INTERSPECIFIC INCOMPATIBILITY IN SOLANUM SPECIES

Pandey , K.K. (Crop Res. Div., D.S. & I.R., Lincoln, Christchurch, New Zealand.) Interspecific incompatibility in Solanum species. Amer. Jour. Bot. 49(8): 874–882. Illus. 1962.—A diallel cross involving 11 self-incompatible and 3 self-compatible species of Solanum was made to study the genetic basis of interspecific incompatibility. Interspecific incompatibility was not limited to crosses in which a self-compatible species was used as the male parent onto a self-incompatible species (unilateral incompatibility). A number of crosses between self-incompatible species were incompatible. In one cross, Q vernei X verrucosum, a self-compatible species was successful as a pollen parent with a self-incompatible species. Unlike other hybrids between self-compatible and self-incompatible species, which are self-incompatible, these F₁ hybrids were self-fertile, and cross-fertile among themselves and with both parents. The self-fertile S. polyadenium was cross-incompatible as a female as well as a male parent with all other species. It is suggested that the unilateral incompatibility is a property of the allele S_C which originated as a consequence of one kind of breakdown of the S_I gene; the S_C allele produces “bare” pollen growth substances which are inactivated in an incompatible style. It is proposed that the failure of the principle of unilateral interspecific incompatibility in solanaceous species may be due to the action of alleles at the second incompatibility locus revealed in certain Mexican species. It is assumed that the South American species are selected intraspecifically only for the action of S alleles but that in certain interspecific crosses and rarely in intraspecific crosses the alleles at the second locus may be expressed, thus interfering with the usual action of S alleles. The F₁ hybrids Q verrucosum (self-fertile) X simplicifolium (self-sterile) were self-incompatible at the tetraploid as well as the diploid level, and their cross-compatibility behavior was consistent with the expected activity of the S_C and S_I alleles of the 2 parents respectively.     

A self-compatible mutant S allele conferring a dominant negative effect on the functional S allele in Ipomoea trifida

A spontaneously occurring self-compatible mutant has been identified in Ipomoea trifida, a species possessing sporophytic self-incompatibility controlled by a single multiallelic S locus. Analysis of the segregation of compatibility/incompatibility phenotypes in selfed and crossed progenies of the self-compatible mutant plant indicated that the self-compatibility trait was caused by a mutation at the S locus; the mutated S allele was therefore designated Sc. RFLP analysis of progeny plants segregating for the Sc allele using the SSP gene (a gene linked closely to the S locus of I. trifida) as a probe confirmed that the mutation was present at the S locus. Self-incompatibility responses were examined in F₁ progenies obtained from crosses between the self-compatible mutant and self-incompatible plants homozygous for one of three S alleles, S ₁ , S ₃ and S ₂₂ , where the dominance relationship is S ₂₂ >S ₁ >S ₃ . All F₁ progeny plants from crosses with S ₂₂ and S ₁ homozygotes were self-incompatible and exhibited the respective phenotypes of each self-incompatible parent (either S ₂₂ or S ₁ ) in both stigma and pollen. However, of the F₁ progeny plants from the cross with the S ₃ homozygote, those carrying the genotype ScS ₃ were all self-compatible and cross-compatible as both female and male parents with the S ₃ homozygote. These results indicate that the dominance relationship between the four S alleles is: S ₂₂ >S ₁ >Sc>S ₃ and so reveal the unexpected finding that the mutated Sc allele is dominant over a functional S ₃ allele. A possible explanation for this observation is that the gene product encoded by the Sc allele confers a dominant negative effect on the S ₃ gene product. Received: 21 June 2000 / Accepted: 18 July 2000     

Pollen tube expression of pseudo-self-compatibility (PSC) inPetunia hybrida

Summary AnS _1.1 self-incompatible (SI) petunia plant which showed atypical seed set was found in an I₇ population. This plant showed a strong SI reaction when selfed but produced varying amounts of seed when used as the seed parent in crosses with unrelated individuals homozygous for the sameS allele. Reciprocal crosses yielded no seed indicating that the reaction was a stylar response. Self seed obtained by high temperature treatments produced 18 plants, all of which exhibited the parental characteristics, the ability to reject self pollen but accept, to varying degrees, pollen bearing the sameS allele from unrelated plants. Several petunias homozygous forS ₁, and exhibiting various levels of PSC as determined by self seed set, progeny tests and temperature treatments, were used as pollen parents. The mean seed set of these crosses produced a ranking of the pollen parents which reflected the PSC levels obtained by other methods. The behavior of the F₁ and F₂ populations suggests that the pollen discriminating ability may be a simply inherited, dominant character in these plants. The styles of these unusual petunias illustrate the participation of the pollen tube in determining PSC.Scientific Journal Series Paper Number 10.479 of the Minnesota Agricultural Experiment Station     

