Biogeochemistry of the stable isotopes of hydrogen and carbon in salt marsh biota

Deuterium to hydrogen ratios of 14 plant species from a salt marsh and lagoon were 55‰ depleted in deuterium relative to the environmental water. Carbon tetrachloride-extractable material from these plants was another 92‰ depleted in deuterium. This gave a fractionation factor from water to CCl₄ extract of 1.147. This over-all fractionation was remarkably constant for all species analyzed. Plants also discriminate against ¹³C, particularly in the lipid fraction. Data suggest that different mechanisms for carbon fixation result in different fractionations of the carbon isotopes. Herbivore tissues reflected the isotopic ratios of plants ingested. Apparently different metabolic processes are responsible for the different degrees of fractionation observed for hydrogen and carbon isotopes.     

Major Evolutionary Trends in Hydrogen Isotope Fractionation of Vascular Plant Leaf Waxes

Hydrogen isotopic ratios of terrestrial plant leaf waxes (δD) have been widely used for paleoclimate reconstructions. However, underlying controls for the observed large variations in leaf wax δD values in different terrestrial vascular plants are still poorly understood, hampering quantitative paleoclimate interpretation. Here we report plant leaf wax and source water δD values from 102 plant species grown in a common environment (New York Botanic Garden), chosen to represent all the major lineages of terrestrial vascular plants and multiple origins of common plant growth forms. We found that leaf wax hydrogen isotope fractionation relative to plant source water is best explained by membership in particular lineages, rather than by growth forms as previously suggested. Monocots, and in particular one clade of grasses, display consistently greater hydrogen isotopic fractionation than all other vascular plants, whereas lycopods, representing the earlier-diverging vascular plant lineage, display the smallest fractionation. Data from greenhouse experiments and field samples suggest that the changing leaf wax hydrogen isotopic fractionation in different terrestrial vascular plants may be related to different strategies in allocating photosynthetic substrates for metabolic and biosynthetic functions, and potential leaf water isotopic differences.     

Hydrogen isotopic compositions of n-alkanes from terrestrial plants correlate with their ecological life forms

Stable hydrogen isotopic compositions (δD) of compound-specific biomarkers, such as n-alkanes from plant leaf waxes, can be used as a proxy for paleoclimatic change. However, the relationship between hydrogen isotopes of plant leaf wax and plant ecological life forms is not well understood. Here, we report the δD of n-alkanes from 34 modern terrestrial plants, including twenty-one C₃ plants and thirteen C₄ plants from northwestern China, determined using gas chromatography/thermal conversion/isotope ratio mass spectrometry. Our data show that the stable hydrogen isotopes are poorly correlated with the plant photosynthetic pathway (C₃ vs. C₄) and that they do not give clear regional precipitation signals. Together with a comparative analysis of published δD values from plant leaf waxes in other regions, we believe that the stable hydrogen isotope of plant leaf waxes is more closely related to ecological life forms of these terrestrial plants (i.e. tree, shrub, and grass). In general, the grasses have more negative δD values than the co-occurring trees and shrubs. Our findings suggest that the δD values of sedimentary leaf waxes from higher plants may record changes of a plant ecosystem under the influence of environmental alteration and imply that reconstruction of the paleoclimate using δD values from plant n-alkanes should be based upon specific plant taxa, and comparison should be made among plants with similar ecological life forms.     

Zinc isotopic fractionation in Phragmites australis in response to toxic levels of zinc

Stable isotope signatures of Zn have shown great promise in elucidating changes in uptake and translocation mechanisms of this metal in plants during environmental changes. Here this potential was tested by investigating the effect of high Zn concentrations on the isotopic fractionation patterns of Phragmites australis (Cav.) Trin. ex Steud. Plants were grown for 40?d in a nutritive solution containing 3.2?μM (sufficient) or 2?mM (toxic) Zn. The Zn isotopic composition of roots, rhizomes, shoots, and leaves was analysed. Stems and leaves were sampled at different heights to evaluate the effect of long-distance transport on Zn fractionation. During Zn sufficiency, roots, rhizomes, and shoots were isotopically heavy (δ(66)Zn(JMC Lyon)=0.2‰) while the youngest leaves were isotopically light (-0.5‰). During Zn excess, roots were still isotopically heavier (δ(66)Zn=0.5‰) and the rest of the plant was isotopically light (up to -0.5‰). The enrichment of heavy isotopes at the roots was attributed to Zn uptake mediated by transporter proteins under Zn-sufficient conditions and to chelation and compartmentation in Zn excess. The isotopically lighter Zn in shoots and leaves is consistent with long-distance root to shoot transport. The tolerance response of P. australis increased the range of Zn fractionation within the plant and with respect to the environment.     

