Control of the immune reaction: T cells in immunized mice which depress the in vivo DNA synthesis response in the lymph nodes to skin painting with the contact sensitizing agent picryl chloride.

This paper describes the properties of a suppressor population in immune mice which specifically depresses DNA synthesis in vivo in normal mice. Mice were immunized by painting the skin with the contact sensitizing agent picryl chloride—an agent which causes contact sensitivity and antibody production. Five days later the regional lymph nodes or spleens were taken and injected into normal recipients which were then immunized by painting the skin with the same agent. The injection of the immune cells depressed the DNA synthesis response to picryl chloride in the regional lymph nodes when assessed 4 days later by the incorporation of radioactive iododeoxyuridine. The cells in the transferred population responsible for this depression were T cells as shown by the effect of anti-θ serum, their failure to adhere to nylon wool and antiimmunoglobulin columns and their appearance in the fraction of cells lacking receptors for C3(EAC^? cells) on resetting with sheep cells coated with antibody and complement. The cells were large and their activity was destroyed by 2500 R in vitro. Their production was prevented by treatment with cyclophosphamide before exposure to antigen but was unaffected by adult thymectomy. In these two aspects they differed from the T cells which suppress contact sensitivity which occur in mice injected with picryl sulphonic acid—an agent which causes unresponsiveness.     

Contact sensitivity to picryl chloride: the occurrence of B suppressor cells in the lymph nodes and spleen of immunized mice.

Mice were immunized for contact sensitivity and antibody production by painting the skin with picryl chloride. Lymph node and spleen cells taken 4 days later transferred contact sensitivity. However, cells taken at 7–8 days failed to transfer but were able to block the transfer by 4 day immune cells. These suppressor cells occurred in the regional lymph nodes, spleen and thymus. The suppressor activity of lymph node and spleen cells was due to B cells as shown by the effect of anti-θ serum and complement, nylon wool filtration and separation of EAC positive and negative cells by centrifugation on a discontinuous gradient. The transfer of fractions rich or poor in macrophages showed that the suppressor cell in the transferred population was not a macrophage. Separation using EAC rosettes suggested that B cells were responsible for the suppressor activity in the thymus.T cells isolated from the lymph nodes and spleen 7–8 days after immunization transferred contact sensitivity although the initial population was inactive. This indicates that passive transfer cells are present in the regional lymph nodes and spleen at later times after immunization but cannot be demonstrated because of the presence of suppressor B cells. However, no passive transfer cells were found in the thymus. The production of B suppressor cells required little or no T cell help and following immunization the spleens of reconstituted (B) mice were at least as active as control cells in causing suppression. There are several different suppressor cells which act in the picryl system and the B suppressor cells in immunized mice described here are distinct from the T suppressor cells in mice injected with picryl sulphonic acid.     

Suppressor cells for the afferent phase of contact sensitivity to picryl chloride: inhibition of DNA synthesis induced by T cells from mice injected with picryl sulfonic acid.

Previous reports have shown that picryl sulfonic acid (PSA) induces suppressor T cells that inhibit the effector phase of contact sensitivity, whereeas its DNP counterpart, dinitrobenzenesulfonate (DNBS) induces cells that inhibit the afferent phase of sensitization. Accordingly, cells from mice injected with DNBS, but not PSA, could be shown to inhibit the DNA synthesis in the lymph nodes that occurs during sensitization. It is now shown that PSA does induce T cells that suppress DNA synthesis but this can only be detected with enriched T cells or by using a regimen of PSA injection different frm previously used to induce suppressor cells for the effector phase. The T cells did not affect responses to oxazolone or dinitrofluorobenzene (DNFB) and were distinguishable from suppressors of the efferent phase in that they could be produced in adult thymectomized but not cyclophosphamide-treated mice. T cells from mice injected with DNBS that inhibited DNA synthesis to DNFB had the same properties.     

Tolerance and contact sensitivity to DNFB in mice. VI. Inhibition of afferent sensitivity by suppressor T cells in adoptive tolerance.

