Structure of the Sm Binding Site From Human U4 snRNA Derived From a 3 ns PME Molecular Dynamics Simulation

Abstract

A molecular dynamics simulation of the Sm binding site from human U4 snRNA was undertaken to determine the conformational flexibility of this region and to identify RNA conformations that were important for binding of the Sm proteins. The RNA was fully-solvated (>9,000 water molecules) and charge neutralized by inclusion of potassium ions. A three nanosecond MD simulation was conducted using AMBER with long-range electrostatic forces considered using the particle mesh Ewald summation method. The initial model of the Sm binding site region had the central and 3′ stem-loops that flanked the Sm site co-axial with one another, and with the single-stranded Sm binding site region ([I] conformation). During the course of the trajectory, the axes of the 3′ stem-loop, and later the central stem-loop, became roughly orthogonal from their original anti-parallel orientation. As these conformational changes occurred, the snRNA adopted first an [L] conformation, and finally a [U] conformation. The [U] conformation was more stable than either the [I] or [L] conformations, and persisted for the final 1 ns of the trajectory. Analysis of the structure resulting from the MD simulations revealed the bulged nucleotide, U₁₁₄, and the mismatched A₉₁-G₁₁₀ base pair provided distinctive structural features that may enhance Sm protein binding. Based on the results of the MD simulation and the available experimental data, we proposed a mechanism for the binding of the Sm protein sub-complexes to the snRNA. In this model, the D₁/D₂ and E/F/G Sm protein sub-complexes first bind the snRNA in the [U] conformation, followed by conformational re-arrangement to the [I] conformation and binding of the D₃/B Sm protein sub-complex.     

Functional interaction of a novel 15.5kD [U4/U6.U5] tri-snRNP protein with the 5' stem-loop of U4 snRNA.

Activation of the spliceosome for splicing catalysis requires the dissociation of U4 snRNA from the U4/U6 snRNA duplex prior to the first step of splicing. We characterize an evolutionarily conserved 15.5 kDa protein of the HeLa [U4/U6.U5] tri-snRNP that binds directly to the 5' stem-loop of U4 snRNA. This protein shares a novel RNA recognition motif with several RNP-associated proteins, which is essential, but not sufficient for RNA binding. The 15.5kD protein binding site on the U4 snRNA consists of an internal purine-rich loop flanked by the stem of the 5' stem-loop and a stem comprising two base pairs. Addition of an RNA oligonucleotide comprising the 5' stem-loop of U4 snRNA (U4SL) to an in vitro splicing reaction blocked the first step of pre-mRNA splicing. Interestingly, spliceosomal C complex formation was inhibited while B complexes accumulated. This indicates that the 15.5kD protein, and/or additional U4 snRNP proteins associated with it, play an important role in the late stage of spliceosome assembly, prior to step I of splicing catalysis. Our finding that the 15.5kD protein also efficiently binds to the 5' stem-loop of U4atac snRNA indicates that it may be shared by the [U4atac/U6atac.U5] tri-snRNP of the minor U12-type spliceosome.     

Domains of human U4atac snRNA required for U12-dependent splicing in vivo

U4atac snRNA forms a base-paired complex with U6atac snRNA. Both snRNAs are required for the splicing of the minor U12-dependent class of eukaryotic nuclear introns. We have developed a new genetic suppression assay to investigate the in vivo roles of several regions of U4atac snRNA in U12-dependent splicing. We show that both the stem I and stem II regions, which have been proposed to pair with U6atac snRNA, are required for in vivo splicing. Splicing activity also requires U4atac sequences in the 5' stem-loop element that bind a 15.5 kDa protein that also binds to a similar region of U4 snRNA. In contrast, mutations in the region immediately following the stem I interaction region, as well as a deletion of the distal portion of the 3' stem-loop element, were active for splicing. Complete deletion of the 3' stem-loop element abolished in vivo splicing function as did a mutation of the Sm protein binding site. These results show that the in vivo sequence requirements of U4atac snRNA are similar to those described previously for U4 snRNA using in vitro assays and provide experimental support for models of the U4atac/U6atac snRNA interaction.     

Conserved domains of human U4 snRNA required for snRNP and spliceosome assembly.

