Preferential incorporation of tubulin into the junctional region of ciliary outer doublet microtubules: a model for treadmilling by lattice dislocation

Even in the presence of colchicine or Taxol(R), sea urchin embryonic cilia undergo substantial steady-state turnover, with a rate of tubulin incorporation approaching half that seen in full regeneration [Stephens: Mol Biol Cell 8:2187-2198, 1997]. Preliminary experiments suggest that tubulin incorporates differentially into the most stable portion of the outer doublet, the junctional protofilaments [Stephens: Cell Struct Funct 24:413-418, 1999]. To explore this possibility further, embryos of the sea urchin Tripneustes gratilla, a ciliary length inducible system [Stephens: J Exp Zool 269:106-115, 1994a], were pulse labeled with (3)H leucine during steady-state turnover or induced elongation, followed by regeneration in the presence of unlabeled leucine. Cilia were isolated by hypertonic shock and fractionated into detergent-soluble membrane plus matrix, thermally-solubilized microtubule walls, and insoluble 9-fold symmetric remnants of A-B junctional protofilaments plus associated architectural elements. The fractions were resolved by SDS-PAGE and the specific activity of alpha-tubulin was determined. In cilia undergoing turnover or elongation during an isotope pulse, the specific activity of tubulin in the junctional region approximated that of precursor membrane plus matrix tubulin but surpassed that of the tubule wall by a factor of approximately 1.5. In cilia regenerated during an isotope chase, the specific activity of junctional tubulin exceeded that of both the membrane plus matrix and the tubule wall by a similar factor. These data indicate that tubulin is preferentially incorporated into junctional protofilaments during steady-state turnover, induced elongation and regeneration. A model for directional incorporation based on surface lattice discontinuities in the outer doublet is proposed.     

Synthesis and Turnover of Embryonic Sea Urchin Ciliary Proteins during Selective Inhibition of Tubulin Synthesis and Assembly

When ciliogenesis first occurs in sea urchin embryos, the major building block proteins, tubulin and dynein, exist in substantial pools, but most 9+2 architectural proteins must be synthesized de novo. Pulse-chase labeling with [³H]leucine demonstrates that these proteins are coordinately up-regulated in response to deciliation so that regeneration ensues and the tubulin and dynein pools are replenished. Protein labeling and incorporation into already-assembled cilia is high, indicating constitutive ciliary gene expression and steady-state turnover. To determine whether either the synthesis of tubulin or the size of its available pool is coupled to the synthesis or turnover of the other 9+2 proteins in some feedback manner, fully-ciliated mid- or late-gastrula stage Strongylocentrotus droebachiensis embryos were pulse labeled in the presence of colchicine or taxol at concentrations that block ciliary growth. As a consequence of tubulin autoregulation mediated by increased free tubulin, no labeling of ciliary tubulin occurred in colchicine-treated embryos. However, most other proteins were labeled and incorporated into steady-state cilia at near-control levels in the presence of colchicine or taxol. With taxol, tubulin was labeled as well. An axoneme-associated 78 kDa cognate of the molecular chaperone HSP70 correlated with length during regeneration; neither colchicine nor taxol influenced the association of this protein in steady-state cilia. These data indicate that 1) ciliary protein synthesis and turnover is independent of tubulin synthesis or tubulin pool size; 2) steady-state incorporation of labeled proteins cannot be due to formation or elongation of cilia; 3) substantial tubulin exchange takes place in fully-motile cilia; and 4) chaperone presence and association in steady-state cilia is independent of background ciliogenesis, tubulin synthesis, and tubulin assembly state.     

Ciliary protein turnover continues in the presence of inhibitors of golgi function: evidence for membrane protein pools and unconventional intracellular membrane dynamics

