to the investigation of the mechanism of a branched-chain reaction of lipid peroxidation in biological and phospholipid membranes as well as to the effect of antioxidants and determination of their activities. It was also used for studying the reaction of formation of free radicals in the complex of cytochrome c with cardiolipin. This reaction plays a key role in the initiation of apoptosis.     

Possible participation of a free-radical lipid intermediate in the hydroxylation of polycyclic hydrocarbons

The effects of pro-oxidants (Fe2+, CCl4) and antioxidants (alpha-tocopherol, propyl gallate) on hydroxylation of polycyclic hydrocarbon benz(a)pyrene and on the NADPH-cytochrome P-450-reductase reaction were studied. The role of allyl radicals formed in the fatty acid chains in discussed. The binding of O2 to free radicals, i. e. formation of peroxy radicals, is regarded only as a possible reaction of the radical utilization. It is assumed that other reactions involving lipid radicals, in particular, electron transfer from the flavoprotein to cytochrome P-480 may occur in microsomal membranes.     

Kinetic chemiluminescence as a method for the study of free radical reactions

The review gives concepts of analysis of kinetics of complex reactions with the participation of free-radicals. The concepts are based on the comparison of the kinetic curves of the chemiluminescent reactions in the presence of a physical enhancer coumarin C-525 with the simulated kinetic functions. This method was applied to the investigation of the mechanism of a branched-chain reaction of lipid peroxidation in biological and phospholipid membranes as well as to the effect of antioxidants and determination of their activities. It was also used for studying the reaction of the formation of free radicals in the complex of cytochrome c with cardiolipin. This reaction plays a key role in the initiation of apoptosis.     

Nitric oxide reaction with lipid peroxyl radicals spares alpha-tocopherol during lipid peroxidation. Greater oxidant protection from the pair nitric oxide/alpha-tocopherol than alpha-tocopherol/ascorbate

The reactions of nitric oxide ((.)NO) and alpha-tocopherol (alpha-TH) during membrane lipid oxidation were examined and compared with the pair alpha-TH/ascorbate. Nitric oxide serves as a more potent inhibitor of lipid peroxidation propagation reactions than alpha-TH and protects alpha-TH from oxidation. Mass spectrometry, oxygen and (.)NO consumption, conjugated diene analyses, and alpha-TH fluorescence determinations all demonstrated that (.)NO preferentially reacts with lipid radical species, with alpha-TH consumption not occurring until (.)NO concentrations fell below a critical level. In addition, alpha-TH and (.)NO cooperatively inhibit lipid peroxidation, exhibiting greater antioxidant capacity than the pair alpha-TH/ascorbate. Pulse radiolysis analysis showed no direct reaction between (.)NO and alpha-tocopheroxyl radical (alpha-T(.)), inferring that peroxyl radical termination reactions are the principal lipid-protective mechanism mediated by (.)NO. These observations support the concept that (.)NO is a potent chain breaking antioxidant toward peroxidizing lipids, due to facile radical-radical termination reactions with lipid radical species, thus preventing alpha-TH loss. The reduction of alpha-T(.) by ascorbate was a comparatively less efficient mechanism for preserving alpha-TH than (.)NO-mediated termination of peroxyl radicals, due to slower reaction kinetics and limited transfer of reducing equivalents from the aqueous phase. Thus, the high lipid/water partition coefficient of (.)NO, its capacity to diffuse and concentrate in lipophilic milieu, and a potent reactivity toward lipid radical species reveal how (.)NO can play a critical role in regulating membrane and lipoprotein lipid oxidation reactions.     

