Diversity,heterogeneity and consumer pressure in a tropical rocky intertidal community

Summary Previous studies indicated that at Taboguilla Island (Gulf of Panama), persistence of many intertidal organisms depended on holes and crevices in the rock as refuges from both vertebrate (fishes) and invertebrate (crabs, gastropods, chitons) consumers. Here, we evaluate the influences of substratum heterogeneity and consumers on patterns of diversity of sessile organisms in this habitat. Local substratum topography is highly variable, ranging from smooth to irregular surfaces. Algal crusts typically dominate all low zone rock surfaces, and most other sessile spegies (invertebrates and foliose algae) occur in holes and crevices. Number (S) and diversity (H) of sessile species is lower on homogeneous surfaces than on heterogeneous surfaces. Rate of increase in S with area sampled is positively correlated with substratum heterogeneity; number of species sampled per transect at a homogeneous site would be about 10 vs 30 to 60 on a heterogeneous site. Large fishes and crabs forage intensively over both substratum types, but cannot enter holes and crevices to eat prey. Gastropods, chitons, limpets, and small crabs feed on both substrata but vary in abundance from hole to hole. Prey mortality is thus intense and constant on open surfaces, but variable in space and time in holes and crevices. When consumers are excluded from the general rock surface, algal crusts are settled upon and overgrown by foliose algae, hydrozoans, and sessile invertebrates, particularly bivalves. Both S and H first increase, as sessile species invade and become more abundant, and then decrease as the rock oyster Chama echinata begins to outcompete other species and dominate primary space. Hence, consumers normally keep local diversity low by removing most sessile prey from open surfaces.In these experiments, a consumer pressure gradient was established by removing 0, 1, 2, 3, and all of 4 distinct groups of consumers. As predicted by the intermediate disturbance hypothesis, lowest diversity occurred at lowest (total exclusion) and highest consumer pressure (normal condition). Highest diversity occurred at intermediate consumer pressure. Unexplained variation in this relationship is probably due to quantitative and qualitative differences in consumer regime, variation among plots in substratum heterogeneity, and insufficient time for competitive dominance by Chama to be fully expressed. On a small (0.25 m²) spatial scale, consumers maintain low diversity by keeping prey scarce and causing local extinctions. On larger spatial scales, they may maintain and even produce high diversity through their interaction with substratum heterogeneity and possibly low dispersal rates of sessile species.     

Top-down and bottom-up community regulation in marine rocky intertidal habitats

Strong top-down control by consumers has been demonstrated in rocky intertidal communities around the world. In contrast, the role of bottom-up effects (nutrients and productivity), known to have important influences in terrestrial and particularly freshwater ecosystems, is poorly known in marine hard-bottom communities. Recent studies in South Africa, New England, Oregon and New Zealand suggest that bottom-up processes can have important effects on rocky intertidal community structure. A significant aspect of all of these studies was the incorporation of processes varying on larger spatial scales than previously considered (10’s to 1000’s of km). In all four regions, variation in oceanographic factors (currents, upwelling, nutrients, rates of particle flux) was associated with different magnitudes of algal and/or phytoplankton abundance, availability of particulate food, and rates of recruitment. These processes led to differences in prey abundance and growth, secondary production, consumer growth, and consumer impact on prey resources. Oceanographic conditions therefore may vary on scales that generate ecologically significant variability in populations at the bottom of the food chain, and through upward-flowing food chain effects, lead to variation in top-down trophic effects. I conclude that top-down and bottom-up processes can be important joint determinants of community structure in rocky intertidal habitats, and predict that such effects will occur generally wherever oceanographic ‘discontinuities’ lie adjacent to rocky coastlines. I further argue that increased attention by researchers and of funding agencies to such benthic–pelagic coupling would dramatically enhance our understanding of the dynamics of marine ecosystems.     

Water temperature, predation, and the neglected role of physiological rate effects in rocky intertidal communities

