Sensory convergence solves a motion ambiguity problem

Our inner ear is equipped with a set of linear accelerometers, the otolith organs, that sense the inertial accelerations experienced during self-motion. However, as Einstein pointed out nearly a century ago, this signal would by itself be insufficient to detect our real movement, because gravity, another form of linear acceleration, and self-motion are sensed identically by otolith afferents. To deal with this ambiguity, it was proposed that neural populations in the pons and midline cerebellum compute an independent, internal estimate of gravity using signals arising from the vestibular rotation sensors, the semicircular canals. This hypothesis, regarding a causal relationship between firing rates and postulated sensory contributions to inertial motion estimation, has been directly tested here by recording neural activities before and after inactivation of the semicircular canals. We show that, unlike cells in normal animals, the gravity component of neural responses was nearly absent in canal-inactivated animals. We conclude that, through integration of temporally matched, multimodal information, neurons derive the mathematical signals predicted by the equations describing the physics of the outside world.     

Perspectives for the comprehensive examination of semicircular canal and otolith function.

A review is presented on the three-dimensional aspects of the vestibulo-oculomotor system and the current functional tests for unilateral examination of the individual receptors in the vestibular labyrinth. In the presentation, attention is directed towards the recently developed vestibular tests, which promise a more comprehensive examination of labyrinth function. More explicitly, unilateral tests for the utricle, saccule and the individual semicircular canals are discussed. Caloric irrigation and rotatory testing are widely used as tests for the integrity of the (horizontal) semicircular canals. Little useful diagnosis is made however on the vertical canals, not to mention the otolith organs. A promising approach to the examination of individual semicircular canal function has been described. This involves the perception of self-rotation in each of the planes of the semicircular canals. The patient/subject is rotated by an arbitrary amount on a standard Barany chair and then required to return the chair to its original position, by joystick control of the chair velocity. In order to test the vertical canals, the head of the subject/patient is positioned so that the plane of each canal lies in the plane of rotation. A promising unilateral test of saccular function involves the use of vestibular evoked myogenic potentials. Here it has been demonstrated that the saccules can be activated using brief, high-intensity acoustic clicks. The myogenic potential is measured using surface electrodes over the sternocleidomastoid muscles. Initial data from patients has indicated that the test is specific for unilateral saccule disorders. The unilateral test of utricle function is based on the eccentric displacement profile. Thus, eccentric displacement of the head to 3.5 cm during constant velocity rotation about the earth-vertical axis generates an adequate unilateral stimulation of the otolith organ, without involving the semicircular canals. This paradigm has also proved efficient in localizing peripheral otolith dysfunction by means of SVV estimation. This represents a novel test of otolith function that can be easily integrated into routine clinical testing. In contrast to the otolith-ocular response, the subjective visual vertical also reflects the processing of otolithic information in the higher brain centres (thalamus, vestibular cortex). Exploitation of the two complementary approaches therefore provides useful information for both experimental and clinical scientists. Of direct interest is the finding that testing with the subject rotating on-centre is sufficient to localize peripheral otolith dysfunction by means of SVV estimation. This represents a novel test of otolith function that can be easily integrated into routine clinical testing. In addition to caloric testing, which has remained the classical unilateral test of vestibular function, the newly developed tests should improve the differential diagnosis of vestibular disorders.     

