Supercoiling in prokaryotic and eukaryotic DNA: changes in response to topological perturbation of plasmids in E. coli and SV40 in vitro, in nuclei and in CV-1 cells.

Changes in DNA linking number have been observed in plasmid DNA purified from E. coli cells after the cells were treated with chloroquine. Chloroquine, a DNA intercalating drug, unwinds the DNA, decreasing the levels of negative supercoiling. Following this in vivo topological perturbation, within minutes DNA gyrase decreases DNA linking number producing more negatively supercoiled DNA topoisomers. Following the removal of the drug from cells, within minutes topoisomerase 1 or DNA gyrase increases the linking number restoring the original level of supercoiling. Analogous changes in DNA linking number after addition of chloroquine are observed in purified plasmid DNA, and in purified SV40 minichromosomes in the presence of exogenous topoisomerase. Changes in linking number are also observed in SV40 chromosomes in isolated nuclei and in SV40 DNA purified from CV-1 cells following topological perturbation with chloroquine. These results suggest that eukaryotic cells may have mechanisms to maintain a defined level of DNA supercoiling.     

DNA topoisomerase I mutants. Increased heterogeneity in linking number and other replicon-dependent changes in DNA supercoiling

Plasmid pBR322 DNA isolated from Salmonella typhimurium supX (topoisomerase I) mutants exhibits a novel supercoiling distribution characterized by extreme heterogeneity in linking number and the presence of highly negatively supercoiled topoisomers. The most negatively supercoiled topoisomers isolated from one supX mutant have more than twice the wild-type level of supercoiling; the distribution as a whole has a median superhelix density about 1.3 times that of wild type. Surprisingly, the supercoiling distribution of plasmid pUC9 DNA isolated from supX mutants differs from that of pBR322. Escherichia coli topoisomerase I mutants have been shown to acquire compensatory mutations that reduce bacterial chromosome supercoiling to below the wild-type level even in the absence of topoisomerase I. We find that such a compensatory mutation in an E. coli topoisomerase I deletion mutant does not reduce pBR322 DNA supercoiling to a level below that of wild type. Thus, the effects of topoisomerase mutations on supercoiling depend on the replicon.     

DNA topology in hyperthermophilic archaea: reference states and their variation with growth phase, growth temperature, and temperature stresses

In order to address the dynamics of DNA topology in hyperthermophilic archaea, we analysed the topological state of several plasmids recently discovered in Thermococcales and Sulfolobales. All of these plasmids were from relaxed to highly positively super-coiled in vitro, i.e. they exhibited a significant linking excess compared to the negatively supercoiled plasmids from mesophilic organisms (both Archaea and Bacteria). In the two archaeai orders, plasmid linking number (Lk) decreased as growth temperature was lowered from its optimal value, i.e. positively super-coiled plasmids were relaxed whereas relaxed plasmids became negatively supercoiled. Growth temperatures above the optimum correlated with higher positive supercoiling in Sulfolobales (Lk increase) but with relaxation of positive supercoils in Thermococcus sp. GE31. The topological variation of plasmid DNA isolated from cells at different growth phases were found to be species specific in both archaeai orders. In contrast, the direction of topological variation under temperature stress was the same, i.e. a heat shock correlated with an increase in plasmid positive supercoiling, whilst a cold shock induced negative supercoiling. The kinetics of these effects were analysed in Sulfolobales. In both temperature upshift (from 80 to 85C) and downshift (from 80 to 65C), a transient sharp variation of Lk occurred first, and then DNA supercoiling progressively reached levels typical of steady-state growth at the final temperature. These results indicate that DNA topology can change with physiological states and environmental modifications in hyperthermophilic archaea.     

