Retinoic acid affects patterning along the anterior–posterior axis of the ascidian embryo

Because retinoic acid (RA) is known to affect anterior-posterior patterning in vertebrate embryos, it was questioned whether it shows similar effects in a more primitive chordate, the ascidian Halocynthia roretzi . Ascidian embryos treated with RA exhibited truncated phenotypes in a dose-dependent manner similar to the anterior truncations seen in vertebrate embryos. The most severely affected larvae possessed a round trunk without the papillae characteristic of the anterior terminal epidermis. Retinoic acid also altered the expression of HrHox-1 and Hroth in a dose-dependent manner. Expression of HrHox-1 increased, whereas expression of Hroth decreased with increasing levels of RA. In treated embryos, HrHox-1 was first expressed pan-ectodermally, then degraded in all but specific regions of the embryo. By contrast, initiation of Hroth expression was not affected, but epidermal expression was lost while expression in the neural tube narrowed toward the anterior in tail-bud embryos. These alterations in the expression of homeobox genes appear to correlate closely to the morphological defects elicited by RA treatment, suggesting broad conservation of developmental patterning mechanisms within the Phylum Chordata.     

Patterning the zebrafish heart tube: acquisition of anteroposterior polarity.

The patterning of an internal organ, like the heart, is little understood. Central to this patterning is the formation, or the acquisition, of an anteroposterior (A-P) axis. We have approached the question of how the heart tube acquires polarity in the zebrafish, Brachydanio rerio, which offers numerous advantages for studying cardiac morphogenesis. During the early stages of organogenesis in the fish, the heart tube lies in an A-P orientation with the venous end lying anteriorly and the arterial end lying posteriorly. High doses (10(-6)-10(-5)M) of retinoic acid (RA) cause truncation of the body axis, as they do in Xenopus. Low doses of retinoic acid (10(-8)-10(-7) M), which do not appear to affect the rest of the embryo, have pronounced effects upon heart tube morphogenesis, causing it to shrink progressively along the A-P axis. To investigate this further, we identified monoclonal antibodies that distinguish between the zebrafish cardiac chambers and used them to show that the RA-induced cardiac truncation always begins at the arterial end of the heart tube. There is a continuous gradient of sensitivity from the arterial to the venous end, such that increasing RA exposure causes the progressive and sequential deletion first of the bulbus arteriosus and then, in order, of the ventricle, the atrium, and the sinus venosus. As exposure increases, parts of chambers are deleted before entire chambers; thus, the sensitivity to RA appears to be independent of chamber boundaries. The analysis of the heart tube's sensitivity to RA and its timing suggest that polarity is established during or shortly after initial commitment to the cardiac lineage.     

Retinoic acid signaling in heart development

Retinoic acid (RA) is a vitamin A metabolite that acts as a morphogen and teratogen. Excess or defective RA signaling causes developmental defects including in the heart. The heart develops from the anterior lateral plate mesoderm. Cardiogenesis involves successive steps, including formation of the primitive heart tube, cardiac looping, septation, chamber development, coronary vascularization, and completion of the four‐chambered heart. RA is dispensable for primitive heart tube formation. Before looping, RA is required to define the anterior/posterior boundaries of the heart‐forming mesoderm as well as to form the atrium and sinus venosus. In outflow tract elongation and septation, RA signaling is required to maintain/differentiate cardiogenic progenitors in the second heart field at the posterior pharyngeal arches level. Epicardium‐secreted insulin‐like growth factor, the expression of which is regulated by hepatic mesoderm‐derived erythropoietin under the control of RA, promotes myocardial proliferation of the ventricular wall. Epicardium‐derived RA induces the expression of angiogenic factors in the myocardium to form the coronary vasculature. In cardiogenic events at different stages, properly controlled RA signaling is required to establish the functional heart.     

