Analysis of putative protomer crosstalk in the trimeric transporter BetP: The heterotrimer approach

The homotrimeric, secondary active betaine carrier BetP from Corynebacterium glutamicum is a model system for stress-regulated transport in bacteria. Its activity responds to hyperosmotic stress and it harbors two different functions, transport catalysis (betaine uptake) and stimulus sensing, resp. activity regulation. Structural information from 2D and 3D crystals as well as functional analysis of monomerized BetP suggested the presence of conformational crosstalk between the individual protomers. To study whether the oligomeric state is functionally significant on a mechanistic level we generated heterooligomeric complexes of BetP in which single protomers within the trimer can be addressed. By testing dominant negative effects in a trimer of one active protomer combined with two protomers in which transport and regulation were abolished, we provide experimental evidence for the absence of functionally significant conformational crosstalk between the protomers on the level of both transport and regulation. This is supported by experiments using mutant forms of putative interacting signal donor and acceptor domains of individual BetP protomers. This result has important consequences for oligomeric transport proteins in general and BetP in particular.     

Na+,K+-ATPase: structure, mechanism, and regulation

Structural organization of alpha- and beta-subunits of Na+,K+-ATPase in the membrane, the enzyme oligomeric structure, and mechanisms of ATP hydrolysis and cation transport are considered. The data on the structure of cation-binding sites and ion-conductive pathways of the pump are reviewed. The properties of isoforms of both subunits are described. Special attention was paid to the ATP modifying effect on Na+,K+-ATPase. To explain the rather complex dependence of the Na+,K+-ATPase activity on ATP concentration, a hypothesis is proposed, which is based on the assumption that the membrane contains the enzyme protomer exhibiting high affinity to ATP and an oligomer having low affinity to the nucleotide and characterized by positive cooperative interactions between subunits. Data on the Na+,K+-ATPase phosphorylation by protein kinases A and C are reviewed.     

Radiolysis of lac repressor by gamma-rays and heavy ions: a two-hit model for protein inactivation

Upon gamma-ray or argon ion irradiation of the lac repressor protein, its peptide chain is cleaved and the protein loses its lac operator-binding activity, as shown respectively by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis and retardation gel electrophoresis. We developed phenomenological models that satisfactorily account for the experimental results: the peptide chain cleavage model considers that the average number of chain breaks per protomer is proportional to the irradiation dose and that the distribution of the number of breaks per protomer obeys Poisson's law. The repressor inactivation model takes into account the quaternary structure (a dimer of dimer) and the organization of the repressor in domains (two DNA binding sites, one per dimer). A protomer is inactivated by at least two different radiation-induced damages. A dimer is inactivated when at least one of the two protomers is inactivated. A tetramer is inactivated when both dimers are inactivated. From the combination of both models, we can deduce that chain cleavage cannot account for the protein inactivation, which should mainly result from oxidation of amino acid side chains. Indeed, particularly oxidizable and accessible amino acids (Tyr, His) are involved in the DNA binding process.     

Cooperativity in highly aggregated enzyme systems. A slow transition model for the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex from Escherichia coli

Three models are compared describing cooperative phenomena in enzymatic reactions in order to explain sigmoidal saturation curves found with the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex from Escherichia coli: the concerted model, the sequential model, and the slow transition model. Both the concerted and the sequential model were considered especially with regard to the increasing number of identical interaction subunits (protomers) in order to get close to the situation found with the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex which consists of 24 protomers. Applying the sequential model to a great number of protomers results in a weak increase of the Hill coefficient, while, in addition to this effect, the concerted model drastically shifts the sigmoidal range of the saturation function to very low ligand concentrations. Such shift is seen with saturation curves of pyruvate and thiamine disphosphate with the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex and a good fit with theoretical curves derived from the concerted model is obtained. However, subcomplexes with a reduced number of protomers exhibited no change in saturation behavior, thus providing evidence against concerted conformational changes of all subunits of the enzyme complex. A scheme for the initial reaction of the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex based on slow transitions is presented and a rate equation has been derived. Ordered binding of thiamine diphosphate and pyruvate and a ligand-induced slow transition between a less active and a fully active enzyme form has been assumed. The curves simulated with this model are in agreement with all essential kinetic data, which are observed with the pyruvate dehydrogenase complex: the atypical shape of the saturation curves of pyruvate and thiamine diphosphate, the respective Hill coefficients and Michaelis constants, the hyperbolic binding behavior of thiamine diphosphate, and the inhibition pattern found for acetyl coenzyme A.     

