Mechanisms of intermolecular homologous recombination in plants as studied with single- and double-stranded DNA molecules.

To elucidate the mechanism for intermolecular homologous recombination in plants we cotransformed Nicotiana tabacum cv Petit Havana SR1 protoplasts with constructs carrying different defective derivatives of the NPTII gene. The resulting kanamycin resistant clones were screened for possible recombination products by PCR, which proved to be a valuable technique for this analysis. Our results show that the double-stranded circular DNA molecules used in this study recombine predominantly via a pathway consistent with the single-strand annealing (SSA) model as proposed for extrachromosomal recombination in mammalian cells. In the remaining cases recombination occurred via a single reciprocal recombination, gene conversion and possibly double reciprocal recombination. Since single-stranded DNA is considered to be an important intermediate in homologous recombination we also established the recombination ability of single-stranded DNA in intermolecular recombination. We found that single-stranded DNA enters in recombination processes more efficiently than the corresponding double-stranded DNA. This was also reflected in the recombination mechanisms that generated the functional NPTII gene. Recombination between a single-stranded DNA and the complementing DNA duplex occurred at similar rates via a single reciprocal recombination and the SSA pathway.     

Genetic transformation of Saccharomyces cerevisiae with single-stranded circular DNA vectors

We asked if single-stranded vector DNA molecules could be used to reintroduce cloned DNA sequences into a eukaryotic cell and cause genetic transformation typical of that observed using double-stranded DNA vectors. DNA was presented to Saccharomyces cerevisiae following a standard transformation protocol, genetic transformants were isolated, and the physical state of the transforming DNA sequence was determined. We found that single-stranded DNA molecules transformed yeast cells 10- to 30-fold more efficiently than double-stranded molecules of identical sequence. More cells were competent for transformation by the single-stranded molecules. Single-stranded circular (ssc) DNA molecules carrying the yeast 2 μ plasmid-replicator sequence were converted to autonomously replicating double-stranded circular (dsc) molecules, suggesting their efficient utilization as templates for DNA synthesis in the cell. Single-stranded DNA molecules carrying 2 μ plasmid non-replicator sequences recombined with the endogenous multicopy 2 μ plasmid DNA. This recombination yielded either the simple molecular adduct expected from homologous recombination (40% of the transformants examined) or aberrant recombination products carrying incomplete transforming DNA sequences, endogenous 2 μ plasmid DNA sequences, or both (60% of the transformants examined). These aberrant recombination products suggest the frequent use of a recombination pathway that trims one or both of the substrate DNA molecules. Similar aberrant recombination products were detected in 30% of the transformants in cotransformation experiments employing single-stranded and double-stranded DNA molecules, one carrying the 2 μ plasmid replicator sequence and the other the selectable genetic marker. We conclude that single-stranded DNA molecules are useful vectors for the genetic transformation of a eukaryotic cell. They offer the advantage of high transformation efficiency, and yield the same intracellular DNA species obtained upon transformation with double-stranded DNA molecules. In addition, single-stranded DNA molecules can participate in a recombination pathway that trims one or both DNA recombination substrates, a pathway not detected, at least at the same frequency, when transforming with double-stranded DNA molecules     

Vital roles of the second DNA-binding site of Rad52 protein in yeast homologous recombination