The volumes of the chambers of the trout heart

Pressure-volume curves were generated for the four chambers of the rainbow trout heart. The maximal end-diastolic volumes of the atrium and sinus venosus were considerably larger than that of the ventricle. The findings indicate that the sinus venosus and atrium act as variable-volume reservoirs that can accommodate changes in ventricular stroke volume within the fixed volume of the pericardium, without compromising vis-à-fronte filling.     

Embryonic retinoic acid synthesis is essential for heart morphogenesis in the mouse

Retinoic acid (RA), the active derivative of vitamin A, has been implicated in various steps of cardiovascular development, but its contribution to early heart morphogenesis has not been clearly established in a mammalian system. To block endogenous RA synthesis, we have disrupted the gene encoding RALDH2, the first retinaldehyde dehydrogenase whose expression has been detected during early mouse post-implantation development. We describe here the heart abnormalities of the RA-deficient Raldh2 mutants that die in utero at gestational day 10.5. The embryonic heart tube forms properly, but fails to undergo rightward looping and, instead, forms a medial distended cavity. Expression of early heart determination factors is not altered in mutants, and the defect in heart looping does not appear to involve the Nodal/Lefty/Pitx2 pathway. Histological and molecular analysis reveal distinct anteroposterior components in the mutant heart tube, although posterior chamber (atria and sinus venosus) development is severely impaired. Instead of forming trabeculae, the developing ventricular myocardium consists of a thick layer of loosely attached cells. Ultrastructural analysis shows that most of the ventricular wall consists of prematurely differentiated cardiomyocytes, whereas undifferentiated cells remain clustered rostrally. We conclude that embryonic RA synthesis is required for realization of heart looping, development of posterior chambers and proper differentiation of ventricular cardiomyocytes. Nevertheless, the precise location of this synthesis may not be crucial, as these defects can mostly be rescued by systemic (maternal) RA administration. However, cardiac neural crest cells cannot be properly rescued in Raldh2(-/- )embryos, leading to outflow tract septation defects.     

Dhrs3a regulates retinoic acid biosynthesis through a feedback inhibition mechanism

Retinoic acid (RA) is an important developmental signaling molecule responsible for the patterning of multiple vertebrate tissues. RA is also a potent teratogen, causing multi-organ birth defects in humans. Endogenous RA levels must therefore be tightly controlled in the developing embryo. We used a microarray approach to identify genes that function as negative feedback regulators of retinoic acid signaling. We screened for genes expressed in early somite-stage embryos that respond oppositely to treatment with RA versus RA antagonists and validated them by RNA in situ hybridization. Focusing on genes known to be involved in RA metabolism, we determined that dhrs3a, which encodes a member of the short-chain dehydrogenase/reductase protein family, is both RA dependent and strongly RA inducible. Dhrs3a is known to catalyze the reduction of the RA precursor all-trans retinaldehyde to vitamin A; however, a developmental function has not been demonstrated. Using morpholino knockdown and mRNA over-expression, we demonstrate that Dhrs3a is required to limit RA levels in the embryo, primarily within the central nervous system. Dhrs3a is thus an RA-induced feedback inhibitor of RA biosynthesis. We conclude that retinaldehyde availability is an important level at which RA biosynthesis is regulated in vertebrate embryos.     

Functional Morphology of the Heart in Fishes

The systemic heart of fishes consists of four chambers in series,the sinus venosus, atrium, ventricle, and conus or bulbus. Valvesbetween the chambers and contraction of all chambers exceptthe bulbus maintain a unidirectional blood flow through theheart. The heart is composed of typical vertebrate cardiac muscle,although there may be minor differences in the distributionof spontaneously active cells, the rate and nature of spreadof excitatory waves, and the characteristics of resting andaction potentials between different fish and other vertebrates.Cholinergic fibers innervate the heart, except in hagfish whichhave aneural hearts. Fish hearts lack sympathetic innervation.The level of vagal tone varies considerably, and is affectedby many factors. In some fish the heart is essentially aneural(without vagal tone) during exercise and may resemble an isolatedmammalian ventricle with increased venous return causing increasedcardiac output. There are many mechanisms that could increasevenous return in exercising fish. rß-adrenergic receptorshave been located on the hearts of some fish, and changing levelsof catecholamines may play a role in regulating cardiac activity.Changes in cardiac output in fish are normally associated withlarge changes in stroke volume and small cha-nges in heart rate.     

