Antimicrobial peptides in toroidal and cylindrical pores

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are small, usually cationic peptides, which permeabilize biological membranes. Their mechanism of action is still not well understood. Here we investigate the preference of alamethicin and melittin for pores of different shapes, using molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of the peptides in pre-formed toroidal and cylindrical pores. When an alamethicin hexamer is initially embedded in a cylindrical pore, at the end of the simulation the pore remains cylindrical or closes if glutamines in the N-termini are not located within the pore. On the other hand, when a melittin tetramer is embedded in toroidal pore or in a cylindrical pore, at the end of the simulation the pore is lined both with peptides and lipid headgroups, and, thus, can be classified as a toroidal pore. These observations agree with the prevailing views that alamethicin forms barrel-stave pores whereas melittin forms toroidal pores. Both alamethicin and melittin form amphiphilic helices in the presence of membranes, but their net charge differs; at pH ∼ 7, the net charge of alamethicin is − 1 whereas that of melittin is + 5. This gives rise to stronger electrostatic interactions of melittin with membranes than those of alamethicin. The melittin tetramer interacts more strongly with lipids in the toroidal pore than in the cylindrical one, due to more favorable electrostatic interactions.     

Charge distribution and imperfect amphipathicity affect pore formation by antimicrobial peptides

Antimicrobial peptides often permeabilize biological membranes via a pore mechanism. Two pore types have been proposed: toroidal, where the pore is partly lined by lipid, and barrel-stave, where a cylindrical pore is completely lined by peptides. What drives the preference of antimicrobial peptides for a certain pore type is not yet fully understood. According to neutron scattering and oriented circular dichroism, melittin and MG-H2 induce toroidal pores whereas alamethicin forms barrel-stave pores. In previous work we found that indeed melittin seems to favor toroidal pores whereas alamethicin favors cylindrical pores. Here we designed mutants of these two peptides and the magainin analog MG-H2, aimed to probe how the distribution of charges along the helix and its imperfectly amphipathic structure influence pore formation. Molecular dynamics (MD) simulations of the peptides in a pre-formed cylindrical pore have been performed. The duration of the simulations was 136ns to 216ns. We found that a melittin mutant with lysine 7 neutralized favors cylindrical pores whereas a MG-H2 mutant with lysines in the N-terminal half of these peptides neutralized and an alamethicin mutant with a positive charge at the position 7 form semitoroidal pores. These results suggest that charged residues within the N-terminal half are important for toroidal pore formation. Toroidal pores produced by MG-H2 are more disordered than the melittin pores, likely because of the charged residues located in the middle of the MG-H2 helix (K11 and K14). Imperfect amphipathicity of melittin seems to play a role in its preference for toroidal pores since the substitutions of charged residues located within the nonpolar face by hydrophobic residues suppress evolution of a toroidal pore. The mutations change the position of lysine 7 near the N-terminus, relative to the lower leaflet headgroups. The MD simulations also show that the melittin P14A mutant forms a toroidal pore, but its configuration diverges from that of melittin and it is probably metastable.     

Evidence for membrane thinning effect as the mechanism for peptide-induced pore formation

Antimicrobial peptides have two binding states in a lipid bilayer, a surface state S and a pore-forming state I. The transition from the S state to the I state has a sigmoidal peptide-concentration dependence indicating cooperativity in the peptide-membrane interactions. In a previous paper, we reported the transition of alamethicin measured in three bilayer conditions. The data were explained by a free energy that took into account the membrane thinning effect induced by the peptides. In this paper, the full implications of the free energy were tested by including another type of peptide, melittin, that forms toroidal pores, instead of barrel-stave pores as in the case of alamethicin. The S-to-I transitions were measured by oriented circular dichroism. The membrane thinning effect was measured by x-ray diffraction. All data were in good agreement with the theory, indicating that the membrane thinning effect is a plausible mechanism for the peptide-induced pore formations.     

