The reactions of octaethylporphyrin and its iron (II) and iron (III) complexes with free radicals

The reactions of dilute solutions of octaethylporphyrin and its iron (II) and iron (III) complexes with methyl, 2-cyanopropyl, t-butoxy, and benzoyloxy radicals are described. The results are summarized: (i) The reactivity of the porphyrin and its high-spin iron (II) and iron (III) complexes toward alkyl and t-butoxy radicals stands in the order: Fe^II > Fe^III ? free porphyrin. For benzoyloxy radicals the order is Fe^II > Porp > Fe^III. (ii) The exclusive path of reaction of high-spin iron (II) porphyrin with radicals is the rapid reduction of the radical and generation of an iron (III) porphyrin. The dominant path of reaction of high-spin iron (III) porphyrin with alkyl and (presumably) t-butoxy radicals is a rapid axial inner sphere reduction of the porphyrin. An axial ligand of iron is transferred to the radical. (iv) The reaction of benzoyloxy radicals with high or low-spin iron (III) porphyrins occurs primarily at the meso position. With the low-spin dipyridyl complex in pyridine the attendant reduction to iron (II) can be observed spectrally. Methyl radicals also reduce this complex by adding to the meso position. (v) The reaction of a radical with either an iron (II) or an iron (III) porphyrin results in the generation of the other valence state of iron and consequently oxidation and reduction products emanating from both iron species are obtained. (vi) No evidence for an iron (IV) is intermediate is apparent. (vii) Iron (II) porphyrins in solvents that impart either spin state are easily oxidized by diacyl peroxides. The occurrence of both axial and peripheral redox reactions with the iron complexes supports an underlying premise of a recent theory of hemeprotein reactivity. The relevance of the work to bioelectron transfer and heme catabolism is noted.     

Near infrared photoluminescence of ytterbium(III) complexes from tripodal ligands with different coordination conformations

Fourteen ytterbium(III) complexes of the tripodal ligands triRNTB (N-substituted tris(benzimidazol-2-ylmethyl)amine) have been prepared and characterized by elemental analysis (EA), infrared spectra (IR), electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) and single-crystal diffraction analysis. Their coordination conformations can be divided into three different types due to the introduction of secondary ligands or counter anions, i.e. ML₂, , and MLA₃ types, therefore resulting in different coordination symmetry on the central Yb(III) ions. Accordingly, the near infrared photoluminescence and photophysical properties of the complexes show contrasting results in peak splitting behavior, lifetime, and quantum efficiency, among which the ML₂ type displaying the most complicated splitting, the shortest lifetime and the smallest quantum efficiency.     

(Catecholato)iron(III) complexes: structural and functional models for the catechol-bound iron(III) form of catechol dioxygenases

Catechol dioxygenases are mononuclear non-heme iron enzymes that catalyze the oxygenation of catechols to aliphatic acids via the cleavage of aromatic rings. In the last 20 years, a number of (catecholato)iron(III) complexes have been synthesized and characterized as structural and functional models for the catechol-bound iron(III) form of catechol dioxygenases. This review focuses on the structural and spectroscopic characteristics and oxygenation activity of the title complexes.     

Synthesis of cobalt(III) complexes with novel open chain oxime ligands and metal-ligand coordination in aqueous solution

Cobalt(III) complexes with new open chain oxime ligands: N,N′-bis(2-hydroxyiminopropionyl)-1,2-aminoethane (H₂pen) and N,N′-bis(2-hydroxyiminopropionyl)-1,3-diaminopropane (H₂pap) have been investigated. Single crystals of Co(papH₋₁)(Im₂)·CH₃OH (1) and Co(papH₋₁)(MEA)₂·1.5H₂O (2) (where Im = imidazole, MEA = monoethanolamine) suitable for X-ray crystallography were grown by slow evaporation of methanol/water solutions at room temperature. The molecular structures have been determined using single-crystal X-ray diffraction methods. The potentiometric and spectrophotometric results in aqueous solution reveal that both of the open chain ligands show a very high efficacy in the coordination of Co(II) ions. As it has been indicated, differences between the two oxime ligands in complexing ability may be attributed to the longer -CH₂- chain in H₂pap and by that a better fit of the relatively large Co(II) ion to the accessible binding site. One of the complex species confirmed under inert atmosphere, namely of type Co(LH₋₁)⁻ (where L = pap or pen), has been shown as the “active” form, capable of dioxygen uptake followed by irreversible oxidation to Co(III).     

