A Study of øX-174 DNA Torus and Lambda DNA Torus Tertiary Structure and the Implications For DNA Self-Assembly

Abstract

Hydrated torus shaped complexes were examined by transmission electron microscopy in both spermidine-condensed linear and nicked circular øX-174 DNA and lambda DNA preparations. Freeze-etch replicas of both these torus samples, produced with very low Pt metal deposition levels (9APt/C), were found to have circumferentially wound single DNA double helix size surface fibers in the range of 30A width. Measurements of torus inner and outer circumference as well as ring thickness were performed. Observed differences in the torus dimension distributions from circular øX-174 DNA and linear øX ?174 DNA may be related to the different topological constraints on DNA folding in these two samples (1). On the basis of annulus thickness measurements øX ?174 DNA toruses, in contrast to lambda DNA toruses, were observed to fall into two classes identified as being formed from monomer DNA condensation and multimer DNA condensation. All of the torus substructure and population dimensions observed here are consistent with the continuous circumferential DNA winding model of torus organization proposed by Marx and Reynolds (1) to explain the micrococcal nuclease cleavage properties of the toruses. End-on view measurements of the torus thickness were made from micrographs obtained by extensive tilting of the object replica. These direct measurements confirmed quaternary structure interpretations made from simple strand packing models. We compared the measured torus properties in this linear DNA size series (5386–48000 bp). With increasing DNA length the pattern of DNA strand self- assembly was found to be more varied producing lambda DNA toruses of varying shape. The relevance of our study to the problem of lambda bacteriophage DNA head packaging was discussed.     

Micrococcal nuclease digestion study of spermidine-condensed DNA

Spermidine-condensed lambda DNA tertiary structures have been studied by micrococcal nuclease digestion. Broad but discrete DNA bands were observed in gel electrophoresis experiments of digests at sizes of: 1003 +/- 115 bp, 1972 +/- 190 bp and 3100 +/- 350 bp. These bands comprise an arithmetic series, similar to, but larger than, arithmetic DNA band series sizes we have observed previously in calf thymus and phi x-174 DNA condensates. The 1003bp monomer lambda DNA band size corresponds to wrapping B DNA once circumferentially about the toroidal-shaped tertiary structures, the predominant condensed structures present in these preparations, and is consistent with the measured electron microscopic dimensions for hydrated lambda DNA toruses previously presented. DNA fragment length stability was determined by release from the digested condensates. Fragments of 80-85bp and sizes below are thermodynamically unstable in the lambda DNA condensates. This fragment size agrees well with a recent determination of the cooperativity size in DNA condensates.     

Ion competition and micrococcal nuclease digestion studies of spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA. Evidence for torus organization by circumferential DNA wrapping

Spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA structures have been studied by ion competition using a sedimentation assay and by micrococcal nuclease digestion. Competitor ions Mg2+, Ca2+ and putrescine2+ show specific ion effects; but all three appear to affect the DNA condensation-decondensation equilibrium caused by spermidine3+ in a qualitatively similar manner, suggesting the spermidine3+-DNA interaction is largely electrostatic. Our data show a hysteresis in condensation and decondensation transition directions. We interpret this in terms of a kinetic block in the condensation direction with decondensation representing the equilibrium state of the system. These results agree with results obtained from related systems using different measurement techniques. Micrococcal nuclease digestion of spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA produces broad but discrete bands in gel electrophoresis experiments. At least two bands determined to be 760 +/- 87 bp and 1355 +/- 135 bp, possess the size ratio 1:1.8 +/- 0.4 consistent with their forming the monomer and dimer fragments of an arithmetic band series. We rationalize this result in terms of a localized micrococcal nuclease cleavage model of circumferentially-wrapped DNA toruses proposed previously by Marx, K.A. and Reynolds, T.C. (Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (1982) 79, 6484-6488). The arithmetic series monomer band (760 +/- 87 bp), corresponding to wrapping B DNA once circumferentially about the torus, is in agreement with the electron microscopic measurements of hydrated calf thymus DNA torus circumferences presented by Marx, K.A. and Ruben, G.C. (Nucleic Acids Res. (1983) 11, 1839-1853).     

