Polar organic phase liquid chromatography with packed capillary columns using a vancomycin chiral stationary phase

Vancomycin immobilized on silica served as the chiral stationary phase (CSP) in this investigation with polar organic solvents as the mobile phase in liquid chromatography (LC). It was shown that trace amounts of water were beneficial for improving peak shape and efficiency. To regulate the retention and selectivity an acid and/or base were added to the mobile phase where an excess of acid was shown to be preferential for enantioseparation. An unusual increase in selectivity with increasing temperature was shown for the acidic drug, thalidomide. Additionally, nonlinear van't Hoff plots were obtained for metoprolol enantiomers that showed increased retention with increasing temperature. Metoprolol also showed unusual behavior in the polar organic phase when water was added to resemble reversed-phase chromatography, with minimum retention observed at high water or high methanol concentrations. In both instances a high degree of electrostatic interaction between metoprolol and vancomycin was concluded. Metoprolol and ten of its analogs were examined on this CSP to evaluate the enantiorecognition process. A comparison in enantioselectivity for a number of acidic and basic drugs using this CSP was also carried out using the polar organic phase, reversed phase, and normal phase LC which were all compared to the results obtained in supercritical fluid chromatography (SFC). Polar organic phase LC offered a better separation of basic molecules while reversed phase LC was preferred for the resolution of acids. SFC showed the broadest enantioselectivity overall and normal phase LC indicated similar properties, as expected, to SFC but with lower column efficiency. Copyright 2000 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Studies on the enantioselective retention mechanisms of cellobiohydrolase I (CBH I) by covalent modification of the intact and fragmented protein

In order to elucidate the chiral recognition mechanisms of the enzyme cellobiohydrolase I (CBH I), its carboxylic groups were covalently modified. The synthetic modification was carried out either in the presence or absence of cellobiose, which has proven to inhibit the enzymatic activity and if present in the mobile phase impairs enantioselectivity of amino alcohols. Compared to the reference CSP (unmodified CBH-I silica and CBH-I core silica), the synthetically modified phases show differences both in enantioselectivity and retention. The enzymatic differences between the CSPs were also in line with the chromatographic results. The selectivity factors of propranolol are almost unchanged during the reaction periods in the presence of cellobiose, while they decreased rapidly without the inhibitor. In one case, even a slight improvement in enantioselectivity was obtained, indicating that non-stereospecific carboxylic groups were ruled out. Chirality 10:760–769, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Mobile phase effects on enantiomer resolution using molecularly imprinted polymers

The aim of this study was to rationalise retention behaviour of a chiral solute on molecularly imprinted polymer (MIP) HPLC stationary phases in terms of variation of the mobile phase. It is generally held that the most important interaction governing the separation of enantiomers on such materials is H-bonding, and that retention times increase with decreasing H-bonding potential of the mobile phase. Previous studies have largely concerned mobile phases containing chloroform with acetic acid as a polar modifier. Boc-L-Phenylalanine (Boc-L-Phe-OH) MIPs were prepared, processed, and packed into HPLC columns, which were then used to investigate the retention characteristics of Boc-L-Phe-OH and Boc-D-Phe-OH with a range of mobile phases. The main observations were as follows: (1) in chloroform-based mobile phases there was generally a linear relationship between the H-bond donator factor of the polar modifier and capacity (K′). Results also indicated a hydrogen bond donor parameter value for a polar modifier at which retention became concentration independent; (2) For given values of K′_L, K′_D varied depending on the polar modifier, indicating that enantiomer resolution was solvent dependent; (3) Using mobile phases based on solvents of lower polarity/H-bonding potential than chloroform, substantial increases in K′ were observed, although enantioselectivity was greatly reduced. Chirality 9:238–242, 1997. © 1997 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

The stereochemical resolution of the enantiomers of aspartame on an immobilized alpha-chymotrypsin HPLC chiral stationary phase: the effect of mobile-phase composition and enzyme activity

The enantioselective and diastereoselective resolutions of the stereoisomers of N alpha-aspartyl-phenylalanine 1-methyl ester (APME) have been accomplished on an HPLC chiral stationary phase based upon alpha-chymotrypsin (the ACHT-CSP) with observed enantioselectivities (alpha 1) for the DL-/LD-enantiomer of as high as 29.17 and for the DD-/LL-enantiomers of as high as 28.97. In addition, the effect on the chromatographic retention of the APME stereoisomers of the activity of the ACHT and the composition of the mobile phase--structure of the anionic component, molarity, and pH--have been studied. The results of this study suggest that the aspartyl moiety and/or the aspartyl-phenylalanine amide linkage play key roles in the observed enantioselectivity; the APME stereoisomers containing L-phenylalanine, i.e., DL- and LL-APME, bind at a different site in the ACHT molecule (the L-Phe site) than the APME stereoisomers containing D-phenylalanine (the D-Phe site); and the observed enantioselectivity is a measure of the difference in the binding affinities at the two sites rather than the consequence of differential affinities at a single site.     