Genetic analysis of interspecific incompatibility in Brassica rapa

In interspecific pollination of Brassica rapa stigmas with Brassica oleracea pollen grains, pollen tubes cannot penetrate stigma tissues. This trait, called interspecific incompatibility, is similar to self-incompatibility in pollen tube behaviors of rejected pollen grains. Since some B. rapa lines have no interspecific incompatibility, genetic analysis of interspecific incompatibility was performed using two F₂ populations. Analysis with an F₂ population between an interspecific-incompatible line and a self-compatible cultivar ‘Yellow sarson’ having non-functional alleles of S-locus genes and MLPK, the stigmas of which are compatible with B. oleracea pollen grains, revealed no involvement of the S locus and MLPK in the difference of their interspecific incompatibility phenotypes. In QTL analysis of the strength of interspecific incompatibility, three peaks of LOD scores were found, but their LOD scores were as high as the threshold value, and the variance explained by each QTL was small. QTL analysis using another F₂ population derived from selected parents having the highest and lowest levels of interspecific incompatibility revealed five QTLs with high LOD scores, which did not correspond to those found in the former population. The QTL having the highest LOD score was found in linkage group A02. The effect of this QTL on interspecific incompatibility was confirmed by analyzing backcrossed progeny. Based on synteny of this QTL region with Arabidopsis thaliana chromosome 5, a possible candidate gene, which might be involved in interspecific incompatibility, is discussed.     

UNILATERAL HYBRIDIZATION IN AUREOLARIA RAF. (SCROPHULARIACEAE)

A review of the slowly accumulating data on artificial hybridization in the genus Aureolaria shows a pattern of unilateral hybridization (or unilateral incompatibility) indicative of a type of homomorphic gametophytic self-incompatibility system, involving multiple S alleles at a single locus, which has been found and genetically analyzed in plants of a few genera of both the Solanaceae and Scrophulariaceae. In such systems, if well developed, the pollen of the self-compatible (SC) plants (in this case the annual A. pedicularia) will not grow on the stigma of the self-incompatible (SI) plants (here the three perennial species of Aureolaria) but the reciprocal cross would be effective and the hybridization would thus be unilateral. The fact that some SI stigma x SC pollen crosses were successful indicates a relatively recent evolutionary age for the less strongly developed (Sc) system in A. pedicularia.     

The genetics of self-incompatibility in Brassica campestris L. ssp. Oleifera Metzg. I. Characteristics of S-locus. Control of self-incompatibility

Self-incompatibility in Brassica campestris c.v. Arlo is controlled by a single locus sporophytic system. The identity and expression of the S alleles were determined in eight inbred and two hybrid families. It was found that co-dominance of alleles is more frequent in the stigma, whereas dominance relations between pairs of alleles predominate in the pollen. A linear order of dominance was established between six S alleles and alleles high, intermediate and low in the dominance series were recognized.In considering the variation in the expression of compatibility and the segregation ratios in inbred, F₁, F₂ and backcross progenies, the presence of a specific S allele conditioning self-fertility, or a single dominant self-compatibility factor independent of the S locus could not be established. Instead, self-compatibility in this cultivar was ascribed to the segregation of a polygenic complex which is capable of modifying the incompatibility reaction to the point of self-fertility, or to a reduction in the strength of the reaction due to the presence of S alleles low in the dominance series.     