Tolerance in contact sensitivity to DNFB can be adoptively transferred to normal mice with lymph node cells from tolerant donors. This tolerance is antigen specific and is mediated by T cells, i.e., "suppressor" T cells. Experiments were carried out to investigate the mechanism(s) by which the suppressor T cells induce tolerance to DNFB contact sensitivity. The suppressor cells were effective only if they were present during the early stages of the afferent limb of sensitization. As measured by DNA synthesis, cell proliferation in the draining lymph nodes of recipients of suppressor cells was found to be significantly less than in control animals indicating that the suppressor cells acted, at least in part, by limiting or inhibiting DNFB-induced cell proliferation. This inhibition was shown to be antigen specific since the DNFB suppressor cells did not inhibit cell proliferation induced by oxazolone, an unrelated contact sensitizer. The ability to DNFB tolerant cells to block afferent sensitization pathways differs from the mechanism of tolerance to picryl chloride, reported by others, where efferent pathways are blocked.     

The inhibitory effect of histamine on lymphoid tissue proliferation in mice

Histamine, injected subcutaneously (10 mg/kg), inhibited the DNA synthesis response to a contact-sensitizing agent (picryl chloride) and also had an inhibitory effect on DNA synthesis in untreated mice. The synthesis was measured by 5-[125I]iodo-2'-deoxyuridine incorporation in spleen, lung, liver, and peripheral lymph nodes and the inhibitory effect was marked and consistent in spleen in both sensitized and nonsensitized animals, but was variable in the other tissues. Since histamine is believed to activate suppressor cells, it is suggested that the inhibition of DNA synthesis in picryl chloride-treated mice is due to the activation of those suppressor cells which limit the specific DNA synthesis in response to the contact-sensitizing agent. The inhibition of DNA synthesis in untreated mice could be due to the activation of suppressor cells that control the ongoing immune response to environmental antigens.     

Infection of mice with Newcastle disease virus inhibits the T suppressor afferent cell circuit which regulates contact sensitivity to picryl chloride

The interaction between Newcastle disease virus (NDV) and the suppressor cell circuit which regulates the induction phase of contact sensitivity reaction to picryl chloride (Pcl) was investigated. NDV infection impairs the activity of the T suppressor afferent cells (Ts-aff) which inhibit DNA synthesis in the draining lymph nodes of mice specifically sensitized with Pcl and the development of contact sensitivity. The inhibitory effect of NDV was evident when the virus was administered up to 2 days before or at the same time as the injection of picrylsulfonic acid; this effect required infectious virus, as NDV inactivated by ultraviolet irradiation failed to inhibit Ts-aff activity. Taken together with the previous finding that the T suppressor efferent cell is unaffected by NDV, the present results support the view that contact sensitivity reaction to picryl chloride is regulated by two distinct T-suppressor-cell circuits.     

Nonspecific inhibitor of DNA synthesis elaborated by T acceptor cells. I. Specific hapten- and I-J-driven liberation of an inhibitor of cell proliferation by Lyt-1-2+ cyclophosphamide-sensitive T acceptor cells armed with a product of Lyt-1+2+-specific suppressor cells

Lyt-1+2+ hapten-specific T suppressor cells (Ts) from mice injected and then painted with picryl or oxazolone derivatives produce hapten-specific T suppressor factors (TsF) in vitro. Stimulation by painting with contact sensitizer (which need not be specific) gives rise to Lyt-1-2+, I-J+, cyclophosphamide-sensitive T acceptor cells (Tacc). When the Tacc population is armed with TsF and then is exposed to specific antigen in the context of I-J-controlled determinants (antigen-presenting, haptenized spleen cells and Ts sharing the same I-J subregion), a nonspecific inhibitor of DNA synthesis (nsINH) appears in the supernatant. This inhibitor suppresses the primary DNA synthetic response to concanavalin A, lipopolysaccharide, and alloantigens in both syngeneic and allogeneic lymphocytes. The nsINH is only effective when added to lymphocyte cultures less than 8 hr after the stimulation with concanavalin A. The nsINH, however, affects neither primary nor secondary cytotoxicity in vitro. These data suggest the mouse immune system is capable of selective regulation of the response to specific antigen by the production of nonspecific soluble suppressor factor(s).     

Enterically induced immunologic tolerance. I. Induction of suppressor T lymphoyctes by intragastric administration of soluble proteins.