Use of an adsorbed chiral selector in capillary LC-MS

Lasalocid was utilized as a chiral selector adsorbed on porous graphitic carbon. Important parameters were identified for the use of the chiral selector in capillary liquid chromatography combined with MS detection. The influence on both retention and enantioselectivity as well as mass spectrometric performance was studied at lasalocid concentrations of up to 12 mg/l (20 microM). Moreover, the stability of retention factors and enantioselectivities was also evaluated at low selector concentration of 1 mg/l (2 microM). The results show that in order to optimize the MS performance the selector concentration should be kept at low microM. The chromatographic performance at reduced selector concentration (1 mg/l = 2 microM) was studied over a 10-day period, showing satisfactory enantioselectivity and stable performance concerning enantioselectivity and retention.     

Enantiomer separation of imidazo-quinazoline-dione derivatives on quinine carbamate-based chiral stationary phase in normal phase mode

The normal phase mode liquid chromatographic enantiomer separation capability of a quinine tert-butyl-carbamate-type chiral stationary phase (CSP) has been investigated for a set of polar [1,5-b]-quinazoline-1,5-dione derivatives. This class of chiral heterocycles is currently under development as potential alpha-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methyl-4-isoxazole propionic acid (AMPA) and/or N-methyl-D-aspartic acid (NMDA) receptor antagonists. The effect of the nature and concentration of polar modifier, i.e., ethanol and isopropanol, in n-hexane-based mobile phases, as well as the substituent pattern of the phenyl ring attached to the quinazolone framework on retention factor, enantioselectivity, and resolution was investigated. The Soczewiński competitive adsorption model was used to describe the relationship between the retention and the binary mobile phase compositions. According to this model, linear plots of the logarithms of retention factor versus molar fractions of the polar modifiers were obtained over a wide concentration range (X(B) between 0.15 and 0.35). Addition of equimolar ethanol yields higher resolution than isopropanol, R(S) values ranging between 1.54 and 2.75, whereas the latter allows to achieve moderately increased enatioselectivity. The resolution was further improved by using a ternary mixture of n-hexane:methanol:isopropanol/85:5:10 (v/v). The most pronounced selectivity factor alpha and resolution R(S) values were obtained for the para-hydroxy substituted compound, indicating that chiral recognition is sensitive to steric and stereoelectronic factors. In the course of optimization, the temperature-dependence on the chiral separation was also investigated. It turned out that the enantiomer separation is predominantly enthalpically driven in normal phase mode.     

Influence of uncharged mobile phase additives,pH, and structure differences on retention and enantioselectivity of chiral hexa- and octa-hydrobenzo(g) quinolines on an ovomucoid glycoprotein column

The enantiomeric resolution of six closely related hexa- and octa-hydrobenzo(g) quinoline racemates by HPLC on an ovomucoid column (Ultron ES-OVM) is described. First, the influence of uncharged mobile phase additives (with different hydrogen bonding properties) and pH on retention and enantioselectivity is investigated. It is shown that an optimum pH of around 6 for the given separations is much more important than the choice of modifier. Second, the influence on enantioselectivity of small differences in molecular structure is examined. In one case a large difference is obtained for diastereomeric racemates depending on the cis- or trans-configuration of the quinoline skeleton. Higher flexibility of the solute seen in the cis enantiomers seems to improve enantioselectivity. © 1993 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Elucidation of the enantioselective recognition mechanism of a penicillin G acylase-based chiral stationary phase towards a series of 2-aryloxy-2-arylacetic acids

A series of structurally related 2-aryloxy-2-arylacetic acids (1-3, 5-16) together with a thioisostere derivative (4) have been synthesized and characterized by GC-MS and 1H NMR. The designed compounds were analyzed on a Penicillin G Acylase chiral stationary phase (PGA-CSP) and the influence of the structure variations on retention and enantioselectivity was investigated. The chromatographic study includes the direct separation of the enantiomers of the synthesized compounds and the determination of the elution order of selected racemic mixtures. 10 out of 16 racemates were separated; high chromatographic enantioseparation factors (alpha > 2) were achieved for some compounds. For the enantiomers of four compounds whose absolute configuration was known (1, 3, 12, 16), the elution order was R:S with the exception of 2-(4-chloro-phenoxy)phenylacetic acid (1), for which the elution order was reversed. Preliminary molecular modeling studies suggest that both polar and charge-transfer interactions as well as steric effects play an important role in determining the retention factors and the enantioselectivities observed.     

