Responses to amputation of denervated ambystoma limbs containing aneurogenic limb grafts

The developing neural tubes and associated neural crest cells were removed from stage 30 Ambystoma maculatum embryos to obtain larvae with aneurogenic forelimbs. Forelimbs were allowed to develop to late 3 digit or early 4 digit stages. Limbs amputated through the mid radius-ulna regenerated typically in the aneurogenic condition. Experiments were designed to test whether grafts of aneurogenic limb tissues would rescue denervated host limb stumps into a regeneration response. In Experiment 1, aneurogenic limbs were removed at the body wall and grafted under the dorsal skin of the distal end of amputated forelimbs of control, normally innervated limbs of locally collected Ambystoma maculatum or axolotl (Ambystoma mexicanum) larvae. In Experiment 1, at the time of grafting or 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 7, or 8 days after grafting, aneurogenic limbs were amputated level with the original host stump. At 7 and 8 days, this amputation included removing the host blastema adjacent to the graft. The host limb was denervated either one day after grafting or on the day of graft amputation. These chimeric limbs only infrequently exhibited delayed blastema formation. Thus, not only did the graft not rescue the host, denervated limb, but the aneurogenic limb tissues themselves could not mount a regeneration response. In Experiment 2, the grafted aneurogenic limb was amputated through its mid-stylopodium at 3, 4, 5, 7, or 8 days after grafting. By 7 and 8 days after grafting, the host limb stump exhibited blastema formation even with the graft extending out from under the dorsal skin. The host limb was denervated at the time of graft amputation. When graft limbs of Experiment 2 were amputated and host limbs were denervated on days 3, 4, or 5, host regeneration did not progress and graft regeneration did not occur. But, when graft limbs were amputated on days 7 or 8 with concomitant denervation of the host limb, regeneration of the host continued and graft regeneration occurred. Thus, regeneration of the graft was correlated with acquisition of nerve-independence by the host limb blastema. In Experiment 3, aneurogenic limbs were grafted with minimal injury to the dorsal skin of neurogenic hosts. When neurogenic host limbs were denervated and the aneurogenic limbs were amputated through the radius/ulna, regeneration of the aneurogenic limb occurred if the neurogenic limb host was not amputated, but did not occur if the neurogenic limb host was amputated. Results of Experiment 3 indicate that the inhibition of aneurogenic graft limb regeneration on a denervated host limb is correlated with substantial injury to the host limb. In Experiment 4, aneurogenic forelimbs were amputated through the mid-radius ulna and pieces of either peripheral nerve, muscle, blood vessel, or cartilage were grafted into the distal limb stump or under the body skin immediately adjacent to the limb at the body wall. In most cases, peripheral nerve inhibited regeneration, blood vessel tissue sometimes inhibited, but other tissues had no effect on regeneration. Taken together, the results suggest: (1) Aneurogenic limb tissues do not produce the neurotrophic factor and do not need it for regeneration, and (2) there is a regeneration-inhibiting factor produced by the nerve-dependent limb stump/blastema after denervation that prevents regeneration of aneurogenic limbs.     

Evidence that the nerve controls molecular identity of progenitor cells for limb regeneration

Adult urodele amphibians can regenerate their limbs after amputation by a process that requires the presence of axons at the amputation plane. Paradoxically, if the limb develops in the near absence of nerves (the 'aneurogenic' limb) it can subsequently regenerate in a nerve-independent fashion. The growth zone (blastema) of regenerating limbs normally contains progenitor cells whose division is nerve-dependent. A monoclonal antibody that marks these nerve-dependent cells in the normal blastema does not stain the mesenchymal cells of developing limb buds and only stains the amputated limb bud when axons have reached the plane of amputation. This report shows that the blastemal cells of the regenerating aneurogenic limb also fail to react with the antibody in situ. These data suggest that the blastemal cells arising during normal regeneration have been altered by the nerve. This regulation may occur either at the time of amputation (when the antigen is expressed) or during development (when the limb is first innervated).     