RecA/Rad51 proteins are essential in homologous DNA recombination and catalyze the ATP-dependent formation of D-loops from a single-stranded DNA and an internal homologous sequence in a double-stranded DNA. RecA and Rad51 require a "recombination mediator" to overcome the interference imposed by the prior binding of single-stranded binding protein/replication protein A to the single-stranded DNA. Rad52 is the prototype of recombination mediators, and the human Rad52 protein has two distinct DNA-binding sites: the first site binds to single-stranded DNA, and the second site binds to either double- or single-stranded DNA. We previously showed that yeast Rad52 extensively stimulates Rad51-catalyzed D-loop formation even in the absence of replication protein A, by forming a 2:1 stoichiometric complex with Rad51. However, the precise roles of Rad52 and Rad51 within the complex are unknown. In the present study, we constructed yeast Rad52 mutants in which the amino acid residues corresponding to the second DNA-binding site of the human Rad52 protein were replaced with either alanine or aspartic acid. We found that the second DNA-binding site is important for the yeast Rad52 function in vivo. Rad51-Rad52 complexes consisting of these Rad52 mutants were defective in promoting the formation of D-loops, and the ability of the complex to associate with double-stranded DNA was specifically impaired. Our studies suggest that Rad52 within the complex associates with double-stranded DNA to assist Rad51-mediated homologous pairing.     

Characterization of the DNA binding activity of stable RecA-DNA complexes. Interaction between the two DNA binding sites within RecA helical filaments

The DNA-binding, annealing and recombinational activities of purified RecA-DNA complexes stabilized by ATP gamma S (a slowly hydrolysable analog of ATP) are described. Electrophoretic analysis, DNase protection experiments and observations by electron microscopy suggest that saturated RecA complexes formed with single- or double-stranded DNA are able to accommodate an additional single strand of DNA with a stoichiometry of about one nucleotide of added single-stranded DNA per nucleotide or base-pair, respectively, of DNA resident in the complex. This strand uptake is independent of complementarity or homology between the added and resident DNA molecules. In the complex, the incoming and resident single-stranded DNA molecules are in close proximity as the two strands can anneal in case of their complementarity. Stable RecA complexes formed with single-stranded DNA bind double-stranded DNA efficiently when the added DNA is homologous to the complexed strand and then initiate a strand exchange reaction between the partner DNA molecules. Electron microscopy of the RecA-single-stranded DNA complexes associated with homologous double-stranded DNA suggests that a portion of duplex DNA is taken into the complex and placed in register with the resident single strand. Our experiments indicate that both DNA binding sites within RecA helical filaments can be occupied by either single- or double-stranded DNA. Presumably, the same first DNA binding site is used by RecA during its polymerization on single- or double-stranded DNA and the second DNA binding site becomes available for subsequent interaction of the protein-saturated complexes with naked DNA. The way by which additional DNA is taken into RecA-DNA complexes shows co-operative character and this helps to explain how topological problems are avoided during RecA-mediated homologous recombination.     

Efficient transfer of base changes from a vector to the rice genome by homologous recombination: involvement of heteroduplex formation and mismatch correction

Gene targeting refers to the alteration of a specific DNA sequence in an endogenous gene at its original locus in the genome by homologous recombination. Through a gene-targeting procedure with positive–negative selection, we previously reported the generation of fertile transgenic rice plants with a positive marker inserted into the Adh2 gene by using an Agrobacterium-mediated transformation vector containing the positive marker flanked by two 6-kb homologous segments for recombination. We describe here that base changes within the homologous segments in the vector could be efficiently transferred into the corresponding genomic sequences of rice recombinants. Interestingly, a few sequences from the host genome were flanked by the changed sequences derived from the vector in most of the recombinants. Because a single-stranded T-DNA molecule in Agrobacterium-mediated transformation is imported into the plant nucleus and becomes double-stranded, both single-stranded and double-stranded T-DNA intermediates can serve in gene-targeting processes. Several alternative models, including the occurrence of the mismatch correction of heteroduplex molecules formed between the genomic DNA and either a single-stranded or double-stranded T-DNA intermediate, are compared to explain the observation, and implications for the modification of endogenous genes for functional genomic analysis by gene targeting are discussed.     

Primary products of break-induced recombination by Escherichia coli RecE pathway.

