The dynamics of engineered resident proteins in the mammalian Golgi complex relies on cisternal maturation

After leaving the endoplasmic reticulum, secretory proteins traverse several membranous transport compartments before reaching their destinations. How they move through the Golgi complex, a major secretory station composed of stacks of membranous cisternae, is a central yet unsettled issue in membrane biology. Two classes of mechanisms have been proposed. One is based on cargo-laden carriers hopping across stable cisternae and the other on “maturing” cisternae that carry cargo forward while progressing through the stack. A key difference between the two concerns the behavior of Golgi-resident proteins. Under stable cisternae models, Golgi residents remain in the same cisterna, whereas, according to cisternal maturation, Golgi residents recycle from distal to proximal cisternae via retrograde carriers in synchrony with cisternal progression. Here, we have engineered Golgi-resident constructs that can be polymerized at will to prevent their recycling via Golgi carriers. Maturation models predict the progress of such polymerized residents through the stack along with cargo, but stable cisternae models do not. The results support the cisternal maturation mechanism.     

Golgi enzymes are enriched in perforated zones of golgi cisternae but are depleted in COPI vesicles

In the most widely accepted version of the cisternal maturation/progression model of intra-Golgi transport, the polarity of the Golgi complex is maintained by retrograde transport of Golgi enzymes in COPI-coated vesicles. By analyzing enzyme localization in relation to the three-dimensional ultrastructure of the Golgi complex, we now observe that Golgi enzymes are depleted in COPI-coated buds and 50- to 60-nm COPI-dependent vesicles in a variety of different cell types. Instead, we find that Golgi enzymes are concentrated in the perforated zones of cisternal rims both in vivo and in a cell-free system. This lateral segregation of Golgi enzymes is detectable in some stacks during steady-state transport, but it was significantly prominent after blocking endoplasmic reticulum-to-Golgi transport. Delivery of transport carriers to the Golgi after the release of a transport block leads to a diminution in Golgi enzyme concentrations in perforated zones of cisternae. The exclusion of Golgi enzymes from COPI vesicles and their transport-dependent accumulation in perforated zones argues against the current vesicle-mediated version of the cisternal maturation/progression model.     

Golgi and Related Vesicle Proteomics: Simplify to Identify

Despite more than six decades of successful Golgi research, the fundamental question as to how biosynthetic material is transported through the secretory pathway remains unanswered. New technologies such as live cell imaging and correlative microscopy have highlighted the plastic nature of the Golgi, one that is sensitive to perturbation yet highly efficient in regaining both structure and function. Single molecule-microscopy and super resolution-microscopy further adds to this picture. Various models for protein transport have been put forward, each with its own merits and pitfalls but we are far from resolving whether one is more correct than the other. As such, our laboratory considers multiple mechanisms of Golgi transport until proven otherwise. This includes the two classical modes of transport, vesicular transport and cisternal progression/maturation as well as more recent models such as tubular inter- and intra-cisternal connections (long lasting or transient) and inter-Golgi stack transport. In this article, we focus on an emerging inductive technology, mass spectrometry-based proteomics that has already enabled insight into the relative composition of compartments and subcompartments of the secretory pathway including mechanistic aspects of protein transport. We note that proteomics, as with any other technology, is not a stand-alone technology but one that works best alongside complementary approaches.     

Exclusion of golgi residents from transport vesicles budding from Golgi cisternae in intact cells

A central feature of cisternal progression/maturation models for anterograde transport across the Golgi stack is the requirement that the entire population of steady-state residents of this organelle be continuously transported backward to earlier cisternae to avoid loss of these residents as the membrane of the oldest (trans-most) cisterna departs the stack. For this to occur, resident proteins must be packaged into retrograde-directed transport vesicles, and to occur at the rate of anterograde transport, resident proteins must be present in vesicles at a higher concentration than in cisternal membranes. We have tested this prediction by localizing two steady-state residents of medial Golgi cisternae (mannosidase II and N-acetylglucosaminyl transferase I) at the electron microscopic level in intact cells. In both cases, these abundant cisternal constituents were strongly excluded from buds and vesicles. This result suggests that cisternal progression takes place substantially more slowly than most protein transport and therefore is unlikely to be the predominant mechanism of anterograde movement.     

Small cargo proteins and large aggregates can traverse the Golgi by a common mechanism without leaving the lumen of cisternae.