The intimate association of the Golgi apparatus with cilia suggests a functional alliance. To explore the relationship between the synthesis and processing of membrane constituents and the turnover or regeneration of cilia, parallel cultures of gastrula-stage sea urchin embryos were pulse-chase labeled with (3)H-leucine in the presence of monensin, brefeldin A, or colchicine. Steady-state labeled cilia were isolated, and the embryos were allowed to regenerate cilia, which were then isolated after the equivalent of two normal regeneration times. Regeneration was absent in colchicine, minimal in monensin, and inhibited about 40% by brefeldin A. Both monensin and brefeldin A effectively inhibited the post-translational processing of prominent phosphatidylinositoylated and palmitoylated membrane proteins and the axoneme-associated transmembrane Spec3 protein, yet most other membrane plus matrix and 9+2 axonemal proteins were labeled to levels indistinguishable from untreated controls. However, total protein analysis of the membrane plus matrix fractions showed a substantial increase in glycoproteins and the calsequestrin-like protein ECaSt/PDI after treatment at steady-state with all three inhibitors and after regeneration in brefeldin A. Other constituents of this compartment, such as membrane-associated tubulin, calmodulin, and a 53-kDa calcium-binding protein, were unchanged. Therefore, inhibition of Golgi function via three different mechanisms left 9+2 protein turnover undiminished but resulted in an accumulation, in the cilium, of already-processed membrane pool constituents and a normally ER-resident protein. A disproportionate elevation of HSP70 suggests that a novel stress response may be involved in inhibiting ciliary regeneration or promoting glycoprotein augmentation.     

The in vitro assembly of flagellar outer doublet tubulin

Flagellar outer doublet microtubules were solubilized by use of sonication, and the tubulin was reassembled in vitro into single microtubules containing 14 and 15 protofilaments. The tubulin assembly was dependent on both the KCl and tubulin concentrations, exhibiting a critical concentration of 0.72 mg/ml at optimum solvent conditions. Flagellar tubulin was purified by cycles of temperature-dependent assembly-disassembly and molecular sieve chromatography, and characterized by two-dimensional gel electrophoresis. Although doublet microtubules were not formed in vitro, outer doublet tubulin assembled onto intact A- and B-subfibers of outer doublet microtubules and basal bodies of Chlamydomonas; the rate of assembly from the distal ends of these structures was greater than that from the proximal ends. Microtubule-associated proteins (MAPs) from mammalian brain stimulated outer doublet tubulin assembly, decorating the microtubules with fine filamentous projections.     

Microtubule structure at improved resolution.

Microtubule architecture can vary with eukaryotic species, with different cell types, and with the presence of stabilizing agents. For in vitro assembled microtubules, the average number of protofilaments is reduced by the presence of sarcodictyin A, epothilone B, and eleutherobin (similarly to taxol) but increased by taxotere. Assembly with a slowly hydrolyzable GTP analogue GMPCPP is known to give 96% 14 protofilament microtubules. We have used electron cryomicroscopy and helical reconstruction techniques to obtain three-dimensional maps of taxotere and GMPCPP microtubules incorporating data to 14 A resolution. The dimer packing within the microtubule wall is examined by docking the tubulin crystal structure into these improved microtubule maps. The docked tubulin and simulated images calculated from "atomic resolution" microtubule models show tubulin heterodimers are aligned head to tail along the protofilaments with the beta subunit capping the microtubule plus end. The relative positions of tubulin dimers in neighboring protofilaments are the same for both types of microtubule, confirming that conserved lateral interactions between tubulin subunits are responsible for the surface lattice accommodation observed for different microtubule architectures. Microtubules with unconventional protofilament numbers that exist in vivo are likely to have the same surface lattice organizations found in vitro. A curved "GDP" tubulin conformation induced by stathmin-like proteins appears to weaken lateral contacts between tubulin subunits and could block microtubule assembly or favor disassembly. We conclude that lateral contacts between tubulin subunits in neighboring protofilaments have a decisive role for microtubule stability, rigidity, and architecture.     