Central nervous system trauma and stroke. I. Biochemical considerations for oxygen radical formation and lipid peroxidation

The generation of oxygen radicals and the process of lipid peroxidation have become a focus of attention for investigators in the fields of central nervous system (CNS) trauma and stroke (e.g., ischemia). Considering our level of understanding of free radical and lipid peroxidation chemistry, absolute proof for their involvement in the pathophysiology of traumatic and ischemic damage to the CNS has been meager. While direct, unequivocal evidence for the participation of free radicals and lipid peroxidation as primary contributors to the death of neuronal tissue waits to be established, numerous recent studies have provided considerable support for the occurrence of free radical and lipid peroxidation reactions in the injured or ischemic CNS. In addition, the pharmacological use of antioxidants and free radical scavengers in the treatment of experimental CNS trauma and ischemia has provided convincing, although indirect evidence, for the involvement of oxygen radicals and lipid peroxidation in these conditions. The intent of this and its companion paper is to review: 1) the biochemical processes which may give rise to free radical reactions in the CNS, 2) the environment of the ischemic cell as it may affect the generation of oxygen radicals and the catalysis of lipid peroxidation reactions, 3) the evidence for the involvement of free radical mechanisms in CNS trauma and ischemia, and 4) the pathophysiological consequences of these phenomena.     

Oxygen concentration dependence of lipid peroxidation and lipid-derived radical generation: application of profluorescent nitroxide switch

Lipid-derived radicals and peroxides are involved in the pathogenesis of oxidative stress diseases and, although lipid peroxide production is a required reaction between a lipid radical and molecular oxygen, a useful lipid radical detection method has remained tentative. Also, the effect of oxygen concentration on lipid peroxide production must be considered because of the hypoxic conditions in cancer and ischemic regions. In this study, the focus was on nitroxide reactivity, which allows spin trapping with carbon-centred radicals via radical-radical reactions and fluorophore quenching through interactions with nitroxide's unpaired electron. Thus, the aim here was to demonstrate a useful detection method for lipid-derived radicals as well as to clarify the effects of oxygen concentration on lipid peroxide production using profluorescent nitroxide. This latter compound reacted with lipid-derived radicals in a manner inversely dependent on oxygen concentration, resulting in fluorescence due to alkoxyamine formation and, conversely, lipid peroxide concentrations decreased with lower oxygen in the reaction system. Furthermore, nitroxide inhibited lipid peroxide production and stopped oxygen consumption in the same solution. These results suggested that the novel application of profluorescent nitroxide could directly and sensitively detect lipid-derived radicals and that radical and peroxide production were dependent on oxygen concentration.     

Effect of oxygen free radicals on ubiquinone in aqueous solution and phospholipid vesicles

The purpose of this study was to evaluate the direct effect of oxygen free radicals produced by ultrasonic irradiation on ubiquinone and to compare the efficiency with which the antioxidant can compete with these radicals when it is both in aqueous solution and within the lipid bilayer. The main product obtained after insonation of aqueous solutions of ubiquinone-0 was ubiquinol, moreover some degradation occurred. The direct electron donor responsible for most of the ubiquinol generated by ultrasonic irradiation appeared to be superoxide radical. Addition reactions of hydroxyl radicals with aromatic ring structure led probably to degradation products of ubiquinone, which were not identified. Experiments were also performed to evaluate the efficiency with which ubiquinone-3 could react with oxygen radicals when it was within the lipid bilayer. The effect of presence or absence of a net surface charge was studied selecting a suitable bilayer including dimyristylphosphatidic acid or stearylamine in uncharged dimyristylphosphatidylcholine vesicles. In these systems hydroxyl radicals did not represent a potential danger for the antioxidant, the reaction between superoxide and ubiquinone-3 instead was significant only in positively charged membranes and gave rise to ubiquinol. It is suggested that ubiquinone acts as an antioxidant by stopping the propagation reaction.     

Oxygen concentration dependence of lipid peroxidation and lipid-derived radical generation: Application of profluorescent nitroxide switch

