Evolution of the diverse array of phosphagen systems present in annelids

Annelids as a group express a variety of phosphagen kinases including creatine kinase (CK), glyocyamine kinase (GK), lombricine kinase (LK), taurocyamine kinase (TK) and a unique arginine kinase (AK) restricted to annelids. In prior work, we have determined and compared the intron/exon organization of the annelid genes for cytoplasmic GK, LK, AK, and mitochondrial TK and LK (MiTK and MiLK, respectively), and found that these annelid genes, irrespective of cytoplasmic or mitochondrial, have the same 8-intron/9-exon organization strikingly similar to mitochondrial CK (MiCK) genes. These results support the view that the MiCK gene is basal and ancestral to the phosphagen kinases unique to annelids. To gain a greater understanding of the evolutionary processes leading to the diversity of annelid phosphagen kinases, we determined for the first time the intron/exon organization of a cytoplasmic CK gene from a polychaete as well as that of another polychaete MiCK gene. These gene structures, coupled with a phylogenetic analyses of annelid enzymes and assessment of the fidelity of substrate specificity of some these phosphagen kinases, provide insight into the pattern of radiation of the annelid enzymes. Annelid phosphagen kinases appeared to have diverged in the following order (earliest first): (1) cytoplasmic AK, LK and TK, (2) GK, and (3) mitochondrial MiLK and MiTK. Interestingly, phylogenetic analyses showed that the above phosphagen kinases appear to be basal to all CK isoforms (mitochondrial, cytoplasmic and flagellar CKs). This somewhat paradoxical placement of CKs most likely reflects a higher rate of evolution and radiation of the annelid-specific LK, TK and GK genes than the CK isoform genes.     

Evolution of the Cytoplasmic and Mitochondrial Phosphagen Kinases Unique to Annelid Groups

Creatine kinase (CK) is a member of a group of phosphoryl transfer enzymes called phosphagen kinases that play a key role in cellular energy transactions in animals. Three CK isoform gene families are known—cytoplasmic CK (CK), flagellar CK (fCK), and mitochondrial CK (MiCK). Each of the isoforms has a unique gene structure (intron/exon organization). A broad array of other phosphagen kinases is present in animals. Some of these enzymes are found only in annelids and closely related groups including glyocyamine kinase (GK), lombricine kinase (LK), taurocyamine kinase (TK), and a unique arginine kinase (AK) restricted to annelids. Phylogenetic analyses of these annelid phosphagen kinases indicate that they appear to have evolved from a CK-like ancestor. To gain a greater understanding of the relationship of the CK isoforms to the annelid enzymes, we have determined the intron/exon organization of the genes for the following phosphagen kinases: Eisenia LK, Sabellastarte AK, and Arenicola mitochondrial TK (MiTK). Analysis of genomic database for the polychaete Capitella sp. yielded two putative LK genes [cytoplasmic LK and mitochondrial LK (MiLK)]. The intron/exon organization of these genes was compared with available data for cytoplasmic and mitochondrial CKs, and an annelid GK. Surprisingly, these annelid genes, irrespective of whether they are cytoplasmic (LK, AK, and GK) or mitochondrial (MiTK and MiLK), had the same 8-intron/9-exon organization and were strikingly similar to MiCK genes sharing seven of eight splice junctions. These results support the view that the MiCK gene is basal and ancestral to the phosphagen kinases unique to annelids.     

Cloning and expression of a lombricine kinase from an echiuroid worm: insights into structural correlates of substrate specificity

