Site-site communication in the EF-hand Ca2+-binding protein calbindin D9k

The cooperative binding of Ca2+ ions is an essential functional property of the EF-hand family of Ca2+-binding proteins. To understand how these proteins function, it is essential to characterize intermediate binding states in addition to the apo- and holo-proteins. The three-dimensional solution structure and fast time scale internal motional dynamics of the backbone have been determined for the half-saturated state of the N56A mutant of calbindin D9k with Ca2+ bound only in the N-terminal site. The extent of conformational reorganization and a loss of flexibility in the C-terminal EF-hand upon binding of an ion in the N-terminal EF-hand provide clear evidence of the importance of site-site interactions in this family of proteins, and demonstrates the strength of long-range effects in the cooperative EF-hand Ca2+-binding domain.     

Protein surface charges and Ca2+ binding to individual sites in calbindin D9k: stopped-flow studies

The kinetics of calcium dissociation from two groups of site-specific mutants of calbindin D9k--a protein in the calmodulin superfamily with two Ca2+ sites and a tertiary structure closely similar to that of the globular domains of troponin C and calmodulin--have been studied by stopped-flow kinetic methods, using the fluorescent calcium chelator Quin 2, and by 43Ca NMR methods. The first group of mutants comprises all possible single, double, and triple neutralizations of three particular carboxylate groups (Glu-17, Asp-19, and Glu-26) that are located on the surface of the protein. These carboxylates are close to the two EF-hand calcium binding sites, but are not directly liganded to the Ca2+ ions. Conservative modification of these negative carboxylate side chains by conversion to the corresponding amides results in a marked reduction in the Ca2+ binding constants for both sites, as recently reported [Linse et al. (1988) Nature 335, 651-652]. The stopped-flow kinetic results show that this reduction in Ca2+ affinity derives primarily from a reduction in the Ca2+ association rate constant, kon. The estimated maximum value of the association rate constant (kon(max) for Ca2+ binding to the wild-type protein is ca. 10(9) M-1 s-1. In contrast, for the mutant protein with three charges neutralized the maximum association rate constant is estimated to be only 2 X 10(7) M-1 s-1.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Biophysical studies of engineered mutant proteins based on calbindin D9k modified in the pseudo EF-hand

The genes for four mutant proteins from calbindin D9k, all with mutations in the N-terminal Ca2+-binding domain (pseudo EF-hand) have been synthesized and expressed in Escherichia coli. The purification scheme has been modified to minimize the formation of deamidated proteins. The set of modifications in the pseudo EF-hand is an attempt to turn this site into a structure resembling an archetypal EF-hand, with its characteristic 113Cd-NMR shift (-80 to -110 ppm) and high calcium-binding constants, whereas the C-terminal Ca2(+)-binding site (EF-hand) is kept intact in all mutant proteins. The mutant proteins studied here all have pseudo EF-hands with a lower calcium-binding constant and a higher calcium off-rate to the pseudo EF-hand than the wild-type protein. From the results obtained it is obvious that proline 20 in the pseudo EF-hand, which has been deleted or replaced by glycine in three of the mutants, has a stabilizing effect on calcium binding to that site. Furthermore, the modifications in the pseudo EF-hand seem to have only a local effect, leaving the tertiary structure of the protein and the calcium-binding properties of the unmodified site virtually unchanged.     

Molecular basis for co-operativity in Ca2+ binding to calbindin D9k. 1H nuclear magnetic resonance studies of (Cd2+)1-bovine calbindin D9k

The molecular basis for the co-operativity in binding of calcium ions by bovine calbindin D9k has been addressed by carrying out a comparative analysis of the solution conformation and dynamics of the apo, half saturated and fully saturated species using two-dimensional 1H nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy. Since the half saturated calcium form of the protein is not significantly populated under equilibrium conditions due to the co-operativity in binding of calcium ions, the half saturated cadmium form of the protein has been substituted for the calcium form. To verify that cadmium forms of calbindin D9k represent viable models for the calcium-bound species, the fully saturated cadmium form has been prepared and compared to the calcium-saturated protein. Virtually complete 1H resonance assignments have been obtained for both the (Cd2+)1 and the (Cd2+)2 states. Secondary structure elements and the global folding pattern were determined from nuclear Overhauser effects, backbone spin-spin coupling constants and slowly exchanging amide protons. Comparisons of the half saturated protein with the apo and calcium-saturated forms of calbindin D9k show that all three structures are highly similar. However, a change in the structural and dynamic properties of the protein does occur upon binding of the first ion; the half saturated form is found to be more similar to the calcium-saturated form than to the apo form. These results have important implications concerning the molecular basis for the co-operativity, and suggest that entropic effects associated with the protein dynamics play an important role.     