Barrel-stave model or toroidal model? A case study on melittin pores

Transmembrane pores induced by amphiphilic peptides, including melittin, are often modeled with the barrel-stave model after the alamethicin pore. We examine this assumption on melittin by using two methods, oriented circular dichroism (OCD) for detecting the orientation of melittin helix and neutron scattering for detecting transmembrane pores. OCD spectra of melittin were systematically measured. Melittin can orient either perpendicularly or parallel to a lipid bilayer, depending on the physical condition and the composition of the bilayer. Transmembrane pores were detected when the helices oriented perpendicularly to the plane of the bilayers, not when the helices oriented parallel to the bilayers. The evidence that led to the barrel-stave model for alamethicin and that to the toroidal model for magainin were reviewed. The properties of melittin pores are closely similar to that of magainin but unlike that of alamethicin. We conclude that, among naturally produced peptides that we have investigated, only alamethicin conforms to the barrel-stave model. Other peptides, including magainins, melittin and protegrins, all appear to induce transmembrane pores that conform to the toroidal model in which the lipid monolayer bends continuously through the pore so that the water core is lined by both the peptides and the lipid headgroups.     

Many-body effect of antimicrobial peptides: on the correlation between lipid's spontaneous curvature and pore formation

Recently we have shown that the free energy for pore formation induced by antimicrobial peptides contains a term representing peptide-peptide interactions mediated by membrane thinning. This many-body effect gives rise to the cooperative concentration dependence of peptide activities. Here we performed oriented circular dichroism and x-ray diffraction experiments to study the lipid dependence of this many-body effect. In particular we studied the correlation between lipid's spontaneous curvature and peptide's threshold concentration for pore formation by adding phosphatidylethanolamine and lysophosphocholine to phosphocholine bilayers. Previously it was argued that this correlation exhibited by magainin and melittin supported the toroidal model for the pores. Here we found similar correlations exhibited by melittin and alamethicin. We found that the main effect of varying the spontaneous curvature of lipid is to change the degree of membrane thinning, which in turn influences the threshold concentration for pore formation. We discuss how to interpret the lipid dependence of membrane thinning.     

Toroidal pores formed by antimicrobial peptides show significant disorder

A large variety of antimicrobial peptides have been shown to act, at least in vitro, by poration of the lipid membrane. The nanometre size of these pores, however, complicates their structural characterization by experimental techniques. Here we use molecular dynamics simulations, to study the interaction of a specific class of antimicrobial peptides, melittin, with a dipalmitoylphosphatidylcholine bilayer in atomic detail. We show that transmembrane pores spontaneously form above a critical peptide to lipid ratio. The lipid molecules bend inwards to form a toroidally shaped pore but with only one or two peptides lining the pore. This is in strong contrast to the traditional models of toroidal pores in which the peptides are assumed to adopt a transmembrane orientation. We find that peptide aggregation, either prior or after binding to the membrane surface, is a prerequisite to pore formation. The presence of a stable helical secondary structure of the peptide, however is not. Furthermore, results obtained with modified peptides point to the importance of electrostatic interactions in the poration process. Removing the charges of the basic amino-acid residues of melittin prevents pore formation. It was also found that in the absence of counter ions pores not only form more rapidly but lead to membrane rupture. The rupture process occurs via a novel recursive poration pathway, which we coin the Droste mechanism.     

Investigation of toroidal pore and oligomerization by melittin using transmission electron microscopy

We studied the effects of melittin on various cell wall components and vesicles of various lipid compositions. To interact with the cytoplasmic membrane, melittin must traverse the cell wall, which is composed of oligosaccharides. Here, we found that melittin had a strong affinity for chitin, peptidoglycan, and lipopolysaccharide. We further examined the influence of lipid compositions on the lysis of the membranes by melittin. The result showed that melittin bound better to negatively charged than to zwitterionic lipid vesicles but was more potent at inducing leakage from zwitterionic lipid vesicles. Our studies further indicated that the oligomeric state of melittin varied between tetramers and octamers during the formation of toroidal pores. Dextran leakage experiments confirmed the formation and dimension of these toroidal pores. Finally, transmission electron microscopy revealed that melittin formed pores via peptide oligomerization by the toroidal pore-forming mechanism. The toroidal pores composed of 7-8 nm diameter rings that encircled 3.5-4.5 nm diameter cavities on zwitterionic lipid vesicles.     