Ultrastructural study of the myocardium of the sinus venosus and sinoatrial valve in the dogfish (Scyliorhinus canicula)

The myocardium of the sinus venosus of the dogfish ( Scyliorhinus canicula ) is located between a thick subepicardial collagen-rich layer and a subendocardial network of nerve fibres and ganglion cells. The sinoatrial valve consists of two transversal folds of the cardiac wall which are separated by connective tissue, except in their free margins.
The myocardium of the sinus venosus and the sinusal face of the sinoatrial valve is arranged in bundles which are surrounded by a 40 nm-thick basal lamina. The myocardial cells measure about 7-9 μm in diameter at the nuclear level. Nerve terminals are frequent in the centre of the bundles. Most of the sinusal myocardiocytes have a scarce amount of myofibrils which are randomly orientated. The sarcoplasmic reticulum is relatively well developed and consists of peripheral couplings, subsarcolemmal vesicles, circular and longitudinal tubules. The scarce intercalated discs show only fasciae adhaerentes . Gap junctions, desmosomes or specific granules are not observed in the sinusal myocardiocytes of the dogfish. In contrast, the atrial myocardiocytes are smaller, about 5-6 μm in diameter at the nuclear level. The cytoplasm is denser and the myofibrils are abundant and orientated in parallel directions. Specific granules are present. although scarce. Subsarcolemmal vesicles are less frequent, while the atrial intercalated discs are larger and more abundant than those of the sinus venosus. Neural elements are scarce in the atrium.
The differences observed between sinus venosus and atrium might be related to the morphological criteria to distinguish between the nodal tissue and the working myocardiocytes of higher vertebrates. On the other hand, we think that the connective tissue placed between sinus venom and atrium means that the contraction impulse generated in the sinus venosus must reach the atrium through the free margin of the valve. It might play a role in the sinoatrial valve function.     

Heart inflow tract of the African lungfish Protopterus dolloi

We report a morphologic study of the heart inflow tract of the African lungfish Protopterus dolloi. Attention was paid to the atrium, the sinus venosus, the pulmonary vein, and the atrioventricular (AV) plug, and to the relationships between all these structures. The atrium is divided caudally into two lobes, has a common part above the sinus venosus, and appears attached to the dorsal wall of the ventricle and outflow tract through connective tissue covered by the visceral pericardium. The pulmonary vein enters the sinus venosus and runs longitudinally toward the AV plug. Then it fuses with the pulmonalis fold and disappears as an anatomic entity. However, the oxygenated blood is directly conveyed into the left atrium by the formation of a pulmonary channel. This channel is formed cranially by the pulmonalis fold, ventrally by the AV plug, and caudally and dorsally by the atrial wall. The pulmonalis fold appears as a wide membranous fold which arises from the left side of the AV plug and extends dorsally to form the roof of the pulmonary channel. The pulmonalis fold also forms the right side of the pulmonary channel and sequesters the upper left corner of the sinus venosus from the main circulatory return. The AV plug is a large structure, firmly attached to the ventricular septum, which contains a hyaline cartilaginous core surrounded by connective tissue. The atrium is partially divided into two chambers by the presence of numerous pectinate muscles extended between the dorsal wall of the atrium and the roof of the pulmonary channel. Thus, partial atrial division is both internal and external, precluding the more complete division seen in amphibians. The present report, our own unpublished observations on other Protopterus, and a survey of the literature indicate that not only the Protopterus, but also other lungfish share many morphologic traits.     