Synthesis and reactivities of binuclear iron(III) complexes with ligands composed of two tridentate chelating groups

Several new binuclear iron(III) complexes were prepared using the binucleating ligands in which two molecules of N,N-bis(2-benzimidazolymethyl)amine are linked by a polyatomic chain, such as-(CH₂)₄(L-4), -(CH₂)₆- (L-6), and -CH₂CH(OH)CH₂H(L-3), etc., and were characterized in terms of the magnetic measurements and cyclic voltammetry. The complexes, Fe₂(L-3′0(NO₃)₅ showed subnormal magnetic moments, 4.10 BM at 299 K and 2.22 BM at 87 K, respectively, suggesting the presence of an alkoxo-bridge structure. This complex showed much higher catalytic activity for the O₂ oxidation of N, N, N′,N′-tetramethyl-1-1,4-diaminobenzene than those of the relevant mononuclear complexes and other binuclear complexes studied here which have no alkoxo-bridge. The complex reacts with catechol and hydrogen peroxide to form 1:1 adducts.     

6,6'-Bis(2-hydroxyphenyl)-2,2'-bipyridine manganese(III) complexes: a novel series of superoxide dismutase and catalase mimetics

A series of novel manganese(III) complexes is described based on a 6,6'-bis(2-hydroxyphenyl)-2,2'-bipyridine template. These complexes show superoxide dismutase and catalase activity. The effect of the aromatic substitution pattern on the SAR is described.     

Synthesis, crystal structure and magnetic properties of a novel iron(III) 18-azametallacrown-6 compound

A novel macrocyclic hexanuclear iron(III) 18-azametallacrown-6 compound, [Fe₆(C₉H₇N₂O₃)₆(CH₃OH)₆]·8CH₃OH·2H₂O, has been prepared using a trianionic pentadentate ligand N-acetylsalicylhydrazide (ashz³⁻) and characterized by X-ray diffraction. Due to the meridional coordination of the ligand to the Fe³⁺ ion, the ligand enforces the stereochemistry of the Fe³⁺ ions as a propeller configuration with alternating Λ/Δ forms. The disc-shaped hexanuclear ring shows about 6.20 Å in diameter at entrance, about 9.31 Å at its largest diameter at the center of the cavity, respectively. There are many kinds of intramolecular and intermolecular hydrogen bonds in the title compound. The OH?O hydrogen bond distances range from 2.609(5)-2.901(5) Å. The magnetic susceptibility (4-275K) study indicates antiferromagnetic exchange interactions between the adjacent Fe³⁺ ions around the ring.     

Synthesis and luminescence properties of two novel lanthanide (III) complexes of acetophenonylcarboxymethyl sulphoxide

A novel ligand containing multiple coordinating groups (sulfinyl, carboxyl and carbonyl groups), acetophenonylcarboxymethyl sulphoxide, was synthesized. Its corresponding two lanthanide (III) binary complexes were synthesized and characterized by element analysis, molar conductivity, FT‐IR, TG‐DTA and UV spectroscopy. Results showed that the composition of these complexes was REL₃L^‐ (ClO₄)₂·3H₂O (RE = Eu (III), Tb (III); L = C₆H₅COCH₂SOCH₂COOH; L^‐ = C₆H₅COCH₂SOCH₂COO^‐). FT‐IR results indicated that acetophenonylcarboxymethyl sulphoxide was bonded with an RE (III) ion by an oxygen atom of the sulfinyl and carboxyl groups and not by an oxygen atom of the carbonyl group due to high steric hinderance. Fluorescent spectra showed that the Tb (III) complex had excellent luminescence as a result of a transfer of energy from the ligand to the excitation state energy level (⁵D₄) of Tb (III). The Eu (III) complex displayed weak luminescence, attributed to low energy transfer efficiency between the triplet state energy level of its ligand and the excited state (⁵D₀) of Eu (III). As a result, the Tb (III) complex displayed a good antenna effect for luminescence. The fluorescence decay curves of Eu (III) and Tb (III) complexes were also measured. Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Iron(III) complexes of certain meridionally coordinating tridentate ligands as models for non-heme iron enzymes: the role of carboxylate coordination

