Recent advances on the structure and function of NDH-1: The complex I of oxygenic photosynthesis

Photosynthetic NADH dehydrogenase-like complex type-1 (a.k.a, NDH, NDH-1, or NDH-1L) is a multi-subunit, membrane-bound oxidoreductase related to the respiratory complex I. Although originally discovered 30 years ago, a number of recent advances have revealed significant insight into the structure, function, and physiology of NDH-1. Here, we highlight progress in understanding the function of NDH-1 in the photosynthetic light reactions of both cyanobacteria and chloroplasts from biochemical and structural perspectives. We further examine the cyanobacterial-specific forms of NDH-1 that possess vectorial carbonic anhydrase (vCA) activity and function in the CO₂-concentrating mechanism (CCM). We compare the proposed mechanism for the cyanobacterial NDH-1 vCA-activity to that of the DAB (DABs accumulates bicarbonate) complex, another putative vCA. Finally, we discuss both new and remaining questions pertaining to the mechanisms of NDH-1 complexes in light of these recent advances.     

A modeling and simulation perspective on the mechanism and function of respiratory complex I

Respiratory complex I is a giant redox-driven proton pump, and central to energy production in mitochondria and bacteria. It catalyses the reduction of quinone to quinol, and converts the free energy released into the endergonic proton translocation across the membrane. The proton pumping sets up the proton electrochemical gradient, which propels the synthesis of ATP. Despite the availability of extensive biochemical, biophysical and structural data on complex I, the mechanism of coupling between the electron and proton transfer reactions remain uncertain. In this work, we discuss current state-of-the-art in the field with particular emphasis on the molecular mechanism of respiratory complex I, as deduced from computational modeling and simulation approaches, but in strong alliance with the experimental data. This leads to novel synthesis of mechanistic ideas on a highly complex enzyme of the electron transport chain that has been associated with a number of mitochondrial and neurodegenerative disorders.     

How inter-subunit contacts in the membrane domain of complex I affect proton transfer energetics

The respiratory complex I is a redox-driven proton pump that employs the free energy released from quinone reduction to pump protons across its complete ca. 200?Å wide membrane domain. Despite recently resolved structures and molecular simulations, the exact mechanism for the proton transport process remains unclear. Here we combine large-scale molecular simulations with quantum chemical density functional theory (DFT) models to study how contacts between neighboring antiporter-like subunits in the membrane domain of complex I affect the proton transfer energetics. Our combined results suggest that opening of conserved Lys/Glu ion pairs within each antiporter-like subunit modulates the barrier for the lateral proton transfer reactions. Our work provides a mechanistic suggestion for key coupling effects in the long-range force propagation process of complex I.     

Single particle analysis of thylakoid proteins from Thermosynechococcus elongatus and Synechocystis 6803: localization of the CupA subunit of NDH-1

The larger protein complexes of the cyanobacterial photosynthetic membrane of Thermosynechoccus elongatus and Synechocystis 6803 were studied by single particle electron microscopy after detergent solubilization, without any purification steps. Besides the "standard" L-shaped NDH-1L complex, related to complex I, large numbers of a U-shaped NDH-1MS complex were found in both cyanobacteria. In membranes from Synechocystis DeltacupA and DeltacupA/cupB mutants the U-shaped complexes were absent, indicating that CupA is responsible for the U-shape by binding at the tip of the membrane-bound arm of NDH-1MS. Comparison of membranes grown under air levels of CO(2) or 3% CO(2) indicates that the number of NDH-1MS particles is 30-fold higher under low-CO(2).     

The 5 kDa Protein NdhP Is Essential for Stable NDH-1L Assembly in Thermosynechococcus elongatus

The cyanobacterial NADPH:plastoquinone oxidoreductase complex (NDH-1), that is related to Complex I of eubacteria and mitochondria, plays a pivotal role in respiration as well as in cyclic electron transfer (CET) around PSI and is involved in a unique carbon concentration mechanism (CCM). Despite many achievements in the past, the complex protein composition and the specific function of many subunits of the different NDH-1 species remain elusive. We have recently discovered in a NDH-1 preparation from Thermosynechococcus elongatus two novel single transmembrane peptides (NdhP, NdhQ) with molecular weights below 5 kDa. Here we show that NdhP is a unique component of the ∼450 kDa NDH-1L complex, that is involved in respiration and CET at high CO₂ concentration, and not detectable in the NDH-1MS and NDH-1MS'' complexes that play a role in carbon concentration. C-terminal fusion of NdhP with his-tagged superfolder GFP and the subsequent analysis of the purified complex by electron microscopy and single particle averaging revealed its localization in the NDH-1L specific distal unit of the NDH-1 complex, that is formed by the subunits NdhD1 and NdhF1. Moreover, NdhP is essential for NDH-1L formation, as this type of NDH-1 was not detectable in a ΔndhP::Km mutant.     