A model of the nystagmus induced by off vertical axis rotation

A three-dimensional model is proposed that accounts for a number of phenomena attributed to the otoliths. It is constructed by extending and modifying a model of vestibular velocity storage. It is proposed that the otolith information about the orientation of the head to gravity changes the time constant of vestibular responses by modulating the gain of the velocity storage feedback loop. It is further proposed that the otolith signals, such as those that generate L-nystagmus (linear acceleration induced nystagmus), are partially coupled to the vestibular system via the velocity storage integrator. The combination of these two hypotheses suggests that a vestibular neural mechanism exists that performs correlation in the mathematical sense which is multiplication followed by integration. The multiplication is performed by the otolith modulation of the velocity storage feedback loop gain and the integration is performed by the velocity storage mechanism itself. Correlation allows calculation of the degree to which two signals are related and in this context provides a simple method of determining head angular velocity from the components of linear acceleration induced by off-vertical axis rotation. Correlation accounts for the otolith supplementation of the VOR and the sustained nystagmus generated by off-vertical axis rotation. The model also predicts the cross-coupling of horizontal and vertical optokinetic afternystagmus that occurs in head-lateral positions and the reported effects of tilt on vestibular responses.     

Alterations in rat horizontal vestibulo-ocular reflex phase as a function of orientation in gravity

The effect of changes in static and dynamic gravity signals on the phase accuracy of the horizontal vestibulo-ocular reflex (HVOR) was studied in rats using chronically implanted scleral search coils to monitor eye movements. Rats were sinusoidally rotated using a range of different frequencies (0.035-2 Hz) in a plane which always activated the horizontal semicircular canals but in one of three different orientations with regard to gravity which differentially activated the otolith organs: 1) upright-normal static gravity signal, no dynamic otolith activation; 2) inverted-inverted static gravity signal, no dynamic otolith activation; 3) on-side-dynamic activation of the otolith organs. In the upright orientation, the HVOR shows a phase advance at 0.2 Hz and below but not at 0.5 Hz and above. Phase accuracy of the HVOR was further degraded in the inverted orientation with rats showing large phase leads at 0.2 Hz and below. In contrast, accuracy of the HVOR was significantly improved at 0.2 Hz and below in the on-side orientation with phase accurate eye movements down to the lowest frequency tested. The results further support the idea that otolith organs play an important role in VOR generation by supplementing the semicircular canals' response to angular head movements.     

Ontogeny of mouse vestibulo-ocular reflex following genetic or environmental alteration of gravity sensing

The vestibular organs consist of complementary sensors: the semicircular canals detect rotations while the otoliths detect linear accelerations, including the constant pull of gravity. Several fundamental questions remain on how the vestibular system would develop and/or adapt to prolonged changes in gravity such as during long-term space journey. How do vestibular reflexes develop if the appropriate assembly of otoliths and semi-circular canals is perturbed? The aim of present work was to evaluate the role of gravity sensing during ontogeny of the vestibular system. In otoconia-deficient mice (ied), gravity cannot be sensed and therefore maculo-ocular reflexes (MOR) were absent. While canals-related reflexes were present, the ied deficit also led to the abnormal spatial tuning of the horizontal angular canal-related VOR. To identify putative otolith-related critical periods, normal C57Bl/6J mice were subjected to 2G hypergravity by chronic centrifugation during different periods of development or adulthood (Adult-HG) and compared to non-centrifuged (control) C57Bl/6J mice. Mice exposed to hypergravity during development had completely normal vestibulo-ocular reflexes 6 months after end of centrifugation. Adult-HG mice all displayed major abnormalities in maculo-ocular reflexe one month after return to normal gravity. During the next 5 months, adaptation to normal gravity occurred in half of the individuals. In summary, genetic suppression of gravity sensing indicated that otolith-related signals might be necessary to ensure proper functioning of canal-related vestibular reflexes. On the other hand, exposure to hypergravity during development was not sufficient to modify durably motor behaviour. Hence, 2G centrifugation during development revealed no otolith-specific critical period.     

