Cation-specific structural accommodation within a catalytic RNA

Metal ions facilitate the folding of the hairpin ribozyme but do not participate directly in catalysis. The metal complex cobalt(III) hexaammine supports folding and activity of the ribozyme and also mediates specific internucleotide photocrosslinks, several of which retain catalytic ability. These crosslinks imply that the active core structure organized by [Co(NH3)6]3+ is different from that organized by Mg2+ and that revealed in the crystal structure [Rupert, P. B., and Ferre-D'Amare, A. R. (2001) Nature 410, 780-786] (1). Residues U+2 and C+3 of the substrate, in particular, adopt different conformations in [Co(NH3)6]3+. U+2 is bulged out of loop A and stacked on residue G36, whereas the nucleotide at position +3 is stacked on G8, a nucleobase crucial for catalysis. Cleavage kinetics performed with +2 variants and a C+3 U variant correlate with the crosslinking observations. Variants that decreased cleavage rates in magnesium up to 70-fold showed only subtle decreases or even increases in observed rates when assayed in [Co(NH3)6]3+. Here, we propose a model of the [Co(NH3)6]3+-mediated catalytic core generated by MC-SYM that is consistent with these data.     

The folding of the hairpin ribozyme: dependence on the loops and the junction

In its natural context, the hairpin ribozyme is constructed around a four-way helical junction. This presents the two loops that interact to form the active site on adjacent arms, requiring rotation into an antiparallel structure to bring them into proximity. In the present study we have compared the folding of this form of the ribozyme and subspecies lacking either the loops or the helical junction using fluorescence resonance energy transfer. The complete ribozyme as a four-way junction folds into an antiparallel structure by the cooperative binding of magnesium ions, requiring 20-40 microM for half-maximal extent of folding ([Mg2+]1/2) and a Hill coefficient n = 2. The isolated junction (lacking the loops) also folds into a corresponding antiparallel structure, but does so noncooperatively (n = 1) at a higher magnesium ion concentration ([Mg2+]1/2 = 3 mM). Introduction of a G + 1A mutation into loop A of the ribozyme results in a species with very similar folding to the simple junction, and complete loss of ribozyme activity. Removal of the junction from the ribozyme, replacing it either with a strand break (serving as a hinge) or a GC5 bulge, results in greatly impaired folding, with [Mg2+]1/2 > 20 mM. The results indicate that the natural form of the ribozyme undergoes ion-induced folding by the cooperative formation of an antiparallel junction and loop-loop interaction to generate the active form of the ribozyme. The four-way junction thus provides a scaffold in the natural RNA that facilitates the folding of the ribozyme into the active form.     

Design of hairpin ribozyme variants with improved activity for poorly processed substrates

Application of ribozymes for knockdown of RNA targets requires the identification of suitable target sites according to the consensus sequence. For the hairpin ribozyme, this was originally defined as Y?2 N?1 *G+1 U+2 Y+3 B+?, with Y = U or C, and B = U, C or G, and C being the preferred nucleobase at positions -2 and +4. In the context of development of ribozymes for destruction of an oncogenic mRNA, we have designed ribozyme variants that efficiently process RNA substrates at U?2 G?1 *G+1 U+2 A+3 A+? sites. Substrates with G?1 *G+1 U+2 A+3 sites were previously shown to be processed by the wild-type hairpin ribozyme. However, our study demonstrates that, in the specific sequence context of the substrate studied herein, compensatory base changes in the ribozyme improve activity for cleavage (eight-fold) and ligation (100-fold). In particular, we show that A+3 and A+? are well tolerated if compensatory mutations are made at positions 6 and 7 of the ribozyme strand. Adenine at position +4 is neutralized by G? →U, owing to restoration of a Watson-Crick base pair in helix 1. In this ribozyme-substrate complex, adenine at position +3 is also tolerated, with a slightly decreased cleavage rate. Additional substitution of A? with uracil doubled the cleavage rate and restored ligation, which was lost in variants with A?, C? and G?. The ability to cleave, in conjunction with the inability to ligate RNA, makes these ribozyme variants particularly suitable candidates for RNA destruction.     

