Enzymatic cyclization of a potent bowman-birk protease inhibitor,sunflower trypsin inhibitor-1, and solution structure of an acyclic precursor peptide

The most potent known naturally occurring Bowman-Birk inhibitor, sunflower trypsin inhibitor-1 (SFTI-1), is a bicyclic 14-amino acid peptide from sunflower seeds comprising one disulfide bond and a cyclic backbone. At present, little is known about the cyclization mechanism of SFTI-1. We show here that an acyclic permutant of SFTI-1 open at its scissile bond, SFTI-1[6,5], also functions as an inhibitor of trypsin and that it can be enzymatically backbone-cyclized by incubation with bovine beta-trypsin. The resulting ratio of cyclic SFTI-1 to SFTI-1[6,5] is approximately 9:1 regardless of whether trypsin is incubated with SFTI-1[6,5] or SFTI-1. Enzymatic resynthesis of the scissile bond to form cyclic SFTI-1 is a novel mechanism of cyclization of SFTI-1[6,5]. Such a reaction could potentially occur on a trypsin affinity column as used in the original isolation procedure of SFTI-1. We therefore extracted SFTI-1 from sunflower seeds without a trypsin purification step and confirmed that the backbone of SFTI-1 is indeed naturally cyclic. Structural studies on SFTI-1[6,5] revealed high heterogeneity, and multiple species of SFTI-1[6,5] were identified. The main species closely resembles the structure of cyclic SFTI-1 with the broken binding loop able to rotate between a cis/trans geometry of the I7-P8 bond with the cis conformer being similar to the canonical binding loop conformation. The non-reactive loop adopts a beta-hairpin structure as in cyclic wild-type SFTI-1. Another species exhibits an iso-aspartate residue at position 14 and provides implications for possible in vivo cyclization mechanisms.     

Disulfide bond mutagenesis and the structure and function of the head-to-tail macrocyclic trypsin inhibitor SFTI-1

SFTI-1 is a novel 14 amino acid peptide comprised of a circular backbone constrained by three proline residues, a hydrogen-bond network, and a single disulfide bond. It is the smallest and most potent known Bowman-Birk trypsin inhibitor and the only one with a cyclic peptidic backbone. The solution structure of [ABA(3,11)]SFTI-1, a disulfide-deficient analogue of SFTI-1, has been determined by (1)H NMR spectroscopy. The lowest energy structures of native SFTI-1 and [ABA(3,11)]SFTI-1 are similar and superimpose with a root-mean-square deviation over the backbone and heavy atoms of 0.26 +/- 0.09 and 1.10 +/- 0.22 A, respectively. The disulfide bridge in SFTI-1 was found to be a minor determinant for the overall structure, but its removal resulted in a slightly weakened hydrogen-bonding network. To further investigate the role of the disulfide bridge, NMR chemical shifts for the backbone H(alpha) protons of two disulfide-deficient linear analogues of SFTI-1, [ABA(3,11)]SFTI-1[6,5] and [ABA(3,11)]SFTI-1[1,14] were measured. These correspond to analogues of the cleavage product of SFTI-1 and a putative biosynthetic precursor, respectively. In contrast with the cyclic peptide, it was found that the disulfide bridge is essential for maintaining the structure of these open-chain analogues. Overall, the hydrogen-bond network appears to be a crucial determinant of the structure of SFTI-1 analogues.     

向日葵胰蛋白酶抑制剂SFTI-1

向日葵胰蛋白酶抑制剂(sunflower trypsininhibitor-1,SFTI-1)是近来发现的Bowman-Birk抑制剂(Bowman-Birk inhibitor,BBI)家族的新成员。由14个氨基酸残基组成的SFTI-1是具有胰蛋白酶抑制活性的天然环肽。SFTI-1的天然环状结构使它成为药物研发中的重要前导化合物。本文综述了近年来SFTI-1在结构、功能、环化机制等方面的研究进展。     

Solution Structure of a Novel C<Subscript>2</Subscript>-Symmetrical Bifunctional Bicyclic Inhibitor Based on SFTI-1

