Multicellular development in Myxococcus xanthus is stimulated by predator-prey interactions

Myxococcus xanthus is a predatory bacterium that exhibits complex social behavior. The most pronounced behavior is the aggregation of cells into raised fruiting body structures in which cells differentiate into stress-resistant spores. In the laboratory, monocultures of M. xanthus at a very high density will reproducibly induce hundreds of randomly localized fruiting bodies when exposed to low nutrient availability and a solid surface. In this report, we analyze how M. xanthus fruiting body development proceeds in a coculture with suitable prey. Our analysis indicates that when prey bacteria are provided as a nutrient source, fruiting body aggregation is more organized, such that fruiting bodies form specifically after a step-down or loss of prey availability, whereas a step-up in prey availability inhibits fruiting body formation. This localization of aggregates occurs independently of the basal nutrient levels tested, indicating that starvation is not required for this process. Analysis of early developmental signaling relA and asgD mutants indicates that they are capable of forming fruiting body aggregates in the presence of prey, demonstrating that the stringent response and A-signal production are surprisingly not required for the initiation of fruiting behavior. However, these strains are still defective in differentiating to spores. We conclude that fruiting body formation does not occur exclusively in response to starvation and propose an alternative model in which multicellular development is driven by the interactions between M. xanthus cells and their cognate prey.     

Quantifying aggregation dynamics during Myxococcus xanthus development

Under starvation conditions, a swarm of Myxococcus xanthus cells will undergo development, a multicellular process culminating in the formation of many aggregates called fruiting bodies, each of which contains up to 100,000 spores. The mechanics of symmetry breaking and the self-organization of cells into fruiting bodies is an active area of research. Here we use microcinematography and automated image processing to quantify several transient features of developmental dynamics. An analysis of experimental data indicates that aggregation reaches its steady state in a highly nonmonotonic fashion. The number of aggregates rapidly peaks at a value 2- to 3-fold higher than the final value and then decreases before reaching a steady state. The time dependence of aggregate size is also nonmonotonic, but to a lesser extent: average aggregate size increases from the onset of aggregation to between 10 and 15 h and then gradually decreases thereafter. During this process, the distribution of aggregates transitions from a nearly random state early in development to a more ordered state later in development. A comparison of experimental results to a mathematical model based on the traffic jam hypothesis indicates that the model fails to reproduce these dynamic features of aggregation, even though it accurately describes its final outcome. The dynamic features of M. xanthus aggregation uncovered in this study impose severe constraints on its underlying mechanisms.     

Sporulation timing in Myxococcus xanthus is controlled by the espAB locus

The fruiting body development of Myxococcus xanthus consists of two separate but interacting pathways: one for aggregation of many cells to form raised mounds and the other for sporulation of individual cells into myxospores. Sporulation of individual cells normally occurs after mound formation, and is delayed at least 30 h after starvation under our laboratory conditions. This suggests that M. xanthus has a mechanism that monitors progress towards aggregation prior to triggering sporulation. A null mutation in a newly identified gene, espA (early sporulation), causes sporulation to occur much earlier compared with the wild type (16 h earlier). In contrast, a null mutation in an adjacent gene, espB, delays sporulation by about 16 h compared with the wild type. Interestingly, it appears that the espA mutant does not require raised mounds for sporulation. Many mutant cells sporulate outside the fruiting bodies. In addition, the mutant can sporulate, without aggregation into raised mounds, under some conditions in which cells normally do not form fruiting bodies. Based on these observations, it is hypothesized that EspA functions as an inhibitor of sporulation during early fruiting body development while cells are aggregating into raised mounds. The aggregation-independent sporulation of the espA mutant still requires starvation and high cell density. The espA and espB genes are expressed as an operon and their translations appear to be coupled. Expression occurs only under developmental conditions and does not occur during vegetative growth or during glycerol-induced sporulation. Sequence analysis of EspA indicates that it is a histidine protein kinase with a fork head-associated (FHA) domain at the N-terminus and a receiver domain at the C-terminus. This suggests that EspA is part of a two-component signal transduction system that regulates the timing of sporulation initiation.     

