A steady-state random-order mechanism for the oxidative deamination of norvaline by glutamate dehydrogenase.

The kinetic mechanism of glutamate dehydrogenase with the monocarboxylic substrate norvaline was examined by using initial-rate steady-state kinetics and inhibition kinetics. To a first approximation the reaction mechanism can be described as a rapid-equilibrium random-order one. Binding synergism between the monocarboxylic substrate and coenzyme is not observed. Dissociation constants for NAD+ and 2-oxoglutarate calculated from the kinetic data assuming a rapid-equilibrium random-order model are in good agreement with independently obtained estimates. Lineweaver-Burk plots with varied norvaline concentration are not strictly linear, and it is concluded that a steady-state random-order model more accurately reflects the observed kinetics with norvaline as substrate.     

Kinetic studies of dogfish liver glutamate dehydrogenase.

Initial-rate studies were made of the oxidation of L-glutamate by NAD+ and NADP+ catalysed by highly purified preparations of dogfish liver glutamate dehydrogenase. With NAD+ as coenzyme the kinetics show the same features of coenzyme activation as seen with the bovine liver enzyme [Engel & Dalziel (1969) Biochem. J. 115, 621--631]. With NADP+ as coenzyme, initial rates are much slower than with NAD+, and Lineweaver--Burk plots are linear over extended ranges of substrate and coenzyme concentration. Stopped-flow studies with NADP+ as coenzyme give no evidence for the accumulation of significant concentrations of NADPH-containing complexes with the enzyme in the steady state. Protection studies against inactivation by pyridoxal 5'-phosphate indicate that NAD+ and NADP+ give the same degree of protection in the presence of sodium glutarate. The results are used to deduce information about the mechanism of glutamate oxidation by the enzyme. Initial-rate studies of the reductive amination of 2-oxoglutarate by NADH and NADPH catalysed by dogfish liver glutamate dehydrogenase showed that the kinetic features of the reaction are very similar with both coenzymes, but reactions with NADH are much faster. The data show that a number of possible mechanisms for the reaction may be discarded, including the compulsory mechanism (previously proposed for the enzyme) in which the sequence of binding is NAD(P)H, NH4+ and 2-oxoglutarate. The kinetic data suggest either a rapid-equilibrium random mechanism or the compulsory mechanism with the binding sequence NH4+, NAD(P)H, 2-oxoglutarate. However, binding studies and protection studies indicate that coenzyme and 2-oxoglutarate do bind to the free enzyme.     

Kinetic studies of ox-liver glutamate dehydrogenase oxidative deamination of two glutamate analogues, L-threo-gamma-methylglutamate and L-alpha-amino-gamma-nitraminobutyrate, in the presence of the allosteric effector ADP

Ox-liver glutamate dehydrogenase is known to utilise a wide range of amino acid substrates. Kinetic studies are presented here for L-threo-gamma-methylglutamate and L-alpha-amino-gamma-nitraminobutyrate in the presence of the allosteric effector ADP. The results presented are considered in the light of similar studies presented elsewhere in which the cofactor was systematically replaced by a variety of analogues. These amino acid analogues share the same pH optimum as glutamate, unlike the monocarboxylic amino acids including alanine and norvaline, and give linear double-reciprocal plots under the conditions used here. Studies with the alternative coenzymes have suggested an ordered addition of glutamate before coenzyme in the presence of ADP. The present results obtained under identical conditions support this conclusion.     

