Secondary binding sites for triplex-forming oligonucleotides containing bulges, loops, and mismatches in the third strand

We have used DNase I footprinting to examine the binding of five different 17-mer oligonucleotides to a 53-base oligopurine tract containing four pyrimidine interruptions. Although all the expected triplexes formed with high affinity (K(d) approximately 10-50 nM), one oligonucleotide produced a footprint at a second site with about 20-fold lower affinity. We have explored the nature of this secondary binding site and suggest that it arises when each end of the third strand forms a 7-mer triplex with adjacent regions on the duplex, generating a contiguous 14-base triplex with a bulge in the center of the third strand oligonucleotide. This unusual binding mode was examined by use of oligonucleotides that were designed with the potential to form different length third-strand loops of various base composition. We find that triplexes containing single-base bulges are generally more stable than those with dinucleotide loops, though triplexes can be formed with loops of up to nine thymines, generating complexes with submicromolar dissociation constants. These structures are much more stable than those formed by adding two separate 7-mer oligonucleotides, which do not generate DNase I footprints, though a stable complex is generated when the two halves are covalently joined by a hexa(ethylene glycol) linker. MPE produces less clear footprints, presumably because this cleavage agent binds to triplex DNA, but confirms that the oligonucleotides can bind in unexpected places. These results suggest that extra care needs to be taken when designing long triplex-forming oligonucleotides so as to avoid triplex formation at shorter secondary sites.     

Relative stability of triplexes containing different numbers of T.AT and C+.GC triplets.

We have used DNase I footprinting to compare the stability of parallel triple helices containing different numbers of T.AT and C+. GC triplets. We have targeted a fragment containing the 17mer sequence 5'-AGGAAGAGAAAAAAGAA with the 9mer oligonucleotides 5'-TCCTTCTCT, 5'-TTCTCTTTT and 5'-TTTTTTCTT, which form triplexes at the 5'-end, centre and 3'-end of the target site respectively. Quantitative DNase I footprinting has shown that at pH 5.0 the dissociation constants of these oligonucleotides are 0.13, 4.7 and >30 microM respectively, revealing that increasing the proportion of C+.GC triplets increases triplex stability. The results suggest that the positive charge on the protonated cytosine contributes to triplex stability, either by a favourable interaction with the stacked pisystem or by screening the charge on the phosphate groups. In the presence of a naphthylquinoline triplex binding ligand all three oligonucleotides bind with similar affinities. At pH 6.0 these triplexes only form in the presence of the triplex binding ligand, while at pH 7.5 footprints are only seen with the oligonucleotide which generates the fewest number of C+.GC triplets (TTTTTTCTT) in the presence of the ligand.     

Stable DNA triple helix formation using oligonucleotides containing 2'-aminoethoxy,5-propargylamino-U

We have prepared oligonucleotides containing the novel base analogue 2'-aminoethoxy,5-propargylamino-U in place of thymidine and examined their ability to form intermolecular and intramolecular triple helices by DNase I footprinting and thermal melting studies. The results were compared with those for oligonucleotides containing 5-propargylamino-dU and 2'-aminoethoxy-T. We find that the bis-substituted derivative produces a large increase in triplex stability, much greater than that produced by either of the monosubstituted analogues, which are roughly equipotent with each other. Intermolecular triplexes with 9-mer oligonucleotides containing three or four base modifications generate footprints at submicromolar concentrations even at pH 7.5, in contrast to the unmodified oligonucleotide, which failed to produce a footprint at pH 5.0, even at 30 microM. UV- and fluorescence melting studies with intramolecular triplexes confirmed that the bis-modified base produces a much greater increase in T(m) than either modification alone.     

DNA sequence specificity of a naphthylquinoline triple helix-binding ligand.

