Negative allogeneic effects in vitro. II. Mapping of histocompatibility differences leading to allosuppression.

When splenic T cells from normal mice recognize alloantigens on primed spleen cells there is a dramatic suppression of the secondary antihapten PFC response of the latter cells. From studies using intra-MHC recombinants it appears that differences at K or D alone can elicit allosuppression. There is sometimes suppression to differences in the I region. Even small differences in H-2K, as seen in the H-2b mutants, are sufficient to lead to such negative allogeneic effects. Thus, as far as has been determined, the specificity of allosuppresive T cells is indistinguishable from that of cytotoxic effector cells. Negative allogeneic effects and positive allogeneic effects different in the degree to which they influenced the primary and secondary responses. In our experiments no evidence for positive allogeneic effects was seen in the secondary response to TNP-carrier even with cells differing at the I region only. In contrast the primary response to SRBC was much enhanced by allogeneic cells and little suppression of that response was seen. It is suggested that the allosuppression is distinct from cytotoxicity and may be a profitable model for the study of suppressor T cells.     

Mechanism of allosuppression: evidence for direct suppression of responding B cells.

The mechanism of allosuppression has been investigated. As previously described, negative allogeneic effects result when T cells recognize MHC-encoded alloantigens on responding lymphocytes, preventing the generation of a secondary anti-PFC response in vitro. Several experiments suggested that this suppression was not due to the generation of cytotoxic effectors. First, effective suppression occurred only when T cells, either unprimed or alloantigen activated, were added during the first 24 hr of the responding culture. Even previously generated cytotoxic effectors were relatively ineffective when added late in the response. Furthermore, no detectable cytotoxic effectors were found in suppressed cultures. The major target of suppression was the responding B cell. Only B cells carrying alloantigens (thus recognized by the T cells) were suppressed; bystander B cells were little affected. Thus allosuppression appears to involve the recognition by T cells of alloantigens on responding B cells and direct suppression of some early event in the development of these B cells into PFC. The responses of primed B cells were found to be preferentially sensitive to the suppressive effects of allo- T cells, whereas the response of unprimed B cells was influenced preferentially by the helper effects of alloantigen-activated T cells. It is possible that the state of differentiation of the B cell may determine the outcome of the interaction with regulatory T cells.     

Functional characteristics of BALB/c T cell lines: suppression in the mixed lymphocyte response and cell-mediated lysis.

Previously, 10 BALB/c T cell lines (Thy 1.2+, Ig-) were shown to express different combinations of Ly 1 and Ly 2 antigens. The possible immunologic function(s) of these tumor cells was determined by investigating the effects of these cells on the responses to mitogens, the mixed lymphocyte response (MLR), and the generation of cell-mediated lysis (CML) by normal spleen cells. Five T cell lines, P1798 and BALENTL 3, 5, 8, and 9, continued to synthesize DNA after exposure to large doses of irradiation. Only BALENTL 4, 6, 7, and 14 (Ly 1-(2+)) and BALENTL 13 (Ly 1+(2-)) were radiosensitive and therefore amenable to study. BALENTL 4 and 14 gave significant suppression of the MLR between BALB/c and C57BL/6; BALENTL 14 also inhibited the generation of BALB/c effector cells against C57BL/6 spleen cells. None of these T cell lines had any effect on the proliferative response of BALB/c spleen cells induced by concanavalin A. However, there was approximately 50% suppression of the phytohemagglutinin response of BALB/c spleen cells by BALENTL 14.     