Flagellar protein dynamics in Chlamydomonas

Cilia and flagella appear to be stable, terminal, microtubule-containing organelles, but they also elongate and shorten in response to a variety of signals. To understand mechanisms that regulate flagellar dynamics, Chlamydomonas cells with nongrowing flagella were labeled with (35)S, and flagella and basal body components were examined for labeled polypeptides. Maximal incorporation of label into the flagella occurred within 3 h. Twenty percent of the flagellar polypeptides were exchanged. These included tubulins, dyneins, and 80 other axonemal and membrane plus matrix polypeptides. The most stable flagellar structure is the PF-ribbon, which comprises part of the wall of each doublet microtubule and is composed of tubulin and three other polypeptides. Most (35)S was incorporated into the high molecular weight ribbon polypeptide, rib240, and little, if any, (35)S is incorporated into PF-ribbon-associated tubulin. Both wild-type (9 + 2) and 9 + 0 flagella, which lack central microtubules, exhibited nearly identical exchange patterns, so labeling is not due to turnover of relatively labile central microtubules. To determine if flagellar length is balanced by protein exchange, (35)S incorporation into disassembling flagella was examined, as was exchange in flagella in which microtubule assembly was blocked by colchicine. Incorporation of (35)S-labeled polypeptides was found to occur into flagellar axonemes during wavelength-dependent shortening in pf18 and in fla10 cells induced to shorten flagella by incubation at 33 degrees C. Colchicine blocked tubulin addition but did not affect the exchange of the other exchangeable polypeptides; nor did it induce any change in flagellar length. Basal bodies also incorporated newly synthesized proteins. These data reveal that Chlamydomonas flagella are dynamic structures that incorporate new protein both during steady state and as flagella shorten and that protein exchange does not, alone, explain length regulation.     

Ciliary protein conservation during development in the ciliated protozoan, Oxytricha

The ciliated protozoan Oxytricha fallax possesses multiple highly localized clusters of basal bodies and cilia, all of which are broken down and rebuilt during prefission morphogenesis-with one major exception. The adoral zone of membranelles (AZM) of the ciliate oral apparatus contains approximately 1,500-2,000 basal bodies and cilia, and it is the only compound ciliary structure that is passed morphologically intact to one daughter cell at each cell division. By labeling all proteins in cells, and then picking the one daughter cell possessing the original labeled AZM, we could then evaluate whether or not the ciliary proteins of the AZM were diluted (i.e., either by degradation to constituent amino acids or by subunit exchange) during cell division. Autoradiographic analysis demonstrated that the label was highly conserved in the AZM (i.e., we saw no evidence of turnover), and electrophoretic data illustrate that at least one of the proteins of the AZM is tubulin. We, therefore, conclude that for at least some of the ciliary and basal body proteins of Oxytricha fallax, AZM morphological conservation is essentially equivalent to molecular conservation.     

Deuterium oxide promotes assembly and bundling of FtsZ protofilaments

The assembly and bundling of FtsZ protofilaments play an important role during bacterial cell division. Deuterium oxide (D2O) is known to have strong stabilization effects on the assembly dynamics of several proteins including tubulin, a homologue of FtsZ. Here, we found that D2O enhanced the light-scattering intensity of the assembly reaction, increased sedimentable polymer mass, and induced bundling of FtsZ protofilaments. D2O also increased the stability of FtsZ polymers under challenged GTP conditions and suppressed dilution-induced disassembly of protofilaments. D2O enhances the assembly parameters of FtsZ and microtubules albeit differently. For example, D2O induced bundling of FtsZ protofilaments, whereas it did not induce bundling of microtubules in vitro. In addition, D2O strongly suppressed the GTP hydrolysis rate of microtubules, but it had no effect on the initial rate of GTP hydrolysis of the FtsZ assembly. D2O (80%) also increased the helical content of FtsZ by 25% compared to the helical content of FtsZ in aqueous buffer. D2O was shown to reduce the binding of 4,4'-dianilino-1,1'-binaphthyl-5,5'-disulfonic acid (bis-ANS) to tubulin. In contrast, we found that D2O strongly enhanced the binding of bis-ANS to FtsZ. The results indicated that D2O promotes assembly and bundling of FtsZ protofilaments by increasing hydrophobic interactions between the protofilaments. The results also suggest that the phosphate release rather than the on-site GTP hydrolysis is the rate-limiting step of the GTP turnover reaction.     

Straight GDP-tubulin protofilaments form in the presence of taxol

Microtubules exist in dynamic equilibrium, growing and shrinking by the addition or loss of tubulin dimers from the ends of protofilaments. The hydrolysis of GTP in beta-tubulin destabilizes the microtubule lattice by increasing the curvature of protofilaments in the microtubule and putting strain on the lattice. The observation that protofilament curvature depends on GTP hydrolysis suggests that microtubule destabilizers and stabilizers work by modulating the curvature of the microtubule lattice itself. Indeed, the microtubule destabilizer MCAK has been shown to increase the curvature of protofilaments during depolymerization. Here, we show that the atomic force microscopy (AFM) of individual tubulin protofilaments provides sufficient resolution to allow the imaging of single protofilaments in their native environment. By using this assay, we confirm previous results for the effects of GTP hydrolysis and MCAK on the conformation of protofilaments. We go on to show that taxol stabilizes microtubules by straightening the GDP protofilament and slowing down the transition of protofilaments from straight to a curved configuration.     

