Mesodermal patterning during avian gastrulation and neurulation: Experimental induction of notochord from non-notochordal precursor cells

The cells that are normally fated to form notochord occupy a region at the rostral tip of the primitive streak at late gastrula/early neurula stages of avian and mammalian development. If these cells are surgically removed from avian embryos in culture, a notochord will nonetheless form in the majority of cases. The origin of this reconstituted notochord previously had not been investigated and was the objective of this study. Chick embryos at late gastrulal early neurula stages were cultured, and the rostral tip of the primitive streak including Hensen's node was removed and replaced with non-node cells from quail epiblast to ensure that the cells normally fated to be notochord would be absent and that healing of the blastoderm would occur. Embryos were allowed to develop for 24 hr, and the presence and origin (host or graft) of the notochord were assessed using antibodies against notochord or quail cells. Two notochords typically developed; both were almost exclusively of host origin. The primitive streak, and in some cases adjacent tissues, was removed from another group of embryos in an attempt to estimate the mediolateral position and extent of the cells required to form reconstituted notochord. Additional experimental embryos with and without grafts were transected at various rostrocaudal levels in an attempt to estimate the rostrocaudal extent of the cells required to form reconstituted notochord. Finally, various levels of the primitive streak either were placed in a neutral environment (the germ cell crescent) or were grafted in place of the node. Collective results from all experiments indicate that the areas lateral to the rostral portion of the primitive streak, estimated to have a rostrocaudal span of less than 500 μm and a mediolateral extent of less than 250 μm, are critical for formation of the reconstituted notochord. Fate mapping and histological examination of this region identify 4 possible precursor cell populations. Further studies are underway to determine which of the 4 possible precursor cell types forms or induces the reconstituted notochord, and which tissue interactions underlie this change in cell fate. © 1995 Wiley-Liss, Inc.     

A chemotactic model for the advance and retreat of the primitive streak in avian development

The formation of the primitive streak in early avian development marks the onset of gastrulation, during which large scale cell movement leads to a trilaminar blastoderm comprising prospective endodermal, mesodermal and ectodermal tissue. During streak formation a specialized group of cells first moves anteriorly as a coherent column, beginning from the posterior end of the prospective anterior-posterior axis (a process called progression), and then reverses course and returns to the most posterior point on the axis (a process called regression). To date little is known concerning the mechanisms controlling either progression or regression. Here we develop a model in which chemotaxis directs the cell movement and which is capable of reproducing the principal features connected with progression and regression of the primitive streak. We show that this model exhibits a number of experimentally-observed features of normal and abnormal streak development, and we propose a number of experimental tests which may serve to illuminate the mechanisms. This paper represents the first attempt to model the global features of primitive streak formation, and provides an initial stage in the development of a more biologically-realistic discrete cell model that will allow for variation of properties between cells and control over movement of individual cells.     

Formation of the avian primitive streak from spatially restricted blastoderm: evidence for polarized cell division in the elongating streak

Gastrulation in the amniote begins with the formation of a primitive streak through which precursors of definitive mesoderm and endoderm ingress and migrate to their embryonic destinations. This organizing center for amniote gastrulation is induced by signal(s) from the posterior margin of the blastodisc. The mode of action of these inductive signal(s) remains unresolved, since various origins and developmental pathways of the primitive streak have been proposed. In the present study, the fate of chicken blastodermal cells was traced for the first time in ovo from prestreak stages XI-XII through HH stage 3, when the primitive streak is initially established and prior to the migration of mesoderm. Using replication-defective retrovirus-mediated gene transfer and vital dye labeling, precursor cells of the stage 3 primitive streak were mapped predominantly to a specific region where the embryonic midline crosses the posterior margin of the epiblast. No significant contribution to the early primitive streak was seen from the anterolateral epiblast. Instead, the precursor cells generated daughter cells that underwent a polarized cell division oriented perpendicular to the anteroposterior embryonic axis. The resulting daughter cell population was arranged in a longitudinal array extending the complete length of the primitive streak. Furthermore, expression of cVg1, a posterior margin-derived signal, at the anterior marginal zone induced adjacent epiblast cells, but not those lateral to or distant from the signal, to form an ectopic primitive streak. The cVg1-induced epiblast cells also exhibited polarized cell divisions during ectopic primitive streak formation. These results suggest that blastoderm cells located immediately anterior to the posterior marginal zone, which secretes an inductive signal, undergo spatially directed cytokineses during early primitive streak formation.     

