A dominant conformational role for amino acid diversity in minimalist protein-protein interfaces

Recent studies have shown that highly simplified interaction surfaces consisting of combinations of just two amino acids, Tyr and Ser, exhibit high affinity and specificity. The high functional levels of such minimalist interfaces might thus indicate small contributions of greater amino acid diversity seen in natural interfaces. Toward addressing this issue, we have produced a pair of binding proteins built on the fibronectin type III scaffold, termed “monobodies.” One monobody contains the Tyr/Ser binary-code interface (termed YS) and the other contains an expanded amino acid diversity interface (YSX), but both bind to an identical target, maltose-binding protein. The YSX monobody bound with higher affinity, a slower off rate and a more favorable enthalpic contribution than the YS monobody. High-resolution X-ray crystal structures revealed that both proteins bound to an essentially identical epitope, providing a unique opportunity to directly investigate the role of amino acid diversity in a protein interaction interface. Surprisingly, Tyr still dominates the YSX paratope and the additional amino acid types are primarily used to conformationally optimize contacts made by tyrosines. Scanning mutagenesis showed that while all contacting Tyr side chains are essential in the YS monobody, the YSX interface was more tolerant to mutations. These results suggest that the conformational, not chemical, diversity of additional types of amino acids provided higher functionality and evolutionary robustness, supporting the dominant role of Tyr and the importance of conformational diversity in forming protein interaction interfaces.     

Exploring the potential of the monobody scaffold: effects of loop elongation on the stability of a fibronectin type III domain

The tenth fibronectin type III domain of human fibronectin (FNfn10) is a small, monomeric beta-sandwich protein, similar to the immunoglobulins. We have developed small antibody mimics, 'monobodies', using FNfn10 as a scaffold. We initially altered two loops of FNfn10 that are structurally equivalent to two of the hypervariable loops of the immunoglobulin domain. In order to assess the possibility of utilizing other loops in FNfn10 for target binding, we determined the effects of the elongation of each loop on the conformational stability of FNfn10. We found that all six loops of FNfn10 allowed the introduction of four glycine residues while retaining the global fold. Insertions in the AB and FG loops exhibited very small degrees of destabilization, comparable to or less than predicted entropic penalties due to the elongation, suggesting the absence of stabilizing interactions in these loops in wild-type FNfn10. Insertions in the BC, CD and DE loops, respectively, resulted in modest destabilization. In contrast, the EF loop elongation was highly destabilizing, consistent with previous studies showing the presence of stabilizing interactions in this loop. These results suggest that all loops, except for the EF loop, can be used for engineering a binding site, thus demonstrating excellent properties of the monobody scaffold.     

Investigating the properties of Bacillus thuringiensis Cry proteins with novel loop replacements created using combinatorial molecular biology

Cry proteins are a large family of crystalline toxins produced by Bacillus thuringiensis. Individually, the family members are highly specific, but collectively, they target a diverse range of insects and nematodes. Domain II of the toxins is important for target specificity, and three loops at its apex have been studied extensively. There is considerable interest in determining whether modifications in this region may lead to toxins with novel specificity or potency. In this work, we studied the effect of loop substitution on toxin stability and specificity. For this purpose, sequences derived from antibody complementarity-determining regions (CDR) were used to replace native domain II apical loops to create "Crybodies." Each apical loop was substituted either individually or in combination with a library of third heavy-chain CDR (CDR-H3) sequences to create seven distinct Crybody types. An analysis of variants from each library indicated that the Cry1Aa framework can tolerate considerable sequence diversity at all loop positions but that some sequence combinations negatively affect structural stability and protease sensitivity. CDR-H3 substitution showed that loop position was an important determinant of insect toxicity: loop 2 was essential for activity, whereas the effects of substitutions at loop 1 and loop 3 were sequence dependent. Unexpectedly, differences in toxicity did not correlate with binding to cadherins--a major class of toxin receptors--since all Crybodies retained binding specificity. Collectively, these results serve to better define the role of the domain II apical loops as determinants of specificity and establish guidelines for their modification.     