Stimulation of lens regeneration from the newt dorsal iris when implanted into the blastema of the regenerating limb

Dorsal iris from the eyes of adult Notophthalmus viridescens was transplanted into the blastema of regenerating limbs, subcutaneously in the limb or shoulder region, into the dorsal fin of larval newts and into the hindbrain of larval Ambystoma maculatum. The iris implants into the blastema regenerated lens vesicles or lenses with fibers in 40–75% of the cases. Multiple lenses were found in a few instances. No lenses developed from iris implants into the dorsal fin. Twenty percent of subcutaneous implants of iris formed lenses or lens vesicles, but lens regeneration from implants into the brain occurred only rarely. Denervation of the limb at the time of iris transplantation into the blastema greatly reduced the number of lenses regenerated. Studies on nerve fiber distribution in dorsal fin, subcutaneous areas, and denervated and innervated regenerating limbs, using the Bodian method, showed a general correlation between density of nerve fibers in the implant site and the incidence of lens regeneration from iris implants into that site. These results provide some evidence for a trophic action of nerve fibers on lens regeneration from the iris.     

Axial characteristics of nerve induced supernumerary limbs in the axolotl

Summary Supernumerary limbs were produced by deviating the sciatic nerve to the surface of the axolotl hindlimb either alone or in combination with small skin grafts from specific limb positions. With no skin grafts a very low frequency of good supernumeraries were produced. However, when associated with skin grafts, this frequency was significantly increased. The pattern of skeletal elements and muscles were analysed in the supernumeraries which formed at each location. In both the anterior-posterior and dorsal-ventral axes specific anatomical features were found which correlated with their position of origin on the host limb. Characteristic features were also observed with respect to the proximal-distal axis of the outgrowths. These phenomena are discussed in relation to our current understanding of the rules of pattern regulation in the regenerating limb.     

The structure of 180° supernumerary limbs and a hypothesis of their formation

The results of a detailed analysis of 100 supernumerary limbs generated by 180° ipsilateral rotation (on the same limb stump) of regeneration blastemas is presented. The limbs were analyzed in terms of their position of origin, frequency, cartilage structure by Victoria blue staining, and muscle structure by serial sections. Single, double, or triple supernumeraries can be produced at no unique position of origin, although the posterodorsal quadrant was preferred. Four classes of supernumerary limbs were generated by such operations—normal; double dorsal or double ventral; part normal/part mirror imaged; part normal/part inverted in approximately equal frequencies. After amputation of these supernumeraries the same muscle patterns are faithfully regenerated. A hypothesis to explain the production of these abnormal limbs is proposed based on the observed phenomenon of fusion of supernumerary blastemata, but their regenerative behaviour presents problems for current models of pattern formation. Similar results have been obtained with developing limb buds and the relation between development and regeneration is discussed.     

Brachially innervated ectopic hindlimbs in the chick embryo. I. Limb motility and motor system anatomy during the development of embryonic behavior

The functional status of brachially innervated hindlimbs, produced by transplanting hindlimb buds of chick embryos in place of forelimb buds, was quantified by analyzing the number and temporal distribution of spontaneous limb movements. Brachially innervated hindlimbs exhibited normal motility until E10 but thereafter became significantly less active than normal limbs and the limb movements were more randomly distributed. Contrary to the findings with axolotls and frogs, functional interaction between brachial motoneurons and hindlimb muscles cannot be sustained in the chick embryo. Dysfunction is first detectable at E10 and progresses to near total immobility by E20 and is associated with joint ankylosis and muscular atrophy. Although brachially innervated hindlimbs were virtually immobile by the time of hatching (E21), they produced strong movements in response to electrical stimulation of their spinal nerves, suggesting a central rather than peripheral defect in the motor system. The extent of motoneuron death in the brachial spinal cord was not significantly altered by the substitution of the forelimb bud with the hindlimb bud, but the timing of motoneuron loss was appropriate for the lumbar rather than brachial spinal cord, indicating that the rate of motoneuron death was dictated by the limb. Measurements of nuclear area indicated that motoneuron size was normal during the motoneuron death period (E6-E10) but the nuclei of motoneurons innervating grafted hindlimbs subsequently became significantly larger than those of normal brachial motoneurons. Although the muscle mass of the grafted hindlimb at E18 was significantly less than that of the normal hindlimb (and similar to that of a normal forelimb), electronmicroscopic examination of the grafted hindlimbs and brachial spinal cords of E20 embryos revealed normal myofiber and neuromuscular junction ultrastructure and a small increase in the number of axosomatic synapses on cross-sections of motoneurons innervating grafted hindlimbs compared to motoneurons innervating normal forelimbs. The anatomical data indicate that, rather than being associated with degenerative changes, the motor system of the brachial hindlimb of late-stage embryos is intact, but inactive. © 1993 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Myogenic defect in muscular dystrophy of the chicken.

