Base pairing between Escherichia coli RNase P RNA and its substrate.

Base pairing between the substrate and the ribozyme has previously been shown to be essential for catalytic activity of most ribozymes, but not for RNase P RNA. By using compensatory mutations we have demonstrated the importance of Watson-Crick complementarity between two well-conserved residues in Escherichia coli RNase P RNA (M1 RNA), G292 and G293, and two residues in the substrate, +74C and +75C (the first and second C residues in CCA). We suggest that these nucleotides base pair (G292/+75C and G293/+74C) in the ribozyme-substrate complex and as a consequence the amino acid acceptor stem of the precursor is partly unfolded. Thus, a function of M1 RNA is to anchor the substrate through this base pairing, thereby exposing the cleavage site such that cleavage is accomplished at the correct position. Our data also suggest possible base pairing between U294 in M1 RNA and the discriminator base at position +73 of the precursor. Our findings are also discussed in terms of evolution.     

RNase P ribozymes selected in vitro to cleave a viral mRNA effectively inhibit its expression in cell culture

An in vitro selection procedure was used to select RNase P ribozyme variants that efficiently cleaved the sequence of the mRNA encoding thymidine kinase of herpes simplex virus 1. Of the 45 selected variants sequenced, 25 ribozymes carried a common mutation at nucleotides 224 and 225 of RNase P catalytic RNA from Escherichia coli (G(224)G(225) --> AA). These selected ribozymes exhibited at least 10 times higher cleavage efficiency (k(cat)/K(m)) than that derived from the wild type ribozyme. Our results suggest that the mutated A(224)A(225) are in close proximity to the substrate and enhance substrate binding of the ribozyme. When these ribozyme variants were expressed in herpes simplex virus 1-infected cells, the levels of thymidine kinase mRNA and protein were reduced by 95-99%. Our study provides the first direct evidence that RNase P ribozyme variants isolated by the selection procedure can be used for the construction of gene-targeting ribozymes that are highly effective in tissue culture. These results demonstrate the potential for using RNase P ribozymes as gene-targeting agents against any mRNA sequences, and using the selection procedure as a general approach for the engineering of RNase P ribozymes.     

Design of hairpin ribozyme variants with improved activity for poorly processed substrates

Application of ribozymes for knockdown of RNA targets requires the identification of suitable target sites according to the consensus sequence. For the hairpin ribozyme, this was originally defined as Y?2 N?1 *G+1 U+2 Y+3 B+?, with Y = U or C, and B = U, C or G, and C being the preferred nucleobase at positions -2 and +4. In the context of development of ribozymes for destruction of an oncogenic mRNA, we have designed ribozyme variants that efficiently process RNA substrates at U?2 G?1 *G+1 U+2 A+3 A+? sites. Substrates with G?1 *G+1 U+2 A+3 sites were previously shown to be processed by the wild-type hairpin ribozyme. However, our study demonstrates that, in the specific sequence context of the substrate studied herein, compensatory base changes in the ribozyme improve activity for cleavage (eight-fold) and ligation (100-fold). In particular, we show that A+3 and A+? are well tolerated if compensatory mutations are made at positions 6 and 7 of the ribozyme strand. Adenine at position +4 is neutralized by G? →U, owing to restoration of a Watson-Crick base pair in helix 1. In this ribozyme-substrate complex, adenine at position +3 is also tolerated, with a slightly decreased cleavage rate. Additional substitution of A? with uracil doubled the cleavage rate and restored ligation, which was lost in variants with A?, C? and G?. The ability to cleave, in conjunction with the inability to ligate RNA, makes these ribozyme variants particularly suitable candidates for RNA destruction.     