Inheritance of S(f)-RNase in Japanese apricot ( Prunus mume) and its relation to self-compatibility

Self-compatible cultivars of Japanese apricot ( Prunus mume Shieb. et Zucc.), a tree species that normally shows S-RNase-based self-incompatiblity, have a horticultural advantage over self-incompatible cultivars. Inheritance of self-compatibility and a common S(f)-RNase allele that is observed in self-compatible cultivars was investigated using progenies from controlled crosses. Total DNAs were isolated from the parents and progenies of seven crosses that included at least one self-compatible cultivar as a parent. These DNAs were PCR-amplified with the Pru-C2 and PCE-R primer pair to determine S-haplotypes of the parents and progenies. A novel S-haplotype, S(8), was found. In all crosses examined, the S(f)-RNase gene was inherited from either the seed or pollen parent as a pistil S-allele in a non-functional S-haplotype. Self-compatibility of about 20 trees each from reciprocal crosses of 'Benisashi ( S(7) S(f))' and 'Shinpeidayu ( S(3) S(f))', and 26 selections from 16 different crosses was tested by pollination and pollen-tube growth studies. Cosegregation of the S(f)-RNase allele and self-compatibility was confirmed with all but selection 1K0-26 ( S(3) S(7)). Selection 1K0-26 ( S(3) S(7)) that originated from 'Benisashi ( S(7) S(f))' x 'Koshinoume ( S(3) S(f))' appeared to be self-compatible even without the S(f)-RNase allele. The possible role of pollen- S, a presumably existing pollen component of gametophytic self-incompatibility, is discussed.     

Genetic analysis of incompatibility in the diploid Ipomoea species closely related to the sweet potato

Summary In order to identify the genotypic constitutions of incompatibility in the diploid species, Ipomoea leucantha Jacq. (K221), which is most closely related to the sweet potato, the progenies derived from the reciprocal crosses, backcrosses and testcrosses were analysed. All the plants examined were self-incompatible, and pollen germination was inhibited on the stigma after incompatible pollinations. No reciprocal differences were found in the incompatibility reactions. In the progenies three incompatibility groups were observed which showed the rather simple segregation ratios. The homozygous plants for incompatibility alleles were obtained in the progenies. The experimental results demonstrated a sporophytic type of incompatibility controlled by a single locus with multiple S-alleles exhibiting a dominance relationship in both the pollen and the stigma. The plants obtained in the progenies had the following genotypes: S ₁ S ₂, S ₁ S ₃, S ₂ S ₂, S ₂ S ₃ and S ₃ S ₃.     

Expression of the S receptor kinase in self-compatible Brassica napus cv. Westar leads to the allele-specific rejection of self-incompatible Brassica napus pollen

Expression of an S receptor kinase (SRK910) transgene in the self-compatible Brassica napus cv. Westar conferred on the transgenic pistil the ability to reject pollen from the self-incompatible Brassica napus W1 line, which carries the S910 allele. In one of the SRK transgenic lines, 1C, virtually no seeds were produced when the transgenic pistils were pollinated with W1 pollen (Mean number of seeds per pod = 1.22). This response was specific to the W1 pollen since pollen from a different self-incompatible Brassica napus line (T2) and self-pollinations were fully compatible. Westar plants expressing an S locus glycoprotein transgene (SLG910) did not show any self-incompatibility response towards W1 pollen. Transgenic Westar plants resulting from crosses between the 1C SRK transgenic line and three SLG910 transgenic lines were also tested for rejection of W1 pollen. The additional expression of the SLG910 transgene in the SRK910 transgenic plants did not cause any significant further reduction in seed production (Mean seeds/pod = 1.04) or have any detectable effects on the number of pollen grains that adhered to the pistil. Thus, while the allele-specific SLG gene was previously reported to have an enhancing effect on the self-incompatibility response, no evidence for such a role was found in this study.     

Self-compatibility in doubled haploids and their F1 hybrids,regenerated via anther culture in self-incompatible Solanum chacoense Bitt.

Summary Homozygous diploid plants originating from pollen of self-incompatible Solanum chacoense clone IP33 were analysed genetically. Among the tested individuals, two were self-compatible. As expected, all the regenerants were compatible, as pistillate parent, with the mother clone. However, three plants also displayed compatibility in the reciprocal crosses. Abnormal S-gene behaviour was observed when some androgenetic plants were intercrossed. In addition in the F₁ hybrids between doubled haploids, the S-gene did not appear to function as expected, suggesting that some changes, possibly the generation of new S-alleles, had occurred.     