The iron(III) complexes [Fe(pda)Cl(H(2)O)(2)] (1), [Fe(tpy)Cl(3)] (2), and [Fe(bbp)Cl(3)] (3), where H(2)pda is pyridine-2,6-dicarboxylic acid, tpy is 2,2':6,2'-terpyridine and bbp is 2,6-bis(benzimidazolyl)pyridine, have been isolated and studied as functional models for the intradiol-cleaving catechol dioxygenase enzymes. Mixed ligand complexes of H(2)pda with the bidentate ligands 2,2'-bipyridine (bpy) and 1,10-phenanthroline (phen) have been also prepared and studied. All the complexes have been characterized using absorption spectral and electrochemical methods. The spectral changes in the catecholate adducts of the complexes generated in situ have been investigated. Upon interacting the complexes with catecholate anions a low energy catecholate to iron(III) charge transfer band appears, which is similar to that observed for enzyme-substrate complexes. All the complexes catalyze the oxidative intradiol cleavage of 3,5-di-tert-butylcatechol (H(2)dbc) in the presence of dioxygen. Interestingly, on replacing the pyridyl groups in 2 and the bulky benzimidazole groups in 3 by the carboxylate groups, the yields of the intradiol cleavage products of dioxygenation increases, 1 (50%)>2 (20%)>3 (10%). The higher intradiol yield for 1 has been ascribed to the meridional coordination of two carboxylate groups of pda(2-). In contrast to the trend in the intradiol cleavage yields, a tremendous decrease in the rate (200 times) is observed on replacing the two pyridyl moieties in 2 by two carboxylates as in 1 and a significant decrease in rate is observed on replacing the pyridyl moieties in 2 by strongly sigma-donating benzimidazole moieties as in 3. This is in conformity with the decrease in Lewis acidities of the iron(III) centers.     

Syntheses of iron(III) aroyl hydrazones containing pyridoxal and salicylaldehyde. The crystal and molecular structure of two iron(III)-pyridoxal isonicotinoyl hydrazone complexes

Iron(III) complexes of three aroyl hydrazones, pyridoxal isonicotinoyl hydrazone (H₂pih), pyridoxal benzoyl hydrazone (H₂pbh), and salicylaldehyde benzoyl hydrazone (H₂sbh), were synthesized and characterized. In aqueous medium at pH 7, [Fe(pih)(Hpih)]·3H₂O is formed. In acidic methanol, a 1:1 ligand-to-metal complex is formed, [FeCl₂(H₂pih)]Cl (1), whereas in aqueous medium at low pH cis-[FeCl₂(H₂pih)(H₂O)]Cl·H₂O (2) is formed. Compounds 1 and 2 are high-spin d⁵ with μ_eff = 5.88 μ_B and 5.93 μ_B (298 K). The crystal structures of 1 and 2 show that H₂pih acts as a tridentate neutral ligand in which the phenolic and hydrazidic protons have shifted to the pyridine nitrogen atoms. The co- ordination polyhedron of 1 is ‘square’ pyramidal, whereas that of 2 is pseudo-octahedral. Compound 1 is triclinic, space group P$\text{l}$, with a = 12.704(2) Å, b = 8.655(2) Å, c = 8.820(2) Å, α = 105.42(1)°, β = 89.87(1)°, γ = 107.60(1)°, V = 888 ų, and Z = 2; 2 is monoclinic, space group P2₁/c, with a = 15.358(4) Å, b = 7.304(3) Å, c = 17.442(4) Å, β = 101.00(2)°, V = 1921 ų, and Z = 4.     

Solution equilibrium studies on metal complexes of 2,3-dihydroxy-phenylalanine-hydroxamic acid (Dopaha) and models: catecholate versus hydroxamate coordination in iron(III)-, aluminium(III)- and molybdenum(VI)-Dopaha complexes