Cell polarity, intercellular signalling and morphogenetic cell movements in Myxococcus xanthus

In Myxococcus xanthus morphogenetic cell movements constitute the basis for the formation of spreading vegetative colonies and fruiting bodies in starving cells. M. xanthus cells move by gliding and gliding motility depends on two polarly localized engines, type IV pili pull cells forward, and slime extruding nozzle-like structures appear to push cells forward. The motility behaviour of cells provides evidence that the two engines are localized to opposite poles and that they undergo polarity switching. Several proteins involved in regulating polarity switching have been identified. The cell surface-associated C-signal induces the directed movement of cells into nascent fruiting bodies. Recently, the molecular nature of the C-signal molecule was elucidated and the motility parameters regulated by the C-signal were identified. From the effect of the C-signal on cell behaviour it appears that the C-signal inhibits polarity switching of the two motility engines. This establishes a connection between cell polarity, signalling by an intercellular signal and morphogenetic cell movements during fruiting body formation.     

Aggregation during fruiting body formation in Myxococcus xanthus is driven by reducing cell movement

When starved, Myxococcus xanthus cells assemble themselves into aggregates of about 10(5) cells that grow into complex structures called fruiting bodies, where they later sporulate. Here we present new observations on the velocities of the cells, their orientations, and reversal rates during the early stages of fruiting body formation. Most strikingly, we find that during aggregation, cell velocities slow dramatically and cells orient themselves in parallel inside the aggregates, while later cell orientations are circumferential to the periphery. The slowing of cell velocity, rather than changes in reversal frequency, can account for the accumulation of cells into aggregates. These observations are mimicked by a continuous agent-based computational model that reproduces the early stages of fruiting body formation. We also show, both experimentally and computationally, how changes in reversal frequency controlled by the Frz system mutants affect the shape of these early fruiting bodies.     

Short-Range Guiding Can Result in the Formation of Circular Aggregates in Myxobacteria Populations

Myxobacteria are social bacteria that upon starvation form multicellular fruiting bodies whose shape in different species can range from simple mounds to elaborate tree-like structures. The formation of fruiting bodies is a result of collective cell movement on a solid surface. In the course of development, groups of flexible rod-shaped cells form streams and move in circular or spiral patterns to form aggregation centers that can become sites of fruiting body formation. The mechanisms of such cell movement patterns are not well understood. It has been suggested that myxobacterial development depends on short-range contact-mediated interactions between individual cells, i.e. cell aggregation does not require long-range signaling in the population. In this study, by means of a computational mass-spring model, we investigate what types of short-range interactions between cells can result in the formation of streams and circular aggregates during myxobacterial development. We consider short-range head-to-tail guiding between individual cells, whereby movement direction of the head of one cell is affected by the nearby presence of the tail of another cell. We demonstrate that stable streams and circular aggregates can arise only when the trailing cell, in addition to being steered by the tail of the leading cell, is able to speed up to catch up with it. It is suggested that necessary head-to-tail interactions between cells can arise from physical adhesion, response to a diffusible substance or slime extruded by cells, or pulling by motility engine pili. Finally, we consider a case of long-range guiding between cells and show that circular aggregates are able to form without cells increasing speed. These findings present a possibility to discriminate between short-range and long-range guiding mechanisms in myxobacteria by experimentally measuring distribution of cell speeds in circular aggregates.     

Patterns of cellular interactions during fruiting-body formation in Myxococcus xanthus.

Aggregation and mound formation during development of the myxobacterium Myxococcus xanthus were examined by scanning electron microscopy and light microscopy. Several complex patterns of multicellular associations were observed. These observations imply that complex, organized cell-cell interactions occur during the process of development. Examination of sliced aggregates revealed that, contrary to common perception, the process of sporulation commenced during mound formation rather than after the completion of mound morphogenesis. The morphogenesis of M. xanthus fruiting bodies is compared with the morphogenesis of fruiting bodies of other members of the Myxobacteriales previously described in the literature.     