Mutation of the pseudo-EF-hand of calbindin D9k into a normal EF-hand. Biophysical studies.

The two Ca(2+)-binding sites in calbindin D9k, a protein belonging to the calmodulin superfamily of intracellular proteins, have slightly different structure. The C-terminal site (amino acids 54-65) is a normal EF-hand as in the other proteins of the calmodulin superfamily, while the N-terminal site (amino acids 14-27) contains two additional amino acids, one of which is a proline. We have constructed and studied five mutants of calbindin D9k modified in the N-terminal site. In normal EF-hand structures the first amino acid to coordinate calcium is invariantly an Asp. For this reason Ala15, is exchanged by an Asp in all mutants and the mutants also contain various other changes in this site. The mutants have been characterized by 43Ca, 113Cd and 1H NMR and by the determination of the calcium binding constants using absorption chelators. In two of the mutants (one where Ala14 is deleted, Ala15 is replaced by Asp and Pro20 is replaced by Gly, the other where, in addition, Asn21 is deleted), we find that the structure has changed considerably compared to the wild-type calbindin. The NMR results indicate that the calcium coordination has changed to mainly side-chain carboxyls, from being octahedrally coordinated by mainly back-bone carbonyls, and/or that the coordination number has decreased. The N-terminal site has thus been turned into a normal EF-hand, in which the calcium ion is coordinated by side-chain carboxyls. Furthermore, the calcium binding constants of these two mutant proteins are almost as high as in the wild-type calbindin D9k. That is, the extensive alterations in the N-terminal site have not disrupted the calcium binding ability of the proteins.     

Electrostatic contributions to the binding of Ca2+ in calbindin D9k

A set of accurate experimental data is provided for Ca2+ ion binding to calbindin D9k, a protein in the calmodulin superfamily of intracellular regulatory proteins. The study comprises both the role of protein surface charges and the effects of added electrolyte. The two macroscopic Ca2(+)-binding constants K1 and K2 are determined for the wild-type and eight mutant calbindins in 0, 0.05, 0.10, and 0.15 M KCl from titrations in the presence of Quin 2 or 5,5'-Br2BAPTA. The mutations involve replacement of surface carboxylates (of Glu17, Asp19, Glu26, and Glu60) with the corresponding amides. It is found that K1K2 may decrease by a factor of up to 2.5 x 10(5) (triple mutant in 0.15 M KCl as compared to the wild-type protein in 0 M KCl). Ca2(+)-binding constants of the individual Ca2+ sites (microscopic binding constants) have also been determined. The positive cooperativity of Ca2+ binding, previously observed at low salt concentration [Linse et al. (1987) Biochemistry 26, 6723-6735], is also present at physiological ionic strength and amounts to 5 kJ.mol-1 at 0.15 M KCl. The electrolyte concentration and some of the mutations are found to affect the cooperativity. 39K NMR studies show that K+ binds weakly to calbindin. Two-dimensional 1H NMR studies show, however, that potassium binding does not change the protein conformation, and the large effect of KCl on the Ca2+ affinity is thus of unspecific nature. Two-dimensional 1H NMR has also been used to assess the structural consequences of the mutations through assignments of the backbone NH and C alpha H resonances of six mutants.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

The dynamics of Ca2+ ions within the solvation shell of calbindin D9k

The encounter of a Ca(2+) ion with a protein and its subsequent binding to specific binding sites is an intricate process that cannot be fully elucidated from experimental observations. We have applied Molecular Dynamics to study this process with atomistic details, using Calbindin D9k (CaB) as a model protein. The simulations show that in most of the time the Ca(2+) ion spends within the Debye radius of CaB, it is being detained at the 1st and 2nd solvation shells. While being detained near the protein, the diffusion coefficient of the ion is significantly reduced. However, due to the relatively long period of detainment, the ion can scan an appreciable surface of the protein. The enhanced propagation of the ion on the surface has a functional role: significantly increasing the ability of the ion to scan the protein's surface before being dispersed to the bulk. The contribution of this mechanism to Ca(2+) binding becomes significant at low ion concentrations, where the intervals between successive encounters with the protein are getting longer. The efficiency of the surface diffusion is affected by the distribution of charges on the protein's surface. Comparison of the Ca(2+) binding dynamics in CaB and its E60D mutant reveals that in the wild type (WT) protein the carboxylate of E60 function as a preferred landing-site for the Ca(2+) arriving from the bulk, followed by delivering it to the final binding site. Replacement of the glutamate by aspartate significantly reduced the ability to transfer Ca(2+) ions from D60 to the final binding site, explaining the observed decrement in the affinity of the mutated protein to Ca(2+).     