Equilibrium results based on pH potentiometric, spectrophotometric and (1)H NMR measurements for the complexes of Fe(III), Al(III) and Mo(VI) with 2,3-dihydroxy-phenylalanine-hydroxamic acid (Dopaha) as well as for binary model systems Fe(III)-, Al(III)-, Mo(VI)-acetohydroxamic acid (Aha), -alpha-alaninehydroxamic acid (alpha-Alaha) and -1,2-dihydroxy-3,5-benzene-disulphonate (Tiron) and ternary model systems Fe(III)-, Al(III)-, Mo(VI)-Tiron-Aha, are summarized in this paper. The amine-type coordination mode is not detectable with these metal ions at all. Precipitation occurs at pH <5.5 with Fe(III) and Al(III) even at a Dopaha-to-metal ion ratio of 10:1. Hydroxamate-type coordination was demonstrated with both metals below the pH range of precipitation but, after dissolution, catecholate-type coordination was exclusively found. The hydroxamate-type coordination mode occurs only in the very acidic pH range for Mo(VI) complexes and the crossover from hydroxamate to catecholate binding occurs at pH >3. A ligand-bridged dinuclear species, [(MoO(2))(2)(Dopaha)(2)](2+), involving mixed-type (catecholate and hydroxamate) coordination modes is formed in the pH range 2.5-5.5. [MoO(2)A(2)H(2)], with catecholate-type coordination, forms above pH 3. On increasing the pH further, deprotonation of the coordinated Dopaha and hydrolytic processes result in the formation of catecholate-coordinated [MoO(3)AH] and [MoO(3)A]. MoO(4)(2-) and free Dopaha exist above pH 10.     

Complexes of hydroxamates III.: Equilibrium and kinetic studies on the reactions of iron(III) with monohydroxamic acids

Spectral analysis of iron(III) complexes with acetohydroxamate (AX) and histidinehydroxamate (HX) in the UV-visible region revealed that many species may exist in pH range 1.0–7.5. The solution spectra were unstable in pH range ~2.7–4.0. Different species were obtained from fresh solutions and overnight solutions. The difference was rationalized due to hydrolysis and/or polymerization of complexes in solution, especially in pH range 2.7–4.0. The kinetics of the reactions of Fe(III) with AX and HX were accomplished, and mechanisms were suggested for both systems. In both cases, Fe³⁺ and FeOH²⁺ species were found to be the active species in the complex formation of 1:1 complex.     

Structural and magnetic characterization of a novel series of dinuclear Cu(II) complexes bridging by 2,5-pyrazine dicarboxylate

A new series of dinuclear 2,5-pyrazine dicarboxylato-bridged copper(II) complexes were synthesized and characterized by spectroscopic techniques. The complexes have the general structural formula [Cu₂(L)₂(μ-pyzdc)](ClO₄)₂·nH₂O where L = TPA, n = 2 (1); L = pmedien, n = 2 (2); L = aepn, n = 3 (3); L = dpt, n = 2 (4); L = Medpt, n = 0 (5); L = dien, n = 0 (6) and L = MeDPA, n = 2 (7) with TPA = tris(2-pyridylmethyl)amine, pmdien = N,N,N′,N′′,N′′-pentamethyldiethylenetriamine, aepn = N-(2-aminoethyl)-1,3-diaminopropane, dpt = dipropylene-triamine, Medpt = 3,3′-diamino-N-methyldipropylamine, dien = diethylenetriamine, MeDPA = N,N-di(2-pyridylmethyl)methylamine. In these complexes, the bridging nature of the 2,5-pyrazine dicarboxylato ligand (pyzdc) was confirmed by single-crystal X-ray crystallography. The structure of the TPA complex 1 consists of μ-pyzdc bridging two Cu(II) centers in a bis(monodentate) bonding fashion through a single oxygen atom supplied by each carboxylate group of the bridged pyzdc in a distorted trigonal bipyramidal geometry achieved by the four nitrogen atoms from the TPA ligand. In the complexes 2-5 derived from tridentate amines, the bridged pyzdc acts as a bis(bidentate) ligand in a distorted square pyramidal geometry achieved by one nitrogen and one carboxylate-oxygen of pyzdc, and by the three N-atoms of the amine coligands. The intradimer Cu?Cu distances in the complexes 2-5 are in the range 6.97-7.45 ? and in it is 10.96 ? in 1. The corresponding intermolecular distances are even shorter (5.34-7.99 ?). The susceptibility measurements at variable temperatures over the 5-300 K range reveal weak antiferromagnetic coupling with J values ranging from −0.61 to −4.78 cm⁻¹.     

