Dissecting Antibodies with Regards to Linear and Conformational Epitopes

An important issue for the performance and specificity of an antibody is the nature of the binding to its protein target, including if the recognition involves linear or conformational epitopes. Here, we dissect polyclonal sera by creating epitope-specific antibody fractions using a combination of epitope mapping and an affinity capture approach involving both synthesized peptides and recombinant protein fragments. This allowed us to study the relative amounts of antibodies to linear and conformational epitopes in the polyclonal sera as well as the ability of each antibody-fraction to detect its target protein in Western blot assays. The majority of the analyzed polyclonal sera were found to have most of the target-specific antibodies directed towards linear epitopes and these were in many cases giving Western blot bands of correct molecular weight. In contrast, many of the antibodies towards conformational epitopes did not bind their target proteins in the Western blot assays. The results from this work have given us insights regarding the nature of the antibody response generated by immunization with recombinant protein fragments and has demonstrated the advantage of using antibodies recognizing linear epitopes for immunoassay involving wholly or partially denatured protein targets.     

Theory of equilibrium binding of a bivalent ligand to cell surface antibody: The effect of antibody heterogeneity on cross-linking

We investigate the equilibrium binding of symmetric bivalent ligands to a heterogeneous population of symmetric bivalent cell surface receptors. The receptors are heterogeneous in their binding affinities (equilibrium binding constants) for the ligand. For any distribution of receptor binding affinities we show how to calculate the total concentration of receptors that are cross-linked by the ligand, i.e., the concentration of cell surface aggregates composed of two or more receptors, as well as the concentration of any given aggregate. We show that certain qualitative properties of cross-linking which hold for homogeneous antibody populations fail to hold in the heterogeneous case. We use our results to interpret certain in vitro experiments in which synthetic bivalent haptens are used to trigger histamine release from basophils which have on their surface antibody specific for the hapten.This work was performed under the auspices of the Department of Energy and supported by Grant AI 16465 from the National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases.     

Antibody colocalization microarray: a scalable technology for multiplex protein analysis in complex samples

DNA microarrays were rapidly scaled up from 256 to 6.5 million targets, and although antibody microarrays were proposed earlier, sensitive multiplex sandwich assays have only been scaled up to a few tens of targets. Cross-reactivity, arising because detection antibodies are mixed, is a known weakness of multiplex sandwich assays that is mitigated by lengthy optimization. Here, we introduce (1) vulnerability as a metric for assays. The vulnerability of multiplex sandwich assays to cross-reactivity increases quadratically with the number of targets, and together with experimental results, substantiates that scaling up of multiplex sandwich assays is unfeasible. We propose (2) a novel concept for multiplexing without mixing named antibody colocalization microarray (ACM). In ACMs, both capture and detection antibodies are physically colocalized by spotting to the same two-dimensional coordinate. Following spotting of the capture antibodies, the chip is removed from the arrayer, incubated with the sample, placed back onto the arrayer and then spotted with the detection antibodies. ACMs with up to 50 targets were produced, along with a binding curve for each protein. The ACM was validated by comparing it to ELISA and to a small-scale, conventional multiplex sandwich assay (MSA). Using ACMs, proteins in the serum of breast cancer patients and healthy controls were quantified, and six candidate biomarkers identified. Our results indicate that ACMs are sensitive, robust, and scalable.     

Quantifying the effects of molecular orientation and length on two-dimensional receptor-ligand binding kinetics

Surface presentation of adhesion receptors influences cell adhesion, although the mechanisms underlying these effects are not well understood. We used a micropipette adhesion frequency assay to quantify how the molecular orientation and length of adhesion receptors on the cell membrane affected two-dimensional kinetic rates of interactions with surface ligands. Interactions of P-selectin, E-selectin, and CD16A with their respective ligands or antibody were used to demonstrate such effects. Randomizing the orientation of the adhesion receptor or lowering its ligand- and antibody-binding domain above the cell membrane lowered two-dimensional affinities of the molecular interactions by reducing the forward rates but not the reverse rates. In contrast, the soluble antibody bound with similar three-dimensional affinities to cell-bound P-selectin constructs regardless of their orientation and length. These results demonstrate that the orientation and length of an adhesion receptor influences its rate of encountering and binding a surface ligand but does not subsequently affect the stability of binding.     