Shaping and bending of the avian neural plate as analysed with a fluorescent-histochemical marker

Shaping and bending of the neural plate are cardinal events of neurulation. These processes are initiated in avian embryos shortly after the onset of gastrulation and concluded concomitantly with the completion of gastrulation. The epiblast undergoes extensive morphogenetic movements during gastrulation and neurulation, but the directions, distances, rates, mechanisms and roles of such rearrangements are largely unknown. To begin to understand these morphogenetic movements, we have mapped regional displacements of the epiblast by injecting a fluorescent-histochemical marker into selected prenodal, nodal and postnodal levels of the blastoderm. Lateral epiblast regions (600 microns lateral to the midline and consisting primarily of surface epithelium) are displaced craniomedially, medial regions (300 microns lateral to the midline and consisting of neural plate and preingressed mesoderm) predominantly medially, and midline regions (consisting of neural plate and primitive streak) predominantly caudally. Displacements within the avian neural plate parallel those previously described for the amphibian neural plate. Furthermore, similar tissue displacements occur within the prenodal and postnodal levels of the avian epiblast despite the fact that neurulation is occurring in the former and gastrulation in the latter. Finally, our results show that ectodermal rudiments contained within a single cross-sectional level of the embryo are a composite of cells derived from multiple craniocaudal and mediolateral levels. Thus, regional tissue displacements are important events to consider in the analysis of the early morphogenesis of axial and paraxial organ rudiments derived from the epiblast.     

Nodal signal is required for morphogenetic movements of epiblast layer in the pre-streak chick blastoderm

During axis formation in amniotes, posterior and lateral epiblast cells in the area pellucida undergo a counter-rotating movement along the midline to form primitive streak (Polonaise movements). Using chick blastoderms, we investigated the signaling involved in this cellular movement in epithelial-epiblast. In cultured posterior blastoderm explants from stage X to XI embryos, either Lefty1 or Cerberus-S inhibited initial migration of the explants on chamber slides. In vivo analysis showed that inhibition of Nodal signaling by Lefty1 affected the movement of DiI-marked epiblast cells prior to the formation of primitive streak. In Lefty1-treated embryos without a primitive streak, Brachyury expression showed a patchy distribution. However, SU5402 did not affect the movement of DiI-marked epiblast cells. Multi-cellular rosette, which is thought to be involved in epithelial morphogenesis, was found predominantly in the posterior half of the epiblast, and Lefty1 inhibited the formation of rosettes. Three-dimensional reconstruction showed two types of rosette, one with a protruding cell, the other with a ventral hollow. Our results suggest that Nodal signaling may have a pivotal role in the morphogenetic movements of epithelial epiblast including Polonaise movements and formation of multi-cellular rosette.     

The importance of the posterior midline region for axis initiation at early stages of the avian embryo

The avian blastoderm acts during its early stages of development as an integrative system programmed to form a single embryonic axis. Here, I report the results of a variety of transplantation experiments of the midline region at stages X-XII, which were carried out to study their relevance for axis initiation. The results of the experimental series discussed herein emphasizes the importance of the posterior midline region (including the marginal zone and Koller's sickle) for axis initiation. This ability resides mainly at stage X in the posterior side of a narrow midline region, while at stages XI-XII it is exhibited at the region which is located more anterior and lateral to the posterior midline region. This posterior midline region has developmental abilities which allow it to initiate a single embryonic axis and at the same time to prevent other regions that also have such abilities to do so. Therefore, in normal development only one embryonic axis develops in the avian blastoderm. It is proposed that the cells which are important to initiate the avian embryonic axis are concentrated mainly at the region of the posterior midline region. These cells may have organizer properties which determine the initiation site of the axis in the avian embryo.     