Engineered RNase P ribozymes increase their cleavage activities and efficacies in inhibiting viral gene expression in cells by enhancing the rate of cleavage and binding of the target mRNA

Engineered RNase P ribozymes are promising gene-targeting agents that can be used in both basic research and clinical applications. We have previously selected ribozyme variants for their activity in cleaving an mRNA substrate from a pool of ribozymes containing randomized sequences. In this study, one of the variants was used to target the mRNA encoding thymidine kinase (TK) of herpes simplex virus 1 (HSV-1). The variant exhibited enhanced cleavage and substrate binding and was at least 30 times more efficient in cleaving TK mRNA in vitro than the ribozyme derived from the wild type sequence. Our results provide the first direct evidence to suggest that a point mutation at nucleotide 95 of RNase P catalytic RNA from Escherichia coli (G(95) --> U(95)) increases the rate of cleavage, whereas another mutation at nucleotide 200 (A(200) --> C(200)) enhances substrate binding of the ribozyme. A reduction of about 99% in TK expression was observed in cells expressing the variant, whereas a 70% reduction was found in cells expressing the ribozyme derived from the wild type sequence. Thus, the RNase P ribozyme variant is highly effective in inhibiting HSV-1 gene expression. Our study demonstrates that ribozyme variants increase their cleavage activity and efficacy in blocking gene expression in cells through enhanced substrate binding and rate of cleavage. These results also provide insights into the mechanism of how RNase P ribozymes efficiently cleave an mRNA substrate and, furthermore, facilitate the development of highly active RNase P ribozymes for gene-targeting applications.     

Specificity of the hairpin ribozyme. Sequence requirements surrounding the cleavage site.

Substrate sequence requirements of the hairpin ribozyme have been partially defined by both mutational and in vitro selection experiments. It was considered that the best targets were those that included the N downward arrowGUC sequence surrounding the cleavage site. In contrast to previous studies that failed to evaluate all possible combinations of these nucleotides, we have performed an exhaustive analysis of the cleavage of 64 substrate variants. They represent all possible sequence combinations of the J2/1 nucleotides except the well established G(+1). No cleavage was observed with 24 sequences. C(+2) variants showed little or no cleavage, whereas U(+2) substrates were all cleavable. The maximal cleavage rate was obtained with the AGUC substrate. Cleavage rates of sequences HGUC (H = A, C, or U), GGUN, GGGR (R = A or G), AGUU, and UGUA were up to 5 times lower than the AGUC one. This shows that other sequences besides NGUC could also be considered as good targets. A second group of sequences WGGG (W = A or U), UGUK (K = G or U), MGAG (M = A or C), AGUA, and UGGA were cleaved between 6 and 10 times less efficiently. Furthermore, the UGCU sequence of a noncleavable viral target was mutated to AGUC resulting in a proficiently cleavable substrate by its cognate hairpin ribozyme. This indicates that our conclusions may be extrapolated to other hairpin ribozymes with different specificity.     

Cross-linking experiments reveal the presence of novel structural features between a hepatitis delta virus ribozyme and its substrate

The kinetic pathway of a trans-acting delta ribozyme includes an essential structural rearrangement involving the P1 stem, a stem that is formed between the substrate and the ribozyme. We performed cross-linking experiments to determine the substrate position within the catalytic center of an antigenomic, trans-acting, delta ribozyme. Substrates that included a 4-thiouridine either in position -1, +4, or +8 (i.e., adjacent to the cleavage site, or located either in the middle of or at the 3'-end of the P1 stem, respectively) were synthesized and shown to be efficiently cleaved. Examination of the cross-linking conditions, the use of various mutated ribozymes, as well as the probing and characterization of the resulting ribozyme-substrate complexes, revealed several new features of the molecular mechanism: (1) the close proximity of several bases between nucleotides of the substrate and ribozyme; (2) the active ribozyme-substrate complex folds in a manner that docks the middle of the P1 stem on the P3 stem, while concomitantly the scissile phosphate is in close proximity to the catalytic cytosine; and, (3) some complexes appear to be compatible with being active intermediates along the folding pathway, while others seem to correspond to misfolded structures. To provide a model representation of these data, a three-dimensional structure of the delta ribozyme was developed using several RNA bioinformatic software packages.     

Design and isolation of ribozyme-substrate pairs using RNase P-based ribozymes containing altered substrate binding sites.

