Performance of an age series of Alnus-cardamom plantations in the Sikkim Himalaya: nutrient dynamics

Nutrient cycling, nutrient use efficiency and nitrogen fixation in an age series of Alnus-cardamom plantations were studied in the eastern Himalaya. The impact of stand age (5, 10, 15, 20, 30 and 40 years) on the nutrient dynamics of mixtures of N2-fixing (Alnus nepalensis) and non-N2-fixing (large cardamom) plants was assessed. Foliar nutrient concentrations of Alnus decreased with advancing age groups of plantations and showed an inverse relationship with stand age. Annual N fixation increased from the 5-year-old stand (52 kg ha(-1)), peaking in the 15-year-old stand (155 kg ha(-1)) and then decreased with increasing plantation age. Nitrogen and phosphorus uptake was lowest in the 40-year-old stand, and highest in the 15- and 5-year-old stand, respectively. Nutrient storage in understorey cardamom was very high: up to 31 % N and 59 % P of the stand total in the 15-year-old stand. Nutrient use efficiency was higher (with faster turnover times) in younger stands and decreased (with slower turnover times) in older plantations. Nitrogen retranslocation showed a strong positive relationship with stand age, while that of P was inversely related to stand age. Nutrient standing stock, uptake and return were also highest in the 15-year-old stand. Nitrogen and P cycling in Alnus-cardamom plantations was functionally balanced. Nutrient cycling and dynamics indicated that Alnus-cardamom plantations performed sustainably up to 15-20 years. The management practice should be altered to incorporate replantation after this age.     

林龄对红松和落叶松人工林土壤温室气体通量的影响

探讨人工林发育过程中土壤温室气体排放及其机制,可为森林温室气体通量估算提供理论依据.采用室内培养方法研究了黑龙江省帽儿山地区不同林龄(15、30和50年生)红松(Pinus koraiensis)和落叶松(Larix gmelinii)人工林土壤温室气体排放/吸收速率及其调控因素.结果 表明:30年生红松和落叶松人工林...     

Influence of stand age on nutrient and energy release through decomposition in alder-cardamom agroforestry systems of the eastern Himalayas

The influence of stand age (5, 10, 15, 20, 30 and 40 years) on the decomposition of litter fractions, nutrient and energy release of mixtures of N₂-fixing alder (Alnus nepalensis) and non-N₂-fixing large cardamom (Amomum subulatum) systems was compared. Seasonal decomposition rates were distinct with the highest rate in the first 6 months followed by subsequent seasons. The decomposition rate was substantially high in younger stands (10- to 15-years) and declined in the older stands. Heat sink from the stand floor litter increased from 171 × 10⁶ kJ year⁻¹ in 5 years to 299 × 10⁶ kJ year⁻¹ at 15 years and then considerably decreased with advancing age. However, energy and nutrient releases were slow at a high initial lignin-to-initial N ratio and C-to-N ratio, and there was an inverse relationship between the k-value of ash-free-mass and N expressed as a function of the C-to-N ratio. Quantities of nutrient release and energy loss per unit area in 24 months of decomposition were highest in 15 years and subsequently they lowered with advancing age. Nutrient loss indicated approximately uniform absolute and relative rates. Absolute energy consistently decreased by 81–88% in 24 months. Ash-free mass of decomposing litter remaining at different retrieval dates was associated with a narrowing of the C-to-N ratio. The relative loss rate of ash-free mass, nutrients and energy content was strongly related to the C-to-N ratio, litter temperature and litter moisture. The influence of Alnus in the younger stands on nutrient and energy releases were rapid, indicating accelerated nutrient cycling and energy dynamics. The intensity of the processes was highly phenomenal and considerably high in younger stands up to 20 years. Thus, an appropriate management cycle of the Alnus-cardamom system for sustainability is 15–20 years.     