Ecologists and physiologists working on rocky shores have emphasizedthe effects of environmental stress on the distribution of intertidalorganisms. Although consumer stress models suggest that physicalextremes may often reduce predation and herbivory through negativeimpacts on the physiological performance of consumers, few fieldstudies have rigorously tested how environmental variation affectsfeeding rates. I review and analyze field experiments that quantifiedper capita feeding rates of a keystone predator, the sea starPisaster ochraceus, in relation to aerial heat stress, waveforces, and water temperature at three rocky intertidal siteson the Oregon coast. Predation rates during 14-day periods wereunrelated to aerial temperature, but decreased significantlywith decreasing water temperature. There was suggestive butinconclusive evidence that predation rates also declined withincreasing wave forces. Data-logger records suggested that thermalstress was rare in the wave-exposed habitats that I studied;sea star body temperatures likely reached warm levels (>24°C)on only 9 dates in 3 yr. In contrast, wind-driven upwellingregularly generated 3 to 5°C fluctuations in water temperature,and field and laboratory results suggest that such changes significantlyalter feeding rates of Pisaster. These physiological rate effects,near the center of an organism's thermal range, may not reducegrowth or fitness, and thus are distinct from the effects ofenvironmental stress. This study underscores the need to considerorganismal responses both under "normal" conditions, as wellas under extreme conditions. Examining both kinds of responsesis necessary to understand how different components of environmentalvariation regulate physiological performance and the strengthof species interactions in intertidal communities.     

中街山列岛岩相潮间带大型底栖动物的群落格局

于2006年9月和2007年7月在中街山列岛4个有居民海岛岩相潮间带设立8个断面,对大型底栖动物的群落结构进行了调查。共获得大型底栖动物34种,其中腔肠动物1种,环节动物3种,甲壳动物10种,软体动物20种。优势种有日本笠藤壶(Tetraclita japonica)、紫贻贝(Mytilus edulis)和节蝾螺(Turb articulatus)等4种。以季节和站位为因子对多样性指数进行双因素方差分析,结果表明只有夏、秋季丰富度指数(P=0.028)存在显著差异,其他指数的方差分析没有显著差异(P>0.05)。3个潮带4个岛屿共12个站位的聚类分析和MDS标序分析表明,12个群落可分为3组(Ⅰ、Ⅱ和Ⅲ组)。大型底栖动物ABC曲线分析表明底栖动物群落尚未受到干扰。     

The structure and replenishment of rocky shore intertidal communities and biogeographic comparisons

Marine scientists have made many recent advances in understanding the connections between the structure of benthic communities, replenishment of populations through dispersal processes, and interactions with the nearshore water mass. In this review, some of the themes and models relating to these processes and interactions are discussed. Benthic–pelagic coupling models are in the early stages of development, but encompass oceanic processes such as upwelling and downwelling, the transport of larvae and their arrival back to shore to settle. Most current knowledge of these processes is based on a few taxa, especially barnacles and mussels. This is discussed with reference and comparison to macroalgae, which dominate much of the intertidal zone on temperate rocky shores, and have quite different life histories, transport and settlement processes. The role of key, habitat-dominating species is discussed, particularly their early life histories, with reference to the differences in community composition, nearshore dynamics and settlement processes in different countries. Finally, some suggestions are made for future work to fill gaps in understanding about rocky shore communities.     

Factors organizing rocky intertidal communities of New England: Herbivory and predation in sheltered bays

In New England, U.S.A., shores exposed to severe wave action are dominated by the common blue mussel Mytilus edulis L. while moderately protected areas are covered with perennial algae. It is thought that algae are limited by mussels which are a superior competitor. Because the effectiveness of predators is inhibited by wave activity, it is assumed that the rate of predation, which varies across this environmental gradient, accounts for the observed distribution of mussels and algae.Shores along sheltered bays appear to be an exception to this pattern and this study addresses some of the possible causes. In New England bays, mussels and barnacles Semibalanus balanoides (L.) are the most common organisms on the solid surfaces in the lower intertidal zone. Perennial macroalgae, such as Chondrus crispas Stackhouse and Fucus vesiculosus L., are rare. The distribution and abundance of species differs from that on moderately protected shores and is similar to very exposed shores which are dominated by mussels and barnacles.Herbivory by the common periwinkle Littorina littorea (L.) limits the abundance of F. vesiculosus and indirectly affects the success of mussels. During 4 years of experimental manipulations, F. vesiculosus rarely recruited in the presence of periwinkles but dominated experimental surfaces if periwinkles were excluded. When experimental surfaces with F. vesiculosus, which had been protected from herbivory for > 1 year, were exposed to natural conditions, herbivores cleared most of the surfaces within several months. Recruitment by barnacles and mussels was higher when periwinkles were excluded. However, the effect of periwinkles on mussels was indirect; the snails reduced barnacle success and thus reduced mussel recruitment which was enhanced by the surface irregularities provided by barnacles.The occurrence of mussels in sheltered bays is not due to a lack of predators. Predators were commonly seen at all sites. Most mussels on experimental surfaces were removed <4 wk when surfaces were exposed to natural levels of predation. Experiments do not provide an explanation for the occurrence of mussels, although the enhancement of mussel recruitment by barnacles suggests that the availability of settlement sites may be important.     