Reassembly of flagellar B (alpha beta) tubulin into singlet microtubules: consequences for cytoplasmic microtubule structure and assembly

B(alpha beta) tubulin was obtained from a homogeneous class of microtubules, the incomplete B subfiber of sea urchin sperm flagellar doublet microtubules, by thermal fractionation. The thermally derived soluble B tubulin fraction (100, 000 g-h) repolymerizes in vitro, yielding microtubule-like structures. The microtubule-associated protein (MAP) composition and certain assembly parameters of thermally derived B tubulin are different from those reported for sonication- derived flageller tubulin and purified vertebrate tubulin. The "microtubules" reassembled from thermally prepared B tubulin are composed of 12-15 protofilaments (73% possess 14 protofilaments). A certain number possess a single "adlumenal component" applied to their inside walls, regardless of the number of protofilaments. Following the first cycle of polymerization, 81% of the B tubulin and essentially 100% of the MAPs remain cold insoluble. Evidence suggests that B tubulin assembles faithfully into a B lattice, creating a j seam between two protofilaments that are laterally bonded in a A-lattice configuration. The significance of these seams is discussed in relation to the mechanism of microtubule assembly, the stability of observed ribbons of protofilaments, and the three-dimensional organization of microtubule-associated components.     

CHLAMYDOMONAS FLAGELLA : II. The Distribution of Tubulins 1 and 2 in the Outer Doublet Microtubules

Quantitative ultrastructural analysis and quantitative gel electrophoresis of preparations of selectively solubilized Chlamydomonas outer doublets indicated that tubulins 1 and 2 were present in both the A tubule and the B tubule, and that only tubulin 1 was present in the three protofilaments which form the wall ("partition") between the lumens of the A and B tubules. The data suggested that the remaining protofilaments of the outer doublet were grouped together in pairs containing the same type of tubulin, pairs containing tubulin 1 alternating with pairs containing tubulin 2. These findings were used to construct models for the arrangement of the two tubulins in the outer doublet. Further analysis by isoelectric focusing resolved tubulins 1 and 2 into at least five bands.     

Flagellar doublet microtubules: fractionation of minor components and alpha-tubulin from specific regions of the A-tubule.

Proteins occurring minor amounts with purified sperm flagellar doublet microtubules were identified and studied by SDS-gel electrophoresis. Methods were developed to solubilize selectively these minor components; electron microscopy (EM) of the fractionated products revealed possible locations of these proteins in the tubule. Doublet microtubules were prepared from sea-urchin (Echinus esculentus and Stronglyocentrotus droebachiensis) and scallop (Pecten maximus) sperm by dialysing flagellar axonemes against 2 mM Tris-0-2 mM EDTA-0-5 mM DTT. EM indicates that these doublet tubule preparations retain at least 70% of their radial spokes; cross-sections show a globule or fibre applied to the inside wall of the A-tubule, across from the inner B-tubule junction. On SDS-gels these preparations separate into at least 10 minor bands, accounting for 20-30% of the total protein; the remaining 75 +/- 4% migrates as tubulin. For E. esculentus the molecular weights and relative amounts of these components are: Component Ee 8 (150000 Daltons; 1%), 11 (114000; 2-5%), 15 (89000; 2%), 16 (80000; 2-5%), 17 (74000; 2%), 18 (69000; 2%), 19 (66000; 2%), 21 (48000; 4-5%), 22 (45000; 3%) and 23 (44500; 3%). Treatment of sea-urchin tubules with 0-1-0-5% sarkosyl, 0-1-0-3 M KSCN or 0-3-0-6 M KI results in the selective solubilization of: first, component 8 and some B-subfibre tubulin; second, components 11 and 23 and the remaining B-subfire tubulin; third, most of the A-subfire tubulin and components 17, 18 and 19. Thermal fractionation extracts none of these components, suggesting they are principally associated with the A-tubule. Finally 25-35% of the original protein is resistant to solubilization, and appears in the EM as ribbons of 3 protofilaments with 16-nm axial repeats. The resistant ribbons contain components 15, 16, 21 and 22 (plus component 20 in S. droebachiensis) in addition to 25 +/- 4% of the total tubulin. The data support the existence of two stable moieties in each doublet tubule: (1) a ribbon of 3 protofilaments and (2) either a second ribbon of 3 protofilaments or an equivalent amount of tubulin in some other form. EM images suggest that one ribbon forms the lateral side of the A-tubule (e.g. protofilaments A1,2,3 or A13,1,2 in the model) and that the globule applied to A13 may be a multisubunit complex of remaining minor components. Treatment of scallop tubules with 0-3 M KSCN preferentially extracts alpha-tubulin, yielding ribbons 1-4 protofilaments wide. The significance of this finding is discussed.     