Crystal structure of novel NADP-dependent 3-hydroxyisobutyrate dehydrogenase from Thermus thermophilus HB8

3-Hydroxyisobutyrate, a central metabolite in the valine catabolic pathway, is reversibly oxidized to methylmalonate semialdehyde by a specific dehydrogenase belonging to the 3-hydroxyacid dehydrogenase family. To gain insight into the function of this enzyme at the atomic level, we have determined the first crystal structures of the 3-hydroxyisobutyrate dehydrogenase from Thermus thermophilus HB8: holo enzyme and sulfate ion complex. The crystal structures reveal a unique tetrameric oligomerization and a bound cofactor NADP+. This bacterial enzyme may adopt a novel cofactor-dependence on NADP, whereas NAD is preferred in eukaryotic enzymes. The protomer folds into two distinct domains with open/closed interdomain conformations. The cofactor NADP+ with syn nicotinamide and the sulfate ion are bound to distinct sites located at the interdomain cleft of the protomer through an induced-fit domain closure upon cofactor binding. From the structural comparison with the crystal structure of 6-phosphogluconate dehydrogenase, another member of the 3-hydroxyacid dehydrogenase family, it is suggested that the observed sulfate ion and the substrate 3-hydroxyisobutyrate share the same binding pocket. The observed oligomeric state might be important for the catalytic function through forming the active site involving two adjacent subunits, which seems to be conserved in the 3-hydroxyacid dehydrogenases. A kinetic study confirms that this enzyme has strict substrate specificity for 3-hydroxyisobutyrate and serine, but it cannot distinguish the chirality of the substrates. Lys165 is likely the catalytic residue of the enzyme.     

Molecular properties of cis,cis-muconate cycloisomerase from Pseudomonas putida

cis,cis-Muconate cycloisomerase (cis,cis-muconate lactonizing enzyme, EC 5.5.1.1.) was purified in crystalline form from Pseudomonas putida. Ultracentrifugation studies, as well as gel filtration chromatography and electrophoresis, indicate that the enzyme is an oligomeric protein of molecular weight 252,000 (s_20,w 12.20 × 10^?13 s), which is built of six homologous protomers of molecular weight 42,000. Studies of enzyme crystals and enzyme molecules in the electron microscope suggest that the cis,cis-muconate cycloisomerase is a hexamer in which the six protomers are arranged in a dihedral point-group symmetry 32 (D₃). Each protomer has a diameter of 42.5Åand six protomers are associated in a structure with a trigonal antiprismatic geometry (a hexamer D₃ octahedron). This model could account for the dimensions most frequently observed by negative staining of the enzyme in solution. A model for the three-dimensional structure of enzyme crystals in which each hexameric enzyme molecule is surrounded by eight neighbouring enzyme molecules, is described.     

Subunit interactions in liver alcohol dehydrogenase: A partial alkylation study.