The allogeneic effect: the mechanism of allosuppression by Lyt-1, Ia- T cells

The kinetics of allohelp mediated by diffusable factors revealed that help by nonirradiated T cells (TOR) peaked at 48 to 72 hr, followed by a sharp decline if the T cells remained in the cultures. The temporal decrease in help after 72 hr was not mediated by suppressor lymphokines because mixtures of early (24 to 48 hr) and late (120-hr) allogeneic supernatants enhanced help synergistically. Lyt-1, Ia- T cells mediated the temporal decline in help and suppressed allogeneic B cell activation in co-cultures, and this "down-regulatory" activity (allosuppression) was radiosensitive. Help by irradiated T cells (T1000R) increased gradually until it plateaued between 96 and 120 hr. The helper activities of the allogeneic supernatants were directly proportional to their T cell growth factor (TCGF) activities. In addition, their kinetics were identical, and the removal of TCGF from 48-hr allogeneic supernatants by adsorption with TCGF-dependent HT-2 cells depleted both helper and TCGF activities. Help was restored to depleted 48-hr and 120-hr allogeneic supernatants by preparations of TCGF obtained from concanavalin A (Con A)-stimulated FS6-14.13 hybridoma cells that were adsorbed with lipopolysaccharide (LPS)-activated B cells or normal spleen cells (NS), but not with HT-2 cells. These results indicate that allohelp is dependent on TCGF. Moreover, help was dependent on at least one factor in addition to TCGF, because a high level of synergy occurred between TCGF and the "help-deficient" 120-hr allogeneic supernatant. In conclusion, the mechanism whereby Lyt-1, Ia- T cells regulated B cell activation with positive and negative allogeneic effects was through the production and subsequent exhaustion of TCGF, respectively. The production of TCGF and help was radioresistant, but exhaustion of TCGF and suppression was radiosensitive.     

Subpopulations of CD8+ cytotoxic T cell precursors collaborate in the absence of conventional CD4+ helper T cells.

Four different subpopulations (Ly6Cneg, Ly6Clow, Ly6Cint, and Ly6Chi) of CD8+ T cells were arbitrarily defined on the basis of differential expression of Ly6C Ag. By combining the processes of electronic cell sorting and automated cell deposition, small numbers of respective CD8+ T cell subpopulations were directly deposited into tissue culture wells in which mitogen-stimulated responses were studied. Anti-CD3-stimulated proliferation and IL-2 production were the strongest by Ly6Cneg/Ly6Clow T cells, moderate for Ly6Cint T cells, and highly deficient for Ly6Chi T cells. The level of IL-2 production for Ly6Cneg CD8+ T cells was comparable to that of conventional CD4+ Th cells. Allogeneic stimulator cells elicited a strong cytotoxic response by Ly6Cneg + low but not Ly6Chi CD8+ T cells in the absence of added lymphokines. When IL-2 was supplied in excess, anti-CD3 induced comparable levels of cell proliferation and cytotoxic activity in Ly6Cneg, Ly6Clow, Ly6Cint, and Ly6Chi CD8+ T cells whereas alloantigen stimulated an approximate fivefold higher cytotoxic response by Ly6Chi than Ly6Cneg + low CD8+ T cells. Stimulation of co-cultures of B10 (CD8b) Ly6Cneg + low and congenic B10.CD8a Ly6Chi CD8+ T cells in the absence of added lymphokines, followed by selective elimination of activated CD8.1+ (CD8.2+) T cells by anti-CD8.1 (anti-CD8.2) + C treatment, allowed the demonstration that help provided by Ly6Cneg + low T cells can be effectively used by both Ly6Cneg + low and Ly6Chi T cells in anti-CD3 and alloantigen induced proliferative and cytotoxic responses, respectively.     

B6 strain Ly49I inhibitory gene expression on T cells in FVB.Ly49IB6 transgenic mice fails to prevent normal T cell functions

Inhibitory Ly49 receptors expressed on NK cells provide a mechanism for tolerance to normal self tissues. The immunoregulatory tyrosine-based inhibitory motifs present in some Ly49s are able to transmit an inhibitory signal upon ligation by MHC class I ligands. In our system, as well as others, mice transgenic for inhibitory Ly49 receptors express these receptors on both NK and T cells. FVB (H2(q)) mice transgenic for the B6 strain Ly49I (Ly49I(B6)) express the inhibitory Ly49 receptor on the surface of both T and NK cells. Although Ly49I functions to prevent NK-mediated rejection of H2(b) donor bone marrow cells in this transgenic mouse strain, the T cells do not appear to be affected by the expression of the Ly49I transgene. FVB.Ly49I T cells have normal proliferative capabilities both in vitro and in vivo in response to the Ly49I ligand, H2(b). In vivo functional T cell assays were also done, showing that transgenic T cells were not functionally affected. T cells in these mice also appear to undergo normal T cell development and activation. Only upon stimulation with suboptimal doses of anti-CD3 in the presence of anti-Ly49I is T cell proliferation inhibited. These data are in contrast with findings in Ly49A, and Ly49G2 receptor transgenic models. Perhaps Ly49I-H2(b) interactions are weaker or of lower avidity than Ly49A-H-2D(d) interactions, especially in T cells.     