A high-throughput hybridoma selection method using fluorometric microvolume assay technology

Monoclonal antibodies (mAb) are not only useful reagents but also represent a promising type of therapeutics due to their high affinity and exquisite specificity for their antigens. A critical step in mAb generation is to identify antigen-specific antibodies. Although enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) has been broadly applied for antibody selection against secreted antigens, an inherent disadvantage for ELISA is the difficulty in identifying antibodies that recognize the native conformation of cell surface antigens. To overcome this drawback, the authors have developed a high-throughput cell-based antibody binding assay using fluorometric microvolume assay technology (FMAT). This method offers a homogeneous assay for detection of antibody binding to its antigen on the cell surface. To distinguish antibodies that bind to antigen on the cell surface from those that bind nonspecifically to cells, the binding is assessed using both antigen-expressing cells and related cells devoid of the antigen expression. This assay can detect antibodies at a concentration as low as 5 ng/mL and cell surface antigen as low as 9000 copies per cell. Results demonstrate that the FMAT method provides a sensitive and homogeneous assay to detect antibody binding to cell surface antigens and is amenable for high-throughput hybridoma selection.     

Optimizing antibody immobilization strategies for the construction of protein microarrays

Antibody microarrays have the potential to revolutionize protein expression profiling. The intensity of specific signal produced on a feature of such an array is related to the amount of analyte that is captured from the biological mixture by the immobilized antibody (the "capture agent"). This in turn is a function of the surface density and fractional activity of the capture agents. Here we investigate how these two factors are affected by the orientation of the capture agents on the surface. We compare randomly versus specifically oriented capture agents based on both full-sized antibodies and Fab' fragments. Each comparison was performed using three different antibodies and two types of streptavidin-coated monolayer surfaces. The specific orientation of capture agents consistently increases the analyte-binding capacity of the surfaces, with up to 10-fold improvements over surfaces with randomly oriented capture agents. Surface plasmon resonance revealed a dense monolayer of Fab' fragments that are on average 90% active when specifically oriented. Randomly attached Fab's could not be packed at such a high density and generally also had a lower specific activity. These results emphasize the importance of attaching proteins to surfaces such that their binding sites are oriented toward the solution phase.     

Reducing heterophilic antibody interference in immunoassays using single-chain antibodies

Sandwich enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) microarrays can simultaneously quantify the levels of multiple diagnostic targets in a biological sample. However, as with traditional ELISA diagnostics, endogenous antibodies in patient sera can cause interference. We demonstrate here that reducing the diagnostic capture antibody to its minimal functional unit (i.e., a single-chain antibody fragment [scFv]) is an effective strategy for reducing assay interference. Our finding illustrates a source of error introduced by the reliance on immunoglobulin-based capture reagents in sandwich immunoassays with human serum samples. We demonstrate that scFvs can be used in such assays to improve reliability by reducing heterophilic antibody interference, thereby improving biomarker analysis and validation.     

Protein microarrays for antibody profiling: specificity and affinity determination on a chip