Specific immune unresponsiveness was induced in inbred mice (BDF1) by the administration of soluble ovalbumin (OVA) by gastric intubation. Anti-hapten (DNP) responses likewise were specifically diminished when animals were fed autologous carrier (OVA or keyhole limpet hemocyanin). Adoptive transfer of spleen cells demonstrated that the tolerant state could be maintained in irradiated recipient mice, and specific anergy could be transferred to normal recipient animals. Adoptive suppression was mediated by T lymphocytes, as demonstrated by nylon wool fractionation and susceptibility of the cells to anti-Thy 1.2 and complement. Transferred B cells had neither suppressive nor augmentative effects. Enteric administration of OVA also specifically diminished antigen-induced DNA synthesis of primed lymph node T cells, although suppressor cells were not identified in the lymph nodes per se.     

The role of dendritic cells in the initiation of immune responses to contact sensitizers. II. Studies in nude mice

Twenty-four hours after skin painting nude mice with picryl chloride, there was an increase in the number of dendritic cells (DC) isolated from the draining lymph nodes. This increased inflow or retention of DC in lymph nodes following skin painting is therefore unlikely to depend on interaction of DC with T cells. The DC obtained initiated primary proliferative responses in vitro in lymph node cells from congenic euthymic mice. Contact sensitivity developed in congenic mice when they received footpad injections of 60,000 DC from the lymph nodes of nude mice skin sensitized 1 day previously with picryl chloride or oxazolone. The initiation of delayed hypersensitivity was therefore independent of T-cell contamination within the donor DC.     

Pseudomonas aeruginosa infection: Activation of B suppressor cells which affect cell cooperation in the induction phase of contact sensitivity to oxazolone in mice

Pseudomonas aeruginosa depresses contact sensitivity to oxazolone in mice by activating B suppressor cells within the lymph nodes that drain the site of sensitization. These suppressor cells affect the induction phase of the immune response by blocking the cooperation between “stimulator” macrophages and “initiator” T cells on one hand and “recruited” T cells on the other.     

Suppressor cells in contact sensitivity. Effect on T cells helping antibody production to picryl chloride.

T cells from mice injected with picryl sulfonic acid have previously been shown to suppress the effector and possibly other phases of contact hypersensitivity reactions to picryl chloride. In this report we examine their effect on T cells helping the early direct anti-TNP plaque-forming cell response of mice painted with picryl chloride. They did not directly inhibit the activity of the helper cells but did inhibit the ability of mice to generate helper cells after skin painting. The suppressor cells were T cells as tested by passage through nylon wool columns and sensitivity to anti-θ serum. Viable syngeneic cells were required for suppression and their effect was specific. The suppressor cells could not be generated in adult thymectomized mice but could be produced in mice treated with high doses (200 mg/kg) of cyclophosphamide. These properties are distinct from those of suppressor T cells produced following immunization with picryl chloride but are the same as those of other suppressor cells induced by PSA which inhibit contact hypersensitivity.     

Role of the fourth complement component (C4) in the regulation of contact sensitivity. III. In vivo effect of purified C4

Lymph node cells obtained from CBA/J mice 4 days after painting with contact sensitizing agents such as picryl chloride or oxazolone ("4-day" cells), induce contact sensitivity into naive recipient mice by membrane-associated immunocomplexes. This immunizing capacity is abolished after incubation of the cells in serum from mice with high C4 levels (C4H), but not in serum from mice with low C4 levels (C4L), and the inhibitory activity of C4H serum is due to the activation of the early components of the classical complement pathway. The presence of 4-day cells depends on C4 levels: in fact, C4H mice lack these cells because they activate their own complement in vivo, whereas C4L mice fail to activate complement in vivo and possess 4-day cells. CBA/J (C4L) mice injected with purified C4 preparations from the C4H mice BALB/c, lose 4-day cells and show a short-term contact-sensitivity reaction, exactly as BALB/c mice, thus indicating that C4 levels play a role in the control of contact-sensitivity reaction to simple chemical haptens.     

The role of dendritic cells in the initiation of immune responses to contact sensitizers. I. In vivo exposure to antigen

Twenty-four hours after skin painting mice with picryl chloride (PIC) there was a four- to fivefold increase in the numbers of dendritic cells (DC) isolated from the lymph nodes. These DC initiated primary proliferative and cytotoxic responses when added to cultures of normal syngeneic lymph node cells. The proliferative response was enhanced when the donors of the responding lymph node cells were sensitized with the same antigen. Contact sensitivity developed in syngeneic mice injected into the footpads with 30,000-50,000 DC from lymph nodes of mice painted with picryl chloride 1 day previously. Thus, 1 day after skin painting mice, there were dendritic cells in the draining lymph nodes which were able both to initiate primary stimulation of lymphocytes in vitro and to sensitize recipient mice to give specific delayed hypersensitivity reactions.     

