Genetic Exchange across a Paracentric Inversion of the Mouse T Complex

Mouse t haplotypes are distinguished from wild-type forms of chromosome 17 by four nonoverlapping paracentric inversions which span a genetic distance of 20 cM. These inversion polymorphisms are responsible for a 100-200-fold suppression of recombination which maintains the integrity of complete t haplotypes and has led to their divergence from the wild-type chromosomes of four species of house mice within which t haplotypes reside. As evidence for the long period of recombinational isolation, alleles that distinguish all t haplotypes from all wild-type chromosomes have been established at a number of loci spread across the 20-cM variant region. However, a more complex picture emerges upon analysis of other t-associated loci. In particular, "mosaic haplotypes" have been identified that carry a mixture of wild-type and t-specific alleles. To investigate the genetic basis for mosaic chromosomes, we conducted a comprehensive analysis of eight t complex loci within 76 animals representing 10 taxa in the genus Mus, and including 23 previously characterized t haplotypes. Higher resolution restriction mapping and sequence analysis was also performed for alleles at the Hba-ps4 locus. The results indicate that a short tract of DNA was transferred relatively recently across an inversion from a t haplotype allele of Hba-ps4 to the corresponding locus on a wild-type homolog leading to the creation of a new hybrid allele. Several classes of wild-type Hba-ps4 alleles, including the most common form in inbred strains, appear to be derived from this hybrid allele. The accumulated data suggest that a common form of genetic exchange across one of the four t-associated inversions is gene conversion at isolated loci that do not play a role in the transmission ratio distortion phenotype required for t haplotype propagation. The implications of the results pose questions concerning the evolutionary stability of gene complexes within large paracentric inversions and suggest that recombinational isolation may be best established for loci residing within a short distance from inversion breakpoints.     

tctN-mutation causing taillessness in mice heterozygous for gene T

Screening of wild male mice trapped in Turkmenistan (Middle Asia) revealed a mouse with a mutation causing strong increase in expressivity of T mutation (Brachyury). A novel mutation was designated tctN-t complex tail interaction Novosibirsk. Compound heterozygotes T/tctN have tailless of extremely short tailed phenotype. Homozygotes tctN/tctN were completely viable and fertile. It was shown that the novel mutation was closely linked to T locus. Further genetic analysis showed that the chromosome with tct had no properties of t haplotypes: no lethal factors or the factors influencing fertility and segregation of homologoues; there was no effect on recombination frequency in the proximal part of chromosome 17 in tctN/+mice. The problems of t haplotype evolution are discussed.     

Genetic Analysis of Mouse T Haplotypes Using Mutations Induced by Ethylnitrosourea Mutagenesis: The Order of T and Qk Is Inverted in T Mutants

The t region of mouse chromosome 17 exhibits recombination suppression with wild-type chromatin. However, the region has resisted classical genetic dissection because of a lack of defined variants. Mutations induced by N-ethyl-N-nitrosourea (ENU) at the Brachyury (T), quaking (qk), and tufted (tf) loci of the mouse tw5 haplotype have now allowed the analysis of crossovers between two complete t haplotypes. A classical breeding analysis of the complete t haplotypes, tw5 and t12, utilizing the newly induced markers, reveals two inversions in t chromatin: one involving T and qk, and one involving tf and the H-2 complex. Moreover, the recombination frequency between the loci of T and qk is reduced compared to the frequency reported in normal chromatin. These two inversions are a sufficient explanation for the recombination inhibition with normal chromatin exhibited by t haplotypes isolated from the wild. Furthermore, the reduced recombination frequency between T and qk may indicate that the proximal gene rearrangement is not a simple inversion.     

Determining the physical limits of the Brassica S locus by recombinational analysis

A genetic analysis was performed to study the frequency of recombination for intervals across the Brassica S locus region. No recombination was observed between the S locus glycoprotein gene and the S receptor kinase gene in the segregating populations that we analyzed. However, a number of recombination breakpoints in regions flanking these genes were identified, allowing the construction of an integrated genetic and physical map of the genomic region encompassing one S haplotype. We identified, based on the pollination phenotype of plants homozygous for recombinant S haplotypes, a 50-kb region that encompasses all specificity functions in the S haplotype that we analyzed. Mechanisms that might operate to preserve the tight linkage of self-incompatibility specificity genes within the S locus complex are discussed in light of the relatively uniform recombination frequencies that we observed across the S locus region and of the structural heteromorphisms that characterize different S haplotypes.     