Protein microarray technology facilitates the detection and quantification of hundreds of binding reactions in one reaction from a minute amount of sample. Proof-of-concept studies have shown that the set-up of sensitive assay systems based on protein arrays is possible, however, the lack of specific capture reagents limits their use. Therefore, the generation and characterisation of capture molecules is one of the key topics for the development of protein array based systems. Recombinant antibody technologies, such as HuCAL (human combinatorial antibody library; MorphoSys, Munich, Germany), allow the fast generation of highly specific binders to nearly any given target molecule. Although antibody libraries comprise billions of members, it is not the selection process, but the detailed characterisation of the pre-selected monoclonal antibodies that presents the bottleneck for the production of high numbers of specific binders. In order to obtain detailed information on the properties of such antibodies, a microarray-based method has been developed. We show that it is possible to define the specificity of recombinant Fab fragments by protein and peptide microarrays and that antibodies can be classified by binding patterns. Since the assay uses a miniaturised system for the detection of antibody-antigen interactions, the observed binding occurs under ambient analyte conditions as defined by Ekins (J. Pharm. Biomed. Anal. 1989, 7, 155-168). This allows the determination of a relative affinity value for each binding event, and a ranking according to affinity is possible. The new microarray based approach has an extraordinary potential to speed up the screening process for the generation of recombinant antibodies with pre-defined selection criteria, since it is intrinsically a high-throughput technology.     

Anti-idiotype antibodies to the 9.1C3 blocking antibody used to probe the lethal hit stage of NK cell-mediated cytolysis

We previously described a monoclonal antibody, 9.1C3, which blocked natural killer (NK) cell-mediated cytolysis by acting on effector cells during a late step in the lethal hit stage. The present work describes the production in rabbits of anti-idiotypic (anti-id) antibodies to the 9.1C3 antibody. In addition to reacting specifically with the 9.1C3 antibody, the anti-id antibodies bound strongly to the K562 target cell. The anti-id antibodies blocked killing of K562 targets by NK, antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity, and NK-like cells but did not inhibit killing by cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL). Pretreatment of cells and washing before assay indicated that blocking occurred at the target cell level. Of particular interest, single cell assays with Percoll-enriched large granular lymphocytes demonstrated that the antibodies caused no reduction in binding. These data are consistent with a model for NK cell-mediated lysis that involves a secondary target cell receptor independent of the primary NK-target cell interaction. The anti-id antibodies immunoprecipitated cell surface proteins of relative m.w. 79K and 62K unreduced, and 94K and 79K reduced from K562 target cells. The development of anti-id antibodies may be a useful procedure to explore the structure and function of cellular receptors involved in NK cell-mediated cytolysis.     

Light chain of natural antibody plays a dominant role in protein antigen binding

Examinations of the contribution and the specificity of heavy (H) and light (L) chains of natural antibodies to antigen binding may help us to better understand antigen recognition and the development of naive B cells. We previously generated natural Fab antibody fragments reactive to preS1 of HBV using a naive, non-immunized Fab antibody library derived from peripheral B cells of a normal healthy volunteer. We now constructed expression vectors for the Fd (VH + CH1), L chain, and scFv fragments using the sequences encoding parental Fabs as a source of natural antibody genes. The recombinant antibody fragments were expressed as inclusion bodies in E. coli BL21 (DE) cells. When denatured and then refolded, the antibody fragments retained their binding properties. Recombinant L chains and scFvs exhibited three- to 40-fold higher affinities (in the order of 10(7) M(-1)) over the parental Fabs, whereas the affinities of Fds (in the order of 10(5) M(-1)) were much lower compared to the parental Fabs. The results obtained from sandwich ELISA revealed that the L chains bound the virus more efficiently than Fds. Additional experiments were performed to evaluate the specificity of the recombinant fragments for surface proteins of HBV. Fds and L chains were reactive towards HBsAg and the preS2 peptide as well as preS1 and showed patterns of epitope recognition quite different from those of parental Fabs. The data presented here demonstrate that the prominence of the L chain in determining protein binding activity is a property of natural antibodies and is quite unlike the antibodies induced by immunization, and that the specificity of Fab is not determined by the individual antibody chain but by the correct pairing of H and L chain.     