Antibody binding loop insertions as diversity elements

In the use of non-antibody proteins as affinity reagents, diversity has generally been derived from oligonucleotide-encoded random amino acids. Although specific binders of high-affinity have been selected from such libraries, random oligonucleotides often encode stop codons and amino acid combinations that affect protein folding. Recently it has been shown that specific antibody binding loops grafted into heterologous proteins can confer the specific antibody binding activity to the created chimeric protein. In this paper, we examine the use of such antibody binding loops as diversity elements. We first show that we are able to graft a lysozyme-binding antibody loop into green fluorescent protein (GFP), creating a fluorescent protein with lysozyme-binding activity. Subsequently we have developed a PCR method to harvest random binding loops from antibodies and insert them at predefined sites in any protein, using GFP as an example. The majority of such GFP chimeras remain fluorescent, indicating that binding loops do not disrupt folding. This method can be adapted to the creation of other nucleic acid libraries where diversity is flanked by regions of relative sequence conservation, and its availability sets the stage for the use of antibody loop libraries as diversity elements for selection experiments.     

Understanding mechanisms governing protein-protein interactions from synthetic binding interfaces

Recent advances in methodologies and design of combinatorial library selection have enabled comprehensive characterization of sequence space for protein-protein interaction interfaces and generation of fully synthetic binding interfaces. By exhaustively introducing and quantitatively analyzing mutations in natural interfaces, new insights into their molecular architecture and plasticity have emerged. Minimalist combinatorial libraries based on a restricted amino acid code have produced synthetic interfaces that rival natural ones using a different set of rules. A two amino acid code composed of just tyrosine and serine in the context of antibody CDR loops is sufficient to produce high affinity and specific interactions with different classes of protein targets. Structural analyses highlight the dominant role of Tyr in forming productive interactions and demonstrate the dominance of conformational diversity over chemical diversity in producing na?ve binding interfaces. Synthetic binding proteins are beginning to be used as a powerful crystallization tool to attack important structural biology problems that are recalcitrant to crystallization using traditional methods.     

High-affinity human antibodies from phage-displayed synthetic Fab libraries with a single framework scaffold

Phage-displayed synthetic antibody libraries were built on a single human framework by introducing synthetic diversity at solvent-exposed positions within the heavy chain complementarity-determining regions (CDRs). The design strategy of mimicking natural diversity using tailored codons had been validated previously with scFv libraries, which produced antibodies that bound to antigen, murine vascular endothelial growth factor (mVEGF), with affinities in the 100nM range. To improve library performance, we constructed monovalent and bivalent antigen-binding fragment (Fab) libraries, and explored different CDR-H3 diversities by varying the amino acid composition and CDR length. A Fab with sub-nanomolar affinity for mVEGF was obtained from a library with CDR-H3 diversity designed to contain all 20 naturally occurring amino acids. We then expanded the library by increasing the variability of CDR-H3 length and using tailored codons that mimicked the amino acid composition of natural CDR-H3 sequences. The library was tested against a panel of 13 protein antigens and high-affinity Fabs were obtained for most antigens. Furthermore, the heavy chain of an anti-mVEGF clone was recombined with a library of light chain CDRs, and the affinity was improved from low nanomolar to low picomolar. The results demonstrated that high-affinity human antibodies can be generated from libraries with completely synthetic CDRs displayed on a single scaffold.     

A semi-synthetic repertoire of intrinsically stable antibody fragments derived from a single-framework scaffold.