Dissection of calbindin D9k into two Ca(2+)-binding subdomains by a combination of mutagenesis and chemical cleavage.

Calbindin D9k is a 75-residue globular protein made up of two Ca2+ binding subdomains of the EF-hand type. In order to examine the subdomains independently, a method was devised to selectively cleave the loop between them. Using site-directed mutagenesis, a unique methionine was substituted for Pro43 in the loop, thus allowing cleavage using cyanogen bromide. Agarose gel electrophoresis shows that the fragments have a high affinity for one another, although less so in the absence of calcium. 1H-NMR spectra of the fragments indicate that the structures of the heterodimers are changed little from that of the intact protein. However, the Ca2+ binding constants of the individual subdomains are several orders of magnitude lower than for the corresponding sites in the uncleaved protein.     

Structures of EF-hand Ca 2+-binding proteins: Diversity in the organization, packing and response to Ca 2+ Binding

The growing database of three-dimensional structures of EF-hand calcium-binding proteins is revealing a previously unrecognized variability in the coformations and organizations of EF-hand binding motifs. The structures of twelve different EF-hand proteins for which coordinates are publicly available are discussed and related to their respective biological and biophysical properties. The classical picture of calcium sensors and calcium signal modulators is presented, along with variants on the basic theme and new structural paradigms.© Kluwer Academic Publishers     

Disulfide bonds in homo- and heterodimers of EF-hand subdomains of calbindin D9k: stability, calcium binding, and NMR studies.

The effect of decreased protein flexibility on the stability and calcium binding properties of calbindin D9k has been addressed in studies of a disulfide bridged calbindin D9k mutant, denoted (L39C + P43M + I73C), with substitutions Leu 39-->Cys, Ile 73-->Cys, and Pro 43-->Met. Backbone 1H NMR assignments show that the disulfide bond, which forms spontaneously under air oxidation, is well accommodated. The disulfide is inserted on the opposite end of the protein molecule with respect to the calcium sites, to avoid direct interference with these sites, as confirmed by 113Cd NMR. The effect of the disulfide bond on calcium binding was assessed by titrations in the presence of a chromophoric chelator. A small but significant effect on the cooperativity was found, as well as a very modest reduction in calcium affinity. The disulfide bond increases Tm, the transition midpoint of thermal denaturation, of calcium free calbindin D9k from 85 to 95 degrees C and Cm, the urea concentration of half denaturation, from 5.3 to 8.0 M. Calbindins with one covalent bond linking the two EF-hand subdomains are equally stable regardless if the covalent link is the 43-44 peptide bond or the disulfide bond. Kinetic remixing experiments show that separated CNBr fragments of (L39C + P43M + I73C), each comprising one EF-hand, form disulfide linked homodimers. Each homodimer binds two calcium ions with positive co-operativity, and an average affinity of 10(6) M-1. Disulfide linkage dramatically increases the stability of each homodimer. For the homodimer of the C-terminal fragment Tm increases from 59 +/- 2 without covalent linkage to 91 +/- 2 degrees C with disulfide, and Cm from approximately 1.5 to 7.5 M. The overall topology of this homodimer is derived from 1H NMR assignments and a few key NOEs.     

Ca2+-binding proteins in nuclei

Nuclei isolated from skeletal muscle of 15-day-old chick embryos, adult chickens, rabbits and from rat liver contain on the average 8-18 nmol Ca2+/mg protein. Digestion of nuclei with DNAase I and RNAase at 37 degrees C for 8--12 h reduced the Ca2+ binding by more than 90%. After nuclease treatment, Ca2+-binding proteins were identified in the nonhistone chromosomal protein fractions and in the insoluble residue by equilibrium dialysis and centrifuge transport, in media of 0.1 M KCl and 1 mM MgCl2. The interaction of Ca2+-binding proteins with chromatin may be of importance in the regulation of the gene expression in response to changes in cytoplasmic and nucleoplasmic free-Ca2+ concentration.     