Genetic analysis of the proximal portion of the mouse t complex: evidence for a second inversion within t haplotypes

Genomic sequences derived from the mouse t complex by a microdissection cloning technique have been used as tools to obtain high resolution genetic maps of the wild-type and t haplotype forms of the most proximal portion of chromosome 17. Genetic mapping was performed through a recombinant inbred strain analysis and an analysis of partial t haplotypes. The accumulated data demonstrate the existence of a large inversion of genetic material, encompassing the loci of T and qk, within the proximal portion of t haplotypes. This newly described proximal inversion and the previously described distal inversion provide an explanation for the suppression of recombination observed along the length of t haplotype DNA in heterozygous mice.     

ENU-induced allele of brachyury (Tkt1) exhibits a developmental lethal phenotype similar to the original brachyury (T) mutation

New alleles of brachyury (Tkt1, Tkt4) were induced in the mouse complete tw5 haplotype by ethylnitrosourea (ENU). Like the original brachyury (T) mutation, the new alleles cause a short-tailed phenotype in heterozygotes, and interact with the t complex tail interaction factor (tct) in trans to cause phenotypically tailless mice. Because ENU is mainly a point mutagen, it is important to determine that the new alleles are homozygous embryonic lethal mutations like the original T allele, and to characterize their embryonic lethal phenotype. Moreover, the Tkt1 mutation maps to an inverted position relative to quaking (qk) in t haplotypes as compared with its position on normal chromosome 17. The Tkt1 allele was separated from the resident tw5 lethal gene, tclw5, by recombination, allowing embryology studies to be performed. Embryological analyses show that the Tkt1 allele is nearly identical to the classic T allele. At 9 and 10 days of development, homozygous Tkt1/Tkt1 embryos are grossly abnormal with properties including 1) irregular, disorganized somite pairs, 2) a shortened posterior end of the embryo, 3) an irregular neural tube, and 4) an abnormal notochord. In addition, 10 day-old abnormal embryos have anterior limb buds that point dorsally rather than ventrally, and are smaller than normal littermates. We conclude that the Tkt1 mutation is a valuable allele for both mapping and molecular characterization of the brachyury locus.     

EVOLUTION AT THE MOUSE t COMPLEX: WHY IS THE t HAPLOTYPE PRESERVED AS AN INTEGRAL UNIT?

Abstract Segregation distorters are selfish genetic elements that bias Mendelian segregation in their favor. All well-known segregation distortion systems consist of one or more "distorter" loci that act upon a "responder" locus. At the t complex of the house mouse, segregation distortion is brought about by the harmful effect of t alleles at a number of distorter loci on the wild-type variant of the responder locus. The responder and distorter alleles are closely linked by a number of inversions, thus forming a coherent t haplotype. It has been conjectured that the close integration of the various components into a "complete" t haplotype has been crucial for the evolutionary success of these selfish genetic elements. By means of a population genetical metapopulation model, we show that this intuition may be unfounded. In fact, under most circumstances an "insensitive" t haplotype retaining only the responder did invade and reach a high frequency, despite the fact that this haplotype has a strong segregation disadvantage. For certain population structures, the complete t haplotype was even competitively excluded by partial t haplotypes with lower segregation ratios. Moreover, t haplotypes carrying one or more recessive lethals only prevailed over their nonlethal counterparts if the product of local population size and migration rate ( Nm ) was not much smaller or larger than one. These phenomena occurred for rather realistic fitness, segregation, and recombination values. It is therefore quite puzzling that partial t haplotypes are absent from natural house mousepopulations, and that t haplotypes carrying recessive lethals prevail over nonlethal t haplotypes.     

Haplotypes That Are Mosaic for Wild-Type and T Complex-Specific Alleles in Wild Mice

Two outstanding problems pertaining to the population dynamics and evolution of the t complex in mice concern the frequency of t haplotypes in the wild and the degree to which these haplotypes recombine with their wild-type homologs. To address these problems, the frequency and distribution of several t complex-associated restriction fragment variants in wild mice were estimated. Sixty-four versions of chromosome 17 from wild-derived Mus musculus musculus and Mus musculus domesticus were examined with DNA probes for six loci within the t complex that exhibit restriction fragment variation. All six probes detect variants that have heretofore been found exclusively associated with the t complex. Haplotype analysis of wild-derived chromosomes revealed a high frequency (45.3%) of "mosaic" haplotypes with a mixture of t-specific and wild-type variants and only one haplotype with t-specific variants at all six loci. When 12 well-characterized t haplotypes isolated from diverse geographic regions were analyzed, only three had a complete set of t-specific restriction fragments for the six loci examined. The preponderance of mosaic haplotypes in both groups of mice can be explained by any one of the following hypotheses: genetic recombination between t haplotypes and their wild-type homologs, the persistence in wild populations of haplotypes that have descended from ancestral partial t haplotypes, or that the restriction fragment variants fixed in the ancestral t haplotype were also fixed in some wild-type haplotypes. There is evidence to support all three of these hypotheses in our data. The allelic composition of some mosaic haplotypes indicates that they may have been formed by segmental recombination, either double crossing over or gene conversion, rather than by simple single crossovers. The occurrence of indistinguishable mosaic haplotypes in both M. m. musculus and M. m. domesticus suggests that these haplotypes are ancestral rather than recently derived.     

