Methidiumpropyl-EDTA.Fe(II) and DNase I footprinting report different small molecule binding site sizes on DNA.

DNase I and MPE.Fe (II) footprinting both employ partial cleavage of ligand-protected DNA restriction fragments and Maxam-Gilbert sequencing gel methods of analysis. One method utilizes the enzyme, DNase I, as the DNA cleaving agent while the other employs the synthetic molecule, methidium-propyl-EDTA (MPE). For actinomycin D, chromomycin A3 and distamycin A, DNase I footprinting reports larger binding site sizes than MPE.Fe (II). DNase I footprinting appears more sensitive for weakly bound sites. MPE.Fe (II) footprinting appears more accurate in determining the actual size and location of the binding sites for small molecules on DNA, especially in cases where several small molecules are closely spaced on the DNA. MPE.Fe (II) and DNase I report the same sequence and binding site size for lac repressor protein on operator DNA.     

Avian Retrovirus pp32 DNA-Binding Protein I. Recognition of Specific Sequences on Retrovirus DNA Terminal Repeats

The avian retrovirus pp32 protein possesses a DNA-nicking activity which prefers supercoiled DNA as substrate. We have investigated the binding of pp32 to avian retrovirus long terminal repeat (LTR) DNA present in both supercoiled and linear forms. The cloned viral DNA was derived from unintegrated Schmidt-Ruppin A (SRA) DNA. A subclone of the viral DNA in pBR322 (termed pPvuII-DG) contains some src sequences, tandem copies of LTR sequences, and partial gag sequences in the order src-U(3) U(5):U(3) U(5)-gag. Binding of pp32 to supercoiled pPvuII-DG DNA followed by digestion of this complex with a multicut restriction enzyme (28 fragments total) permitted pp32 to preferentially retain on nitrocellulose filters two viral DNA fragments containing only LTR DNA sequences. In addition, pp32 also preferentially retained four plasmid DNA fragments containing either potential promoters or Tn3 "left-end" inverted repeat sequences. Mapping of the pp32 binding sites on viral LTR DNA was accomplished by using the DNase I footprinting technique. The pp32 protein, but not the avian retrovirus alphabeta DNA polymerase, is able to form a unique protein-DNA complex with selected regions of either SRA or Prague A LTR DNAs. Partial DNase I digestion of a 275-base pair SRA DNA fragment complexed with pp32 gives upon electrophoresis in denaturing gels a unique ladder pattern, with regions of diminished DNase I susceptibility from 6 to 10 nucleotides in length, in comparison with control digests in the absence of protein. The binding of pp32 to this fragment also yields enhanced DNase I-susceptible sites that are spaced between the areas protected from DNase I digestion. The protected region of this unique complex was a stretch of 170 +/- 10 nucleotides that encompasses the presumed viral promoter site in U(3), which is adjacent to the src region, extends through U(5), and proceeds past the joint into U(3) for about 34 base pairs. No specific protection or DNase I enhancement by pp32 was observed in experiments with a 435-base pair SRA DNA fragment derived from a part of U(3) and the adjacent src region or a 55-base pair DNA fragment derived from another part of U(3). The DNA sequence of Prague A DNA at the fused LTRs differs from that of SRA DNA. The alteration in the sequence at the juncture of the LTRs prevented pp32 from forming a stable complex in this region of the LTR. Our results are relevant to two aspects of the interaction between pp32 and LTR DNA. First, the pp32 protein in the presence of selected viral DNA restriction fragments possibly forms a higher order oligomer analogous to Escherichia coli DNA gyrase-DNA complexes or eucaryotic nucleosome structures. Second, the specificity of the binding suggests a role for pp32 and the protected DNA sequences in the retrovirus life cycle. The preferred sequences to which pp32 binds include two adjacent 15-base pair inverted terminal repeats at the joint between U(5) and U(3) in SRA DNA. This region is involved in circularization of linear DNA and is perhaps the site that directs integration into cellular DNA.     