Inherited muscular dystrophy of the chicken is thought to arise from abnormal development of trophic regulation of skeletal muscles by their innervating nerves. To determine whether expression of muscular dystrophy in the chicken is a property of the nerves or of the muscles, wing limb buds were transplanted between normal and dystrophic chick embryos at $\text{3}\text{1}\text{2}$ days of incubation (stage 19–20). Muscles of donor limbs innervated by nerves of the hosts were compared to contralateral unoperated host limb muscles in chicks from 6 to 25 weeks after hatching. Expression of normal or dystrophic phenotype was determined by examination of five different properties which are altered in dystrophic chick muscle: electromyographic evidence of myotonia; fiber diameter; acetylcholinesterase activity, localization, and isozymes; lactic dehydrogenase activity; and succinic dehydrogenase activity. Genetically normal muscle innervated by nerves of normal or dystrophic hosts was phenotypically normal while genetically dystrophic muscle innervated by normal nerves was phenotypically dystrophic. The results suggest that inherited muscular dystrophy of the chicken arises from a defect of muscle rather than from a lesion in the nerves themselves.     

Nerve-independent DNA synthesis and mitosis in regenerating hindlimbs of larval Xenopus laevis

Summary Xenopus laevis larvae at stage 52–53 (according to Nieuwkoop and Faber 1956) were subjected to amputation of both limbs at the thigh level as well as to repeated denervations of the right limb. Results obtained in larvae sacrificed during wound healing (1 after amputation), blastema formation (3 days) and blastema growth (5 and 7 days) showed that denervated right limbs have undergone the same histological modifications observed in innervated left limbs and have formed a regeneration blastema consisting of mesenchymal cells with a pattern of DNA synthesis and mitosis very similar to that in presence of nerves. Also, the patterns of cellular density in regenerating right and left limbs were very similar. On the whole, the data here reported show a highly remarkable degree of nerve-independence for regeneration in hindlimbs of larval Xenopus laevis at stage 52–53 and lend some substance to the hypothesis that, in early limbs, there would exist trophic factors capable of replacing those released by nerves, promoting DNA synthesis and mitosis in blastemal cells. Offprint requests to: S. Filoni     

Lens formation from cornea implanted into amputated hindlimbs of Xenopus laevis larvae requires innervation or proliferating cell populations in the stump

The capacity of amputated early and late limbs of larval Xenopus laevis to promote lens-forming transformations of corneal implants in the absence of a limb regeneration blastema has been tested by implanting outer cornea fragments from donor larvae at stage 48 (according to Nieuwkoop and Faber 1956), into limb stumps of larvae at stage 52 and 57. Blastema formation has been prevented either by covering the amputation surface with the skin or by reconnecting the amputated part to the limb stump. Results show that stage 52 non-regenerating limbs could promote lens formation from corneal implants not only when innervated but also when denervated. A similar result was observed in stage 57 limbs where blastema formation was prevented by reconnecting the amputated part to the stump. In this case, relevant tissue dedifferentiation was observed in the boundary region between the stump and the autografted part of the limb. However, stage 57 limbs, where blastema formation was prevented by covering the amputation surface with skin, could promote lens formation from the outer cornea only when innervated. In this case, no relevant dedifferentiation of the stump tissues was observed. These results indicate that blastema formation is not a prerequisite for lens-forming transformations of corneal fragments implanted into amputated hindlimbs of larval X. laevis and that lens formation can be promoted by factors delivered by the nerve fibres or produced by populations of undifferentiated or dedifferentiated limb cells.     