Functional implications from an unexpected position of the 49-kDa subunit of NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase

Membrane-bound complex I (NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase) of the respiratory chain is considered the main site of mitochondrial radical formation and plays a major role in many mitochondrial pathologies. Structural information is scarce for complex I, and its molecular mechanism is not known. Recently, the 49-kDa subunit has been identified as part of the "catalytic core" conferring ubiquinone reduction by complex I. We found that the position of the 49-kDa subunit is clearly separated from the membrane part of complex I, suggesting an indirect mechanism of proton translocation. This contradicts all hypothetical mechanisms discussed in the field that link proton translocation directly to redox events and suggests an indirect mechanism of proton pumping by redox-driven conformational energy transfer.     

Cyanobacterial NDH-1 complexes: multiplicity in function and subunit composition

In cyanobacteria, the NAD(P)H:quinone oxidoreductase (NDH-1) is involved in a variety of functions like respiration, cyclic electron flow around PSI and CO₂ uptake. Several types of NDH-1 complexes, which differ in structure and are responsible for these functions, exist in cyanobacterial membranes. This minireview is based on data obtained by reverse genetics and proteomics studies and focuses on the structural and functional differences of the two types of cyanobacterial NDH-1 complexes: NDH-1L, important for respiration and PSI cyclic electron flow, and NDH-1MS, the low-CO₂ inducible complex participating in CO₂ uptake. The NDH-1 complexes in cyanobacteria share a common NDH-1M 'core' complex and differ in the composition of the distal membrane domain composed of specific NdhD and NdhF proteins, which in complexes involved in CO₂ uptake is further associated with the hydrophilic carbon uptake (CUP) domain. At present, however, very important questions concerning the nature of catalytically active subunits that constitute the electron input device (like NADH dehydrogenase module of the eubacterial 'model' NDH-1 analogs), the substrate specificity and reaction mechanisms of cyanobacterial complexes remain unanswered and are shortly discussed here.     

Roles of semiquinone species in proton pumping mechanism by complex I

Complex I (NDH-1) translocates protons across the membrane using electron transfer energy. Two different coupling mechanisms are currently being discussed for complex I: direct (redox-driven) and indirect (conformation-driven). Semiquinone (SQ) intermediates are suggested to be key for the coupling mechanism. Recently, using progressive power saturation and simulation techniques, three distinct SQ species were resolved by EPR analysis of E. coli complex I reconstituted into proteoliposomes. The fast-relaxing SQ (SQ_Nf) signals completely disappeared in the presence of the uncoupler gramicidin D or the potent E. coli complex I inhibitor squamotacin. The slow-relaxing SQ (SQ_Ns) signals were insensitive to gramicidin D, but they were sensitive to squamotacin. The very slow-relaxing SQ (SQ_Nvs) signals were insensitive to both gramicidin D and squamotacin. Interestingly, no SQ_Ns signal was observed in the ΔNuoL mutant, which lacks transporter module subunits NuoL and NuoM. Furthermore, we sought out the effect of using menaquinone (which has a lower redox potential compared to that of ubiquinone) as an electron acceptor on the proton pumping stoichiometry by in vitro reconstitution experiments with ubiquinone-rich or menaquinone-rich double knock-out membrane vesicles, which contain neither complex I nor NDH-2 (non-proton translocating NADH dehydrogenase). No difference in the proton pumping stoichiometry between menaquinone and ubiquinone was observed in the ΔNuoL and D178N mutants, which are considered to lack the indirect proton pumping mechanism. However, the proton pumping stoichiometry with menaquinone decreased by half in the wild-type. The roles and relationships of SQ intermediates in the coupling mechanism of complex I are discussed.     