We report the design, construction and use of an antibody bacteriophage display library built on the scaffold of a single-chain variable fragment (scFv) previously proven to be functionally expressed in the reducing environment of both bacterial and plant cytoplasm and endowed with intrinsic high thermodynamic stability. Four amino acid residues of the third hypervariable loop (CDR3) of both VH and VL were combinatorially mutated, generating a repertoire of approximately 5x10(7) independent scFvs, cloned in a phagemid vector. The ability of the antibody phage library to yield specific binders was tested by biopanning against several antigens. Successful selection of fully active scFvs was obtained, confirming the notion that combinatorial mutagenesis of few amino acid residues centrally located in the antigen-binding site is sufficient to provide binding specificities against virtually any target. High yields of both soluble and phage antibodies were obtained in Escherichia coli. Maintenance of the cognate scFv antibody stability in the newly selected scFv fragments was demonstrated by guanidinium chloride denaturation/renaturation studies and by soluble antibody expression in the bacterial cytoplasm. The antibody library described here allows the isolation of new stable binding specificities, potentially exploitable as immunochemical reagents for intracellular applications.     

Yeast Puf3 mutants reveal the complexity of Puf-RNA binding and identify a loop required for regulation of mRNA decay

The eukaryotic Puf proteins regulate mRNA translation and degradation by binding the 3' untranslated regions of target mRNAs. Crystal structure analysis of a human Puf bound to RNA suggested a modular mode of binding, with specific amino acids within each of eight repeat domains contacting a single nucleotide of the target RNA. Here we study the mechanism by which the yeast Puf3p binds and stimulates the degradation of COX17 mRNA. Mutation of the predicted RNA-binding positions of Puf3p to those found in Puf5p demonstrated that a single amino acid change in Puf3p abolished detectable binding to COX17. Since this amino acid position in both Puf3p and Puf5p is predicted to contact an adenine in the respective target RNAs, the amino acid in Puf3p must play a more critical role in promoting COX17 interaction. In contrast, an amino acid change in the third repeat of Puf3p, which interacts with the only divergent nucleotide between the Puf3p and Puf5p targets, had no effect on binding COX17. These results argue that a simple set of rules cannot reliably link specific amino acid positions with target specificity. Each of these amino acid changes in Puf3p enhanced binding to the Puf5p target HO RNA, suggesting a different mode of binding to this target. Finally, we identified an outer surface loop that was dispensable for binding but was required to promote both rapid deadenylation and subsequent decapping of the COX17 mRNA, most likely as a point of protein-protein interactions.     

A conformation-constrained peptide library based on insect defensin A

Here, we reported a conformation-constrained peptide library, that was constructed based on the scaffold of a 29 amino acids peptide derived from insect defensin A. The peptide scaffold was designed utilizing the InsightII molecular modeling software and then displayed on M13 filamentous bacteriophage by fusion with coat protein III. The library was constructed by randomization of seven positions located within the two loops of the peptide scaffold generating approximately 8.3 x 10(8) transformants. Sequences from 14 randomly selected phage clones indicated that the distribution of nucleotides and amino acids paralleled with the expected frequency. Screening against the target proteins: tumor necrosis factor alpha, TNF receptor 1, TNF receptor 2 and monoclonal antibody against BMP-2 showed significant enrichment in all cases. The results presented here show that the reconstructed insect defensin A domain will be a promising non-antibody protein scaffold for the presentation of a phage-displayed constrained peptide library.     

Development and application of cytotoxic T lymphocyte-associated antigen 4 as a protein scaffold for the generation of novel binding ligands

We have explored the possibilities of using human cytotoxic T lymphocyte-associated antigen 4 (CTLA-4) as a single immunoglobulin fold-based scaffold for the generation of novel binding ligands. To obtain a suitable protein library selection system, the extracellular domain of CTLA-4 was first displayed on the surface of a filamentous phage as a fusion product of the phage coat protein p3. CTLA-4 was shown to be functionally intact by binding to its natural ligands B7-1 (CD80) and B7-2 (CD86) both in vitro and in situ. Secondly, the complementarity determining region 3 (CDR3) loop of the CTLA-4 extracellular domain was evaluated as a permissive site. We replaced the nine amino acid CDR3-like loop of CTLA-4 with the sequence XXX-RGD-XXX (where X represents any amino acid). Using phage display we selected several CTLA-4-based variants capable of binding to human alphavbeta3 integrin, one of which showed binding to integrins in situ. To explore the construction of bispecific molecules we also evaluated one other potential permissive site diametrically opposite the natural CDR-like loops, which was found to be tolerant of peptide insertion. Our data suggest that CTLA-4 is a suitable human scaffold for engineering single-domain molecules with one or possibly more binding specificities.     