Specific protection of nucleotides in the lac operator from DMS methylation and DNase I nicking by crude bacterial cell extracts

Crude bacterial cell extracts prepared from an Escherichia coli lacIq strain were shown to protect specific nucleotides in the lac operator from methylation by dimethyl sulfate (DMS) or digestion by DNase I, whereas no protection was observed using extracts prepared from a nearly isogenic lacI- strain. These experiments show that it is not necessary to use purified regulatory proteins in experiments designed to localize sequences on DNA which interact with proteins. Therefore, crude cell extracts should be useful in DNA "footprinting" experiments to define regions of DNA which bind to unknown regulatory proteins.     

A 27 bp cis-acting sequence is essential for L-type calcium channel alpha(1C) subunit expression in vascular smooth muscle cells

Expression of L-type calcium channels in cardiac myocytes and vascular smooth muscle cells (VSMC) critically regulates the contractile state of these cells. In order to discover the elements in the promoter region of the Ca(v)1.2 gene encoding the vascular/cardiac calcium channel alpha(1C) subunit that are important for the basal gene expression, approximately 2 kb of the 5'-flanking sequence of the Ca(v)1.2 gene has been cloned in our lab. In this study, using various lengths of the 5'-flanking DNA fused with a luciferase gene as a reporter, we have defined a 493-bp fragment of the cis-regulatory DNA which carries the majority of promoter activity in pulmonary artery smooth muscle (PAC1) cells. DNase I footprinting analysis of this 493-bp DNA using nuclear extracts from PAC1 cells revealed a 27-bp DNA sequence that contains a c-Ets like motif (CAGGATGC). Mutation of the Ets-like site and the respective flanking sequence within the DNase I footprinting protection region induced a marked change in the promoter activity in PAC1 cells. Electrophoretic mobility shift assays (EMSA) confirmed the presence of specific binding factor(s) in PAC1 cells' nuclear extracts for this 27-bp DNA. Competition studies with the wild-type and mutated DNA fragments established the importance of the 27 bp DNA sequence for high-affinity binding of the nuclear proteins to the promoter. We conclude that there is a 27 bp region in the promoter of the Ca(v)1.2 gene to which nuclear proteins from VSMC bind and strongly regulate the basal promoter activity.     

A recommended workflow for DNase I footprinting using a capillary electrophoresis genetic analyzer

Fragment analysis was developed to determine the sizes of DNA fragments relative to size standards of known lengths using a capillary electrophoresis genetic analyzer. This approach has since been adapted for use in DNA footprinting. However, DNA footprinting requires accurate determination of both fragment length and intensity, imposing specific demands on the experimental design. Here we delineate essential considerations involved in optimizing the fragment analysis workflow for use in DNase I footprinting to ensure that changes in DNase I cleavage patterns may be reliably identified.     

Identification and purification of DBF-A, a double-stranded DNA-binding protein from Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Using oligonucleotide affinity chromatography with DNase I footprinting as an assay we have looked for proteins that interact with sequence elements within the yeast origin of replication, autonomously replicating sequence 1 (ARS1). In this work we describe a protein that binds with high affinity to DNA but displays only moderate sequence specificity. It is eluted at 0.7 M salt from an ARS1 oligonucleotide column. Footprinting analysis on ARS1 at a high protein concentration revealed at least three sites of protection flanking element A and its repeats. Element A itself is rendered hypersensitive to DNase I digestion upon protein binding. This pattern is also observed for the H4 and HMR-E ARSs, suggesting that the protein alters the DNA conformation at element A and its repeats. The affinity-purified fraction is also capable of supercoiling a relaxed, covalently closed plasmid in the presence of topoisomerase. Highly purified preparations of the protein are enriched in an 18-kDa polypeptide which can be renatured from a denaturing gel and shown to bind ARS1 DNA. We have designated this protein DBF-A, DNA-binding factor A.     