Rapid tubulin synthesis during ciliated cell differentiation

Using pulse-chase conditions in culture we have investigated the incorporation of 3H-leucine into tubulin of isolated oviducts from 5 day-old mice. Label appears in soluble, particulate and axonemal fractions minutes after incubation. In the latter two fractions, but not in the soluble fraction, this label is rapidly diluted under chase conditions. The data do not fit a simple model of sequential transfer of radioactively labeled, newly synthesized tubulin from a soluble fraction through centriole precursors to assembled ciliary axonemes.     

Regulation of Cortical Proteins in Euplotes*

SYNOPSIS. A method of isolating cortical organelles from single specimens of Euplotes eurystomus, involving lysis in an induced electric current, is described. The isolation technic was coupled with radioautography to study the patterns of incorporation and conservation of labeled proteins in the membranellar band (MB). Isolated single cells of known age were followed thru one or more divisions. A method of distinguishing between daughter cells (proters and opisthes) at division was utilized in some experiments. The old MB, which is apparently morphostatic, incorporates significant amounts of labeled proteins. The pattern of incorporation in total cell proteins at the 1st and 2nd divisions after pulse-chase indicates that the levels of incorporation among daughter cells is equivalent. However, at the 1st division after pulse-chase, the new (opisthe) MB is generally more heavily labeled than the old (proter) MB, and at the 2nd and 3rd divisions new MBs incorporate less label as their development is farther removed in time from the beginning of the chase. The higher level of incorporation in the MB of the 1st division opisthe is maintained thru subsequent divisions, indicating that in Euplotes proteins of the MB are relatively stable.     

Probing in vivo metabolism by stable isotope labeling of storage lipids and proteins in developing Brassica napus embryos

Developing embryos of Brassica napus accumulate both triacylglycerols and proteins as major storage reserves. To evaluate metabolic fluxes during embryo development, we have established conditions for stable isotope labeling of cultured embryos under steady-state conditions. Sucrose supplied via the endosperm is considered to be the main carbon and energy source for seed metabolism. However, in addition to 220 to 270 mM carbohydrates (sucrose, glucose, and fructose), analysis of endosperm liquid revealed up to 70 mM amino acids as well as 6 to 15 mM malic acid. Therefore, a labeling approach with multiple carbon sources is a precondition to quantitatively reflect fluxes of central carbon metabolism in developing embryos. Mid-cotyledon stage B. napus embryos were dissected from plants and cultured for 15 d on a complex liquid medium containing (13)C-labeled carbohydrates. The (13)C enrichment of fatty acids and amino acids (after hydrolysis of the seed proteins) was determined by gas chromatography/mass spectrometry. Analysis of (13)C isotope isomers of labeled fatty acids and plastid-derived amino acids indicated that direct glycolysis provides at least 90% of precursors of plastid acetyl-coenzyme A (CoA). Unlabeled amino acids, when added to the growth medium, did not reduce incorporation of (13)C label into plastid-formed fatty acids, but substantially diluted (13)C label in seed protein. Approximately 30% of carbon in seed protein was derived from exogenous amino acids and as a consequence, the use of amino acids as a carbon source may have significant influence on the total carbon and energy balance in seed metabolism. (13)C label in the terminal acetate units of C(20) and C(22) fatty acids that derive from cytosolic acetyl-CoA was also significantly diluted by unlabeled amino acids. We conclude that cytosolic acetyl-CoA has a more complex biogenetic origin than plastidic acetyl-CoA. Malic acid in the growth medium did not dilute (13)C label incorporation into fatty acids or proteins and can be ruled out as a source of carbon for the major storage components of B. napus embryos.     