Thermodynamics of ion-induced RNA folding in the hammerhead ribozyme: an isothermal titration calorimetric study

The hammerhead ribozyme undergoes a well-defined two-stage conformational folding process, induced by the binding of magnesium ions. In this study, we have used isothermal titration calorimetry to analyze the thermodynamics of magnesium binding and magnesium ion-induced folding of the ribozyme. Binding to the natural sequence ribozyme is strongly exothermic and can be analyzed in terms of sequential interaction at two sites with association constants K(A) = 480 and 2840 M(-1). Sequence variants of the hammerhead RNA give very different isothermal titration curves. An A14G variant that cannot undergo ion-induced folding exhibits endothermic binding. By contrast, a deoxyribose G5 variant that can undergo only the first of the two folding transitions gives a complex titration curve. However, despite these differences the ITC data for all three species can be analyzed in terms of the sequential binding of magnesium ions at two sites. While the binding affinities are all in the region of 10(3) M(-1), corresponding to free energies of Delta G degrees = -3.5 to -4 kcal mol(-1), the enthalpic and entropic contributions show much greater variation. The ITC experiments are in good agreement with earlier conformational studies of the folding of the ion-induced folding of the hammerhead ribozyme.     

Folding of the natural hammerhead ribozyme is enhanced by interaction of auxiliary elements

It has been shown that the activity of the hammerhead ribozyme at microM magnesium ion concentrations is markedly increased by the inclusion of loops in helices I and II. We have studied the effect of such loops on the magnesium ion-induced folding of the ribozyme, using fluorescence resonance energy transfer. We find that with the loops in place, folding into the active conformation occurs in a single step, in the microM range of magnesium ion concentration. Disruption of the loop-loop interaction leads to a reversion to two-step folding, with the second stage requiring mM concentrations of magnesium ion. Sodium ions also promote the folding of the natural form of the ribozyme at high concentrations, but the folding occurs as a two-stage process. The loops clearly act as important auxiliary elements in the function of the ribozyme, permitting folding to occur efficiently under physiological conditions.     

Structural basis for the guanosine requirement of the hairpin ribozyme

To form a catalytically active complex, the essential nucleotides of the hairpin ribozyme, embedded within the internal loops of the two domains, must interact with one another. Little is known about the nature of these essential interdomain interactions. In the work presented here, we have used recent topographical constraints and other biochemical data in conjunction with molecular modeling (constraint-satisfaction program MC-SYM) to generate testable models of interdomain interactions. Visual analysis of the generated models has revealed a potential interdomain base pair between the conserved guanosine immediately downstream of the reactive phosphodiester (G(+1)) and C(25) within the large domain. We have tested this former model through activity assays, using all 16 combinations of bases at positions +1 and 25. When the standard ribozyme was used, catalytic activity was severely suppressed with substrates containing U(+1), C(+1), or A(+1). Similarly, mutations of the putative pairing partner (C(25) to A(25) or G(25)) reduce activity by several orders of magnitude. The U(25) substitution retains a significant level of activity, consistent with the possible formation of a G.U wobble pair. Strikingly, when combinations of Watson-Crick (or wobble) base pairs were introduced in these positions, catalytic activity was restored, strongly suggesting the existence of the proposed interaction. These results provide a structural basis for the guanosine requirement of this ribozyme and indicate that the hairpin ribozyme can now be engineered to cleave a wider range of RNA sequences.     