Analysis of the negative allogeneic effect using B cells and helper T cell lines as an indicator system: B cells identified as target cells for suppression

The target cells for H-2b T lymphocytes mediating a negative allogeneic effect in vitro were analyzed by using carrier-specific helper T cell lines of H-2b, H-2d, or F1 origin and hapten-primed T-depleted spleen cells also expressing one or both of these haplotypes. The helper T cell lines were shown to be carrier specific and H-2b or H-2d restricted. Most importantly, the lines derived from H-2b homozygous mice were devoid of alloreactivity against H-2d and vice versa. Titration of naive H-2b T lymphocytes to the indicator cultures resulted in suppression of the secondary anti-DNP response of the indicator cells whenever the B cells expressed H-2d antigens. The lack of suppression observed in mixtures in which only the helper T cell lines expressed H-2d antigens was not reversed by the increased addition of naive H-2bxd cells, indicating that an insufficient amount of H-2d antigens present on the low number of helper T cells used did not account for this finding. Moreover, the polyclonal plaque-forming cell responses of F1 spleen cells to LPS were also suppressed by naive parental T cells. From these findings it is concluded that the suppressor T cells directly recognize and inhibit allogeneic B cells without the involvement of helper T cells. In addition, it was shown that the suppression of secondary anti-hapten responses by naive allogeneic T cells is blocked by monoclonal anti-Lyt-2 antibody added at the onset of culture. Addition late in culture had no effect, pointing to a functional role of the Lyt-2-bearing structure at an early stage of the suppressive events resulting in the negative allogeneic effect.     

Hierarchy of cytotoxic T cell clones. II. Intraclonal triggering of lysis by hapten-specific CTL

Cells from clones of anti-hapten murine cytotoxic T lymphocytes (CTL) can act as both target and effector cells, but will not lyse members of the same clone. The effect of haptenation on the cytolytic activity of anti-fluorescein (FL) and anti-trinitrophenol (TNP) CTL clones was examined. Treatment of anti-FL clones with fluorescein isothiocyanate or anti-TNP clones with trinitrobenzene sulphonic acid induces these clones to kill in an antigen-independent fashion. Targets killed by the haptenated CTL included syngeneic and allogeneic B lymphocyte blast cells, P815, YAC-1 and in one case human GM 4072 tumor cells. The importance of CD8 and T cell receptor (TCR) occupancy is demonstrated by the ability to block autotriggering by antibody directed against Ly 2 and the TCR. The results demonstrate that effects other than antigen recognition of the target play a role in the final outcome of effector-target cell interactions and provide a mechanism which could lead to autodestruction and immunosuppression particularly in some types of viral infection.     

The virus-specific and allospecific cytotoxic T-lymphocyte response to lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus is modified in a subpopulation of CD8(+) T cells coexpressing the inhibitory major histocompatibility complex class I receptor Ly49G2

The role of negatively signaling NK cell receptors of the Ly49 family on the specificity of the acute CD8(+) cytotoxic T-lymphocyte (CTL) response was investigated in lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus (LCMV)-infected C57BL/6 mice. Activated CD8(+) T cells coexpressing Ly49G2 expanded during LCMV infection, and T-cell receptor analyses by flow cytometry and CDR3 spectratyping revealed a unique polyclonal T-cell population in the Ly49G2(+) fraction. These cells lysed syngeneic targets infected with LCMV or coated with two of three LCMV immunodominant peptides examined. Transfection of these sensitive targets with H2D(d), a ligand for Ly49G2, inhibited lysis. This was reversed by antibody to Ly49G2, indicating effective negative signaling. LCMV characteristically induces an anti-H2(d) allospecific T-cell response that includes T-cell clones cross-reactive between allogeneic and LCMV-infected syngeneic targets. The CD8(+) Ly49G2(+) population mediated no allospecific killing, nor was any NK-like killing observed against YAC-1 cells. This study shows that CD8(+) Ly49G2(+) cells participate in the virus-induced CTL response but lyse a more restricted range of targets than the rest of the virus-induced CTL population.     