Numerical modeling of the cupular displacement and motion of otoconia particles in a semicircular canal

Balance is achieved and maintained by a balance system called a labyrinth that is composed of three semicircular canals and the otolith organs that sense linear gravity and acceleration. Within each semicircular canal, there is a gelatinous structure called the cupula, which is deformed under the influence of the surrounding endolymph. One of the balance disorders is benign paroxysmal positional vertigo, and one of the pathological conditions that have been identified as possible causes of this syndrome is canalithiasis—disturbance of the endolymph flow and cupular displacement caused by the free-moving otoconia particles within the lumen of the canal. Analysis of phenomena occurring within the semicircular canal can help to explain some balance-related disorders and the response of the vestibular system to external perturbations under various pathological conditions. Numerical simulations allow a study of the influence of a wide range of factors, without the need to perform experiments and clinical examinations. In case of canalithiasis, an accurate explanation and tracking of the motion of otoconia particles in vivo is obviously nearly impossible. In this study, a numerical model was developed to predict the motion of otoconia particles within the semicircular canal and the effect of the endolymph flow and particles on the deformation of the cupula.     

Purkinje cells in posterior cerebellar vermis encode motion in an inertial reference frame

The ability to orient and navigate through the terrestrial environment represents a computational challenge common to all vertebrates. It arises because motion sensors in the inner ear, the otolith organs, and the semicircular canals transduce self-motion in an egocentric reference frame. As a result, vestibular afferent information reaching the brain is inappropriate for coding our own motion and orientation relative to the outside world. Here we show that cerebellar cortical neuron activity in vermal lobules 9 and 10 reflects the critical computations of transforming head-centered vestibular afferent information into earth-referenced self-motion and spatial orientation signals. Unlike vestibular and deep cerebellar nuclei neurons, where a mixture of responses was observed, Purkinje cells represent a homogeneous population that encodes inertial motion. They carry the earth-horizontal component of a spatially transformed and temporally integrated rotation signal from the semicircular canals, which is critical for computing head attitude, thus isolating inertial linear accelerations during navigation.     

Distributed parallel processing in the vertical vestibulo-ocular reflex: Learning networks compared to tensor theory

The vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) is capable of producing compensatory eye movements in three dimensions. It utilizes the head rotational velocity signals from the semicircular canals to control the contractions of the extraocular muscles. Since canal and muscle coordinate frames are not orthogonal and differ from one another, a sensorimotor transformation must be produced by the VOR neural network. Tensor theory has been used to construct a linear transformation that can model the three-dimensional behavior of the VOR. But tensor theory does not take the distributed, redundant nature of the VOR neural network into account. It suggests that the neurons subserving the VOR, such as vestibular nucleus neurons, should have specific sensitivity-vectors. Actual data, however, are not in accord. Data from the cat show that the sensitivity-vectors of vestibular nucleus neurons, rather than aligning with any specific vectors, are dispersed widely. As an alternative to tensor theory, we modeled the vertical VOR as a three-layered neural network programmed using the back-propagation learning algorithm. Units in mature networks had divergent sensitivity-vectors which resembled those of actual vestibular nucleus neurons in the cat. This similarity suggests that the VOR sensorimotor transformation may be represented redundantly rather than uniquely. The results demonstrate how vestibular nucleus neurons can encode the VOR sensorimotor transformation in a distributed manner.     

Linear acceleration-evoked cardiovascular responses in awake rats.

It has been well documented that vestibular-mediated cardiovascular regulation plays an important role in maintaining stable blood pressure (BP) during postural changes. But the underlying neural mechanisms remain to be elucidated. In particular, because the vestibular stimulation employed in previous animal studies activated both semicircular canals and otolith organs, the contributions of the otolith system has not been studied selectively. The goal of the present study was to characterize cardiovascular responses to natural otolith stimulation in awake rats that were subjected to pure linear motion. In any of the four directions tested, transient linear motion produced a short-latency ( approximately 520 ms) increase in mean BP with a peak of 8.27 +/- 0.66 mmHg and was followed by a decrease in BP. There was an initial small biphasic response in heart rate (HR) that was followed by a longer duration increase. The short-latency increase in BP was absent in rats that were pentobarbital sodium anesthetized or that were labyrinthectomized bilaterally, but it was unaffected by baroreceptor denervation, indicating that it was of otolith origin. The increase in BP was linear acceleration intensity dependent and was not affected by absence of visual cues. Furthermore, the BP response was attenuated by inactivation of the medial and inferior vestibular nuclei by microinjections of muscimol, indicating that the otolith-driven cardiovascular responses are mediated by the neurons in these areas. These results not only demonstrate the otolith specific influences on the cardiovascular system but also they establish the first rodent model for examining the neural mechanisms underlying the otolith-mediated cardiovascular regulation.     