Genetic and molecular analysis in Cristobalina sweet cherry,a spontaneous self-compatible mutant

Self-compatibility in a naturally self-incompatible species like sweet cherry is a highly interesting trait for breeding purposes and a powerful tool with which to investigate the basis of the self-incompatible reaction in gametophytic systems. However, natural self-compatibility in sweet cherry is a very rare phenomenon. Cristobalina is a local Spanish sweet cherry cultivar that has proven to be spontaneously self-compatible. In this work, the nature of the self-compatibility in Cristobalina has been studied using genetic and molecular approaches. Pollination studies and microscopic observations of pollen tube growth were carried out to confirm the self-compatible character and the results obtained indicate that self-compatibility is caused by a failure of the pollen and not the style factor. Polymerase chain reaction (PCR) analysis of progenies derived from Cristobalina revealed that self-compatibility in this genotype is not related uniquely to one of the two pollen S alleles, but that pollen grains carrying either of the two haplotypes can overcome the incompatibility barrier. Moreover, PCR analysis and microscopic observation of pollen tube growth in progeny derived from Cristobalina also confirmed that the self-compatible descendants can carry either of the two S haplotypes of their progenitor. Isolation and sequencing of the style S-RNases and pollen SFBs revealed that the DNA sequences of these factors are the same as those described in other self-incompatible sweet cherry cultivars with the same S alleles. Possible mechanisms to explain self-compatibility in Cristobalina are discussed.     

S RNase and Interspecific Pollen Rejection in the Genus Nicotiana: Multiple Pollen-Rejection Pathways Contribute to Unilateral Incompatibility between Self-Incompatible and Self-Compatible Species

In self-incompatible (SI) plants, the S locus acts to prevent growth of self-pollen and thus promotes outcrossing within the species. Interspecific crosses between SI and self-compatible (SC) species often show unilateral incompatibility that follows the SI x SC rule: SI species reject pollen from SC species, but the reciprocal crosses are usually compatible. The general validity of the SI x SC rule suggests a link between SI and interspecific pollen rejection; however, this link has been questioned because of a number of exceptions to the rule. To clarify the role of the S locus in interspecific pollen rejection, we transformed several Nicotiana species and hybrids with genes encoding SA2 or SC10 RNase from SI N. alata. Compatibility phenotypes in the transgenic plants were tested using pollen from three SC species showing unilateral incompatibility with N. alata. S RNase was implicated in rejecting pollen from all three species. Rejection of N. plumbaginifolia pollen was similar to S allele-specific pollen rejection, showing a requirement for both S RNase and other genetic factors from N. alata. In contrast, S RNase-dependent rejection of N. glutinosa and N. tabacum pollen proceeded without these additional factors. N. alata also rejects pollen from the latter two species through an S RNase-independent mechanism. Our results implicate the S locus in all three systems, but it is clear that multiple mechanisms contribute to interspecific pollen rejection.     

POLLEN TUBE GROWTH AND INCOMPATIBILITY FOLLOWING INTRA- AND INTER-SPECIFIC POLLINATIONS IN LILIUM LONGIFLORUM

The growth of pollen tubes of a sampling of Lilium species in styles of L. longiflorum incubated at 24 C for 48 hr after pollination indicated two types of interspecific incompatibility. Pollen tubes of two self-compatible species of section Leucolirion, the section including L. longiflorum, stopped growth abruptly upon reaching the stylar canal, were of abnormal morphology, and were incapable of continued growth with longer incubation. Pollen tubes of self-compatible or self-incompatible species of sections Sinomartagon, Pseudolirium, Liriotypus, and Daurolirion approached but did not exceed the length of intraspecific incompatible pollen tubes in styles of L. longiflorum. Pollen tube morphology was normal and tubes were capable of continued growth with additional incubation. Unilateral interspecific incompatibility occurred in reciprocal crosses between self-incompatible L. longiflorum and self-compatible L. regale and L. formosanum, but exceptions occurred in Aurelian hybrids. Incubation of interspecifically pollinated L. longiflorum styles at 39 C, which removes the self-incompatibility reaction, had no effect on interspecific incompatibility.     