Structural basis for the negative allostery between Ca(2+)- and Mg(2+)-binding in the intracellular Ca(2+)-receptor calbindin D9k.

The three-dimensional structures of the magnesium- and manganese-bound forms of calbindin D9k were determined to 1.6 A and 1.9 A resolution, respectively, using X-ray crystallography. These two structures are nearly identical but deviate significantly from both the calcium bound form and the metal ion-free (apo) form. The largest structural differences are seen in the C-terminal EF-hand, and involve changes in both metal ion coordination and helix packing. The N-terminal calcium binding site is not occupied by any metal ion in the magnesium and manganese structures, and shows little structural deviation from the apo and calcium bound forms. 1H-NMR and UV spectroscopic studies at physiological ion concentrations show that the C-terminal site of the protein is significantly populated by magnesium at resting cell calcium levels, and that there is a negative allosteric interaction between magnesium and calcium binding. Calcium binding was found to occur with positive cooperativity at physiological magnesium concentration.     

Structures and metal-ion-binding properties of the Ca2+-binding helix-loop-helix EF-hand motifs

The 'EF-hand' Ca2+-binding motif plays an essential role in eukaryotic cellular signalling, and the proteins containing this motif constitute a large and functionally diverse family. The EF-hand is defined by its helix-loop-helix secondary structure as well as the ligands presented by the loop to bind the Ca2+ ion. The identity of these ligands is semi-conserved in the most common (the 'canonical') EF-hand; however, several non-canonical EF-hands exist that bind Ca2+ by a different co-ordination mechanism. EF-hands tend to occur in pairs, which form a discrete domain so that most family members have two, four or six EF-hands. This pairing also enables communication, and many EF-hands display positive co-operativity, thereby minimizing the Ca2+ signal required to reach protein saturation. The conformational effects of Ca2+ binding are varied, function-dependent and, in some cases, minimal, but can lead to the creation of a protein target interaction site or structure formation from a molten-globule apo state. EF-hand proteins exhibit various sensitivities to Ca2+, reflecting the intrinsic binding ability of the EF-hand as well as the degree of co-operativity in Ca2+ binding to paired EF-hands. Two additional factors can influence the ability of an EF-hand to bind Ca2+: selectivity over Mg2+ (a cation with very similar chemical properties to Ca2+ and with a cytoplasmic concentration several orders of magnitude higher) and interaction with a protein target. A structural approach is used in this review to examine the diversity of family members, and a biophysical perspective provides insight into the ability of the EF-hand motif to bind Ca2+ with a wide range of affinities.     

The EF-hand Ca2+-binding protein p22 plays a role in microtubule and endoplasmic reticulum organization and dynamics with distinct Ca2+-binding requirements

We have reported that p22, an N-myristoylated EF-hand Ca(2+)-binding protein, associates with microtubules and plays a role in membrane trafficking. Here, we show that p22 also associates with membranes of the early secretory pathway membranes, in particular endoplasmic reticulum (ER). On binding of Ca(2+), p22's ability to associate with membranes increases in an N-myristoylation-dependent manner, which is suggestive of a nonclassical Ca(2+)-myristoyl switch mechanism. To address the intracellular functions of p22, a digitonin-based "bulk microinjection" assay was developed to load cells with anti-p22, wild-type, or mutant p22 proteins. Antibodies against a p22 peptide induce microtubule depolymerization and ER fragmentation; this antibody-mediated effect is overcome by preincubation with the respective p22 peptide. In contrast, N-myristoylated p22 induces the formation of microtubule bundles, the accumulation of ER structures along the bundles as well as an increase in ER network formation. An N-myristoylated Ca(2+)-binding p22 mutant, which is unable to undergo Ca(2+)-mediated conformational changes, induces microtubule bundling and accumulation of ER structures along the bundles but does not increase ER network formation. Together, these data strongly suggest that p22 modulates the organization and dynamics of microtubule cytoskeleton in a Ca(2+)-independent manner and affects ER network assembly in a Ca(2+)-dependent manner.     