Community stability: effects of limpet removal and reintroduction in a rocky intertidal community

Summary The stability of a high rocky intertidal community was assessed in a controlled field experiment in which the most common consumers, limpets, were temporarily removed. Compared to the unmanipulated plots, the exclusion plots developed greater algal abundance and altered species composition of both algae and barnacles. The community was not perturbed beyond its capacity to recover, since the community structure of the limpet-removal plots converged on the structure of the unmanipulated plots following limpet reintroduction. Different components of the community recovered at different rates, depending on whether or not the species had a size-related escape from the limpets. Algae had no size-related escape from limpets. The difference in algal abundance between manipulated and unmanipulated plots lasted less than six months after limpet reintroduction. Barnacles, however, had a size-related escape from limpets and therefore recovered more slowly. The difference in barnacle species composition between the perturbed and unperturbed plots lasted for 17 months after limpet reintroduction. The length of the limpet removal period (16 or 28 months) did not appear to affect the rate of community recovery.     

The influence of coastal upwelling on the functional structure of rocky intertidal communities

Summary Relationships between organisms at all trophic levels are influenced by the primary productivity of the ecosystem, and factors which enhance rates of primary production may modify trophic relationships and community structure. Nutrient enrichment of intertidal and nearshore waters leads to enhanced production by intertidal algae, and it was hypothesized that where rocky shores are washed by nutrient-rich upwelled waters, the intertidal communities should show a characteristic functional structure, based on the effects of enhanced primary production. Study sites were chosen on rocky shores in southern Africa, central Chile and the Canary Islands, in areas with and without coastal upwelling, and mid-shore community structure at these sites was analysed in terms of the abundance of certain functional guilds of organisms.It was found that algal cover and the biomass of herbivorous limpets supported per unit area on rocky shores were significantly greater in regions of coastal upwelling than in regions where upwelling did not occur. Ground cover by sessile filter-feeding organisms was significantly greater on shores in non-upwelled areas. However, correspondence analysis showed no functional aspect of intertidal community structure that was characteristic of coasts washed by upwelled waters. Primary reasons for this are probably the large variations in the nature of nutrient enrichment that accompanies upwelling, and in the nutrient status of non-upwelled areas. Other factors are man's exploitation of intertidal organisms and differences in the genetic origins of the intertidal species involved.     

Biogeographical patterns of rocky intertidal communities along the Pacific coast of North America

Aim Our aim in this paper is to present the first broad‐scale quantification of species abundance for rocky intertidal communities along the Pacific coast of North America. Here we examine the community‐level marine biogeographical patterns in the context of formerly described biogeographical regions, and we evaluate the combined effects of geographical distance and environmental conditions on patterns of species similarity across this region. Location Pacific coast of North America. Methods Data on the percentage cover of benthic marine organisms were collected at 67 rocky intertidal sites from south‐eastern Alaska, USA, to central Baja California Sur, Mexico. Cluster analysis and non‐metric multidimensional scaling were used to evaluate the spatial patterns of species similarity among sites relative to those of previously defined biogeographical regions. Matrices of similarity in species composition among all sites were computed and analysed with respect to geographical distance and long‐term mean sea surface temperature (SST) as a measure of environmental conditions. Results We found a high degree of spatial structure in the similarity of intertidal communities along the coast. Cluster analysis identified 13 major community structure ‘groups’. Although breaks between clusters of sites generally occurred at major biogeographical boundaries, some of the larger biogeographical regions contained several clusters of sites that did not group according to spatial position or identifiable coastal features. Additionally, there were several outliers – sites that grouped alone or with sites outside their region – for which localized features may play an important role in driving community structure. Patterns of species similarity at the large scale were highly correlated with geographical distance among sites and with SST. Importantly, we found community similarity to be highly correlated with long‐term mean SST while controlling for the effects of geographical distance. Main conclusions These findings reveal a high degree of spatial structure in the similarity of rocky intertidal communities of the north‐east Pacific, and are generally consistent with those of previously described biogeographical regions, with some notable differences. Breaks in similarity among clusters are generally coincident with known biogeographical and oceanographic discontinuities. The strong correlations between species similarity and both geographical position and SST suggest that both geography and oceanographic conditions have a large influence on patterns of intertidal community structure along the Pacific coast of North America.     