Energetics of pore formation induced by membrane active peptides

Antimicrobial peptides are known to form pores in cell membranes. We study this process in model bilayers of various lipid compositions. We use two of the best-studied peptides, alamethicin and melittin, to represent peptides making two types of pores, that is, barrel-stave pores and toroidal pores. In both cases, the key control variable is the concentration of the bound peptides in the lipid bilayers (expressed in the peptide-lipid molar ratio, P/L). The method of oriented circular dichroism (OCD) was used to monitor the peptide orientation in bilayers as a function of P/L. The same samples were scanned by X-ray diffraction to measure the bilayer thickness. In all cases, the bilayer thickness decreases linearly with P/L and then levels off after P/L exceeds a lipid-dependent critical value, (P/L)*. OCD spectra showed that the helical peptides are oriented parallel to the bilayers as long as P/L < (P/L)*, but as P/L increases over (P/L)*, an increasing fraction of peptides changed orientation to become perpendicular to the bilayer. We analyzed the data by assuming an internal membrane tension associated with the membrane thinning. The free energy containing this tension term leads to a relation explaining the P/L-dependence observed in the OCD and X-ray diffraction measurements. We extracted the experimental parameters from this thermodynamic relation. We believe that they are the quantities that characterize the peptide-lipid interactions related to the mechanism of pore formation. We discuss the meaning of these parameters and compare their values for different lipids and for the two different types of pores. These experimental parameters are useful for further molecular analysis and are excellent targets for molecular dynamic simulation studies.     

Molecular details on the intermediate states of melittin action on a cell membrane

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) provide a promising solution to the serious threat of multidrug-resistant bacteria or superbugs to public healthcare, due to their unique disruption to bacterial membrane such as perforation. Unfortunately, the underlying action mechanism of AMPs, especially the possible transition between the membrane binding and perforation states of peptides (i.e., the classical two-state model), is still largely unknown. Herein, by combining experimental techniques with pertinent membrane models and molecular dynamic (MD) simulations, new insights into the intermediate states of the AMP melittin-membrane interaction process are obtained. Specifically, it is demonstrated that, after the initial binding, the accumulated melittin on the bilayer triggers vigorous fluctuation of the membrane and even extracts some lipid molecules exclusively from the deformed outer leaflet of the bilayer. Such a distinctive mass removal manner and the resultant local asymmetry in lipid number between the two leaflets change the mechanical status of the membrane and in turn reduce the free energy barrier for the melittin insertion. Finally, the formation of the transmembrane pores is facilitated significantly. These findings provide new insights into the complicated antimicrobial mechanisms of AMPs.     

Piscidin,Fish Antimicrobial Peptide: Structure,Classification, Properties,Mechanism, Gene Regulation and Therapeutical Importance

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are short molecules produced by almost all organisms. Fish AMPs contain innate immune components as their primary immune molecules. The fish AMPs include piscidins, hepcidins, defensins, cathelicidins and histone-derived peptides. Piscidin is potent and broad-spectrum; this peptide was conserved among Acanthopterygii superorder and is therapeutically important among other AMPs. It was present mainly in the tissues of gills, muscle, head-kidney, skin and intestine of teleost. Piscidin AMP family includes piscidin, moronecidin, pleurocidin, epinecidin, gaduscidin, misgurin, dicentracin, chrysophsin and myxinidin. This review reports the structural properties of various piscidin and their mode of action as it is important to know their mechanism how the peptide involved in antimicrobial activity. In addition, the gene expression of piscidin which influenced the immune responses, their pharmaceutical importance and biological applications were described. Overall, the review explains a broad spectrum of knowledge on piscidin, its classes and types, structure, cytotoxicity, membrane permeabilization, properties and therapeutical implications.