Procollagen (PC)-I aggregates transit through the Golgi complex without leaving the lumen of Golgi cisternae. Based on this evidence, we have proposed that PC-I is transported across the Golgi stacks by the cisternal maturation process. However, most secretory cargoes are small, freely diffusing proteins, thus raising the issue whether they move by a transport mechanism different than that used by PC-I. To address this question we have developed procedures to compare the transport of a small protein, the G protein of the vesicular stomatitis virus (VSVG), with that of the much larger PC-I aggregates in the same cell. Transport was followed using a combination of video and EM, providing high resolution in time and space. Our results reveal that PC-I aggregates and VSVG move synchronously through the Golgi at indistinguishable rapid rates. Additionally, not only PC-I aggregates (as confirmed by ultrarapid cryofixation), but also VSVG, can traverse the stack without leaving the cisternal lumen and without entering Golgi vesicles in functionally relevant amounts. Our findings indicate that a common mechanism independent of anterograde dissociative carriers is responsible for the traffic of small and large secretory cargo across the Golgi stack.     

In vitro transport on cis and trans sides of the Golgi involves two distinct types of coatomer and ADP-ribosylation factor-independent transport intermediates

The cisternal maturation model proposes that secretory proteins transit the Golgi in cisternae that mature by the continuous retrograde transport of Golgi enzymes in vesicles. We have tested the hypothesis that de novo generation of transport intermediates containing medial, trans, and trans Golgi network (TGN) enzymes is reconstituted in vitro. Our analysis shows that the majority of transport is mediated by a steady state of transport intermediate production and consumption by Golgi cisternae, with only a minor contribution of pre-existing transport intermediates. Transport in the medial and trans regions of the stack involved intermediates containing Golgi enzymes, apparently moving in a retrograde direction. In contrast, transport between the trans Golgi and TGN was exclusively mediated by intermediates containing secretory protein, as expected for anterograde transport. These intermediates may be physiologically relevant, because only these two specific types of intermediates can be detected in cell homogenates. By analogy to the coatomer (COPI)-independent transport of Golgi enzymes to the endoplasmic reticulum, the steady-state production of intra-Golgi transport intermediates was not impaired by inhibition of COPI vesicle formation. These data suggest a model for COPI-independent intra-Golgi transport by cisternal maturation with a shift in mechanism to anterograde transport at the trans Golgi and TGN boundary.     

Pre- and post-Golgi vacuoles operate in the transport of Semliki Forest virus membrane glycoproteins to the cell surface

The effect of reduced temperature on synchronized transport of SFV membrane proteins from the ER via the Golgi complex to the surface of BHK-21 cells revealed two membrane compartments where transport could be arrested. At 15 degrees C the proteins could leave the ER but failed to enter the Golgi cisternae and accumulated in pre-Golgi vacuolar elements. At 20 degrees C the proteins passed through Golgi stacks but accumulated in trans-Golgi cisternae, vacuoles, and vesicular elements because of a block affecting a distal stage in transport. Both blocks were reversible, allowing study of the synchronous passage of viral membrane proteins through the Golgi complex at high resolution by immunolabeling in electron microscopy. We propose that membrane proteins enter the Golgi stack via tubular extensions of the pre-Golgi vacuolar elements which generate the Golgi cisternae. The proteins pass across the Golgi apparatus following cisternal progression and enter the post-Golgi vacuolar elements to be routed to the cell surface.     

Architecture of the Golgi apparatus of a scale-forming alga: biogenesis and transport of scales

Mechanisms of transport of secretory products across the Golgi apparatus (GA) as well as of scale formation in prymnesiophytes have remained controversial. We have used a quantitative morphological approach to study formation and transport of scales across the GA in haploid cells of Pleurochrysis sp. The GA of these cells differs from the GA of higher plants in at least six morphological characteristics. Our results show that scales form in the trans-Golgi network (TGN) and transit the TGN in heretofore unrecognized prosecretory vesicles. Prosecretory vesicles differentiate into secretory vesicles prior to exocytosis of scales to the cell surface. Because prosecretory vesicles are only fragments of TGN cisternae, the classical model of cisternal progression is not a valid mechanism of transport in this alga. TGN transport vesicles are also involved in scale formation; however, the role of tubular connections between cisternae of a single stack-TGN unit is not clear. The relationship of two morphological types of cisternal dilations to a membrane-associated, bottlebrush-shaped macromolecule of novel morphology suggests a new hypothesis for the biogenesis of scales.     