U4 snRNA is phylogenetically highly conserved and organized in several domains. To determine the function of each of the domains of human U4 snRNA in the multi-step process of snRNP and spliceosome assembly, we used reconstitution procedures in combination with snRNA mutagenesis. The highly conserved 5' terminal domain of U4 snRNA consists of the stem I and stem II regions that have been proposed to base pair with U6 snRNA, and the 5' stem-loop structure. We found that each of these structural elements is essential for spliceosome assembly. However, only the stem II region is required for U4-U6 interaction, and none of these elements for Sm protein binding. In contrast, the 3' terminal domain of U4 snRNA containing the Sm binding site is dispensable for both U4-U6 interaction and spliceosome assembly. Our results support an organization of the U4 snRNP into multiple functional domains, each of which acts at distinct stages of snRNP and spliceosome assembly.     

Mutational analysis of Saccharomyces cerevisiae U4 small nuclear RNA identifies functionally important domains.

U4 small nuclear RNA (snRNA) is essential for pre-mRNA splicing, although its role is not yet clear. On the basis of a model structure (C. Guthrie and B. Patterson, Annu. Rev. Genet. 22:387-419, 1988), the molecule can be thought of as having six domains: stem II, 5' stem-loop, stem I, central region, 3' stem-loop, and 3'-terminal region. We have carried out extensive mutagenesis of the yeast U4 snRNA gene (SNR14) and have obtained information on the effect of mutations at 105 of its 160 nucleotides. Fifteen critical residues in the U4 snRNA have been identified in four domains: stem II, the 5' stem-loop, stem I, and the 3'-terminal region. These domains have been shown previously to be insensitive to oligonucleotide-directed RNase H cleavage (Y. Xu, S. Petersen-Bjørn, and J. D. Friesen, Mol. Cell. Biol. 10:1217-1225, 1990), suggesting that they are involved in intra- or intermolecular interactions. Stem II, a region that base pairs with U6 snRNA, is the most sensitive to mutation of all U4 snRNA domains. In contrast, stem I is surprisingly insensitive to mutational change, which brings into question its role in base pairing with U6 snRNA. All mutations in the putative Sm site of U4 snRNA yield a lethal or conditional-lethal phenotype, indicating that this region is important functionally. Only two nucleotides in the 5' stem-loop are sensitive to mutation; most of this domain can tolerate point mutations or small deletions. The 3' stem-loop, while essential, is very tolerant of change. A large portion of the central domain can be removed or expanded with only minor effects on phenotype, suggesting that it has little function of its own. Analysis of conditional mutations in stem II and stem I indicates that although these single-base changes do not have a dramatic effect on U4 snRNA stability, they are defective in RNA splicing in vivo and in vitro, as well as in spliceosome assembly. These results are discussed in the context of current knowledge of the interactions involving U4 snRNA.     

RNA structure and RNA-protein interactions in purified yeast U6 snRNPs

The U6 small nuclear RNA (snRNA) undergoes major conformational changes during the assembly of the spliceosome and catalysis of splicing. It associates with the specific protein Prp24p, and a set of seven LSm2p-8p proteins, to form the U6 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein (snRNP). These proteins have been proposed to act as RNA chaperones that stimulate pairing of U6 with U4 snRNA to form the intermolecular stem I and stem II of the U4/U6 duplex, whose formation is essential for spliceosomal function. However, the mechanism whereby Prp24p and the LSm complex facilitate U4/U6 base-pairing, as well as the exact binding site(s) of Prp24p in the native U6 snRNP, are not well understood. Here, we have investigated the secondary structure of the U6 snRNA in purified U6 snRNPs and compared it with its naked form. Using RNA structure-probing techniques, we demonstrate that within the U6 snRNP a large internal region of the U6 snRNA is unpaired and protected from chemical modification by bound Prp24p. Several of these U6 nucleotides are available for base-pairing interaction, as only their sugar backbone is contacted by Prp24p. Thus, Prp24p can present them to the U4 snRNA and facilitate formation of U4/U6 stem I. We show that the 3' stem-loop is not bound strongly by U6 proteins in native particles. However, when compared to the 3' stem-loop in the naked U6 snRNA, it has a more open conformation, which would facilitate formation of stem II with the U4 snRNA. Our data suggest that the combined association of Prp24p and the LSm complex confers upon U6 nucleotides a conformation favourable for U4/U6 base-pairing. Interestingly, we find that the open structure of the yeast U6 snRNA in native snRNPs can also be adopted by human U6 and U6atac snRNAs.     