A novel bifunctional bicyclic inhibitor has been created that combines features both from the Bowman–Birk inhibitor (BBI) proteins, which have two distinct inhibitory sites, and from sunflower trypsin inhibitor-1 (SFTI-1), which has a compact bicyclic structure. The inhibitor was designed by fusing together a pair of reactive loops based on a sequence derived from SFTI-1 to create a backbone-cyclized disulfide-bridged 16-mer peptide. This peptide has two symmetrically spaced trypsin binding sites. Its synthesis and biological activity have been reported in a previous communication [Jaulent and Leatherbarrow, 2004, PEDS 17, 681]. In the present study we have examined the three-dimensional structure of the molecule. We find that the new inhibitor, which has a symmetrical 8-mer half-cystine CTKSIPP′I′ motif repeated through a C₂ symmetry axis also shows a complete symmetry in its three-dimensional structure. Each of the two loops adopts the expected canonical conformation common to all BBIs as well as SFTI-1. We also find that the inhibitor displays a strong and unique structural identity, with a notable lack of minor conformational isomers that characterise most reactive site loop mimics examined to date as well as SFTI-1. This suggests that the presence of the additional cyclic loop acts to restrict conformational mobility and that the deliberate introduction of cyclic symmetry may offer a general route to locking the conformation of β-hairpin structures. Electronic supplementary material Electronic supplementary material is available for this article at and accessible for authorised users.     

Discovery, structural determination, and putative processing of the precursor protein that produces the cyclic trypsin inhibitor sunflower trypsin inhibitor 1

Backbone-cyclized proteins are becoming increasingly well known, although the mechanism by which they are processed from linear precursors is poorly understood. In this report the sequence and structure of the linear precursor of a cyclic trypsin inhibitor, sunflower trypsin inhibitor 1 (SFTI-1) from sunflower seeds, is described. The structure indicates that the major elements of the reactive site loop of SFTI-1 are present before processing. This may have importance for a protease-mediated cyclizing reaction as the rigidity of SFTI-1 may drive the equilibrium of the reaction catalyzed by proteolytic enzymes toward the formation of a peptide bond rather than the normal cleavage reaction. The occurrence of residues in the SFTI-1 precursor susceptible to cleavage by asparaginyl proteases strengthens theories that involve this enzyme in the processing of SFTI-1 and further implicates it in the processing of another family of plant cyclic proteins, the cyclotides. The precursor reported here also indicates that despite strong active site sequence homology, SFTI-1 has no other similarities with the Bowman-Birk trypsin inhibitors, presenting interesting evolutionary questions.     

The absolute structural requirement for a proline in the P3'-position of Bowman-Birk protease inhibitors is surmounted in the minimized SFTI-1 scaffold

SFTI-1 is a small cyclic peptide from sunflower seeds that is one of the most potent trypsin inhibitors of any naturally occurring peptide and is related to the Bowman-Birk family of inhibitors (BBIs). BBIs are involved in the defense mechanisms of plants and also have potential as cancer chemopreventive agents. At only 14 amino acids in size, SFTI-1 is thought to be a highly optimized scaffold of the BBI active site region, and thus it is of interest to examine its important structural and functional features. In this study, a suite of 12 alanine mutants of SFTI-1 has been synthesized, and their structures and activities have been determined. SFTI-1 incorporates a binding loop that is clasped together with a disulfide bond and a secondary peptide loop making up the circular backbone. We show here that the secondary loop stabilizes the binding loop to the consequences of sequence variations. In particular, full-length BBIs have a conserved cis-proline that has been shown previously to be required for well defined structure and potent activity, but we show here that the SFTI-1 scaffold can accommodate mutation of this residue and still have a well defined native-like conformation and nanomolar activity in inhibiting trypsin. Among the Ala mutants, the most significant structural perturbation occurred when Asp14 was mutated, and it appears that this residue is important in stabilizing the trans peptide bond preceding Pro13 and is thus a key residue in maintaining the highly constrained structure of SFTI-1. This aspartic acid residue is thought to be involved in the cyclization mechanism associated with excision of SFTI-1 from its 58-amino acid precursor. Overall, this mutational analysis of SFTI-1 clearly defines the optimized nature of the SFTI-1 scaffold and demonstrates the importance of the secondary loop in maintaining the active conformation of the binding loop.     