Abstract

Lipid-derived radicals and peroxides are involved in the pathogenesis of oxidative stress diseases and, although lipid peroxide production is a required reaction between a lipid radical and molecular oxygen, a useful lipid radical detection method has remained tentative. Also, the effect of oxygen concentration on lipid peroxide production must be considered because of the hypoxic conditions in cancer and ischemic regions. In this study, the focus was on nitroxide reactivity, which allows spin trapping with carbon-centred radicals via radical–radical reactions and fluorophore quenching through interactions with nitroxide's unpaired electron. Thus, the aim here was to demonstrate a useful detection method for lipid-derived radicals as well as to clarify the effects of oxygen concentration on lipid peroxide production using profluorescent nitroxide. This latter compound reacted with lipid-derived radicals in a manner inversely dependent on oxygen concentration, resulting in fluorescence due to alkoxyamine formation and, conversely, lipid peroxide concentrations decreased with lower oxygen in the reaction system. Furthermore, nitroxide inhibited lipid peroxide production and stopped oxygen consumption in the same solution. These results suggested that the novel application of profluorescent nitroxide could directly and sensitively detect lipid-derived radicals and that radical and peroxide production were dependent on oxygen concentration.     

2 pathways of polycyclic hydrocarbon hydroxylation in endoplasmic reticulum membranes

The effect of pro-oxidant (ions of iron) and antioxidants (alpha-tocopherol, propylgallate) on hydroxylation of polycyclic hydrocarbon benz(a)-pyrene and the effect of hydroxylation process on lipid peroxidation have been studied. The role of allyl radicals formed in the fatty acid chains is discussed. The binding of oxygen radicals (formation of peroxy radicals) is regarded only as on of the possible reactions of the radical utilization. It is assumed that other reactions involving lipid (allyl) radicals, in particular, hydroxylation of benz(alpha)pyrene may occur in microsomal membranes.     

Development of fluorescence and cross-links in eye lens crystallin by interaction with lipid peroxy radicals

Senile nuclear cataract formation is associated with the accumulation of fluorescent insoluble proteins. alpha-Crystallin from bovine eye lens was treated with the lipid peroxy radicals generated by interaction of linoleic acid 13-monohydroperoxide or phosphatidylcholine hydroperoxide with methemoglobin. A blue non-tryptophan fluorescence composed of at least two kinds of fluorophores, stable and unstable on borohydride treatment, was produced. One of the stable fluorophores was identified as dityrosine by comparison of its retention times in amino acid analysis and HPLC with those of authentic dityrosine. Dityrosine was formed by the radical reaction, and less than 0.3% of the total tyrosine residues of the protein were transformed into dityrosine. The unstable fluorophores may be produced on the amino groups of alpha-crystallin by the non-radical reaction of the decomposition products of the radicals including monofunctional aldehyde species. Extensive intermolecular cross-links could not be explained only by the dityrosine content, but by the other modifications. Formation of fluorescence and intermolecular cross-links in alpha-crystalline in reaction with the lipid peroxy radicals suggested the participation of lipid peroxidation in the cataractous process.     

Detection of radicals produced by reaction of hydroperoxides with rat liver microsomal fractions.

EPR spin trapping using the spin traps 5,5-dimethyl-1-pyrroline N-oxide (DMPO) and 3,5-dibromo-4-nitrosobenzene sulphonic acid (DBNBS) has been employed to examine the generation of radicals produced on reaction of a number of primary, secondary and lipid hydroperoxides with rat liver microsomal fractions in both the presence and absence of reducing equivalents. Two major mechanisms of radical generation have been elucidated. In the absence of NADPH or NADH, oxidative degradation of the hydroperoxide occurs to give initially a peroxyl radical which in the majority of cases can be detected as a spin adduct to DMPO; these radicals can undergo further reactions which result in the generation of alkoxyl and carbon-centered radicals. In the presence of NADPH (and to a lesser extent NADH) alkoxyl radicals are generated directly via reductive cleavage of the hydroperoxide. These alkoxyl radicals undergo further fragmentation and rearrangement reactions to give carbon-centered species which can be identified by trapping with DBNBS. The type of transformation that occurs is highly dependent on the structure of the alkoxyl radical with species arising from beta-scission, 1,2-hydrogen shifts and ring closure reactions being identified; these processes are in accord with previous chemical studies and are characteristic of alkoxyl radicals present in free solution. Studies using specific enzyme inhibitors and metal-ion chelators suggest that most of the radical generation occurs via a catalytic process involving haem proteins and in particular cytochrome P-450. An unusual species (an acyl radical) is observed with lipid hydroperoxides; this is believed to arise via a cage reaction after beta-scission of an initial alkoxyl radical.     