Phage-displayed antibody libraries of synthetic heavy chain complementarity determining regions

A structure-based approach was used to design libraries of synthetic heavy chain complementarity determining regions (CDRs). The CDR libraries were displayed as either monovalent or bivalent single-chain variable fragments (scFvs) with a single heavy chain variable domain scaffold and a fixed light chain variable domain. Using the structure of a parent antibody as a guide, we restricted library diversity to CDR positions with significant exposure to solvent. We introduced diversity with tailored degenerate codons that ideally only encoded for amino acids commonly observed in natural antibody CDRs. With these design principles, we reasoned that we would produce libraries of diverse solvent-exposed surfaces displayed on stable scaffolds with minimal structural perturbations. The libraries were sorted against a panel of proteins and yielded multiple unique binding clones against all six antigens tested. The bivalent library yielded numerous unique sequences, while the monovalent library yielded fewer unique clones. Selected scFvs were converted to the Fab format, and the purified Fab proteins retained high affinity for antigen. The results support the view that synthetic heavy chain diversity alone may be sufficient for the generation of high-affinity antibodies from phage-displayed libraries; thus, it may be possible to dispense with the light chain altogether, as is the case in natural camelid immunoglobulins.     

The Trp cage motif as a scaffold for the display of a randomized peptide library on bacteriophage T7

Phage libraries displaying linear or disulfide-constrained peptides often yield weak binders, upon screening against a target, and must be optimized to improve affinity. The disadvantages of libraries based on larger complex proteins, such as single chain antibodies, have stimulated interest in the development of smaller nonimmunoglobulin protein scaffolds. A promising candidate is the Trp cage motif, a 20-residue C-terminal sequence of exendin-4. Amino acid substitution within the Trp cage resulted in a 20-mer peptide recognized as an ultrafast cooperative folding miniprotein, with ideal characteristics for the discovery of small structured nonimmunoglobulin motifs having a stable tertiary structure. Although we were unable to display the Trp cage on M13 phage, successful display was achieved using the lytic T7 phage. Interestingly, mutations were observed at a frequency dependent on display valency. A Trp cage library designed with randomized amino acids at seven solvent-exposed positions was developed from 1.6 x 10(9) primary clones in T7Select10-3b. DNA sequencing of 109 library clones revealed 38% mutants and 16% truncations by TAG codons at randomized positions. Amino acid frequencies were largely within expected bounds and DIVAA analysis revealed that the library had an average diversity of 0.67. Utility of the library was demonstrated by identification of HPQ containing Trp cage miniproteins, which bound streptavidin, and AAADPYAQWLQSMGPHSGRPPPR, which bound to human bronchial epithelial cells. A high complexity library based on the Trp cage miniprotein has demonstrated potential for identifying novel cell and protein binding peptides that could be used for the delivery of therapeutic molecules or as target-specific therapeutic agents.     

Construction of TNF-binding proteins by grafting hypervariable regions of F10 antibody on human fibronectin domain scaffold

Tumor necrosis factor (TNF) plays a key role in the pathogenesis of various diseases. To study the possibility of constructing TNF-binding proteins by grafting hypervariable regions of immunoglobulins (CDR), we have replaced amino acid sequences of loops from the tenth type III domain of human fibronectin (¹⁰Fn3) by amino acid sequences of CDR from the light and heavy chains of the anti-TNF antibody F10. The assessment of TNF-binding properties of the resulting proteins by ELISA has revealed the highest activity of Hd3 containing sequences CDR-H1 and CDR-H2 of the antibody F10 and of Hd2 containing sequences CDR-H1 and CDR-H3. The proteins constructed by us on the fibronectin domain scaffold specifically bound TNF during Western blotting and also weakened its cytotoxic effect on L929 line cells. The highest neutralizing activity was demonstrated by the proteins Hd2 and Hd3, which induced, respectively, 10- and 50-fold increase in the EC₅₀ of TNF.     