Oxygen isotope ratios between soil water and stem water of trees in pot experiments

Since the oxygen isotopic ratio of water extracted from stems reflects that of water taken up by roots, the stem water isotope ratio can be used to analyze the source of water for plant growth. However, it is known that the fractionation of isotopes during evaporation from the surface soil increases the isotope ratio in soil water drastically. In this study, it was experimentally confirmed that the stem water of Elaeocarpus sylvestris vs. ellipticus Hara seedlings is not isotopically similar to the water source in the case where evaporation from the soil occurs actively. However, since water in these plant bodies was replaced in about 2 days in the pot experiments, the 2-day-averaged values of the soil water isotope ratio approached the stem water isotope ratio. Thus, time-course samplings of the soil and stems, and measurements of the replacement time of water in the plant body (water volume in plant/transpiration rate) are recommended for correct interpretation of the isotopic signature of soil water and stem water.     

Oxygen and Hydrogen Isotope Ratios of Water from Photosynthetic Tissues of CAM and C(3) Plants

Water samples from photosynthetic tissues of C₃ and Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) plants that grew together in the field were extracted and the stable oxygen and hydrogen isotope ratios determined. During the day, ¹⁸O/¹⁶O and deuterium/hydrogen (D/H) ratios of water from CAM plants were lower than those observed in water from C₃ plants. The patterns of diurnal variation (or lack thereof) in isotope ratios of plant water are consistent with the gross anatomical and physiological characteristics of the plants studied here. Our observations support the previously advanced hypothesis that high D/H ratios in cellulose nitrate prepared from CAM plants relative to those for C₃ plants are not caused by greater deuterium enrichment in the water in CAM plants, but rather by isotopic fractionations associated with different biochemical reactions in the two types of plants.     

Isotope ratios of cellulose from plants having different photosynthetic pathways

Hydrogen and carbon isotope ratios of cellulose nitrate and oxygen isotope ratios of cellulose from C₃, C₄, and Crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) plants were determined for plants growing within a small area in Val Verde County, Texas. Plants having CAM had distinctly higher deuterium/hydrogen (D/H) ratios than plants having C₃ and C₄ metabolism. When hydrogen isotope ratios are plotted against carbon isotope ratios, each photosynthetic mode separates into a distinct cluster of points. C₄ plants had many D/H ratios similar to those of C₃ plants, so that hydrogen isotope ratios cannot be used to distinguish between these two photosynthetic modes. Portulaca mundula, which may have a modified photosynthetic mode between C₄ and CAM, had a hydrogen isotope ratio between those of the C₄ and CAM plants. When oxygen isotope ratios are plotted against carbon isotope ratios, no distinct clustering of the C₄ and CAM plants occurs. Thus, oxygen isotope ratios are not useful in distinguishing between these metabolic modes. A plot of hydrogen isotope ratios versus oxygen isotope ratios for this sample set shows considerable overlap between oxygen isotope ratios of the different photosynthetic modes without a concomitant overlap in the hydrogen isotope ratios of CAM and the other two photosynthetic modes. This observation is consistent with the hypothesis that higher D/H ratios in CAM plants relative to C₃ and C₄ plants are due to isotopic fractionations occurring during biochemical reactions.     

Effects of Relative Humidity on Carbon Isotope Fractionation in Plants

Four C₃ plants and a C₄ plant were grown from seeds at four levels (30, 45, 60, and 75 %) of relative humidity. All plants were subjected to a 16 h day, at 500 μE/m².s^?1 photon flux density. Mature leaves were analyzed for their carbon isotopic composition. Isotope fractionation decreased by up to 3 ‰ with decreasing relative humidity in all C₃ plants, while the opposite trend was observed in the C₄ plant. The observed shifts in both C₃ and C₄ plants are attributed to decreased stomatal conductance at low relative humidity, resulting in a smaller P_i.     