Free radicals in primary photobiological processes.

Formation of a semiquinone free radical derived from chlorophyll in the reaction of photoreduction has been discovered by A. A. Krasnovsky, Sr. in 1953. This review consider the results obtained in the author's laboratory, concerning the participation of free radicals in photochemical reactions under UV-irradiation of aromatic amino acids, proteins, and lipids, as well as in the reactions of chemiluminescence (CL) in the protein and chlorophyll-containing systems. Free radicals are the very first products of photochemical reactions in all systems studied. The back reactions of radicals are accompanied with photon emission. From the point of view of the molecular energetics, the radiativeless electronic transition in molecules is the most probable event, the transition triplet level is less probable, and the transition to the singlet excited level is virtually impossible. This may explain the low quantum yield of CL, similarity of CL and phosphorescence (rather than fluorescence) spectrum of the reaction products, low quantum yield of CL, and its high temperature coefficient.     

Identification of ubiquinone as the secondary electron acceptor in the photosynthetic apparatus of Chromatium vinosum

Extracting Chromatium vinosum chromatophores with light petroleum destroys their ability to perform photochemistry on the second of two closely-spaced actinic flashes, without affecting photochemistry on the first flash. Extraction also increases the likelihood of a back-reaction in which an electron returns from the primary electron acceptor directly to P₈₇₀. These effects probably reflect the removal of a secondary electron acceptor. Extraction does not appear to interfere with the primary photochemical reaction. Reconstituting the extracted chromatophores with the lipid extract or with pure ubiquinone (Q) completely reverses the effects of the extraction. Chromatography of the lipid extract shows that Q is the only active material that it contains in detectable quantity. These observations support the conclusion that Q is the secondary electron acceptor.

Piericidin A, certain alkyl-substituted quinolinequinones, and a substituted 4,7-dioxobenzothiazole inhibit electron transfer between the primary and secondary acceptors. The sensitivity to these inhibitors, and the participation of Q and non-heme iron suggest that the secondary electron-transfer reaction resembles the reactions catalyzed by respiratory dehydrogenases.

The proton uptake that follows flash excitation does not seem to be tightly linked to the reduction of the secondary electron acceptor. It still occurs (though with decreased amplitude) in extracted chromatophores, and even in the presence of inhibitors of the secondary electron-transfer reaction.     

Oxidative Processes Induced by <Emphasis Type="Italic">tert</Emphasis>-Butyl Hydroperoxide in Human Red Blood Cells: Chemiluminescence Studies

The erythrocyte is a good model for investigation of the mechanisms of cell damage induced by oxidizing agents. Oxidative damage to cell components and cellular metabolism results in impaired rheological properties of circulating red blood cells and is involved in the development of some pathologies. The aim of the present study was to elucidate further the oxidative processes induced by tert-butyl hydroperoxide (tBOOH) in erythrocytes, identify cellular targets damaged by the oxidant, as well as estimate the energy and stoichiometry of the reactions that occur. The generation of free radicals in the cell was registered using the chemiluminescence technique. The products of oxyhemoglobin (oxyHb) oxidation, changes in intracellular glutathione (GSH) pool, and accumulation of the stable products of membrane lipid peroxidation were concurrently measured. The oxidative processes induced by tBOOH in red blood cells can be described as follows: 1) rapid GSH oxidation (30-60 sec) by glutathione peroxidase; 2) formation of radicals in the reaction between tBOOH and cellular Hb, which are then immediately consumed in lipid peroxidation reactions; 3) generation of chemiluminescence by the radicals formed. Several stages of the oxidative processes can be revealed. The order of the chemiluminescence reaction (n) with respect to oxidant was estimated to be equal to 2.5 at oxidant concentrations less than 0.5 mM and equal to 1.0 at higher oxidant concentrations. The order of the reaction of membrane lipid peroxidation was found to be n = 2.2 at 0.25-0.6 mM tBOOH and n = 0.5 at higher oxidant concentrations. The apparent activation energy of membrane lipid peroxidation was 55.8 +/- 6.4 kJ/mol, and that of oxyHb oxidation was 108 +/- 16 kJ/mol. It is shown that the interaction of tBOOH and HOCl in erythrocytes is accompanied by changes in both the total number of radicals generated in the cell and the time corresponding to the maximal rate of radical generation.     