Immobilized vancomycin as chiral stationary phase in packed capillary liquid chromatography

Fused silica-packed capillary columns containing vancomycin immobilized by reductive amination on an aldehyde-silica were used to separate enantiomers of some non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs. Attempts have been made to qualitatively explain the influence of various mobile phase compositions on the enantioselective retention. The effects of mobile phase pH, buffer, and organic modifier concentrations were investigated as well as the influence of salts of hydrophobic ions added to the mobile phase to induce ion pair retention. Chirality 10:273–280, 1998. © 1998 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

Enantioselective phenylacetylene addition to aldehydes and ketones catalyzed by recyclable polymeric Zn(salen) complex

New polymeric Zn(salen) complex was employed in the enantioselective phenylacetylene addition to aldehydes and ketones to produce corresponding chiral secondary propargylic alcohols with yields (up to 96%) and enantioselectivity (up to 72%) and tertiary propargylic alcohols with yields (up to 79%) and enantioselectivity (up to 68%) at room temperature, with added advantage of four times reuse with retention of enantioselectivity.     

Epoxide hydrolase activity of Chryseomonas luteola for the asymmetric hydrolysis of aliphatic mono-substituted epoxides

Asymmetric hydrolysis of a homologous range of straight chain 1,2-epoxyalkanes was achieved using whole cells of Chryseomonas luteola. Depending on the chain length, hydrolyses of the racemic epoxides afforded optically active epoxides and diols with varying degrees of optical purity. In the case of 1,2-epoxyoctane, the enantiomeric excess of the remaining (S)-epoxide and formed (R)-diol was excellent (ees > 98% and eep = 86%). This is the first report of a bacterial epoxide hydrolase with such unusual enantioselectivity for terminal mono-substituted epoxides bearing no directing group on the chiral C-2 carbon. Benzyl glycidyl ether and the 2,2-disubstituted epoxide, 2-methyl-1,2-epoxyheptane, were hydrolysed, but no enantioselectivity was observed. © Rapid Science Ltd. 1998     

Comparative study of coated and immobilized polysaccharide-based chiral stationary phases and their applicability in the resolution of enantiomers

The enantioselective and chromatographic properties of Chiralpak AD and Chiralpak IA as well as those of Chiralcel OD and Chiralpak IB have been evaluated using a set of 48 compounds that differ in their physical and chemical properties. The impact of the different immobilisation methodologies of the chiral polysaccharide, i.e., coated or immobilized on retention and enantioselectivity was studied. The study on immobilized chiral stationary phases (CSPs) was expanded to also include mobile phases containing mixtures of alkanes and more non-conventional solvents such as ethyl acetate, ethers, acetone and dichloromethane. In this paper we report some of the general trends observed for the 48 racemic compounds with respect to retention, alpha and Rs. Further, the impact of the immobilisation methodology and the choice of the mobile phase on the elution order of the enantiomers is also discussed.     

Apparent and true enantioselectivity in enantioseparations

The separation factor of two compounds in chromatography is the ratio of their equilibrium constants or retention factors. This parameter is universally employed to investigate their resolution and to optimize the experimental conditions of their analysis. In enantioseparations, the situation is more complex because there is a mixed retention mechanism. The retention factor is the sum of two contributions, one enantioselective, the other nonselective. Although both contribute to retention, the latter being identical for the two enantiomers and does not contribute to their separation. We show how these two contributions can be measured and how it becomes necessary to distinguish between the apparent, alpha(app), and the true, alpha(true), separation factors. The existence of nonselective sites is responsible for alpha(app) being less than alpha(true). Depending on the difference between these two factors, the more effective approach to improve a separation is either to increase the enantioselectivity or to reduce the nonselective interactions. Practical applications to separations of different beta-blockers on cellobiohydrolase are discussed. The apparent enantioselectivity of alprenolol is larger and increases faster with increasing pH than that of the more hydrophobic propranolol, in spite of the importance of hydrophobic interactions in the enantioselective mechanism. These two unexpected properties are discussed and explained.     

A chiral stationary phase which affords unusually high levels of enantioselectivity

A chiral stationary phase (CSP) derived from N-(1-naphthyl) leucine has been prepared. This CSP is conceptually similar to the CSP derived from N-(2-naphthyl)alanine and was expected to separate the enantiomers of the same clientele of analytes as does the latter. The magnitudes of the separation factors observed on the two CSPs may differ markedly for a given analyte, the new CSP often affording much greater enantioselectivity.     

Enantiomeric separations of amino alcohols by packed-column SFC on Hypercarb with L-(+)-tartaric acid as chiral selector

The use of L-(+)-tartaric acid as a chiral mobile phase additive (CMPA) has been investigated in a packed-column SFC system. The CMPA, carbon dioxide, and methanol, containing a high concentration of aliphatic amine additive, were used as the mobile phase and Hypercarb as support [Gyllenhaal O., Karlsson A., SFC of metoprolol and other amino alcohols on Hypercarb (in preparation)]. Good enantioselectivities were obtained for tertiary amine homologues of 2-amino alcohols, used as beta-adrenoreceptor-blocking drugs. Moderate selectivities were observed for aromatic compounds having a second substituent in the ortho-position. The overall retention was influenced by the aromaticity of the analytes as well as the presence of free electron pairs in the molecule. Increased concentrations of CMPA gave higher retention and also increased the enantioselectivity. The practical utility of this present enantioselective system was demonstrated on one batch of (S)-metoprolol that was N-methylated with methyl iodide. The enantiomeric separation was accomplished within 10 min.     