不同林龄桤-柏混交林生态系统的碳储量及其分配

选取代表性的10、15、20和25年生桤(Alnus cremastogyne)柏(Cupressus funebris)混交林及由桤-柏混交林演替而来的30年生纯柏林为研究对象, 探讨了川中丘陵区人工桤-柏混交林生态系统碳储量的变化动态及其分配规律.结果表明：桤-柏混交林的植被碳储量在10～30年间持续增加,30年时达到52.40 t·hm^-2,5个林龄中乔木层碳储量所占比例均在85.59%以上;桤-柏混交林的土壤碳储量(0～40 cm)在10～15年间显著增加(P<0.05),15年时达最大值84.79 t·hm^-2,15～25年间显著下降(P<0.05),25～30年间趋于稳定(P>0.05);桤-柏混交林生态系统碳储量在15年时达最大值118.13 t·hm^-2,15～25年间缓慢下降,25～30年间有所增加;植被碳储量所占比例在10～30年间持续增加,土壤碳储量则相反.与我国其他类型人工林相比,桤-柏混交林的碳储量偏低.     

不同林龄杉木人工林土壤C:N:P化学计量特征及其与土壤理化性质的关系

为了阐明林龄对杉木人工林土壤理化性质及碳氮磷(C∶N∶P)生态化学计量特征的影响,在福建农林大学三明莘口林场选取4个林龄(4, 20, 24, 33a)的杉木人工林为研究对象,测定0—20,20—40,40—60 cm深度土壤的水分-物理性质、pH、总碳(TC)、全氮(TN)、全磷(TP)、全钾(TK),探讨它们随林龄的变化及其与C∶N∶P化学计量比之间的关系,为杉木人工林持续经营管理提供科学依据。结果表明:(1)随着林龄的增加,质量含水量、田间持水量和毛管孔隙度先减小后增加,在20 a达到最小,TN和TP也有相似的变化趋势,但在24 a林分的深层土壤达到最小,TC和TK保持不变;(2)随着林龄的增加,C∶N保持不变,C∶P和N∶P在24 a成熟林达到最大,但只在20—60 cm达到显著差异;(3)TC与多数水分-物理性质及3个生态化学计量比显著相关,质量含水量和孔隙度与C∶N∶P生态化学计量比均显著相关,TP与C∶P和N∶P显著负相关。土壤物理性质与土壤养分循环存在一定关联,有机质与土壤结构及养分平衡的调节有关,研究区杉木林发育过程中土壤腐殖质化进程较缓慢,24 a成熟林杉木的生长受到土壤磷的限制,在杉木速生阶段适当增施磷肥,保证林木的良好生长,促进土壤与植物的良性养分循环。     

秦岭地区华北落叶松人工林地土壤养分和酶活性变化

以秦岭地区不同林龄(5年生、10年生、20年生、30年生和40年生)华北落叶松人工林为研究对象,采用野外调查采样和室内分析相结合的方法,研究了不同林龄华北落叶松人工林地土壤剖面p H值、有机质养分和酶活性的变化。结果表明:土壤p H值随着林龄有降低趋势,随着土层深度的增加有升高趋势。土壤有机质和土壤速效氮、速效磷和速效钾在近熟龄期显著高于幼龄期。土壤中的磷酸酶、脲酶、蔗糖酶和过氧化氢酶活性随着林龄都呈"高—低—高"的趋势,幼龄期的土壤蔗糖酶活性显著高于近熟龄的,而磷酸酶、脲酶和过氧化氢酶活性是近熟龄期的显著高于中幼龄。土壤速效养分和酶活性都随着土层深度的增加有显著的降低。相关分析表明磷酸酶活性与有机质、速效氮、速效磷、速效钾和脲酶活性呈极显著的正相关性(P0.01),脲酶与有机质、速效氮和速效钾呈极显著正相关。蔗糖酶与过氧化氢酶活性显著负相关(P0.05),与p H值有一定的正相关性。秦岭地区华北落叶松人工林进入近熟林之后土壤肥力有一定的恢复,而在中幼龄阶段土壤养分比较缺乏,尤其是氮磷。     

马尾松人工林发育过程中的养分动态

为了解马尾松人工林不同发育时期的养分动态,利用空间代替时间的方法对7、17、31和51年生4个年龄阶段的马尾松人工林养分积累、分配及循环进行了研究.结果表明:马尾松人工林发育过程中,生物量积累与养分积累具有不同步性,从17年生到51年生,生物量积累增长速率是N、P、K、Ca和Mg积累增长速率的3.3、5.4、3.3、3.7和9.8倍;各器官中养分的分配与养分库增长速率有关,随着林龄的增长,树干养分的比重和养分的根冠比增大;单位养分生产的干物质量随林龄增长而提高,51年生时林分的养分循环系数较高,具有低存留、高归还的特点,养分利用效率最高.缩短轮伐期降低了养分高效利用的机会.为维持林地的长期生产力,建议将马尾松人工林轮伐期延长到50年以上,同时降低收获强度.     