EspC is involved in controlling the timing of development in Myxococcus xanthus

The espC null mutation caused accelerated aggregation and formation of tiny fruiting bodies surrounded by spores, which were also observed in the espA mutant and in CsgA-overproducing cells in Myxococcus xanthus. In addition, the espC mutant appeared to produce larger amounts of the complementary C-signal than the wild-type strain. These findings suggest that EspC is involved in controlling the timing of fruiting body development in M. xanthus.     

Induction of beta-lactamase influences the course of development in Myxococcus xanthus.

Myxococcus xanthus is a gram-negative bacterium that develops in response to starvation on a solid surface. The cells assemble into multicellular aggregates in which they differentiate from rod-shaped cells into spherical, environmentally resistant spores. Previously, we have shown that the induction of beta-lactamase is associated with starvation-independent sporulation in liquid culture (K. A. O'Connor and D. R. Zusman, Mol. Microbiol. 24:839-850, 1997). In this paper, we show that the chromosomally encoded beta-lactamase of M. xanthus is autogenously induced during development. The specific activity of the enzyme begins to increase during aggregation, before spores are detectable. The addition of inducers of beta-lactamase in M. xanthus, such as ampicillin, D-cycloserine, and phosphomycin, accelerates the onset of aggregation and sporulation in developing populations of cells. In addition, the exogenous induction of beta-lactamase allows M. xanthus to fruit on media containing concentrations of nutrients that are normally too high to support development. We propose that the induction of beta-lactamase is an integral step in the development of M. xanthus and that this induction is likely to play a role in aggregation and in the restructuring of peptidoglycan which occurs during the differentiation of spores. In support of this hypothesis, we show that exogenous induction of beta-lactamase can rescue aggregation and sporulation of certain mutants. Fruiting body spores from a rescued mutant are indistinguishable from wild-type fruiting body spores when examined by transmission electron microscopy. These results show that the signal transduction pathway leading to the induction of beta-lactamase plays an important role in aggregation and sporulation in M. xanthus.     

Morphogenesis in Myxococcus xanthus and Myxococcus virescens (Myxobacterales)

1. Myxococcus xanthus B and M. virescens V2 were compared with a view to establishing the control of their morphogenetic cycles. Both organisms are typical myxococci and on solid media with low concentrations of nutrient they form fruiting bodies, within which vegetative cells convert to myxospores. Ultrathin sections of vegetative M. virescens resembled those of M. xanthus and contained prominent heavily stained bodies, presumed to be polyphosphate granules. Shadowed preparations showed fimbriae associated with M. xanthus but not with M. virescens. 2. M. xanthus B converted to myxospores in liquid medium in response to certain alcohols. M. virescens V2 produced phase-refractile spheres, which were not viable and had an unusual ultrastructure. 3. The distributions of fruiting bodies on solid media containing 0.02% Casitone were recorded for the two species and were compared with a Poisson distribution. Cells responded to differences in cell density in a manner suggestive of a response to a chemotactic attractant. Cells growing vegetatively and also cells forming fruiting bodies produced 3',5'-cyclic adenosine monophosphate (cAMP) as measured by the incorporation of exogeneous [3H] adenosine into cAMP. 4. The significance of these findings for theories of fruiting body formation are discussed.     

Genetic analysis of tag mutants of Myxococcus xanthus provides evidence for two developmental aggregation systems

Temperature-dependent aggregation mutants (tag) of the myxobacterium Myxococcus xanthus aggregated into mounds and developed into fruiting bodies normally at 28 degrees C; however, they failed to form mounds at 34 degrees C. The timing of sporulation was unaffected by the mutations, and normal numbers of spores were produced at both permissive and restrictive temperatures. This class of mutations was originally identified through screening of ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS)-generated mutations. Subsequent work identified a linked insertion of transposon Tn5, which was used to map the EMS-generated mutations to four loci. In this paper, we describe the cloning of the tag loci and the use of transposon mutagenesis to further analyze the tag loci. Nine tag complementation groups spanning 8.5 kilobase pairs of DNA were identified through mapping of 28 independent Tn5 insertions. All insertion and deletion mutants had the same phenotype as the EMS mutants: they were temperature sensitive for mound formation. This result suggests that M. xanthus has at least two sets of genes for developmental aggregation. The tag genes constitute one set of these genes; they are required for normal development at 34 degrees C but are not required for normal development at 28 degrees C.     