Analysis of extraembryonic mesodermal structure formation in the absence of morphological primitive streak

During mouse gastrulation, the primitive streak is formed on the posterior side of the embryo. Cells migrate out of the primitive streak to form the future mesoderm and endoderm. Fate mapping studies revealed a group of cell migrate through the proximal end of the primitive streak and give rise to the extraembryonic mesoderm tissues such as the yolk sac blood islands and allantois. However, it is not clear whether the formation of a morphological primitive streak is required for the development of these extraembryonic mesodermal tissues. Loss of the Cripto gene in mice dramatically reduces, but does not completely abolish, Nodal activity leading to the absence of a morphological primitive streak. However, embryonic erythrocytes are still formed and assembled into the blood islands. In addition, Cripto mutant embryos form allantoic buds. However, Drap1 mutant embryos have excessive Nodal activity in the epiblast cells before gastrulation and form an expanded primitive streak, but no yolk sac blood islands or allantoic bud formation. Lefty2 embryos also have elevated levels of Nodal activity in the primitive streak during gastrulation, and undergo normal blood island and allantois formation. We therefore speculate that low level of Nodal activity disrupts the formation of morphological primitive streak on the posterior side, but still allows the formation of primitive streak cells on the proximal side, which give rise to the extraembryonic mesodermal tissues formation. Excessive Nodal activity in the epiblast at pre‐gastrulation stage, but not in the primitive streak cells during gastrulation, disrupts extraembryonic mesoderm development.     

Cell populations and morphogenetic movements underlying formation of the avian primitive streak and organizer

The cell populations and morphogenetic movements that contribute to the formation of the avian primitive streak and organizer-Hensen's node-are poorly understood. We labeled selected groups of cells with fluorescent dyes and then followed them over time during formation and progression of the primitive streak and formation of Hensen's node. We show that (1) the primitive streak arises from a localized population of epiblast cells spanning the caudal midline of Koller's sickle, with the mid-dorsal cells of the primitive streak arising from the midline of the epiblast overlying Koller's sickle and the deeper and more lateral primitive streak cells arising more laterally within the epiblast overlying the sickle, from an arch subtending about 30 degrees; (2) convergent extension movements of cells in the epiblast overlying Koller's sickle contribute to formation of the initial primitive streak; and (3) Hensen's node is derived from a mixture of cells originating both from the epiblast just rostral to the incipient (stage 2) primitive streak and later from the epiblast just rostral to the elongating (stage 3a/b) primitive streak, as well as from the rostral tip of the progressing streak itself. Collectively, these results provide new information on the formation of the avian primitive streak and organizer, increasing our understanding of these important events of early development of amniotes.     

Axis formation in half blastoderms of the chick: Stage at separation and the relative positions of fused halves influence axis development

The blastoderm of the avian embryo acts during the early stages of development as an integrative system programmed to form a single embryonic axis. Isolated parts of the blastoderm are known to each form an axis, owing to the system's properties. In the work reported here, the regulative capability of the right and left halves of chick blastoderms to form an embryonic axis was examined systematically at different stages. This revealed a progressive change in the developing blastoderm. After early separation, the axis in each half will form at some distance from the blastoderm's original midline, while with late separation the axis will form next to the original midline and may even lack one row of somites at the medial rim. Since development stops in culture after about 2 days, axis development after early separation ceases before somites are formed, whereas after late separation somites and brain vesicles can develop. In addition, an attempt was made to learn whether the two halves of blastoderm, when shifted along the midline and then reunited in staggered fashion, act as a single or two separate embryonic fields. When reunion of the right and left halves was achieved so that the posterior end of one half was adjoining the posterior area pellucida region of the other half, a single embryonic axis developed. When, on the other hand, the shift was larger so that the posterior end was fused to the central area pellucida of the other half, two separated embryonic axes developed.     