辽东山区不同林龄日本落叶松人工林土壤微生物、养分及酶活性

对辽宁省抚顺市大孤家林场11、20、34和47年生日本落叶松人工纯林表层土壤(0~5 cm)微生物群落结构、养分及酶活性进行了研究.结果表明: 土壤微生物、养分及酶活性各项指标基本呈现11或47年林龄较高,而20或34年林龄较低.随林龄增加,土壤地力呈现衰退趋势,土壤微生物群落结构及酶活性变化对地力衰退呈现响应趋势,不同林龄真菌群落结构的差异较细菌显著.典范对应分析(CCA)表明,土壤养分含量及pH值对微生物群落结构的季节变化没有影响,但对在不同林龄间微生物的变化有影响.土壤全氮、有机碳、C/N、速效氮和pH值对不同林龄细菌分布影响较大,土壤速效磷、全钾、交换性镁离子和pH值对真菌分布影响较大.细菌与真菌群落主要的T RFs片段与氮、磷的相关性都较高,而真菌群落与有机碳、钾的相关性高于细菌群落.11和47年林龄微生物群落与土壤养分、酶活性的相关性高于20与34年.因此,土壤微生物(尤其是土壤真菌)可以敏感地指示土壤肥力的变化.     

Biomass, Productivity and Energetics in Himalayan Alder Plantations

Biomass, net primary production and energy fixation in an agesequence of Himalayan alder (Alnus nepalensis D. Don) plantationswere estimated in the Kalimpong forest division of the easternHimalayas. Biomass in the plantations ranged from 106 t ha^–1(7-year stand) to 606 t ha^–1 (56-year stand) demonstratingthe potential of the alder for accumulating large biomass. Netprimary production and net energy fixation rates of the plantationswere reduced by nearly half in the 7-year stand (25 t ha^–1year^–1; 421 x 10⁶ kJ ha^–1 year^–1) comparedwith the 56-year stand (13 t ha^–1 year^–1; 215 x10⁶ kJ ha^–1 year^–1). Compartmental models of energystorage and flow rates were developed for the 7-year and 56-yearstands. The production efficiency, energy conversion efficiencyand energy efficiency in N₂ fixation have inverse relationshipswith plantation age. These efficiencies, when treated with eachother, showed significant exponential functions. Alnus nepalensis D. Don, Himalayan alder, plantation age, biomass, net primary production, energy flow, efficiencies     

Structure and Function of an Age Series of Poplar Plantations in Central Himalaya: I Dry Matter Dynamics

The biomass and net primary productivity (NPP) of 5- to 8-year-oldpoplar (Populus deltoides Marsh, Clone D₁₂₁) plantations growingin the Tarai belt (low-lying plains with high water table adjacentto foothills of central Himalaya) were estimated. Allometricequations for all the above-ground and below-ground componentsof trees and shrubs were developed for each stand. Understorey,forest floor biomass, and litter fall were also estimated fromstands. The biomass of plantation, forest floor litter mass,tree litter fall and net primary productivity (NPP) of treesand shrubs increased with increase in plantation age, whereasherb biomass and NPP significantly (P < 0·01) decreasedwith increasing plantation age. The total plantation biomassincreased from 84·0 in the 5-year-old to 170·0t ha^-1 in the 8-year-old plantation and NPP from 16·8t ha^-1 year^-1 in the 5- and 6-year-old to 21·8 t ha^-1year^-1 in the 8-year-old plantation. The biomass accumulationratio (biomass: net production, BAR) for different tree componentsincreased with the age of plantation increase. The BAR ratioranged from 4·9 in the 5-year-old to 7·7 in the8-year-old plantation.Copyright 1995, 1999 Academic Press Populus deltoides plantations (Clone D₁₂₁), biomass, dry matter turnover, net primary productivity, Tarai belt of Central Himalaya     