The transient kinetics of aldehyde reduction by NADH catalyzed by liver alcohol dehydrogenase consist of two kinetic processes. This biphasic rate behavior is consistent with a model in which one of the two identical subunits in the enzyme is inactive during the reaction at the adjacent protomer. Alternatively, enzyme heterogeneity could result in such biphasic behavior. We have prepared liver alcohol dehydrogenase containing a single major isozyme; and the transient kinetics of this purified enzyme are biphasic.Addition of two [¹⁴C]carboxymethyl groups per dimer to the two “reactive” sulfhydryl groups (Cys46) yields enzyme which is catalytically inactive toward alcohol oxidation. Alkylated enzyme, as initially isolated by gel filtration chromatography at pH 7·5, forms an NAD⁺-pyrazole complex. However, the ability to bind NAD⁺-pyrazole is rapidly lost in pH 8·75 buffer; therefore, our alkylated preparations, as isolated by chromatography at pH 8·75, are inactive toward NAD⁺-pyrazole complex formation. We have prepared partially inactivated enzyme by allowing iodoacetic acid to react with liver alcohol dehydrogenase until 50% of the NAD⁺-pyrazole binding capacity remains; under these reaction conditions one [¹⁴C]carboxymethyl group is added per dimer. This partially alkylated enzyme preparation is isolated by gel filtration and has been aged sufficiently to lose NAD⁺-pyrazole binding ability at alkylated subunits. When solutions of native liver alcohol dehydrogenase and partially alkylated liver alcohol dehydrogenase containing the same number of unmodified active sites are allowed to react with substrate under single turnover conditions, partially alkylated enzyme is only half as reactive as native enzyme. This indicates that some molecular species in partially alkylated liver alcohol dehydrogenase that react with pyrazole and NAD⁺ during the active site titration do not react with substrate. These data are consistent with a model in which a subunit adjacent to an alkylated protomer in the dimeric enzyme is inactive toward substrate. In addition, NAD⁺-pyrazole binding at the protomers adjacent to alkylated subunits is slowly lost so that 75% of the enzyme-NAD⁺-pyrazole binding capacity is lost in 50% alkylated enzyme. These data supply strong evidence for subunit interactions in liver alcohol dehydrogenase.Binding experiments performed on partially alkylated liver alcohol dehydrogenase indicate that coenzyme binding is normal at a subunit adjacent to an alkylated protomer even though active ternary complexes cannot be formed. One hypothesis consistent with these results is the unavailability of zinc for substrate binding at the active site in subunits adjacent to alkylated protomers in monoalkylated dimer.     

Inactivation mechanism of tetrameric beta-galactosidase by gamma-rays involves both fragmentation and temperature-dependent denaturation of protomers

The radiation inactivation method is widely used to estimate the molecular size of membrane-bound enzymes, receptors, and transport systems in situ. The method is based on the principle that exposure of frozen solutions or lyophilized protein preparations to increasing doses of ionizing radiations results in a first-order decay of biological activity proportional to radiation inactivation size of the protein. This parameter is believed to reflect the "functional unit" of the protein defined as the minimal assembly of structure (protomers) required for expression of a given biological activity. We tested the functional unit as a concept to interpret radiation inactivation data of proteins with Escherichia coli beta-galactosidase, where the protomers are active only when associated in a tetramer. Gamma-Irradiation of beta-galactosidase at both -78 and 38 degrees C followed by quantitation of the residual unfragmented promoter band by SDS-polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis yielded the protomer size, indicating that only one protomer is fragmented by each radiation hit. By following the enzyme activity as a function of dose it was found that only the protomer that has been directly hit and fragmented at -78 degrees C was effectively inactivated. In contrast, at 38 degrees C, it was the whole tetramer that was inactivated. beta-Galactosidase cannot have two different functional units depending on temperature. The inactivation of the whole beta-galactosidase tetramer at 38 degrees C is in fact related to protomer fragmentation but also to the production of stable denatured protomers (detected by gel-filtration HPLC and differential UV spectroscopy) due to energy transfer from fragmented protomers toward unhit protomers.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

DNA gyrase subunit stoichiometry and the covalent attachment of subunit A to DNA during DNA cleavage.

Escherichia coli DNA gyrase contains a 1:1 ratio of protomers coded by the genes gyrA and gyrB. This along with previous results shows that the enzyme has two copies of each protomer and thus a molecular weight of 400,000. Abortion of the gyrase reaction results in double-strand breakage of the DNA and covalent attachment of both gyrA protomers to the 5'-cut ends. We conclude that the gyrA protomer contains a critical part of the active site for the concerted breakage and reunion reaction of gyrase, the topoisomerase activity of the enzyme.     