Phosphagen kinases constitute a large family of enzymes catalyzing the reversible phosphorylation of guanidino acceptor compounds. These guanidino substrates differ substantially in size and chemical properties. In spite of the appearance of X-ray crystal structures for two members of this family, creatine kinase (CK) and arginine kinase (AK), the structural correlates of substrate specificity remain to be fully elucidated. We have determined the cDNA and deduced amino acid sequences for lombricine (guanidinethylphosphoserine) kinase (LK) from the echiuroid worm Urechis caupo and expressed the cDNA in Escherichia coli. The recombinant protein was purified by affinity chromatography and showed high capacity for phosphorylation of lombricine. Phosphagen kinases consist of a small, N-terminal domain and a much larger domain connected by a linker sequence. A key event in catalysis in CK and AK, and certainly all other phosphagen kinases, is a large conformational change involving involving a rotation of the two domains and the movement of two highly conserved flexible loops (one located in the small domain; the other located in the large domain of these enzymes) which clamp down on the substrates. Multiple sequence alignments of Urechis LK with the only other LK sequence available and CK, AK and glycocyamine kinase sequences, confirm the importance of the small flexible loop located in the N-terminal domain of phosphagen kinases as one component of the structural determinants of guanidine specificity. The role of the other flexible loop in the large domain in terms of substrate specificity remains questionable.     

Origin and properties of cytoplasmic and mitochondrial isoforms of taurocyamine kinase

Taurocyamine kinase (TK) is a member of the highly conserved family of phosphagen kinases that includes creatine kinase (CK) and arginine kinase. TK is found only in certain marine annelids. In this study we used PCR to amplify two cDNAs coding for TKs from the polychaete Arenicola brasiliensis, cloned these cDNAs into the pMAL plasmid and expressed the TKs as fusion proteins with the maltose-binding protein. These are the first TK cDNA and deduced amino acid sequences to be reported. One of the two cDNA-derived amino acid sequences of TKs shows a high amino acid identity to lombricine kinase, another phosphagen kinase unique to annelids, and appears to be a cytoplasmic isoform. The other sequence appears to be a mitochondrial isoform; it has a long N-terminal extension that was judged to be a mitochondrial targeting peptide by several on-line programs and shows a higher similarity in amino acid sequence to mitochondrial creatine kinases from both vertebrates and invertebrates. The recombinant cytoplasmic TK showed activity for the substrates taurocyamine and lombricine (9% of that of taurocyamine). However, the mitochondrial TK showed activity for taurocyamine, lombricine (30% of that of taurocyamine) and glycocyamine (7% of that of taurocyamine). Neither TK catalyzed the phosphorylation of creatine. Comparison of the deduced amino acid sequences of mitochondrial CK and TK indicated that several key residues required for CK activity are lacking in the mitochondrial TK sequence. Homology models for both cytoplasmic and mitochondrial TK, constructed using CK templates, provided some insight into the structural correlation of differences in substrate specificity between the two TKs. A phylogenetic analysis using amino acid sequences from a broad spectrum of phosphagen kinases showed that annelid-specific phosphagen kinases (lombricine kinase, glycocyamine kinase and cytoplasmic and mitochondrial TKs) are grouped in one cluster, and form a sister-group with CK sequences from vertebrate and invertebrate groups. It appears that the annelid-specific phosphagen kinases, including cytoplasmic and mitochondrial TKs, evolved from a CK-like ancestor(s) early in the divergence of the protostome metazoans. Furthermore, our results suggest that the cytoplasmic and mitochondrial isoforms of TK evolved independently.     

Expression of horseshoe crab arginine kinase in Escherichia coli and site-directed mutations of the reactive cysteine peptide

Arginine kinase (AK) from the horseshoe crab Limulus polyphemus was expressed in Escherichia coli. The bulk of expressed protein resided in insoluble inclusion bodies. However, approximately 3 mg enzyme protein/l culture was present as active soluble AK. The AK-containing expression vector construct was subjected to site-directed mutagenesis via a polymerase chain reaction-based megaprimer protocol. The AK reactive cysteine peptide was engineered so that it was identical to the corresponding peptide sequence of creatine kinase, another member of the guanidino kinase enzyme family. The resulting expressed protein had a considerably reduced specific activity but was still specific for arginine/arginine phosphate. No catalytic activity was observed with other guanidine substrates (creatine, glycocyamine, taurocyamine, lombricine). The reactive cysteine peptide, characteristic of all guanidino kinases, very likely plays a minimal role in determining guanidine specificity.     