不同林龄油松(Pinus tabulaeformis)人工林植物、凋落物与土壤C、N、P化学计量特征

在陕西省北部延安市境内子午岭林区,采用时空互代的方法选取9、23、33、47年生油松(Pinus tabuliformis)人工林为研究对象,比较油松不同器官(叶、枝、干、根)、凋落物及土壤C、N、P含量及其比值的差异,探讨它们随林龄的变化及其相互间的关系,以期为油松人工林的生产、改善和林木生长环境的调节提供参考。结果表明:除根中C含量在林龄间差异不显著外,其它器官C、N、P含量及其比值在林龄间均差异显著且随林龄增加变化趋势不尽相同。9、23、33、47年生油松林C、N、P含量及N∶P比值均在叶中最高;C∶N比值均在干中最高,根中次之;C∶P比值均在干中最高,其它器官大小次序不一。除33年生油松林叶中N∶P比值大于14外,其它各器官各林龄N∶P比值均小于14,且N∶P比值随林龄先增加后减少,故可判断油松在该区域受N限制较为严重,且随林龄的增加受N限制的情况有所缓解。不同林龄土壤和凋落物C、N、P含量及其比值差异显著,且后者均大于前者。土壤与凋落物C、P含量及C∶N、C∶P、N∶P比值随林龄增加变化趋势完全一致,表明土壤与凋落物之间有着密切的关系。叶片与凋落物N、P含量及C∶N、C∶P、N∶P比值之间显著相关,表明凋落物的养分承自植物叶片,二者之间关系紧密;植物和土壤的C、N、P含量之间均不存在显著相关性,说明土壤C、N、P供应量对乔木叶片C、N、P含量影响不大。     

Regenerative and age dynamic of spruce population in pine plantations under conditions typical for spruce development

We have studied the natural regeneration of spruce (Picea abies L.) under a canopy of pine (Pinus sylvestris L.) on loamy soils. Spruce survival and growth depend on the duration of the regeneration period from the creation of the plantation and the local conditions formed as a result of uneven thinning of pine and spruce canopy. The formation of spruce population is mainly determined by trees that regenerated upon intensive thinning of 20- to 40-year-old pine trees. Spruce regeneration may be enhanced by timely cleaning cutting in pine plantations. The first one, done at the age of 15–20 years, favors pine growth and spruce regeneration. At the normal reproduction of spruce population under the canopy of 80-year-old pine plantations, the second spruce layer is formed. Trunk reserve in this layer is 20–25% of the reserves of the first layer. After its formation, the light regime in the forest depends greatly on the space volume occupied by spruce crowns. Their percentage is especially high at the relative height equal to 0.4–0.7 of the mean spruce height in the second layer. Smaller spruce trees may exist for a long time period, but their development is slowed down and they die at the undergrowth stage. When the plantation is 150 years old, the reserves of spruce trees regenerated under the canopy of pine comprise one-third of the total reserves of the plantation. If the growing conditions are favorable for spruce (C₃), the stability and productivity of pine-spruce plantations exceed those of the pure spruce plantations. The reasonability of natural spruce regeneration for the creation of pine-spruce plantations under C₃ conditions should be substantiated with the consideration of their designation, ages of cuttings, and the possibility of plantation creation and sanitary cuttings according to the valid regulations.     

黄土高原半干旱区不同林龄柠条人工林土壤线虫群落特征

为了解柠条人工林对半干旱地区脆弱生态环境的改善作用,在黄土高原柠条种植的重点区域——宁夏南部山区,选取4个林龄(4、14、24和34年生)的柠条人工林作为对象,调查林中土壤线虫群落的组成、结构与多样性特征,并分析它们与土壤理化性质之间的关系,探明黄土高原半干旱区柠条林植被恢复过程中土壤线虫群落的演变特征及其环境影响因素...     