Influence of DNA supercoiling on the loss of culturability of Escherichia coli cells incubated in seawater

The relationship between the loss of culturability of Escherichia coli cells in seawater and the DNA supercoiling level of a reporter plasmid (pUC8) have been studied under different experimental conditions. Transfer to seawater of cells grown at low osmolarity decreased their ability to grow without apparent modification of the plasmid supercoiling. We found that E. coli cells could be protected against seawater-induced loss of culturability by increasing their DNA-negative supercoiling in response to environmental factors: either a growth at high osmolarity before the transfer to seawater, or addition of organic matter (50-mg/l peptone) in seawater. We further found conditions where a DNA-induced relaxation was accompanied by an increase in seawater sensitivity. Indeed, inactivation of either one of the subunits A and B of DNA gyrase, which leads to important DNA relaxation, was accompanied in both cases by an increased loss of culturability of conditional mutants after transfer to seawater which could not be explained uniquely by the increase in the temperature required to inactivate the gyrase. Similarly, a strain harbouring a mutation in topoisomerase I, compensated by another mutation in subunit B of the gyrase, was more sensitive to seawater than the isogenic wild-type cell and this greater sensitivity was correlated to a relaxation of plasmid DNA. Again, in these different cases, a previous growth at high osmolarity protected against this seawater sensitivity. We thus propose that the ability of E. coli cells to survive in seawater and maintain their ability to grow on culture media could be linked, at least in part, to the topological state of their DNA.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

In vitro DNA binding of the archaeal protein Sso7d induces negative supercoiling at temperatures typical for thermophilic growth.

The topological state of DNA in hyperthermophilic archaea appears to correspond to a linking excess in comparison with DNA in mesophilic organisms. Since DNA binding proteins often contribute to the control of DNA topology by affecting DNA geometry in the presence of DNA topoisomerases, we tested whether the histone-like protein Sso7d from the hyperthermophilic archaeon Sulfolobus solfataricus alters DNA conformation. In ligase-mediated supercoiling assays carried out at 37, 60, 70, 80 and 90 degrees C we found that DNA binding of increasing amounts of Sso7d led to a progressive decrease in plasmid linking number (Lk), producing negative supercoiling. Identical unwinding effects were observed when recombinant non-methylated Sso7d was used. For a given Sso7d concentration the DNA unwinding induced was augmented with increasing temperature. However, after correction for the overwinding effect of high temperature on DNA, plasmids ligated at 60-90 degrees C exhibited similar sigma values at the highest Sso7d concentrations assayed. These results suggest that Sso7d may play a compensatory role in vivo by counteracting the overwinding effect of high temperature on DNA. Additionally, Sso7d unwinding could be involved in the topological changes observed during thermal stress (heat and cold shock), playing an analogous role in crenarchaeal cells to that proposed for HU in bacteria.     

Plasmid curing effect of trovafloxacin

The effect of sub-inhibitory concentrations of trovafloxacin, a recently developed fluoroquinolone molecule, on the capability of Escherichia coli cells to maintain three different types of plasmids has been investigated by a number of approaches, including the quantification of the loss of plasmid-borne functions and of plasmid DNA by quantitative PCR. The results obtained demonstrate that at concentrations ranging from the MIC to 1/8 of the MIC, trovafloxacin induces a clear, albeit incomplete, 'episome-curing' effect which was observed with plasmids differing in copy number, size and nature of the replication origin of the episome. This effect was most likely not due to an alteration of DNA supercoiling.     

Influence of highly curved DNA segments on in vivo topology of plasmids

Recombinant plasmids carrying a highly curved DNA structure are sometimes unstable in Escherichia coli. In order to know the underlying mechanism, several plasmids carrying one or two highly bent DNA segment(s) from the human adenovirus type 2 (Ad2) enhancer and/or origin region of phage replication were systematically constructed and propagated in E. coli. The highly bent DNA segments disturbed the action of DNA topoisomerases: i.e. they were shown to be able to produce an anomalously wide spectrum of linking number topoisomers that tails toward lower supercoiling with a little of the DNA actually positively supercoiled. Furthermore, bent DNA caused multimeric plasmid formation. The linking number topoisomers and multimers seemed to be intermediate topological states of the bent DNA-containing plasmids that would lead to the deletion occurring in them. The nucleotide sequence of a deletion product of a bent DNA-containing plasmid showed that the putative source of the severe topological constraint was entirely eliminated from the plasmid.     