Hypotaurocyamine kinase evolved from a gene for arginine kinase

Hypotaurocyamine kinase (HTK) is a member of the highly conserved family of phosphagen kinases that includes creatine kinase (CK) and arginine kinase (AK). HTK is found only in sipunculid worms, and it shows activities for both the substrates hypotaurocyamine and taurocyamine. Determining how HTK evolved in sipunculids is particularly insightful because all sipunculid-allied animals have AK and only some sipunculids have HTK. We determined the cDNA sequence of HTK from the sipunculid worm Siphonosoma cumanense for the first time, cloned it in pMAL plasmid and expressed it in E. coli as a fusion protein with maltose-binding protein. The cDNAderived amino acid sequence of Siphonosoma HTK showed high amino acid identity with molluscan AKs. Nevertheless, the recombinant enzyme of Siphonosoma HTK showed no activity for the substrate arginine, but showed activity for taurocyamine. Comparison of the amino acid sequences of HTK and AK indicated that the amino acid residues necessary for the binding of the substrate arginine in AK have been completely lost in Siphonosoma HTK sequence. The phylogenetic analysis indicated that the HTK amino acid sequence was placed just outside the molluscan AK cluster, which formed a sister group with the arthropod and nematode AKs. These results suggest that Siphonosoma HTK evolved from a gene for molluscan AK. Moreover, to confirm this assertion, we determined by PCR that the gene for Siphonosoma HTK has a 5-exon/4-intron structure, which is homologous with that of the molluscan AK genes. Further, the positions of splice junctions were conserved exactly between the two genes. Thus, we conclude that Siphonosoma HTK has evolved from a primordial gene for molluscan AK.     

Identification of amino acid residues responsible for taurocyamine binding in mitochondrial taurocyamine kinase from Arenicola brasiliensis

In order to investigate the residues associated with binding of the substrate taurocyamine in Arenicola mitochondrial taurocyamine kinase (TK), we performed Ala-scanning of the amino acid sequence HTKTV at positions 67-71 on the GS loop, and determined apparent K(m) and V(max) (appK(m) and appV(max), respectively) of the mutant forms for the substrates taurocyamine and glycocyamine. The appK(m) values for taurocyamine of the K69A, T70A and V71A mutants were significantly increased as compared with wild-type, suggesting that these residues are associated with taurocyamine binding. Of special interest is a property of V71A mutant: its catalytic efficiency for glycocyamine was twice that for taurocyamine, indicating that the V71A mutant acts like a glycocyamine kinase, rather than a TK. The role of the amino acid residue K95 of Arenicola MiTK was also examined. K95 was replaced with R, H, Y, I, A and E. K95R, K95H and K95I have a 3-fold higher affinity for taurocyamine, and activity was largely lost in K95E. On the other hand, the K95Y mutant showed a rather unique feature; namely, an increase in substrate concentration caused a decrease in initial velocity of the reaction (substrate inhibition). This is the first report on the key amino acid residues responsible for taurocyamine binding in mitochondrial TK.     

Crystal structure of shrimp arginine kinase in binary complex with arginine—a molecular view of the phosphagen precursor binding to the enzyme

Arginine kinase (AK) is a key enzyme for energetic balance in invertebrates. Although AK is a well-studied system that provides fast energy to invertebrates using the phosphagen phospho-arginine, the structural details on the AK-arginine binary complex interaction remain unclear. Herein, we determined two crystal structures of the Pacific whiteleg shrimp (Litopenaeus vannamei) arginine kinase, one in binary complex with arginine (LvAK-Arg) and a ternary transition state analog complex (TSAC). We found that the arginine guanidinium group makes ionic contacts with Glu225, Cys271 and a network of ordered water molecules. On the zwitterionic side of the amino acid, the backbone amide nitrogens of Gly64 and Val65 coordinate the arginine carboxylate. Glu314, one of proposed acid–base catalytic residues, did not interact with arginine in the binary complex. This residue is located in the flexible loop 310–320 that covers the active site and only stabilizes in the LvAK-TSAC. This is the first binary complex crystal structure of a guanidine kinase in complex with the guanidine substrate and could give insights into the nature of the early steps of phosphagen biosynthesis.     