Rifampicin-resistant initiation of DNA synthesis on the isolated strands of ColE plasmid DNA.

The opposite strands of the ColE1 and ColE3 plasmids were isolated as circular single-stranded DNA molecules. These molecules were compared with M13 and phi X174 viral DNA with respect to their capacity to function as templates for in vitro DNA synthesis by a replication enzyme fraction from Escherichia coli. It was found for both ColE plasmids that the conversion of H as well as L strands to duplex DNA molecules closely resembles phi X174 complementary strand synthesis and occurs by a rifampicin-resistant priming mechanism involving the dnaB, dnaC, and dnaG gene products. Restriction analysis of partially double-stranded intermediates indicates that preferred start sites for DNA synthesis are present on both strands of the ColE1 HaeII-C fragment. Inspection of the nucleotide sequence of this region reveals structural similarities with the origin of phi X174 complementary strand synthesis. We propose that the rifampicin-resistant initiation site (rri) in the ColE1 L strand is required for the priming of discontinuous lagging strand synthesis during vegetative replication and that the rri site in the H strand is involved in the initiation of L strand synthesis during conjugative transfer.     

φX-174 Bacteriophage Structural Mutants Which Affect Deoxyribonucleic Acid Synthesis

Seven cistrons in X-174 were identified and one in particular was studied intensively: cistron A, which is assigned a protein in the mature phage. Amber mutants in this cistron synthesize a new deoxyribonucleic acid (DNA) form in addition to circular phage DNA upon infection of the restrictive host. This DNA is linear, non-infectious, and single-stranded; it is formed from the phage strand of replicative form X-174 DNA. These mutants produce two different defective particles in the restrictive host. One particle contains circular phage DNA but is not infectious; the other contains the new DNA form and is similar to the 70S particles found in wild-type phage lysates. The mutant A gene product acts independently of normal A protein upon mixed infection of the restrictive host with an A mutant and a mutant from any other cistron or wild type.     

Ion competition and micrococcal nuclease digestion studies of spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA: Evidence for torus organization by circumferential DNA wrapping

Spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA structures have been studied by ion competition using a sedimentation assay and by micrococcal nuclease digestion. Competitor ions Mg²⁺, Ca²⁺ and putrescine²⁺ show specific ion effects; but all three appear to affect the DNA condensation-decondensation equilibrium caused by spermidine³⁺ in a qualitatively similar manner, suggesting the spermidine³⁺-DNA interaction is largely electrostatic. Our data show a hysteresis in condensation and decondensation transition directions. We interpret this in terms of a kinetic block in the condensation direction with decondensation representing the equilibrium state of the system. These results agree with results obtained from related systems using different measurement techniques. Micrococcal nuclease digestion of spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA produces broad but discrete bands in gel electrophoresis experiments. At least two bands determined to be 760 ± 87 bp and 1355 ± 135 bp, possess the size ratio 1:1.8 ± 0.4 consistent with their forming the monomer and dimer fragments of an arithmetic band series. We rationalize this result in terms of a localized micrococcal nuclease cleavage model of circumferentially-wrapped DNA toruses proposed previously by Marx, K.A. and Reynolds, T.C. (Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. (1982) 79, 6484–6488). The arithmetic series monomer band (760 ± 87 bp), corresponding to wrapping B̄ DNA once circumferentially about the torus, is in agreement with the electron microscopic measurements of hydrated calf thymus DNA torus circumferences presented by Marx, K.A. and Ruben, G.C. (Nucleic Acids Res. (1983) 11, 1839–1853).     