Identification of major sporulation proteins of Myxococcus xanthus using a proteomic approach

Myxococcus xanthus is a soil-dwelling, gram-negative bacterium that during nutrient deprivation is capable of undergoing morphogenesis from a vegetative rod to a spherical, stress-resistant spore inside a domed-shaped, multicellular fruiting body. To identify proteins required for building stress-resistant M. xanthus spores, we compared the proteome of liquid-grown vegetative cells with the proteome of mature fruiting body spores. Two proteins, protein S and protein S1, were differentially expressed in spores, as has been reported previously. In addition, we identified three previously uncharacterized proteins that are differentially expressed in spores and that exhibit no homology to known proteins. The genes encoding these three novel major spore proteins (mspA, mspB, and mspC) were inactivated by insertion mutagenesis, and the development of the resulting mutant strains was characterized. All three mutants were capable of aggregating, but for two of the strains the resulting fruiting bodies remained flattened mounds of cells. The most pronounced structural defect of spores produced by all three mutants was an altered cortex layer. We found that mspA and mspB mutant spores were more sensitive specifically to heat and sodium dodecyl sulfate than wild-type spores, while mspC mutant spores were more sensitive to all stress treatments examined. Hence, the products of mspA, mspB, and mspC play significant roles in morphogenesis of M. xanthus spores and in the ability of spores to survive environmental stress.     

Fruiting body morphogenesis in submerged cultures of Myxococcus xanthus.

Induced by starvation, the development of fruiting bodies by Myxococcus xanthus on glass and plastic surfaces under a layer of liquid was followed microscopically. Calcium ions and a neutral pH were required for development of a Myxococcus strain that grew dispersed in liquid culture. Initially asymmetric aggregates later became round, and sporulation followed aggregation.     

A new set of chemotaxis homologues is essential for Myxococcus xanthus social motility

Myxococcus xanthus cells aggregate and develop into multicellular fruiting bodies in response to starvation. A new M. xanthus locus, designated dif for defective in fruiting, was identified by the characterization of a mutant defective in fruiting body formation. Molecular cloning, DNA sequencing and sequence analysis indicate that the dif locus encodes a new set of chemotaxis homologues of the bacterial chemotaxis proteins MCPs (methyl-accepting chemotaxis proteins), CheW, CheY and CheA. The dif genes are distinct genetically and functionally from the previously identified M. xanthus frz chemotaxis genes, suggesting that multiple chemotaxis-like systems are required for the developmental process of M. xanthus fruiting body formation. Genetic analysis and phenotypical characterization indicate that the M. xanthus dif locus is required for social (S) motility. This is the first report of a M. xanthus chemotaxis-like signal transduction pathway that could regulate or co-ordinate the movement of M. xanthus cells to bring about S motility.     

Induction of coordinated movement of Myxococcus xanthus cells.

Rhythmically advancing waves of cells, called ripples, arise spontaneously during the aggregation of Myxococcus xanthus into fruiting bodies. Extracts prepared by washing rippling cells contain a substance that will induce quiescent cells to ripple. Three lines of evidence indicate that murein (peptidoglycan) is the ripple-inducing substance in the extracts. First, ripple-inducing activity is associated with the cell envelope of sonically disrupted M. xanthus cells. Second, whole cells, cell extracts, or purified murein from a variety of different bacteria are capable of inducing ripples. In contrast, extracts prepared from Methanobacterium spp. which contain pseudomurein instead of typical bacterial murein fail to induce ripples. Third, four components of M. xanthus murein, N-acetylglucosamine, N-acetylmuramic acid, diaminopimelate, and D-alanine, are able to induce ripples. Ripples produced by aggregating cells have a wavelength of 45 micrometers and a maximum velocity of 2 micrometers/min. Both of the multigene systems that control gliding motility appear to be required for rippling, and all known mutations at the spoC locus eliminate both rippling and sporulation.     