Variable intron/exon structure in the oligochaete lombricine kinase gene

Lombricine kinase is an annelid enzyme that belongs to the phosphagen kinase family of which creatine kinase and arginine kinase are the typical representatives. The enzymes play important roles in the cellular energy metabolism of animals. Biochemical, physiological and molecular information with respect to lombricine kinase is limited compared to other phosphagen kinases. This study presents data on the cDNA sequences of lombricine kinase from two smaller oligochaetes, Enchytraeus sp. and Stylaria sp. The deduced amino acid sequences are analyzed and compared with other selected phosphagen kinases. The intron/exon structure of the lombricine kinase gene was determined for these two species as well as two additional oligochaetes, Lumbriculus variegatus and Tubifex tubifex, and compared with available data for annelid phosphagen kinases. The data indicate the existence of a variable organization of the proposed 8-intron/9-exon gene structure. The results provide further insights in the evolution and position of these enzymes within the phosphagen kinase family.     

The role of Arg-96 in Danio rerio creatine kinase in substrate recognition and active center configuration

In creatine kinases (CKs), the amino acid residue-96 is a strictly conserved arginine. This residue is not directly associated with substrate binding, but it is located close to the binding site of the substrate creatine. On the other hand, the residue-96 is known to be involved in expression in the substrate specificity of various other phosphagen (guanidino) kinases, since each enzyme has a specific residue at this position: arginine kinase (Tyr), glycocyamine kinase (Ile), taurocyamine kinase (His) and lombricine kinase (Lys). To gain a greater understanding of the role of residue-96 in CKs, we replaced this residue in zebra fish Danio rerio cytoplasmic CK with other 19 amino acids, and expressed these constructs in Escherichia coli. All the twenty recombinant enzymes, including the wild-type, were obtained as soluble form, and their activities were determined in the forward direction. Compared with the activity of wild-type, the R96K mutant showed significant activity (8.3% to the wild-type), but 10 mutants (R96Y, A, S, E, H, T, F, C, V and N) showed a weak activity (0.056–1.0%). In the remaining mutants (R96Q, G, M, P, L, W, D and I), the activity was less than 0.05%. Our mutagenesis studies indicated that Arg-96 in Danio CK can be substituted for partially by Lys, but other replacements caused remarkable loss of activity. From careful inspection of the crystal structures (transition state analog complex (TSAC) and open state) of Torpedo cytoplasmic CK, we found that the side chain of R96 forms hydrogen bonds with A339 and D340 only in the TSAC structure. Based on the assumption that CKs consist of four dynamic domains (domains 1–3, and fixed domain), the above hydrogen bonds act to link putative domains 1 and 3 in TSAC structure. We suggest that residue-96 in CK and equivalent residues in other phosphagen kinases, which are structurally similar, have dual roles: (1) one involves in distinguishing guanidino substrates, and (2) the other plays a key role in organizing the hydrogen-bond network around residue-96 which offers an appropriate active center for the high catalytic turnover. The mode of development of the network appears to be unique each phosphagen kinase, reflecting evolution of each enzyme.     

Evidence that amino-acid residues are responsible for substrate synergism of locust arginine kinase

A series of mutants were constructed to investigate the amino-acid residues responsible for the synergism in substrate binding of arginine kinase (AK). AK contains a pair of highly conserved amino acids (Y75 and P272) that form a hydrogen bond. In the locust (Locusta migratoria manilensis) AK, mutants in two highly conserved sites can cause pronounced loss of activity, conformational changes and distinct substrate synergism alteration. The Y75F and Y75D mutants showed strong synergism (Kd/Km=6.2-13.4), while in single mutants, P272G and P272R, and a double mutant, Y75F/P272G, the synergism was almost completely lost (Kd/Km=1.1-1.4). Another double mutant, Y75D/P272R, had characteristics similar to those of the wild-type enzyme. All these results suggest that the amino-acid residues 75 and 272 play an important role in regulating the synergism in substrate binding of AK. Fluorescence spectra showed that all mutants except Y75D/P272R displayed a red shift to different degrees. All the results provided direct evidence that there is a subtle relationship between the synergism in substrate binding and the conformational change.     

