Effect of leaf litter and density on fitness and population performance of the hole mosquito Aedes triseriatus

Abstract.

• 1 We tested the effects of food, in the form of leaf litter, and density on population growth and fitness correlates of the tree hole mosquito Aedes triseriatus. Our field experiment used a 2 x 2 randomized block design, with three holes as blocks. In cages within three holes, we manipulated densities of Aedes triseriatus larvae, and presence of leaf litter. Our laboratory experiment used a 2 x 3 factorial design in which we also manipulated densities of larvae and availability of leaf litter within similar cages (inside, outside, or absent). For both experiments we determined effects on survival, days to and mass at eclosion of both sexes, and a composite index of population performance λ′, that estimates finite rate of increase.
• 2 In the field experiment, we found significant and large effects of leaf litter and of density on the performance of A. triseriatus. The effect of density did not depend on leaf litter availability. We documented significant variation among tree holes for most correlates of fitness. Often, the effects of treatments varied significantly depending on the tree hole tested.
• 3 In the laboratory experiment we found significant effects of density and litter, and that direct browsing on leaf litter is necessary for the effect of litter on performance of A. triseriatus. In the laboratory, the negative effect of increased density was dependent on leaf litter availability.
• 4 Our results demonstrate that leaf litter has important effects on population performance of tree hole mosquitoes in natural tree holes. Direct browsing on the surface of leaf litter is the most likely mechanism by which litter enhances population growth. The impact of litter on populations varies among tree holes.

     

Reversible non‐genetic phenotypic heterogeneity in bacterial quorum sensing

Bacteria co‐ordinate their social behaviour in a density‐dependent manner by production of diffusible signal molecules by a process known as quorum sensing (QS). It is generally assumed that in homogenous environments and at high cell density, QS synchronizes cells in the population to perform collective social tasks in unison which maximize the benefit at the inclusive fitness of individuals. However, evolutionary theory predicts that maintaining phenotypic heterogeneity in performing social tasks is advantageous as it can serve as a bet‐hedging survival strategy. Using Pseudomonas syringae and Xanthomonas campestris as model organisms, which use two diverse classes of QS signals, we show that two distinct subpopulations of QS‐responsive and non‐responsive cells exist in the QS‐activated population. Addition of excess exogenous QS signal does not significantly alter the distribution of QS‐responsive and non‐responsive cells in the population. We further show that progeny of cells derived from these subpopulations also exhibited heterogeneous distribution patterns similar to their respective parental strains. Overall, these results support the model that bacteria maintain QS‐responsive and non‐responsive subpopulations at high cell densities in a bet‐hedging strategy to simultaneously perform functions that are both positively and negatively regulated by QS to improve their fitness in fluctuating environments.     

Measuring performance in nature: implications for studies of fitness within populations

Significant relationships among morphology, behavior, performanceand fitness have long served as bona fide evidence for the roleof selection in shaping natural populations. Here, I discusshow studies of ecological performance, or how organisms performin nature, provide an ecological context for such selectionstudies. Laboratory studies assume that the level of performanceexpressed under "optimal" conditions accurately reflects thelevel of performance used in nature, but I show here that thisassumption is not always borne out. A review of how variousfactors affect ecological performance (ontogeny, microhabitat,and macrohabitat) show that animals often express very differentlevels of movement speed both among different tasks, and whencomparing laboratory versus field performance. Thus, a failureto take this variation into account could lead to negative,or even misleading significant fitness-character correlations.While laboratory performance studies should continue to playa key role in studies of selection, recent technological (i.e.,portable high-speed cameras) and methodological developmentsshould enable researchers to measure performance in nature tohigh degrees of accuracy. Thus, I encourage researchers to measureperformance both in the laboratory and in the field, and thusexpand the traditional paradigm of morphology     