Alternative models for break-induced recombination predict different distributions of primary products. The double-stranded break-repair model predicts a noncrossover product and equimolar amounts of two crossover products. The one-end pairing model predicts two crossover products, but not necessarily in equimolar amounts, and the single-stranded annealing model predicts deletion of the fragment between the pairing sequences. Depending on the structure of the recombining substrate(s) and the nature of the resectioning step that precedes strand annealing, the single-stranded annealing mechanism would yield only one or both crossover products. We tested these predictions for the RecE recombination pathway of Escherichia coli. Nonreplicating intramolecular recombination substrates with a double-stranded break (DSB) within one copy of a direct repeat were released from chimera lambda phage by in vivo restriction, and the distribution of primary circular recombination products was determined. Noncrossover products were barely detectable, and the molar ratio of the two crossover products was proportional to the length ratio of the homologous ends flanking the DSB. These results suggest an independent pairing of each end with the intact homolog and argue against the double-stranded break-repair model. However, the results do not distinguish alternative pairing mechanisms (strand invasion and strand annealing). The kinetics of heteroduplex formation and heteroduplex strand polarity were investigated. Immediately following the DSB induction, heteroduplex formation was done by pairing the strands ending 3' at the break. A slow accumulation of the complementary heteroduplex made by the pairing of the strands ending 5' at the break (5' heteroduplexes) was observed at a larger stage. The observed bias in heteroduplex strand polarity depended on DSB induction at a specific site. The 5' heteroduplexes may have been generated by reciprocal strand exchange, pairing that is not strand specific, or strand-specific pairing induced at random breaks.     

Homologous pairing in genetic recombination: recA protein makes joint molecules of gapped circular DNA and closed circular DNA

The recA protein, which is essential for genetic recombination in E. coli, promotes the homologous pairing of double-stranded DNA and linear single-stranded DNA, thereby forming a three-stranded joint molecule called a D loop. Single-stranded DNA stimulates recA protein to unwind double-stranded DNA. By a presumably related mechanism, recA protein promoted the homologous pairing of two circular double-stranded molecules when one of them had a gap in one strand. The two molecules were joined at homologous sites by noncovalent bonds. The covalently closed molecule remained intact and was not topologically linked to the intact circular strand of the gapped substrate. Electron microscopy showed that molecules were usually linked at two or more nearby points. The junctions in most molecules were shorter than 300 nucleotides. Sometimes the region between two extreme points was separated into two arms, producing an ellipsoidal loop (called an eye loop). The junctions in these biparental joint molecules were frequently remote from the site of the gap. We infer that a free end of the interrupted strand crossed over to form a structure like a D loop which moved away from the gap by branch migration.     

Intermolecular homologous recombination in plants.

To study DNA topological requirements for homologous recombination in plants, we have constructed pairs of plasmids that contain nonoverlapping deletions in the neomycin phosphotransferase gene [APH(3')II], which, when intact, confers kanamycin resistance to plant cells. Protoplasts isolated from Nicotiana tabacum were cotransformed with complementary pairs of plasmids containing these truncated gene constructs. Homologous recombination or gene conversion within the homologous sequences (6 to 405 base pairs) of the protein-coding region of the truncated genes led to the restoration of the functional APH(3')II gene, rendering these cells resistant to kanamycin. Circular plasmid DNAs recombined very inefficiently, independent of the length of the homologous region. A double-strand break in one molecule only slightly increased the recombination frequency. The most favorable substrates for recombination were linear molecules. In this case, the recombination frequency was positively correlated with the length of the homologous regions. The recombination frequency of plasmids linearized at sites proximal to the deletion-homology junction was significantly higher than when linearization was distal to the homologous region. Vector homology within cotransformed plasmid sequences also increased the recombination frequency.     