Clathrin adaptors mediate two sequential pathways of intra-Golgi recycling

The pathways of membrane traffic within the Golgi apparatus are not fully known. This question was addressed using the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, in which the maturation of individual Golgi cisternae can be visualized. We recently proposed that the AP-1 clathrin adaptor mediates intra-Golgi recycling late in the process of cisternal maturation. Here, we demonstrate that AP-1 cooperates with the Ent5 clathrin adaptor to recycle a set of Golgi transmembrane proteins, including some that were previously thought to pass through endosomes. This recycling can be detected by removing AP-1 and Ent5, thereby diverting the AP-1/Ent5–dependent Golgi proteins into an alternative recycling loop that involves traffic to the plasma membrane followed by endocytosis. Unexpectedly, various AP-1/Ent5–dependent Golgi proteins show either intermediate or late kinetics of residence in maturing cisternae. We infer that the AP-1/Ent5 pair mediates two sequential intra-Golgi recycling pathways that define two classes of Golgi proteins. This insight can explain the polarized distribution of transmembrane proteins in the Golgi.     

Sec7p directs the transitions required for yeast Golgi biogenesis

Endoplasmic reticulum (ER)-to-Golgi traffic in yeast proceeds by the maturation of membrane compartments from post-ER vesicles to intermediate small vesicle tubular clusters (VTCs) to Golgi nodular membrane networks (Morin-Ganet et al., Traffic 2000; 1: 56–68). The balance between ER and Golgi compartments is maintained by COPII- and COPI-mediated anterograde and retrograde traffic, which are dependent on Sec7p and ARF function. The sec7-4 temperature-sensitive allele is a mutation in the highly conserved Sec7 domain (Sec7d) found in all ARF-guanine nucleotide exchange factor proteins. Post-ER trafficking is rapidly inactivated in sec7-4 mutant yeast at the restrictive temperature. This conditional defect prevented the normal production of VTCs and instead generated Golgi-like tubes emanating from the ER exit sites. These tubes progressively developed into stacked cisternae defining the landmark sec7 mutant phenotype. Consistent with the in vivo results, a Sec7d peptide inhibited ER-to-Golgi transport and displaced Sec7p from its membrane anchor in vitro . The similarities in the consequences of inactivating Sec7p or ARFs in vivo was revealed by genetic disruption of yeast ARFs or by addition of brefeldin A (BFA) to whole cells. These treatments, as in sec7-4 yeast, affected the morphology of membrane compartments in the ER-Golgi transition. Further evidence for Sec7p involvement in the transition for Golgi biogenesis was revealed by in vitro binding between distinct domains of Sec7p with ARFs, COPI and COPII coat proteins. These results suggest that Sec7p coordinates membrane transitions in Golgi biogenesis by directing and scaffolding the binding and disassembly of coat protein complexes to membranes, both at the VTC transition from ER exit sites to form Golgi elements and for later events in Golgi maturation.     

Traffic through the Golgi apparatus.

The role of vesicles in cargo transport through the Golgi apparatus has been controversial. Large forms of cargo such as protein aggregates are thought to progress through the Golgi stack by a process of cisternal maturation, balanced by a return flow of Golgi resident proteins in COPI-coated vesicles. However, whether this is the primary role of vesicles, or whether they also serve to transport small cargo molecules in a forward direction has been debated. Two papers (Martínez-Menárguez et al., 2001; Mironov et al., 2001, this issue) use sophisticated light and electron microscopy to provide evidence that the vesicular stomatitis virus membrane glycoprotein (VSV G)* is largely excluded from vesicles in vivo, and does not move between cisternae, whereas resident Golgi enzymes freely enter vesicles as predicted by the cisternal maturation model. Both papers conclude that vesicles are likely to play only a minor role in the anterograde transport of cargo through the Golgi apparatus in mammalian tissue culture cells.     

Capacity of the Golgi apparatus for cargo transport prior to complete assembly

In yeast, particular emphasis has been given to endoplasmic reticulum (ER)-derived, cisternal maturation models of Golgi assembly while in mammalian cells more emphasis has been given to golgins as a potentially stable assembly framework. In the case of de novo Golgi formation from the ER after brefeldin A/H89 washout in HeLa cells, we found that scattered, golgin-enriched, structures formed early and contained golgins including giantin, ranging across the entire cis to trans spectrum of the Golgi apparatus. These structures were incompetent in VSV-G cargo transport. Second, we compared Golgi competence in cargo transport to the kinetics of addition of various glycosyltransferases and glycosidases into nascent, golgin-enriched structures after drug washout. Enzyme accumulation was sequential with trans and then medial glycosyltransferases/glycosidases found in the scattered, nascent Golgi. Involvement in cargo transport preceded full accumulation of enzymes or GPP130 into nascent Golgi. Third, during mitosis, we found that the formation of a golgin-positive acceptor compartment in early telophase preceded the accumulation of a Golgi glycosyltransferase in nascent Golgi structures. We conclude that during mammalian Golgi assembly components fit into a dynamic, first-formed, multigolgin-enriched framework that is initially cargo transport incompetent. Resumption of cargo transport precedes full Golgi assembly.     