Mutational inhibition of ligation in the hairpin ribozyme: substitutions of conserved nucleobases A9 and A10 destabilize tertiary structure and selectively promote cleavage

The hairpin ribozyme acts as a reversible, site-specific endoribonuclease that ligates much more rapidly than it cleaves cognate substrate. While the reaction pathway for ligation is the reversal of cleavage, little is known about the atomic and electrostatic details of the two processes. Here, we report the functional consequences of molecular substitutions of A9 and A10, two highly conserved nucleobases located adjacent to the hairpin ribozyme active site, using G, C, U, 2-aminopurine, 2,6-diaminopurine, purine, and inosine. Cleavage and ligation kinetics were analyzed, tertiary folding was monitored by hydroxyl radical footprinting, and interdomain docking was studied by native gel electrophoresis. We determined that nucleobase substitutions that exhibit significant levels of interference with tertiary folding and interdomain docking have relatively large inhibitory effects on ligation rates while showing little inhibition of cleavage. Indeed, one variant, A10G, showed a fivefold enhancement of cleavage rate and no detectable ligation, and we suggest that this property may be uniquely well suited to intracellular targeted RNA cleavage applications. Results support a model in which formation of a kinetically stable tertiary structure is essential for ligation of the hairpin ribozyme, but is not necessary for cleavage.     

Investigation of the proposed interdomain ribose zipper in hairpin ribozyme cleavage using 2'-modified nucleosides

The hairpin ribozyme achieves catalytic cleavage through interaction of essential nucleotides located in two distinct helical domains that include internal loops. Initial docking of the two domains is ion dependent and appears to be followed by a structural rearrangement that allows the ribozyme to achieve a catalytically active state that can undergo cleavage. The proposed structural rearrangement may also be ion dependent and is now of increased importance due to recent evidence that docking is not rate limiting and that metal ions are unlikely to be involved in the chemical cleavage step. An initial structural model of the docked hairpin ribozyme included a proposal for a ribose zipper motif that involves two pairs of hydroxyl groups at A(10) and G(11) in domain A pairing with C(25) and A(24) in domain B, respectively. We have used a chemical functional group substitution technique to study whether this proposed ribose zipper is likely to be present in the active, conformationally rearranged ribozyme that is fit for cleavage. We have chemically synthesized a series of individually modified hairpin ribozymes containing 2'-analogues of nucleosides, that include 2'-deoxy and 2'-deoxy-2'-fluoro at each of the four nucleoside positions, 2'-amino-2'-deoxy, 2'-deoxy-2'-thio, and 2'-arabino at position C(25), and 2'-oxyamino at position A(10), as well as some double substitutions, and we studied their cleavage rates under both single- and multiple-turnover conditions. We conclude that at least some of the hydrogen-bonding interactions in the ribose zipper motif, either as originally proposed or in a recently suggested structural variation, are unlikely to be present in the active rearranged form of the ribozyme that undergoes cleavage. Instead, we provide strong evidence for a very precise conformational positioning for the residue C(25) in the active hairpin. A precise conformational requirement would be expected for C(25) if it rearranges to form a base-triple with A(9) and the essential residue neighboring the cleavage site G(+1), as recently proposed by another laboratory. Our results provide further support for conformational rearrangement as an important step in hairpin ribozyme cleavage.     

The role of magnesium ions and 2'-hydroxyl groups in the VS ribozyme-substrate interaction

The minimal substrate of the trans-cleaving Neurospora VS ribozyme has a stem-loop structure and interacts with the ribozyme by RNA tertiary interactions that remain only partially defined. The magnesium ion dependence of the catalytic parameters of a trans-cleaving VS-derived ribozyme were studied. The turnover number of the catalytic RNA was found to depend on the binding of at least three magnesium ions, with an apparent magnesium ion dissociation constant of 16mM, but K(M) was observed to be metal ion independent in the millimolar range. To address the role of 2'-hydroxyl groups of the VS substrate RNA in interactions with the ribozyme, 23 altered substrates, each with a single 2'-deoxyribonucleoside substitution, were synthesised and their kinetic properties in the VS ribozyme reaction were analysed. The removal of five 2'-hydroxyl groups, at positions G620, A621, U628, C629 and G630 inhibited the reaction, whereas at two sites, G623 and A639, reaction was stimulated by the modification. Substitution of G620 with a 2'-deoxynucleoside was expected to inhibit the reaction, in line with the critical role of this 2'-hydroxyl group in the transesterification reaction. Altered substrates in which a 2'-O-methyl nucleoside replaced A621, U628, C629 and G630 were prepared and characterised. Although removal of the hydroxyl group of A621 inhibited the turnover number of the ribozyme significantly, this activity was recovered upon 2'-O-methyl adenosine substitution, suggesting that the 2'-oxygen atom of this nucleoside forms an important contact within the ribozyme active site. A cluster of residues within the loop region of the substrate, were more modestly affected by 2'-deoxynucleoside substitution. In two cases, magnesium binding was impaired, suggesting that stem-loop I is a possible magnesium ion binding site.     