Homologous recombination involving small single-stranded oligonucleotides in human cells

Gene modification by homologous recombination is one of the techniques that may eventually be used in gene replacement therapy. We tested whether small, synthetic single-stranded oligodeoxynucleotides are capable of participating in homologous recombination in human cells. A plasmid carrying a mutant neomycin phosphotransferase (neo) gene was cotransfected with a 40-nucleotide single-stranded oligomer that contained the wild-type neo gene sequence into human cells. Cells expressing neo were selected in the antibiotic G418. These cells contained wild-type molecules, which resulted from recombination between the two molecules. The results indicate that this approach may be useful in correcting or introducing single point mutations into the genomes of mammalian cells.     

A molecular throttle: the recombination hotspot chi controls DNA translocation by the RecBCD helicase

RecBCD enzyme is a heterotrimeric helicase/nuclease that initiates homologous recombination at double-stranded DNA breaks. Several of its activities are regulated by the DNA sequence chi (5'-GCTGGTGG-3'), which is recognized in cis by the translocating enzyme. When RecBCD enzyme encounters chi, the intensity and polarity of its nuclease activity are changed, and the enzyme gains the ability to load RecA protein onto the chi-containing, unwound single-stranded DNA. Here, we show that interaction with chi also affects translocation by RecBCD enzyme. By observing translocation of individual enzymes along single molecules of DNA, we could see RecBCD enzyme pause precisely at chi. Furthermore, and more unexpectedly, after pausing at chi, the enzyme continues translocating but at approximately one-half the initial rate. We propose that interaction with chi results in an enzyme in which one of the two motor subunits, likely the RecD motor, is uncoupled from the holoenzyme to produce the slower translocase.     

Human Rad51 filaments on double- and single-stranded DNA: correlating regular and irregular forms with recombination function

Recombinase proteins assembled into helical filaments on DNA are believed to be the catalytic core of homologous recombination. The assembly, disassembly and dynamic rearrangements of this structure must drive the DNA strand exchange reactions of homologous recombination. The sensitivity of eukaryotic recombinase activity to reaction conditions in vitro suggests that the status of bound nucleotide cofactors is important for function and possibly for filament structure. We analyzed nucleoprotein filaments formed by the human recombinase Rad51 in a variety of conditions on double-stranded and single-stranded DNA by scanning force microscopy. Regular filaments with extended double-stranded DNA correlated with active in vitro recombination, possibly due to stabilizing the DNA products of these assays. Though filaments formed readily on single-stranded DNA, they were very rarely regular structures. The irregular structure of filaments on single-stranded DNA suggests that Rad51 monomers are dynamic in filaments and that regular filaments are transient. Indeed, single molecule force spectroscopy of Rad51 filament assembly and disassembly in magnetic tweezers revealed protein association and disassociation from many points along the DNA, with kinetics different from those of RecA. The dynamic rearrangements of proteins and DNA within Rad51 nucleoprotein filaments could be key events driving strand exchange in homologous recombination.     

Multiple interactions with the Rad51 recombinase govern the homologous recombination function of Rad54

In eukaryotes, Rad51 and Rad54 functionally cooperate to mediate homologous recombination and the repair of damaged chromosomes by recombination. Rad51, the eukaryotic counterpart of the bacterial RecA recombinase, forms filaments on single-stranded DNA that are capable of pairing the bound DNA with a homologous double-stranded donor to yield joint molecules. Rad54 enhances the homologous DNA pairing reaction, and this stimulatory effect involves a physical interaction with Rad51. Correspondingly, the ability of Rad54 to hydrolyze ATP and introduce superhelical tension into covalently closed circular plasmid DNA is stimulated by Rad51. By controlled proteolysis, we show that the amino-terminal region of yeast Rad54 is rather unstructured. Truncation mutations that delete the N-terminal 113 or 129 amino acid residues of Rad54 attenuate or ablate physical and functional interactions with Rad51 under physiological ionic strength, respectively. Surprisingly, under less stringent conditions, the Rad54 Delta129 protein can interact with Rad51 in affinity pull-down and functional assays. These results highlight the functional importance of the N-terminal Rad51 interaction domain of Rad54 and reveal that Rad54 contacts Rad51 through separable epitopes.     