Presence of T cell-associated surface antigens on murine NK cells.

The expression of T cell-associated surface antigens on natural killer (NK) spleen cells of C57BL/6 mice was evaluated by cytotoxic depletion experiments with alloantisera prepared against the Thy 1, Ly 1, Ly 2, Ly 5, Ly 6, and NK 1 antigens. The NK activity of these nonimmunized spleen cells for YAC-1 leukemia cells was dramatically reduced by antisera to the Ly 5 and NK 1 antigens. Variable results were obtained with anti-Ly 6 sera--certain pools of this antiserum decreased the NK activity, whereas other pools showed only negligible effects. The NK activity of the same cell suspensions was not affected by antisera to the Thy 1, Ly 1, and Ly 2 antigens. In parallel tests the T cell-associated cell surface antigens of alloimmune T killer cells were similarly evaluated by cytotoxic depletion experiments. In this case, the activity of these cells was consistently diminished by antisera to the Thy 1, Ly 2, Ly 5, and Ly 6 antigens, but not by antisera to the Ly 1 and NK 1 antigens. On this basis it was concluded that the NK cells expressed a restricted subset of T cell-associated alloantigens and therefore may have been derived from the T cell lineage of lymphocytes.     

Alloantigen-induced T helper activity. I. Minimal genetic differences necessary to induce a positive allogeneic effect.

Addition of histoincompatible lymphocytes can influence the course of ongoing immune responses. Such allogeneic effects may either augment or diminish immune responses. We describe here the minimal genetic differences necessary to generate positive allogeneic effects (allohelp) in a humoral immune response. The antibody response to sheep erythrocytes of T cell-depleted mouse spleen cells was reconstituted by addition of syngeneic or allogeneic nylon wool column-passaged spleen T cells. T cells were pretreated with mitomycin C before culture to prevent development of allo-suppression and cytotoxic lymphocytes. Positive allogeneic effects were operationally defined as superior helper effects (to generate greater antibody forming cell responses) with T cells allogeneic rather than syngeneic to the responding B cells. Thus, addition of allogeneic T cells resulted in many more antibody forming cells than did equal numbers of syngeneic T cells, and fewer allogeneic than syngeneic T cells were necessary to generate comparable responses. With congenic, recombinant, and mutant mouse lines, genetic differences in the H-2 complex and those associated with Mls were each sufficient to provide positive allogeneic effects. With intra-H-2 recombinants, differences at either I or D were sufficient. A disparity at H-2K alone, as provided by the H-2 mutant B6.C-H-2ba against the parental line C57BL/6By, also induced helper effects. The significance of these results is discussed.     

The allogeneic effect: M-locus differences substitute for differences in the H-2 major histocompatibility complex.

The primary immune response against sheep red blood cells in T cell-deficient spleen cell cultures from nude mice was tested in the absence and presence of allogeneic spleen cells. The allogeneic spleen cells differed either in regard to the major histocompatibility complex (H-2) or only with respect to the M-locus. Surprisingly the M-locus different spleen cells were almost as efficient in enhancing the anti-sheep red blood cell response in nude cultures as were the cells differing on the complete H-2 complex. Evidence is presented that AKR anti-theta serum sensitive T cells are responsible for the M-locus-dependent effect edscribed. This effect is shown to be mediated by a factor released from actived T cells stimulated in M-locus different mixed lymphocyte cultures. Since almost identical parameters have been observed in both the M-locus-dependent situation as in the "classical" allogeneic situation we concluded that an allogeneic effect can be induced by T cells responding to a complete set of the major histocompatibility complex (H-2) as well as to lymphocyte-activating determinants (M-locus) alone.     