Assembly of the U1 snRNP involves interactions with the backbone of the terminal stem of U1 snRNA

Nucleotide analog interference mapping (NAIM) is a powerful method for identifying RNA functional groups involved in protein-RNA interactions. We examined particles assembled on modified U1 small nuclear RNAs (snRNAs) in vitro and detected two categories of interferences. The first class affects the stability of two higher-order complexes and comprises changes in two adenosines, A65 and A70, in the loop region previously identified as the binding site for the U1 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein (snRNP)-specific U1A protein. Addition of an exocyclic amine to position 2 of A65 interferes strongly with protein binding, whereas removal or modification of the exocyclic amine at position 6 makes little difference. Modifications of A70 exhibit the opposite effects: Additions at position 2 are permitted, but modification of the exocyclic amine at position 6 significantly inhibits protein binding. These interactions, critical for U1A-U1 snRNA recognition in the context of in vitro snRNP assembly, are consistent with previous structural studies of the isolated protein with the RNA hairpin containing the U1A binding site. The second category of interferences affects all partially assembled U1-protein complexes by decreasing the stability of Sm core protein associations. Interestingly, most strong interferences occur at phosphates in the terminal stem-loop region of U1, rather than in the Sm binding site. These data argue that interactions with the phosphate backbone of the terminal stem loop are essential for the stable association of Sm core proteins with the U1 snRNA. We suggest that the stem loop of all Sm snRNAs may act as a clamp to hold the ring of Sm proteins in place.     

Direct binding of small nuclear ribonucleoprotein G to the Sm site of small nuclear RNA. Ultraviolet light cross-linking of protein G to the AAU stretch within the Sm site (AAUUUGUGG) of U1 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein reconstituted in vitro.

The major small nuclear ribonucleoproteins (snRNPs) U1, U2, U5 and U4/U6 participate in the splicing of pre-mRNA. U1, U2, U4 and U5 RNAs share a highly conserved sequence motif PuA(U)nGPu, termed the Sm site, which is normally flanked by two hairpin loops. The Sm site provides the major binding site for the group of common proteins, B', B, D1, D2, D3, E, F and G, which are shared by the spliceosomal snRNPs. We have investigated the ability of common snRNP proteins to recognize the Sm site of snRNA by using ultraviolet light-induced RNA-protein cross-linking within U1 snRNP particles. The U1 snRNP particles, reconstituted in vitro, contained U1 snRNA labelled with 32P. Cross-linking of protein to this U1 snRNA occurred only in the presence of the single-stranded stretch of snRNA that makes up the conserved Sm site. Characterization of the cross-linked protein by one and two-dimensional gel electrophoresis indicated that snRNP protein G had become cross-linked to the U1 snRNA. This was confirmed by specific immunoprecipitation of the cross-linked RNA-protein complex with an anti-G antiserum. The cross-link was located on the U1 snRNA by fingerprint analysis with RNases T1 and A; this demonstrated that the protein G has been cross-linked to the AAU stretch within the 5'-terminal half of the Sm site (AAUUUGUGG). These results suggest that the snRNP protein G may be involved in the direct recognition of the Sm site.     

Assembly and dynamics of the U4/U6 di-snRNP by single-molecule FRET

In large ribonucleoprotein machines, such as ribosomes and spliceosomes, RNA functions as an assembly scaffold as well as a critical catalytic component. Protein binding to the RNA scaffold can induce structural changes, which in turn modulate subsequent binding of other components. The spliceosomal U4/U6 di-snRNP contains extensively base paired U4 and U6 snRNAs, Snu13, Prp31, Prp3 and Prp4, seven Sm and seven LSm proteins. We have studied successive binding of all protein components to the snRNA duplex during di-snRNP assembly by electrophoretic mobility shift assay and accompanying conformational changes in the U4/U6 RNA 3-way junction by single-molecule FRET. Stems I and II of the duplex were found to co-axially stack in free RNA and function as a rigid scaffold during the entire assembly, but the U4 snRNA 5′ stem-loop adopts alternative orientations each stabilized by Prp31 and Prp3/4 binding accounting for altered Prp3/4 binding affinities in presence of Prp31.     

Purified U7 snRNPs lack the Sm proteins D1 and D2 but contain Lsm10, a new 14 kDa Sm D1-like protein

U7 snRNPs were isolated from HeLa cells by biochemical fractionation, followed by affinity purification with a biotinylated oligonucleotide complementary to U7 snRNA. Purified U7 snRNPs lack the Sm proteins D1 and D2, but contain additional polypeptides of 14, 50 and 70 kDa. Microsequencing identified the 14 kDa polypeptide as a new Sm-like protein related to Sm D1 and D3. Like U7 snRNA, this protein, named Lsm10, is enriched in Cajal bodies of the cell nucleus. Its incorporation into U7 snRNPs is largely dictated by the special Sm binding site of U7 snRNA. This novel type of Sm complex, composed of both conventional Sm proteins and the Sm-like Lsm10, is most likely to be important for U7 snRNP function and subcellular localization.     