Processing of mispaired and unpaired bases in heteroduplex DNA in E. coli

Bacteriophage lambda and phi X 174 DNAs, carrying sequenced mutations, have been used to construct in vitro defined species of heteroduplex DNA. Such heteroduplex DNAs were introduced by transfection, as single copies, into E. coli host cells. The progeny of individual heteroduplex molecules from each infective center was analyzed. The effect of the presence of GATC sequences (phi X 174 system) and of their methylation (lambda system) was tested. The following conclusions can be drawn: some mismatched base pairs trigger the process of mismatch repair, causing a localized strand-to-strand information transfer in heteroduplex DNA: transition mismatches G:T and A:C are efficiently repaired, whereas the six transversion mismatches are not always readily recognized and/or repaired. The recognition of transversion mismatches appears to depend on the neighbouring nucleotide sequence; single unpaired bases (frameshift mutation "mismatches") are recognized and repaired, some equally efficiently on both strands (longer and shorter), some more efficiently on the shorter (-1) strand; large non-homologies (about 800 bases) are not repaired by the Mut H, L, S, U system, but some other process repairs the non-homology with a relatively low efficiency; full methylation of GATC sequences inhibits mismatch repair on the methylated strand: this is the chemical basis of strand discrimination (old/new) in mismatch correction; unmethylated GATC sequences appear to improve mismatch repair of a G:T mismatch in phi X 174 DNA, but there may be some residual mismatch repair in GATC-free phi X 174, at least for some mismatches.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Evidence for hydrated spermidine-calf thymus DNA toruses organized by circumferential DNA wrapping

In spermidine-condensed calf thymus DNA preparations, torus-shaped condensates were shown by transmission electron microscopy to exist under the hydrated conditions of the freeze fracture experiment. Using extremely low Pt metal deposition levels (9 A Pt/C) high-contrast replicas of the spermidine-DNA toruses were obtained that showed circumferential wrapping of single DNA double helix-size surface fibres. Stereoscopic analysis of high magnification stereomicrographs established some details of the three-dimensional organization of two DNA double helix sections winding circumferentially on the inner surface of one such torus. These measurements demonstrate the usefulness of stereoscopic analysis of these high macromolecular organization magnification. Measurements on a number of torus-shaped complexes (n = 16) yielded these average dimensions: inner circumference (1840 +/- 204 A) outer circumference (2800 +/- 222 A), torus ring thickness (143 +/- 18 A). These data support a continuous circumferential DNA-winding model of torus organization proposed by Marx & Reynolds.     

DNA sequences which support activities of the bacteriophage phi X174 gene A protein

The DNA sequence of 30 nucleotides which surrounds the origin of viral strand DNA replication is highly conserved amongst the icosahedral single-stranded DNA bacteriophages. The A gene of these phages encodes a protein which is required for initiation and termination of viral strand DNA synthesis and acts as a nicking-closing activity specifically within this 30-nucleotide sequence. A system of purified Escherichia coli host proteins and phi X174 gene A protein has been developed which specifically replicates in vitro the viral strand of phi X174 from RF (replicative form) I template DNA and yields single-stranded circular DNA products (RF leads to SS(c) DNA replication system). Recombinant plasmids carrying inserts derived from phage phi X174 or G4 DNA which range in length from 49 to 1175 base pairs and contain the 30-nucleotide conserved sequence have been shown to support phi X A protein-dependent DNA synthesis in vitro in this replication system. We report here that insertion of the 30-nucleotide sequence alone into pBR322 allows the resulting recombinant plasmids to support phi X A protein-dependent in vitro DNA synthesis as efficiently as phi X174 template DNA in the RF leads to SS(c) replication system. The 30-nucleotide sequence functions as a fully wild type DNA replication origin as determined by the rate of DNA synthesis and the structure of resulting DNA products. Furthermore, the DNA sequence requirements for nicking of RF I DNA by the phi X A protein and for supporting replication origin function have been partially separated. Homology to positions 1, 29, and 30 of the 30-nucleotide conserved sequence are not required for cleavage of RF I DNA by the A protein; homology to position 1 but not 29 or 30 is required for efficient DNA replication.     

Homologous pairing of DNA molecules promoted by a protein from Ustilago

A protein from mitotic cells of Ustilago maydis was purified on the basis of its ability to reanneal complementary single strands of DNA. The protein catalyzed the uptake of linear single strands by super-helical DNA, but only in reactions with homologous combinations of single-strand fragments and super-helical DNA from phages phi X174 and fd. No reaction occurred with heterologous combinations. The protein also efficiently paired circular single strands and linear duplex DNA molecules. The product was a joint molecule in which the circular single strand displaced one strand of the duplex. Efficient pairing depended upon ATP, and ATPase activity was found associated with the purified protein. ATP-dependent reannealing of complementary single strands was not detectable in the rec1 mutant of Ustilago, which is deranged in meiotic recombination, as complete tetrads are rare, and is defective in radiation-induced mitotic gene conversion.     