We have examined the effect of a naphthylquinoline triplex-binding ligand on the formation of intermolecular triplexes on DNA fragments containing the target sites A6G6xC6T6 and G6A6xT6C6. The ligand enhances the binding of T6C2, but not T2C6, to A6G6xC6T6 suggesting that it has a greater effect on TxAT than C+xGC triplets. The complex with T6C2 is only stable below pH 6.0, confirming the requirement for protonation of the third strand cytosines. Antiparallel triplexes with GT-containing oligonucleotides are also stabilised by the ligand. The complex between G5T5 and A6G6xC6T6 is stabilised by lower ligand concentrations than that between T5G5 and G6A6xC6T6. The ligand does not promote the interaction with GT-containing oligonucleotides which have been designed to bind in a parallel orientation. Although the formation of antiparallel triplexes is pH independent, we find that the ligand has a greater stabilising effect at lower pH, suggesting that the active species is protonated. The ligand does not promote the binding of antiparallel GA-containing oligonucleotides at pH 7.5 but induces the interaction between A5G5 and G6A6xT6C6 at pH 5.5. Ethidium bromide does not promote the formation of any of these triplexes and destabilises the interaction of acridine-linked pyrimidine-containing third strands with these target sites.     

DNA triple helix stabilisation by a naphthylquinoline dimer

We have used DNase I footprinting to examine the effect of a novel naphthylquinoline dimer, designed as a triplex-specific bis-intercalator, on the stability of intermolecular DNA triplexes. We find that this compound efficiently promotes triplex formation between the 9-mer oligonucleotide 5'-TTTTTTCTT and its oligopurine duplex target at concentrations as low as 0.1 microM, enhancing the triplex stability by at least 1000-fold. This compound, which is the first reported example of a triplex bis-intercalator, is about 30 times more potent than the simple monofunctional ligand.     

High throughput measurement of duplex, triplex and quadruplex melting curves using molecular beacons and a LightCycler

We have used oligonucleotides containing molecular beacons to determine melting profiles for intramolecular DNA duplexes, triplexes and quadruplexes (tetraplexes). The synthetic oligonucleotides used in these studies contain a fluorophore (fluorescein) and quencher (methyl red) attached either to deoxyribose or to the 5 position of dU. In the folded DNA structures the fluorophore and quencher are in close proximity and the fluorescence is quenched. When the structures melt, the fluorophore and quencher are separated and there is a large increase in fluorescence. These experiments were performed in a Roche LightCycler; this requires small amounts of material (typically 4 pmol oligonucleotide) and can perform 32 melting profiles in parallel. We have used this technique to compare the stability of triplexes containing different base analogues and to confirm the selectivity of a triplex-binding ligand for triplex, rather than duplex, DNA. We have also compared the melting of inter- and intramolecular quadruplexes.     

Stable recognition of TA interruptions by triplex forming oligonucleotides containing a novel nucleoside

We have prepared the 2'-aminoethoxy derivative of the S nucleoside ((2AE)S) and incorporated it into triplex-forming oligonucleotides for recognition of TA interruptions within a target oligopurine tract. Fluorescence melting, UV melting, and DNase I footprinting experiments show that (2AE)S has greater affinity than G or S for a single TA interruption. Stable triplexes are formed at pH 6.0 at an 18-mer target site containing two TA interruptions, even though this contains eight C(+).GC triplets. Although (2AE)S and S produce stable triplexes at TA interruptions, they also interact with other base pairs, in particular, CG, although the selectivity for TA improves with increased pH.( 2AE)S is the best nucleoside described so far for recognition of TA within a triple-helix target.     

Synthesis and triplex-forming properties of cyclic oligonucleotides with (G,A)-antiparallel strands

Cyclic oligonucleotides carrying an oligopurine Watson-Crick sequence linked to the corresponding (G,A)- and (G,T)-antiparallel strands were prepared by nonenzymatic template-assisted cyclization of phosphorylated precursors. Cyclization was attempted using 3'-phosphate and 5'-phosphate linear precursors with carbodiimide or BrCN activation. The best results were obtained with the 5'-phosphorylated precursors and carbodiimide activation. Cyclic oligonucleotides bind polypyrimidine target sequence by formation of antiparallel triplexes. We have used UV and circular dichroism (CD) spectroscopy to analyze triplexes formed by cyclic oligonucleotides carrying G and A in the reverse-Hoogsteen strand. The relative stability of the triplexes formed by cyclic and linear oligonucleotides with a common polypyrimidine target was determined by melting experiments. The most-stable triplexes were formed by the cyclic oligonucleotide, followed by the unphosphorylated and phosphorylated oligonucleotide precursors, and, finally, the corresponding hairpin. Although the differences in binding affinity between cyclic oligonucleotides and their corresponding linear precursors are small, the use of cyclic oligonucleotides offers a clear advantage over conventional duplex recognition.     