Simulation of vestibular semicircular canal responses during righting movements of a freely falling cat

The righting maneuver of a freely falling cat was filmed at 1000 pictures per second, and the head position about the roll axis was digitized from each film frame using a graphics input tablet. The head angular velocity and acceleration were computed from the roll axis position trajectory. Head acceleration trajectories approximated two periods of a damped sinusoid at a frequency of 26 Hz. Head acceleration peak amplitudes exceeded 120,000 deg/s². These trajectories were used as stimuli for the horizontal semicircular canals in a computer simulation of first-order afferent responses during the fall. Linear system afferent response dynamics, characterized in a previous study of the cat horizontal canal using pseudorandom rotations, provided the basis for linear predictions of falling cat afferent responses. Results showed predicted single afferent firing rates that exceeded physiological values; and variations in afferent sensitivities and phase were predicted among different neurons. Fast head movement information could be carried by ensemble populations of vestibular neurons, and a phase-locking encoding hypothesis is proposed which accomplishes this. Implications for central program versus peripheral vestibular feedback strategies for motor control during falling are presented and discussed.     

Three-dimensional head angular velocity detection from otolith afferent signals

Afferent signals from the otolith organs can produce compensatory eye position and velocity signals which has been described as linear vestibulo-ocular reflex (LVOR). The afferent otolith signals carry information about head orientation and changes of head orientation relative to gravity. A head orientation (tilt) related position signal can be obtained from population vector coding of tonic otolith afferent signals during static or dynamic head tilts, which in turn could produce compensatory eye position signals in the LVOR. On the other hand, eye angular velocity signals may be extracted, as proposed in this study, from the population response of tilt-velocity sensitive otolith afferents. Such afferents are shown to encode instantaneous head orientation relative to gravity at onset of a head movement and, as the movement continues, the projection of head angular velocity onto the earth-horizontal plane, indicating the instantaneous direction of movement relative to gravity. Angular velocity components along the earth-vertical direction which are not directly encoded by otolith afferents can be detected by central signal processing. Central reconstruction of 3D head angular velocity allows to obtain information about absolute head orientation in space even in the absence of semicircular canal related information. Such information is important for generating compensatory eye movements as well as for dynamic control of posture.     

Function of otolith organ in goldfish revealed from analysis of eye movement induced by acceleration.

An otolith organ on ground behave as a detector of both gravity and linear acceleration, and play an important role in controlling posture and eye movement for tilt of the head or translational motion. On the other hand, a gravitational acceleration ingredient to an otolith organ disappears in microgravity environment. However, linear acceleration can be received by otolith organ and produce a sensation that is different from that on Earth. It is suggested that in microgravity signal from the otolith organ may cause abnormality of posture control and eye movement. Therefore, the central nervous system may re-interprets all output from the otolith organ to indicate linear motion. A study of eye movement has been done a lot as one of a reflection related to an otolith organ system. In this study, we examined function of otolith organ in goldfish revealed from analysis of eye movement induced by linear acceleration or the tilt of body. We analyzed both torsional and vertical eye movements from video images frame by frame. For tilting stimulation, torsional eye movements induced by head down was larger than that induced by head up for larger tilt angle than 30 degrees. In the case of linear acceleration below 0.4 G, however, no clear differences were observed in both torsional and vertical eye movement. These results suggest that body tilt and linear acceleration may not be with equivalent stimulation to cause eye movement on the ground.     