The binding of oxidized coenzymes by glutamate dehydrogenase and the effects of glutarate and purine nucleotides

1. The binding of NAD(+) and NADP(+) to glutamate dehydrogenase has been studied in sodium phosphate buffer, pH7.0, by equilibrium dialysis. Approximate values for the dissociation constants are 0.47 and 2.5mm respectively. For NAD(+) the value agrees with that estimated from initial-rate results. 2. In the presence of the substrate analogue glutarate both coenzymes are bound more firmly, and there is one active centre per enzyme subunit. The binding results cannot be described in terms of independent and identical active centres, and binding is stronger at low coenzyme concentrations than at high concentrations. Either the six subunits of the oligomer are not identical or there are negative interactions between them in the binding of coenzymes in ternary complexes with glutarate. The latter explanation is favoured. 3. The binding studies support the conclusions drawn from earlier kinetic studies of the glutamate reaction. 4. ADP and GTP respectively decrease and increase the affinity of the enzyme for NAD(+) and NADP(+), in both the presence and absence of glutarate. The negative binding interactions in the presence of glutarate are abolished by ADP, which decreases the affinity for the coenzymes at low concentrations of the latter. 5. In the presence of glutarate, GTP and NAD(+) or NADP(+), the association of enzyme oligomers is prevented, and the solubility of the enzyme is decreased; the complex of enzyme and ligands readily crystallizes. 6. The results are discussed in relation to earlier kinetic studies.     

The kinetic mechanism of ox liver glutamate dehydrogenase in the presence of the allosteric effector ADP. The oxidative deamination of L-glutamate.

In steady-state kinetic studies of ox liver glutamate dehydrogenase in 0.11 M-potassium phosphate buffer, pH7, at 25 degrees C, the concentration of ADP was varied from 0.5 to 1000 microM. Inhibition was observed except when the concentrations of both glutamate and coenzyme were high, when activation was seen. With NAD+ or NADP+ as coenzyme, 200 microM-ADP was sufficient to saturate the enzyme with respect to the major effect of this nucleotide. In the presence of 210 microM-ADP, widely varied concentrations of coenzyme give linear Lineweaver-Burk plots, in marked contrast with results obtained previously for kinetics without ADP. This has allowed evaluation for the reaction with NAD+, NADP+ and acetylpyridine-adenine dinucleotide (315 microM-ADP in the last case) of all four initial rate parameters, i.e. the phi coefficients in the equation: (Formula: see text) where A is coenzyme and B is glutamate. The relative constancy of phi B and of phi AB/phi A with the different coenzymes point to a compulsory-order mechanism with glutamate as the leading substrate. This conclusion, though unexpected, agrees well with various previous observations on the binding of oxidized coenzyme.     

Dual nucleotide specificity of bovine glutamate dehydrogenase. The role of negative co-operativity.

The thionicotinamide analogues of NAD+ and NADP+ were shown to be good alternative coenzymes for bovine glutamate dehydrogenase, with similar affinity and approx. 40% of the maximum velocity obtained with the natural coenzymes. Both thionicotinamide analogues show non-linear Lineweaver-Burk plots, which with the natural coenzymes have been attributed to negative co-operativity. Since the reduced thionicotinamide analogues have an isosbestic point at 340nm and have an absorption maximum at 400nm, it is possible to monitor reduction of natural coenzyme and thionicotinamide analogue simultaneously by dual-wavelength spectroscopy. When glutamate dehydrogenase is presented with NADP+ and thio-NADP+ simultaneously, the enzyme oligomer senses saturation of its coenzyme-binding sites irrespective of the exact nature of the coenzyme and locks the oligomer into its highly saturated form even when low saturation of the monitored coenzyme is present. These experiments substantiate the suggestion that glutamate dehydrogenase shows negative co-operativity in its catalytically active form.     

A kinetic study of the oxidative deamination of L-glutamate by Peptostreptococcus asaccharolyticus glutamate dehydrogenase using a variety of coenzymes

The NAD+-specific glutamate dehydrogenase from Peptostreptococcus asaccharolyticus follows Michaelis-Menten kinetics in contrast to the enzyme from several other sources, and thus gives linear double-reciprocal plots of initial-rate data. The initial-rate parameters have been determined for this bacterial dehyrogenase in the direction of oxidative deamination. The use of alternative coenzymes leads to some conclusions about the order of substrate addition. An investigation of the pH dependence of this reaction reveals that the binding of oxidised coenzyme is independent of pH over the range 6-9. The kinetic data are consistent with an ordered addition of coenzyme prior to glutamate, the reverse of the mechanism derived with ox glutamate dehydrogenase in the presence of ADP.     