Mechanical unfolding of covalently linked GroES: Evidence of structural subunit intermediates

It is difficult to determine the structural stability of the individual subunits or protomers of many proteins in the cell that exist in an oligomeric or complexed state. In this study, we used single‐molecule force spectroscopy on seven subunits of covalently linked cochaperonin GroES (ESC7) to evaluate the structural stability of the subunit. A modified form of ESC7 was immobilized on a mica surface. The force‐extension profile obtained from the mechanical unfolding of this ESC7 showed a distinctive sawtooth pattern that is typical for multimodular proteins. When analyzed according to the worm‐like chain model, the contour lengths calculated from the peaks in the profile suggested that linked‐GroES subunits unfold in distinct steps after the oligomeric ring structure of ESC7 is disrupted. The evidence that structured subunits of ESC7 withstand external force to some extent even after the perturbation of the oligomeric ring structure suggests that a stable monomeric intermediate is an important component of the equilibrium unfolding reaction of GroES.     

Kinetic cooperativity in the concerted model for allosteric enzymes.

The cooperativity of enzyme-substrate interactions is investigated in the concerted allosteric model of Monod, Wyman and Changeux. The general case of K-V systems is considered, in which the two protomer conformational states R and T postulated in the theory differ in catalytic and binding properties. An expression for the Hill coefficient nH defined with respect to the asymptotic velocity V infinity to is analyzed in conditions which exclude substrate inhibition. Kinetic cooperativity is always positive (nH greater than 1) in the case of a dimer enzyme, and in the case of an inactive T state. Slight kinetic negative cooperativity (nH less than 1) occurs under restrictive conditions for larger numbers of protomers when the substrate binds significantly to the less active state of the enzyme, but the phenomenon remains negligible for trimers and tetramers. These conclusions differ from those obtained [A. Goldbeter, J. Mol.Biol.90 (1974) 185] with the Hill coefficient based on the absolute maximum velocity, which may exceed the experimental value V infinity to in K-V systems. The results extend those of Paulus and DeRiel [J. Mol. Biol. 97 (1975) 667] and support the view that in most cases, negative cooperativity is not compatible with a mechanism based on a concerted and conservative allosteric transition. The Hill coefficients for binding and catalysis are compared in K-V systems.     

Gene duplication and protein evolution. Case of aminoacyl-t-RNA synthetases]

Aminoacyl-tRNA synthetases are a functionally homologous group of enzymes which catalyse the first step of protein synthesis. The accumulation of data on the oligomeric structures of these enzymes has revealed a wide diversity in the sizes and organization of the protomers. This is not consistent with the idea of a family with homologous primary and tertiary structures. Howewer recent studies have shown that all these enzymes may have evolved from a common ancestor through gene duplication and fusion which has led to extensive repeating sequences in the corresponding subunits.     

Low-resolution structure of the tetrameric phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase from Escherichia coli. A neutron small-angle scattering study of hybrids composed of protonated and deuterated protomers

Escherichia coli phenylalanyl-tRNA synthetase is a tetrameric protein composed of two types of protomers. In order to resolve the subunit organization, neutron small-angle scattering experiments have been performed in different contrasts with all types of isotope hybrids that could be obtained by reconstituting the alpha 2 beta 2 enzyme from the protonated and deuterated forms of the alpha and beta subunits. Experiments have been also made with the isolated alpha promoter. A model for the alpha 2 beta 2 tetramer is deduced where the two alpha promoters are elongated ellipsoids (45 x 45 x 160 A3) lying side by side with an angle of about 40 degrees between their long axes and where the two beta subunits are also elongated ellipsoids (31 x 31 x 130 A3) with an angle of 30 degrees between their axes. This model was obtained by assuming that the two pairs of subunits are in contact in an orthogonal manner and by taking advantage of the measured distance between the centers of mass of the alpha 2 and beta 2 pairs (d = 23 +/- 2 A).     

An Asymmetric Deuterium Labeling Strategy to Identify Interprotomer and Intraprotomer NOEs in Oligomeric Proteins