The influence of leaf‐atmosphere NH3(g) exchange on the isotopic composition of nitrogen in plants and the atmosphere

The distribution of nitrogen isotopes in the biosphere has the potential to offer insights into the past, present and future of the nitrogen cycle, but it is challenging to unravel the processes controlling patterns of mixing and fractionation. We present a mathematical model describing a previously overlooked process: nitrogen isotope fractionation during leaf‐atmosphere NH_3(g) exchange. The model predicts that when leaf‐atmosphere exchange of NH_3(g) occurs in a closed system, the atmospheric reservoir of NH_3(g) equilibrates at a concentration equal to the ammonia compensation point and an isotopic composition 8.1‰ lighter than nitrogen in protein. In an open system, when atmospheric concentrations of NH_3(g) fall below or rise above the compensation point, protein can be isotopically enriched by net efflux of NH_3(g) or depleted by net uptake. Comparison of model output with existing measurements in the literature suggests that this process contributes to variation in the isotopic composition of nitrogen in plants as well as NH_3(g) in the atmosphere, and should be considered in future analyses of nitrogen isotope circulation. The matrix‐based modelling approach that is introduced may be useful for quantifying isotope dynamics in other complex systems that can be described by first‐order kinetics.     

Calcium isotope fractionation in alpine plants

In order to develop Ca isotopes as a tracer for biogeochemical Ca cycling in terrestrial environments and for Ca utilisation in plants, stable calcium isotope ratios were measured in various species of alpine plants, including woody species, grasses and herbs. Analysis of plant parts (root, stem, leaf and flower samples) provided information on Ca isotope fractionation within plants and seasonal sampling of leaves revealed temporal variation in leaf Ca isotopic composition. There was significant Ca isotope fractionation between soil and root tissue $\Updelta^{44/42}\hbox{Ca}_{\rm root-soil} \approx -0.40\,\permille$ in all investigated species, whereas Ca isotope fractionation between roots and leaves was species dependent. Samples of leaf tissue collected throughout the growing season also highlighted species differences: Ca isotope ratios increased with leaf age in woody species but remained constant in herbs and grasses. The Ca isotope fractionation between roots and soils can be explained by a preferential binding of light Ca isotopes to root adsorption sites. The observed differences in whole plant Ca isotopic compositions both within and between species may be attributed to several potential factors including root cation exchange capacity, the presence of a woody stem, the presence of Ca oxalate, and the levels of mycorrhizal infection. Thus, the impact of plants on the Ca biogeochemical cycle in soils, and ultimately the Ca isotope signature of the weathering flux from terrestrial environments, will depend on the species present and the stage of vegetation succession.     

Silicon Isotopic Fractionation by Banana (Musa spp.) Grown in a Continuous Nutrient Flow Device

The determination of the plant-induced Si-isotopic fractionation is a promising tool to better quantify their role in the continental Si cycle. Si-isotopic signatures of the different banana plant parts and Si source were measured, providing the isotopic fractionation factor between plant and source. Banana plantlets (Musa acuminata Colla, cv Grande Naine) were grown in hydroponics at variable Si supplies (0.08, 0.42, 0.83 and 1.66 mM Si). Si-isotopic compositions were determined on a multicollector plasma source mass spectrometer (MC-ICP-MS) operating in dry plasma mode. Results are expressed as δ²⁹Si relative to the NBS28 standard, with an average precision of ± 0.08‰ (±2σ_D). The fractionation factor ²⁹ε between bulk banana plantlets and source solution is −0.40 ± 0.11‰. This confirms that plants fractionate Si isotopes by depleting the source solution in ²⁸Si. The intra-plant fractionation Δ²⁹Si between roots and shoots amounts to −0.21 ± 0.08‰. Si-isotopic compositions of the various plant parts indicate that heavy isotopes discrimination occurs at three levels in the plant (at the root epidermis, for xylem loading and for xylem unloading). At each step, preferential crossing of light isotopes leaves a heavier solution, and produces a lighter solution. Si-isotopic fractionation processes are further discussed in relation with Si uptake and transport in plants. These findings have important implications on the study of continental Si cycle.     