高山松种实性状与生殖适应性

高山松(Pinus densata)是云南松(P. yunnanensis)与油松(P. tabulaeformis)自然杂交产生的二倍体杂种,是植物同倍体杂交物种形成的典型案例。高山松分布于青藏高原东南缘,占据了两个亲本种都不能正常生长的高海拔地带。良好生殖适应性的产生是物种形成的关键,但对高山松在高海拔生境下生殖适应性的变异与杂交起源遗传背景关系的研究尚未见报道。该研究通过对来自该种分布区内6个代表居群样本、13个反映高山松生殖适应性的种实性状的分析,探讨了其生殖性状在居群水平的变异模式,揭示了具有不同遗传组成和起源历史的高山松居群的生殖特性。研究结果表明:6个研究居群在种实性状上存在显著差异;可育种鳞数、总种鳞数、总种子数、可育种鳞率和可育种鳞密度等与纬度呈显著负相关关系;球果结种率与经度和生态梯度值呈显著的正相关关系;胚珠败育率则与经度和生态梯度值呈显著的负相关关系;球果长度也呈现了与经度的显著负相关。高山松球果结种率很高,平均为74%;球果的结种数、种子长和种翅长与云南松、油松及其它松属双维管亚属多数种接近;球果长度、球果总种鳞数接近油松的报道。这些结果表明,高山松在亲本种不能正常生长、繁衍的高原环境下具备正常的生殖能力;其种实特征在居群间分化显著并呈现一定的地理梯度变化。居群间的显著差异反映了其杂种起源特性,与高山松居群的遗传背景有关,也反映了处在异质生态环境中的高山松居群具有各自的生殖生态进化趋向。     

Density-dependent protogynous sex change in territorial-haremic fishes: models and evidence

Several hypotheses of the proximate control of protogynous (female-to-male)sex change propose that social group composition triggers sexchange, but they do not address how proximate cues are alteredby population density. I present three mutually exclusive encounter-ratethreshold hypotheses that assume that population density determinesrates of contact between social group members and that ratesof contact are cues for sex change. Different densities arepredicted to induce sex change, depending on the encountersassumed to be important in the sex change process (e.g., encounterswith smaller and larger individuals). Tests of the models usea pomacanthid angelfish(Centropyge potten) to show that continuedpresence of a smaller (female) conspecific is needed for sexchange, and that continued presence of a larger (male) conspecificcan either inhibit sex change or prevent its behavioral stimulation.Using constant social group composition, sex change is preventedat higher density but not at a lower density. The absolute encounter-ratethreshold hypothesis, which predicts sex change under intermediate-densityconditions, is the most probable model of the social controlof sex change in C.potteri     

Effects of Population Density on Sex Expression in Onoclea sensibilis L. on Agar and Ashed Soil

Population density affected the sex expression of agar-growngametophytes of Onoclea sensibilis L. The time of onset of sexualitywas advanced, the proportion of females was increased, and thegrowth rate of individuals was greater at lower densities. Populationdensity had no effect on the sex expression of Onoclea grownon ashed soil, and there was no difference in growth rate ofindividuals grown on ashed soil at different densities. Covariateanalysis, using thallus width as a measure of growth rate, indicatedthat the effect of density on sex expression was mostly associatedwith growth rate. The differing effects of population densityon agar and ashed soil demonstrate that substrate influencessex expression in Onoclea. This influence is most dramatic insingle-gametophyte cultures, where agar cultures produced 97per cent females and ashed soil cultures 100 per cent males. Onoclea sensibilis L., sensitive fern, fern gametophytes, sexuality, population density     

RESPONSE TO DENSITY IN A WILD POPULATION OF THE PERENNIAL HERB SALVIA LYRATA: VARIATION AMONG FAMILIES

In order to determine the potential for natural selection to promote genetic specialization to different environments, this study quantified genetic variation for response to conspecific density and to other aspects of the environment that vary spatially. The progeny of a random collection of Salvia lyrata, a perennial herb, were planted into the source field in a range of densities and into several closely neighboring locations. The highest density and particular locations induced significantly greater mortality relative to the remaining densities and locations, indicating major effects of density and spatial location on fitness. Over the duration of the entire study, there was also significant variation among families in mortality. The survival data gave no indication of variation among families in their responses to the range of environments. Conversely, results based on growth and size indicated that different families were favored in different densities and locations, in support of the hypothesis that environment-dependent selection promotes specialization to different environments in this species. The correlation among families between leaf number in high and low density was small and positive, indicating near-independence of performance in different densities.     

Late Transplanting and the Yield of Phaseolus vulgaris L.