Selection and characterization of cell binding and internalizing phage antibodies

Many therapeutic targets are cell surface receptors, which can be challenging antigens for antibody generation. For many therapeutic applications, one needs antibodies that not only bind the cell surface receptor but also are internalized into the cell. This allows use of the antibody to deliver various payloads into the cell to achieve a therapeutic effect. Phage antibody technology has proven a powerful tool for the generation and optimization of human antibodies to any antigen. While applied to the generation of antibodies to purified proteins, it is possible to directly select cell binding and internalizing antibodies on cells. Potential advantages of this approach include: cell surface receptors are in native conformation on intact cells while this might not be so for recombinant proteins; antibodies can be selected for both cell binding and internalization properties; the antibodies can be used to identify their tumor associated antigens; and such antibodies can be used for human treatment directly since they are human in sequence. This review will discuss the factors that impact the successful selection of cell binding and internalizing antibodies. These factors include the cell types used for selection, the impact of different phage antibody library formats, and the specific selection protocols used.     

Bi-Epitope SPR Surfaces: A Solution to Develop Robust Immunoassays

Surface plasmon resonance (SPR)-based immunoassays have numerous applications and require high affinity reagents for sensitive and reliable measurements. We describe a quick approach to turn low affinity antibodies into appropriate capture reagents. We used antibodies recognizing human ephrin type A receptor 2 (EphA2) and a ProteOn XPR36 as a model system. We generated so-called ‘bi-epitope’ sensor surfaces by immobilizing various pairs of anti-EphA2 antibodies using standard amine coupling. The apparent binding affinities to EphA2 and EphA2 detection sensitivities of the bi-epitope and ‘single-epitope’ surfaces were then compared. For all antibody pairs tested, bi-epitope surfaces exhibited an ∼10–100-fold improvement in apparent binding affinities when compared with single-epitope ones. When pairing 2 antibodies of low intrinsic binding affinities (∼10⁻⁸ M) and fast dissociation rates (∼10⁻² s⁻¹), the apparent binding affinity and dissociation rate of the bi-epitope surface was improved up to ∼10^–10 M and 10⁻⁴ s⁻¹, respectively. This led to an ∼100–200-fold enhancement in EphA2 limit of detection in crude cell supernatants. Our results show that the use of antibody mixtures in SPR applications constitutes a powerful approach to develop sensitive immunoassays, as previously shown for non-SPR formats. As SPR-based assays have significantly expanded their reach in the last decade, such an approach promises to further accelerate their development.     

A Rapid Method to Characterize Mouse IgG Antibodies and Isolate Native Antigen Binding IgG B Cell Hybridomas

B cell hybridomas are an important source of monoclonal antibodies. In this paper, we developed a high-throughput method to characterize mouse IgG antibodies using surface plasmon resonance technology. This assay rapidly determines their sub-isotypes, whether they bind native antigen and their approximate affinities for the antigen using only 50 μl of hybridoma cell culture supernatant. Moreover, we found that mouse hybridomas secreting IgG antibodies also have membrane form IgG expression without Igα. Based on this surface IgG, we used flow cytometry to isolate rare γ2a isotype switched variants from a γ2b antibody secreting hybridoma cell line. Also, we used fluorescent antigen to single cell sort antigen binding hybridoma cells from bulk mixture of fused hybridoma cells instead of the traditional multi-microwell plate screening and limiting dilution sub-cloning thus saving time and labor. The IgG monoclonal antibodies specific for the native antigen identified with these methods are suitable for in vivo therapeutic uses, but also for sandwich ELISA assays, histology, flow cytometry, immune precipitation and x-ray crystallography.     