Val65 plays an important role in the substrate synergism, structural stability and activity of arginine kinase

Arginine kinase, a member of phosphagen kinase, is a key enzyme in the cellular energy metabolism of invertebrates. A series mutation of conserved amino acid residue V65 was constructed to investigate its role in AK substrate synergism, structural stability and activity. Our study revealed that mutation in this conserved site could cause pronounced loss of activity, conformational changes and distinct substrate synergism alteration. Spectroscopic experiments indicated that these mutations influenced transition from the molten globule intermediate to the native state in folding process. These results provided herein suggest that amino acid residue V65 played a relatively important role in AK substrate synergism, structural stability and activity.     

Replacement of an interdomain residue Val39 of Escherichia coli aspartate aminotransferase affects the catalytic competence without altering the substrate specificity of the enzyme

Three mutant Escherichia coli aspartate aminotransferases in which Val39 was changed to Ala, Leu, and Phe by site-directed mutagenesis were prepared and characterized. Among the three mutant and the wild-type enzymes, the Leu39 enzyme had the lowest Km values for dicarboxylic substrates. The Km values of the Ala39 enzyme for dicarboxylates were essentially the same as those of the wild-type (Val39) enzyme. These two mutant enzymes showed essentially the same kcat values for dicarboxylic substrates as did the wild-type enzyme. On the other hand, incorporation of a bulky side-chain at position 39 (Phe39 enzyme) decreased both the affinity (1/Km) and catalytic ability (kcat) toward dicarboxylic substrates. These results show that the position 39 residue is involved in the modulation of both the binding of dicarboxylic substrates to enzyme and the catalytic ability of the enzyme. Although the replacement of Val39 with other residues altered both the kcat and Km values toward various substrates including dicarboxylic and aromatic amino acids and the corresponding oxo acids, it did not alter the ratio of the kcat/Km value of the enzyme toward a dicarboxylic substrate to that for an aromatic substrate. The affinity for aromatic substrates was not affected by changing the residue at position 39. These data indicate that, although the side chain bulkiness of the residue at position 39 correlates well with the activity toward aromatic substrates in the sequence alignment of several aminotransferases [Seville, M., Vincent M.G., & Hahn, K. (1988) Biochemistry 27, 8344-8349], the residue does not seem to be involved in the recognition of aromatic substrates.     

Multiple arginine residues contribute to the increased efficacy of peptide substrates for the cAMP-dependent protein kinase

Efficient cAMP-dependent protein kinase substrates typically contain an arginine dyad one amino acid removed from the residue which undergoes phosphorylation (ie. Arg-Arg-X-Ser). However, several naturally occurring protein kinase inhibitors and substrates possess additional basic residues that are proximal to the arginine dyad, implying the presence of either an extended or an additional acidic subsite on the enzyme. In this study, we investigated the substrate efficacy of several multiple arginine-bearing peptides. The most efficient substrate studied, Arg-Arg-Leu-Arg-Arg-Ala-Ser-Leu-Gly, exhibits a nearly eleven-fold increase in kcat/Km relative to Leu-Arg-Arg-Ala-Ser-Leu-Gly. The enhanced kcat/Km is primarily a consequence of a reduced Km. These results suggest that a double arginine dyad, separated by a single amino acid, represents the optimal sequence for basic residues on cAMP-dependent protein kinase substrates.     