Essential nucleotide sequences and secondary structure elements of the hairpin ribozyme.

In vitro selection experiments have been used to isolate active variants of the 50 nt hairpin catalytic RNA motif following randomization of individual ribozyme domains and intensive mutagenesis of the ribozyme-substrate complex. Active and inactive variants were characterized by sequencing, analysis of RNA cleavage activity in cis and in trans, and by substrate binding studies. Results precisely define base-pairing requirements for ribozyme helices 3 and 4, and identify eight essential nucleotides (G8, A9, A10, G21, A22, A23, A24 and C25) within the catalytic core of the ribozyme. Activity and substrate binding assays show that point mutations at these eight sites eliminate cleavage activity but do not significantly decrease substrate binding, demonstrating that these bases contribute to catalytic function. The mutation U39C has been isolated from different selection experiments as a second-site suppressor of the down mutants G21U and A43G. Assays of the U39C mutation in the wild-type ribozyme and in a variety of mutant backgrounds show that this variant is a general up mutation. Results from selection experiments involving populations totaling more than 10(10) variants are summarized, and consensus sequences including 16 essential nucleotides and a secondary structure model of four short helices, encompassing 18 bp for the ribozyme-substrate complex are derived.     

The influence of junction conformation on RNA cleavage by the hairpin ribozyme in its natural junction form

In the natural form of the hairpin ribozyme the two loop-carrying duplexes that comprise the majority of essential bases for activity form two adjacent helical arms of a four-way RNA junction. In the present work we have manipulated the sequence around the junction in a way known to perturb the global folding properties. We find that replacement of the junction by a different sequence that has the same conformational properties as the natural sequence gives closely similar reaction rate and Arrhenius activation energy for the substrate cleavage reaction. By comparison, rotation of the natural sequence in order to alter the three-dimensional folding of the ribozyme leads to a tenfold reduction in the kinetics of cleavage. Replacement with the U1 four-way junction that is resistant to rotation into the antiparallel structure required to allow interaction between the loops also gives a tenfold reduction in cleavage rate. The results indicate that the conformation of the junction has a major influence on the catalytic activity of the ribozyme. The results are all consistent with a role for the junction in the provision of a framework by which the loops are presented for interaction in order to create the active form of the ribozyme.     

In vitro selection of second site revertants analysis of the hairpin ribozyme active site

We have used in vitro genetics to evaluate the function and interactions of the conserved base G8 in the hairpin ribozyme catalytic RNA. Second site revertant selection for a G8X mutant, where X is any of the other three natural nucleobases, yielded a family of second site suppressors of the G8U mutant, but not of G8C or G8A, indicating that only G and U can be tolerated at position 8 of the ribozyme. This result is consistent with recent observations that point to the functional importance of G8 N-1 in the chemistry of catalysis by this ribozyme reaction. Suppression of the G8U mutation was observed when changes were made directly across loop A from the mutated base at substrate position +2 or positions +2 and +3 in combination. The same changes made in the context of the natural G8 sequence resulted in a very large drop in activity. Thus, the G8U mutation results in a change in specificity of the ribozyme from 5'-N / GUC-3' to 5'-N / GCU-3'. The results presented imply that G8 interacts directly with U+2 during catalysis. We propose that this interaction favors the correct positioning of the catalytic determinants of G8. The implications for the folding of the ribozyme and the catalytic mechanism are discussed.     