A two-state stabilization-change mechanism for proton-pumping complex I

Despite its central function in oxidative phosphorylation, the molecular mechanism of proton pumping respiratory complex I is still elusive. In recent years, considerable progress has been made towards understanding structure/function relationships in this very large and complicated membrane protein complex. Last year X-ray crystallographic analysis of bacterial and mitochondrial complex I provided important insights into its molecular architecture. Based on this evidence, here a hypothetical molecular mechanism for redox-driven proton pumping of complex I is proposed. According to this mechanism, two pump modules are driven by two conformational strokes that are generated by stabilization of the anionic forms of semiquinone and ubiquinol that are formed in the peripheral arm of complex I during turnover. This results in the experimentally determined pumping stoichiometry of 4 H(+)/2e(-). In the two-state model, electron transfer from iron-sulfur cluster N2 is allowed only in the 'E-state,' while protonation of the substrate is only possible in the stabilizing 'P-state.' In the membrane arm, transition from the E- to the P-state drives the two pump modules via long range conformational energy transfer through the recently discovered helical transmission element connecting them. The proposed two-state stabilization-change mechanism is fully reversible and thus inherently explains the operation of complex I in forward and reverse mode. This article is part of a Special Issue entitled Allosteric cooperativity in respiratory proteins.     

NdhM Subunit Is Required for the Stability and the Function of NAD(P)H Dehydrogenase Complexes Involved in CO2 Uptake in Synechocystis sp. Strain PCC 6803

The cyanobacterial type I NAD(P)H dehydrogenase (NDH-1) complexes play a crucial role in a variety of bioenergetic reactions such as respiration, CO₂ uptake, and cyclic electron transport around photosystem I. Two types of NDH-1 complexes, NDH-1MS and NDH-1MS′, are involved in the CO₂ uptake system. However, the composition and function of the complexes still remain largely unknown. Here, we found that deletion of ndhM caused inactivation of NDH-1-dependent cyclic electron transport around photosystem I and abolishment of CO₂ uptake, resulting in a lethal phenotype under air CO₂ condition. The mutation of NdhM abolished the accumulation of the hydrophilic subunits of the NDH-1, such as NdhH, NdhI, NdhJ, and NdhK, in the thylakoid membrane, resulting in disassembly of NDH-1MS and NDH-1MS′ as well as NDH-1L. In contrast, the accumulation of the hydrophobic subunits was not affected in the absence of NdhM. In the cytoplasm, the NDH-1 subcomplex assembly intermediates including NdhH and NdhK were seriously affected in the ΔndhM mutant but not in the NdhI-deleted mutant ΔndhI. In vitro protein interaction analysis demonstrated that NdhM interacts with NdhK, NdhH, NdhI, and NdhJ but not with other hydrophilic subunits of the NDH-1 complex. These results suggest that NdhM localizes in the hydrophilic subcomplex of NDH-1 complexes as a core subunit and is essential for the function of NDH-1MS and NDH-1MS′ involved in CO₂ uptake in Synechocystis sp. strain PCC 6803.     

Respiratory complex I – Mechanistic insights and advances in structure determination

Complex I is the largest and most intricate redox-driven proton pump of the respiratory chain. The structure of bacterial and mitochondrial complex I has been determined by X-ray crystallography and cryo-EM at increasing resolution. The recent cryo-EM structures of the complex I-like NDH complex and membrane bound hydrogenase open a new and more comprehensive perspective on the complex I superfamily. Functional studies and molecular modeling approaches have greatly advanced our understanding of the catalytic cycle of complex I. However, the molecular mechanism by which energy is extracted from the redox reaction and utilized to drive proton translocation is unresolved and a matter of ongoing debate. Here, we review progress in structure determination and functional characterization of complex I and discuss current mechanistic models.     

Complex I: A Chimaera of a Redox and Conformation-Driven Proton Pump?

From phylogenetic sequence analysis, it can be concluded that the proton-pumping NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase (complex I) has evolved from preexisting modules for electron transfer and proton translocation. It is built up by a peripheral NADH dehydrogenase module, an amphipatic hydrogenase module, and a membrane-bound transporter module. These modules, or at least part of them, are also present in various other bacterial enzymes. It is assumed that they fulfill a similar function in complex I and related enzymes. Based on the function of the individual modules, it is possible to speculate about the mechanism of complex I. The hydrogenase module might work as a redox-driven proton pump, while the transporter module might act as a conformation-driven proton pump. This implies that complex I contains two energy-coupling sites. The NADH dehydrogenase module seems to be involved in electron transfer and not in proton translocation.     