Pattern of segmental recombination in the distal inversion of mouse t haplotypes

To examine genetic exchange between t haplotypes and their wild-type homologs, four previously identified mouse Chromosome (Chr) 17 variants termed mosaic haplotypes were analyzed in detail. Three of these haplotypes-one from a Mus musculus population in Bulgaria, one from a Mus domesticus population in Chile, and one from a M. domesticus population in Germany-display properties indicative of the t complex. All four haplotypes are exceptional because they are characterized by the presence of a few wild-type DNA markers in the distal inversion [In(17)4] of a t haplotype chromosome: thus, they are classified as mosaic t haplotypes. The mosaic pattern for each haplotype is distinct, however. We compared the mosaic haplotypes with each other, and with several well-characterized laboratory t haplotypes, by analyzing several DNA markers in the In(17)4 region of the t complex, where all of the mosaicism occurs. We used a combination of high-resolution restriction mapping, DNA sequencing, and analysis of new DNA markers to classify the haplotypes. This analysis shows that segmental exchange, either by gene conversion or double crossing-over, has occurred at molecular markers in the vicinity of a gene, Dnahc8, that is a candidate for the t complex distorter locus Tcd2. While it is unclear whether segmental exchanges have included the Tcd2 gene, it is apparent that several independent recombination events have occurred in In(17)4 during the recent evolution of t haplotypes.     

Nonhomologous Pairing in Mice Heterozygous for a t Haplotype Can Produce Recombinant Chromosomes with Duplications and Deletions

We have investigated the structure and properties of a chromosomal product recovered from a rare recombination event between a t haplotype and a wild-type form of mouse chromosome 17. Our embryological and molecular studies indicate that this chromosome (twLub2) is characterized by both a deletion and duplication of adjacent genetic material. The deletion appears to be responsible for a dominant lethal maternal effect and a recessive embryonic lethality. The duplication provides an explanation for the twLub2 suppression of the dominant T locus phenotype. A reanalysis of previously described results with another chromosome 17 variant called TtOrl indicates a structure for this chromosome that is reciprocal to that observed for twLub2. We have postulated the existence of an inversion over the proximal portion of all complete t haplotypes in order to explain the generation of the partial t haplotypes twLub2 and TtOrl. This proximal inversion and the previously described distal inversion are sufficient to account for all of the recombination properties that are characteristic of complete t haplotypes. The structures determined for twLub2 and TtOrl indicate that rare recombination can occur between nonequivalent genomic sequences within the inverted proximal t region when wild-type and t chromosomes are paired in a linear, nonhomologous configuration.     

Targeted Mutagenesis of a Candidate T Complex Responder Gene in Mouse T Haplotypes Does Not Eliminate Transmission Ratio Distortion

Transmission ratio distortion (TRD) associated with mouse t haplotypes causes +/t males to transmit the t-bearing chromosome to nearly all their offspring. Of the several genes involved in this phenomenon, the t complex responder (Tcr(t)) locus is absolutely essential for TRD to occur. A candidate Tcr(t) gene called Tcp10b(t) was previously cloned from the genetically defined Tcr(t) region. Its location, restricted expression in testis, and a unique postmeiotic alternative splicing pattern supported the idea that Tcp10b(t) was Tcr(t). To test this hypothesis in a functional assay, ES cells were derived from a viable partial t haplotype, and the Tcp10b(t) gene was mutated by homologous recombination. Mutant mice were mated to appropriate partial t haplotypes to determine whether the targeted chromosome exhibited transmission ratios characteristic of the responder. The results demonstrated that the targeted chromosome retained full responder activity. Hence, Tcp10b(t) does not appear to be Tcr(t). These and other observations necessitate a reevaluation of genetic mapping data and the actual nature of the responder.     