Solvent protection of the hammerhead ribozyme in the ground state: evidence for a cation-assisted conformational change leading to catalysis

Tertiary folding of the hammerhead ribozyme has been analyzed by hydroxyl radical footprinting. Three hammerhead constructs with distinct noncore sequences, connectivities, and catalytic properties show identical protection patterns, in which conserved core residues (G5, A6, U7, G8, and A9) and the cleavage site (C17, G1.1, and U1.2) become reproducibly protected from nucleolytic attack by radicals. Metal ion titrations show that all protections appear together, suggesting a single folding event to a common tertiary structure, rather than an ensemble of different folds. The apparent binding constants for folding and catalysis by Mg(2+) are lower than those for Li(+) by 3 orders of magnitude, but in each case the protected sites are identical. For both Mg(2+) and Li(+), the ribozyme folds into the protected tertiary structure at significantly lower cation concentrations than those required for cleavage. The sites of protection include all of the sites of reduced solvent accessibility calculated from two different crystal structures, including both core and noncore nucleotides. In addition, experimentally observed protected sites include additional sequences adjacent to those predicted by the crystal structures, suggesting that the solution structure may be folded into a more compact shape. A 2'-deoxy substitution at G5 abolishes all protection, indicating that the 2'-OH is essential for folding. Together, these results support a model in which low concentrations of metal ions fold the ribozyme into a stable ground state tertiary structure that is similar to the crystallographic structures, and higher concentrations of metal ions support a transient conformational change into the transition state for catalysis. These data do not themselves address the issue as to whether a large- or small-scale conformational change is required for catalysis.     

Nucleotide analog interference mapping of the hairpin ribozyme: implications for secondary and tertiary structure formation.

The hairpin ribozyme is a small, naturally occurring RNA capable of folding into a distinct three-dimensional structure and catalyzing a specific phosphodiester transfer reaction. We have adapted a high throughput screening procedure entitled nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) to identify functional groups important for proper folding and catalysis of this ribozyme. A total of 18 phosphorothioate-tagged nucleotide analogs were used to determine the contribution made by individual ribose 2'-OH and purine functional groups to the hairpin ribozyme ligation reaction. Substitution with 2'-deoxy-nucleotide analogs disrupted activity at six sites within the ribozyme, and a unique interference pattern was observed at each of the 11 conserved purine nucleotides. In most cases where such information is available, the NAIM data agree with the previously reported single-site substitution results. The interference patterns are interpreted in comparison to the isolated loop A and loop B NMR structures and a model of the intact ribozyme. These data provide biochemical evidence in support of many, but not all, of the non-canonical base-pairs observed by NMR in each loop, and identify the functional groups most likely to participate in the tertiary interface between loop A and loop B. These groups include the 2'-OH groups of A10, G11, U12, C25, and A38, the exocyclic amine of G11, and the minor groove edge of A9 and A24. The data also predict non-A form sugar pucker geometry at U39 and U41. Based upon these results, a revised model for the loop A tertiary interaction with loop B is proposed. This work defines the chemical basis of purine nucleotide conservation in the hairpin ribozyme, and provides a basis for the design and interpretation of interference suppression experiments.     

A guanine nucleobase important for catalysis by the VS ribozyme

A guanine (G638) within the substrate loop of the VS ribozyme plays a critical role in the cleavage reaction. Replacement by any other nucleotide results in severe impairment of cleavage, yet folding of the substrate is not perturbed, and the variant substrates bind the ribozyme with similar affinity, acting as competitive inhibitors. Functional group substitution shows that the imino proton on the N1 is critical, suggesting a possible role in general acid-base catalysis, and this in accord with the pH dependence of the reaction rate for the natural and modified substrates. We propose a chemical mechanism for the ribozyme that involves general acid-base catalysis by the combination of the nucleobases of guanine 638 and adenine 756. This is closely similar to the probable mechanism of the hairpin ribozyme, and the active site arrangements for the two ribozymes appear topologically equivalent. This has probably arisen by convergent evolution.     