Role of the fourth complement component (C4) in the regulation of contact sensitivity. I. Analysis in mice with high and low C4 levels

Lymph node cells collected from CBA/J mice 4 days after painting the skin with picryl chloride are able to immunize naive recipients by hapten-IgM immuno complexes. These cells ("4-day" cells) activate the early components of the classical pathway of complement from mice of the H-2 Sd haplotype (high-C4), but fail to activate the classical pathway of complement from mice of the H-2 Sk haplotype (low-C4). Incubation of "4-day" cells in complement from mice with high-C4 levels abolishes the induction of contact sensitivity, probably as a consequence of the solubilization of membrane-bound immuno complexes caused by complement activation. The presence of "4-day" cells is determined by the levels of C4. In fact, using strains of mice which differ only at the S region of the H-2 complex, we found that mice of the H-2 Sd (and perhaps H-2 Sb) haplotype (high-C4 levels) lack "4-day" cells in their lymph nodes and this is due to the activation of the early components of the classical complement pathway which occurs in vivo in these mice during sensitization with picryl chloride. The finding that contact sensitivity reaction to picryl chloride in H-2 Sk mice lasts about 21 days, whereas H-2 Sd mice show a contact sensitivity reaction until 7 days after sensitization, strongly suggests that the S region, and in particular C4 levels, controls the persistence of "4-day" immunogenic cells, and so play a role in the duration of the contact sensitivity reaction to picryl chloride in the mouse.     

Studies on the role of antigen-presenting cells in the systemic suppression of contact hypersensitivity by UVB radiation

Exposure of mice to UVB radiation produces a highly selective, systemic immunosuppression associated with the appearance of suppressor T lymphocytes. Suppression of delayed hypersensitivity to hapten-coupled syngeneic cells has been shown to result from an altered distribution of antigen-presenting cells. The purpose of this study was to determine whether an alteration in the activity of antigen-presenting cells could account for the systemic suppression of contact hypersensitivity (CHS) by UVB radiation. Fluorescein isothiocyanate (FITC) was used for contact sensitization because it uses different antigen-presenting cells than does oxazolone to induce CHS. Our previous studies demonstrated that CHS to oxazolone was suppressed by UVB irradiation. In these studies, we show that exposure of mice to UVB radiation before epicutaneous application of FITC onto unirradiated skin markedly decreased the CHS response to FITC painted on unexposed ears. Cyclophosphamide-sensitive suppressor T cells were detectable in the spleens of mice exhibiting decreased CHS. The antigen-presenting activity of cells in lymph nodes draining the site of epicutaneous sensitization (DLN cells) was assessed by injecting them into the hind footpads of syngeneic recipients and measuring the CHS response to FITC 6 days later. Viable DLN cells from UVB-irradiated, FITC-sensitized mice were equal to those from unirradiated, FITC-sensitized mice in their ability to induce CHS in normal recipients. No sensitization resulted when killed DLN cells were used for immunization, indicating that sensitization was not caused by reprocessing of antigen by host cells. We conclude that impairment of the CHS reaction in UVB-irradiated mice does not appear to be blocked at an initial step of antigen uptake, processing, or presentation, but must be impaired at some other step in the immunologic pathway.     

Delayed hypersensitivity in mast-cell-deficient mice

The ability of mast cell-deficient Wf/Wf and W/Wv mice to produced delayed hypersensitivity responses was examined. The W/Wv mice did not have detectable mast cells and could not produce IgE-mediated passive cutaneous anaphylaxis. Mice of both genotypes produced large delayed hypersensitivity responses to the contact sensitizers oxazolone and picryl chloride. The responses were indistinguishable from responses of control mice when challenged with optimal or suboptimal doses of antigen. Delayed hypersensitivity could be transferred into Wf/Wf mice by an antigen-specific T cell line, and the proliferative responses in the lymph nodes of these mice after, painting with sensitizer, were normal.     

