Genetic analysis of mutations that compensate for loss of Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I

A transposon Tn10 insertion in topA, the structural gene of Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I, behaves as an excluded marker in genetic crosses with many strains of E. coli. However, derivative strains that accept this mutant topA allele are readily selected. We show that many of these topA mutant strains contain additional mutations that compensate for the loss of DNA topoisomerase I. Genetic methods for mapping and manipulating such compensatory mutations are described. These methods include a plate-mating test for the ability of strains to accept a topA::Tn10 allele and a powerful indirect selection for transferring compensatory mutations from male strains into non-compensatory female strains. One collection of spontaneous compensatory mutants is analyzed in detail and is shown to include compensatory mutations at three distinct loci: gyrA and gyrB, the genes that encode the subunits of DNA gyrase, and a previously unidentified locus near tolC. Mutations at this third locus, referred to as toc (topoisomerase one compensatory) mutations, do not behave as point mutations in transductional crosses and do not result in lowered DNA gyrase activity. These results show that wild-type strains of E. coli require DNA topoisomerase I, and at least one class of compensatory mutations can relieve this requirement by a mechanism other than reduction of DNA gyrase activity.     

Viability of Escherichia coli topA mutants lacking DNA topoisomerase I

The viability of the topA mutants lacking DNA topoisomerase I was thought to depend on the presence of compensatory mutations in Escherichia coli but not Salmonella typhimurium or Shigella flexneri. This apparent discrepancy in topA requirements in different bacteria prompted us to reexamine the topA requirements in E. coli. We find that E. coli strains bearing topA mutations, introduced into the strains by DNA-mediated gene replacement, are viable at 37 or 42 degrees C without any compensatory mutations. These topA(-) cells exhibit cold sensitivity in their growth, however, and this cold sensitivity phenotype appears to be caused by excessive negative supercoiling of intracellular DNA. In agreement with previous results (Zhu, Q., Pongpech, P., and DiGate, R. J. (2001) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U. S. A. 98, 9766-9771), E. coli cells lacking both type IA DNA topoisomerases I and III are found to be nonviable, indicating that the two type IA enzymes share a critical cellular function.     

The genetic control of DNA supercoiling in Salmonella typhimurium

We have elucidated the genetic control of DNA supercoiling in Salmonella typhimurium. The level of superhelix density is controlled by two classes of genes. The only member of the first class is topA, the structural gene for topoisomerase I. The second class, tos, (topoisomerase one suppressor) consists of at least two genes, one of which is linked to gyrA, the structural gene for the topoisomerase subunit of DNA gyrase. Deletions of topA result in oversupercoiling of plasmid DNA. These mutations do not require the acquisition of second-site compensatory mutations to allow cell growth, in contrast to the situation in Escherichia coli. However, tos mutations, unlinked to topA, have been isolated which reduce plasmid superhelix density. We conclude that the level of DNA supercoiling in S. typhimurium is a dynamic balance between the effects of the gene products of topA (relaxation) and tos (supercoiling) which act independently of each other. Using a variety of combinations of these mutations we have constructed a series of isogenic strains, each of which has a different but precisely defined level of plasmid supercoiling; the series as a whole provides a wide range of supercoiling both above and below the wild-type level.     

Tus-mediated arrest of DNA replication in Escherichia coli is modulated by DNA supercoiling

In the absence of RecA, expression of the Tus protein of Escherichia coli is lethal when ectopic Ter sites are inserted into the chromosome in an orientation that blocks completion of chromosome replication. Using this observation as a basis for genetic selection, an extragenic suppressor of Tus-mediated arrest of DNA replication was isolated with diminished ability of Tus to halt DNA replication. Resistance to tus expression mapped to a mutation in the stop codon of the topA gene (topA869), generating an elongated topoisomerase I protein with a marked reduction in activity. Other alleles of topA with mutations in the carboxyl-terminal domain of topoisomerase I, topA10 and topA66, also rendered recA strains with blocking Ter sites insensitive to tus expression. Thus, increased negative supercoiling in the DNA of these mutants reduced the ability of Tus-Ter complexes to arrest DNA replication. The increase in superhelical density did not diminish replication arrest by disrupting Tus-Ter interactions, as Tus binding to Ter sites was essentially unaffected by the topA mutations. The topA869 mutation also relieved the requirement for recombination functions other than recA to restart replication, such as recC, ruvA and ruvC, indicating that the primary effect of the increased negative supercoiling was to interfere with Tus blockage of DNA replication. Introduction of gyrB mutations in combination with the topA869 mutation restored supercoiling density to normal values and also restored replication arrest at Ter sites, suggesting that supercoiling alone modulated Tus activity. We propose that increased negative supercoiling enhances DnaB unwinding activity, thereby reducing the duration of the Tus-DnaB interaction and leading to decreased Tus activity.     