Studies on the phi X174 gene A protein-mediated termination of leading strand DNA synthesis

Recombinant RF (replicate form) I DNAs containing the bacteriophage phi X174 gene A protein-recognition sequence are cleaved by the phi X A protein yielding a phi X RF II X A protein complex (Zipursky, S.L., Reinberg, D., and Hurwitz, J. (1980) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 77, 5182-5186). Such complexes support DNA synthesis in both RF I leads to SS(c) and RF I leads to RF I phi X DNA replication reactions in vitro. Two phi X A protein-recognition sequences were inserted into plasmid pBR322. Both sequences were contiguous with the same strand of the vector DNA and separated by 667 and 4275 base pairs. This recombinant plasmid (G27-4) was cleaved by the phi X A protein at either insert and both inserts support the initiation of RF leads to SS(c) DNA synthesis. This was verified by the finding that replication products were circular molecules of 667 and 4275 nucleotides. This finding is in keeping with the multifunctional activities associated with the phi X A protein; these include the site-specific nicking of RF I DNA which initiates DNA synthesis and site-specific termination resulting in the circularization of the displaced DNA strand. The phi X A protein and the Escherichia coli rep and SSb proteins catalyze the unwinding of phi X RF I DNA in vitro (Scott, J.F., Eisenberg, S., Bertsch, L.L., and Kornberg, A. (1977) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 74, 193-197). Recombinant plasmid G27-4 RF I DNA was also unwound in vitro by this enzyme system; in this case, both circular and linear single-stranded DNA molecules of 667 and 4275 nucleotides, as well as full length circular single-stranded DNA were formed. Full length linear DNA was not detected. The two single-stranded circular DNA products formed as leading strands in RF leads to SS(c) reaction mixtures containing G27-4 RF I DNA differed in their ability to support lagging strand DNA synthesis. It was shown that the large single-stranded circular product included DNA sequences homologous to a replication factor Y effector sequence required for RF leads to RF and SS(c) leads to RF replication (Zipursky, S.L., and Marians, K.J. (1980) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 77, 6521-6525). The 4275-nucleotide, but not the 667-nucleotide, single-stranded circular DNA product was converted to a duplex structure.     

The bacteriophage lambda O and P protein initiators promote the replication of single-stranded DNA.

A soluble enzyme system that specifically initiates lambda dv plasmid DNA replication at a bacteriophage lambda replication origin [Wold et al. (1982) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 79, 6176-6180] is also capable of replicating the single-stranded circular chromosomes of phages M13 and phi X174 to a duplex form. This chain initiation on single-stranded templates is novel in that it is absolutely dependent on the lambda O and P protein chromosomal initiators and on several Escherichia coli proteins that are known to function in the replication of the lambda chromosome in vivo, including the host dnaB, dnaG (primase), dnaJ and dnaK replication proteins. Strand initiation occurs at multiple sites following an O and P protein-dependent pre-priming step in which the DNA is converted into an activated nucleoprotein complex containing the bacterial dnaB protein. We propose a scheme for the initiation of DNA synthesis on single-stranded templates in this enzyme system that may be relevant to strand initiation events that occur during replication of phage lambda in vivo.     

Selective cloning of a DNA single-strand initiation determinant from phi X174 replicative-form DNA.

An M13 phage deletion mutant, M13 delta E101, developed as a vector for selecting DNA sequences that direct DNA strand initiation on a single-stranded template, has been used for cloning restriction enzyme digests of phi X174 replicative-form DNA. Initiation determinants, detected on the basis of clear-plaque formation by the chimeric phage, were found only in restriction fragments containing the unique effector site in phi X174 DNA for the Escherichia coli protein n' dATPase (ATPase). Furthermore, these sequences were functional only when cloned in the orientation in which the phi X174 viral strand was joined to the M13 viral strand. A 181-nucleotide viral strand fragment containing this initiation determinant confers a phi X174-type complementary-strand replication mechanism on M13 chimeras. The chimeric phage is converted to the parental replicative form in vivo by a mechanism resistant to rifampin, a specific inhibitor of the normal RNA polymerase-dependent mechanism of M13. In vitro, the chimeric single-stranded DNA promotes the assembly of a functional multiprotein priming complex, or primosome, identical to that utilized by intact phi X174 viral strand DNA. Chimeric phage containing the sequence complementary to the 181-nucleotide viral strand sequence shows no initiation capability, either in vivo or in vitro.     