Human alveolar macrophage FcR-mediated cytotoxicity. Heteroantibody- versus conventional antibody-mediated target cell lysis

Human alveolar macrophage have three distinct receptors for IgG: FcRI, FcRII, and FcRIII. In order to compare the ability of these receptors to mediate target cell lysis, three different assay systems were examined. First, we studied lysis of chicken E (CE) opsonized with heteroantibodies, which are synthetic antibodies composed of Fab fragments with anti-FcR activity covalently linked to Fab fragments with anti-CE activity. We found alveolar macrophage readily lysed heteroantibody-opsonized CE via each of the three FcR classes (FcRI, 20 +/- 5%; FcRII, 27 +/- 7%; and FcRIII, 13 +/- 13%, p less than 0.05). Non-FcR-dependent lysis of anti-beta 2-microglobulin x anti-CE heteroantibody-opsonized CE was not detected. Second, lysis of hybridoma cell lines bearing anti-FcR antibodies on their cell surface was examined to assess killing of "tumor-like" target cells. Whereas peripheral blood monocytes and lymphocytes were able to lyse hybridoma cell lines bearing surface anti-FcR mAb, alveolar macrophages were not. Third, activity of alveolar macrophage FcR was examined in a conventional antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity assay by using O+ (R1,R2) human RBC opsonized with human anti-D and anti-CD serum as target cells. We found lysis of anti-D and anti-CD opsonized human RBC was mediated exclusively via FcRI. No activity of FcRII or FcRIII was detected in these latter assays even if performed under conditions that impair FcRI activity. Thus, all three FcR present on alveolar macrophage mediate lysis of heteroantibody-opsonized CE; in contrast, with the use of a conventional antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity assay, only FcRI activity was detected. We were unable to demonstrate lysis of anti-FcR-bearing hybridoma cell lines by alveolar macrophages.     

Development of a novel mammalian cell surface antibody display platform

Antibody display systems have been successfully applied to screen, select and characterize antibody fragments. These systems typically use prokaryotic organisms such as phage and bacteria or lower eukaryotic organisms, such as yeast. These organisms possess either no or different post-translational modification functions from mammalian cells and prefer to display small antibody fragments instead of full-length IgGs. We report here a novel mammalian cell-based antibody display platform that displays full-length functional antibodies on the surface of mammalian cells. Through recombinase-mediated DNA integration, each host cell contains one copy of the gene of interest in the genome. Utilizing a hot-spot integration site, the expression levels of the gene of interest are high and comparable between clones, ensuring a high signal to noise ratio. Coupled with fluorescence-activated cell sorting (FACS) technology, our platform is high throughput and can distinguish antibodies with very high antigen binding affinities directly on the cell surface. Single-round FACS can enrich high affinity antibodies by more than 500 fold. Antibodies with significantly improved neutralizing activity have been identified from a randomly mutagenized library, demonstrating the power of this platform in screening and selecting antibody therapeutics.     

A quantitative LC-MS/MS method for comparative analysis of capture-antibody affinity toward protein antigens

A mass spectrometry-based antibody selection procedure was developed to evaluate optimal 'capture' monoclonal antibodies that can be used in a variety of analytical measurement applications. The isotope-dilution liquid chromatography-tandem mass spectrometry (ID LC-MS/MS) methodology is based on the use of multiple-reaction monitoring of tryptic peptide fragments derived from protein antigens. A panel of monoclonal antibodies (mAb) was evaluated based on a quantitative determination of relative binding affinity to human cardiac troponin I following immunoprecipitation. Dissociation constants (K(d)) were determined for 'bound mAb-antigen' vs. 'unbound antigen' using non-linear regression analysis. Relative quantification of both antigen and antibody was based on the use of stable isotope-labeled synthetic peptides as internal standards. Optimal 'capture' mAbs were determined through evaluation of relative K(d) constants of all monitored peptide transitions. A panel of six pre-screened candidate capture mAbs was concluded to consist of two subsets of mAbs, each with statistically equivalent K(d) constants as determined using NIST Standard Reference Material (SRM) 2921 - Human Cardiac Troponin Complex. This ID LC-MS/MS method is shown to be capable of quantitatively differentiating mAbs based on relative binding affinities. Selection of optimal capture mAbs can be applied toward a number of analytical applications which require metrological traceability and unbiased quantification.     