Tracing origins and migration of wildlife using stable isotopes: a review

To understand the ecology of migratory animals it is important to link geographic regions used by individuals including breeding, wintering, and intermediate stopover sites. Previous conventional approaches used to track animal movements have relied on extrinsic markers and typically the subsequent recovery of individuals. This approach has generally been inappropriate for most small, or non-game animals. The use of intrinsic markers such as fatty acid profiles, molecular DNA analyses, and the measurement of naturally occurring stable isotopes in animal tissues offer alternative approaches. This paper reviews the use of stable isotope analyses (primarily δ¹³C, δ¹⁵N, δ³⁴S, δD, δ⁸⁷Sr) to trace nutritional origin and migration in animals. This approach relies on the fact that foodweb isotopic signatures are reflected in the tissues of organisms and that such signatures can vary spatially based on a variety of biogeochemical processes. Organisms moving between isotopically distinct foodwebs can carry with them information on the location of previous feeding. Such an approach has been used to track animal use of inshore versus offshore, marine versus freshwater, terrestrial C₃ versus marine, terrestrial mesic versus xeric, and C₃ versus C₄ or Crassulacean acid metabolism foodwebs. More recently, the use of stable hydrogen isotope analyses (δD) to link organisms to broad geographic origin in North America is based on large-scale isotopic contours of growing-season average δD values in precipitation. This technique, especially when combined with the assay of other stable isotopes, will be extremely useful in helping to track migration and movement of a wide range of animals from insects to birds and mammals. Future research to refine our understanding of natural and anthropogenic-induced isotopic gradients in nature, and to explore the use of stable isotopes of other elements, is recommended. Received: 1 July 1998 / Accepted: 9 December 1998     

Short-term measurement of carbon isotope fractionation in plants

Combustion-based studies of the carbon-13 content of plants give only an integrated, long-term value for the isotope fractionation associated with photosynthesis. A method is described here which permits determination of this isotope fractionation in 2 to 3 hours. To accomplish this, the plant is enclosed in a glass chamber, and the quantity and isotopic content of the CO₂ remaining in the atmosphere are monitored during photosynthesis. Isotope fractionation studies by this method give results consistent with what is expected from combustion studies of C₃, C₄, and Crassulacean acid metabolism plants. This method will make possible a variety of new studies of environmental and species effects in carbon isotope fractionation.     

Carbon isotope fractionation in plants

Plants with the C₃, C₄, and crassulacean acid metabolism (CAM) photosynthetic pathways show characteristically different discriminations against ¹³C during photosynthesis. For each photosynthetic type, no more than slight variations are observed within or among species. CAM plants show large variations in isotope fractionation with temperature, but other plants do not. Different plant organs, subcellular fractions and metabolises can show widely varying isotopic compositions. The isotopic composition of respired carbon is often different from that of plant carbon, but it is not currently possible to describe this effect in detail. The principal components which will affect the overall isotope discrimination during photosynthesis are diffusion of CO₂, interconversion of CO₂ and HCO^?₃, incorporation of CO₂ by phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase or ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase, and respiration. Theisotope fractionations associated with these processes are summarized. Mathematical models are presented which permit prediction of the overall isotope discrimination in terms of these components. These models also permit a correlation of isotope fractionations with internal CO₂ concentrations. Analysis of existing data in terms of these models reveals that CO₂ incorporation in C₃ plants is limited principally by ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase, but CO₂ diffusion also contributes. In C₄ plants, carbon fixation is principally limited by the rate of CO₂ diffusion into the leaf. There is probably a small fractionation in C₄ plants due to ribulose bisphosphate carboxylase.     

Small‐mammal isotope ecology tracks climate and vegetation gradients across western North America