Amino acid residues 62 and 193 play the key role in regulating the synergism of substrate binding in oyster arginine kinase

The purpose of this study is to clarify the amino acid residues responsible for the synergism in substrate binding of arginine kinase (AK), a key enzyme in invertebrate energy metabolism. AKs contain a pair of highly conserved amino acids (D62 and R193) that form an ion pair, and replacement of these residues can cause a pronounced loss of activity. Interestingly, in the oyster Crassostrea AK, these residues are replaced by an N and a K, respectively. Despite this replacement, the enzyme retains high activity and moderate synergism in substrate binding (Kd/Km=2.3). We replaced the N62 by G or D and the K193 by G or R in Crassostrea AK, and also constructed the double mutants of N62G/K193G and N62D/K193R. All of the mutants retained 50-90% of the wild-type activity. In N62G and N62D mutants, the Kmarg for arginine binding was comparable to that of wild-type enzyme, but the Kdarg was increased 2-5-fold, resulting in a strong synergism (Kd/Km=4.9-11.3). On the other hand, in K193G and K193R mutants, the Kmarg was increased 4-fold, and synergism was lost almost completely (Kd/Km=1.0-1.4). The N62G/K193G double mutant showed similar characteristics to the K193G and K193R mutants. Another double mutant, N62D/K193R, similar to the amino acid pair in the wild-type enzyme, had characteristics similar to those of the wild-type enzyme. These results indicate that the amino acid residues 62 and 193 play the key role in mediating the synergism in substrate binding of oyster arginine kinase.     

Aspartic acid 405 contributes to the substrate specificity of aminopeptidase B

Aminopeptidase B (EC 3.4.11.6, ApB) specifically cleaves in vitro the N-terminal Arg or Lys residue from peptides and synthetic derivatives. Ap B was shown to have a consensus sequence found in the metallopeptidase family. We determined the putative zinc binding residues (His324, His328, and Glu347) and the essential Glu325 residue for the enzyme using site-directed mutagenesis (Fukasawa, K. M., et al. (1999) Biochem. J. 339, 497-502). To identify the residues binding to the amino-terminal basic amino acid of the substrate, rat cDNA encoding ApB was cloned into pGEX-4T-3 so that recombinant protein was expressed as a GST fusion protein. Twelve acidic amino acid residues (Glu or Asp) in ApB were replaced with a Gln or Asn using site-directed mutagenesis. These mutants were isolated to characterize the kinetic parameters of enzyme activity toward Arg-NA and compare them to those of the wild-type ApB. The catalytic efficiency (kcat/Km) of the mutant D405N was 1.7 x 10(4) M(-1) s(-1), markedly decreased compared with that of the wild-type ApB (6.2 x 10(5) M(-1) s(-1)). The replacement of Asp405 with an Asn residue resulted in the change of substrate specificity such that the specific activity of the mutant D405N toward Lys-NA was twice that toward Arg-NA (in the case of wild-type ApB; 0.4). Moreover, when Asp405 was replaced with an Ala residue, the kcat/Km ratio was 1000-fold lower than that of the wild-type ApB for hydrolysis of Arg-NA; in contrast, in the hydrolysis of Tyr-NA, the kcat/Km ratios of the wild-type (1.1 x 10(4) M(-1) s(-1)) and the mutated (8.2 x 10(3) M(-1) s(-1)) enzymes were similar. Furthermore, the replacement of Asp-405 with a Glu residue led to the reduction of the kcat/Km ratio for the hydrolysis of Arg-NA by a factor of 6 and an increase of that for the hydrolysis of Lys-NA. Then the kcat/Km ratio of the D405E mutant for the hydrolysis of Lys-NA was higher than that for the hydrolysis of Arg-NA as opposed to that of wild-type ApB. These data strongly suggest that the Asp 405 residue is involved in substrate binding via an interaction with the P1 amino group of the substrate's side chain.     