Identification of novel Ssl0352 protein (NdhS), essential for efficient operation of cyclic electron transport around photosystem I, in NADPH:plastoquinone oxidoreductase (NDH-1) complexes of Synechocystis sp. PCC 6803

Cyanobacterial NADPH:plastoquinone oxidoreductase, or type I NAD(P)H dehydrogenase, or the NDH-1 complex is involved in plastoquinone reduction and cyclic electron transfer (CET) around photosystem I. CET, in turn, produces extra ATP for cell metabolism particularly under stressful conditions. Despite significant achievements in the study of cyanobacterial NDH-1 complexes during the past few years, the entire subunit composition still remains elusive. To identify missing subunits, we screened a transposon-tagged library of Synechocystis 6803 cells grown under high light. Two NDH-1-mediated CET (NDH-CET)-defective mutants were tagged in the same ssl0352 gene encoding a short unknown protein. To clarify the function of Ssl0352, the ssl0352 deletion mutant and another mutant with Ssl0352 fused to yellow fluorescent protein (YFP) and the His(6) tag were constructed. Immunoblotting, mass spectrometry, and confocal microscopy analyses revealed that the Ssl0352 protein resides in the thylakoid membrane and associates with the NDH-1L and NDH-1M complexes. We conclude that Ssl0352 is a novel subunit of cyanobacterial NDH-1 complexes and designate it NdhS. Deletion of the ssl0352 gene considerably impaired the NDH-CET activity and also retarded cell growth under high light conditions, indicating that NdhS is essential for efficient operation of NDH-CET. However, the assembly of the NDH-1L and NDH-1M complexes and their content in the cells were not affected in the mutant. NdhS contains a Src homology 3-like domain and might be involved in interaction of the NDH-1 complex with an electron donor.     

A possible role for iron-sulfur cluster N2 in proton translocation by the NADH: ubiquinone oxidoreductase (complex I)

The proton-pumping NADH:ubiquinone oxidoreductase, the respiratory complex I, couples the transfer of electrons from NADH to ubiquinone with the translocation of protons across the membrane. The enzyme mechanism is still unknown due to the lack of a high-resolution structure and its complicated composition. The complex from Escherichia coli is made up of 13 subunits called NuoA through NuoN and contains one FMN and nine iron-sulfur (Fe/S) clusters as redox groups. The pH dependence of the midpoint redox potential of the Fe/S cluster named N2 and its spin-spin interaction with ubiquinone radicals made it an ideal candidate for a key component in redox-driven proton translocation. During the past years we have assigned the subunit localization of cluster N2 to subunit NuoB by site-directed mutagenesis and predicted its ligation by molecular simulation. Redox-induced FT-IR spectroscopy has shown that its redox reaction is accompanied by the protonation and deprotonation of individual amino acid residues. These residues have been identified by site-directed mutagenesis. The enzyme catalytic activity depends on the presence of cluster N2 and is coupled with major conformational changes. From these data a model for redox-induced conformation-driven proton translocation has been derived.     

Transmembrane proton translocation by cytochrome c oxidase

Respiratory heme-copper oxidases are integral membrane proteins that catalyze the reduction of molecular oxygen to water using electrons donated by either quinol (quinol oxidases) or cytochrome c (cytochrome c oxidases, CcOs). Even though the X-ray crystal structures of several heme-copper oxidases and results from functional studies have provided significant insights into the mechanisms of O2 -reduction and, electron and proton transfer, the design of the proton-pumping machinery is not known. Here, we summarize the current knowledge on the identity of the structural elements involved in proton transfer in CcO. Furthermore, we discuss the order and timing of electron-transfer reactions in CcO during O2 reduction and how these reactions might be energetically coupled to proton pumping across the membrane.     