Cytoskeletal proteins of the cell surface in Tetrahymena : II. Turnover of major proteins

The turnover of surface membrane-associated cytoskeletal proteins has been studied in Tetrahymena. These proteins undergo rapid turnover and appear to be in equilibrium with precursor pools within the cytosol. Carefully controlled pulse-chase experiments, alone and in combination with cycloheximide, have shown that labeled proteins accumulated in the cytoskeleton after they were no longer being synthesized within the cell. The movement of subunits from the cytoskeleton to the cytosol was also demonstrated using tubulin isolated from these two compartments within the cell.     

Changes in the hydrodynamic properties of microtubules induced by taxol

Microtubule assembly was followed and monitored by (1) the turbidity at 350 nm, (2) the weight of the pelleted microtubules, (3) linear dichroism, LD tau, of the turbidity upon flow orientation, (4) the specific viscosity, eta spec, and (5) electron microscopy. These five methods showed the same features for normal microtubule assembly, but were different in the presence of taxol, a drug which binds to tubulin. The The apparent steady state of microtubule assembly in the presence of taxol as found by turbidity or the weight of pelleted polymer did not represent a stable state, as both LD tau and eta spec continued to change for a much longer time. Microtubules assembled in the presence of taxol from microtubule proteins as well as from purified tubulin were difficult to orient, as high flow gradients were needed and the maximal LD tau value represented only 20% of the LD tau for normal microtubules. In contrast to the slow relaxation of normal microtubules, rapid relaxation to random orientation was found in the presence of taxol. Low orientability was also indicated by electron micrographs, in which pelleted microtubules were seen to be randomly oriented in the presence of taxol. Taxol induced a very high eta spec, 4-times the steady-state value in the initial phase of assembly, which slowly declined again to a steady state, an effect which was also found for assembly of purified tubulin assembled in the absence of the microtubule-associated proteins. The presence of taxol did not change the relative amount and composition of the microtubule-associated proteins in the assembled microtubules. The results therefore suggest that taxol alters the hydrodynamic properties of the microtubules due to its interaction with tubulin and that this alteration is not an effect of the microtubule-associated proteins.     

Low resolution structure of microtubules in solution. Synchrotron X-ray scattering and electron microscopy of taxol-induced microtubules assembled from purified tubulin in comparison with glycerol and MAP-induced microtubules.

The structure of microtubules has been characterized to 3 nm resolution employing time-resolved X-ray scattering. This has revealed detailed structural features of microtubules not observed before in solution. The polymerization of highly purified tubulin, induced by the antitumour drug taxol, has been employed as a microtubule model system. This assembly reaction requires Mg2+, is optimal at a 1:1 taxol to tubulin heterodimer molar ratio, proceeds with GTP or GDP and is intrinsically reversible. The X-ray scattering profiles are consistent with identical non-globular alpha and beta-tubulin monomers ordered within the known helical surface lattice of microtubules. Purified tubulin-taxol microtubules have a smaller mean diameter (approx. 22 nm) than those induced by microtubule associated proteins or glycerol (approx. 24 nm), but nearly identical wall substructure to the resolution of the measurements. This is because the majority of the former consist of only 12 protofilaments instead of the typical 13 protofilaments, as confirmed by electron microscopy of thin-sectioned, negatively stained and ice-embedded taxol microtubules. It may be concluded that taxol induces a slight reduction of the lateral contact curvature between tubulin monomers. The main fringe pattern observed in cryo-electron micrographs is consistent with a simple 12 protofilament 3-start skewed lattice model. Cylindrical closure of this lattice can be achieved by tilting the lattice 0.8 degrees with respect to the microtubule axis. The closure implies a discontinuity in the type of lateral contacts between the tubulin monomers (regardless of whether these are of the -alpha-beta- or the -alpha-alpha-/-beta-beta- type), which indicates that lateral contacts and the subunit specificity of taxol binding are, to a large degree, equivalent.