不同林龄杉木人工林土壤硝化和反硝化作用

对不同林龄杉木人工林(5、8、21、27和40年生)土壤硝化与反硝化过程及功能微生物丰度进行研究。结果表明: 土壤净硝化速率随林龄的增加波动变化,8、27年生杉木人工林土壤净硝化速率显著低于5、21和40年生。27年生杉木人工林土壤氨氧化古菌(AOA) amoA基因丰度显著低于40年生,其他林龄AOA amoA基因丰度之间无显著差异。不同林龄杉木人工林的氨氧化细菌(AOB) amoA基因丰度、反硝化功能基因丰度以及反硝化潜势均无显著差异。逐步回归分析表明,土壤氨氧化微生物AOA amoA基因丰度受土壤理化性质的影响不显著,土壤总碳和土壤pH是影响AOB丰度的重要因子。反硝化功能基因narG、nirK及nosZ随土壤pH的增加而增加,编码亚硝酸盐还原酶(NIR)的功能基因(nirK、nirS)受土壤总碳的影响。林龄可通过影响AOA amoA基因丰度影响土壤净硝化速率。林龄直接作用于反硝化潜势,或间接影响土壤微生物生物量碳、土壤pH及反硝化功能基因丰度(narG和nirK),进而影响反硝化潜势。相较于反硝化过程,土壤硝化作用及AOA amoA基因丰度对杉木林分发育更加敏感,可适当延长轮伐期以降低土壤硝化作用造成的氮流失风险。     

Impact of altitudinal gradients on energetics and efficiencies of N<Subscript>2</Subscript>-fixation in alder–cardamom agroforestry systems of the eastern Himalayas

The impact of altitudinal gradients on the performance of alder–cardamom agroforestry systems was analyzed on nitrogenase activity, N₂-fixation efficiency, and stand energetics and efficiencies in the eastern Himalayas. Acetylene reduction (AR activity) measurements showed that nitrogenase activity considerably increased with advancing altitudes from 500 to 800 m to a peak at 900–1,200 m. AR activity was fairly high, between 1,300 and 1,700 m, and sharply decreased in the stands between 1,800 and 2,100 m. AR activity increased in the growing season and peaked in the rainy season. This significantly coincided with cardamom flowering during the onset of growing season to full fruiting stage at peak activity period. AR activity was dependent on soil temperature and moisture and showed a positive relationship. Nodule moisture was also a limiting factor for AR activity and showed a positive correlation. Diurnal changes showed a marked variation with highest AR activity between 8 and 12 h. The performance of commercial cardamom crop is dependent on the associated shade trees. Yield potential significantly coincided with the rate of N₂-fixation both at age chronosequence and altitudinal gradients. The management comprises growing large number of alder until 10 years and thinning, and gap filling of cardamom up to 20 years. Such maintenance caused non-equilibrium conditions that favored systems efficiency and excellent production until 20 years. System efficiency sharply declined at low rates of N₂-fixation, AR activity, root nodule production, and agronomic yield due to the influence of stand age and altitudinal gradients. Agroforestry stands at 900–1,700 m were more energy cost-effective due to the lower energy required for per-kg N-fixation with high N supply (115–155 kg ha⁻¹) confirming functionally efficient than those stands at extreme higher and lower altitudinal ranges. Therefore, replantation of alder and cardamom and phase wise agroforestry rotation after 20 years could be an ecologically and economically sustainable management practice.     

不同林龄杉木人工林的水分利用效率与叶片养分浓度

以亚热带不同林龄(3、8、14、21、46年生)杉木人工林为研究对象,探索不同叶龄(当年生、1年生、2年生和3年生)叶片氮、磷养分状况和水分利用效率的差异及其相互关系.结果表明: 不同叶龄水分利用效率差异显著,总体趋势为当年生>1年生>2年生>3年生,而林龄对水分利用效率影响不显著.叶片N/P为11.4～19.6,其中,幼龄林和老龄林叶片N/P高于速生期林分叶片N/P,氮、磷浓度随叶龄的变化趋势一致,为当年生>1年生>2年生>3年生.水分利用效率随林龄变化不显著,可能是因为叶片光合速率和气孔导度同时随林龄下降.水分利用效率与叶片氮浓度相关不显著,而与叶片磷浓度呈显著正相关,与N/P呈显著负相关,表明在氮沉降增加的背景下,亚热带森林中植物磷含量逐渐成为影响水分利用效率的重要因子.     