Substrate recognition and cleavage by the bacterial RNase P RNA requires two domains, a specificity domain, or S-domain, and a catalytic domain, or C-domain. The S-domain binds the T stem-loop region in a pre-tRNA substrate to confer specificity for tRNA substrates. In this work, the entire S-domain of the Bacillus subtilis RNase P RNA is replaced with an artificial substrate binding module. New RNA substrates are isolated by in vitro selection using two libraries containing random regions of 60 nt. At the end of the selection, the cleavage rates of the substrate library are approximately 0.7 min(-1)in 10 mM MgCl(2)at 37 degrees C, approximately 4-fold better than the cleavage of a pre-tRNA substrate by the wild-type RNase P RNA under the same conditions. The contribution of the S-domain replacement to the catalytic efficiency is from 6- to 22 000-fold. Chemical and nuclease mapping of two ribozyme-product complexes shows that this contribution correlates with direct interactions between the S-domain replacement and the selected substrate. These results demonstrate the feasibility of design and isolation of RNase P-based, matching ribozyme-substrate pairs without prior knowledge of the sequence or structure of the interactive modules in the ribozyme or substrate.     

Oligonucleotide facilitators may inhibit or activate a hammerhead ribozyme.

Facilitators are oligonucleotides capable of affecting hammerhead ribozyme activity by interacting with the substrate at the termini of the ribozyme. Facilitator effects were determined in vitro using a system consisting of a ribozyme with 7 nucleotides in every stem sequence and two substrates with inverted facilitator binding sequences. The effects of 9mer and 12mer RNA as well as DNA facilitators which bind either adjacent to the 3'- or 5'-end of the ribozyme were investigated. A kinetic model was developed which allows determination of the apparent dissociation constant of the ribozyme-substrate complex from single turnover reactions. We observed a decreased dissociation constant of the ribozyme-substrate complex due to facilitator addition corresponding to an additional stabilization energy of delta delta G=-1.7 kcal/mol with 3'-end facilitators. The cleavage rate constant was increased by 3'-end facilitators and decreased by 5'-end facilitators. Values for Km were slightly lowered by all facilitators and kcat was increased by 3'-end facilitators and decreased by 5'-end facilitators in our system. Generally the facilitator effects increased with the length of the facilitators and RNA provided greater effects than DNA of the same sequence. Results suggest facilitator influences on several steps of the hammerhead reaction, substrate association, cleavage and dissociation of products. Moreover, these effects are dependent in different manners on ribozyme and substrate concentration. This leads to the conclusion that there is a concentration dependence whether activation or inhibition is caused by facilitators. Conclusions are drawn with regard to the design of hammerhead ribozyme facilitator systems.     

Photocrosslinking detects a compact, active structure of the hammerhead ribozyme

The hammerhead ribozyme has been intensively studied for approximately 15 years, but its cleavage mechanism is not yet understood. Crystal structures reveal a Y-shaped molecule in which the cleavage site is not ideally aligned for an S(N)2 reaction and no RNA functional groups are positioned appropriately to perform the roles of acid and base or other functions in the catalysis. If the ribozyme folds to a more compact structure in the transition state, it probably does so only transiently. We have used photocrosslinking as a tool to trap hammerhead ribozyme-substrate complexes in various stages of folding. Results suggest that the two substrate residues flanking the cleavage site approach and stack upon two guanosines (G8 and G12) in domain 2, moving 10-15 A closer to domain 2 than they appear in the crystal structure. Most crosslinks obtained with the nucleotide analogues positioned in the ribozyme core are catalytically inactive; however, one cobalt(III) hexaammine-dependent crosslink of an unmodified ribozyme retains catalytic activity and confirms the close stacking of cleavage site residue C17 with nucleotide G8 in domain 2. These findings suggest that residues involved in the chemistry of hammerhead catalysis are likely located in that region containing G8 and G12.     

Detailed analysis of base preferences at the cleavage site of a trans-acting HDV ribozyme: a mutation that changes cleavage site specificity.

In our previous attempt at in vitro selection of a trans - acting human hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozyme, we found that one of the variants, G10-68-725G, cleaved a 13 nt substrate, HDVS1, at two sites [Nishikawa,F., Kawakami,J., Chiba,A., Shirai,M., Kumar,P.K.R. and Nishikawa,S. (1996) Eur. J. Biochem., 237, 712-718]. One site was the normal cleavage site and the other site was shifted 1 nt toward the 3'-end. To clarify the interactions between nucleotides around the cleavage site of the trans -acting HDV ribozyme, we analyzed the efficiency of the reaction for every possible base pair between the substrate and the ribozyme at positions -1 (-1N:726N) and +1 (+1N:725N) relative to the cleavage site using the genomic HDV ribozyme, TdS4(Xho), and derivatives of the most active variant, G10-68. These mutagenesis analyses revealed that the +1 base of the substrate affects the structure of the catalytic core in the complex with G10-68-725G, substrate and divalent metal ions, and it shifts the cleavage site. In a comparison with other variants of the trans -acting HDV ribozyme, we found that this cleavage site shift occurred only with G10-68-725G.     