Phenolic chain-breaking antioxidants--their activity and mechanisms of action

This tutorial review is focused on some mechanistic aspects of peroxidation process and chemistry of phenolic chain-breaking antioxidants. Lipids are susceptible to oxidative degradation caused by radicals and during autoxidation (peroxidation) the chain reaction is mediated by peroxyl radicals leading to damage of integrity and the protective and organizational properties of biomembranes. Phenolic antioxidants provide active system of defence against lipid peroxidation, however, the effectiveness of their antioxidant action depends on several important parameters. Stoichiometry of the reaction with free radicals, fate of a phenoxyl radical, polarity of the microenvironment, localization of antioxidant molecules, their concentration and mobility, kinetic solvent effects, and interactions with other co-antioxidants are considered. Principal mechanisms of reaction between phenols and free radicals (Hydrogen Atom Transfer, Proton Coupled Electron Transfer and two mechanisms based on separate electron transfer and proton transfer steps) are described.     

Decrease in 2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-piperidine-1-oxyl (TEMPO) EPR signal in ozone-treated erythrocyte membranes

In ozone-treated erythrocyte membrane suspension a slow decrease occurs in the EPR signal of 2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-piperidine-1-oxyl (TEMPO). Because of the absence of such a phenomenon in control membranes and ozonized buffer, this effect must be caused by reaction of nitroxide radicals with products of ozone reactions with membrane components. To find out which components are responsible for the decrease in EPR signal we studied this effect in simple model systems. The same phenomenon was observed both in lipid and protein systems treated by ozone. For unsaturated fatty acids, the correlation between the rate of decrease in EPR signal and the number of double bonds in the lipid molecule was very strong. This suggests that the observed decrease in the nitroxide radical TEMPO EPR signal in ozone-treated erythrocyte membranes is a complex process, but probably the most important reaction is recombination of nitroxide radicals with organic free radicals produced both in the process of lipid peroxidation and ozonolysis of double bonds.     

Solvent Effects in the Spin Trapping Of Lipid Oxyl Radicals

Studies documenting spin trapping of lipid radicals in defined model systems have shown some surprising solvent effects with the spin trap DMPO. In aqueous reactions comparing the reduction of H₂O₂ and methyl linoleate hydroperoxide (MLOOH) by Fe^z+, hydroxyl (HO·) and lipid alkoxyl (LO·) radicals produce identical four-line spectra with line intensities 1:2:2:1. Both types of radicals react with commonly-used HO· scavengers, e.g. with ethanol to produce ·C(CH₃)HOH and with dirnethylsulfoxide (DMSO)togive ·CH₃. However, DMSO radicals (either ·CH₃or ·OOCH₃) react further with lipids, and when radicals are trapped in these MLOOH systems, multiple adducts are evident. When acetonitrile is added to the aqueous reaction systems in increasing concentrations, ·CH₂CN radicals resulting from HO· attack on acetonitrile are evident, even with trace quantities of that solvent. In contrast, little, if any, reaction of LO· with acetonitrile occurs, even in 100% acetonitrile. A single four-line signal persists in the lipid systems as long as any water is present, although the relative intensity of the two center lines decreases as solvent-induced changes gradually dissociate the nitrogen and β-hydrogen splitting constants. Extraction of the aqueous-phase adducts into ethyl acetate shows clearly that the identical four-line spectra in the H₂0₂ and MLOOH systems arise from different radical species in this study, but the lack of stability of the adducts to phase transfer may limit the use of this technique for routine adduct identification in more complex systems. These results indicate that the four-line 1:2:2:1. a_N = a_H = 14.9G spectrum from DMPO cannot automatically be assigned to the HO· adduct in reaction systems where lipid is present, even when the expected spin adducts from ethanol or DMSO appear confirmatory for HO-. Conclusive distinction between HO· and LO· ultimately will require use of ¹³C-labelled DMPO or HPLC-MS separation and specific identification of adducts when DMPO is used as the spin trap.     