Initiation of genetic recombination and recombination-dependent replication

Recombination initiates at double-stranded DNA breaks and at single-stranded DNA gaps. These DNA strand discontinuities can arise from DNA-damaging agents and from normal DNA replication when the DNA polymerase encounters an imperfection in the DNA template or another protein. The machinery of homologous recombination acts at these breaks and gaps to promote the events that result in gene recombination, as well as the reattachment of detached replication arms and the resumption of DNA replication. In Escherichia coli, these events require collaboration (RecA, RecBCD, RecFOR, RecQ, RuvABC and SSB proteins) and DNA replication (PriABC proteins and the DNA polymerases). The initial steps common to these recombination and recombination-dependent replication processes are reviewed.     

Loop L1 governs the DNA-binding specificity and order for RecA-catalyzed reactions in homologous recombination and DNA repair

In all organisms, RecA-family recombinases catalyze homologous joint formation in homologous genetic recombination, which is essential for genome stability and diversification. In homologous joint formation, ATP-bound RecA/Rad51-recombinases first bind single-stranded DNA at its primary site and then interact with double-stranded DNA at another site. The underlying reason and the regulatory mechanism for this conserved binding order remain unknown. A comparison of the loop L1 structures in a DNA-free RecA crystal that we originally determined and in the reported DNA-bound active RecA crystals suggested that the aspartate at position 161 in loop L1 in DNA-free RecA prevented double-stranded, but not single-stranded, DNA-binding to the primary site. This was confirmed by the effects of the Ala-replacement of Asp-161 (D161A), analyzed directly by gel-mobility shift assays and indirectly by DNA-dependent ATPase activity and SOS repressor cleavage. When RecA/Rad51-recombinases interact with double-stranded DNA before single-stranded DNA, homologous joint-formation is suppressed, likely by forming a dead-end product. We found that the D161A-replacement reduced this suppression, probably by allowing double-stranded DNA to bind preferentially and reversibly to the primary site. Thus, Asp-161 in the flexible loop L1 of wild-type RecA determines the preference for single-stranded DNA-binding to the primary site and regulates the DNA-binding order in RecA-catalyzed recombinase reactions.     

rec-A protein-promoted recombination reaction consists of two independent processes, homologous matching and processive unwinding. A study involving an anti-rec-A protein-monoclonal IgG

recA protein promotes the formation and processing of joint molecules of homologous double-stranded DNA and single-stranded DNA. We studied the effects of an anti-recA protein monoclonal IgG (ARM193) on two processes carried out by the recA protein. The homologous matching, i.e. pairing of double-stranded DNA and single-stranded DNA by forming intermolecular base-pairing at homologous regions was found to occur even in the presence of an excess amount of antibody ARM193. On the other hand, processive unwinding, i.e. the propagation of the unwinding of double-stranded DNA through a processive reaction of recA protein, which occurs even in the absence of single-stranded DNA, was found to be very sensitive to the inhibition by antibody ARM193. Therefore, we conclude that homologous matching and processive unwinding are independent of each other. Analysis of the effect of antibody ARM193 on the various activities of recA protein suggests that the entire reaction of the formation of joint molecules and their processing can be rationalized in terms of these two underlying processes, homologous matching and processive unwinding. This analysis also suggests that homologous matching seems to require only the binding itself of active units of recA protein to single-stranded DNA but not necessarily either the cooperativity of the protein or unwinding.     

Breakage--reunion and copy choice mechanisms of recombination between short homologous sequences.