Synthesis, crystal structure and magnetic characterization of a series of four phenoxo-bridged binuclear manganese(III) Schiff base complexes

A family of four new phenoxo-bridged binuclear manganese(III) complexes of the general formula, [Mn(L)(X)]₂ where L = [N,N′-bis(salicylidene)]propane-1,2-diamine and X = salicylaldehyde anion (sal⁻) (1); NCS⁻ (2); NCO⁻ (3) and [Mn(L′)(N₃)]₂·2C₂H₅OH (4) where L′ = [N,N′-bis(2-hydroxyacetophenylidene)]propane-1,2-diamine has been prepared. The syntheses have been achieved by reacting manganese perchlorate with 1,2-diaminopropane and salicylaldehyde (or 2-hydroxyacetophenone for 4) or along with the respective pseudohalides so that the tetradentate Schiff base H₂L or H₂L′ is obtained in situ to bind the Mn(III) ion. The complexes have been characterized by IR spectroscopy, elemental analysis, crystal structure analysis and variable-temperature magnetic susceptibility measurements. The single crystal X-ray diffraction studies show that the compounds are isostructural containing dimeric Mn(III) units with bridging phenolate oxygen atoms. Low temperature magnetic studies indicate that the complexes 1-3 exhibit intradimer ferromagnetic exchange as well as single-molecule magnet (SMM) behavior while complex 4 is found to undergo an intradimer antiferromagnetic coupling.     

Biomimetic hydrolytic activation by Fe(III) aggregates: structures,reactivity and properties of novel oxo-bridged iron complexes

The tetranuclear aggregate (enH(2))[Fe(4)(mu(3)-O)(heidi)(4)(mu-O,O'-O(2)CNHC(2)H(4)NH(3))] x 4H(2)O contains a novel bidentate zwitterionic carbamic acid ligand. Magnetic studies indicate that the unsymmetrical Fe(4) core is ferrimagnetic with an S=4 ground state. Similar ligands have been obtained on rectangular tetranuclear aggregates [M(4)(mu-O)(mu-OH)(hpdta)(2)(mu-X)(2)](n-) (M[double bond]Fe, Al, Ga). The carbamic acid ligands are considered to result from the hydrolytic activation (fixation) of atmospheric CO(2) by the aggregate precursor to give a carbonato intermediate, which then reacts with the organic diamine used as base in the synthesis. Similar aggregates with acetate ligands result from hydrolytic activation of the DMA used as cosolvent. Closely related mechanisms for these two activation processes are proposed, which are also related to the accepted mechanisms for carbonic anhydrase and urease.     

Tripodal oxygen and tripodal nitrogen ligands in hydroformylation reactions: formation of novel rhodium(III) carbonyl bis(acyl) complexes

The rhodium(I) complexes TpmsRh(CO)₂ (1) and TpmsRh(cod) (2) of the tripodal nitrogen ligand tris(pyrazolyl)methanesulfonate, Tpms⁻=[(pz)₃CSO₃]⁻, catalyze the hydroformylation of 1-hexene. Addition of phosphine has a negative effect on the activity. The hydroformylation activity reaches a maximum at about 60 °C. At temperatures above 80 °C hydrogenation becomes an important secondary reaction. When the catalysis is performed at 60 °C in acetone with 1 or 2 as catalyst precursor all of the rhodium is recovered in the form of the rhodium(III) bis(acyl) complex TpmsRh(CO)(COC₆H₁₃)₂ (9). A similar behaviour is observed with rhodium(I) complexes bearing the tripodal oxygen ligand L_OMe⁻=[(cyclopentadienyl)tris(dimethylphosphito-P) cobalt O,O^′,O″]⁻. In this case all of the rhodium is transformed into L_OMeRh(CO)(COC₆H₁₃)₂ (10). These hitherto unknown bis(acyl) rhodium(III) complexes show the same catalytic activity as the rhodium(I) starting compounds.     