Otolith and semicircular canal inputs to single vestibular neurons in cats.

Researchers studied the convergence of the vertical posterior semicircular canal (PC), saccular nerves (SAC), utricular nerves (UT), and horizontal semicircular canal nerves (HC) on single vestibular neurons. The vestibular neurons were categorized by their innervating targets. Vestibular neurons were classified as vestibulospinal proper neurons (VS), vestibulo-ocular proper neurons (VO), vestibulo-oculo-spinal neurons sending axon collaterals to the extraocular motoneuron pools and spinal cord (VOS), and vestibular nucleus neurons without axons to the oculomotor nuclei or the spinal cord (V). Results indicate that the percentage of convergence of VS neurons was higher that that of neurons sending axons to the oculomotor nuclei (VO and VOS). They conclude that the convergence of canal and otolith inputs likely contributes mainly to vestibulospinal reflexes by sending inputs to the neck and other muscles during head inclination, which creates the combined stimuli of angular and linear acceleration.     

Influence of vestibular activation on respiration in humans

The purpose of this study was to determine the effects of the semicircular canals and otolith organs on respiration in humans. On the basis of animal studies, we hypothesized that vestibular activation would elicit a vestibulorespiratory reflex. To test this hypothesis, respiratory measures, arterial blood pressure, and heart rate were measured during engagement of semicircular canals and/or otolith organs. Dynamic upright pitch and roll (15 cycles/min), which activate the otolith organs and semicircular canals, increased respiratory rate (Delta2 +/- 1 and Delta3 +/- 1 breaths/min, respectively; P < 0.05). Dynamic yaw and lateral pitch (15 cycles/min), which activate the semicircular canals, increased respiration similarly (Delta3 +/- 1 and Delta2 +/- 1, respectively; P < 0.05). Dynamic chair rotation (15 cycles/min), which mimics dynamic yaw but eliminates neck muscle afferent, increased respiration (Delta3 +/- 1; P < 0.05) comparable to dynamic yaw (15 cycles/min). Increases in respiratory rate were graded as greater responses occurred during upright (Delta5 +/- 2 breaths/min) and lateral pitch (Delta4 +/- 1) and roll (Delta5 +/- 1) performed at 30 cycles/min. Increases in breathing frequency resulted in increases in minute ventilation during most interventions. Static head-down rotation, which activates otolith organs, did not alter respiratory rate (Delta1 +/- 1 breaths/min). Collectively, these data indicate that semicircular canals, but not otolith organs or neck muscle afferents, mediate increased ventilation in humans and support the concept that vestibular activation alters respiration in humans.     

Assessment of inertial and gravitational inputs to the vestibular system

A new device for the assessment of instantaneous angular and linear accelerations of the head is presented, which is based on four linear tri-axial accelerometers suitably attached to the head by an helmet. A procedure for reproducible helmet placement and calibration is given. A method is also illustrated to work out the different linear accelerations sensed by the vestibular organs in the left and right labyrinths and the components of the angular acceleration sensed by their semicircular canals. The computation is based on few individual parameters describing the helmet position with respect to external landmarks and on the average internal position and orientation of the vestibula. The purpose is to study the components of internal inertial forces, which represent the primary inputs to the vestibular system devoted to equilibrium and oculomotor control. The system is designed to be of easy application during rehabilitation exercises and in clinical environment during diagnostic and therapeutic manoeuvres. The prototype is tested with simple free movements such as "yes", "no", and gait.     