DNA topoisomerase I mutants. Increased heterogeneity in linking number and other replicon-dependent changes in DNA supercoiling

Plasmid pBR322 DNA isolated from Salmonella typhimurium supX (topoisomerase I) mutants exhibits a novel supercoiling distribution characterized by extreme heterogeneity in linking number and the presence of highly negatively supercoiled topoisomers. The most negatively supercoiled topoisomers isolated from one supX mutant have more than twice the wild-type level of supercoiling; the distribution as a whole has a median superhelix density about 1.3 times that of wild type. Surprisingly, the supercoiling distribution of plasmid pUC9 DNA isolated from supX mutants differs from that of pBR322. Escherichia coli topoisomerase I mutants have been shown to acquire compensatory mutations that reduce bacterial chromosome supercoiling to below the wild-type level even in the absence of topoisomerase I. We find that such a compensatory mutation in an E. coli topoisomerase I deletion mutant does not reduce pBR322 DNA supercoiling to a level below that of wild type. Thus, the effects of topoisomerase mutations on supercoiling depend on the replicon.     

RNase HI overproduction is required for efficient full-length RNA synthesis in the absence of topoisomerase I in Escherichia coli

It has long been known that Escherichia coli cells deprived of topoisomerase I (topA null mutants) do not grow. Because mutations reducing DNA gyrase activity and, as a consequence, negative supercoiling, occur to compensate for the loss of topA function, it has been assumed that excessive negative supercoiling is somehow involved in the growth inhibition of topA null mutants. However, how excess negative supercoiling inhibits growth is still unknown. We have previously shown that the overproduction of RNase HI, an enzyme that degrades the RNA portion of an R-loop, can partially compensate for the growth defects because of the absence of topoisomerase I. In this article, we have studied the effects of gyrase reactivation on the physiology of actively growing topA null cells. We found that growth immediately and almost completely ceases upon gyrase reactivation, unless RNase HI is overproduced. Northern blot analysis shows that the cells have a significantly reduced ability to accumulate full-length mRNAs when RNase HI is not overproduced. Interestingly, similar phenotypes, although less severe, are also seen when bacterial cells lacking RNase HI activity are grown and treated in the same way. All together, our results suggest that excess negative supercoiling promotes the formation of R-loops, which, in turn, inhibit RNA synthesis.     

Involvement of integration host factor (IHF) in maintenance of plasmid pSC101 in Escherichia coli: mutations in the topA gene allow pSC101 replication in the absence of IHF.

Integration host factor (IHF), encoded by the himA and himD genes, is a histonelike DNA-binding protein that participates in many cellular functions in Escherichia coli, including the maintenance of plasmid pSC101. We have isolated and characterized a chromosomal mutation that compensates for the absence of IHF and allows the maintenance of wild-type pSC101 in him mutants, but does not restore IHF production. The mutation is recessive and was found to affect the gene topA, which encodes topoisomerase I, a protein that relaxes negatively supercoiled DNA and acts in concert with DNA gyrase to regulate levels of DNA supercoiling. A previously characterized topA mutation, topA10, could also compensate for the absence of IHF to allow pSC101 replication. IHF-compensating mutations affecting topA resulted in a large reduction in topoisomerase I activity, and plasmid DNA isolated from such strains was more negatively supercoiled than DNA from wild-type strains. In addition, our experiments show that both pSC101 and pBR322 plasmid DNAs isolated from him mutants were of lower superhelical density than DNA isolated from Him+ strains. A concurrent gyrB gene mutation, which reduces supercoiling, reversed the ability of topA mutations to compensate for a lack of him gene function. Together, these findings indicate that the topological state of the pSC101 plasmid profoundly influences its ability to be maintained in populations of dividing cells and suggest a model to account for the functional interactions of the him, rep, topA, and gyr gene products in pSC101 maintenance.     