Unilateral incompatibility in Capsicum (Solanaceae): occurrence and taxonomic distribution

BACKGROUND AND AIMS: Unilateral incompatibility (UI) occurs when pollinations between species are successful in one direction but not in the other. Self-incompatible (SI) species frequently show UI with genetically related, self-compatible (SC) species, as pollen of SI species is compatible on the SC pistil, but not vice versa. Many examples of unilateral incompatibility, and all those which have been studied most intensively, are found in the Solanaceae, particularly Lycopersicon, Solanum, Nicotiana and Petunia. The genus Capsicum is evolutionarily somewhat distant from Lycopersicon and Solanum and even further removed from Nicotiana and Petunia. Unilateral incompatibility has also been reported in Capsicum; however, this is the first comprehensive study of crosses between all readily available species in the genus. METHODS: All readily available (wild and domesticated) species in the genus are used as plant material, including the three genera from the Capsicum pubescens complex plus eight other species. Pollinations were made on pot-grown plants in a glasshouse. The number of pistils pollinated per cross varied (from five to 40 pistils per plant), depending on the numbers of flowers available. Pistils were collected 24 h after pollination and fixed for 3-24 h. After staining, pistils were mounted in a drop of stain, squashed gently under a cover slip and examined microscopically under ultra-violet light for pollen tube growth. KEY RESULTS: Unilateral incompatibility is confirmed in the C. pubescens complex. Its direction conforms to that predominant in the Solanaceae and other families, i.e. pistils of self-incompatible species, or self-compatible taxa closely related to self-incompatible species, inhibit pollen tubes of self-compatible species. CONCLUSIONS: Unilateral incompatibility in Capsicum does not seem to have arisen to prevent introgression of self-compatibility into self-incompatible taxa, but as a by-product of divergence of the C. pubescens complex from the remainder of the genus.     

Inbreeding depression in self-incompatible and self-compatible populations of Leavenworthia alabamica

Inbreeding depression is one of the leading factors preventing the evolution of self-fertilization in plants. In populations where self-fertilization evolves, theory suggests that natural selection against partially recessive deleterious alleles will reduce inbreeding depression. The purpose of this study was to evaluate this hypothesis by comparing the magnitude of inbreeding depression in self-incompatible and self-compatible populations of Leavenworthia alabamica. Within-population crosses were conducted to compare the quantity and quality of offspring produced by outcrossing and self-fertilization. These progeny were grown in a common greenhouse and inbreeding depression was measured in germination, survival, biomass, transition rate to flowering, flower number, petal length, pollen grains/anther, pollen viability, and ovule number. In comparison to outcrossing, self-fertilization led to the production of fewer and smaller seeds within self-incompatible populations. Moreover, inbreeding depression was observed in eight of 11 offspring traits within self-incompatible populations of L. alabamica. In contrast, there was significant inbreeding depression only in flower number within self-compatible populations. The results of this study are consistent with the idea that self-fertilization selectively removes partially recessive deleterious alleles causing inbreeding depression in natural plant populations. However, in plant species such as L. alabamica where self-compatibility may evolve in small populations following long-distance dispersal, declines in inbreeding depression may also be facilitated by genetic drift.     

A stylar ribonuclease assay to detect self-compatible seedlings in almond progenies

Six almond progenies, each the product of a cross between a self-compatible and a self-incompatible parent, were analysed for stylar ribonucleases. Proteins were extracted and separated using non-equilibrium pH gradient electrofocusing (NEPHGE), and the gels were stained for ribonuclease activity. Most seedlings showed either two principal bands, interpreted as corresponding to two incompatibility alleles, or a single band. The seedlings were also bagged in the field at flowering time to determine fruit set after selfing, and some were also examined for the growth of pollen-tubes in selfed styles using UV fluorescence microscopy. With very few exceptions, those seedlings showing single-banded zymograms were found to be self-compatible according to field and microscope studies, and those with two bands were found to be self-incompatible. We conclude that the allele for self-compatibility in almond does not code for ribonuclease activity and that the ribonuclease isoenzyme assay is a convenient technique for predicting self-compatibility in segregating progenies. A novel band in two derivatives of ’Ferrastar’ was ascribed to a new incompatibility allele, S ₁₀ . Received: 19 January 1999 / Accepted: 30 January 1999     

Divergent mating systems and parental conflict as a barrier to hybridization in flowering plants