Control of early anterior-posterior patterning in the mouse embryo by TGF-beta signalling

Prior to gastrulation the mouse embryo exists as a symmetrical cylinder consisting of three tissue layers. Positioning of the future anterior-posterior axis of the embryo occurs through coordinated cell movements that rotate a pre-existing proximal-distal (P-D) axis. Overt axis formation becomes evident when a discrete population of proximal epiblast cells become induced to form mesoderm, initiating primitive streak formation and marking the posterior side of the embryo. Over the next 12-24 h the primitive streak gradually elongates along the posterior side of the epiblast to reach the distal tip. The most anterior streak cells comprise the 'organizer' region and include the precursors of the so-called 'axial mesendoderm', namely the anterior definitive endoderm and prechordal plate mesoderm, as well as those cells that give rise to the morphologically patent node. Signalling pathways controlled by the transforming growth factor-beta ligand nodal are involved in orchestrating the process of axis formation. Embryos lacking nodal activity arrest development before gastrulation, reflecting an essential role for nodal in establishing P-D polarity by generating and maintaining the molecular pattern within the epiblast, extraembryonic ectoderm and the visceral endoderm. Using a genetic strategy to manipulate temporal and spatial domains of nodal expression reveals that the nodal pathway is also instrumental in controlling both the morphogenetic movements required for orientation of the final axis and for specification of the axial mesendoderm progenitors.     

Identification of emergent motion compartments in the amniote embryo

Abstract

The tissue scale deformations (≥1mm) required to form an amniote embryo are poorly understood. Here, we studied ～400 μm-sized explant units from gastrulating quail embryos. The explants deformed in a reproducible manner when grown using a novel vitelline membrane-based culture method. Time-lapse recordings of latent embryonic motion patterns were analyzed after disk-shaped tissue explants were excised from three specific regions near the primitive streak: 1) anterolateral epiblast, 2) posterolateral epiblast, and 3) the avian organizer (Hensen's node). The explants were cultured for 8 hours—an interval equivalent to gastrulation. Both the anterolateral and the posterolateral epiblastic explants engaged in concentric radial/centrifugal tissue expansion. In sharp contrast, Hensen's node explants displayed Cartesian-like, elongated, bipolar deformations—a pattern reminiscent of axis elongation. Time-lapse analysis of explant tissue motion patterns indicated that both cellular motility and extracellular matrix fiber (tissue) remodeling take place during the observed morphogenetic deformations. As expected, treatment of tissue explants with a selective Rho-Kinase (p160ROCK) signaling inhibitor, Y27632, completely arrested all morphogenetic movements. Microsurgical experiments revealed that lateral epiblastic tissue was dispensable for the generation of an elongated midline axis— provided that an intact organizer (node) is present. Our computational analyses suggest the possibility of delineating tissue-scale morphogenetic movements at anatomically discrete locations in the embryo. Further, tissue deformation patterns, as well as the mechanical state of the tissue, require normal actomyosin function. We conclude that amniote embryos contain tissue-scale, regionalized morphogenetic motion generators, which can be assessed using our novel computational time-lapse imaging approach. These data and future studies—using explants excised from overlapping anatomical positions—will contribute to understanding the emergent tissue flow that shapes the amniote embryo.     

The migration of paraxial and lateral plate mesoderm cells emerging from the late primitive streak is controlled by different Wnt signals

Background  

Co-ordinated cell movement is a fundamental feature of developing embryos. Massive cell movements occur during vertebrate gastrulation and during the subsequent extension of the embryonic body axis. These are controlled by cell-cell signalling and a number of pathways have been implicated. Here we use long-term video microscopy in chicken embryos to visualize the migration routes and movement behaviour of mesoderm progenitor cells as they emerge from the primitive streak (PS) between HH stages 7 and 10.     

Presence of serotonin in early chick embryos

With biochemical analysis and with autoradiography based on injection of 5-[3H]hydroxytryptophan, it was possible to demonstrate the presence of serotonin (5-hydroxytryptamine) in early chick embryos as early as the pre-streak stage. The biochemical analysis which covered the early developmental period (0.5-6 days of incubation) revealed an elevated concentration of serotonin at gastrulation; from then it stayed at a lower and fairly even level. Autoradiographs of embryos at the pre-streak stage, the primitive streak stage, the head fold stage and the 4-6 somites stage indicated the presence of serotonin in intracellular yolk granules and in cell nuclei. Moreover, the amine appeared associated with microfilaments and microtubules, particularly in developing neural cells. Notably the elevated concentration of serotonin at gastrulation, but also the intracellular distribution of the amine during early organogenesis, indicates a prominent role for it in cell-shape changes and morphogenesis in the early chick embryo.     