The ecology of Mytilus edulis L. in exposed rocky intertidal communities

Information is given to show that Mytilus edulis L. is an important component of exposed rocky coast communities of the Western Hemisphere. It is abundant on the exposed coast of Washington State with a potential distribution extending from + 10.6 ft ( + 3.2 m) down to at least 10 m depth: it is not continuous along this entire gradient. It dominates a band from +10.6 ft down to +9.6 ft ( + 3.2 to + 2.9 m) tidal height where it usually intergrades with its congener M. californianus Conrad. Its upper limit appears to be determined by desiccation stress and the lower probably by competition and or predation.In the mid-intertidal zone, from + 5.6 to + 9.6 ft ( + 1.7 to 2.9 m), where M. californianus is dominant, M. edulis occurs in patches of cleared space which usually form in the M. californianus bed matrix in winter months. Here, it acts as an opportunistic species by colonizing quickly and growing rapidly to reproductive size. It is preyed upon by Thais spp. which prefer it to Mytilus californianus and eventually is eliminated from these patches. It also occurs, sometimes abundantly, in tufts of the red alga Endocladia muricata (Postels & Ruprect) J. Agardh at high and mid-intertidal heights.In low intertidal and subtidal regions, to ≈ 10 m depth, Mytulis edulis can be found in refuges of filamentous or intricately arranged substrata which generally offer protection from predation. These are represented by a wide variety of forms such as hydroids. bryozoans, filamentous algae, coralline algae, and kelp with convoluted holdfasts or complex stipes.     

Effects of avian grazing on the algal community and small invertebrates in the rocky intertidal zone

In this study of a rocky intertidal habitat in northern Japan, feeding by avian consumers had significant effects on algal assemblages and small herbivorous invertebrates. The effects of the birds on algae were different from those of invertebrate grazers such as urchins and gastropods. The abundance of the dominant algal species decreased during the grazing period, increased again after the grazing period, and indirectly affected algal species richness and evenness. Avian grazing also decreased the density of tube-dwelling amphipods on the dominant alga, but did not change the density of mobile and free-living isopods. These results suggest that avian grazers may act as habitat modifiers rather than exploitative competitors for the small herbivorous crustaceans. Avian herbivores consumed only the upper parts of large algal fronds, apparently reducing the amount of suitable microhabitat for the small herbivorous crustaceans, which are subject to a variety of physical or biological stress. Thus, avian herbivores function as ecosystem engineers, regulating community structure in a manner different to invertebrate herbivores in rocky intertidal habitats.     

Response of a rocky intertidal ecosystem engineer and community dominant to climate change

To evaluate how climate change might impact a competitively dominant ecological engineer, we analysed the growth response of the mussel Mytilus californianus to climate patterns [El Niño-Southern Oscillation, Pacific Decadal Oscillation (PDO)]. Mussels grew faster during warmer climatic events. Growth was initially faster on a more productive cape compared to a less productive cape. Growth rates at the two capes merged in 2002, coincidentally with a several year-long shift from warm to cool PDO conditions. To determine the mechanism underlying this response, we examined growth responses to intertidal sea and air temperatures, phytoplankton, sea level and tide height. Together, water temperature (32%) and food (12.5%) explained 44.5% of the variance in mussel growth; contributions of other factors were not significant. In turn, water temperature and food respond to climate-driven variation in upwelling and other, unknown factors. Understanding responses of ecosystem engineers to climate change will require knowing direct thermal effects and indirect effects of factors altered by temperature change.     

The grazing effect of limpets on the macroalgal community of a rocky intertidal shore

Abstract Abundance of macro-algae in the mid-littoral zone on a Victorian intertidal rocky shore varied seasonally, algae being rare in Summer and common in Winter and Spring. Field experiments demonstrated that, of two species of grazing limpets (Cellana tramoserica and Siphonana diemenensis), only Siphonaria had a major effect on the abundance of foliose algae (e.g. Scytopsiphon lomeniarid) and neither species had a great effect on the encrusting algae (Ralfsia spp.). There was no evidence of competition for food between the two species of limpets, in contrast with results found for similar species in New South Wales.     

Tidal activity rhythms and depth distribution of rocky shore fish in an altered intertidal environment

In this note we report on changes of activity level of littoral fish and their use of different microhabitats in an altered intertidal environment, where intertidal fish are never emersed and turbulence is confined to high tides. Despite these atypical conditions, the structure of the assemblage is basically the same found in a typical rocky-shore situation. Two intertidal fish known to possess internal tidal rhythms, Lipophrys pholis and Coryphoblennius galerita, retain those rhythms in these altered conditions, and the associated social changes in L. pholis are also retained. These observations support the studies of Gibson (1971), who showed that changes in hydrostatic pressure were of prime importance in keeping the tidal rhythm entrained. The subtidal Parablennius pilicornis, on the contrary, is more active during low tide than at high tide. The hypothesis that some subtidal species are excluded from the intertidal by a turbulence-avoiding mechanism is discussed.