A major difficulty in determining the structure of an oligomeric protein by NMR is the problem of distinguishing inter- from intraprotomer NOEs. In order to address this issue in studies of the 27 kD compact trimeric domain of the MHC class II-associated invariant chain, we compared the 13C NOESY-HSQC spectrum of a uniformly 13C-labeled trimer with the spectrum of the same trimer labeled with 13C in only one protomer, and with deuterium in the other two protomers. The spectrum of the unmixed trimer included both inter- and intraprotomer NOEs while the spectrum of the mixed trimer included only intraprotomer peaks. NOEs clearly absent from the spectrum of the mixed trimer could be confidently assigned to interprotomer interactions. Asymmetrically labeled trimers were isolated by refolding a 13C-labeled shorter form of the protein with a 2H-labeled longer form, chromatographically purifying trimers with only one short chain, and then processing with trypsin to yield only protomers with the desired N- and C-termini. In contrast to earlier studies, in which statistical mixtures of differently labeled protomers were analyzed, our procedure generated only a well-defined 1:2 oligomer, and no other mixed oligomers were present. This increased the maximum possible concentration of NMR-active protomers and thus the sensitivity of the experiments. Related methods should be applicable to many oligomeric proteins, particularly those with slow protomer exchange rates.     

Studies of homogeneous "biosynthetic" L-threonine dehydratase from Escherichia coli K-12. Some kinetic properties and molecular multiplicity.

"Biosynthetic" L-threonine dehydratase (EC 4.2.1.16) was purified to a homogeneous state with 29% yield of total activity from Escherichia coli K-12. The homogeneity of the enzyme was shown by polyacrylamide gel disc electrophoresis in the presence of dodecyl sulphate. The enzyme consisted of equal subunits having a molecular weight of about 57 000. The polyacrylamide gel disc electrophoresis has shown that the native enzyme consisted of a set of oligomeric forms. The multiplicity of molecular organization of the enzyme was reflected in complicated kinetic behaviour: at pH greater than 9 on the plots of initial reaction rate (v) versus initial substrate concentration ([S]o) there were four inflexion points (two intermediate plateaux), the position and deepness of which depended on enzyme concentration. At pH 8.3 on the v versus [S]o plots appeared two inflexion points (one intermediate plateu), the position of which practically did not depend on enzyme concentration in the reaction mixture, but strongly depended on the enzyme concentration in the stock solution. Repeated polyacrylamide gel disc electrophoresis of several oligomeric forms, isolated by the first electrophoresis, has shown that the oligomeric forms underwent a slow polymerization. It was suggested that "biosynthetic" L-threonine dehydratase from E. coli K-12 is a set of multiple oligomeric forms, having different kinetic parameters. Probably, each form of the enzyme has a "simple" kinetics characterized by hyperbolic or sigmoidal shape of v versus [S]o plots. The rate of equilibrium installation between the oligomeric forms was small in comparison with the enzyme reaction velocity, that lead to the complex kinetic curves, appearing as a result of summing up of the kinetics inherent to theindividual forms.     

Only one protomer is active in the dimer of SARS 3C-like proteinase

The severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 3C-like protease has been proposed to be a key target for structurally based drug design against SARS. The enzyme exists as a mixture of dimer and monomer, and only the dimer was considered to be active. In this report, we have investigated, using molecular dynamics simulation and mutational studies, the problems as to why only the dimer is active and whether both of the two protomers in the dimer are active. The molecular dynamics simulations show that the monomers are always inactive, that the two protomers in the dimer are asymmetric, and that only one protomer is active at a time. The enzyme activity of the hybrid severe acute respiratory syndrome coronavirus 3C-like protease of the wild-type protein and the inactive mutant proves that the dimerization is important for enzyme activity and only one active protomer in the dimer is enough for the catalysis. Our simulations also show that the right conformation for catalysis in one protomer can be induced upon dimer formation. These results suggest that the enzyme may follow the association, activation, catalysis, and dissociation mechanism for activity control.     

Multimeric structure of the secreted meprin A metalloproteinase and characterization of the functional protomer