Colloquium 14: New Functions for Retinoic Acid in the Developing CNS. The role of retinoic acid in the patterning of the developing nervous system

Retinoic acid (RA) is metabolised from its precursor, retinol (vitamin A). In mammalian embryos, retinol is provided by the mother via the placenta and in birds retinol comes from the yolk. We have studied the role of RA in CNS development in quail embryos by depriving adult quails of retinol in the diet which results in them laying eggs which have no retinol stores. The resulting embryos are therefore retinol and RA deficient. The CNS of these embryos is abnormal in three regards; patterning, neural crest production and neurite outgrowth. With regard to patterning, at an early stage of development prior to somitogenesis, hindbrain patterning genes are not induced which leads to the respecification of the posterior hindbrain territory. This region is not lost from the embryo but instead becomes transformed into an enlarged anterior hindbrain. Another aspect of patterning that is abnormal in these RA deficient embryos is the dorsoventral gene expression domains in the anterior spinal cord. These domains are required for the proper specification of motor neurons, sensory neurons and various classes of interneurons. Consequently these neuronal classes are mis‐specified in the RA deficient embryos. With regard to the neural crest, these cells often fail to migrate correctly and then die in the absence of RA. With regard to neurite outgrowth, very little outgrowth seems to take place in these deficient embryos which suggests that RA is involved in neurite outgrowth. Taking these experiments into the adult to examine the role of RA in neurite regeneration, we have had success in inducing neurite outgrowth in vitro from adult mouse spinal cord by manipulating the retinoic acid receptors which transduce the RA signal at the level of the nucleus.     

Effect of retinoids on <Emphasis Type="Italic">Post2 Нох</Emphasis> gene expression in nereid polychaetes

Retinoic acid (RA) plays an important role in vertebrate development and regeneration. RA signalling directly regulates the expression of Hox genes, being in this way involved in the patterning of the anterior-posterior (AP) axis of vertebrate embryos. So far the relationship between retinoic acid signalling and Hox genes has been shown only for chordates. In this study we incubated juvenile worms and regenerating worms of two polychaete species from the family Nereididae, Alitta virens and Platynereis dumerilii, with all-trans-retinal, the precursor of retinoic acid. Under the influence of all-trans-retinal the anterior expression boundary of Post2 Нох gene shifted towards the anterior end both in intact and in regenerating worms of both species. Our data indicate the existence of a relationship between RA signalling and Нох genes in Protostomia.     

Regionalized metabolic activity establishes boundaries of retinoic acid signalling.

The competence of a cell to respond to the signalling molecule retinoic acid (RA) is thought to depend largely on its repertoire of cognate zinc finger nuclear receptors. XCYP26 is an RA hydroxylase that is expressed differentially during early Xenopus development. In Xenopus embryos, XCYP26 can rescue developmental defects induced by application of exogenous RA, suggesting that the enzymatic modifications introduced inhibit RA signalling activities in vivo. Alterations in the expression pattern of a number of different molecular markers for neural development induced upon ectopic expression of XCYP26 reflect a primary function of RA signalling in hindbrain development. Progressive inactivation of RA signalling results in a stepwise anteriorization of the molecular identity of individual rhombomeres. The expression pattern of XCYP26 during gastrulation appears to define areas within the prospective neural plate that develop in response to different concentrations of RA. Taken together, these observations appear to reflect an important regulatory function of XCYP26 for RA signalling; XCYP26-mediated modification of RA modulates its signalling activity and helps to establish boundaries of differentially responsive and non-responsive territories.     