Gut thoughts on the Golgi complex

The new millennium coincides within 1 year of Camillo Golgi's centennial celebrations. It is quite remarkable that the structure and formation of this organelle is as controversial today as was its mere existence from Golgi's time to the 1950s, when EM approaches were introduced. Since the late 1950s, two opposing models of Golgi structure and function have split the Golgi scientific community, namely vesicular transport versus organelle maturation. Although a few years ago Golgi maturation seemed to be 'out for the count', it has recently seen an almost messianic revival. In this review, I argue that this large-scale desertion from the vesicle transport model to the maturation camp is premature. I propose an alternative, dynamic steady-state model, in which transient tubular connections function in parallel to vesicular transport and that the biosynthetic pathway is made up of three major distinct compartments: the ER, the Golgi and the TGN.     

Expression of a wild-type CFTR maintains the integrity of the biosynthetic/secretory pathway in human cystic fibrosis pancreatic duct cells.

The structural integrity of the Golgi complex is essential to its functions in the maturation, sorting, and transport of plasma membrane proteins. Previously, we demonstrated that in pancreatic duct CFPAC-1 cells, which express DeltaF508 CFTR (cystic fibrosis transmembrane conductance regulator), the intracellular trafficking of carbonic anhydrase IV (CA IV), a membrane protein involved in HCO(3)(-) secretion, was impaired. To determine whether these abnormalities were related to changes in the Golgi complex, we examined the ultrastructure and distribution of Golgi compartments with regard to the microtubule cytoskeleton in CFPAC-1 cells transfected or not with the wild-type CFTR. Ultrastructural and immunocytochemical analysis showed that in polarized CFPAC-1 cells, Golgi stacks were disconnected from one another and scattered throughout the cytoplasm. The colocalization of CA IV with markers of Golgi compartments indicated the ability of stacks to transfer this enzyme. This Golgi dispersal was associated with abnormal microtubule distribution and multiplicity of the microtubule-organizing centers (MTOCs). In reverted cells, the normalization of Golgi structure, microtubule distribution, and MTOC number was observed. These observations suggest that the entire biosynthetic/secretory pathway is disrupted in CFPAC-1 cells, which might explain the abnormal intracellular transport of CA IV. Taken together, these results point to the fact that the expression of DeltaF508 CFTR affects the integrity of the secretory pathway.     

Prohormone transport through the secretory pathway of neuroendocrine cells.

En route through the secretory pathway of neuroendocrine cells, prohormones pass a series of membrane-bounded compartments. During this transport, the prohormones are sorted to secretory granules and proteolytically cleaved to bioactive peptides. Recently, progress has been made in a number of aspects concerning secretory protein transport and sorting, particularly with respect to transport events in the early regions of the secretory pathway. In this review we will deal with some of these aspects, including: i) selective exit from the endoplasmic reticulum via COPII-coated vesicles and the potential role of p24 putative cargo receptors in this process, ii) cisternal maturation as an alternative model for protein transport through the Golgi complex, and iii) the mechanisms that may be involved in the sorting of regulated secretory proteins to secretory granules. Although much remains to be learned, interesting new insights into the functioning of the secretory pathway have been obtained.     

The Yeast Golgi Apparatus

The Golgi apparatus is an organelle that has been extensively studied in the model eukaryote, yeast. Its morphology varies among yeast species; the Golgi exists as a system of dispersed cisternae in the case of the budding yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae, whereas the Golgi cisternae in Pichia pastoris and Schizosaccharomyces pombe are organized into stacks. In spite of the different organization, the mechanism of trafficking through the Golgi apparatus is believed to be similar, involving cisternal maturation, in which the resident Golgi proteins are transported backwards while secretory cargo proteins can stay in the cisternae. Questions remain regarding the organization of the yeast Golgi, the regulatory mechanisms that underlie cisternal maturation of the Golgi and transport machinery of cargo proteins through this organelle. Studies using different yeast species have provided hints to these mechanisms.      