Kinetic studies of glutamate dehydrogenase. The reductive amination of 2-oxoglutarate

1. Kinetic studies of the reductive amination of 2-oxoglutarate catalysed by glutamate dehydrogenase with NADH and NADPH as coenzyme were made at pH7.0 and pH 8.0. The concentrations of both substrates and coenzymes were simultaneously varied over wide ranges. Lineweaver-Burk plots with respect to each substrate and coenzyme were linear, except that with high concentrations of 2-oxoglutarate or coenzyme inhibition occurred. There was no evidence of the negative homotropic interactions between the enzyme subunits that were revealed in previous kinetic studies of the reverse reaction. 2. The initial-rate results are shown to be inconsistent with any of the six possible compulsory-order mechanisms for this three-substrate reaction, and it is concluded that a random-order mechanism is the most likely one. On the basis of this mechanism, the dissociation constants of all the binary, ternary and quaternary complexes of the enzyme and substrates are calculated from initial-rate parameters. 3. The results are discussed in relation to those of earlier workers who concluded that the mechanism is of the compulsory-order type.     

Regulation of ox liver glutamate dehydrogenase activity by coenzymes

The effects of coenzymes NAD(P) and NAD(P)H on the kinetics of the ox liver glutamate dehydrogenase reaction have been studied. The oxidized coenzymes were shown to activate alpha-ketoglutarate amination at inhibiting concentrations of NADH and NADPH. The reduced coenzymes, NADH and NADPH, inhibit glutamate deamination with both NAD and NADP as coenzymes. The data obtained are discussed in terms of literature data on the mechanisms of the coenzyme effects on the glutamate dehydrogenase activity and are inconsistent with the theory of direct ligand--ligand interactions. It was shown that the peculiarities of the glutamate dehydrogenase kinetics can easily be interpreted in the light of the two state models.     

Ligand-induced changes in the conformational stability and flexibility of glutamate dehydrogenase and their role in catalysis and regulation

Bovine glutamate dehydrogenase (GDH) is allosterically regulated and requires substrate‐induced subunit interactions for maximum catalytic activity. Steady‐state and presteady‐state kinetics indicate that the rate‐limiting step depends on the nature of the substrate and are likely associated with conformational fluctuations necessary for optimal hydride transfer. Deuterated glutamate shows a steady‐state isotope effect but no effect on the presteady‐state burst rate, demonstrating that conformational effects are rate limiting for hydride transfer while product release is overall rate limiting for glutamate. Guanidine hydrochloride unfolding, heat inactivation, and differential scanning calorimetry demonstrate the effects of alternative substrates, glutamate and norvaline, on conformational stability. Glutamate has little effect on overall stability, whereas norvaline markedly stabilizes the protein. Limited proteolysis demonstrates that glutamate had a variety of effects on local flexibility, whereas norvaline significantly decreased conformational fluctuations that allow protease cleavage. Dynamic light scattering suggests that norvaline stabilizes all interfaces in the hexamer, whereas glutamate had little effect on trimer–trimer interactions. The substrate glutamate exhibits negative cooperativity and complex allosteric regulation but has only minor effects on global GDH stability, while promoting certain local conformational fluctuations. In contrast, the substrate norvaline does not show negative cooperativity or allow allosteric regulation. Instead, norvaline significantly stabilizes the enzyme and markedly slows or prevents local conformational fluctuations that are likely to be important for cooperative effects and to determine the overall rate of hydride transfer. This suggests that homotropic allosteric regulation by the enzymatic substrate involves changes in both global stability and local flexibility of the protein.     

A product-inhibition study of bovine liver glutamate dehydrogenase.