A novel role for retinoids in patterning the avian forebrain during presomite stages

Retinoids, and in particular retinoic acid (RA), are known to induce posterior fates in neural tissue. However, alterations in retinoid signalling dramatically affect anterior development. Previous reports have demonstrated a late role for retinoids in patterning craniofacial and forebrain structures, but an earlier role in anterior patterning is not well understood. We show that enzymes involved in synthesizing retinoids are expressed in the avian hypoblast and in tissues directly involved in head patterning, such as anterior definitive endoderm and prechordal mesendoderm. We found that in the vitamin A-deficient (VAD) quail model, which lacks biologically active RA from the first stages of development, anterior endodermal markers such as Bmp2, Bmp7, Hex and the Wnt antagonist crescent are affected during early gastrulation. Furthermore, prechordal mesendodermal and prospective ventral telencephalic markers are expanded posteriorly, Shh expression in the axial mesoderm is reduced, and Bmp2 and Bmp7 are abnormally expressed in the ventral midline of the neural tube. At early somite stages, VAD embryos have increased cell death in ventral neuroectoderm and foregut endoderm, but normal cranial neural crest production, whereas at later stages extensive apoptosis occurs in head mesenchyme and ventral neuroectoderm. As a result, VAD embryos end up with a single and reduced telencephalic vesicle and an abnormally patterned diencephalon. Therefore, we propose that retinoids have a dual role in patterning the anterior forebrain during development. During early gastrulation, RA acts in anterior endodermal cells to modulate the anteroposterior (AP) positional identity of prechordal mesendodermal inductive signals to the overlying neuroectoderm. Later on, at neural pore closure, RA is required for patterning of the mesenchyme of the frontonasal process and the forebrain by modulating signalling molecules involved in craniofacial morphogenesis.     

The heart-forming fields: one or multiple?

The recent identification of a second mesodermal region as a source of cardiomyocytes has challenged the views on the formation of the heart. This second source of cardiomyocytes is localized centrally on the embryonic disc relative to the remainder of the classic cardiac crescent, a region also called the pharyngeal mesoderm. In this review, we discuss the concept of the primary and secondary cardiogenic fields in the context of folding of the embryo, and the subsequent temporal events involved in formation of the heart. We suggest that, during evolution, the heart developed initially only with the components required for a systemic circulation, namely a sinus venosus, a common atrium, a 'left' ventricle and an arterial cone, the latter being the myocardial outflow tract as seen in the heart of primitive fishes. These components developed in their entirety from the classic cardiac crescent. Only later in the course of evolution did the appearance of novel signalling pathways permit the central part of the cardiac crescent, and possibly the contiguous pharyngeal mesoderm, to develop into the cardiac components required for the pulmonary circulation. These latter components comprise the right ventricle, and that part of the left atrium that derives from the mediastinal myocardium, namely the dorsal atrial wall and the atrial septum. It is these elements which are now recognized as developing from the second field of pharyngeal mesoderm. We suggest that, rather than representing development from separate fields, the cardiac components required for both the systemic and pulmonary circulations are derived by patterning from a single cardiac field, albeit with temporal delay in the process of formation.     

Regulation of retinoic acid distribution is required for proximodistal patterning and outgrowth of the developing mouse limb

Exogenous retinoic acid (RA) induces marked effects on limb patterning, but the precise role of endogenous RA in this process has remained unknown. We have studied the role of RA in mouse limb development by focusing on CYP26B1, a cytochrome P450 enzyme that inactivates RA. Cyp26b1 was shown to be expressed in the distal region of the developing limb bud, and mice that lack CYP26B1 exhibited severe limb malformation (meromelia). The lack of CYP26B1 resulted in spreading of the RA signal toward the distal end of the developing limb and induced proximodistal patterning defects characterized by expansion of proximal identity and restriction of distal identity. CYP26B1 deficiency also induced pronounced apoptosis in the developing limb and delayed chondrocyte maturation. Wild-type embryos exposed to excess RA phenocopied the limb defects of Cyp26b1(-/-) mice. These observations suggest that RA acts as a morphogen to determine proximodistal identity, and that CYP26B1 prevents apoptosis and promotes chondrocyte maturation, in the developing limb.     