Design and expression of soluble CTLA-4 variable domain as a scaffold for the display of functional polypeptides.

We have designed and engineered the human cytotoxic T-lymphocyte associated protein-4 (CTLA-4) variable (V-like) domain to produce a human-based protein scaffold for peptide display. First, to test whether the CTLA-4 CDR-like loops were permissive to loop replacement/insertion we substituted either the CDR1 or CDR3 loop with somatostatin, a 14-residue intra-disulfide-linked neuropeptide. Upon expression as periplasmic-targeted proteins in Escherichia coli, molecules with superior solubility characteristics to the wild-type V-domain were produced. These mutations in CTLA-4 ablated binding to its natural ligands CD80 and CD86, whereas binding to a conformation-dependent anti-CTLA-4 monoclonal antibody showed that the V-domain framework remained correctly folded. Secondly, to develop a system for library selection, we displayed both wild-type and mutated CTLA-4 proteins on the surface of fd-bacteriophage as fusions with the geneIII protein. CTLA-4 displayed on phage bound specifically to immobilized CD80-Ig and CD86-Ig and in one-step panning enriched 5,000 to 2,600-fold respectively over wild-type phage. Bacteriophage displaying CTLA-4 with somatostatin in CDR3 (CTLA-4R-Som3) specifically bound somatostatin receptors on transfected CHO-K1 cells pre-incubated with 1 microg/ml tunicamycin to remove receptor glycosylation. Binding was specific, as 1 microM somatostatin successfully competed with CTLA-4R-Som3. CTLA-4R-Som3 also activated as well as binding preferentially to non-glycosylated receptor subtype Sst4. The ability to substitute CDR-like loops within CTLA-4 will enable design and construction of more complex libraries of single V-like domain binding molecules. Proteins 1999;36:217-227.     

Evolution of an interloop disulfide bond in high-affinity antibody mimics based on fibronectin type III domain and selected by yeast surface display: molecular convergence with single-domain camelid and shark antibodies

The 10th human fibronectin type III domain ((10)Fn3) is one of several protein scaffolds used to design and select families of proteins that bind with high affinity and specificity to macromolecular targets. To date, the highest affinity (10)Fn3 variants have been selected by mRNA display of libraries generated by randomizing all three complementarity-determining region -like loops of the (10)Fn3 scaffold. The sub-nanomolar affinities of such antibody mimics have been attributed to the extremely large size of the library accessible by mRNA display (10(12) unique sequences). Here we describe the selection and affinity maturation of (10)Fn3-based antibody mimics with dissociation constants as low as 350 pM selected from significantly smaller libraries (10(7)-10(9) different sequences), which were constructed by randomizing only 14 (10)Fn3 residues. The finding that two adjacent loops in human (10)Fn3 provide a large enough variable surface area to select high-affinity antibody mimics is significant because a smaller deviation from wild-type (10)Fn3 sequence is associated with a higher stability of selected antibody mimics. Our results also demonstrate the utility of an affinity-maturation strategy that led to a 340-fold improvement in affinity by maximizing sampling of sequence space close to the original selected antibody mimic. A striking feature of the highest affinity antibody mimics selected against lysozyme is a pair of cysteines on adjacent loops, in positions 28 and 77, which are critical for the affinity of the (10)Fn3 variant for its target and are close enough to form a disulfide bond. The selection of this cysteine pair is structurally analogous to the natural evolution of disulfide bonds found in new antigen receptors of cartilaginous fish and in camelid heavy-chain variable domains. We propose that future library designs incorporating such an interloop disulfide will further facilitate the selection of high-affinity, highly stable antibody mimics from libraries accessible to phage and yeast surface display methods.     