Metalloregulation of triple helix formation by control of the loop conformation

The flexible polypyridine ligand, 2,2':6',2(')-terpyridine (terpy), was built into the backbone of oligonucleotides to form DNA conjugates. The terpy unit functioned as a good loop when the conjugates formed the bimolecular triplexes with complementary oligopurine. The triplex structure was destabilized by the specific interaction with divalent transition metal ions (Cu(2+), Zn(2+), and Fe(2+)), in particular Cu(2+) ions. This ion destabilized one of the triplexes by 4.2 kcalmol(-1) or made the triplex formation constant less than 1/10(3) at 298 K. This result is attributed to the substantial turbulence of the terminal structure of the triplexes.     

DNA triple helix formation at target sites containing several pyrimidine interruptions: stabilization by protonated cytosine or 5-(1-propargylamino)dU.

DNase I footprinting has been used to study the formation of parallel triplexes at oligopurine target sequences which are interrupted by pyrimidines at regular intervals. TA interruptions are targeted with third strand oligonucleotides containing guanine, generating G x TA triplets, while CG base pairs are targeted with thymine, forming T x CG triplets. We have attempted to optimize the stability of these complexes by varying the base composition and sequence arrangement of the target sites, and by replacing the third strand thymines with the positively charged analogue 5-(1-propargylamino)dU (U(P)). For the target sequence (AAAT)(5)AA, in which pyrimidines are positioned at every fourth residue, triplex formation with TG-containing oligonucleotides is only detected in the presence of a triplex-binding ligand, though stable triplexes were detected at the target site (AAAAAT)(3)AAAA. Triplex stability at targets containing pyrimidines at every fourth residue is increased by introducing guanines into the duplex repeat unit using the targets (AGAT)(5)AA and (ATGA)(5)AA. In contrast, placing C(+) x GC triplets on the 5'-side of G x TA, using the target (AGTA)(5)TT, produces complexes of lower stability. We have attempted further to increase the stability of these complexes by using the positively charged thymine base analogue U(P), and have shown that (TU(P)TG)(5)TT forms a more stable complex with target (AAAT)(5)AA than the unmodified third strand, generating a footprint in the absence of a triplex-binding ligand. Triplex formation at (AGTA)(5)AA is improved by using the modified oligonucleotide (TCGU(P))(5)TT, generating a complex in which the charged triplets C(+) x GC and U(P) x AT alternate with uncharged triplets. In contrast, placing U(P) x AT triplets adjacent to C(+) x GC, using the third strand oligonucleotide (U(P)CGT)(5)TT, reduces triplex formation, while the third strand with both substitutions, (U(P)CGU(P))(5)TT, produces a complex with intermediate stability. It appears that, although adjacent U(P) x AT triplets form stable triplexes, placing U(P) x AT adjacent to C(+) x GC is unfavorable. Similar results were obtained with fragments containing CG inversions within the oligopurine tract, though triplexes at (AAAAAC)(3)AA were only detected in the presence of a triplex-binding ligand. Placing C(+) x GC on the 5'-side of T x CG triplets also reduces triplex formation, while a 3'-C(+) x GC produces complexes with increased stability.     