Length variation of helix III in a hammerhead ribozyme and its influence on cleavage activity

The previously described HIV-1 directed hammerhead ribozyme 2as-Rz12 can form with its target RNA 2s helices I and III of 128 and 278 base pairs (bp). A series of derivatives was made in which helix III was truncated to 8, 5, 4, 3, and 2 nucleotides (nt). These asymmetric hammerhead ribozymes were tested for in vitro cleavage and for inhibition of HIV-1 replication in human cells. Truncation of helix III to 8 bp did not affect the in vitro cleavage potential of the parental catalytic antisense RNA 2as-Rz12. Further truncation of helix III led to decreased cleavage rates, with no measurable cleavage activity for the 2 bp construct. All catalytically active constructs showed complex cleavage kinetics. Three kinetic subpopulations of ribozyme-substrate complexes could be discriminated that were cleaved with fast or slow rates or not at all. Gel purification of preformed ribozyme-substrate complexes led to a significant increase in cleavage rates. However, the complex cleavage pattern remained. In mammalian cells, the helix III-truncated constructs showed the same but no increased inhibitory effect of the comparable antisense RNA on HIV-1 replication.     

Identification of adenosine functional groups involved in substrate binding by the ribonuclease P ribozyme

The RNA component of bacterial ribonuclease P (RNase P) binds to substrate pre-tRNAs with high affinity and catalyzes site-specific phosphodiester bond hydrolysis to generate the mature tRNA 5' end. Herein we describe the use of biotinylated pre-tRNA substrates to isolate RNase P ribozyme-substrate complexes for nucleotide analogue interference mapping of ribozyme base functional groups involved in substrate recognition. By using a series of adenosine base analogues tagged with phosphorothioate substitutions, we identify specific chemical groups involved in substrate binding. Only 10 adenosines in the Escherichia coli ribozyme show significant sensitivity to interference: A65, A66, A136, A232-234, A248, A249, A334, and A347. Most of these adenosine positions are universally conserved among all bacterial RNase P RNAs; however, not all conserved adenosines are sensitive to analogue substitution. Importantly, all but one of the sensitive nucleotides are located at positions of intermolecular cross-linking between the ribozyme and the substrate. One site of interference that did not correlate with available structural data involved A136 in J11/12. To confirm the generality of the results, we repeated the interference analysis of J11/12 in the Bacillus subtilis RNase P ribozyme, which differs significantly in overall secondary structure. Notably, the B. subtilis ribozyme shows an identical interference pattern at the position (A191) that is homologous to A136. Furthermore, mutation of A136 in the E. coli ribozyme gives rise to a measurable increase in the equilibrium binding constant for the ribozyme-substrate interaction, while mutation of a nearby conserved nucleotide (A132) that is not sensitive to analogue incorporation does not. These results strongly support direct participation of nucleotides in the P4, P11, J5/15, and J18/2 regions of ribozyme structure in pre-tRNA binding and implicate an additional region, J11/12, as involved in substrate recognition. In aggregate, the interference results provide a detailed chemical picture of how the conserved nucleotides adjacent to the pre-tRNA substrate contribute to substrate binding and provide a framework for subsequent identification of the specific roles of these chemical groups in substrate recognition.     