Clonal analysis of epiblast fate during germ layer formation in the mouse embryo.

The fate of cells in the epiblast at prestreak and early primitive streak stages has been studied by injecting horseradish peroxidase (HRP) into single cells in situ of 6.7-day mouse embryos and identifying the labelled descendants at midstreak to neural plate stages after one day of culture. Ectoderm was composed of descendants of epiblast progenitors that had been located in the embryonic axis anterior to the primitive streak. Embryonic mesoderm was derived from all areas of the epiblast except the distal tip and the adjacent region anterior to it: the most anterior mesoderm cells originated posteriorly, traversing the primitive streak early; labelled cells in the posterior part of the streak at the neural plate stage were derived from extreme anterior axial and paraxial epiblast progenitors; head process cells were derived from epiblast at or near the anterior end of the primitive streak. Endoderm descendants were most frequently derived from a region that included, but extended beyond, the region producing the head process: descendants of epiblast were present in endoderm by the midstreak stage, as well as at later stages. Yolk sac and amnion mesoderm developed from posterolateral and posterior epiblast. The resulting fate map is essentially the same as those of the chick and urodele and indicates that, despite geometrical differences, topological fate relationships are conserved among these vertebrates. Clonal descendants were not necessarily confined to a single germ layer or to extraembryonic mesoderm, indicating that these lineages are not separated at the beginning of gastrulation. The embryonic axis lengthened up to the neural plate stage by (1) elongation of the primitive streak through progressive incorporation of the expanding lateral and initially more anterior regions of epiblast and, (2) expansion of the region of epiblast immediately cranial to the anterior end of the primitive streak. The population doubling time of labelled cells was 7.5 h; a calculated 43% were in, or had completed, a 4th cell cycle, and no statistically significant regional differences in the number of descendants were found. This clonal analysis also showed that (1) growth in the epiblast was noncoherent and in most regions anisotropic and directed towards the primitive streak and (2) the midline did not act as a barrier to clonal spread, either in the epiblast in the anterior half of the axis or in the primitive streak. These results taken together with the fate map indicate that, while individual cells in the epiblast sheet behave independently with respect to their neighbours, morphogenetic movement during germ layer formation is coordinated in the population as a whole.     

Non-canonical Wnt signaling through Wnt5a/b and a novel Wnt11 gene, Wnt11b, regulates cell migration during avian gastrulation

Knowledge of the molecular mechanisms regulating cell ingression, epithelial–mesenchymal transition and migration movements during amniote gastrulation is steadily improving. In the frog and fish embryo, Wnt5 and Wnt11 ligands are expressed around the blastopore and play an important role in regulating cell movements associated with gastrulation. In the chicken embryo, although Wnt5a and Wnt5b are expressed in the primitive streak, the known Wnt11 gene is expressed in paraxial and intermediate mesoderm, and in differentiated myocardial cells, but not in the streak. Here, we identify a previously uncharacterized chicken Wnt11 gene, Wnt11b, that is orthologous to the frog Wnt11 and zebrafish Wnt11 (silberblick) genes. Chicken Wnt11b is expressed in the primitive streak in a pattern similar to chicken Wnt5a and Wnt5b. When non-canonical Wnt signaling is blocked using a Dishevelled dominant-negative protein, gastrulation movements are inhibited and cells accumulate in the primitive streak. Furthermore, disruption of non-canonical Wnt signaling by overexpression of full-length or dominant-negative Wnt11b or Wnt5a constructions abrogates normal cell migration through the primitive streak. We conclude that non-canonical Wnt signaling, mediated in part by Wnt11b, is important for regulation of gastrulation cell movements in the avian embryo.     

Autoradiographic evidence for the sliding of the upper layer over the basement membrane in chicken blastoderms during gastrulation.