Identification of bovine brain Ca2+-binding proteins

In a previous communication (Waisman, D.M., Smallwood, J.I., Lafreniere, D. and Rasmussen, H. (1983) Biochem, Biophys. Res. Commun. 116, 435-441) we reported that chromatography of bovine brain 100,000 X g supernatant on diethylaminoethyl (DEAE) cellulose and analysis of resultant fractions by chelex competitive calcium binding assay, resolved three peaks of calcium binding activity. Gel permeation chromatographic analysis of each peak resolved apparent Mr 40,000 (Peak I), Mr 75,000, Mr 230,000 and Mr 420,000 (Peak II), and Mr 38,000 (Peak III). In the present communication the calcium binding proteins responsible for the calcium binding activity peaks resolved by gel permeation chromatography, have been purified and identified as caligulin, (Mr 40,000), calcineurin, (Mr 230,000) and calmodulin, (Mr 38,000). In addition, a novel calcium binding protein (Mr 48,000 by SDS PAGE) has been identified from the Mr 75,000 calcium binding activity peak.     

Functional properties of calbindin D9K mutants with exchanged Ca2+ binding sites

We have constructed three different engineered proteins based on calbindin D9K by either exchanging the two calcium binding sites within the protein or making the amino acid sequence of the two calcium binding sites identical. The individual calcium binding sites of the engineered proteins retain most of their ion binding characteristics as well as the basal structure of their Ca2+ ligand sphere in the new environment. Even the protein with its sites interchanged, a mutation involving 30 amino acids out of a total of 75, still binds calcium with an affinity as high as that of many natural EF-hand proteins.     

Site-site interactions in EF-hand calcium-binding proteins. Laser-excited europium luminescence studies of 9-kDa calbindin, the pig intestinal calcium-binding protein

Europium(III) binding to 9-kDa calbindin from pig intestines was studied by direct excitation of the 7Fo----5Do transition of the ion and by near-ultraviolet circular dichroic spectroscopy. Europium(III) binding is clearly biphasic. As with other lanthanides the C-terminal metal-binding site (site II) is filled first. The europium ion in this site gives an excitation spectrum with a single peak at 579.1 nm (peak 2). The occupation of the N-terminal site (site I) by europium gives excitation spectra that are pH-dependent and show a peak at 579.4 nm (peak 1a) at pH 5 which shifts to 578.7 nm (peak 1b) over the pH range 5-7. At pH 8.07 the fluorescence from europium in site I largely disappears because of weak binding, whereas that from site II is quenched by about 75% in spite of full occupancy of the site as shown by circular dichroic titration. There is a strong interaction between the two sites in spite of the very different affinities. The fluorescence from site II increases stoichiometrically with the addition not only of the first equivalent of europium, but also concomitantly with the fluorescence from site I upon addition of the second equivalent. Furthermore, when Eu1-calbindin is titrated with calcium the fluorescence at 579.1 nm is quenched by about 30% during the addition of one equivalent of calcium which fills site I. Subsequent titration with large excesses of calcium displaces europium from site II. The affinity of site II for europium is about 100 times that of calcium under these conditions.     

Three-dimensional solution structure of Ca(2+)-loaded porcine calbindin D9k determined by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy.

The three-dimensional solution structure of native, intact porcine calbindin D9k has been determined by distance geometry and restrained molecular dynamics calculations using distance and dihedral angle constraints obtained from 1H NMR spectroscopy. The protein has a well-defined global fold consisting of four helices oriented in a pairwise antiparallel manner such that two pairs of helix-loop-helix motifs (EF-hands) are joined by a linker segment. The two EF-hands are further coupled through a short beta-type interaction between the two Ca(2+)-binding loops. Overall, the structure is very similar to that of the highly homologous native, minor A form of bovine calbindin D9k determined by X-ray crystallography [Szebenyi, D. M. E., & Moffat, K. (1986) J. Biol. Chem. 261, 8761-8776]. A model structure built from the bovine calbindin D9k crystal structure shows several deviations larger than 2 A from the experimental distance constraints for the porcine protein. These structural differences are efficiently removed by subjecting the model structure to the experimental distance and dihedral angle constraints in a restrained molecular dynamics protocol, thereby generating a model that is very similar to the refined distance geometry derived structures. The N-terminal residues of the intact protein that are absent in the minor A form appear to be highly flexible and do not influence the structure of other regions of the protein. This result is important because it validates the conclusions drawn from the wide range of studies that have been carried out on minor A forms rather than the intact calbindin D9k.