Alignment of the two domains of the hairpin ribozyme-substrate complex defined by interdomain photoaffinity crosslinking

The hairpin ribozyme-substrate complex contains two independently folding domains that interact with one another to form a catalytic complex. However, little is known about the key structural elements involved in these tertiary interactions. Here, we report the use of a photochemical crosslinking method to investigate the relative proximity and orientation of the two domains of the hairpin ribozyme. This method allows the incorporation of a photochemical azidophenacyl group at specified positions within synthetic oligoribonucleotides. Photocrosslinking was performed following the assembly of four RNA oligonucleotides into active ribozyme-substrate complexes. Two photoagent attachment sites in the substrate binding strand within domain A (between positions A7-G8 and A10-G11) and three in the 5' strand of domain B (A20-G21, A22-A23 and A24-C25) were studied. Several crosslinks between the substrate binding strand and the 5' segment of domain B were detected. All of the photo agent-specific crosslinked species were dependent upon proper assembly and folding of the ribozyme-substrate complex. In addition, a substrate base mutation (G+1 to A+1) that prevents the docking of the two domains, blocks the crosslink formation. Four interdomain crosslinks (A7-G8/C25-A26 (two species); A10-G11/A22 and A24-C25/C12-G13) have been shown to retain catalytic activity. Taken together, these results indicate that the characterized crosslinks provide important information concerning the alignment of the two domains and accurately reflect the active docked conformation of the molecule.     

Energetic contribution of non-essential 5' sequence to catalysis in a hepatitis delta virus ribozyme

Hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozymes employ multiple catalytic strategies to achieve overall rate enhancement of RNA cleavage. These strategies include general acid-base catalysis by a cytosine side chain and involvement of divalent metal ions. Here we used a trans-acting form of the antigenomic ribozyme to examine the contribution of the 5' sequence in the substrate to HDV ribozyme catalysis. The cleavage rate constants increased for substrates with 5' sequence alterations that reduced ground-state binding to the ribozyme. Quantitatively, a plot of activation free energy of chemical conversion versus Gibb's free energy of substrate binding revealed a linear relationship with a slope of -1. This relationship is consistent with a model in which components of the substrate immediately 5' to the cleavage site in the HDV ribozyme-substrate complex destabilize ground-state binding. The intrinsic binding energy derived from the ground-state destabilization could contribute up to 2 kcal/mol toward the total 8.5 kcal/mol reduction in activation free energy for RNA cleavage catalyzed by the HDV ribozyme.     

A base change in the catalytic core of the hairpin ribozyme perturbs function but not domain docking

The hairpin ribozyme is a small endonucleolytic RNA motif with potential for targeted RNA inactivation. It optimally cleaves substrates containing the sequence 5'-GU-3' immediately 5' of G. Previously, we have shown that tertiary structure docking of its two domains is an essential step in the reaction pathway of the hairpin ribozyme. Here we show, combining biochemical and fluorescence structure and function probing techniques, that any mutation of the substrate base U leads to a docked RNA fold, yet decreases cleavage activity. The docked mutant complex shares with the wild-type complex a common interdomain distance as measured by time-resolved fluorescence resonance energy transfer (FRET) as well as the same solvent-inaccessible core as detected by hydroxyl-radical protection; hence, the mutant complex appears nativelike. FRET experiments also indicate that mutant docking is kinetically more complex, yet with an equilibrium shifted toward the docked conformation. Using 2-aminopurine as a site-specific fluorescent probe in place of the wild-type U, a local structural rearrangement in the substrate is observed. This substrate straining accompanies global domain docking and involves unstacking of the base and restriction of its conformational dynamics, as detected by time-resolved 2-aminopurine fluorescence spectroscopy. These data appear to invoke a mechanism of functional interference by a single base mutation, in which the ribozyme-substrate complex becomes trapped in a nativelike fold preceding the chemical transition state.     

Extensive phosphorothioate substitution yields highly active and nuclease-resistant hairpin ribozymes.

The catalytic function of the hairpin ribozyme has been investigated by modification-interference analysis of both ribozyme and substrate, using ribonucleoside phosphorothioates. Thiophosphate substitutions in two ribozyme domains were examined by using a novel and highly efficient two-piece ribozyme assembled from two independently synthesized oligoribonucleotides. The catalytic proficiency of the two-piece construct (KM = 48 nM, kcat = 2.3 min-1) is nearly identical to that of the one-piece ribozyme. The two-piece ribozyme is essentially unaffected by substitution with thiophosphates 5' to all guanosines, cytidines, and uridines. In contrast, incorporation of multiple adenosine phosphorothioates in the 5' domain of the ribozyme decreases ribozyme activity by a factor of 25. Modification-interference experiments using ribozymes partially substituted with adenosine phosphorothioate suggest that thiophosphates 5' to A7, A9 and A10 interfere with cleavage to a greater extent than substitutions at other sites within the molecule, but the effect is modest. Within the substrate, phosphorothioate substitution does not directly interfere with cleavage, rather, increasing thiophosphate content decreases the stability of the ribozyme-substrate complex. We describe the construction of a hairpin ribozyme containing dinucleotide extensions at its 5' and 3' ends. Full substitution of this molecule with G and C phosphorothioates results in a ribozyme with greatly enhanced stability against cellular ribonucleases without significant loss of catalytic efficiency.     