Role of Amino Acid Residues on the GS Region of Stichopus Arginine Kinase and Danio Creatine Kinase

Stichopus arginine kinase (AK) is a unique enzyme in that it evolved not from the AK gene but from the creatine kinase (CK) gene: the entire amino acid sequence is homologous with other CKs apart from the guanidine specificity region (GS region), which is identical in structure to that of AK. Ten independent mutations were introduced around the GS region in Stichopus AK. When an insertion or deletion was introduced near the GS region, the Vmax of the mutant enzyme was dramatically decreased to less than 0.1% of the wild type, suggesting that the length of the GS region is crucial for the recognition of the guanidine substrate. Replacement of Phe63 and Leu65 to Gly in the Stichopus enzyme caused a remarkable increase in the Kmarg. This indicates that Phe63 and Leu65 are associated with the arginine substrate-binding affinity. The hydrogen bond formed between the Asp62 and Arg193 residues is thought to play a key role in stabilizing the closed substrate-bound structure of AK. Mutants that eliminated this hydrogen bond had a considerably decreased Vmax, accompanied by a threefold increase in Kmarg. It is noted that the value of the Kmarg of the mutants became very close to the Kdarg value of the wild type. Six independent mutations were introduced in the GS region of Danio M-CK. Almost equivalent values of Kmcr and Kdcr in all of the mutants indicated that a typical synergism was completely lost. The results suggested that the Ile69 to Gly mutant, displaying a high Kmcr and a low Vmax, plays an important role in creatine-binding. This is consistent with the observation that in the structure of Torpedo CK, Ile69 provides a hydrophobic pocket to optimize creatine-binding.     

Catalytic mechanism of scytalone dehydratase: site-directed mutagenisis, kinetic isotope effects, and alternate substrates.

On the basis of the X-ray crystal structure of scytalone dehydratase complexed with an active center inhibitor [Lundqvist, T., Rice, J., Hodge, C. N., Basarab, G. S., Pierce, J. and Lindqvist, Y. (1994) Structure (London) 2, 937-944], eight active-site residues were mutated to examine their roles in the catalytic mechanism. All but one residue (Lys73, a potential base in an anti elimination mechanism) were found to be important to catalysis or substrate binding. Steady-state kinetic parameters for the mutants support the native roles for the residues (Asn131, Asp31, His85, His110, Ser129, Tyr30, and Tyr50) within a syn elimination mechanism. Relative substrate specificities for the two physiological substrates, scytalone and veremelone, versus a Ser129 mutant help assign the orientation of the substrates within the active site. His85Asn was the most damaging mutation to catalysis consistent with its native roles as a general base and a general acid in a syn elimination. The additive effect of Tyr30Phe and Tyr50Phe mutations in the double mutant is consistent with their roles in protonating the substrate's carbonyl through a water molecule. Studies on a synthetic substrate, which has an anomeric carbon atom which can better stabilize a carbocation than the physiological substrate (vermelone), suggest that His110Asn prefers this substrate over vermelone in order to balance the mutation-imposed weakness in promoting the elimination of hydroxide from substrates. All mutant enzymes bound a potent active-site inhibitor in near 1:1 stoichiometry, thereby supporting their active-site integrity. An X-ray crystal structure of the Tyr50Phe mutant indicated that both active-site waters were retained, likely accounting for its residual catalytic activity. Steady-state kinetic parameters with deuterated scytalone gave kinetic isotope effects of 2.7 on kcat and 4.2 on kcat/Km, suggesting that steps after dehydration partially limit kcat. Pre-steady-state measurements of a single-enzyme turnover with scytalone gave a rate that was 6-fold larger than kcat. kcat/Km with scytalone has a pKa of 7.9 similar to the pKa value for the ionization of the substrate's C6 phenolic hydroxyl, whereas kcat was unaffected by pH, indicating that the anionic form of scytalone does not bind well to enzyme. With an alternate substrate having a pKa above 11, kcat/Km had a pKa of 9.3 likely due to the ionization of Tyr50. The non-enzyme-catalyzed rate of dehydration of scytalone was nearly a billion-fold slower than the enzyme-catalyzed rate at pH 7.0 and 25 degrees C. The non-enzyme-catalyzed rate of dehydration of scytalone had a deuterium kinetic isotope effect of 1.2 at pH 7.0 and 25 degrees C, and scytalone incorporated deuterium from D2O in the C2 position about 70-fold more rapidly than the dehydration rate. Thus, scytalone dehydrates through an E1cb mechanism off the enzyme.