Control of suppressor cell activity: autoanti-idiotype B cells produced by painting with picryl chloride inhibit the T-suppressor cell which blocks the efferent stage of contact sensitivity

This paper describes a B “suppressor of suppressor” cell which blocks the production or action of the T-suppressor cell, Ts-eff (cs), which acts at the efferent stage of the contact sensitivity reaction. Ts-eff (cs) occur in mice 7 days after injecting picrylsulfonic acid (PSA) and are assayed by their ability to block the passive transfer of contact sensitivity in a 24-hr experiment. These Ts-eff (cs) cannot be demonstrated in mice painted with picryl chloride and injected with PSA 8 days later. In fact, 8 days after painting mice contain B cells which prevent the appearance of Ts-eff (cs) following the injection of PSA. Moreover, the serum of mice 12 days after painting contains antibody which inactivates Ts-eff (cs). This antibody is anti-idiotypic as shown by its absorption to and elution from insolubilized mouse anti-picryl antibody and the lack of effect of absorption with insolubilized picryl groups. The antibody belongs to the IgG2a class and requires an intact Fc moiety for its action.     

T suppressor factor activity is due to two separate molecules. The Lyt-1(-)2+I-J+ cells of mice primed with antigen make an antigen binding molecule which is only active when complemented by cofactor made by Lyt-1+2(-)I-J+ cells

Mice primed with picrylsulfonic acid (PSA) and then painted on the skin with picryl chloride produce antigen-specific T suppressor factor (TsF). In contrast unpainted primed mice fail to produce active TsF. This is not due to the absence of the antigen binding part of TsF but to the absence of a cofactor. This cofactor is (a) antigen nonspecific and occurs in potassium chloride extract of normal spleen cells. It also occurs in the 24 hr supernatant of normal cells modified by haptenisation with picryl or the unrelated NP antigen (4-hydroxy-3-nitrophenylacetyl), and in preparations of conventional TsF (PSA/PCl) from painted PSA-primed mice; (b) bears I-J determinants; and (c) is produced by Lyt-1+2(-)I-J+ cells. The antigen binding molecule occurs alone in the supernatant of PSA-primed mice. It lacks I-J determinants and has a molecular weight around 35,000 and 75,000. It is produced by Lyt-1(-)2+I-J+ cells and is only active when complemented by cofactor. However, the complementation is genetically restricted and the restriction maps to the I-J subregion of the MHC.     

A splenic requirement for the generation of suppressor T cells.

Tolerance to contact sensitization with DNFB may be induced by DNBSO3. This specific unresponsiveness may occur via one or both of two mechanisms--production of suppressor T cells or clone inhibition. We investigated the role of the spleen in this unresponsiveness. Splenectomized mice may be tolerized by i.v. injection of DNBSO3, but they are incapable of serving as donors of lymph node cells for transfer of tolerance to normal recipients. Kinetic studies indicated that the spleen must be present at least three days after tolerization in order to permit development of a significant number of suppressor cells in the peripheral lymph nodes. We interpret these results to indicate that 1) clone inhibition does not require the spleen, 2) the generation of suppressor T cells is dependent on the presence of the spleen, and 3) it is likely that tolerogens in this system induce suppressor cells in the spleen and some of these cells or their products leave the spleen to reach the peripheral lymph nodes.     

In vitro immune blastogenesis during contact sensitivity in tumor-bearing mice: I. Description of progressive impairment and demonstration of splenic suppressor cells

T-cell responsiveness was measured by the DNA response of disassociated spleen and lymph node cells when exposed to antigen in vitro. Sensitized splenic lymphocytes from fibrosarcoma-bearing mice immunized with 2,4-dinitro-1,5-difluorobenzene (DN2FB) demonstrated a progressive decrease in T-cell responsiveness to the haptenprotein conjugate DNP-BSA. Hyporesponsiveness to the dinitrophenylated-protein conjugate appeared in the spleens but not lymph nodes of tumorous animals. Normal host lymph node cells (LNC) responded strongly 24 to 48 h after sensitization and subsequently declined with a corresponding increase in responsiveness in the spleen. Tumor-bearing hosts (TBH) had similar LNC kinetics during immunization, however, spleen cells were significantly suppressed when compared to normal BALB/c mice sensitization kinetics. Spleen cells from TBH were also capable of suppressing the in vitro response of normal primed lymphocytes to DNP-BSA when admixed. Results from these experiments suggest that in vitro measurement of contact sensitivity was affected by suppressor cells/products existing in the spleens but not lymph nodes of fibrosarcoma-bearing mice.