Critical nature of a specific uridine O2-carbonyl for cleavage by the hammerhead ribozyme.

Three modified hammerhead ribozyme/substrate complexes have been prepared in which individual uridine O2-carbonyls have been eliminated. The modified complexes were chemically synthesized with the substitution of a single 2-pyridone (2P) base analogue for residues U4, U7, and U16.1. Steady-state kinetic analyses indicate that the cleavage efficiencies for the U7 and U16.1 complexes were not significantly reduced relative to the native complex as measured by kcat/KM. The cleavage efficiency for the 2P4 complex, with the analogue present within the uridine loop, was reduced by greater than 2 orders of magnitude. This significant reduction in catalytic efficiency was due primarily to a decrease in kcat. The pH vs cleavage rate profile suggests that the O2-carbonyl of the U4 residue of the hammerhead complex is critical for transition state stabilization and efficient cleavage activity. The results of a Mg2+ rescue assay do not implicate the O2-carbonyl of U4 in an interaction with a divalent metal ion. In addition, the results of a ribozyme folding assay suggest that the presence of the 2P4 within the uridine loop does not alter the folding pathway (relative to the native sequence) both in the absence and in the presence of Mg2+. The O2-carbonyl of U4 appears oriented toward the interior of the catalytic pocket where it may be involved in a critical hydrogen bonding interaction necessary for transition state stabilization.     

Detailed analysis of base preferences at the cleavage site of a trans-acting HDV ribozyme: a mutation that changes cleavage site specificity.

In our previous attempt at in vitro selection of a trans - acting human hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozyme, we found that one of the variants, G10-68-725G, cleaved a 13 nt substrate, HDVS1, at two sites [Nishikawa,F., Kawakami,J., Chiba,A., Shirai,M., Kumar,P.K.R. and Nishikawa,S. (1996) Eur. J. Biochem., 237, 712-718]. One site was the normal cleavage site and the other site was shifted 1 nt toward the 3'-end. To clarify the interactions between nucleotides around the cleavage site of the trans -acting HDV ribozyme, we analyzed the efficiency of the reaction for every possible base pair between the substrate and the ribozyme at positions -1 (-1N:726N) and +1 (+1N:725N) relative to the cleavage site using the genomic HDV ribozyme, TdS4(Xho), and derivatives of the most active variant, G10-68. These mutagenesis analyses revealed that the +1 base of the substrate affects the structure of the catalytic core in the complex with G10-68-725G, substrate and divalent metal ions, and it shifts the cleavage site. In a comparison with other variants of the trans -acting HDV ribozyme, we found that this cleavage site shift occurred only with G10-68-725G.     

Metal ion binding and the folding of the hairpin ribozyme

The hairpin ribozyme comprises two formally unpaired loops carried on two arms of a four-way helical RNA junction. Addition of divalent metal ions brings about a conformational transition into an antiparallel structure in which there is an intimate association between the loops to generate the active form of the ribozyme. In this study, we have used fluorescence resonance energy transfer to analyze the global folding of the complete ribozyme, and the simple four-way junction derived from it, over a wide concentration range of divalent and monovalent metal ions. The simple junction undergoes an ion-induced rotation into an antiparallel form. In the presence of a constant background concentration of sodium ions, the magnesium-ion-induced transition is characterized by noncooperative binding with a Hill coefficient n = 1. By contrast, the magnesium-ion-induced folding of the complete ribozyme is more complex, involving two distinct binding phases. The first phase occurs in the micromolar range, and involves the cooperative binding of at least three magnesium ions. This can also be achieved by high concentrations of sodium ions, and is therefore likely to be due to diffuse binding of cations at the junction and the interface of the loop-loop interaction. The second phase occurs in the millimolar range, and can only be induced by divalent metal ions. This transition occurs in response to the noncooperative, site-specific binding of magnesium ions. We observe a good correlation between the extent of ion-induced folding and cleavage activity.