The prediction that very high seed yields of dry beans (Phaseolusvulgaris L.) would be produced by the delayed transplantingof large plants has been tested in a factorial experiment withfour dates of transplanting and eight plant populations. Therewere significant differences in yield between transplantingdates and between population densities, and there was a significantdate-density interaction. At low plant densities (up to about30 plants m^–2) the three transplanted treatments yieldedless than the hand-sown controls, and late transplanting yieldedless than early. At the highest density the situation was reversed;all three transplanted treatments out-yielded the controls andlate transplanting tended to out-yield plants transplanted early.The biggest yield was 340 g seed m^–2 from a transplantedcrop grown at 35 plants m^–2. The data on yield fitted a modified rectangular hyperbola ofthe form where y is yield per unit area, p is the number of plants perunit area, t is the number of days between sowing and transplanting,and B_o, n, m, and p are arbitrary parameters. This equationaccounted for 91 per cent of the variation in yield with t andp. It is suggested that late transplanting had adverse effects,due to transplanting ‘shock’ and which were mostmarked at low plant densities; and beneficial effects, ascribableto an effect on plant ‘plasticity’, which were mostmarked at high plant densities. Possible physiological mechanismsof these effects are discussed. Phaseolus vulgaris, yield, density, transplanting     

POPULATION DENSITY EFFECTS ON GROWTH IN CULTURE OF THE EDIBLE SNAIL HELIX ASPERSA VAR. MAXIMA

The effects of population density on the growth of H. aspersaMÜller var. maxima under controlled environmental conditionswere examined. Inhibitory effects on snail growth and maturityresulting from increased population density, between 100–800snails m^–2 of floor area, were observed for a range ofcontainer cleaning frequencies. At all population densities,enhanced snail growth was observed when the frequency of containercleaning was increased to a two-day interval. No significantdifferences were recorded, following 19 weeks growth, betweenfinal mean weights of snails from containers cleaned less frequently.The lowest snail mortality was consistently recorded at thelowest population density in the most frequently cleaned containers.At all snail population densities three phases of growth wereobserved: (a) lag (0–5 weeks), (b) rapid (6–15 weeks)and (c) stable (16 weeks and over). During the first three weeksof growth, high population density had a positive effect ondiet consumption, food conversion efficiency and snail growth.Adverse population density effects increased progressively duringphase (b), typically following 9 weeks growth. Juvenile snailstransferred from high to low population densities during phase(b) continued to exhibit slower growth rates associated withhigh population densities. Food conversion efficiency of snailsin all treatments decreased throughout the experimental periodbut with no overall effect of container cleaning frequency apparent.Inherent growth variability of sibling snails was unaffectedby population density or container cleaning frequency. The importanceof the results for intensive snail culture is discussed. (Received 23 June 1994; accepted 1 December 1994)     

The role of pelagic water mites in the control of cladoceran population in a temperate lake of the southern Andes

In a small temperate lake of the southern Andes, Bosmina longirostrisand Ceriodaphnia dubia coexist with the predaceous water miteLimnesia patagonica. Sampling of natural populations and laboratoryexperiments were carried out. The field population of Limnesiadid not show a numerical response to the density or biomassof its prey. Laboratory experiments showed that the water miterejected C.dubia adults and juveniles as prey, but consumedBosmina. The maximum predation rate was 40 prey predator^–1day^–1 and a linear relationship between predation rateand prey density was obtained (R² = 66%). The contribution ofmortality due to predation and the predation risk are too lowto provoke a prey suppression. By means of computer modelling,the densities of predator necessary to explain half of the totalprey mortality were calculated. These densities were one ortwo orders of magnitude higher than those in the field. It isconcluded that Limnesia could really be a suppressor, but thepotential depends greatly on its density.     

Experimental analysis of the evolutionary potential of hybridization in leopard frogs (Anura: Ranidae)