The interaction of nerves of opposite regenerating polarity in fused newt forelimbs

Previous studies involving nerve interactions and limb regenerative processes were carried out on adult newts after their forelimbs were amputated through the distal radius and ulna and fused end-to-end. On the basis of limb regeneration results at the junction of the fused limbs, it was postulated that regenerating nerves from each limb (i.e., nerves of opposite polarity) would not invade the foreign territory of the contralateral limb if it were already normally innervated. A direct study of this nerve interaction, however, was not made in this earlier study. The present investigation was designed to obtain direct histological and electrophysiological evidence for the interaction of nerves of opposite regenerating polarity in fused newt forelimbs. The primary objective was to determine how the regenerating nerves would interact in the establishment of innervation territories-first, at the fusion zone, which represents the junction of the normal innervation territories of the nerves of each limb; and secondly, half way up one of the limbs, where interaction would occur in a territory normally innervated by only one of the regenerating nerves. The results showed that when nerves of opposite regenerating polarity approached one another at the junction of the fused limbs a discontinuation of axonal growth occurred; no indication of overlap of nerves into foreign territory was seen. When the nerves were allowed to interact within one of the fused limbs, however, an overlap of nerve fibers and a functional "double innervation" of that limb was demonstrated. These results are discussed in terms of possible mechanisms for the establishment of innervation territories in salamander limbs. The question of nerve-muscle reinnervation specificity is also raised.     

Regeneration in the tail fan of crayfish

Summary The tail fan of a crayfish consists of the caudal end of the body, the telson, and the most caudal limbs, the uropods. We investigated the positional information in these structures with grafting operations. The uropods are biramous; they bifurcate to a lateral exopodite and a medial endopodite. After the distal part of a uropod ramus was grafted to the stump of a ramus, medio-lateral or dorso-ventral mismatch of surfaces provoked the production of supernumerary distal parts. Proximo-distal intercalation between exopodite and endopodite yielded a mosaic ramus. The results show that the two rami contain equivalent ramus fields in congruent orientation. The exopodite consists of basal and distal segments; each of these segments seems to have an equivalent segmental field.The telson regenerated an ablated distal portion poorly, unlike the limbs of crayfish. After the posterior lobe of the telson was inverted dorso-ventrally and grafted into the telson stump, supernumerary posterior lobes regenerated dorsal and ventral to the graft. Thus the dorsal and ventral surfaces of the telson embody different positional information. A grafted uropod endopodite or exopodite healed to the telson, but dorsoventral inversion of the graft did not provoke the formation of supernumerary structures at the graft-host boundary. Because supernumeraries did not form, the relations between positional information in the telson (a body axis structure) and the uropod (a limb) remain unclear.     

The influence of denervation on grafted hindlimb regeneration of larval Xenopus laevis

The aim of the present research is to ascertain whether in larval Xenopus laevis nerve-independence for the regeneration of early stage limbs and nerve-dependence of late stage limbs observed in a previous work (Filoni and Paglialunga, '90) is related to extrinsic (systemic) factors or to intrinsic changes taking place in the limb cells themselves during development. In this paper the regenerative capacity of early and late stage hindlimbs under the same extrinsic conditions, insofar as both are grafted onto the denervated hindlimbs of host larvae at the same developmental stage, is studied. All the grafted limbs are amputated after the host larvae have reached stage 57-58 (according to Nieuwkoop and Faber, '56). In experiment I, the grafted limb is amputated at stage 52, at the thigh level; in experiment II, the grafted limb is amputated at stage 54-55, at the tarsalia level; in experiment III the grafted limb is amputated at stage 57, at the tarsalia level. In all three experiments, together with the grafted limb, also the host limb is amputated at the tarsalia level. The results show that while grafted limbs amputated at stages 52 and 54-55 regenerate in the absence of nerves, grafted limbs amputated at stage 57 cannot. The failure of late stage grafted limbs to regenerate cannot be explained in terms of an immune-type inhibiting reaction since it has been observed also in denervated autografted limbs and in the host limbs. Since all the grafted limbs are in the same environmental conditions, the results show that in larval Xenopus laevis nerve-independence for regeneration of early stage limbs and nerve-dependence of late stage limbs are not related to factors extrinsic to the limb but to intrinsic changes taking place in the limb cells themselves during development.     