Transgenic expression of Ly49A on T cells impairs a specific antitumor response

Inhibitory MHC receptors determine the reactivity and specificity of NK cells. These receptors can also regulate T cells by modulating TCR-induced effector functions such as cytotoxicity, cytokine production, and proliferation. Here we have assessed the capacity of mouse T cells expressing the inhibitory MHC class I receptor Ly49A to respond to a well-defined tumor Ag in vivo using Ly49A transgenic mice. We find that the presence of Ly49A on the vast majority of lymphocytes prevents the development of a significant Ag-specific CD8+ T cell response and, consequently, the rejection of the tumor. Despite minor alterations in the TCR repertoire of CD8+ T cells in the transgenic lines, precursors of functional tumor-specific CD8+ T cells exist but could not be activated most likely due to a lack of appropriate CD4+ T cell help. Surprisingly, all of these effects are observed in the absence of a known ligand for the Ly49A receptor as defined by its ability to regulate NK cell function. Indeed, we found that the above effects on T cells may be based on a weak interaction of Ly49A with Kb or Db class I molecules. Thus, our data demonstrate that enforced expression of a Ly49A receptor on conventional T cells prevents a specific immune response in vivo and suggest that the functions of T and NK cells are differentially sensitive to the presence of inhibitory MHC class I receptors.     

Comparing the kinetics of NK cells, CD4, and CD8 T cells in murine cytomegalovirus infection

NK cells recognize virus-infected cells with germline-encoded activating and inhibitory receptors that do not undergo genetic recombination or mutation. Accordingly, NK cells are often considered part of the innate immune response. The innate response comprises rapid early defenders that do not form immune memory. However, there is increasing evidence that experienced NK cells provide increased protection to secondary infection, a hallmark of the adaptive response. In this study, we compare the dynamics of the innate and adaptive immune responses by examining the kinetic profiles of the NK and T cell response to murine CMV infection. We find that, unexpectedly, the kinetics of NK cell proliferation is neither earlier nor faster than the CD4 or CD8 T cell response. Furthermore, early NK cell contraction after the peak of the response is slower than that of T cells. Finally, unlike T cells, experienced NK cells do not experience biphasic decay after the response peak, a trait associated with memory formation. Rather, NK cell contraction is continuous, constant, and returns to below endogenous preinfection levels. This indicates that the reason why Ag-experienced NK cells remain detectable for a prolonged period after adoptive transfer and infection is in part due to the high precursor frequency, slow decay rate, and low background levels of Ly49H(+) NK cells in recipient DAP12-deficient mice. Thus, the quantitative contribution of Ag-experienced NK cells in an endogenous secondary response, with higher background levels of Ly49H(+) NK cells, may be not be as robust as the secondary response observed in T cells.     

Stimulator requirements for primed alloreactive T cells: macrophages and dendritic cells activate T cells across all genetic disparities

The cellular requirements for stimulating primed alloreactive T cells have been investigated. In vitro-primed secondary alloreactive cells, long-term lines, and Ly 1+2- noncytolytic clones which reacted with allo-H-2K, D, or Mls (M locus) antigens were tested. The data indicated that a specialized antigen-presenting cell such as a macrophage or a dendritic cell was required for stimulating primed alloreactive cells across all the genetic disparities tested. B and T lymphocytes were ineffective stimulators. The stimulator requirement for secondary and Ly 1+2- clone responses was heterogeneous, since both macrophages and dendritic cells were effective stimulators. Thus, the allostimulator requirement for inducing proliferation and mediator secretion by the primed T-cell populations closely paralleled the requirement for stimulating unprimed populations. The only exception found was the peritoneal washout population, which did not stimulate a primary response but did stimulate secondary responses. The failure of peritoneal macrophages to stimulate a primary response was shown to be due to an inhibitory pathway which did not occur when the responding population was alloantigen primed.     

Impaired anti-viral T cell responses due to expression of the Ly49A inhibitory receptor.