     

Influence of the arrangement and secondary structure of melittin peptides on the formation and stability of toroidal pores

Melittin interactions with lipid bilayers and melittin formed pores are extensively studied to understand the mechanism of the toroidal pore formation. Early experimental studies suggested that melittin peptide molecules are anchored by their positively charged residues located next to the C-terminus to only one leaflet of the lipid bilayer (asymmetric arrangement). However, the recent non-linear spectroscopic experiment suggests a symmetric arrangement of the peptides with the C-terminus of the peptides anchored to both bilayers. Therefore, we present here a computational study that compares the effect of symmetric and asymmetric arrangements of melittin peptides in the toroidal pore formation. We also investigate the role of the peptide secondary structure during the pore formation. Two sets of the symmetric and asymmetric pores are prepared, one with a helical peptide from the crystal structure and the other set with a less helical peptide. We observe a stable toroidal pore being formed only in the system with a symmetric arrangement of the less helical peptides. Based on the simulation results we propose that the symmetric arrangement of the peptides might be more favorable than the asymmetric arrangement, and that the helical secondary structure is not a prerequisite for the formation of the toroidal pore.     

The Structure of a Melittin-Stabilized Pore

Melittin has been reported to form toroidal pores under certain conditions, but the atomic-resolution structure of these pores is unknown. A 9-μs all-atom molecular-dynamics simulation starting from a closely packed transmembrane melittin tetramer in DMPC shows formation of a toroidal pore after 1 μs. The pore remains stable with a roughly constant radius for the rest of the simulation. Surprisingly, one or two melittin monomers frequently transition between transmembrane and surface states. All four peptides are largely helical. A simulation in a DMPC/DMPG membrane did not lead to a stable pore, consistent with the experimentally observed lower activity of melittin on anionic membranes. The picture that emerges from this work is rather close to the classical toroidal pore, but more dynamic with respect to the configuration of the peptides.     

Bicontinuous inverted cubic phase stabilization as an index of antimicrobial and membrane fusion peptide activity

Some antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) and membrane fusion-catalyzing peptides (FPs) stabilize bicontinuous inverted cubic (Q_II) phases. Previous authors proposed a topological rationale: since AMP-induced pores, fusion intermediates, and Q_II phases all have negative Gaussian curvature (NGC), peptides which produce NGC in one structure also do it in another. This assumes that peptides change the curvature energy of the lipid membranes. Here I test this with a Helfrich curvature energy model. First, experimentally, I show that lipid systems often used to study peptide NGC have NGC without peptides at higher temperatures. To determine the net effect of an AMP on NGC, the equilibrium phase behavior of the host lipids must be determined. Second, the model shows that AMPs must make large changes in the curvature energy to stabilize AMP-induced pores. Peptide-induced changes in elastic constants affect pores and Q_II phase differently. Changes in spontaneous curvature affect them in opposite ways. The observed correlation between Q_II phase stabilization and AMP activity doesn't show that AMPs act by lowering pore curvature energy. A different rationale is proposed. In theory, AMPs could simultaneously stabilize Q_II phase and pores by drastically changing two particular elastic constants. This could be tested by measuring AMP effects on the individual constants. I propose experiments to do that. Unlike AMPs, FPs must make only small changes in the curvature energy to catalyze fusion. It they act in this way, their fusion activity should correlate with their ability to stabilize Q_II phases.     

Antimicrobial Properties and Membrane-Active Mechanism of a Potential α-Helical Antimicrobial Derived from Cathelicidin PMAP-36