RNA-mediated specificity of DNA packaging into hybrid lambda/phi 29 proheads.

A small RNA (pRNA, 174 nt) is known to be essential for DNA packaging in bacteriophage phi 29. However, in an in vitro DNA packaging system based on hybrid lambda/phi 29 proheads (made up of head proteins from phage lambda and connectors from phage phi 29), the specificity of DNA packaging is lost, and different RNA molecules fulfil the requirements for DNA packaging, albeit with less efficiency than phi 29 pRNA. Competition assays with RNAs from different sources have shown that phi 29 connectors bind preferentially pRNA. An increase in the efficiency of phi 29 DNA packaging into hybrid proheads induced by phi 29 pRNA is observed because, when phi 29 pRNA is incubated with hybrid proheads, phi 29 DNA is packaged more efficiently than other DNAs of similar length. Furthermore, when hybrid proheads carrying phi 29 pRNA are incubated with a mixture of DNAs from different sources, phi 29 DNA is selectively packaged, thus indicating that phi 29 pRNA determines the specificity of DNA packaging.     

Circular and linear simian virus 40 DNAs differ in recombination.

Linear forms of simian virus 40 (SV40) DNA, when added to transfection mixtures containing circular SV40 and phi X174 RFI DNAs, enhanced the frequency of SV40/phi X174 recombination, as measured by infectious center in situ plaque hybridization in monkey BSC-1 cells. The sequences required for the enhancement of recombination by linear DNA reside within the SV40 replication origin/regulatory region (nucleotides 5,171 to 5,243/0 to 128). Linearization of phi X174 RFI DNA did not increase the recombination frequency. The SV40/phi X174 recombinant structures arising from transfections supplemented with linear forms of origin-containing SV40 DNA contained phi X174 DNA sequences interspersed within tandem head-to-tail repeats derived from the recombination-enhancing linear DNA. Evidence is presented that the tandem repeats are not formed by homologous recombination and that linear forms of SV40 DNA must compete with circular SV40 DNA for the available T antigen to enhance recombination. We propose that the enhancement of recombination by linear SV40 DNA results from the entry of that DNA into a rolling circle type of replication pathway which generates highly recombinogenic intermediates.     

Effects of genome size on bacteriophage phi X174 DNA packaging in vitro

Effects of the size of template DNA on the DNA packaging reaction of bacteriophage phi X174 were studied using plasmids of various sizes which contain the phi X174 origin of DNA replication and the in vitro phage synthesizing system (Aoyama, A., Hamatake, R. K., and Hayashi, M. (1983) Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 80, 4195-4199). DNA between 78.5% and 101% of the length of phi X174 DNA produced infectious particles efficiently. Packaging of DNA smaller or larger than this range produced uninfectious defective particles. Although these particles contained circular single-stranded DNA, they suffered structural changes which altered the sedimentation properties or the ability to adsorb to the cells. Mutant phage were found from the packaging reaction of DNA larger than 101% of phi X174 DNA. These mutants deleted the termination region of DNA, suggesting that they were produced by early termination of the phage synthesizing reaction.     