Host strain influences on supercoiled plasmid DNA production in Escherichia coli: Implications for efficient design of large-scale processes

We set out to investigate if E. coli genotype plays a significant role in host strain selection for optimal processing of plasmid DNA based on both quality and quantity of supercoiling. Firstly 17 E. coli commercial and non-commercial strains were selected and their available genetic backgrounds were researched in the open literature. Growth characteristics of all the strains were considered and made impartial by using a common medium and growth condition platform. By keeping the growth conditions constant for each strain/plasmid combination, we are only looking at one variable which is the host strain. The second step was to attempt to correlate the findings with common genotype characteristics (e.g. mutations such as endA or recA). We found that one can screen the number of strains which are likely to give good productivity early on, before any further optimisation and verification is performed, both for small and large plasmids. Also, it is worth noting that complex plasmid interactions with each strain prevent the use of genotype alone in making an intelligent choice for supercoiling optimisation. This leads to a third optimisation step selecting a few of the potentially high performing strains based on high DNA yield and supercoiling, with a view to identify the factors which need improvement in strain design and bioreactor optimisation. We found that high specific growth rates of some strains did not affect the level of DNA supercoiling but did influence the total plasmid yield, potentially an important aspect in the design of fermentation strategy. Interestingly, a few host/plasmid combinations result in what appears to be runaway plasmid replication.     

The genetic control of DNA supercoiling in Salmonella typhimurium

We have elucidated the genetic control of DNA supercoiling in Salmonella typhimurium. The level of superhelix density is controlled by two classes of genes. The only member of the first class is topA, the structural gene for topoisomerase I. The second class, tos, (topoisomerase one suppressor) consists of at least two genes, one of which is linked to gyrA, the structural gene for the topoisomerase subunit of DNA gyrase. Deletions of topA result in oversupercoiling of plasmid DNA. These mutations do not require the acquisition of second-site compensatory mutations to allow cell growth, in contrast to the situation in Escherichia coli. However, tos mutations, unlinked to topA, have been isolated which reduce plasmid superhelix density. We conclude that the level of DNA supercoiling in S. typhimurium is a dynamic balance between the effects of the gene products of topA (relaxation) and tos (supercoiling) which act independently of each other. Using a variety of combinations of these mutations we have constructed a series of isogenic strains, each of which has a different but precisely defined level of plasmid supercoiling; the series as a whole provides a wide range of supercoiling both above and below the wild-type level.     

Bacterial DNA supercoiling and [ATP]/[ADP] ratio: changes associated with salt shock.

When Escherichia coli K-12 was shifted from a medium lacking salt to one containing 0.5 M NaCl, both the [ATP]/[ADP] ratio and negative supercoiling of plasmid DNA increased within a few minutes. After about 10 min both declined, eventually reaching a level slightly above that observed with cells growing exponentially in the absence of salt. Since in vitro the [ATP]/[ADP] ratio influences the level of supercoiling generated by gyrase (H. Westerhoff, M. O'Dea, A. Maxwell, and M. Gellert, Cell Biophys. 12:157-181, 1988), the physiological response of supercoiling to salt shock is most easily explained by the sensitivity of gyrase to changes in the intracellular [ATP]/[ADP] ratio. This raises the possibility that the [ATP]/[ADP] ratio is an important factor in the control of supercoiling.     

Novobiocin induces positive supercoiling of small plasmids from halophilic archaebacteria in vivo.

The halophilic archaebacterium Halobacterium strain GRB harbours a multicopy plasmid of 1.7 kb which is negatively supercoiled. After addition of novobiocin to culture medium all 1.7 kb plasmid molecules become positively supercoiled. Positive supercoiling occurs at the same dose of novobiocin inhibiting the eubacterial DNA gyrase in vitro. Novobiocin also induces positive supercoiling of pHV2, a 6.3 kb plasmid from Halobacterium volcanii. These results indicate the existence of a mechanism producing positive superturns in halobacteria. The 1.7 kb plasmid from Halobacterium GRB could be used to produce high amounts of pure positively supercoiled DNA for biophysical and biochemical studies.     