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs), which present in the non-specific immune system of organism, are amongst the most promising candidates for the development of novel antimicrobials. The modification of naturally occurring AMPs based on their residue composition and distribution is a simple and effective strategy for optimization of known AMPs. In this study, a series of truncated and residue-substituted derivatives of antimicrobial peptide PMAP-36 were designed and synthesized. The 24-residue truncated peptide, GI24, displayed antimicrobial activity comparable to the mother peptide PMAP-36 with MICs ranging from 1 to 4 µM, which is lower than the MICs of bee venom melittin. Although GI24 displayed high antimicrobial activity, its hemolytic activity was much lower than melittin, suggesting that GI24 have optimal cell selectivity. In addition, the crucial site of GI24 was identified through single site-mutation. An amino acid with high hydrophobicity at position 23 played an important role in guaranteeing the high antimicrobial activity of GI24. Then, lipid vesicles and whole bacteria were employed to investigate the membrane-active mechanisms. Membrane-simulating experiments showed that GI24 interacted strongly with negatively charged phospholipids and weakly with zwitterionic phospholipids, which corresponded well with the data of its biological activities. Membrane permeabilization and flow cytometry provide the evidence that GI24 killed microbial cells by permeabilizing the cell membrane and damaging membrane integrity. GI24 resulted in greater cell morphological changes and visible pores on cell membrane as determined using scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and transmission electron microscope (TEM). Taken together, the peptide GI24 may provide a promising antimicrobial agent for therapeutic applications against the frequently-encountered bacteria.     

Leakage of internal markers from erythrocytes and lipid vesicles induced by melittin, gramicidin S and alamethicin: a comparative study.

The membrane-disruptive capacities of melittin, derivatised melittins, alamethicin and gramicidin S have been compared for the human erythrocyte membrane and lipid vesicles of three different compositions (phosphatidylcholine, 85% phosphatidylcholine/15% phosphatidylserine, and a lipid analogue of the outer leaflet of the human erythrocyte membrane). The sensitivity to ionic strength, divalent metal ions and polylysine of release of fluorescent markers from liposomes and of haemoglobin from intact erythrocytes has been assayed. Acetyl melittin was found to he more effective than melittin in lysing phosphatidylcholine and phosphatidylcholine/phosphatidylserine vesicles, somewhat less effective in the lipid analogue and markedly less effective in lysing erythrocytes. Succinyl melittin was non-haemolytic, but was able to lyse lipid vesicles at a high concentration. Ca2+ inhibited melittin haemolysis at high ionic strength (150 mM NaCl), but produced a more complex response of stimulation followed by inhibition at low ionic strength. In lipid vesicles, Ca2+ either stimulated melittin lysis or was ineffective. Zn2+ exerted effects similar to Ca2+ with lipid vesicles at approx. 10-fold lower concentration except that a weak inhibition was observed for the erythrocyte membrane lipid analogue at high ionic strength. Polylysine strongly inhibited haemolysis by melittin at low ionic strength, but was ineffective or stimulatory in lipid vesicle lysis. High phosphate concentration also inhibited melittin haemolysis, but again no corresponding effect could he found in any of the lipid vesicle systems. These disparities between effects of melittin on erythrocytes and lipid vesicles support the proposal that melittin-protein interactions are of consequence to its haemolytic action. Similar experiments were performed with gramicidin S and alamethicin in order to compare their lytic properties with those of melittin. It was found that each lysin exhibited its own individual pattern of sensitivity to lipid composition, ionic strength and inhibition by cations. It thus appears likely that the detailed molecular interactions responsible for lysis are significantly different for each of these three agents.     

Melittin-Induced Permeabilization,Re-sealing,and Re-permeabilization of E. coli Membranes