Pattern regulation in the embryonic chick limb: Supernumerary limb formation with anterior (non-ZPA) limb bud tissue

The formation of supernumerary limbs and limb structures was studied by juxtaposing normally nonadjacent embryonic chick limb bud tissue. A “wedge” (ectoderm and mesoderm) of anterior or mid donor right wing bud (stage 21) was inserted in a slit made in a host right limb bud (stage 21) at the same position as its position of origin or to a more posterior position. The AER of the donor tissue and host wing bud were aligned with each other. Donor tissue was grafted with its dorsalventral polarity the same as the host's limb bud or reversed to that of the host's. Depending on the position of origin of the donor limb bud tissue and the position to which it was transplanted in a host, supernumerary wings or wing structures formed. Furthermore, depending on the orientation of the graft in the host, supernumerary limbs with either left or right asymmetry developed. The results of experiments performed here are considered in light of two current models which have been used to describe supernumerary limb formation: one based on local, short-range, cell-cell interactions and the other based on long-range positional signaling via a diffusible morphogen.     

Nerve-independence of limb regeneration in larval Xenopus laevis is related to the presence of mitogenic factors in early limb tissues.

Early limbs of larval Xenopus laevis can form a regeneration blastema in the absence of nerves. The nerve-independence could be due to the synthesis of neurotrophic-like factors by the limb bud cells. To test this hypothesis, two series of experiments were performed. Series A: the right hindlimbs of stage 57 larvae (acc. to Nieuwkoop and Faber. 1956. Normal table of Xenopus laevis [Daudin]. Amsterdam: North-Holland Pub. Co.), which are nerve-dependent for regeneration, were amputated through the tarsalia. The regenerating limbs were submitted to: sham denervation; denervation; denervation and implantation of a fragment of an early limb, or a late limb, or a spinal cord. Series B: froglets were subjected to amputation of both forelimbs. The cone blastemas were transplanted into denervated hindlimbs of stage 57 larvae, together with a fragment of an early or a late limb. The results in series A showed that the implantation of early limb tissue into the denervated blastema maintained cell proliferation at levels similar to those observed after the implantation of a spinal cord fragment or in sham denervated blastemas. However, the implantation of late limb tissues were ineffective. The results of series B showed that the implantation of early limb tissue, but not of late limb tissue prevented the inhibition of cell proliferation and the regression of denervated limb blastemas of juveniles. These results indicate that the nerve-independence is related to the synthesis of diffusible mitogenic neurotrophic-like factors in early limb tissues, and that nerve-dependence is established when differentiated cells of late limb tissues stop producing these factors.     

Types of supernumerary outgrowths produced after inverting the dorsoventral limb axis of the anuranBufo bufo

Summary Contralateral grafts were performed on the larval limb buds of the anuranBufo bufo. The dorsoventral axis of 80 buds at stages IV or V was inverted. Ten tadpoles were used as controls. Fifty-two supernumerary structures developed, all of them in dorsal or ventral locations on the host stump. The majority (32 out of the 44 outgrowths with more than 3 toes) were normal limbs of stump handedness. However, the following abnormal structures were also observed: 2 double-posterior, 3 mixed-symmetric, and 7 undetermined cases. These results are in agreement with the predictions of a hierarchical polar coordinate model for epimorphic regeneration.     

Nerve-dependent and -independent tenascin expression in the developing chick limb bud.