Characterization of the putative replisome organizer of the lactococcal bacteriophage r1t

Analysis of the nucleotide sequence of the genome of the lactococcal bacteriophage r1t showed that it may encode at least two proteins involved in DNA replication. On the basis of its similarity with the G38P protein encoded by the Bacillus subtilis phage SPP1, the product of orf11 (Pro11) is thought to be involved in the initiation of phage DNA replication. This protein was overexpressed in Lactococcus lactis and partially purified. Gel retardation analysis using various r1t DNA fragments indicates that Pro11 specifically binds to a sequence located within its cognate gene. DNase I footprinting showed that Pro11 protects a stretch of DNA of 47 bp. This region spans four 6-bp short direct repeats, which suggests that the region contains four binding sites for Pro11. 1,10-Phenanthroline-copper footprinting confirmed the protection of the hexamers. An asymmetric protection pattern of each strand was observed, suggesting that Pro11 contacts each DNA strand separately at contiguous hexamers. We propose a model for the binding of Pro11 to its target sites that may account for the torsion strain required for strand opening at the origin of replication.     

Identification of a nuclear protein interacting with a novel site on rat androgen receptor promoter after transcription factor NFkB is displaced from adjacent site

Sequence-specific DNA-protein interactions mediate the regulation of rat androgen receptor (rAR) gene expression. Previously, DNase I footprinting revealed that nuclear factor kappa B (NFkB) binds to region -574 to -554 on rAR promoter and represses its expression. In this study, we demonstrate that when NFkB protein is removed from its site by competitor DNA in DNase I footprinting reaction, a new DNase I protected region is formed overlapping adjacently (-594 to -561). This indicates that another nuclear protein (named here as FRN, factor repressed by NFkB) binds to rAR promoter only after NFkB protein is displaced. By competitive electrophoretic mobility shift assay and mutation analysis, we confirmed the formation of FRN-DNA complex. FRN interacts with a novel sequence on rAR promoter and may play a role in regulation of rAR gene expression in concert with NFkB.     

Structural aspects of a higher order nucleoprotein complex: induction of an altered DNA structure at the Mu-host junction of the Mu type 1 transpososome.

The Mu in vitro strand transfer reaction proceeds via two stable higher order nucleoprotein complexes, the Type 1 and Type 2 transpososomes. The Mu A protein is responsible for the structural and functional integrity of the Type 1 transpososome. We have investigated the quaternary structure of the Mu A protein within this complex by chemical cross-linking experiments and found that the basic structural unit is an A tetramer. Three Mu A binding sites in the transpososome are protected by DNase I footprinting: the outermost A binding sites L1 and R1, as well as R2. Genetic evidence is also presented which corroborates this result. Efficient formation of Type 1 complexes occurs in mini-Mus with the L3 or R3 sites deleted or when the L2 site has been substituted; but no reaction occurs in the absence of R2. The protection at the L1 and R1 sites extends 12-13 bp beyond the Mu-host junctions as seen by DNase I and methidiumpropyl-EDTA.Fe(II) [MPE.Fe(II)] foot-printing, indicating Mu A contacts with the flanking host sequences in the transpososome but not on linear DNA; furthermore, hydroxyl radical footprinting shows an unprecedentedly large enhancement on the continuous strand, 2 bp beyond the nick site outside the Mu right end, which suggests that an altered DNA structure is induced upon Type 1 complex formation.     

Gibberellin treatment stimulates nuclear factor binding to the gibberellin response complex in a barley alpha-amylase promoter.

The promoters of a majority of cereal alpha-amylase genes contain three highly conserved sequences (gibberellin response element, box I, and pyrimidine box). Recent studies have demonstrated the functional importance of four regions that either coincide with or are immediately proximal to these three conserved elements as well as an upstream Opaque-2 binding sequence. In this study, we describe the characterization of nuclear protein factors from barley aleurone layers whose binding activity toward gibberellin response complex sequences from the barley low-pl alpha-amylase gene (Amy32b) promoter is stimulated by gibberellin A3 (GA3) treatment. Barley proteins isolated from crude nuclear extracts prepared from aleurone layers incubated with or without GA3 were fractionated by anion exchange fast protein liquid chromatography and studied using band shift assays, sequence-specific competitions, and DNase I footprinting. A GA3-dependent binding activity eluting at 210 mM KCl was shown to bind specifically to the gibberellin response element and the closely associated box I. DNase I footprinting with the proteins in this fraction indicated interactions with sequences in the gibberellin response element and box I. A second DNA binding activity eluting at 310 mM KCl was present constitutively in extracts prepared from tissues incubated both in the absence and in the presence of hormone. Proteins in this fraction were able to bind to many DNA sequences and, in general, were largely nonspecific. DNase I footprinting with the proteins in this fraction indicated a large area of protection with a single unoccupied region located at the 3' end of box I. The possible function of such an activity in hormone regulation of the alpha-amylase genes is discussed.     