DCCD sensitivity of electron and proton transfer by NADH: ubiquinone oxidoreductase in bovine heart submitochondrial particles--a thermodynamic approach

The sensitivity of the H+/2e- ratio of the redox-driven proton pumping by the NADH: ubiquinone reductase (complex I) of the submitochondrial particles to dicyclohexylcarbodiimide (DCCD) was studied by a thermodynamic approach, measuring the membrane potential and delta pH across the membrane and the redox potential difference across the complex I span of the respiratory chain. The delta Gr/delta muH+ ratio did not decrease upon additions of 50 or 100 nmol of DCCD per mg protein in the presence of oligomycin although the H+/2e- ratio has been demonstrated to decrease upon DCCD addition in kinetic experiments with mitochondria. Complex I then becomes reminiscent of the cytochrome bc1 complex, which shows DCCD sensitivity of the kinetically but not thermodynamically determined H+/2e- ratio.     

The Origin of Cluster N2 of the Energy-Transducing NADH–Quinone Oxidoreductase: Comparisons of Phylogenetically Related Enzymes

NADH–quinone (Q) oxidoreductase is a large and complex redox proton pump, which utilizes the free energy derived from oxidation of NADH with lipophilic electron/proton carrier Q to translocate protons across the membrane to generate an electrochemical proton gradient ( ). Although its molecular mechanism is largely unknown, recent biochemical, biophysical, and molecular biological studies have revealed that particular subunits and cofactors play an essential role in the energy-coupling reaction. Based on these latest experimental data, we exhaustively analyzed the sequence information available from evolutionarily related enzymes such as [NiFe] hydrogenases. We found significant and conserved sequence differences in the PSST/Nqo6/NuoB, 49kDa/Nqo4/NuoD, and ND1/Nqo8/NuoH subunit homologs between complex I/NDH-1 and [NiFe] hydrogenases. The alterations, especially in the postulated ligand motif for cluster N2 in the PSST/Nqo6/NuoB subunits, appear to be evolutionarily important in determining the physiological function of complex I/NDH-1. These observations led us to propose a hypothetical evolutionary scheme: during the course of evolution, drastic changes have occurred in the putative cluster N2 binding site in the PSST/Nqo6/NuoB subunit and the progenitors of complex I/NDH-1 have concurrently become to utilize a lipophilic electron/proton carrier such as Q as its physiological substrate. This scheme provides new insights into the structure and function relationship of complex I/NDH-1 and may help us understand its energy-coupling mechanism.     

Characterization of the complex I-associated ubisemiquinone species: toward the understanding of their functional roles in the electron/proton transfer reaction

NADH-ubiquinone oxidoreductase (called complex I for mitochondrial enzyme and NDH-1 for bacterial counterparts) is an energy transducer, which utilizes the redox energy derived from the oxidation of NADH with ubiquinone to generate an electrochemical proton gradient (Deltamu(H(+))) across the membrane. The complex I/NDH-1 contain one non-covalently bound flavin mononucleotide and as many as eight iron-sulfur clusters as electron transfer components in common. In addition, electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopic studies have revealed that three ubisemiquinone (SQ) species with distinct spectroscopic and thermodynamic properties are detectable in complex I and function as electron/proton translocators. Thus, the understanding of molecular properties of the individual quinone species is prerequisite to elucidate the energy-coupling mechanism of complex I. We have investigated these SQ species using EPR spectroscopy and found that the three SQ species have strikingly different properties. We will report characteristics of these SQ species and discuss possible functional roles of individual quinone species in the electron/proton transfer reaction of complex I/NDH-1.     

几种蓝藻光合NAD（P）H脱氢酶复合体研究的新进展

蓝藻NAD（P）H脱氢酶（NDH-1）是一种重要的光合膜蛋白复合体,参与CO2吸收、围绕光系统I的循环电子传递和细胞呼吸。就几种蓝藻NDH-1复合体的鉴定、结构、生理功能等研究的新进展进行了综述与分析,并对今后NDH-1复合体的研究作了展望。     

Cyanobacterial NADPH dehydrogenase complexes

Cyanobacteria possess functionally distinct multiple NADPH dehydrogenase (NDH-1) complexes that are essential to CO₂ uptake, photosystem-1 cyclic electron transport and respiration. The unique nature of cyanobacterial NDH-1 complexes is the presence of subunits involved in CO₂ uptake. Other than CO₂ uptake, chloroplastic NDH-1 complex has a similar role as cyanobacterial NDH-1 complexes in photosystem-1 cyclic electron transport and respiration (chlororespiration). In this mini-review we focus on the structure and function of cyanobacterial NDH-1 complexes and their phylogeny. The function of chloroplastic NDH-1 complex and characteristics of plants defective in NDH-1 are also described for comparison.