Synthesis and evaluation of the sunflower derived trypsin inhibitor as a potent inhibitor of the type II transmembrane serine protease, matriptase.

We report here the synthesis of a 14-amino acid long bicyclic peptide, previously isolated from sunflower seeds. This peptide, termed sunflower trypsin inhibitor (SFTI-1), is one of the most potent naturally occurring small-molecule trypsin inhibitors. In addition to inhibiting trypsin, the synthetic SFTI-1 is also a very potent inhibitor, with a K(i) of 0.92nM, of the recently identified epithelial serine protease, termed 'matriptase'.     

In vivo biosynthesis of an Ala-scan library based on the cyclic peptide SFTI-1

We present the in vivo biosynthesis of wild-type sunflower trypsin inhibitor 1 (SFTI-1) inside E. coli cells using an intramolecular native chemical ligation in combination with a modified protein splicing unit. SFTI-1 is a small backbone cyclized polypeptide with a single disulfide bridge. A small library containing multiple Ala mutants was also biosynthesized and its activity was assayed using a trypsin-binding assay. This study clearly demonstrates the exciting possibility of generating large cyclic peptide libraries in live E. coli cells, and is a critical first step for developing in vivo screening and directed evolution technologies using the cyclic peptide SFTI-1 as a molecular scaffold.     

Mastering the canonical loop of serine protease inhibitors: enhancing potency by optimising the internal hydrogen bond network

Background

Canonical serine protease inhibitors commonly bind to their targets through a rigid loop stabilised by an internal hydrogen bond network and disulfide bond(s). The smallest of these is sunflower trypsin inhibitor (SFTI-1), a potent and broad-range protease inhibitor. Recently, we re-engineered the contact β-sheet of SFTI-1 to produce a selective inhibitor of kallikrein-related peptidase 4 (KLK4), a protease associated with prostate cancer progression. However, modifications in the binding loop to achieve specificity may compromise structural rigidity and prevent re-engineered inhibitors from reaching optimal binding affinity.

Methodology/Principal Findings

In this study, the effect of amino acid substitutions on the internal hydrogen bonding network of SFTI were investigated using an in silico screen of inhibitor variants in complex with KLK4 or trypsin. Substitutions favouring internal hydrogen bond formation directly correlated with increased potency of inhibition in vitro. This produced a second generation inhibitor (SFTI-FCQR Asn₁₄) which displayed both a 125-fold increased capacity to inhibit KLK4 (K _i = 0.0386±0.0060 nM) and enhanced selectivity over off-target serine proteases. Further, SFTI-FCQR Asn₁₄ was stable in cell culture and bioavailable in mice when administered by intraperitoneal perfusion.

Conclusion/Significance

These findings highlight the importance of conserving structural rigidity of the binding loop in addition to optimising protease/inhibitor contacts when re-engineering canonical serine protease inhibitors.     

Albumins and their processing machinery are hijacked for cyclic peptides in sunflower

The cyclic peptide sunflower trypsin inhibitor 1 (SFTI-1) blocks trypsin and is a promising drug lead and protein engineering scaffold. We show that SFTI-1 and the newfound SFT-L1 are buried within PawS1 and PawS2, precursors for seed storage protein albumins. Proalbumins are matured by asparaginyl endopeptidase, which we show is required to liberate both ends of SFTI-1 as well as to mature PawS1 albumin. Thus, these peptides emerge from within an albumin precursor by the action of albumin's own processing enzyme.     

Conformational studies of [Abu(3, 11)]-SFTI-1, an analogue of the trypsin inhibitor isolated from sunflower seeds.