1. Initial rates of oxidative deamination of L-glutamate with NAD+ as coenzyme, and of reductive aminiation of 2-oxoglutarate with NADH as coenzyme, catalysed by bovine liver glutamate dehydrogenase were measured in 0.111 M-sodium phosphate buffer, pH 7, at 25 degrees C, in the absence and presence of product inhibitors. All 12 possible combinations of variable substrate and product inhibitor were used. 2. Strict competition was observed between NAD+ and NADH, and between glutamate and 2-oxoglutarate. All other inhibition patterns were clearly non-competitive, except for inhibition by NH4+ with NAD+ as variable substrate. Here the extrapolation did not permit a clear distinction between competitive and non-competitive inhibition. 3. Mutually non-competitive behaviour between glutamate and NH4+ indicates that these substrates can be bound at the active site simultaneously. 4. Primary Lineweaver-Burk plots and derived secondary plots of slopes and intercepts against inhibitor concentration were linear, with one exception: with 2-oxoglutarate as variable substrate, the replot of primary intercepts against inhibitory NAD+ concentration was curved. 5. Separate Ki values were evaluated for the effect of each product inhibitor on the individual terms in the reciprocal initial-rate equations. With this information it is possible to calculate rates for any combination of substrate concentrations within the experimental range with any concentration of a single product inhibitor. 6. The inhibition patterns are consistent with neither a simple compulsory-order mechanism nor a rapid-equilibrium random-order mechanism without modification. They can, however, be reconciled with either type of mechanism by postulating appropirate abortive complexes. Of the two compulsory sequences that have been proposed, one, that in which the order of binding is NADH, NH4+, 2-oxoglutarate, requires an implausible pattern of abortive complex-formation to account for the results. 7. On the basis of a rapid-equilibrium random-order mechanism, dissociation constants can be calculated from the Ki values. Where these can be compared with independent estimates from the kinetics of the uninhibited reaction or from direct measurements of substrate binding, the agreement is reasonable good. On balance, therefore, the results provide further support for the rapid-equilibrium random-order mechanism under these conditions.     

The importance of arginine residues in the catalytic and regulatory functions of bovine-liver glutamate dehydrogenase.

Bovine liver glutamate dehydrogenase reacts rapidly with 2,3-butanedione to yield modified enzyme with 29% of its original maximum activity, but no change in its Michaelis constants for substrates and coenzymes. No significant reduction in the inactivation rate is produced by the addition of the allosteric activator ADP or inhibitor GTP, while partial protection against inactivation is provided by the coenzyme NAD+ or substrate 2-oxoglutarate when added separately. The most marked decrease in the rate of inactivation (about 10-fold) is provided by the combined addition of NAD+ and 2-oxoglutarate, suggesting that modification takes place in the region of the active site. Reaction with 2,3-butanedione also results in loss of the ability of the enzyme to be activated by ADP. Addition of ADP (but not NAD+, 2-oxoglutarate or GTP) to the incubation mixture protects markedly against the loss of activatability of ADP. It is concluded that 2,3-butanedione produces two distinguishable effects on glutamate dehydrogenase: a relatively specific modification of the regulatory ADP site and a distinct modification in the active center. Reaction of two arginyl residues per peptide chain appears to be responsible for disruption of the ADP activation property of the enzyme, while alteration of a maximum of five arginyl residues can be related to the reduction of maximum catalytic activity. Electrostatic interactions between the positively charged arginine groups and the negatively charged substrate, coenzyme and allosteric purine nucleotide may be important for the normal function of glutamate dehydrogenase.     

Formation of transient complexes in the glutamate dehydrogenase catalyzed reaction.