Mutagenesis at a specific position in a DNA sequence

Predefined changes in a known DNA sequence were introduced by a general method. Oligodeoxyribonucleotides complementary to positions 582 to 593 of the viral DNA strand of the bacteriophage phiX174 am3 mutant (pGTATCCTACAAA), and to the wild type sequence in this region (pGTATCCTACAAA), were synthesized and used as specific mutagens. Each of these oligonucleotides was incorporated into a complete circular complementary strand when used as primer on a genetically heterologous viral strand template, by the combined action of subtilisin-treated Escherichia coli DNA polymerase I and T4 DNA ligase. Incomplete duplexes were removed or were inactivated by nuclease S1 and the products were used to transfect spheroplasts of E. coli. Both oligonucleotides induced specific mutations at high efficiency when used with heterologous template (15% mutants among progeny phage). The am phages isolated by this procedure are phenotypically gene E mutants, and contain A at position 587 of the viral strand. They thus appear identical with am3 and provide evidence that the change G leads to A at position 587 is sufficient to produce a defective E function. Since the template for the induction of am mutants carried another genetic marker (sB1), the strains carrying the induced mutations have the new genotype am3 sB1. It should be possible to introduce the am3 mutation into any known mutant strain of phi174 using this same oligonucleotide. Both possible transition mutations were induced in these experiments. In principle, the method could also induce transversions, insertions, and deletions. The method should be applicable to other circular DNAs of similar size, for example recombinant DNA plasmids.     

Estrogens protect against hydrogen peroxide and arachidonic acid induced DNA damage

The ability of estrogens to protect against DNA damage induced by either hydrogen peroxide or arachidonic acid alone or in combination with Cu²⁺ was investigated. DNA strand breaks were determined by conversion of double stranded supercoiled ØX-174 RFI DNA to double stranded open circular DNA and linear single stranded DNA. Estradiol-17β significantly decreased the formation of single and double strand breaks in DNA induced by H₂O₂ alone or with Cu²⁺. Equilin (an equine estrogen) was more effective than estradiol-17β at the doses tested. Arachidonic acid in the presence of Cu²⁺ caused the formation of high levels of linear DNA which was protected by estrogen with equilen being more effective. These studies suggest that estrogens through this protective effect on DNA damage might contribute to cardioprotection.     

Enzymatic properties of the bacteriophage phi X174 A protein on superhelical phi X174 DNA: a model for the termination of the rolling circle DNA replication.

Incubation of phi X174 replication form I DNA with the A* protein of phi X174 in the presence of MN2+ results in the formation of three different types of DNA molecules: open circular form DNA (RFII), linear form DNA (RFIII) and the relaxed covalently closed form DNA (RFIV). The RFII and RFIII DNAs are shown to be A* protein-DNA complexes by electron microscopy using the protein labeling technique of Wu and Davidson (1). The linear double-stranded RFIII DNA molecule carries at one end a covalently attached A* protein whereas at the other end of the molecule the single-stranded termini are covalently linked to each other. The structure of the RFIII DNA shows its way of formation. The described properties of the A* protein indicate the way the larger A protein functions in the termination step of the rolling-circle type of phi X174 DNA replication.     

Effect of phi X C protein on leading strand DNA synthesis in the phi X174 replication pathway

The influence of the bacteriophage phi X174 (phi X) C protein on the replication of bacteriophage phi X174 DNA has been examined. This small viral protein, which is required for the packaging of phi X DNA into proheads, inhibits leading strand DNA synthesis. The inhibitory effect of the phi X C protein requires a DNA template bearing an intact 30-base pair (bp) phi X origin of DNA replication that is the target site recognized by the phi X A protein. Removal of nucleotides from the 3' end of this 30-bp conserved origin sequence prevents the inhibitory effects of the phi X C protein. Leading strand replication of supercoiled DNA substrates containing the wild-type phi X replication origin results in the production of single-stranded circular DNA as well as the formation of small amounts of multimeric and sigma structures. These aberrant products are formed when the termination and reinitiation steps of the replication pathway reactions are skipped as the replication fork moves through the origin sequence. Replication carried out in the presence of the phi X C protein leads to a marked decrease in these aberrant structures. While the exact mechanism of action of the phi X C protein is not clear, the results presented here suggest that the phi X C protein slows the movement of the replication fork through the 30-bp origin sequence, thereby increasing the fidelity of the termination and reinitiation reactions. In keeping with the requirement for the phi X C protein for efficient packaging of progeny phi X DNA into proheads, the phi X C protein-mediated inhibition of leading strand synthesis is reversed by the addition of proteins essential for phi X bacteriophage formation. Incubation of plasmid DNA substrates bearing mutant 30 base pair phi X origin sequences in the complete packaging system results in the in vitro packaging and production of infectious particles in a manner consistent with the replication activity of the origin under study.