A mouse model for benign paroxysmal positional vertigo with genetic predisposition for displaced otoconia

Abnormal formation of otoconia, the biominerals of the inner ear, results in balance disorders. The inertial mass of otoconia activates the underlying mechanosensory hair cells in response to change in head position primarily during linear and rotational acceleration. Otoconia associate exclusively with the two gravity receptors, the utricle and saccule. The cristae sensory epithelium is associated with an extracellular gelatinous matrix known as cupula, equivalent to otoconia. During head rotation, the inertia of endolymphatic fluids within the semicircular canals deflects the cupula of the corresponding crista and activates the underlying mechanosensory hair cells. It is believed that detached free‐floating otoconia particles travel ectopically to the semicircular canal and cristae and are the culprit for benign paroxysmal positional vertigo (BPPV). The Slc26a4 mouse mutant harbors a missense mutation in pendrin. This mutation leads to impaired transport activity of pendrin and to defects in otoconia composition and distribution. All Slc26a4 ^loop/loop homozygous mutant mice are profoundly deaf but show inconsistent vestibular deficiency. A panel of behavioral tests was utilized in order to generate a scoring method for vestibular function. A pathological finding of displaced otoconia was identified consistently in the inner ears of mutant mice with severe vestibular dysfunction. In this work, we present a mouse model with a genetic predisposition for ectopic otoconia with a clinical correlation to BPPV. This unique mouse model can serve as a platform for further investigation of BPPV pathophysiology, and for developing novel treatment approaches in a live animal model.     

Motion from the past. A new method to infer vestibular capacities of extinct species

The vestibular system detects head movement in space and maintains visual and postural stability. The semicircular canal system is responsible for registering head rotation. How it responds to head rotation is determined by the rotational axis and the angular acceleration of the head, as well as the sensitivity and orientation of each semicircular canal. The morphological parameters of the semicircular canals are supposed to allow an optimal detection of head rotations induced by some behaviours, especially locomotor. We propose a new method of semicircular canal analysis, based on the computation of central streamlines of virtually reconstructed labyrinths. This method allows us to ascertain the functional structure of the semicircular canal system and to infer its capacity to detect particular head rotations, induced by particular behaviours. In addition, this method is well-suited for datasets provided by any kind of serial sectioning methods, from MRI to μCT scanning and even mechanical serial sectioning, of extant and extinct taxa.     

A sustained hyper-g load as a tool to simulate space sickness

In April 1989 the three European scientist astronauts of the D1 Spacelab Mission were exposed to a 1.5 hours +3G centrifuge run in supine position, resulting in a linear acceleration along the subjects' x-axis. Afterwards, severe motion sickness symptoms were provoked by head movements (Sickness Induced by Centrifugation: SIC). The astronauts mentioned close similarities with what they experienced in space during the D1-Spacelab Mission in 1985, where head movements also provoked motion sickness symptoms (Space Adaptation Syndrome: SAS). Moreover, the astronauts agreed that the rank order of their susceptibility to SAS was the same as for SIC. It was therefore postulated that with this method SAS could be simulated on earth. Additionally, in otolith function tests following the centrifuge run, changes in visual-vestibular interaction were observed, which replicated objective findings obtained with the same astronauts immediately after the D1 Spacelab Mission. During the last couple of years a series of experiments has been carried out to determine the nature of the stimulus causing SIC, the incidence of SIC, and the underlying cardio-vascular and/or vestibular mechanisms. These experiments were carried out on several astronauts and some 50 'normal' healthy subjects. In the next sections the main findings of all these experiments and the implications are summarized.     

Motor function in microgravity: movement in weightlessness

Microgravity provides unique, though experimentally challenging, opportunities to study motor control. A traditional research focus has been the effects of linear acceleration on vestibular responses to angular acceleration. Evidence is accumulating that the high-frequency vestibulo-ocular reflex (VOR) is not affected by transitions from a 1 g linear force field to microgravity (<1 g); however, it appears that the three-dimensional organization of the VOR is dependent on gravitoinertial force levels. Some of the observed effects of microgravity on head and arm movement control appear to depend on the previously undetected inputs of cervical and brachial proprioception, which change almost immediately in response to alterations in background force levels. Recent studies of post-flight disturbances of posture and locomotion are revealing sensorimotor mechanisms that adjust over periods ranging from hours to weeks.