An upper layer (epiblast) fragment taken laterally from the Anlage fields of neural plate or chordamesoderm of a quail blastoderm, labelled with 3H-glucosamine, was grafted isotopically (in a similar region), isochronically (at the similar stage of development) and isotropically (with the same caudocranial and dorsoventral polarity) in the epiblast of a mesoblast free area of a chicken blastoderm (St 4-5 Vakaet, 1970: full grown primitive streak). On the autoradiographs of the sections through such cultured blastoderms with fully integrated quail grafts, we observed a labelling of the basement membrane laterally and slightly cranially from the labelled graft in its final position. Since only the epiblast and its basement membrane are involved, the pattern of the observed labelling indicates that the grafted and integrated quail epiblast fragment glides in toto over the mediocaudally localized basement membrane, leaving behind a track of radioactivity. Sliding of whole groups of epiblast cells over the basement membrane seems thus to be a normal phenomenon during avian gastrulation.     

Left‐right asymmetry in the chick embryo requires core planar cell polarity protein Vangl2

Consistent left‐right patterning is a fascinating and biomedically important problem. In the chick embryo, it is not known how cells determine their position (left or right) relative to the primitive streak, which is required for subsequent asymmetric gene expression cascades. We show that the subcellular localization of Vangl2, a core planar cell polarity (PCP) protein, is consistently polarized, giving cells in the blastoderm a vector pointing toward the primitive streak. Moreover, morpholino‐mediated loss‐of‐function of Vangl2 by electroporation into chicks at very early stages randomizes the normally left‐sided expression of Sonic hedgehog. Strikingly, Vangl2 morpholinos also induce a desynchronization of asymmetric gene expression within the left and right domains of Hensen's node. These data reveal the existence of polarized planar cell polarity protein localization in gastrulating chick and demonstrate that the PCP pathway is functionally required for normal asymmetry in the chick upstream of Sonic hedgehog. These data suggest a new and widely applicable class of models for the spread and coordination of left‐right patterning information in the embryonic blastoderm. genesis 47:719–728, 2009. © 2009 Wiley‐Liss, Inc.     

Avian sickle endoblast induces gastrulation or neurulation in the isolated area centralis or isolated anti-sickle region respectively

By the quail-chicken chimera technique, we studied, in culture, the inducing effect of sickle endoblast (derived from Rauber's sickle by centripetal and cranial migration) on the isolated Rauber's sickle-free central part of the area centralis or on the isolated Rauber's sickle-free anti-sickle region from unincubated chicken blastoderms. Just as Rauber's sickle, the flat one-cell-thick sickle endoblast (Stage 2-3, Hamburger & Hamilton, 1951) induces a primitive streak (PS) and a neural plate in the area centralis. If a vitelline membrane is interposed between the sickle endoblast and the area centralis, then a small primitive streak is still induced, suggesting the effect of a diffusible factor on PS formation. In the adjacent upper layer of an isolated anti-sickle region the apposed sickle endoblast induces only a (pre)neural plate. By contrast, this (pre)neural plate inducing effect is rapidly and totally suppressed after grafting on the anti-sickle region of whole unincubated blastoderms. This suggests dominating positional information phenomena emanating from Rauber's sickle over the whole blastoderm. After grafting sickle endoblast either on the isolated area centralis or on isolated anti-sickles, no junctional endoblast and no blood islands developed. This suggests that the differentiation of Rauber's sickle material into sickle endoblast is irreversible. Our results indicate that Rauber's sickle material under the form of sickle endoblast also influences early neurulation phenomena (at distance in space and time). The present study indicates the existence of a temporo-spatially bound cascade of gastrulation and neurulation phenomena and blood island formation in the avian blastoderm, starting from Rauber's sickle, the primary major organizer with inducing, inhibiting and dominating potencies. The latter not only plays a role by secretion of signalling molecules (positional information) but it also influences development by its cell lineages (junctional endoblast and sickle endoblast).     

Establishment of anterior-posterior polarity in avian embryos.

In pre-streak chick embryos, the extraembryonic posterior marginal zone is able to induce an embryonic axis at an ectopic site without contributing cells to the induced primitive streak. This region expresses mesoderm-inducing factors that are capable of inducing an ectopic streak. Downstream of these events, chordin and bone morphogenetic protein acting within the central disc may play mutually opposing roles influencing streak formation. Although extraembryonic regions are important in establishing the embryonic axis, there does not appear to be an anterior region with head-inducing activity similar to that of the anterior visceral endoderm of the mammalian embryo.