Synthesis of 3'-3'-linked oligonucleotides branched by a pentaerythritol linker and the thermal stabilities of the triplexes with single-stranded DNA or RNA

Synthesis of 3'-3'-linked oligonucleotides branched by a pentaerythritol linker is described. The branched oligonucleotides were synthesized on a DNA/RNA synthesizer using a controlled pore glass (CPG) with a pentaerythritol linker carrying 4,4'-dimethoxytrityl (DMTr) and levulinyl (Lev) groups. The stability of the triplexes between the branched oligonucleotides and the target single-stranded DNA or RNA was studied by thermal denaturation. The oligonucleotides with the pentaerythritol linker formed thermally stable triplexes with the single-stranded DNA and RNA. Furthermore, the branched oligonucleotides containing 2'-O-methylribonucleosides, especially the oligonucleotide composed of 2'-deoxyribonucleosides and 2'-O-methylribonucleosides, stabilized the triplexes with the single-stranded DNA or RNA. Thus, the branched oligonucleotide containing 2'-O-methylribonucleosides may be a candidate for a novel antisense molecule by the triplex formation.     

Metalloregulation of Triple Helix Formation by Control of the Loop Conformation

The flexible polypyridine ligand, 2,2′:6′,2^″-terpyridine (terpy), was built into the backbone of oligonucleotides to form DNA conjugates. The terpy unit functioned as a good loop when the conjugates formed the bimolecular triplexes with complementary oligopurine. The triplex structure was destabilized by the specific interaction with divalent transition metal ions (Cu²⁺, Zn²⁺, and Fe²⁺), in particular Cu²⁺ ions. This ion destabilized one of the triplexes by 4.2 kcalmol^?1 or made the triplex formation constant less than 1/10³ at 298 K. This result is attributed to the substantial turbulence of the terminal structure of the triplexes.     

Thermodynamic and kinetic stability of intermolecular triple helices containing different proportions of C+*GC and T*AT triplets

We have used oligonucleotides containing appropriately placed fluorophores and quenchers to measure the stability of 15mer intermolecular triplexes with third strands consisting of repeats of TTT, TTC, TCC and TCTC. In the presence of 200 mM sodium (pH 5.0) triplexes that contain only T·AT triplets are unstable and melt below 30°C. In contrast, triplets with repeats of TTC, TCC and CTCT melt at 67, 72 and 76°C, respectively. The most stable complex is generated by the sequence containing alternating C⁺·GC and T·AT triplets. All four triplexes are stabilised by increasing the ionic strength or by the addition of magnesium, although triplexes with a higher proportion of C⁺·GC triplets are much less sensitive to changes in the ionic conditions. The enthalpies of formation of these triplexes were estimated by examining the concentration dependence of the melting profiles and show that, in the presence of 200 mM sodium at pH 5.0, each C⁺·GC triplet contributes about 30 kJ mol^–1, while each T·AT contributes only 11 kJ mol^–1. Kinetic experiments with these oligonucleotides show that in 200 mM sodium (pH 5.0) repeats of TCC and TTC have half-lives of ~20 min, while the triplex with alternating C⁺·GC and T·AT triplets has a half-life of ~3 days. In contrast, the dissociation kinetics of the triplex containing only T·AT are too fast to measure.     

DNA sequence specificity of triplex-binding ligands.

We have examined the ability of naphthylquinoline, a 2,7-disubstituted anthraquinone and BePI, a benzo[e]pyridoindole derivative, to stabilize parallel DNA triplexes of different base composition. Fluorescence melting studies, with both inter- and intramolecular triplexes, show that all three ligands stabilize triplexes that contain blocks of TAT triplets. Naphthylquinoline has no effect on triplexes formed with third strands composed of (TC)n or (CCT)n, but stabilizes triplexes that contain (TTC)n. In contrast, BePI slightly destabilizes the triplexes that are formed at (TC)n (CCT)n and (TTC)n. 2,7-Anthraquinone stabilizes (TC)n (CCT)n and (TTC)n, although it has the greatest effect on the latter. DNase I footprinting studies confirm that triplexes formed with (CCT)n are stabilized by the 2,7-disubstituted amidoanthraquinone but not by naphthylquinoline. Both ligands stabilize the triplex formed with (CCTT)n and neither affects the complex with (CT)n. We suggest that BePI and naphthylquinoline can only bind between adjacent TAT triplets, while the anthraquinone has a broader sequence of selectivity. These differences may be attributed to the presence (naphthylquinoline and BePI) or absence (anthraquinone) of a positive charge on the aromatic portion of the ligand, which prevents intercalation adjacent to C+GC triplets. The most stable structures are formed when the stacked rings (bases or ligand) alternate between charged and uncharged species. Triplexes containing alternating C+GC and TAT triplets are not stabilized by ligands as they would interrupt the alternating pattern of charged and uncharged residues.     