Independent roles for retinoic acid in segmentation and neuronal differentiation in the zebrafish hindbrain

Segmentation of the vertebrate hindbrain into rhombomeres is essential for the anterior-posterior patterning of cranial motor nuclei and their associated nerves. The vitamin A derivative, retinoic acid (RA), is an early embryonic signal that specifies rhombomeres, but its roles in neuronal differentiation within the hindbrain remain unclear. Here we have analyzed the formation of primary and secondary hindbrain neurons in the zebrafish mutant neckless (nls), which disrupts retinaldehyde dehydrogenase 2 (raldh2), and in embryos treated with retinoid receptor (RAR) antagonists. Mutation of nls disrupts secondary, branchiomotor neurons of the facial and vagal nerves, but not the segmental pattern of primary, reticulospinal neurons, suggesting that RA acts on branchiomotor neurons independent of its role in hindbrain segmentation. Very few vagal motor neurons form in nls mutants and many facial motor neurons do not migrate out of rhombomere 4 into more posterior segments. When embryos are treated with RAR antagonists during gastrulation, we observe more severe patterning defects than seen in nls. These include duplicated reticulospinal neurons and posterior expansions of rhombomere 4, as well as defects in branchiomotor neurons. However, later antagonist treatments after rhombomeres are established still disrupt branchiomotor development, suggesting that requirements for RARs in these neurons occur later and independent of segmental patterning. We also show that RA produced by the paraxial mesoderm controls branchiomotor differentiation, since we can rescue the entire motor innervation pattern by transplanting wild-type cells into the somites of nls mutants. Thus, in addition to its role in determining rhombomere identities, RA plays a more direct role in the differentiation of subsets of branchiomotor neurons within the hindbrain.     

Fin duplications and deletions induced by disruption of retinoic acid signaling

 Retinoic acid (RA), a derivative of vitamin A, plays a critical role as a signaling molecule in axial patterning of vertebrates. Here we report that RA exposure of zebrafish (Danio rerio) and mummichog (Fundulus heteroclitus) embryos during gastrulation results in homeotic duplications of the pectoral fins in up to 94% of fish. We have observed three to four pairs of fins in an individual fish. Although some duplications are partial, many represent complete axial duplications of the pectoral girdle and fin and include coracoscapulae, proximal radials, and dermal fin elements. Fin duplications are observed only at a defined dose of RA. Inhibition of RA synthesis by exposure to citral during a narrow developmental window leads to fish which lack pectoral fins but can be rescued by addition of exogenous RA, suggesting that RA signaling is critical to fin specification during early development. The ability to consistently induce multiple fins in a large number of vertebrate embryos should contribute to the understanding of genetic regulation of the normal positioning of limbs during embryogenesis. Received: 30 August 1997 / Accepted: 6 December 1997     

Retinoic acid-mediated patterning of the pre-pancreatic endoderm in Xenopus operates via direct and indirect mechanisms

Early patterning of the endoderm as a prerequisite for pancreas specification involves retinoic acid (RA) as a critical signalling molecule in gastrula stage Xenopus embryos. In extension of our previous studies, we made systematic use of early embryonic endodermal and mesodermal explants. We find RA to be sufficient to induce pancreas-specific gene expression in dorsal but not ventral endoderm. The differential expression of retinoic acid receptors (RARs) in gastrula stage endoderm is important for the distinct responsiveness of dorsal versus ventral explants. Furthermore, BMP signalling, that is repressed dorsally, prevents the formation of pancreatic precursor cells in the ventral endoderm of gastrula stage Xenopus embryos. An additional requirement for mesoderm suggests the production of one or more further pancreas inducing signals by this tissue. Finally, recombination of manipulated early embryonic explants, and also inhibition of RA activity in whole embryos, reveal that RA signalling, as it is relevant for pancreas development, operates simultaneously on both mesodermal and endodermal germ layers.