Parental conflicts can lead to antagonistic coevolution of the sexes and of parental genomes. Within a population, the resulting antagonistic effects should balance, but crosses between populations can reveal conflict. Parental conflict is less intense in self-pollinating plants than in outcrossers because outcrossing plants are pollinated by multiple pollen donors unrelated to the seed parent, while a self-pollinating plant is primarily pollinated by one individual (itself). Therefore, in crosses between plants with differing mating systems, outcrossing parents are expected to "overpower" selfing parents. We call this the weak inbreeder/strong outbreeder (WISO) hypothesis. Prezygotically, such overpowering can alter pollination success, and we argue that our hypothesis explains a common pattern of unilateral incompatibility, in which pollen from self-incompatible populations fertilizes ovules of self-compatible individuals but the reciprocal cross fails. A postzygotic manifestation of overpowering is aberrant seed development due to parent-of-origin effects such as genomic imprinting. We evaluate evidence for the WISO hypothesis by reviewing published accounts of crosses between plants of different mating systems. Many, but not all, of such reports support our hypothesis. Since parental conflicts can perturb fertilization and development, such conflicts may strengthen reproductive barriers between populations, contributing to speciation.     

Self-incompatibility in passionfruit: evidence of gametophytic-sporophytic control

Self-incompatibility in passionfruit was studied in families originated from crosses among plants that presented differences in reciprocal crosses. The three families, obtained by crossing S(3) plants, exhibited one incompatible group; no reciprocal differences were observed. The phenotype of the families was the same as the parent plants, S(3). These results suggest the presence of a gene ( G), gametophytic in its action, associated to the sporophytic gene S, modifying the incompatibility reaction in passionfruit. The reciprocal difference exhibited in the crosses among the parents could be explained as a matching between plants homozygous for S, but homozygous and heterozygous for G. Actually this would be a partially compatible cross, not detectable when the evaluation is done based on fruit set data. As the family originated from this kind of cross is homozygous for S and heterozygous for G, no reciprocal differences are expected, and the phenotype should be the same as the parental plants, as observed in the present work.     

Genetics of self incompatibility in diploid Ageratum houstonianum mill

Summary Diallels and backcrosses among self-incompatible (SI) clones and progeny of Ageratum houstonianum Mill. could be organized into intra-incompatible classes. Four of 5 progenies segregated in expected ratios of S genotypes. Ageratum expressed a one-locus incompatibility system of the sporophytic type with a linear dominance series of multiple alleles and complete allelic dominance in both pollen and stigma. In the second part of the study, a high percentage of self-seed set was observed during the first flowering of a progeny from a pseudo-self compatible (PSC) seed source. Six progenies were derived from the PSC seed source. Five of the 6 segregated PSC SI plants, 4 of which fit a 3 1 ratio of PSC SI plants. All plants of the sixth progeny were SI. Two F₁ progenies with the same PSC pollen parent produced significantly different segregations of PSC SI plants. It appeared that PSC acted as a major gene when the most recessive S allele was also present, but PSC was not expressed when the most dominant S allele was present. Clones propagated from PSC plants were SI and cross incompatible with a related S-allele tester. Thus, PSC was transient in that it was apparent in seed-propagated plants but not in plants clonally propagated from the PSC individuals.Scientific Journal Series Paper Number 12,299 of the Minnesota Agricultural Experiment Station     

Unilateral incompatibility within the brassicaceae: further evidence for the involvement of the self-incompatibility (S)-locus

Unilateral pollen-pistil incompatibility within the Brassicaceae has been re-examined in a series of interspecific and intergeneric crosses using 13 self-compatible (SC, Sc) species and 12 self-incompatible (SI) species from ten tribes. SC x SC crosses were usually compatible, SI x SC crosses showed unilateral incompatibility, while SI x SI crosses were often incompatible or unilaterally incompatible. Unilateral incompatibility (UI) is shown to be overcome by bud pollination or treating stigmas with cycloheximide — features in common with self-incompatibility. Treating stigmas with pronase prevents pollen tubes from penetrating the stigma in normally compatible intra-and interspecific pollinations. The results presented show that the presence of an incompatibility system is important in predicting the outcome of interspecific and intergeneric crosses and, combined with the physiological similarities between UI and SI, would suggest an involvement of the S-locus in UI.