The reaction of glutamate dehydrogenase and glutamate (gl) with NAD+ and NADP+ has been studied with stopped-flow techniques. The enzyme was in all experiments present in excess of the coenzyme. The results indicate that the ternary complex (E-NAD(P)H-kg) is present as an intermediate in the formation of the stable complex (E-NAD(P)H-gl). The identification of the complexes is based on their absorption spectra. The binding of the coenzyme to (E-gl) is the rate-limiting step in the formation of (E-NAD(P)H-kg) while the dissociation of alpha-ketoglutarate (kg) from this complex is the rate-limiting step in the formation of (E-NAD(P)H-gl). The Km for glutamate was 20-25 mM in the first reaction and 3 mM in the formation of the stable complex. The Km values were independent of the coenzyme. The reaction rates with NAD+ were approximately 50% greater than those with NADP+. Furthermore, high glutamate concentration inhibited the formation of (E-NADH-kg) while no substrate inhibition was found with NADP+ as coenzyme. ADP enhanced while GTP reduced the rate of (E-NAD(P)H-gl) formation. The rate of formation of (E-NAD(P)H-kg) was inhibited by ADP, while it increased at high glutamate concentration when small amounts of GTP were added. The results show that the higher activity found with NAD+ compared to NADP+ under steady-state assay conditions do not necessarily involve binding of NAD+ to the ADP activating site of the enzyme. Moreover, the substrate inhibition found at high glutamate concentration under steady-state assay condition is not due to the formation of (E-NAD(P)H-gl) as this complex is formed with Km of 3 mM glutamate, and the substrate inhibition is only significant at 20-30 times this concentration.     

Negative co-operativity in glutamate dehydrogenase. Involvement of the 2-position in glutamate in the induction of conformational changes.

The 2-position substituent on substrates or substrate analogues for glutamate dehydrogenase is shown to be intimately involved in the induction of conformational changes between subunits in the hexamer by coenzyme. These conformational changes are associated with the negative co-operativity exhibited by this enzyme. 2-Oxoglutarate and L-2-hydroxyglutarate induce indications of co-operativity similar to those induced by the substrate of oxidative deamination, glutamate, in kinetic studies. Glutarate (2-position CH2) does not. A comparison of the effects of L-2-hydroxyglutarate and D-2-hydroxyglutarate or D-glutamate indicates that the 2-position substituent must be in the L-configuration for these conformational changes to be triggered. In addition, glutarate and L-glutamate in ternary enzyme-NAD(P)H-substrate complexes induce very different coenzyme fluorescence properties, showing that glutamate induces a different conformation of the enzyme-coenzyme complex from that induced by glutarate. Although glutamate and glutarate both tighten the binding of reduced coenzyme to the active site, the effect is much greater with glutamate, and the binding is described by two dissociation constants when glutamate is present. The data suggest that the two carboxy groups on the substrate are required to allow synergistic binding of coenzyme and substrate to the active site, but that interactions between the 2-position on the substrate and the enzyme trigger the conformational changes that result in subunit-subunit interactions and in the catalytic co-operativity exhibited by this enzyme.     

Nickel-induced substrate inhibition of bovine liver glutamate dehydrogenase

The effects of nickel ions on reductive amination and oxidative deamination activities of bovine liver glutamate dehydrogenase (GDH) were examined kinetically by UV spectroscopy, at 27 degrees C, using 50 mM Tris, pH 7.8, containing 0.1 M NaCl. Kinetic analysis of the data obtained by varying NADH concentration indicated strong inhibition, presumably due to binding of the coenzyme to the regulatory site. In contrast, almost no inhibition was observed in the forward reaction. The fact that nickel ions have the capacity to enhance binding of NADH to the enzyme was confirmed by an electrochemical method using a modified glassy carbon electrode. Use of NADPH instead of NADH showed only a weak substrate inhibition, presumably related to lower affinity of NADPH for binding to the regulatory site. Lineweaver-Burk plots with respect to alpha-ketoglutarate and ammonium ions indicated substrate and competitive inhibition patterns in the presence of nickel ions, respectively. ADP at 0.2 mM concentration protected inhibition caused by nickel. These observations are explained in terms of formation of a nickel-NADH complex with a higher affinity for binding to the regulatory site in GDH, as compared with the situation where nickel is not present. Such effects may be important for regulation of GDH and other NADH-utilizing enzymes.     