Arguments against the significance of the Fenton reaction contributing to signal pathways under in vivo conditions

One of the common explanations for oxidative stress in the physiological milieu is based on the Fenton reaction, i.e. the assumption that radical chain reactions are initiated by metal-catalyzed electron transfer to hydrogen peroxide yielding hydroxyl radicals. On the other hand — especially in the context of so-called “iron switches” — it is postulated that cellular signaling pathways originate from the interaction of reduced iron with hydrogen peroxide.

Using fluorescence detection and EPR for identification of radical intermediates, we determined the rate of iron complexation by physiological buffer together with the reaction rate of concomitant hydroxylations of aromatic compounds under aerobic and anaerobic conditions. With the obtained overall reaction rate of 1,700 M^-1s^-1 for the buffer-dependent reactions and the known rates for Fenton reactions, we derive estimates for the relative reaction probabilities of both processes.

As a consequence we suggest that under in vivo conditions initiation of chain reactions by hydroxyl radicals generated by the Fenton reaction is of minor importance and hence metal-dependent oxidative stress must be rather independent of the so-called “peroxide tone”. Furthermore, it is proposed that — in the low (subtoxic) concentration range — hydroxylated compounds derived from reactions of “non-free” (crypto) OH radicals are better candidates for iron-dependent sensing of redox-states and for explaining the origin of cellular signals than the generation of “free” hydroxyl radicals.     

Decrease in 2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-piperidine-1-oxyl (TEMPO) EPR signal in ozone-treated erythrocyte membranes

In ozone-treated erythrocyte membrane suspension a slow decrease occurs in the EPR signal of 2,2,6,6-tetramethyl-piperidine-1-oxyl (TEMPO). Because of the absence of such a phenomenon in control membranes and ozonized buffer, this effect must be caused by reaction of nitroxide radicals with products of ozone reactions with membrane components. To find out which components are responsible for the decrease in EPR signal we studied this effect in simple model systems. The same phenomenon was observed both in lipid and protein systems treated by ozone. For unsaturated fatty acids, the correlation between the rate of decrease in EPR signal and the number of double bonds in the lipid molecule was very strong. This suggests that the observed decrease in the nitroxide radical TEMPO EPR signal in ozone-treated erythrocyte membranes is a complex process, but probably the most important reaction is recombination of nitroxide radicals with organic free radicals produced both in the process of lipid peroxidation and ozonolysis of double bonds.     

Arguments against the significance of the Fenton reaction contributing to signal pathways under in vivo conditions

One of the common explanations for oxidative stress in the physiological milieu is based on the Fenton reaction, i.e. the assumption that radical chain reactions are initiated by metal-catalyzed electron transfer to hydrogen peroxide yielding hydroxyl radicals. On the other hand — especially in the context of so-called “iron switches” — it is postulated that cellular signaling pathways originate from the interaction of reduced iron with hydrogen peroxide.

Using fluorescence detection and EPR for identification of radical intermediates, we determined the rate of iron complexation by physiological buffer together with the reaction rate of concomitant hydroxylations of aromatic compounds under aerobic and anaerobic conditions. With the obtained overall reaction rate of 1,700 M^-1s^-1 for the buffer-dependent reactions and the known rates for Fenton reactions, we derive estimates for the relative reaction probabilities of both processes.

As a consequence we suggest that under in vivo conditions initiation of chain reactions by hydroxyl radicals generated by the Fenton reaction is of minor importance and hence metal-dependent oxidative stress must be rather independent of the so-called “peroxide tone”. Furthermore, it is proposed that — in the low (subtoxic) concentration range — hydroxylated compounds derived from reactions of “non-free” (crypto) OH radicals are better candidates for iron-dependent sensing of redox-states and for explaining the origin of cellular signals than the generation of “free” hydroxyl radicals.