Genetic variants of the tuberous sclerosis 2 tumour suppressor gene in mouse t haplotypes

The murine t complex on chromosome 17 contains a number of homozygous lethal and semi-lethal mutations that disrupt development of the mouse embryo. We recently characterized an embryonic lethality in the rat that results from a germ-line mutation in the tuberous sclerosis 2 (Tsc-2) tumour suppressor gene (the Eker mutation). Remarkably, mouse embryos homozygous for tw8 mutation display cranial defects reminiscent of those observed in rat embryos homozygous for the Eker mutation. To determine whether the Tsc-2 gene, which is in the t complex, is mutated in tw8 or other t haplotypes, we characterized this gene in a series of t haplotype mice. Four Tsc-2 polymorphisms were identified: three in the coding region and one intronic that appeared to be common to all t haplotypes analysed. No evidence was found to argue that the Tsc-2 gene is altered in tw8 haplotype mice. However, in the tw5 haplotype we found a G to T mutation in Tsc-2 that was present only in this t haplotype. In contrast to other polymorphisms within the Tsc-2 coding region which did not result in amino acid changes in Tsc-2 gene product tuberin, this mutation substituted a phenylalanine for a conserved cysteine in tw5 tuberin. Within the t complex, the Tsc-2 gene and the putative tw5 locus appeared to map to different positions, complicating identification of Tsc-2 as a candidate for the tw5 locus and suggesting that the G to T mutation in the Tsc-2 gene may have arisen independently of the tw5 functional mutation.     

Phylogenetic analysis of the alpha-globin pseudogene-4 (Hba-ps4) locus in the house mouse species complex reveals a stepwise evolution of t haplotypes [published erratum appears in Mol Biol Evol 1994 Jan;11(1):158]

A parsimony analysis was performed on restriction sites at the Hba-ps4 pseudogene locus within one of four inversions associated with mouse t haplotypes. The results suggest that all t haplotypes form a monophyletic group and that the in (17)4 inversion originated before the radiation of the Mus musculus species complex but after the divergence of the lineages leading to M. spretus, M. abbotti, and M. hortulanus. A time frame based on the evolutionary rate of mouse pseudogenes places the origin of this t haplotype inversion at 1.5 Mya, or approximately 1.5 Myr after the origin of the more proximal t complex inversion, in (17)2. The accumulated evidence indicates that complete t haplotypes have been assembled in a stepwise manner, with each of these inversions occurring on separate chromosomal lineages and at different evolutionary times. In addition, the evolutionary relationships of pseudogene sequences resulting from genetic exchange between wild-type and t haplotype alleles were examined. Analysis of sequences from the 5' and 3' sides of a putative site of recombination resulted in cladograms with different topologies. The implications for hypotheses concerning the evolutionary forces acting on t haplotypes and their rapid propagation throughout worldwide populations of mice are discussed.      

Search for differences among t haplotypes in distorter and responder genes

Transmission ratio distortion due to the mouse t complex is though to be due to harmful effects of trans-acting distorter genes acting on a responder, with the t complex form of the responder being relatively resistant to this harmful action of the distorters. Previous work had indicated that naturally occurring t haplotypes differed in their responders or in distorters lying near the responder, with the result that animals doubly heterozygous for two responder-carrying haplotypes transmitted these haplotypes unequally. In the present work t haplotypes could be divided into three types on the basis of their transmission when doubly heterozygous with the responder-carrying partial haplotype tlowH. The majority, t0, t6, tw1, tw2 and tw73, were transmitted equally with tlowH, a second group, including tw5 and two haplotypes derived from it, were transmitted less frequently than tlowH, and the single member of a third group, tw32, was transmitted in excess of tlowH. This last result suggests that the underlying differences are in the responder itself, rather than in the distorters. Search for differences among t haplotypes in distorters produced some equivocal results possibly resulting from effects of genetic background. In particular, results of others suggesting presence of a fourth distorter, Tcd-4, were not confirmed.     

The molecular organization of the H-2K region of two t-haplotypes: implications for the evolution of genetic diversity.

The genetic diversity between the t12 and tw5 haplotype chromosomes was studied by analyzing the molecular organization of the H-2K region. Twenty-one cosmid clones spanning over 150 kb of the H-2K region of both t-haplotypes were defined, and high resolution restriction maps were determined. Detailed comparison of the t12 and tw5 restriction maps revealed the following. (i) The H-2K regions of both t-haplotypes retain a very similar molecular organization to that reported for B10, BALB/c and AKR. The nucleotide sequence diversity estimated from restriction site polymorphism is 0.68% between the t12 and tw5 haplotypes; these two t-haplotypes are no more similar to one another than BALB/c is to AKR. (ii) Genetic recombination is strongly implicated in generating H-2 polymorphism. (iii) Genetic polymorphisms, defined as small restriction fragment size differences, are observed at multiple sites along the H-2K region. An Alu-like B2 sequence and BAM5-R homologous sequence were identified as the inserted/deleted DNA segments of two of these sites, suggesting that insertion/deletion of mobile elements is a general mechanism for generating genetic diversity.     