Synthesis and characterization of tetraphenylporphyrin iron(III) complexes with substituted phenylcyanamide ligands

Several five coordinate complexes of [(TPP)Fe^III(L)] in which TPP is the dianion of tetraphenylporphyrin and L is the monoanion of phenylcyanamide (pcyd) (1), 2,5-dichlorophenylcyanamide (2,5-Cl₂pcyd) (2), 2,6-dichlorophenylcyanamide (2,6-Cl₂pcyd) (3), and 2,3,4,6-tetrachlorophenylcyanamide (2,3,4,6-Cl₄pcyd) (4) have been prepared by the reaction of [(TPP)Fe^IIICl] with appropriate thallium salt of phenylcyanamide. Each of the complexes has been characterized by IR, UV-Vis and ¹H NMR spectroscopic data. Dark red-brown needles of [(TPP)Fe^III(2,6-Cl₂pcyd)] (C₅₁H₃₁Cl₂FeN₆ · CHCl₃) crystallize in the triclinic system. The crystal structure of Fe(III) compound shows a slight distortion from square pyramidal coordination with the 2,6-dichlorophenylcyanamide anion in the axial position through nitrile nitrogen atom. Iron atom is 0.47(1) Å out of plane of the porphyrin toward phenylcyanamide ligand. In non-coordinating solvents, such as benzene or chloroform, these complexes exhibit ¹H NMR spectra that are characteristic of high-spin (S = 5/2) species. The X-ray crystal structure parameters are also consistent with high-spin iron(III) complexes. The iron(III) phenylcyanamide complexes are not reactive toward molecular oxygen; however, these complexes react with HCl and produce TPPFe^IIICl.     

The kinetics and mechanisms of the reactions of iron(III) with quercetin and morin

The kinetics and mechanisms of the reactions of a pseudo-first order excess of iron(III) with the flavonoids quercetin and morin have been investigated in aqueous solution at 25 degrees C and an ionic strength of 0.5M. Mechanisms have been proposed which account satisfactorily for the kinetic data. The data are consistent with a mechanism in which the metal:ligand complex formed initially on reaction of iron(III) with the ligand subsequently decomposes through an electron transfer step. Morin forms a 1:1 metal:ligand complex while quercetin forms a 2:1 metal:ligand complex. Both ligands showed evidence for the involvement of the iron hydroxo dimer Fe2(OH)2(4+) in the complex formation reaction at the hydroxy-carbonyl moiety. The iron(III) assisted decomposition of the initial iron(III) complex formed was also investigated and the rate constants evaluated. Both the complex formation and subsequent electron transfer reactions of iron(III) with these ligands were monitored using UV-visible spectrophotometry. All of the suggested mechanisms and calculated rate constants are supported by calculations carried out using global analysis of time dependant spectra.     

Iron(III), chromium(III) and cobalt(II) complexes with squarate: Synthesis, crystal structure and magnetic properties

The preparation and variable temperature-magnetic investigation of three squarate-containing complexes of formula [Fe₂(OH)₂(C₄O₄)₂(H₂O)₄]·2H₂O (1) [Cr₂(OH)₂(C₄O₄)₂(H₂O)₄]·2H₂O (2) and [Co(C₄O₄)(H₂O)₄]_n (3) [H₂C₄O₄ = 3.4-dihydroxycyclobutene-1,2-dione (squaric acid)] together with the crystal structures of 1 and 3 are reported. Complex 1 contains discrete centrosymmetric [Fe₂(OH)₂(C₄O₄)₂(H₂O)₄] diiron(II) units where the iron pairs are joined by a di-μ-hydroxo bridge and two squarate ligands acting as bridging groups through adjacent oxygen atoms. Two coordinated water molecules in cis position complete the octahedral environment at each iron atom in 1. The iron-iron distance with the dinuclear unit is 3.0722(6) Å and the angle at the hydroxo bridge is 99.99(7)°, values which compare well with the corresponding ones in the isostructural compound 2 (2.998 Å and 99.47°) whose structure was reported previously. The crystal structure of 3 contains neutral chains of squarato-O¹,O³-bridged cobalt(II) ions where four coordinated water molecules complete the six-coordination at each cobalt atom. The cobalt-cobalt separation across the squarate bridge is 8.0595(4) Å. A relatively important intramolecular antiferromagnetic coupling occurs in 1 whereas it is very weak in 2, the exchange pathway being the same [J = −14.4 (1) and −0.07 cm⁻¹ (2), the spin Hamiltonian being defined as ]. A weak intrachain antiferromagnetic interaction between the high-spin cobalt(II) ions occurs in 3 (J = −0.30 cm⁻¹). The magnitude and nature of these magnetic interactions are discussed in the light of their respective structures and they are compared with those reported for related systems.