DNA supercoiling in vivo

DNA topoisomerase mutants of Escherichia coli and Saccharomyces cerevisiae were used to study the topological state of intracellular DNA. In E. coli, it is shown that switching off the gene topA encoding DNA topoisomerase I leads to an increase in the degree of negative supercoiling of intracellular DNA and inhibition of the growth of the cells: a d(pCpG)16.d(pCpG)16 sequence on a plasmid is also shown to flip from a right-handed B-helical structure to a left-handed Z-helical structure in vivo when topA is switched off. In S. cerevisiae, the topological state of intracellular DNA is little affected by the cellular levels of the topoisomerases.     

Escherichia coli DNA topoisomerase I mutants have compensatory mutations in DNA gyrase genes

Escherichia coli deletion mutants lacking DNA topoisomerase I have been identified previously and shown to grow at a normal rate. We show that such strains grow normally only because of spontaneously arising mutations that compensate for the topoisomerase I defect. Several of these compensatory mutations have been found to map at or near the genes encoding DNA gyrase, gyrA and gyrB. DNA gyrase assays of crude extracts show that strains carrying the mutations have lower gyrase activity. Thus the mutations are in the gyrase structural genes or in nearby regulatory sequences. These results, in conjunction with DNA supercoiling measurements of others, indicate that in vivo DNA superhelicity is a result of a balance between topoisomerase I and gyrase activities. An excess of negative supercoils due to an absence of topoisomerase I is deleterious to the cell, but a moderate gyrase deficiency is not harmful.     

Novobiocin-dependent topA deletion mutants of Escherichia coli.

Previous reports of the transduction of topA deletions in Escherichia coli suggested that delta top A transductants grow normally only if they acquire spontaneous mutations that compensate for the topoisomerase I defect. We show that P1-mediated transduction of delta topA in the presence of sublethal concentrations of novobiocin, an inhibitor of the DNA gyrase B subunit, yields uncompensated Top- isolates which are dependent on novobiocin for optimum growth. In the absence of novobiocin these delta topA strains grow slowly, indicating that topA deletions are deleterious but not lethal to the cell. We propose that inhibitors of DNA gyrase B, presumably by lowering intracellular levels of DNA supercoiling, can phenotypically suppress a topoisomerase I defect in E. coli.     

Identification of the tip-encoded receptor in bacterial sensing.

Relaxation of titratable supercoils in bacterial nucleoids was measured following treatment of topA mutants with coumermycin or oxolinic acid, inhibitors of DNA gyrase. Relaxation occurred after treatment of the mutants with either inhibitor. We detected no significant difference in relaxation between topA- and topA+ strains treated with coumermycin. This finding, together with previous observations, supports the idea that relaxation caused by coumermycin probably arises from the relaxing activity of gyrase itself. The source of DNA relaxation caused by oxolinic acid was not identified. Nucleoid supercoiling can be increased by adding oxolinic acid to a strain that carries three topoisomerase mutations: delta topA, gyrB225, and gyrA (Nalr) (S. H. Manes, G. J. Pruss, and K. Drlica, J. Bacteriol. 155:420-423, 1983). We found that this increase in supercoiling requires partial sensitivity to the drug and at the delta topA and gyrA mutations. Full resistance to oxolinic acid in the presence of the delta topA, gyrB225, and gyrA mutations was conferred by an additional mutation that maps at or near gyrB.     

Control of bacterial DNA supercoiling

Two DNA topoisomerases control the level of negative supercoiling in bacterial cells. DNA gyrase introduces supercoils, and DNA topoisomerase I prevents supercoiling from reaching unacceptably high levels. Perturbations of supercoiling are corrected by the substrate preferences of these topoisomerases with respect to DNA topology and by changes in expression of the genes encoding the enzymes. However, supercoiling changes when the growth environment is altered in ways that also affect cellular energetics. The ratio of [ATP] to [ADP], to which gyrase is sensitive, may be involved in the response of supercoiling to growth conditions. Inside cells, supercoiling is partitioned into two components, superhelical tension and restrained supercoils. Shifts in superhelical tension elicited by nicking or by salt shock do not rapidly change the level of restrained supercoiling. However, a steady-state change in supercoiling caused by mutation of topA does alter both tension and restrained supercoils. This communication between the two compartments may play a role in the control of supercoiling.