黄土高原子午岭地区人工油松林碳氮磷生态化学计量特征

分析人工植被重建背景下,森林植物、枯落物与土壤的碳(C)、氮(N)、磷(P)化学计量特征有助于深入理解森林生态系统养分循环规律和系统稳定机制。以黄土高原子午岭地区的3个林龄(10、25 a和40 a)的人工油松林为对象,通过测定油松林叶片、枯落物和土壤的碳(C)、氮(N)、磷(P)含量,研究人工油松林不同林龄叶片、枯落物和土壤的化学计量学特征。结果表明,不同林龄油松叶片C、N、P含量分别为538.85—560.54 g/kg、9.00—10.47 g/kg和1.04—1.13 g/kg。在3个林龄油松林中,除叶片C含量外,叶片N、P含量存在显著差异(P0.05);枯落物层以及土壤层的C、N、P含量均存在显著差异(P0.05),且枯落物层含量大于土壤层。随着林龄的增加,叶片C∶N比呈现先减小后增大的变化,N∶P和C∶P比呈显著增加趋势,而枯落物层C∶N、C∶P和N∶P比无显著差异。同时,随着林龄的增加,除10—20 cm土层的C∶N比外,土壤的C∶N比在0—10 cm土层和C∶P和N∶P比在0—10和10—20 cm皆呈显著增加趋势。研究区油松林叶片N∶P比平均值为9.13,低于14,表明油松林生长主要受氮的限制。土壤的N含量与叶片和枯落物层的N含量、以及三者间N∶P比呈显著线性相关(P0.05),充分体现了油松林植物、枯落物与土壤之间的互动关系。研究结果可为我国黄土高原脆弱生态区的生态功能恢复与植被重建提供科学依据。     

平地无风条件下蒙古栎阔叶床层的火行为Ⅰ.蔓延速率影响因子与预测模型

以东北林业大学帽儿山实验林场蒙古栎次生林下的蒙古栎凋落叶片为材料,根据研究地区同类可燃物的野外条件,在实验室内构建了不同载量、高度和含水率的可燃物床层,进行100次平地无风条件下的点烧试验.结果表明：平地无风条件下蒙古栎阔叶床层的林火蔓延速率不超过0.5 m·min^-1;可燃物含水率、床层载量和高度对蒙古栎阔叶床层的林火蔓延速率具有显著影响;含水率对林火蔓延速率的影响与可燃物床层高度、载量等无显著关系,而可燃物床层高度对林火蔓延速率的影响与可燃物床层载量有关.可燃物床层压缩比对蒙古栎阔叶床层的林火蔓延速率影响不大.以可燃物含水率、床层载量和高度为预测因子的林火蔓延速率预测模型能解释83%的林火蔓延速率变差,模型的平均绝对误差为0.04 m·min^-1,平均相对误差不超过17%.     

亚高山针叶林人工恢复过程中生物量和材积动态研究

研究了近70年不同林龄亚高山人工云杉林的地上部分生物量及材积变化规律．结果表明,20年林龄前的云杉单株生物量增长缓慢,以小枝和叶生长为主,约占50％;20年以后,单株生物量增长加快,以树干积累为主,大体上超过60％;30年后增长速度相对减慢,自40年开始并保持快速增长．云杉种群生物量表现出类似的增长,但林龄在30至50年间增长速度减慢．群落生物量总体上持续增长,但灌木层生物量在初期快速增长,从20年林龄后逐渐减少;草本层生物量则一直减少,到70年时仅占不足0．2％．在近70年人工恢复过程中,云杉单株材积平均生长量和连年生长量都逐渐增大,越在后期生长越迅速;林分蓄积则在30至50年林龄之间有一段连年生长量相对减小的时期．根据树干解析资料,建立了70年人工云杉林的单株材积与胸径和树高的数学模型．     

太行山东坡不同林龄杏树林碳储量及其分配特征

在生物量调查的基础上,对太行山东坡4、8、12年生和16年生杏树林生态系统碳储量及其分配特征进行了研究。结果表明:杏树各器官碳含量在447.3—488.1 g/kg;树干碳含量随林龄的增长而显著降低(P0.05),不同林龄间树根、树枝和树叶碳含量无显著差异;土壤层(0—100 cm)碳含量随林龄的增长而增大;随土层深度的增加而降低。林龄对杏树林乔木层、土壤层和生态系统碳储量均有显著影响。4、8、12年生和16年生杏树林生态系统碳储量分别为27.810、72.647、82.450 Mg/hm2和102.336Mg/hm2;土壤层碳储量占总碳储量的90.1%—99.6%,且主要集中于0—40 cm。乔木层碳储量分配随着林龄的增长而增加,土壤碳储量分配则减小。结果揭示了土壤层是杏树林生态系统的主要碳库;杏树人工林生态系统在生长过程中能显著地积累有机碳。研究结果可为经济林经营管理及碳汇功能评价提供参考。