To study recombination between short homologous sequences in Escherichia coli we constructed plasmids composed of the pBR322 replicon, M13 replication origin and a recombination unit inserted within and inactivating a gene encoding chloramphenicol resistance. The unit was composed of short direct repeats (9, 18 or 27 bp) which flanked inverted repeats (0, 8 or 308 bp) and a gene encoding kanamycin resistance. Recombination between direct repeats restored a functional chloramphenicol resistance gene, and could be detected by a simple phenotype test. The plasmids replicated in a double-stranded form, using the pBR322 replicon, and generated single-stranded DNA when the M13 replication origin was activated. The frequency of chloramphenicol-resistant cells was low (10(-8)-10(-4] when no single-stranded DNA was synthesized but increased greatly (to 100%) after induction of single-stranded DNA synthesis. Recombination between 9 bp direct repeats entailed no transfer of DNA from parental to recombinant plasmids, whereas recombination between 18 or 27 bp repeats entailed massive transfer. The presence or length of inverted repeats did not alter the pattern of DNA transfer. From these results we propose that direct repeats of 9 bp recombine by a copy choice process, while those greater than or equal to 18 bp can recombine by a breakage-reunion process. Genome rearrangements detected in many organisms often occur by recombination between sequences less than 18 bp, which suggests that they may result from copy choice recombination.     

Homologous recombination between single-stranded DNA and chromosomal genes in Saccharomyces cerevisiae.

Transformation of Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains was examined by using the URA3 and TRP1 genes cloned into M13 vectors in the absence of sequences capable of promoting autonomous replication. These constructs transform S. cerevisiae cells to prototrophy by homologous recombination with the resident mutant gene. Single-stranded DNA was found to transform S. cerevisiae cells at efficiencies greater than that of double-stranded DNA. No conversion of single-stranded transforming DNA into duplex forms could be detected during the transformation process, and we conclude that single-stranded DNA may participate directly in recombination with chromosomal sequences. Transformation with single-stranded DNA gave rise to both gene conversion and reciprocal exchange events. Cotransformation with competing heterologous single-stranded DNA specifically inhibited transformation by single-stranded DNA, suggesting that one of the components in the transformation-recombination process has a preferential affinity for single-stranded DNA.     

Schizosaccharomyces pombe Rad22A and Rad22B have similar biochemical properties and form multimeric structures

The Saccharomyces cerevisiae Rad52 protein has a crucial role in the repair of DNA double-strand breaks by homologous recombination. In vitro, Rad52 displays DNA binding and strand annealing activities and promotes Rad51-mediated strand exchange. Schizosaccharomyces pombe has two Rad52 homologues, Rad22A and Rad22B. Whereas rad22A deficient strains exhibit severe defects in repair and recombination, rad22B mutants have a much less severe phenotype. To better understand the role of Rad22A and Rad22B in double-strand break repair, both proteins were purified to near homogeneity. Using gel retardation and filter binding assays, binding of Rad22A and Rad22B to short single-stranded DNAs was demonstrated. Binding of Rad22A to double-stranded oligonucleotides or linearized plasmid molecules containing blunt ends or short single-stranded overhangs could not be detected. Rad22B also does not bind efficiently to short duplex oligonucleotides but binds readily to DNA fragments containing 3'-overhangs. Rad22A as well as Rad22B efficiently promote annealing of complementary single-stranded DNAs. In the presence of Rad22A annealing of complementary DNAs is almost 90%. Whereas in reactions containing Rad22B the maximum level of annealing is 60%, most likely due to inhibition of the reaction by duplex DNA. Gel-filtration experiments and electron microscopic analyses indicate self-association of Rad22A and Rad22B and the formation of multimeric structures as has been observed for Rad52 in yeast and man.     

Copy choice illegitimate DNA recombination

Precise excision of Tn10 and related transposons occurs by recombination between directly repeated 9 bp sequences that flank the transposon. The excision, which is a model for a class of illegitimate DNA recombination events, was stimulated 10(6) times by induction of single-stranded DNA synthesis, occurred during conversion of single-stranded DNA to double-stranded form, and entailed no transfer of physical material from parental to progeny molecules. We conclude that it occurred by copy choice DNA recombination and suggest that other illegitimate recombination events may occur by a similar mechanism.