With only 14 amino acid residues, the trypsin inhibitor SFTI-1 is the smallest naturally occurring serine proteinase inhibitor. It consists of two cyclic fragments (with head-to-tail cyclization and a disulfide bridge). In our previous paper, we showed that the removal of the disulfide bridge produced 2.4-fold lower activity. Here, we present the total conformational analysis of the [Abu(3, 11)]-SFTI-1 analog by means of 2D NMR spectroscopy in conjunction with theoretical methods. The peptide was synthesized by Fmoc SPPS. It was cyclized with PyBop and DIPEA in DMF. The NMR studies were performed in DMSO-d(6) at 303 K. Conformations of the peptide studied were calculated by the following three approaches: distance geometry (DG), molecular dynamics (MD) and determination of the statistical weights of conformations. The first two algorithms use a CHARMM force field, whereas the last uses an ECEPP/3 force field. Our calculations resulted in three sets of conformers with 7, 9 and 6 representatives, respectively. All our results were compared with published ones. It was found that the peptide has an ill-defined structure. Despite its conformational flexibility, the binding loop (3-11 fragment) displayed geometry similar to the corresponding fragments of the other SFTI-1 analogs and to the inhibitor itself. Furthermore, the peptide bond between the Ile7 and Pro8 residues adopts cis geometry, which is essential for inhibitory activity. Copyright (c) 2008 European Peptide Society and John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Peptomeric analogues of trypsin inhibitor SFTI-1 isolated from sunflower seeds

A series of linear and monocyclic analogues of trypsin inhibitor SFTI-1 isolated from sunflower seeds, modified by N-(4-aminobutyl)glycine (Nlys) and N-benzylglycine (Nphe), were obtained by the solid-phase method. Some of these peptomers displayed trypsin or chymotrypsin inhibitory activity. In contradiction to the literature data, in most analogues peptide bonds formed by these peptoid monomers were at least partially hydrolyzed by the experimental enzymes at two different pH (3.5 and 8.3). Nevertheless, the replacement of Phe present in the P(1) substrate specificity of linear inactive SFTI-1 analogue with Nphe, yielded a potent chymotrypsin inhibitor. The introduction of one cyclic element (a disulfide bridge or head-to-tail cyclization) to the analogues synthesized significantly increased their proteinase resistance.     

The (1)H-NMR solution structure of the antitryptic core peptide of Bowman-Birk inhibitor proteins: a minimal canonical loop

Bowman-Birk inhibitor (BBI) proteins contain an inhibitory motif comprising a disulfide-bonded sequence that interacts with serine proteinases. Recently, a small 14-residue peptide from sunflowers (SFTI-1), which has potent anti-trypsin activity, has been found to have the same motif. However, this peptide also has an unusual head-to-tail cyclisation. To address the role of the core inhibitory sequence itself, we have solved the (1)H-NMR solution structure of an antitryptic 11-residue cyclic peptide that corresponds to the core reactive site loops of both SFTI-1 and Bowman-Birk inhibitor proteins. A comparison is made between the secondary chemical shifts found in this family and the canonical regions of several other inhibitors, giving some insight into relative flexibility and hydrogen bonding patterns in these inhibitors. The solution structure of the core peptide in isolation is found to retain essentially the same three-dimensional arrangement of both backbone and side chains as observed in larger antitryptic BBI and SFTI-1 fragments as well as in the complete proteins. The retention of the canonical conformation in the core peptide explains the peptids inhibitory potency. It therefore represents a minimization of both the BBI and SFTI-1 sequences. We conclude that the core peptide is a conformationally defined, canonical scaffold, which can serve as a minimal platform for the engineering of biological activity.     