Ox liver glutamate dehydrogenase. The role of lysine-126 reappraised in the light of studies of inhibition and inactivation by pyridoxal 5''-phosphate.

The time-course of inactivation of bovine liver glutamate dehydrogenase by pyridoxal 5'-phosphate was studied in the presence of varied amounts of 2-oxoglutarate or NADH. Pseudo-first-order analysis reveals that the protection by both these compounds is competitive with respect to the chemical modifier. The competition is only partial, however: saturation with either NADH or 2-oxoglutarate decreases the rate constant for inactivation to a finite minimum and not to zero. Similarly, the plot of activity at equilibrium as a function of the concentration of the protecting substrate or coenzyme reveals that neither NADH nor 2-oxoglutarate protects completely against inactivation. In initial-rate experiments, pyridoxal 5'-phosphate, used as an instantaneous inhibitor rather than a long-term inactivator, displayed non-competitive inhibition with respect to both 2-oxoglutarate and NADH. These results clearly indicate that, although there is mutual hindrance between the binding to the enzyme of pyridoxal 5'-phosphate, on the one hand, and 2-oxoglutarate or NADH on the other, binding is not mutually exclusive. These findings are discussed in terms of the two-step mechanism for inactivation by pyridoxal 5'-phosphate. It is concluded that lysine-126 cannot be solely responsible for binding either the substrate or the coenzyme, but could be essential for the catalytic step.     

Reversal of the extreme coenzyme selectivity of Clostridium symbiosum glutamate dehydrogenase

Active-site mutants of glutamate dehydrogenase from Clostridium?symbiosum have been designed and constructed and the effects on coenzyme preference evaluated by detailed kinetic measurements. The triple mutant F238S/P262S/D263K shows complete reversal in coenzyme selectivity from NAD(H) to NADP(H) with retention of high levels of catalytic activity for the new coenzyme. For oxidized coenzymes, k(cat) /K(m) ratios of the wild-type and triple mutant enzyme indicate a shift in preference of approximately 1.6?×?10(7) -fold, from ～?80?000-fold in favour of NAD(+) to ～?200-fold in favour of NADP(+) . For reduced coenzymes the corresponding figure is 1.7?×?10(4) -fold, from ～?1000-fold in favour of NADH to ～?17-fold in favour of NADPH. A fourth mutation (N290G), previously identified as having a potential bearing on coenzyme specificity, did not engender any further shift in preference when incorporated into the triple mutant, despite having a significant effect when expressed as a single mutant.     

Protection of glutamate dehydrogenase by nicotinamide–adenine dinucleotide against reversible inactivation by pyridoxal 5′-phosphate as a sensitive indicator of conformational change induced by substrates and substrate analogues

1. The steady residual activity of ox liver glutamate dehydrogenase at equilibrium with the reversible inactivator pyridoxal 5'-phosphate was measured in the presence and absence of various protecting agents. 2. NAD(+) (up to 15mm) and its 3-acetylpyridine analogue (up to 5mm) both failed to protect, in contrast with NADH. 3. Partial protection was given by glutarate and by succinate. Adipate and pentanoate were much less effective. 4. Correspondingly, whereas succinate and glutarate were both shown to be strong inhibitors of the catalytic reaction, competitive with glutamate, adipate was only weakly competitive, and the still weaker inhibition by pentanoate was non-competitive. 5. When the enzyme was saturated with glutarate, NAD(+) became a good, although still partial, protecting agent. In the absence of protection, 1.8mm-pyridoxal 5'-phosphate decreased enzyme activity to 9%, in the presence of 150mm-glutarate to 29%, and with glutarate and 1mm-NAD(+) only to 73%. 6. 2-Oxoglutarate also promoted protection by NAD(+), but neither pentanoate nor succinate did so. The finding with succinate is remarkable in view of findings 3 and 4 above. 7. It seems possible that substrates or analogues possessing the glutarate structure promote a conformational change that alters the mode of NAD(+) binding. This may explain why glutamate is a much better substrate than norvaline or aspartate and why negative interactions in coenzyme binding occur only in the formation of ternary complexes with glutamate or its analogues.     