新型蛋白质配体-亲和体研究进展

亲和体(affibody)是一种衍生于葡萄球菌A蛋白B结构域的人工蛋白质分子．B结构域含58个氨基酸,形成3个α螺旋结构,分子质量约为6.5 ku．其中第一及第二螺旋中的13个特定位点的氨基酸对其结构无明显影响,这些位点可被随机突变形成理论上可与任何靶分子结合的亲和体文库．筛选该文库可获得能与某一靶分子特异结合的亲和体．亲和体与靶分子的结合特性与抗体相似,但与抗体相比具有一些独特的优势,如：通过体外筛选即可获得,以化学合成方法或原核表达即可大量制备,分子质量小、在生物体内组织穿透性强、血浆清除率高,理化稳定性好,可以通过交联或融合表达与标记分子(如荧光蛋白、生物素等)结合而不影响其与靶分子的结合能力．亲和体可作为抗体的替代品,用于蛋白质识别、分离及纯化、实验诊断、分子显像及靶向治疗．     

噬菌体短肽库的构建及其随机短肽的多样性

噬菌体短肽库是将随机合成的寡核苷酸序列通过与单链噬菌体外壳蛋白基因融合,从而将随机短肽表达于噬菌体的表面。将体外随机化学合成的寡聚核苷酸序列重组到单价噬菌体表达载体,构建了噬菌体短肽库,证明其库容为２×１０￣７集落形成单位（ｃｆｕ）,重组率为９３％。同时将１１个随机克隆进行序列测定,证实其寡聚核苷酸序列和氨基酸的分布几乎是完全随机的,其多样性可以满足特异性短肽筛选的要求。     

Fibronectin type III domain based monobody with high avidity

Significant efforts have been made to improve the target-binding strength of numerous affinity molecules that are widely used in biomedical research and clinical applications. While many antibody-like fragments have been successfully optimized through affinity maturation, the process is time-consuming and restricted by the stability, solubility, and expression level of the protein sequences. To generate a fibronectin type III domain (FN3) based monobody that binds to the tumor-related biomarkers with exceptional high strength and stability, we developed a multivalent strategy by fusing an alphavbeta3-binding FN3 monobody with a short COMP pentamerization domain through a linker that facilitates appropriate display of multivalent FN3 domains. The fusion protein was highly expressed in the soluble fraction of Escherichia coli and efficiently self-assembled into a pentameric molecule that could be readily purified. Compared to the monomeric form, the pentameric monobody bound to alphavbeta3 integrin much more tightly with significantly slower off-rate, while still maintaining its excellent specificity toward alphavbeta3 when tested by using purified integrins and integrin-expressing cell lines. The multivalent strategy we describe here could be applied to engineer other FN3 monobodies to acquire significantly improved targeting-binding strengths.     

Alpha-amylase inhibitors selected from a combinatorial library of a cellulose binding domain scaffold

A disulfide bridge-constrained cellulose binding domain (CBD(WT)) derived from the cellobiohydrolase Cel7A from Trichoderma reesei has been investigated for use in scaffold engineering to obtain novel binding proteins. The gene encoding the wild-type 36 aa CBD(WT) domain was first inserted into a phagemid vector and shown to be functionally displayed on M13 filamentous phage as a protein III fusion protein with retained cellulose binding activity. A combinatorial library comprising 46 million variants of the CBD domain was constructed through randomization of 11 positions located at the domain surface and distributed over three separate beta-sheets of the domain. Using the enzyme porcine alpha-amylase (PPA) as target in biopannings, two CBD variants showing selective binding to the enzyme were characterized. Reduction and iodoacetamide blocking of cysteine residues in selected CBD variants resulted in a loss of binding activity, indicating a conformation dependent binding. Interestingly, further studies showed that the selected CBD variants were capable of competing with the binding of the amylase inhibitor acarbose to the enzyme. In addition, the enzyme activity could be partially inhibited by addition of soluble protein, suggesting that the selected CBD variants bind to the active site of the enzyme.