Genes required for developmental signalling in Myxococcus xanthus: three asg loci.

asg-carrying strains of Myxococcus xanthus arose in a selection for mutants defective in cell-cell signalling during fruiting body development. All 15 asg mutations examined were found to lie in one of three genetic loci, asgA, asgB, or asgC. The loci were defined by linkage to different insertions of transposon Tn5 and molecular cloning of asgA. asg mutants of all three types were deficient in the aggregation of cells into mounds of the sort that normally give rise to fruiting bodies. asg mutants were also deficient in spore formation; sporulation is normally one of the last steps in fruiting body development. Consistent with a requirement for cell-to-cell signalling, at 1 to 2 h asg+-carrying cells release a material called A-factor that can rescue development of asg mutants. asgA, asgB, and asgC mutants released 5% or less of the asg+ level of A-factor, as measured by bioassay. The experimental results are consistent with the hypothesis that a deficiency in A-factor production or release is the primary developmental defect in asg mutants and that aggregation and sporulation depend on A-factor. asg mutations at all three loci also changed the color and morphology of growing colonies, and failure to release A-factor may itself arise from a defect in growing cells.     

Territorial interactions between two Myxococcus Species.

It is unusual to find fruiting bodies of different myxobacteria occupying the same territory on natural samples. We were thus interested in determining whether myxobacteria establish territorial dominance and, if so, what the mechanism of that interaction is. We had previously observed that vegetative swarms of Myxococcus xanthus and Stigmatella aurantiaca placed close to each other on an agar surface initially merged but eventually separated. Further studies indicated that these two species also formed separate fruiting bodies when mixed together on developmental agar (unpublished observation). We examined the interactions between two more closely related myxobacteria, M. xanthus and M. virescens, in greater detail. When mixtures of a kanamycin-resistant strain of M. xanthus and a kanamycin-sensitive strain of M. virescens were placed together under developmental conditions, the cells sorted themselves out and established separate fruiting body territories. In addition, differential viable counts of a mixture of the two species during development indicated that each strain was producing an extracellular component that inhibited the growth and development of the other. Nevertheless, finally, M. virescens invariably outcompeted M. xanthus at all input ratios of M. xanthus/M. virescens tested. This is consistent with the observation that M. virescens is by far the more commonly encountered of the two species. The properties of the inhibitory substance from M. virescens are consistent with the possibility that it is a bacteriocin. Our working hypothesis is that the bacteriocin plays a role in the establishment of myxobacterial territoriality. If so, this is an example of an ecological function of bacteriocins.     

Reversing cell polarity: evidence and hypothesis

The long, rod-shaped cells of myxobacteria are polarized by their gliding engines. At the rear, A-engines push while pili pull the front end forward. An hypothesis is developed whereby both engines are partially dis-assembled, then re-assembled at the opposite pole when cells reverse their movement direction. Reversals are induced by an Mgl G-protein switch that controls engine polarity. The switch is driven by an oscillatory circuit of Frizzy proteins. In growing cells, the circuit gives rise to an occasional reversal that makes swarming possible. Then, as myxobacteria begin fruiting body development, a rising level of C-signal input drives the oscillator and changes the reversal pattern. Cells reverse regularly every eight minutes in traveling waves, the reversal period is then prolonged enabling cells to form streams that enlarge tiny random aggregates into fruiting bodies.     

Phenotypic analyses of frz and dif double mutants of Myxococcus xanthus

Myxococcus xanthus is a Gram-negative gliding bacterium that aggregates and develops into multicellular fruiting bodies in response to starvation. Two chemosensory systems (frz and dif), both of which are homologous to known chemotaxis proteins, were previously identified through characterization of various developmental mutants. This study aims to examine the interaction between these two systems since both of them are required for fruiting body formation of M. xanthus. Through detailed phenotypic analyses of frz and dif double mutants, we found that both frz and dif are involved in cellular reversal and social motility; however, the frz genes are epistatic in controlling cellular reversal, whereas the dif genes are epistatic in controlling social motility. The study suggests that the integration of these two chemotaxis systems may play a central role in controlling the complicated social behaviors of M. xanthus.