Importance of specific nucleotides in the folding of the natural form of the hairpin ribozyme

The hairpin ribozyme in its natural context consists of two loops in RNA duplexes that are connected as arms of a four-way helical junction. Magnesium ions induce folding into the active conformation in which the two loops are in proximity. In this study, we have investigated nucleotides that are important to this folding process. We have analyzed the folding in terms of the cooperativity and apparent affinity for magnesium ions as a function of changes in base sequence and functional groups, using fluorescence resonance energy transfer. Our results suggest that the interaction between the loops is the sum of a number of component interactions. Some sequence variants such as A10U, G+1A, and C25U exhibit loss of cooperativity and reduced affinity of apparent magnesium ion binding. These variants are also very impaired in ribozyme cleavage activity. Nucleotides A10, G+1, and C25 thus appear to be essential in creating the conformational environment necessary for ion binding. The double variant G+1A/C25U exhibits a marked recovery of both folding and catalytic activity compared to either individual variant, consistent with the proposal of a triple-base interaction among A9, G+1, and C25 [Pinard, R., Lambert, D., Walter, N. G., Heckman, J. E., Major, F., and Burke, J. M. (1999) Biochemistry 38, 16035-16039]. However, substitution of A9 leads to relatively small changes in folding properties and cleavage activity, and the double variant G+1DAP/C25U (DAP is 2,6-diaminopurine), which could form an isosteric triple-base interaction, exhibits folding and cleavage activities that are both very impaired compared to those of the natural sequence. Our results indicate an important role for a Watson--Crick base pair between G+1 and C25; this may be buttressed by an interaction with A9, but the loss of this has less significant consequences for folding. 2'-Deoxyribose substitution leads to folding with reduced magnesium ion affinity in the following order: unmodified RNA > dA9 > dA10 > dC25 approximately dA10 plus dC25. The results are interpreted in terms of an interaction between the ribose ring of C25 and the ribose and base of A10, in agreement with the proposal of Ryder and Strobel [Ryder, S. P., and Strobel, S. A. (1999) J. Mol. Biol. 291, 295-311]. In general, there is a correlation between the ability to undergo ion-induced folding and the rate of ribozyme cleavage. An exception to this is provided by G8, for which substitution with uridine leads to severe impairment of cleavage but folding characteristics that are virtually unaltered from those of the natural species. This is consistent with a direct role for the nucleobase of G8 in the chemistry of cleavage.     

Mixed DNA/RNA polymers are cleaved by the hammerhead ribozyme.

A series of chemically synthesized oligodeoxyribonucleotides containing one or two ribonucleotides (DNA/RNA mixed polymers) at and/or adjacent to the cleavage site of the substrate can be cleaved by the "hammerhead" ribozyme. In comparison with the all-RNA substrate, the predominantly deoxyribonucleotide substrates have (1) lower optimal temperatures of cleavage, (2) approximately 6-fold higher Km's and 7-fold lower kcat's at 30 degrees C, and (3) 15-fold higher Km's and 8-fold lower kcat's at 37 degrees C. The extent to which the RNA substrate cleavage is inhibited in the presence of an all-DNA (KI = 13 microM) and an RNA substrate analogue with a dC at the cleavage site (KI = 0.96 microM) supports the contention that the formation of the ribozyme-substrate complex with the predominantly deoxyribonucleotide substrates (D substrates) is impaired. The weaker binding of D substrates was confirmed by thermal denaturation and determination of the Tm of the complex. Analysis of the kinetic data also suggests that the conformation of the catalytic core of the ribozyme-substrate complex differs from that of the all-RNA complex, a change that results from the presence of a DNA/RNA heteroduplex in the complex.