Artificial crossing using Rana blairi and R. sphenocephala frogs produced conspecific, interspecific and F₁ backcross hybrid genotypes. Although hybrid males used in the crosses were sterile, crosses using hybrid females produced viable larvae. The larval performance of resultant parental and hybrid genotypes was measured in experimental ponds at two densities. Density significantly affected survival, body mass at metamorphosis, larval period length and metamorphosis for all genotypes. Survival was the same among genotypes, but decreased with increasing density. Body mass at metamorphosis was the same among genotypes, but decreased with increasing density. Larval period increased with increasing density. Among genotypes, larvae from the conspecific R. sphenocephala cross had the shortest larval period while larvae from the conspecific R. blairi cross had the longest larval period. All hybrid genotypes had larval periods longer than R. sphenocephala, but shorter than R. blairi. The percentage of individuals metamorphosing was highest for R. sphenocephala ponds and lowest for R. blairi ponds across densities. Ponds with hybrid larvae produced a greater proportion of metamorphs than those with R. blairi larvae, but a smaller proportion than R. sphenocephala ponds. Equivalent or increased relative larval performance of hybrid genotypes under the conditions of our experiment suggests that hybrid genotypes may possess similar or higher fitnesses relative to their progenitors in some environments. Reduced fertility of adult hybrid males is a powerful selective force against natural hybridization. Nevertheless, because of the successful reproduction by female hybrids, natural hybridization has the potential to serve as a mechanism for the introgression of novel genetic variation that can benefit both R. blairi and R. sphenocephala in fluctuating and unpredictable larval environments. Experimental determination of the fitness of parental and hybrid genotypes is crucial for a comprehensive understanding of the effects of hybridization on organismal evolution.     

Multi-component gene network design as a survival strategy in diverse environments

Background

Gene-environment interactions are often mediated though gene networks in which gene expression products interact with other network components to dictate network activity levels, which in turn determines the fitness of the host cell in specific environments. Even though a gene network is the right context for studying gene-environment interactions, we have little understanding on how systematic genetic perturbations affects fitness in the context of a gene network.

Results

Here we examine the effect of combinatorial gene dosage alterations on gene network activity and cellular fitness. Using the galactose utilization pathway as a model network in diploid yeast, we reduce the copy number of four regulatory genes (GAL2, GAL3, GAL4, GAL80) from two to one, and measure the activity of the perturbed networks. We integrate these results with competitive fitness measurements made in six different rationally-designed environments containing different galactose concentrations representing the natural induction spectrum of the galactose network. In the lowest galactose environment, we find a nonlinear relationship between gene expression and fitness while high galactose environments lead to a linear relationship between the two with a saturation regime reached at a sufficiently high galactose concentration. We further uncover environment-specific relevance of the different network components for dictating the relationship between the network activity and organismal fitness, indicating that none of the network components are redundant.

Conclusions

These results provide experimental support to the hypothesis that dynamic changes in the environment throughout natural evolution is key to structuring natural gene networks in a multi-component fashion, which robustly provides protection against population extinction in different environments.

     

The adaptive evolution of plasticity: phytochrome-mediated shade avoidance responses

Many plants display a characteristic suite of developmental"shade avoidance" responses, such as stem elongation and acceleratedreproduction, to the low ratio of red to far-red wavelengths(R:FR) reflected or transmitted from green vegetation. ThisR:FR cue of crowding and vegetation shade is perceived by thephytochrome family of photoreceptors. Phytochrome-mediated responsesprovide an ideal system for investigating the adaptive evolutionof phenotypic plasticity in natural environments. The molecularand developmental mechanisms underlying shade avoidance responsesare well studied, and testable ecological hypotheses exist fortheir adaptive significance. Experimental manipulation of phenotypesdemonstrates that shade avoidance responses may be adaptive,resulting in phenotypes with high relative fitness in the environmentsthat induce those phenotypes. The adaptive value of shade avoidancedepends upon the competitive environment, resource availability,and the reliability of the R:FR cue for predicting the selectiveenvironment experienced by an induced phenotype. Comparativestudies and a reciprocal transplant experiment with Impatienscapensis provide evidence of adaptive divergence in shade avoidanceresponses between woodland and clearing habitats, which mayresult from population differences in the frequency of selectionon shade avoidance traits, as well as differences in the reliabilityof the R:FR cue. Recent rapid progress in elucidating phytochromesignaling pathways in the genetic model Arabidopsis thalianaand other species now provides the opportunity for studyinghow selection on shade avoidance traits in natural environmentsacts upon the molecular mechanisms underlying natural phenotypicvariation.     