A protein factor which reduces the negative supercoiling requirement in the Mu DNA strand transfer reaction is Escherichia coli integration host factor

We have examined the supercoiling requirement for the in vitro Mu DNA strand transfer reaction and found that optimal efficiency requires a high level (sigma = -0.06) of donor plasmid superhelicity. At in vivo levels of supercoiling (sigma = -0.025) the reaction does not occur. Using an unreactive donor plasmid with a near physiological level of supercoiling, we identified an Escherichia coli protein factor which has the novel property of reducing the donor plasmid supercoiling requirement for the in vitro Mu DNA strand transfer reaction by 40%. This protein, which we named supercoiling relief factor was purified to near homogeneity and found to be identical to integration host factor (IHF), a protein known to induce site specific bends in DNA. The dramatic reduction in the supercoiling requirement was promoted by about 1.5 IHF dimers/donor substrate molecule. At these low levels of IHF, the HU requirement for the reaction was also reduced; a synergistic effect of the two proteins resulted in a greater than 10-fold stimulation of the reaction under appropriate conditions. Furthermore, at high concentrations of IHF, HU could be completely eliminated from the reaction.     

DNA supercoiling in a thermotolerant mutant ofEscherichia coli

A spontaneously occurring, nalidixic acid-resistant (Nal^R), thermotolerant (T/r) mutant ofEscherichia coli was isolated. Bacteriophage P1-mediated transduction showed that Nal^R mapped at or neargyr A, one of the two genes encoding DNA gyrase. Expression ofgyrA ⁺ from a plasmid rendered the mutant sensitive to nalidixic acid and to high temperature, the result expected for alleles mapping ingyrA. Plasmid linking number measurements, made with DNA from cells grown at 37° C or shifted to 48° C, revealed that supercoiling was about 12% less negative in the T/r mutant than in the parental strain. Each strain preferentially expressed two different proteins at 48° C. The genetic and supercoiling data indicate that thermo-tolerance can arise from an alteration in DNA gyrase that lowers supercoiling. This eubacterial study, when. coupled with those of archaebacteria, suggests that DNA relaxation is a general aspect of thermotolerance.     

DNA supercoiling in a thermotolerant mutant ofEscherichia coli

A spontaneously occurring, nalidixic acid-resistant (Nal^R), thermotolerant (T/r) mutant ofEscherichia coli was isolated. Bacteriophage P1-mediated transduction showed that Nal^R mapped at or neargyr A, one of the two genes encoding DNA gyrase. Expression ofgyrA ⁺ from a plasmid rendered the mutant sensitive to nalidixic acid and to high temperature, the result expected for alleles mapping ingyrA. Plasmid linking number measurements, made with DNA from cells grown at 37° C or shifted to 48° C, revealed that supercoiling was about 12% less negative in the T/r mutant than in the parental strain. Each strain preferentially expressed two different proteins at 48° C. The genetic and supercoiling data indicate that thermo-tolerance can arise from an alteration in DNA gyrase that lowers supercoiling. This eubacterial study, when. coupled with those of archaebacteria, suggests that DNA relaxation is a general aspect of thermotolerance.     

Bacterial DNA supercoiling and [ATP]/[ADP]. Changes associated with a transition to anaerobic growth.

Shifting Escherichia coli from aerobic to anaerobic growth caused changes in the ratio of [ATP]/[ADP] and in negative supercoiling of chromosomal and plasmid DNA. Shortly after lowering oxygen tension, both [ATP]/[ADP] and supercoiling transiently decreased. Under conditions of exponential anaerobic growth, both were higher than under aerobic conditions. These correlations may reflect an effect of [ATP]/[ADP] on DNA gyrase, since in vitro [ATP]/[ADP] influences the level of plasmid supercoiling attained when gyrase is either introducing or removing supercoils. When the supercoiling activity of gyrase was perturbed by a mutation in gyrB, a shift to anaerobic conditions resulted in plasmid supercoil relaxation similar to that seen with wild-type. However, the low level of supercoiling in the mutant persisted during a time when supercoiling in wild-type recovered and then exceeded aerobic levels. Thus, changes in oxygen tension can alter DNA supercoiling through an effect on gyrase, and correlations exist between changes in supercoiling and changes in the intracellular ratio of [ATP]/[ADP].