The KDEL receptor couples to Gαq/11 to activate Src kinases and regulate transport through the Golgi

Membrane trafficking involves large fluxes of cargo and membrane across separate compartments. These fluxes must be regulated by control systems to maintain homoeostasis. While control systems for other key functions such as protein folding or the cell cycle are well known, the mechanisms that control secretory transport are poorly understood. We have previously described a signalling circuit operating at the Golgi complex that regulates intra-Golgi trafficking and is initiated by the KDEL receptor (KDEL-R), a protein previously known to mediate protein recycling from the Golgi to the endoplasmic reticulum (ER). Here, we investigated the KDEL-R signalling mechanism. We show that the KDEL-R is predicted to fold like a G-protein-coupled receptor (GPCR), and that it binds and activates the heterotrimeric signalling G-protein Gα(q/11) which, in turn, regulates transport through the Golgi complex. These findings reveal an unexpected GPCR-like mode of action of the KDEL-R and shed light on a core molecular control mechanism of intra-Golgi traffic.     

Membrane targeting of p115 phosphorylation mutants and their effects on Golgi integrity and secretory traffic

The cytosolic phosphoprotein p115 is required for ER to Golgi traffic and for Golgi reassembly after mitosis. In cells, p115 is localized to ER exit sites, ER-Golgi Intermediate Compartment (ERGIC) and the Golgi, and cycles between these compartments. P115 is phosphorylated on serine 942, and this modification appears to control p115 association with membranes. P115 is likely to function by reversibly interacting with effector proteins, and in the Golgi, two proteins, GM130 and giantin, have been shown to bind p115. The GM130-p115 and the giantin-p115 interactions are enhanced by p115 phosphorylation. Phosphorylation appears to be essential for p115 function, since substitutions of serine 942 abolish p115 ability to sustain cisternal reformation in an in vitro assay reconstituting Golgi reassembly after mitosis. Here, we explored how phosphorylation of p115 affects its intracellular targeting to distinct cellular compartments, and its function in secretory traffic. We generated phosphorylation mutants of p115 and tested their ability to target to ER exit sites, ERGIC and the Golgi. In addition, we explored whether expression of the mutants causes disruption of Golgi structure and perturbs ER-Golgi traffic of a VSV-G cargo protein.     

Simulated de novo assembly of golgi compartments by selective cargo capture during vesicle budding and targeted vesicle fusion

The Golgi apparatus is comprised of stacked cisternal membranes forming subcompartments specialized for posttranslational processing of newly synthesized secretory cargo. Recent experimental evidence indicates that the Golgi apparatus can undergo de novo biogenesis from the endoplasmic reticulum, but the mechanism by which the membranes self assemble into compartmentalized structures remains unknown. We developed a discrete-event computer simulation model to test whether two fundamental mechanisms—vesicle-coat-mediated selective concentration of soluble N-ethylmaleimide-sensitive factor attachment protein receptor (SNARE) proteins during vesicle formation, and SNARE-mediated selective fusion of vesicles—suffice to generate and maintain compartments. Simulations verified that this minimal model is adequate for homeostasis of preestablished compartments, even in response to small perturbations, and for de novo formation of stable compartments. The model led to a novel prediction that Golgi size is in part dependent on target SNARE expression level. This prediction was supported by a demonstration that exogenous expression of the Golgi target SNARE syntaxin-5 alters Golgi size in living cells.     

The p115-interactive proteins GM130 and giantin participate in endoplasmic reticulum-Golgi traffic

The transport factor p115 is essential for endoplasmic reticulum (ER) to Golgi traffic. P115 interacts with two Golgi proteins, GM130 and giantin, suggesting that they might also participate in ER-Golgi traffic. Here, we show that peptides containing the GM130 or the giantin p115 binding domain and anti-GM130 and anti-giantin antibodies inhibit transport of vesicular stomatitis virus (VSV)-G protein to a mannosidase II-containing Golgi compartment. To determine whether p115, GM130, and giantin act together or sequentially during transport, we compared kinetics of traffic inhibition. Anti-p115, anti-GM130, and anti-giantin antibodies inhibited transport at temporally distinct steps, with the p115-requiring step before the GM130-requiring stage, and both preceding the giantin-requiring stage. Examination of the distribution of the arrested VSV-G protein showed that anti-p115 antibodies inhibited transport at the level of vesicular-tubular clusters, whereas anti-GM130 and anti-giantin antibodies inhibited after the VSV-G protein moved to the Golgi complex. Our results provide the first evidence that GM130 and giantin are required for the delivery of a cargo protein to the mannosidase II-containing Golgi compartment. These data are most consistent with a model where transport from the ER to the cis/medial-Golgi compartments requires the action of p115, GM130, and giantin in a sequential rather than coordinate mechanism.