Introduction of alpha-hydroxymethyamino acid residues in substrate specificity P1 position of trypsin inhibitor SFTI-1 from sunflower seeds retains its activity

In many complexes formed by serine proteinases and their inhibitors, the hydroxyl group provided by water molecule or by the inhibitor Ser residue is located close to the inhibitor P1-P1' reactive site. In order to investigate the role of this group, we synthesized analogues of trypsin inhibitor SFTI-1 isolated from the seeds of sunflower modified in P1 by alpha-hydroxymethylserine (HmSer) and both enantiomers of alpha-hydroxymethylvaline (HmVal). All the synthesized analogues inhibited bovine beta-trypsin and human leukocyte elastase. SFTI-1 analogues with HmVal and HmSer appear to be potent inhibitors of bovine beta-trypsin, whereas [Val5]SFTI-1 is practically inactive. Also trypsin inhibitory activity of [Ser5]SFTI-1 is significantly lower. Since the electrostatic interaction between protonated epsilon-NH2 group of the inhibitor P1 position and beta-carboxylate of trypsin Asp189 is the main driving force for interaction of both molecules, the results obtained are very interesting. We believe that these SFTI-1 analogues belong to a novel class of serine proteinase inhibitors.     

Crystal structure of bovine trypsin and wheat germ trypsin inhibitor (I-2b) complex (2:1) at 2.3 a resolution

The Bowman-Birk trypsin inhibitor (BBI) from wheat germ (I-2b) consists of 123 amino acid residues with two inhibitory loops. The crystal structure of a bovine trypsin-wheat germ trypsin inhibitor (I-2b) complex (2:1) has been determined at 2.3 A resolution to a final R-factor of 0.177. A distance of 37.2 A between the contiguous contact loops allows them to bind and inhibit two trypsin molecules simultaneously and independently. Each domain shares the same overall fold with 8 kDa BBIs. The five disulfide bridges in each domain are a subset of seven disulfide bridges in the 8 kDa BBIs. I-2b consists of ten beta-strands and the loops connecting these strands but it lacks alpha-helices. The conformations of the contiguous contact loops of I-2b are in a heart-like structure. The reactive sites in both domains, Arg 17 and Lys 76, are located on the loop connecting anti-parallel beta-strands, beta 1/beta 2 and beta 6/beta 7. Strands beta 1 and beta 6 are in direct contact with trypsin molecules and form stable triple stranded beta-sheet structures via hydrogen bonds.     

Chemical synthesis and kinetic study of the smallest naturally occurring trypsin inhibitor SFTI-1 isolated from sunflower seeds and its analogues

The smallest known naturally occurring trypsin inhibitor SFTI-1 (14 amino acid residues head-to-tail cyclic peptide containing one disulfide bridge) and its two analogues with one cycle each were synthesized by the solid phase method. Their trypsin inhibitory activity was determined as association equilibrium constants (K(a)). Additionally, hydrolysis rates with bovine beta-trypsin were measured. Among all three peptides, the wild SFTI-1 and the analogue with the disulfide bridge only had, within the experimental error, the same activity (the K(a) values 1.1 x 10(10) and 9.9 x 10(9) M(-1), respectively). Both peptides displayed unchanged inhibitory activity up to 6 h. The trypsin inhibitory activity of the analogue with the head-to-tail cycle only was 2.4-fold lower. It was also remarkably faster hydrolyzed (k = 1.1 x 10(-4) mol(peptide) x mol(enzyme)(-1) x s(-1)) upon the incubation with the enzyme than the other two peptides. This indicates that the head-to-tail cyclization is significantly less important than the disulfide bridge for maintaining trypsin inhibitory activity.     

Structure of the trypsin-binding domain of Bowman-Birk type protease inhibitor and its interaction with trypsin

The crystal structure of the complex formed by bovine trypsin and Bowman-Birk type protease inhibitor AB-I extracted from azuki beans (Vigna angularis) 'Takara' has been analyzed. The structure was solved by the application of the phase combination of single isomorphous phases and trypsin model phases, followed by phase improvement using the iterative Fourier technique. From the resulting electron density map, a three-dimensional atomic model of the trypsin binding domain of AB-I has been built. The peptide chain at the trypsin reactive site turns back sharply at Pro29 and forms a 9-residue ring (Cys24-Cys32). The 'front side' of this ring, consisting of the reactive site (Cys24-Met28), interacts with trypsin in a similar manner to other families of inhibitors and forms a stable complex, which seems to be maintained by the interactions with the 'back side' of this ring (Pro29-Cys34). The similar spatial arrangements of the 'back side' of this inhibitor and the 'secondary contact region' of the other inhibitors with respect to the reactive site suggest an important common role of these regions in exhibiting inhibitory activity.     