Stable carbon, nitrogen, hydrogen and oxygen isotopes have been used to infer aspects of species ecology and environment in both modern ecosystems and the fossil record. Compared to large mammals, stable isotopic studies of small‐mammal ecology are limited; however, high species and ecological diversity within small mammals presents several advantages for quantifying resource use and organism–environment interactions using stable isotopes over various spatial and temporal scales. We analyzed the isotopic composition of hair from two heteromyid rodent species, Dipodomys ordii and Perognathus parvus, from localities across western North America in order to characterize dietary variation in relation to vegetation and climatic gradients. Significant correlations between the carbon isotopic composition (δ¹³C) of these species and several climatic variables imply that seasonal temperature and precipitation control the composition and distribution of dietary resources (grass seeds). Our results also suggest a moisture influence on the nitrogen isotopic composition (δ¹⁵N) of heteromyid diets. Population‐ and species‐level variation in δ¹³C and δ¹⁵N values record fine‐scale habitat heterogeneity and significant differences in resource use between species. Using classification and regression‐tree techniques, we modeled the geographic variation in heteromyid δ¹³C_diet values based on 10 climatic variables and generated an isotope landscape model (‘isoscape’). The isoscape predictions for δ¹³C_diet differ from expectations based on observed C₄ distributions and instead indicate that D. ordii and P. parvus record seasonally abundant grass resources, with additional model deviations potentially attributed to geographic variation in dietary selection. The oxygen and hydrogen isotopic composition of D. ordii is enriched relative to local meteoric water and suggests that individuals rely on highly evaporated water sources, such as seed moisture. Based on the climatic influences on vegetation and diet documented in this study, the isotopic composition of small mammals has high potential for recording ecological responses to environmental changes over short and long time scales.     

Fractionation of stable sulfur isotopes during microbiological processes in Slavyansk lakes]

The isotopic content of sulphur in sulphates increases with depth in waters containing hydrogen sulphide of the meromictic lakes Repnoe and Veisovo as a result of microbiological reduction of sulphates. At the same time, hydrogen sulphide enrichments 19 to 25% of the light isotope 32S in the lake Veisovo, and 24 to 32% in the lake Repnoe. The fractionation of sulphur isotopes, manifested in the enrichment of sulphides with lighter isotopes, and that of sulphates with heavier isotopes, was found also in the bottom deposits of the lake Repnoe. The isotope and microbiological data suggest that, in the zone of mass growth of the phototrophic sulphur bacteria in the lake Repnoe, there are two processes of fractionation: (a) due to the bacterial reduction of sulphates; and (b) due to anaerobic oxidation of hydrogen sulphide, resulting in the enrichment of hydrogen sulphide with the light isotope 32S by 5 to 7 promille.     

Differential C Isotope Discrimination by Fungi during Decomposition of C3- and C4-Derived Sucrose

Stable isotope analysis is a major tool used in ecosystem studies to establish pathways and rates of C exchange between various ecosystem components. Little is known about isotopic effects of many such components, especially microbes. Here we report on the discovery of an unexpected pattern of C isotopic discrimination by basidiomycete fungi with far-reaching consequences for our understanding of isotopic processing in ecosystems where these microbes mediate material transfers across trophic levels. We measured fractionation effects on three ecologically relevant basidiomycete species under controlled laboratory conditions. Sucrose derived from C₃ and C₄ plants is fractionated differentially by these microbes in a taxon-specific manner. The differentiation between mycorrhizal and saprotrophic fungi observed in the field by others is not explained by intrinsic discrimination patterns. Fractionation occurs during sugar uptake and is sensitive to the nonrandom distribution of stable isotopes in the sucrose molecule. The balance between respiratory physiology and fermentative physiology modulates the degree of fractionation. These discoveries disprove the assumption that fungal C processing does not significantly alter the distribution of stable C isotopes and provide the basis for a reevaluation of ecosystem models based on isotopic evidence that involve C transfer across microbial interfaces. We provide a mechanism to account for the observed differential discrimination effects.     

Insights into nitrogen and carbon dynamics of ectomycorrhizal and saprotrophic fungi from isotopic evidence

The successful use of natural abundances of carbon (C) and nitrogen (N) isotopes in the study of ecosystem dynamics suggests that isotopic measurements could yield new insights into the role of fungi in nitrogen and carbon cycling. Sporocarps of mycorrhizal and saprotrophic fungi, vegetation, and soils were collected in young, deciduous-dominated sites and older, coniferous-dominated sites along a successional sequence at Glacier Bay National Park, Alaska. Mycorrhizal fungi had consistently higher δ¹⁵N and lower δ¹³C values than saprotrophic fungi. Foliar δ¹³C values were always isotopically depleted relative to both fungal types. Foliar δ¹⁵N values were usually, but not always, more depleted than those in saprotrophic fungi, and were consistently more depleted than in mycorrhizal fungi. We hypothesize that an apparent isotopic fractionation by mycorrhizal fungi during the transfer of nitrogen to plants may be attributed to enzymatic reactions within the fungi producing isotopically depleted amino acids, which are subsequently passed on to plant symbionts. An increasing difference between soil mineral nitrogen δ¹⁵N and foliar δ¹⁵N in later succession might therefore be a consequence of greater reliance on mycorrhizal symbionts for nitrogen supply under nitrogen-limited conditions. Carbon signatures of mycorrhizal fungi may be more enriched than those of foliage because the fungi use isotopically enriched photosynthate such as simple sugars, in contrast to the mixture of compounds present in leaves. In addition, some ¹³C fractionation may occur during transport processes from leaves to roots, and during fungal chitin biosynthesis. Stable isotopes have the potential to help clarify the role of fungi in ecosystem processes. Received: 7 January 1998 / Accepted: 9 November 1998     