Architecture of the U5 small nuclear RNA.

We have used comparative sequence analysis and deletion analysis to examine the secondary structure of the U5 small nuclear RNA (snRNA), an essential component of the pre-mRNA splicing apparatus. The secondary structure of Saccharomyces cerevisiae U5 snRNA was studied in detail, while sequences from six other fungal species were included in the phylogenetic analysis. Our results indicate that fungal U5 snRNAs, like their counterparts from other taxa, can be folded into a secondary structure characterized by a highly conserved stem-loop (stem-loop 1) that is flanked by a moderately conserved internal loop (internal loop 1). In addition, several of the fungal U5 snRNAs include a novel stem-loop structure (ca. 30 nucleotides) that is adjacent to stem-loop 1. By deletion analysis of the S. cerevisiae snRNA, we have demonstrated that the minimal U5 snRNA that can complement the lethal phenotype of a U5 gene disruption consists of (i) stem-loop 1, (ii) internal loop 1, (iii) a stem-closing internal loop 1, and (iv) the conserved Sm protein binding site. Remarkably, all essential, U5-specific primary sequence elements are encoded by a 39-nucleotide domain consisting of stem-loop 1 and internal loop 1. This domain must, therefore, contain all U5-specific sequences that are essential for splicing activity, including binding sites for U5-specific proteins.     

Multiple requirements for nematode spliced leader RNP function in trans-splicing.

The 5' exon donor in nematode trans-splicing, the SL RNA, is a small (approximately 100 nt) RNA that resembles cis-spliceosomal U snRNAs. Extensive analyses of the RNA sequence requirements for SL RNA function have revealed four essential elements, the core Sm binding site, three nucleotides immediately downstream of this site, a region of Stem-loop II, and a 5' splice site. Although these elements are necessary and sufficient for SL RNA function in vitro, their respective roles in promoting SL RNA activity have not been elucidated. Furthermore, although it has been shown that assembly of the SL RNA into an Sm RNP is a prerequisite for function, the protein composition of the SL RNP has not been determined. Here, we have used oligoribonucleotide affinity to purify the SL RNP and find that it contains core Sm proteins as well as four specific proteins (175, 40, 30, and 28 kDa). Using in vitro assembly assays; we show that association of the 175- and 30-kDa SL-specific proteins correlates with SL RNP function in trans-splicing. Binding of these proteins depends upon the sequence of the core Sm binding site; SL RNAs containing the U1 snRNA Sm binding site assemble into Sm RNPs that contain core, but not SL-specific proteins. Furthermore, mutational and thiophosphate interference approaches reveal that both the primary nucleotide sequence and a specific phosphate oxygen within a segment of Stemloop II of the SL RNA are required for function. Finally, mutational activation of an unusual cryptic 5' splice site within the SL sequence itself suggests that U5 snRNA may play a primary role in selecting and specifying the 5' splice site in SL addition trans-splicing.     

The conserved central domain of yeast U6 snRNA: importance of U2-U6 helix Ia in spliceosome assembly

In the pre-mRNA processing machinery of eukaryotic cells, U6 snRNA is located at or near the active site for pre-mRNA splicing catalysis, and U6 is involved in catalyzing the first chemical step of splicing. We have further defined the roles of key features of yeast U6 snRNA in the splicing process. By assaying spliceosome assembly and splicing in yeast extracts, we found that mutations of yeast U6 nt 56 and 57 are similar to previously reported deletions of U2 nt 27 or 28, all within yeast U2-U6 helix Ia. These mutations lead to the accumulation of yeast A1 spliceosomes, which form just prior to the Prp2 ATPase step and the first chemical step of splicing. These results strongly suggest that, at a late stage of spliceosome assembly, the presence of U2-U6 helix Ia is important for promoting the first chemical step of splicing, presumably by bringing together the 5' splice site region of pre-mRNA, which is base paired to U6 snRNA, and the branchsite region of the intron, which is base paired to U2 snRNA, for activation of the first chemical step of splicing, as previously proposed by Madhani and Guthrie [Cell, 1992, 71: 803-817]. In the 3' intramolecular stem-loop of U6, mutation G81C causes an allele-specific accumulation of U6 snRNP. Base pairing of the U6 3' stem-loop in yeast spliceosomes does not extend as far as to include the U6 sequence of U2-U6 helix Ib, in contrast to the human U6 3' stem-loop structure.     