Synthesis and properties of 2-azido-NAD+. A study of interaction with glutamate dehydrogenase

A photoactive coenzyme analog of NAD+ has been synthesized by chemically coupling [32P]2-azido-AMP and NMN to produce [32P]nicotinamide 2-azidoadenosine dinucleotide (2-azido-NAD+). The utility of 2-azido-NAD+ as an effective active-site-directed photoprobe was demonstrated using bovine liver glutamate dehydrogenase as a model enzyme. In the absence of ultraviolet light, 2-azido-NAD+ is a substrate for this enzyme. Photoincorporation of probe was saturable with two different apparent dissociation constants of 10 microM and 40 microM. Protection of photoinsertion was seen with the natural substrate NAD+ with apparent dissociation constants of less than 5 microM and 25 microM. This observation may be explained on the basis of negative cooperative interaction between the subunits. The photoinsertion of 2-azido-NAD+ was increased by GTP and decreased by ADP in accordance with their known effects on NAD+ binding. When the enzyme was covalently modified by photolysis in the presence of saturating amounts of photoprobe, an approximately 40% inhibition of the enzyme activity was observed. These results demonstrate that the photoaffinity coenzyme analog has potential application as a probe to characterize NAD(+)-binding proteins and to identify the active sites of these proteins.     

Construction, separation and properties of hybrid hexamers of glutamate dehydrogenase in which five of the six subunits are contributed by the catalytically inert D165S.

In vitro subunit hybridization was used to explore the basis of putative allosteric behaviour in clostridial glutamate dehydrogenase. C320S and D165S mutant enzymes were chosen to construct the hybrid proteins. The C320S mutant protein is fully active and shows normal allosteric properties but lacks the reactive cysteine. D165S is capable of binding both glutamate and NAD(+) but is catalytically inactive. The mutant proteins were denatured separately in 4 M urea, mixed in a 5 : 1 (D165S/C320S) ratio and diluted into a refolding mixture composed of 2 mM NAD(+), 1 M fluoride and artificial chaperones (4 mM polyoxyethylene 10 lauryl ether and 1.6 mM beta-cyclodextrin). Under these conditions approximately 50% refolding was achieved for both mutant proteins separately. The renatured mixture was concentrated and separated from denatured proteins and the components of the refolding mixture by ultrafiltration and ion-exchange chromatography. Ellman's reagent, 5,5'-dithiobis (2-nitrobenzoic acid) (DTNB), which binds close to the NAD(+) binding site, thus abolishing coenzyme binding in the wild-type enzyme, also reacts with D165S but has no effect on C320S. Modification by DTNB was coupled with dye-ligand affinity chromatography on a Procion Red HE-3B column in order to separate the hybrid mixture into fractions of defined composition. An optimized procedure based on salt gradient elution was developed. DTNB-modified 5 : 1 hybrids, with only one subunit capable of binding coenzyme, showed classical Michaelis-Menten kinetics when the NAD(+) concentration was varied, whereas removal of the thionitrobenzoate moieties that blocked the other five coenzyme binding sites in the hexamer reinstated nonlinear behaviour, suggesting that 'nonlinear' behaviour of the native enzyme and the hybrid with six coenzyme binding sites depends on binding to multiple sites. When assayed at high pH with increasing glutamate concentration, the sample with only one active subunit showed reduced sigmoidicity in the dependence of reaction rate on glutamate concentration (h = 3.0) compared with native C320S with six active subunits (h = 5.2) suggesting that the interaction between the subunits was reduced but not abolished completely. Catalytically silent subunits can thus still contribute to cooperativity.