Thermodynamic and computational studies of DNA triple helices containing a nucleotide or a non-nucleotide linker in the third strand.

In this paper we report a thermodynamic characterisation of stability and melting behaviour of four different triple helices at pH 6.0. The target duplex consists of 16 base pairs in alternate sequence of the type 5'-(purine)(m)(pyrimidine)(m)-3'. The four triplexes are formed by targeting the 16-mer duplex with an all pyrimidine 16-mer or 15-mer or 14-mer third strand. The 16-mer oligonucleotide contains a 3'-3' phosphodiester junction and corresponding triplex was named 16-mer P. The 14-mer oligonucleotide contains a non-nucleotide linker, the 1,2,3 propanetriol residue and the corresponding triplex was named 14-mer PT. For the 15-mer oligonucleotide both junctions were alternatively used and the relative triplexes were named 15-mer P and 15-mer PT, respectively. These linkers introduce the appropriate polarity inversion and let the third strand switch from one oligopurine strand of the duplex to the other. Thermal denaturation profiles indicate the initial loss of the third strand followed by the dissociation of the target duplex. Transition enthalpies, entropies and free energies were derived from differential scanning calorimetric measurements. The comparison of Gibbs energies reveals that a more stable triplex is obtained when in the third strand there is the lack of one nucleotide in the junction region and a propanetriol residue as linker was used. The thermodynamic data were discussed in light of molecular mechanics and dynamics calculations.     

Nucleosides and nucleotides. Part 226: alternate-strand triple-helix formation by 3'-3'-linked oligodeoxynucleotides composed of asymmetrical sequences

In this paper, we describe the synthesis of the 3'-3'-linked oligonucleotides connected with pentaerythritol composed of asymmetrical sequences. Stability of the triplexes between these oligonucleotides and the DNA targets involving the adjacent oligopurine domains on alternate strands was investigated using the electrophoretic mobility shift assay (EMSA) and DNase I footprinting experiment. It was found that the 3'-3'-linked oligonucleotides composed of asymmetrical sequences formed the stable antiparallel triplexes with the DNA targets as compared with the unlinked oligonucleotides. Thus, oligonucleotides linked with pentaerythritol would be useful as antigene oligonucleotides for DNA targets consisting of the alternating oligopyrimidine-oligopurine sequences.     

Stability of DNA triplexes on shuttle vector plasmids in the replication pool in mammalian cells

Triple helix-forming oligonucleotides may be useful as gene-targeting reagents in vivo, for applications such as gene knockout. One important property of these complexes is their often remarkable stability, as demonstrated in solution and in cells following transfection. Although encouraging, these measurements do not necessarily report triplex stability in cellular compartments that support DNA functions such as replication and mutagenesis. We have devised a shuttle vector plasmid assay that reports the stability of triplexes on DNA that undergoes replication and mutagenesis. The assay is based on plasmids with novel variant supF tRNA genes containing embedded sequences for triplex formation and psoralen cross-linking. Triple helix-forming oligonucleotides were linked to psoralen and used to form triplexes on the plasmids. At various times after introduction into cells, the psoralen was activated by exposure to long wave ultraviolet light (UVA). After time for replication and mutagenesis, progeny plasmids were recovered and the frequency of plasmids with mutations in the supF gene determined. Site-specific mutagenesis by psoralen cross-links was dependent on precise placement of the psoralen by the triple helix-forming oligonucleotide at the time of UVA treatment. The results indicated that both pyrimidine and purine motif triplexes were much less stable on replicated DNA than on DNA in vitro or in total transfected DNA. Incubation of cells with amidoanthraquinone-based triplex stabilizing compounds enhanced the stability of the pyrimidine triplex.