The permeabilization of model lipid bilayers by cationic peptides has been studied extensively over decades, with the bee-sting toxin melittin perhaps serving as the canonical example. However, the relevance of these studies to the permeabilization of real bacterial membranes by antimicrobial peptides remains uncertain. Here, we employ single-cell fluorescence microscopy in a detailed study of the interactions of melittin with the outer membrane (OM) and the cytoplasmic membrane (CM) of live Escherichia coli. Using periplasmic green fluorescent protein (GFP) as a probe, we find that melittin at twice the minimum inhibitory concentration first induces abrupt cell shrinkage and permeabilization of the OM to GFP. Within ～4 s of OM permeabilization, the CM invaginates to form inward facing “periplasmic bubbles.” Seconds later the bubbles begin to leak periplasmic GFP into the cytoplasm. Permeabilization is localized, consistent with possible formation of toroidal pores. Within ～20 s, first the OM and then the CM re-seals to GFP. Some 2–20 min later, both CM and OM are re-permeabilized to GFP. We invoke a mechanism based on curvature stress concepts derived from model bilayer studies. The permeabilization and re-sealing events involve sequential, time-dependent build-up of melittin density within the outer and inner leaflets of each bilayer. We also propose a mechanical explanation for the early cell shrinkage event induced by melittin and a variety of other cationic peptides. As peptides gain access to the periplasm, they bind to the anionic peptido-crosslinks of the lipopolysaccharide layer, increasing its longitudinal elastic modulus. The cell wall shrinks because it can withstand the same turgor pressure with smaller overall extension. Shrinkage in turn induces invagination of the CM, preserving its surface area. We conclude by comparing the behavior of different peptides.     

Molecular mechanism of antimicrobial peptides: the origin of cooperativity

Based on very extensive studies on four peptides (alamethicin, melittin, magainin and protegrin), we propose a mechanism to explain the cooperativity exhibited by the activities of antimicrobial peptides, namely, a non-linear concentration dependence characterized by a threshold and a rapid rise to saturation as the concentration exceeds the threshold. We first review the structural basis of the mechanism. Experiments showed that peptide binding to lipid bilayers creates two distinct states depending on the bound-peptide to lipid ratio P/L. For P/L below a threshold P/L*, all of the peptide molecules are in the S state that has the following characteristics: (1) there are no pores in the membrane, (2) the axes of helical peptides are oriented parallel to the plane of membrane, and (3) the peptide causes membrane thinning in proportion to P/L. As P/L increases above P/L*, essentially all of the excessive peptide molecules occupy the I state that has the following characteristics: (1) transmembrane pores are detected in the membrane, (2) the axes of helical peptides are perpendicular to the plane of membrane, (3) the membrane thickness remains constant for P/L> or =P/L*. The free energy based on these two states agrees with the data quantitatively. The free energy also explains why lipids of positive curvature (lysoPC) facilitate and lipids of negative curvature (PE) inhibit pore formation.     

The effect of membrane curvature on the conformation of antimicrobial peptides: implications for binding and the mechanism of action

Short cationic antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are believed to act either by inducing transmembrane pores or disrupting membranes in a detergent-like manner. For example, the antimicrobial peptides aurein 1.2, citropin 1.1, maculatin 1.1 and caerin 1.1, despite being closely related, appear to act by fundamentally different mechanisms depending on their length. Using molecular dynamics simulations, the structural properties of these four peptides have been examined in solution as well as in a variety of membrane environments. It is shown that each of the peptides has a strong preference for binding to regions of high membrane curvature and that the structure of the peptides is dependent on the degree of local curvature. This suggests that the shorter peptides aurein 1.2 and citropin 1.1 act via a detergent-like mechanism because they can induce high local, but not long-range curvature, whereas the longer peptides maculatin 1.1 and caerin 1.1 require longer range curvature to fold and thus bind to and stabilize transmembrane pores.     

Effects of membrane channel-forming polypeptides on mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation. A comparison of alamethicin, gramicidin A, melittin and tetraacetyl melittin

Transmembrane channel-forming polypeptides can function as uncouplers of mitochondrial oxidative phosphorylation. The observed effects are dependent on the phosphate ion (Pi) concentration in the medium. At low Pi (2.5 mM) the order of uncoupling efficiencies is gramicidin A much greater than alamethicin greater than tetraacetyl melittin greater than melittin. The remarkably high activity of gramicidin A suggests insertion of preformed channel dimers into the membrane. It is also suggested that lipid phase association of peptides is necessary in the other cases. At Pi = 100 mM inhibitory effects are observed for alamethicin and tetraacetyl melittin. Less pronounced inhibition is seen for melittin, while no such effect is noted for gramicidin A. The site of inhibition is shown to be complex IV, and the differences in the behavior of the peptides are rationalized in terms of channel structures.