Mobile phase modifier effects in multimodal cation exchange chromatography

This study examines protein adsorption behavior and the effects of mobile phase modifiers in multimodal chromatographic systems. Chromatography results with a diverse protein library indicate that multimodal and ion exchange resins have markedly different protein binding behavior and selectivity. NMR results corroborate the stronger binding observed for the multimodal system and provide insight into the structural basis for the observed binding behavior. Protein-binding affinity and selectivity in multimodal and ion exchange systems are then examined using a variety of mobile phase modifiers. Arginine and guanidine are found to have dramatic effects on protein adsorption, yielding changes in selectivity in both chromatographic systems. While sodium caprylate leads to slightly weaker chromatographic retention for most proteins, certain proteins exhibit significant losses in retention in both systems. The presence of a competitive binding mechanism between the multimodal ligand and sodium caprylate for binding to ubiquitin is confirmed using STD NMR. Polyol mobile phase modifiers are shown to result in increased retention for weakly bound proteins and decreased retention for strongly bound proteins, indicating that the overall retention behavior is determined by a balance between changes in electrostatic and hydrophobic interactions. This work provides an improved understanding of protein adsorption and mobile phase modifier effects in multimodal chromatographic systems and sets the stage for future work to develop more selective protein separation systems.     

Substituent effects on chiral resolutions of derivatized 1‐phenylalkylamines by heptakis(2,3‐di‐O‐methyl‐6‐O‐tert‐butyldimethylsilyl)‐β‐cyclodextrin GC stationary phase

Chiral resolutions of trifluoroacetyl‐derivatized 1‐phenylalkylamines with different type and position of substituent were investigated by capillary gas chromatography by using heptakis(2,3‐di‐O‐methyl‐6‐O‐tert‐butyldimethylsilyl)‐β‐cyclodextrin diluted in OV‐1701 as a chiral stationary phase. The influence of column temperature on retention and enantioselectivity was examined. All enantiomers of meta‐substituted analytes as well as fluoro‐substituted analytes could be resolved. Temperature had a favorable influence on enantioselectivity for small amines with substituents at the ortho‐position. The type of substituent at the stereogenic center of amines also had a crucial effect as the ethyl group led to poor enantioseparation. Among all analytes studied, trifluoroacetyl‐derivatized 1‐(2′‐fluorophenyl)ethylamine exhibited baseline resolution with the shortest analysis time.     

Mechanisms of retention of pyrrolidinyl norephedrine on immobilized alpha(1)-acid glycoprotein

The HPLC separation of the R,S and S,R enantiomers of pyrrolidinyl norephedrine on immobilized alpha-1 glycoprotein (AGP) was investigated. Conditions for the separation were varied using a premixed mobile phase containing an ammonium phosphate buffer and an organic modifier. The influence of mobile phase pH, ionic strength, organic modifier composition, modifier type, and temperature on the chiral selectivity and retention were investigated. The presented data demonstrate that independent phenomena govern the enantioselectivity and retention. Retention is a function of both ion exchange equilibria and hydrophobic adsorption. Thermodynamic data derived from van't Hoff plots illustrates that while enantioselectivity is also enthalpically driven, the magnitude of the enthalpy term is governed by pH. Enantioselectivity has little dependence on ionic strength. Hydrophobic interactions appear to foster hydrogen bonding interactions; the two appear to be mutually responsible for chiral selectivity. The chiral selectivity decreases as the pH is decreased and increases with mobile phase buffer strength.     

Gas phase enantioselective reduction catalyzed by immobilized ketoreductase: Effects of water activity and reaction temperature

The performance (activity, stability, enantioselectivity and productivity) of the commercial ketoreductase immobilized on non-porous glass supports was investigated as functions of the water activity and the reaction temperature in a continuous gas phase reactor. The enantioselective reduction of 2-butanone to (S)-2-butanol with the in situ regeneration of β-nicotinamide adenine dinucleotide phosphate by 2-propanol catalyzed by the immobilized ketoreductase was used as a model reaction. The activity, stability and enantioselectivity were strongly influenced by the water activity and the reaction temperature. The optimal water activity and reaction temperature were obtained at 0.8 and 313–323 K in terms of the productivity, respectively. Successfully, the enantioselectivity for the gas phase system attained the level identical to that for the aqueous phase system.