Application of Monoculture Yield/Density Relationships to Plant Competition in Binary Additive Series

Binary additive series experiments involving various pairedcombinations of barnyardgrass (BYG), redroot pigweed (RPW),green foxtail (GFT) and rape (RPS) were undertaken in fieldplots in 1980 and 1981. The experimental design used permittedinvestigation of the performance of a one species (the ‘competitor’) over a range of densities, in the presenceof different constant densities of a second species (the ‘indicator’),and as pure stands. Top growth (d.wt after approximately 95d) in monoculture was found to be well-described by de Wit'sspacing formula where M_s is yield, s is space per seed or plant, is maximum(asymptotic) yield at infinite density and ß is spaceper seed or plant at half the maximum yield (i.e. /2). The formulawas also found to fit the observed yields of a competing speciesover the entire range of densities of an indicator. Correlationcoefficients between observed yields and values calculated bymeans of the spacing formula ranged from 0.934 to 0.999, withmost greater than 0.990. The changes in the slopes of a competingspecies' yield curves as indicator density increases reflectthe competitive abilities of the pair of species present. Barnyardgrassand RPS were found to be strong competitors against RPW andGFT, and RPW strongly competed against GFT. The spacing formulacan thus be used to predict the performance of a competing speciesin additive series experiments, and thereby provides anothermeans of investigating crop-weed and other interactions. Echinochloa crusgalli (L.) Beauv., Setaria viridis (L.) Beauv., Amaranthus retroflexus L., Brassica napus L., barnyardgrass, green foxtail, redroot pigweed, rape, competition, binary additive series, yield/density relationships     

Mating system structure and population density in a polygynous lizard, Sauromalus obesus (= ater)

Increases in population density often are associated with achange in mating system structure in numerous taxa. Typically,male interactions are minimal in extremely low density populations.As density increases, males exhibit territoriality but if densitybecomes too high, the energetic cost of defending a territorywill eventually outweigh the reproductive benefits associatedwith territoriality. Consequently, males in high density populationsmay abandon territoriality and adopt dominance polygyny, lekking behavior, or scramble competition. We investigated the relationshipbetween population density and mating system structure in threepopulations of the chuckwalla, Sauromalus obesus (= ater),near Phoenix, Arizona. Densities in the Phoenix Mountains (2.7chuckwallas/ha) were lower than any population previously studied.In the Santan Mountains (10.9 chuckwallas/ha), densities weresimilar to populations studied in the Mojave Desert, and inthe South Mountains (65 chuckwallas/ha), densities were the highest yet recorded. Male mating behavior was examined by determininghome range overlap and by making direct behavioral observations.Male home range size decreased with increasing population density.There was little overlap in home ranges among males in allthree populations, whereas home ranges of males and femalesconsistently overlapped, indicating that males were strictly territorial. This conclusion was supported by behavioral observationsof interactions among individuals in a natural setting. Thenumber of females wihin male territories was correlated withfood resources (plants) in all three populations. Female homerange size appeard to be related to food resources whereasmale home ranges appeared to be related to female distribution,population density, and geology. The retention of territoriality in spite of high population densities raises new questions aboutthe relationship between density and resource defense.     

Trojan Genes and Transparent Genomes: Sexual Selection,Regulatory Evolution and the Real Hopeful Monsters

Potential impacts of genetically modified (GM) animals in natural environments are explored in a framework of regulatory evolution. Transgenic growth hormone animals express remarkable alterations and plasticity in development, physiology and behavior in response to environmental factors (nutrition, temperature, photoperiod), suggesting that standard laboratory assessments are likely to underestimate their evolutionary potential. Sexual selection is examined in the context of female self-referent appraisal of male fitness that reflects performance in the species-specific niche. Wild-type females may recognize and discriminate against GM males (the Transparent Genome Hypothesis) but if accepted as mates, pleiotropic disruption associated with GMs may reduce fitness of the natural population (the Trojan Gene Hypothesis). Alternatively, facilitation of regulatory evolution by sexual reproduction (recombination and segregation) may derive modifier selection, masking, integration, or niche shifts. Other aspects explored include mutation theory, purging, pleiotropy, epigenetics and plasticity, behavior and the Bruce effect, and mismatch of genetic or epigenetic background between GM stock and natural populations.     

Population density and the evolution of male aggression

In some cases male animals engage in aggressive contests for access to females, in others they adopt more passive strategies and invest in traits that assist them in detecting females or in competing with rivals in other ways, such as sperm competition. One possible factor determining the fitness of these different strategies is population density. Theoretically, aggressive tactics should be found at intermediate population densities. At low densities males that invest in traits related to searching for mates could be favoured, whereas at the highest densities males that fight over females might pay excessive costs for this behaviour because of the number of rival males that they will encounter. Current empirical evidence is mostly consistent with this scheme: in some cases it seems that traits that are associated with locating mates are favoured at low densities, with aggression related traits favoured at higher densities, and in other cases aggression is selected but as density increases less aggressive strategies become more common. There remain substantial differences between species, however, and I discuss how variation in mating system, in the costs of aggression and in the nature of sperm competition, plus ecological differences between species, can change the relationship between population density and the fitness consequences of aggressive and passive behavioural strategies.     