Nucleotide sequence binding preferences of nogalamycin investigated by DNase I footprinting

Four DNA restriction fragments, designated tyrT, pTyr2, pUC13, and Xbs1, have been used as substrates for footprinting studies with DNase I in the presence of the anthracycline antibiotic nogalamycin. With each fragment a distinct pattern of antibiotic-protected binding sites is observed, but no concensus sequence emerges from the data. All sites are located in regions of alternating purine-pyrimidine sequence, most commonly associated with the dinucleotide steps TpG (CpA) and GpT (ApC), suggesting that the preferred binding sites may contain all four nucleotides and/or that peculiarities of the dynamics of DNA conformation at alternating sequences may be critical for nogalamycin binding. Some concentration dependence of footprinting patterns is evident, in contrast to previous studies with a variety of sequence-specific ligands. Enhanced susceptibility to attack by DNase I is commonly observed at sequences flanking strong antibiotic-binding sites. Nogalamycin selectively inhibits cleavage of DNA at certain guanine-containing sequences by the G-specific photosensitized reaction with methylene blue. Comparison of these effects with its action on the G-specific reaction with dimethyl sulfate suggests that the amino sugar moiety of nogalamycin may be preferentially located in the minor helical groove at some binding sites but in the major groove at others.     

Terminase host factor: a histone-like E. coli protein which can bind to the cos region of bacteriophage lambda DNA.

Terminase Host Factor (THF), an E. coli protein capable of fulfilling the host factor requirement for in vitro bacteriophage lambda terminase activity, displays properties characteristic of the prokaryotic type II DNA-binding or "histone-like" proteins. It is a 22 K basic, heat- and acid-stable protein which binds non-specifically to various DNAs. Conditions can be established, however, where THF binds preferentially to the cohesive end site (cos) of lambda DNA forming several distinct complexes as visualized by band retardation in polyacrylamide gels. DNase I footprinting reveals that THF can protect several regions of the top strand on the right side (+) of cos but does not bind as well to the left side (-). The binding regions are separated either by unprotected or by DNase I- hypersensitive bases. Under the conditions used in these experiments, DNA which does not contain cos lambda sequences does not show this pattern of protection. Several repeated motifs in the cos lambda nucleotide sequence may represent a consensus sequence for THF interaction. THF may be similar to other "histone-like" proteins which display both non-specific and selective DNA-binding capacities.     

A human DNA-binding protein is methylation-specific and sequence-specific.

A nuclear protein isolated from human placenta, methylated DNA-binding protein (MDBP), binds selectively to DNA enriched in 5-methylcytosine. We now demonstrate that MDBP is a sequence-specific, as well as methylation-specific, DNA-binding protein. From ten restriction fragments of pBR322 DNA methylated with human DNA methyltransferase, one was bound to MDBP very much more strongly than any of the others. For this preferential binding to MDBP, the DNA had to be methylated. By a DNase I protection experiment (DNase I footprinting), a 22-base sequence within this methylated restriction fragment was shown to be specifically protected by MDBP. The sequence-specificity of MDBP coupled with its dependence on DNA methylation suggests that this is one of the proteins which modulates important functions of human DNA methylation in vivo.     

Footprinting: a method for determining the sequence selectivity, affinity and kinetics of DNA-binding ligands

Footprinting is a simple method for assessing the sequence selectivity of DNA-binding ligands. The method is based on the ability of the ligand to protect DNA from cleavage at its binding site. This review describes the use of DNase I and hydroxyl radicals, the most commonly used footprinting probes, in footprinting experiments. The success of a footprinting experiment depends on using an appropriate DNA substrate and we describe how these can best be chosen or designed. Although footprinting was originally developed for assessing a ligand's sequence selectivity, it can also be employed to estimate the binding strength (quantitative footprinting) and to assess the association and dissociation rate constants for slow binding reactions.