The extracellular matrix protein, tenascin, appears in a restricted pattern during organ morphogenesis. Tenascin accumulates along developing peripheral nerves as they leave the spinal cord and enter the limb mesenchyme (Wehrle and Chiquet, Development 110, 401-415, 1990). Here we found that most but not all tenascin deposited along growing nerves is of glial origin. By in situ hybridization with a tenascin cDNA probe, we determined the site of tenascin mRNA accumulation both in normal and nerve-free limbs. In normal wing buds, tenascin mRNA was first detected within the developing limb nerves. Vinculin-positive glial precursor cells, which comigrate with the axons, are the likely source of this tenascin message. In nerveless wing grafts, tenascin was first expressed in tendon primordia in the absence, and thus independently, from innervation. In contrast to normal limbs, grafted wing buds neither contained vinculin-positive glial precursor cells, nor expressed tenascin in regions proximal to tendon primordia. In normal wing buds, tenascin deposited by tendon primordia transiently parallels and surrounds certain developing nerves. After the major nerve pattern is established, tenascin mRNA disappears from nerves in the upper limb, but is expressed in perichondrium and tendons. We propose that glial tenascin facilitates the penetration of axons into the limb bud and is important for nerve fasciculation. In some places, early tendon primordia might help to guide the migration of axons and glial precursor cells towards their target.     

Neural control of RNA synthesis in regenerating limbs of the adult newtTriturus viridescens

Summary Polyacrylamide gel electrophoresis was used to investigate the role of nerves in controlling patterns of RNA synthesis in regenerating limbs of the adult newt,Triturus viridescens. Denervation has the same effect on nerve-dependent and independent stages of regeneration, reducing by approximately 40–50% the synthesis of ribosomal and transfer RNA. Although a differential qualitative response of messenger RNA synthesis to denervation between nerve-dependent and independent stages has not been ruled out, the results would indicate that the effect of the nerve on RNA metabolism in individual blastema cells is the same over the whole process of regeneration. Since the one constant effect of denervation on regeneration is to inhibit regenerate growth in volume, the emancipation of blastemal morphogenetic activity from nerve requirements is more likely to be a function of attaining a critical mass of blastema cells, rather than a change in the metabolic response of blastema cells to the nerve.Research supported by a Biomedical Sciences Grant from the School of Life Sciences, University of Illinois, to D.L.S.     

Evidence for fusion of myoblasts in amphibian embryos. I. Homoplastic transplantations of somitic material labeled with tritiated thymidine

In order to obtain more direct evidence for the occurrence of myoblast fusion in the developing amphibian embryo, the following transplantations were performed in vitro. The nuclei of early embryos. Ambystoma tigrinum and A. maculatum, were labeled with tritiated thymidine. Portions of prospective somite areas from these labeled donors were grafted homoplastically and orthotopically into unlabeled hosts of the same, or nearly the same, stage. The stages employed were: neurula, early tail bud, and late tail bud. Hosts were raised until they had developed into more advanced larval forms, fixed, sectioned, and prepared for radioautographic processing according to the customary procedures. The histological preparations contained varying numbers of multinucleate myotubes of a “composite” nature: that is, individual myotubes contained labeled nuclei of the donor, side by side with unlabeled nuclei of the host. There was no doubt that the mononucleate myoblasts of the grafts had fused with those of the host species to form the mutlinucleate composite myotubes. In addition to the above determinations, the method of thymidine labeling has proven to be a satisfactory method of tracing, in the context of the intact organism, somitic cell derivatives up to the feeding larval stage. Mesenchymal cells from the grafted labeled somitic tissues were consequently found in: dermatomic, sclerotomic and intermyotomic locations; the matrix of the dorsal fin; the limb bud; the abdominal muscles.     

Position of origin of donor posterior chick wing bud tissue transplanted to an anterior host site determines the extra structures formed

The formation of supernumerary limb structures was studied by juxtaposing normally nonadjacent embryonic chick limb bud tissue. Different “wedges” (ectodern and mesoderm) of posterior donor right wing bud (stage 21) were transplanted to a slit made in stage 20–23 host right wing buds. Donor posterior tissue was transplanted to an anterior position in a host wing bud or, as a control, to the same position as its position of origin. Transplanting different wedges of posterior tissue to the same anterior host position results in wings with supernumerary structures, and different extra structures form depending on the position of origin of the donor tissue. The identification of extra limb structures formed was based on the skeletal and integumentary patterns of resulting wings and the pattern of muscles as seen in serial sections of resulting limbs. The results of experiments presented here are considered in light of current models that have been used to describe the formation of supernumerary limb structures by the embryonic chick limb bud.