Hydrogen isotopic differences between C3 and C4 land plant lipids: consequences of compartmentation in C4 photosynthetic chemistry and C3 photorespiration

The ²H/¹H ratio of carbon‐bound H in biolipids holds potential for probing plant lipid biosynthesis and metabolism. The biochemical mechanism underlying the isotopic differences between lipids from C₃ and C₄ plants is still poorly understood. GC‐pyrolysis‐IRMS (gas chromatography‐pyrolysis‐isotope ratio mass spectrometry) measurement of the ²H/¹H ratio of leaf lipids from controlled and field grown plants indicates that the biochemical isotopic fractionation (ε²H_{lipid_biochem}) differed between C₃ and C₄ plants in a pathway‐dependent manner: ε²H_C4 > ε²H_C3 for the acetogenic pathway, ε²H_C4 < ε²H_C3 for the mevalonic acid pathway and the 1‐deoxy‐D‐xylulose 5‐phosphate pathway across all species examined. It is proposed that compartmentation of photosynthetic CO₂ fixation into C₄ mesophyll (M) and bundle sheath (BS) cells and suppression of photorespiration in C₄ M and BS cells both result in C₄ M chloroplastic pyruvate – the precursor for acetogenic pathway – being more depleted in ²H relative to pyruvate in C₃ cells. In addition, compartmentation in C₄ plants also results in (i) the transferable H of NADPH being enriched in ²H in C₄ M chloroplasts compared with that in C₃ chloroplasts for the 1‐deoxy‐D‐xylulose 5‐phosphate pathway pathway and (ii) pyruvate relatively ²H‐enriched being used for the mevalonic acid pathway in the cytosol of BS cells in comparison with that in C₃ cells.     

Carbon and hydrogen isotope fractionation under continuous light: implications for paleoenvironmental interpretations of the High Arctic during Paleogene warming

The effect of low intensity continuous light, e.g., in the High Arctic summer, on plant carbon and hydrogen isotope fractionations is unknown. We conducted greenhouse experiments to test the impact of light quantity and duration on both carbon and hydrogen isotope compositions of three deciduous conifers whose fossil counterparts were components of Paleogene Arctic floras: Metasequoia glyptostroboides, Taxodium distichum, and Larix laricina. We found that plant leaf bulk carbon isotopic values of the examined species were 1.75–4.63‰ more negative under continuous light (CL) than under diurnal light (DL). Hydrogen isotope values of leaf n-alkanes under continuous light conditions revealed a D-enriched hydrogen isotope composition of up to 40‰ higher than in diurnal light conditions. The isotope offsets between the two light regimes is explained by a higher ratio of intercellular to atmospheric CO₂ concentration (C _i/C _a) and more water loss for plants under continuous light conditions during a 24-h transpiration cycle. Apparent hydrogen isotope fractionations between source water and individual lipids (ε_{lipid–water}) range from −62‰ (Metasequoia C₂₇ and C₂₉) to −87‰ (Larix C₂₉) in leaves under continuous light. We applied these hydrogen fractionation factors to hydrogen isotope compositions of in situ n-alkanes from well-preserved Paleogene deciduous conifer fossils from the Arctic region to estimate the δD value in ancient precipitation. Precipitation in the summer growing season yielded a δD of −186‰ for late Paleocene, −157‰ for early middle Eocene, and −182‰ for late middle Eocene. We propose that high-latitude summer precipitation in this region was supplemented by moisture derived from regionally recycled transpiration of the polar forests that grew during the Paleogene warming.