Meprin A secreted from kidney and intestinal epithelial cells is capable of cleaving growth factors, extracellular matrix proteins, and biologically active peptides. The secreted form of meprin A is a homo-oligomer composed of alpha subunits, a multidomain protease of 582 amino acids coded for near the major histocompatibility complex of the mouse and human genome. Analyses of the recombinant homo-oligomeric form of mouse meprin A by gel filtration, nondenaturing gel electrophoresis, and cross-linking (with disuccinimidyl suberate or N-(4-azido-2,3,5,6-tetraflourobenzyl)-3-maleimidylpropionamide) indicate that the secreted enzyme forms high molecular weight multimers, with a predominance of decamers. The multimers are composed of disulfide-linked dimers attached noncovalently by interactions involving the meprin, A5 protein, receptor protein-tyrosine phosphatase mu (MAM) domain. The active protomer is the noncovalently linked dimer. Linkage of active protomers by disulfide-bonds results in an oligomer of approximately 900 kDa, which is unique among proteases and distinguishes meprin A as the largest known secreted protease. Electron microscopy revealed that the protein was present in two states, a crescent-shaped structure and a closed ring. It is concluded from this and other data that the covalent attachment of the protomers enables noncovalent associations of the native enzyme to form higher oligomers that are critical for hydrolysis of protein substrates.     

Subunit structure of islet-activating protein, pertussis toxin, in conformity with the A-B model

The subunit structure of islet-activating protein (IAP), pertussis toxin, has been analyzed to study a possibility that this protein is one of the A-B toxins [Gill, D. M. (1978) in Bacterial Toxins and Cell Membranes (Jeljaszewicz, J., & Wadstrom, T., Eds.) pp 291-332, Academic Press, New York]. Heating IAP with 1% sodium dodecyl sulfate caused its dissociation into five dissimilar subunits named S-1 (with a molecular weight of 28 000), S-2 (23 000), S-3 (22 000), S-4 (11 700), and S-5 (9300), as revealed by polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis; their molar ratio in the native IAP was 1:1:1:2:1. The molecular weight of IAP estimated by equilibrium ultracentrifugation was 117 000 which was not at variance with the value obtained by summing up molecular weights of the constituent subunits. The preparative separation of these IAP subunits was next undertaken; exposure of IAP to 5 M ice-cold urea for 4 days followed by column chromatography with carboxymethyl-Sepharose caused sharp separation of S-1 and S-5, leaving the other subunits as two dimers. These dimers were then dissociated into their constituent subunits, i.e., S-2 and S-4 for one dimer and S-3 and S-4 for the other, after 16-h exposure to 8 M urea; these subunits were obtained individually upon further chromatography on a diethylaminoethyl-Sepharose column. Subunits other than S-1 were adsorbed as a pentamer by a column using haptoglobin as an affinity adsorbent. The same pentamer was obtained by adding S-5 to the mixture of two dimers. Neither this pentamer nor other oligomers (or protomers) exhibited biological activity in vivo. Recombination of S-1 with the pentamer at the 1:1 molar ratio yielded a hexamer which was identical with the native IAP in electrophoretic mobility and biological activity to enhance glucose-induced insulin secretion when injected into rats. In the broken-cell preparation, S-1 was biologically as effective as the native IAP; both catalyzed ADP-ribosylation of a protein in membrane preparations from rat C6 glioma cells. In conclusion, IAP is an oligomeric protein consisting of an A (active) protomer (the biggest subunit) and a B (binding) oligomer which is produced by connecting two dimers by the smallest subunit in a noncovalent manner. Rationale for this terminology is discussed based on the A-B model.     

Modification of glutamate dehydrogenase by pyridoxal-5'-phosphate. Study of the structural organisation of the hexamer and its possible role in the realization of GTP action

The catalytic and regulator properties of glutamate dehydrogenase by modification of Lys-126 residue by puridoxal-5'-phosphate was studied. The phosphopyridoxyl derivative of the enzyme with blocked NADH-induced binding site of GTP not capable of being polymerized was taken as a model. It was shown that: blocking the epsilon-amino group of Lys-126 residue brings to a simultaneous inactivation of the enzyme and desensibilization of its residual activity to GTP action; the modification of Lys-126 residue and resulting inactivation of the enzyme and desensibilization to GTP action were non-cooperative processes, with equal values of pseudofirst order rate constants; modification of Lys-126 residue of any of hexamer's protomer results in the desensibilization to GTP action on one of the contacting, catalytically active protomers. The experimental dependence of the inhibition degree of the enzyme by GTP upon the average number of modified residues of Lys-126 is explained by the model of the hexamer of glutamate dehydrogenase with identical interlocation of any of the protomers in relation to the one in contact.