A phylogenetic study of U4 snRNA reveals the existence of an evolutionarily conserved secondary structure corresponding to 'free' U4 snRNA

The nucleotide sequence of Physarum polycephalum U4 snRNA*** was determined and compared to published U4 snRNA sequences. The primary structure of P polycephalum U4 snRNA is closer to that of plants and animals than to that of fungi. But, both fungi and P polycephalum U4 snRNAs are missing the 3' terminal hairpin and this may be a common feature of lower eucaryote U4 snRNAs. We found that the secondary structure model we previously proposed for 'free' U4 snRNA is compatible with the various U4 snRNA sequences published. The possibility to form this tetrahelix structure is preserved by several compensatory base substitutions and by compensatory nucleotide insertions and deletions. According to this finding, association between U4 and U6 snRNAs implies the disruption of 2 internal helical structures of U4 snRNA. One has a very low free energy, but the other, which represents one-half of the helical region of the 5' hairpin, requires 4 to 5 kcal to be open. The remaining part of the 5' hairpin is maintained in the U4/U6 complex and we observed the conservation, in all U4 snRNAs studied, of a U bulge residue at the limit between the helical region which has to be melted and that which is maintained. The 3' domain of U4 snRNA is less conserved in both size and primary structure than the 5' domain; its structure is also more compact in the RNA in solution. In this domain, only the Sm binding site and the presence of a bulge nucleotide in the hairpin on the 5' side of the Sm site are conserved throughout evolution.     

Characterization of U6 snRNA-protein interactions

Through a combination of in vitro snRNP reconstitution, photocross-linking and immunoprecipitation techniques, we have investigated the interaction of proteins with the spliceosomal U6 snRNA in U6 snRNPs, U4/U6 di-snRNPs and U4/U6.U5 tri-snRNPs. Of the seven Lsm (Sm-like) proteins that associate specifically with this spliceosomal snRNA, three were shown to contact the RNA directly, and to maintain contact as the U6 RNA is incorporated into tri-snRNPs. In tri-snRNPs, the U5 snRNP protein Prp8 contacts position 54 of U6, which is in the conserved region that contributes to the formation of the catalytic core of the spliceosome. Other tri-snRNP-specific contacts were also detected, indicating the dynamic nature of protein interactions with this important snRNA. The uridine-rich extreme 3' end of U6 RNA was shown to be essential but not sufficient for the association of the Lsm proteins. Interestingly, the Lsm proteins associate efficiently with the 3' half of U6, which contains the 3' stem-loop and uridine-rich 3' end, suggesting that the Lsm and Sm proteins may recognize similar features in RNAs.     

In vivo assembly of functional U7 snRNP requires RNA backbone flexibility within the Sm-binding site

Most histone precursor mRNAs (pre-mRNAs) in metazoans are matured by 3'-end cleavage directed by the U7 small nuclear ribonucleoprotein (snRNP). RNA functional groups necessary for in vivo assembly and activity of the U7 snRNP were examined by nucleotide-analog interference mapping and mutagenesis using a chimeric mouse histone H4 pre-mRNA-U7 snRNA construct that is cleaved in cis in Xenopus laevis oocytes. Assembly of the unique U7 Sm protein core is rate limiting for processing in vivo and requires four conserved nucleotides within the U7 Sm-binding site, as well as the correct positioning and size of the U7 terminal stem-loop structure. To our surprise, pseudouridine substitution revealed a requirement for backbone flexibility at a particular position within the U7 Sm site, providing in vivo biochemical evidence that an unusual C2'-endo sugar conformation is necessary for assembly of the Sm ring.     

In vitro assembly of U1 snRNPs.

An efficient system for the in vitro assembly of U1 snRNPs is described. RNA-protein interactions in a series of U1 snRNA mutants assembled both in vivo and in vitro were studied in order to verify the accuracy of the system. Two discrete protein binding sites are defined by immunoprecipitation with antibodies against different protein components of the U1 snRNP and a newly developed protein sequestering assay. The U1 snRNP-specific proteins 70K and A require only the 5'-most stem-loop structure of U1 snRNA for binding, the common U snRNP proteins require the conserved Sm binding site (AUnG). Interactions between these two groups of proteins are detected. These results are combined to derive a model of the U1 snRNP structure. The potential use of the in vitro system in the functional analysis of U1 snRNP proteins is discussed.