Inhibitory receptors specific for alleles of MHC class I proteins play an important role in determining the reactivity and specificity of NK cells. To determine whether these receptors are also able to regulate T cell functions, we have studied anti-viral immune responses in mice transgenic for a class I-specific inhibitory receptor, Ly49A. Although nontransgenic mice express Ly49A primarily on NK cells and some T cells, the Ly49A transgenic mice express Ly49A on all lymphocytes, including T cells. We have assessed the activation, expansion, cytokine production, and cytotoxic activity of CD8 T cells in both transgenic and nontransgenic mice following infection with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus. As expected, nontransgenic mice made a potent virus-specific CD8 T cell response following virus infection. However, as measured in cytolysis assays and by cytokine production, virus-specific CD8 T cell activity was reduced in Ly49A transgenic mice. This inhibition was largely, but not always exclusively, dependent upon the presence, either in vivo or in vitro, of the Ly49A ligand, H-2Dd. Strikingly Ly49A transgenic mice have reduced capacity to control infection with the virulent lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus variant clone 13. Overall, these studies demonstrate that expression of killer inhibitory receptors can modulate anti-viral T cell responses in vivo and in vitro.     

Helper cells activated by allogeneic H-2K or H-2D differences have a Ly phenotype distinct from those responsive to I differences.

Helper activity for the primary in vitro response to sheep erythrocytes was induced by recognition of foreign major histocompatibility antigens. The Lyt phenotypes of helper activity induced by differences in the whole haplotype, K or D antigens, I region antigen, or by differences at the M1s locus were determined. All allohelper cells expressed Ly1. In a single spleen cell suspension helper activity generated in response to the whole haplotype, I region, or M1s antigens was derived from an Ly2-negative population, whereas helper activity generated to K or D alone was derived from a population of Ly2-positive cells. Mixtures of anti-Ly1 and anti-Ly2 treated populations were unable to generate helper activity in response to K or D differences. Such helper activity was therefore dependent on the presence of Ly12 cells. It was concluded that the Ly phenotype of the helper cells is not determined solely by the T cell function but is influenced by the region of the major histocompatibility complex that is recognized. Possible interpretations of these findings are discussed.     

Maintenance of hyporesponsiveness to antigen by a distinct subclass of T lymphocytes.

Immunization with increasing doses of SRBC, in excess of 10(8), results in a progressive decline in the anti-SRBC PFC response. This hyporesponsive state is antigen specific and is reflected in a decrease of both T helper and B antibody-forming activity. We asked whether the apparent defect of T helper activity reflected a) an absence of alphaSRBC helper T cell activity, or b) the presence of SRBC-specific suppressor T cells within the hyporesponsive population. Our results indicate that at least a portion of hyporesponsiveness noted after antigen exposure to large doses of antigen can be ascribed to specific suppressor T cell activation. Fractionation of the suppressive T cell population using Ly antiserum showed that specific suppressive activity was mediated by a subclass of T cells (Ly2+), distinct from that committed to express helper function (Ly1).     

The origins of alloreactivity: differentiation of prekiller cells to viral infection results in alloreactive cytolytic T lymphocytes

Mice maintained in our animal colony become primed to Sendai virus. This "environmental" priming is reflected in a shift in prekiller activity from the Ly 123 to Ly 23 T cell set and in increased virus-specific cytolytic activity. This transition is accompanied by the development of cytolytic activity against allogeneic targets (not expressing Sendai antigens). These findings are consistent with the view that continued stimulation of Ly 123 cells by autologous MHC antigens, associated with foreign antigens such as a virus, generate Ly 23 prekiller cells that respond to alloantigens as well as autologous cells infected with the relevant virus.     

Macromolecular insoluble cold globulin (MICG): a novel protein from mouse lymphocytes. III. Relationship to the mixed lymphocyte reaction and effect of anti-MICG antiserum in vivo.

In the present communication we have examined the relationship between the synthesis of macromolecular insoluble cold globulin (MICG) and the mixed lymphocyte reaction (MLR). In addition, we have studied in vivo the effect of antiserum to MICG on the antibody response to sheep red blood cells. The experiments indicate that MICG synthesis compared to either IgM or total protein is selectively stimulated in responder T cells exposed to allogeneic stimulator cells in the MLR. Furthermore, cytotoxicity studies utilizing anti-MICG antiserum demonstrated that T cells bearing MICG on their surface are an essential component of the responder cell population in the MLR. In vivo administration of antiserum to MICG significantly suppressed both the primary and secondary antibody response to sheep red blood cells. A possible mechanism for this suppression is discussed.