Implication of the disulfide bridge in trypsin inhibitor SFTI-1 in its interaction with serine proteinases

Fourteen monocyclic analogues of trypsin inhibitor SFTI-1 isolated from sunflower seeds were synthesized by the solid-phase method. The purpose of this work was to establish the role of a disulfide bridge present in inhibitor’s side chains of Cys3 and Cys11 in association with serine proteinases. This cyclic fragment was replaced by the disulfide bridges formed by l-pencillamine (Pen), homo-l-cysteine (Hcy), N-sulfanylethylglycine (Nhcy) or combination of the three with Cys. As in the substrate specificity the P₁ position of the synthesized analogues Lys, Nlys [N-(4-aminobutyl)glycine], Phe or Nphe (N-benzylglycine) were present, and they were checked for trypsin and chymotrypsin inhibitory activity. The results clearly indicated that Pen and Nhcy were not acceptable at the position 3, yielding inactive analogues, whereas another residue (Cys11) could be substituted without any significant impact on the affinity towards proteinase. On the other hand, elongation of the Cys3 side chain by introduction of Hcy did not affect inhibitory activity, and an analogue with the Hcy–Hcy disulfide bridge was more than twice as effective as the reference compound ([Phe⁵] SFTI-1) in inhibition of bovine α-chymotrypsin.     

Making Ends Meet: Microwave-Accelerated Synthesis of Cyclic and Disulfide Rich Proteins Via In Situ Thioesterification and Native Chemical Ligation

The development of synthetic methodologies for cyclic peptides is driven by the discovery of cyclic peptide drug scaffolds such as the plant-derived cyclotides, sunflower trypsin inhibitor 1 (SFTI-1) and the development of cyclized conotoxins. Currently, the native chemical ligation reaction between an N-terminal cysteine and C-terminal thioester group remains the most robust method to obtain a head-to-tail cyclized peptide. Peptidyl thioesters are effectively generated by Boc SPPS. However, their generation is challenging using Fmoc SPPS because thioester linkers are not stable to repeated piperidine exposure during deprotection. Herein we describe a Fmoc-based protocol for synthesizing cyclic peptides adapted for microwave assisted solid phase peptide synthesis. The protocol relies on the linker Di-Fmoc-3,4-diaminobenzoic acid, and we demonstrate the use of Gly, Ser, Arg and Ile as C-terminal amino acids (using HBTU and HATU as coupling reagents). Following synthesis, an N-acylurea moiety is generated at the C-terminal of the peptide; the resin bound acylurea peptide is then deprotected and cleaved from the resin. The fully deprotected peptide undergoes thiolysis in aqueous buffer, generating the thioester in situ. Ultimately, the head-to-tail cyclized peptide is obtained via native chemical ligation. Two naturally occurring cyclic peptides, the prototypical Möbius cyclotide kalata B1 and SFTI-1 were synthesized efficiently, avoiding potential branching at the diamino linker, using the optimized protocol. In addition, we demonstrate the possibility to use the approach for the synthesis of long and synthetically challenging linear sequences, by the ligation of two truncated fragments of a 50-residue long plant defensin.     

The three-dimensional structure of interleukin-1 beta

The three-dimensional structure of human recombinant interleukin-1 beta has been determined at 0.24 nm resolution by X-ray crystallographic techniques. The partially refined model has a crystallographic R-factor of just under 19%. The structure is composed of 12 beta-strands forming a complex network of hydrogen bonds. The core of the structure can best be described as a tetrahedron whose edges are each formed by two antiparallel beta-strands. The interior of this structure is filled with hydrophobic side-chains. There is a 3-fold repeat in the folding of the polypeptide chain. Although this folding pattern suggests gene triplication, no significant internal sequence homology between topologically corresponding residues exists. The folding topology of interleukin-1 beta is very similar to that described by A. D. McLachlan [(1979) J. Mol. Biol. 133, 557-563] for soybean trypsin inhibitor.