Evolutionary divergence of field and laboratory populations of Manduca sexta in response to host‐plant quality

1. The tobacco hornworm, Manduca sexta, has been an important model system in insect biology for more than 50 years. In nature, M. sexta successfully utilises a range of host plants that vary in quality. The consequences of laboratory domestication and rearing on artificial diet for fitness of phytophagous insects on natural host plants have not been explored. 2. We examine the evolutionary divergence of two domesticated laboratory populations and a field population (separated for more than 40 years, or > 250 laboratory generations) of M. sexta with respect to performance and fitness on two natural host plants: a typical host plant, tobacco (Nicotiana tabacum) and a novel host plant, devil's claw (Proboscidea louisianica). 3. For both field and laboratory populations, rearing on devil's claw resulted in animals with lower survival, smaller final size, longer development time, and reduced size‐corrected fecundity than animals reared on tobacco. Reductions in some fitness components (survival and fecundity) were greater for the laboratory population animals than the field population animals. 4. When reared on tobacco, the laboratory population animals had similar or larger pupal masses and slightly shorter development times than when reared on artificial diet, suggesting that laboratory domestication on artificial diet has not greatly affected the ability of M. sexta to perform well on a typical natural host plant. 5. Although field and laboratory populations exhibited qualitatively similar responses to host‐plant quality, i.e. reduced performance on devil‘s claw, the magnitude of this reduction differed across populations, with the domesticated laboratory populations having greater reductions in performance than the field population. The use of domesticated populations as models for responses of field populations may therefore be more appropriate for considering environmental conditions that are relatively benign or near‐optimal, than when exploring responses to extreme or stressful conditions.     

Grooming in desert bighorn sheep (Ovis canadensis mexicana) and the ghost of parasites past

Ectoparasites such as ticks have a negative effect on host fitness,whereas parasite-defense grooming is effective in removing ticks.The central control (programmed grooming) model proposes thatanimals engage in preventive tick-defense grooming in responseto an internal timing mechanism, even in the absence of peripheralstimulation from parasites. This model predicts that smalleranimals will groom more frequently than larger ones becauseof the higher cost of parasitism for a small animal (body sizeprinciple). The peripheral stimulation (stimulus driven) modelpredicts no size-related differences in grooming rate in theabsence of tick bite irritation. We observed grooming behaviorin a Chihuahuan desert population of bighorn sheep (Ovis canadensismexicana), where ticks have been absent for perhaps thousandsof years. Although not exposed to ticks, bighorns self groomedby means of oral and scratch grooming, albeit at very low ratescompared to size-matched ungulates in both tick-infested andtick-free environments. Logistic regression and general linearmodels revealed both the probability that grooming was performedduring a 10-min focal sample and the rate of grooming when itoccurred was greater for younger, smaller age/sex categoriesof less body mass. Oral and scratch grooming were negativelyassociated with body mass during both years, with juveniles(X = 15 kg) grooming the most frequently and the oldest males(X = 70–85 kg) grooming the least. Assuming that programmedgrooming evolved in a tick-infested environment, the currentgrooming behavior of this population is a relict of their ancestralenvironment, an adaptation to the "ghost of parasites past."     

Exploration and Social Play in Squirrel Monkeys (Saimiri)

Squirrel monkeys (Saimiri) have been studied in a variety oflaboratory and natural environments. The frequency and formof exploration and social play vary considerably among differentenvironments. For example, in some environments, young monkeyshave been observed to play for 3 hr per day; but in one naturalenvironment, not a single bout of social play was seen duringa 10-week intensive study. Numerous intermediate levels of playactivity have been observed. Whereas many theories of play make it appear that play is essentialfor the development of sexual behavior, integrated roles introop structure, control of aggressive responses, social cohesion,etc., the data on squirrel monkeys indicate that social organizationand many normal social behaviors can develop without socialplay. However, the opportunity to play socially provides learningexperiences that increase the variety of each animal's behavioralrepertoire and the subtly of social cues to which it can respond.An adaptive modicum of competence can appear without socialplay, but the opportunity to play socially develops the competenceof animals beyond that modicum.