Genetic and Molecular Analysis of the Proximal Region of the Mouse T-Complex Using New Molecular Probes and Partial T-Haplotypes

The t-complex is located on the proximal third of chromosome 17 in the house mouse. Naturally occurring variant forms of the t-complex, known as complete t-haplotypes, are found in wild mouse populations. The t-haplotypes contain at least four nonoverlapping inversions that suppress recombination with the wild-type chromosome, and lock into strong linkage disequilibrium loci affecting normal transmission of the chromosome, male gametogenesis and embryonic development. Partial t-haplotypes derived through rare recombination between t-haplotypes and wild-type homologs have been critical in the analysis of these properties. Utilizing two new DNA probes. Au3 and Au9, and several previously described probes, we have analyzed the genetic structure of several partial t-haplotypes that have arisen in our laboratory, as well as several wild-type chromosomes deleted for loci in this region. With this approach we have been able to further our understanding of the structural and dynamic characteristics of the proximal region of the t-complex. Specifically, we have localized the D17Tul locus as most proximal known in t-haplotypes, achieved a better structural analysis of the partial t-haplotype t6, and defined the structure and lethal gene content of partial t-haplotypes derived from the lethal tw73 haplotype.     

Cis-effects on meiotic recombination across distinct a1-sh2 intervals in a common Zea genetic background

Genetic distances across the a1-sh2 interval varied threefold in three near-isogenic stocks that carry structurally distinct teosinte A1 Sh2 haplotypes (from Z. mays spp. mexicana Chalco, Z. mays spp. parviglumis, and Z. luxurians) and a common maize a1::rdt sh2 haplotype. In each haplotype >85% of recombination events resolved in the proximal 10% of the approximately 130-kb a1-sh2 interval. Even so, significant differences in the distributions of recombination breakpoints were observed across subintervals among haplotypes. Each of the three previously detected recombination hot spots was detected in at least one of the three teosinte haplotypes and two of these hot spots were not detected in at least one teosinte haplotype. Moreover, novel hot spots were detected in two teosinte haplotypes. Due to the near-isogenic nature of the three stocks, the observed variation in the distribution of recombination events is the consequence of cis-modifications. Although generally negatively correlated with rates of recombination per megabase, levels of sequence polymorphisms do not fully account for the nonrandom distribution of recombination breakpoints. This study also suggests that estimates of linkage disequilibrium must be interpreted with caution when considering whether a gene has been under selection.     

Functional Analysis of Mutations of Murine Chromosome 17 with the Use of Tertiary Trisomy

Analysis of the functional nature of mutations can be based on comparisons of their manifestation in organisms with a deletion or duplication of a particular chromosome segment. With the use of reciprocal translocation T(16;17)43H, it is feasible to produce mice with tertiary trisomy of the proximal region of chromosome 17. The mutations on chromosome 17 we tested included brachyury (T), hairpin tail (Thp), kinky (Fuki), quaking (qk), tufted (tf), as well as tct (t complex tail interaction), and tcl (t complex lethal) that are specific to t haplotypes. The set of dominant and recessive mutations was assigned to two groups: one obligatory, manifesting itself in the phenotype independently of the number of normal alleles in di- and trisomics, and the other facultative, phenotypically manifesting itself depending upon the dosage of mutant alleles. A model was derived from analysis of the interaction of the T and Thp mutations with t haplotypes. It seeks to explain the morphogenetic effects of the mutations observed in mice of different genotypes. The tir gene is postulated to reside on chromosome 17 within its framework. It is suggested that the gene dosage ratio at the tir and tct loci determines tail length.     

The in vivo and in vitro transmission ratio distortion of one complete and two partial t haplotypes in mice

The effects of different types of insemination (normal and delayed matings and in vitro fertilization) on the transmission ratio distortion (TRD) of three t haplotypes were determined. The tw73 haplotype which contains all of the loci known to affect TRD is transmitted at equivalent frequencies in normal matings and in in vitro fertilizations (0.84 and 0.85, respectively) but at a significantly lower frequency (0.62) in delayed matings. The distal partial th18 haplotype is transmitted at equivalent frequencies in all types of insemination (0.66 to 0.70) while the proximal partial tw18 haplotype is transmitted in Mendelian frequencies in normal matings and in in vitro inseminations but at a significantly lower frequency in delayed matings. The results are discussed with reference to the current genetic model for transmission ratio distortion.