Designing Cell-Targeted Therapeutic Proteins Reveals the Interplay between Domain Connectivity and Cell Binding

The therapeutic efficacy of cytokines is often hampered by severe side effects due to their undesired binding to healthy cells. One strategy for overcoming this obstacle is to tether cytokines to antibodies or antibody fragments for targeted cell delivery. However, how to modulate the geometric configuration and relative binding affinity of the two domains for optimal activity remains an outstanding question. As a result, many antibody-cytokine complexes do not achieve the desired level of cell-targeted binding and activity. Here, we address these design issues by developing a computational model to simulate the dynamics and binding kinetics of natural and engineered fusion proteins such as antibody-cytokine complexes. To verify the model, we developed a modular system in which an antibody fragment and a cytokine are conjugated via a DNA linker that allows for programmable linker geometry and protein spatial configuration. By assembling and testing several anti-CD20 antibody fragment-interferon α complexes, we showed that varying the linker length and cytokine binding affinity controlled the magnitude of cell-targeted signaling activation in a manner that agreed with the model predictions, which were expressed as dose-signaling response curves. The simulation results also revealed that there is a range of cytokine binding affinities that would achieve optimal therapeutic efficacy. This rapid prototyping platform will facilitate the rational design of antibody-cytokine complexes for improved therapeutic outcomes.     

Alteration in H chain V region affects complement activation by chimeric antibodies

Chimeric antibodies to the synthetic polypeptide (Tyr, Glu)-Ala-Lys ((T,G)-A-L) were used to examine C activation by human IgG1. Two IgG1 antibodies, which contained mouse L chains and H chains with mouse V domains and human C domains, differed only in their VH domain. Ag binding and C activation by these antibodies were analyzed by ELISA. When limiting amounts of Ag were used in the assays, the antibodies required different quantities of Ag for optimal binding, suggesting that the antibodies bind to different epitopes on the (T,G)-A-L molecule. However, when competitive inhibition assays were performed with an optimal concentration of Ag, there were no differences in relative binding affinities for (T,G)-A-L or dissociation characteristics of the antibodies. C activation was examined at optimal Ag concentration to ensure equivalent binding of two IgG1 antibodies to Ag. After combination with immobilized Ag, these two antibodies bearing different V regions exhibited marked differences in the binding of C components C1q and C3d. When present in equal amounts in the assay, antibody 10B activated C and bound more C1q and C3d than antibody B11. These results indicate that V region differences can affect C activation by IgG.     

Modeling bispecific monoclonal antibody interaction with two cell membrane targets indicates the importance of surface diffusion

We have developed a mathematical framework for describing a bispecific monoclonal antibody interaction with two independent membrane-bound targets that are expressed on the same cell surface. The bispecific antibody in solution binds either of the two targets first, and then cross-links with the second one while on the cell surface, subject to rate-limiting lateral diffusion step within the lifetime of the monovalently engaged antibody-antigen complex. At experimental densities, only a small fraction of the free targets is expected to lie within the reach of the antibody binding sites at any time. Using ordinary differential equation and Monte Carlo simulation-based models, we validated this approach against an independently published anti-CD4/CD70 DuetMab experimental data set. As a result of dimensional reduction, the cell surface reaction is expected to be so rapid that, in agreement with the experimental data, no monovalently bound bispecific antibody binary complexes accumulate until cross-linking is complete. The dissociation of the bispecific antibody from the ternary cross-linked complex is expected to be significantly slower than that from either of the monovalently bound variants. We estimate that the effective affinity of the bivalently bound bispecific antibody is enhanced for about 4 orders of magnitude over that of the monovalently bound species. This avidity enhancement allows for the highly specific binding of anti-CD4/CD70 DuetMab to the cells that are positive for both target antigens over those that express only one or the other We suggest that the lateral diffusion of target antigens in the cell membrane also plays a key role in the avidity effect of natural antibodies and other bivalent ligands in their interactions with their respective cell surface receptors.