Variation in the frequency and type of sperm chromosomal abnormalities among normal men

Summary The chromosomal constitution of 1582 human sperm from 30 normal men of proven fertility was investigated after sperm penetration of hamster eggs. A minimum of 30 sperm chromosome complements were analysed per donor so that the distribution and variation in the frequency and type of sperm chromosomal abnormalities could be assessed. The mean frequency of sperm chromosomal abnormalities in individual men was 10.4% (±6.0%) with a range of 0–24.7%. For numerical abnormalities the mean was 4.7% (±2.9%) with a range of 0–10% and for structural abnormalities the mean was 6.2% (±6.0%) with a range of 0–23.1%. The 95% confidence intervals for the mean of an individual male were 0–10.5% for numerical abnormalities, 0–18.2% for structural abnormalities, and 0–22.4% for total abnormalities. There was a significant excess of hypohaploid complements compared with hyperhaploid complements. Since hypohaploid complements could be caused by technical artefact, a conservative estimate of aneuploidy was obtained by doubling the frequency of hyperhaploid sperm, yielding an estimate of 2.4% aneuploidy. The proportion of X-bearing (53%) and Y-bearing (47%) sperm did not differ significantly. These results were compared to the other two large studies of sperm chromosome complements from normal men.     

Effect of cryopreservation on the frequency of chromosomal abnormalities and sex ratio in human sperm

The effects of cryopreservation on the frequency and type of chromosomal abnormalities in human sperm were investigated. Employing a technique that enables direct visualization of human sperm chromosomes following in vitro penetration of hamster oocytes, sperm samples from 10 normal men were examined before and after freezing in liquid nitrogen. A total of 1,960 sperm karyotypes were analyzed, 1,132 before freezing and 828 after freezing. There was no significant difference in the frequency of structural chromosomal anomalies (10.5% prefreeze vs. 8.5% postfreeze), but there was a significant decrease in the frequency of numerical abnormalities (5.2% prefreeze vs. 3.0% postfreeze). However, there was a large excess of hypohaploid complements compared with hyperhaploid complements, suggesting that the hypohaploid complements were caused by technical artefact. A conservative estimate of aneuploidy, derived by doubling the hyperhaploid frequencies, did not differ before (0.4%) and after (0.4%) freezing. There was no evidence for interdonor variability in response to sperm cryopreservation for total chromosomal abnormalities, structural abnormalities, and sex ratios. The sex ratios were also not affected by cryopreservation and did not differ significantly from the theoretical 50%. It is concluded that cryopreservation does not affect the frequencies of chromosomal abnormalities or alter the sex ratio in human sperm, provided that an adequate cryoprotective buffer and freezing system is employed.     

Comparison of chromosomal abnormalities in hamster egg and human sperm pronuclei

One thousand human sperm and hamster egg haploid karyotypes were analyzed at the pronuclear stage after in vitro penetration. The frequency of abnormalities in human sperm was 8.5%, with 5.2% aneuploidy and 3.3% structural abnormalities. The hamster egg complements had an abnormality rate of 3.8%, with 3.3% aneuploidy and 0.5% structural abnormalities. In both human and hamster complements, chromosome abnormalities were observed in all chromosome groups, demonstrating that all chromosomes are susceptible to nondisjunction, not just acrocentric or small chromosomes. There is an intriguing difference between the frequency of hyperhaploid and hypohaploid complements in human sperm and hamster eggs. In the human complements, 2.4% were hyperhaploid and 2.7% hypohaploid. This is very close to the theoretical 1 to 1 ratio expected from nondisjunction. The hamster egg complements had more hypohaploid (2.2%) than hyperhaploid (0.9%) complements, despite identical treatment. Higher rates of hypohaploidy are generally ascribed to artificial loss of chromosomes, but may in fact reflect a predisposition of oocytes to anaphase lag during meiosis. The frequency of abnormalities (both numerical and structural) is higher in human complements than in hamster. This may reflect an innate propensity for meiotic chromosome abnormalities in humans or may result from greater exposure of humans to mutagenic agents.     

The frequency of aneuploidy among individual chromosomes in 6,821 human sperm chromosome complements

The human sperm/hamster egg fusion technique has been used to analyse 6,821 human sperm chromosome complements from 98 men to determine if all chromosomes are equally likely to be involved in aneuploid events or if some chromosomes are particularly susceptible to nondisjunction. The frequency of hypohaploidy and hyperhaploidy was compared among different chromosome groups and individual chromosomes. In general, hypohaploid sperm complements were more frequent than hyperhaploid complements. The distribution of chromosome loss in the hypohaploid complements indicated that significantly fewer of the large chromosomes and significantly more of the small chromosomes were lost, suggesting that technical loss predominantly affects small chromosomes. Among the autosomes, the observed frequency of hyperhaploid sperm equalled the expected frequency (assuming an equal frequency of nondisjunction for all chromosomes) for all chromosome groups. Among individual autosomes, only chromosome 9 showed an increased frequency of hyperhaploidy. The sex chromosomes also showed a significant increase in the frequency of hyperhaploidy. These results are consistent with studies of spontaneous abortions and liveborns demonstrating that aneuploidy for the sex chromosomes is caused by paternal meiotic error more commonly than aneuploidy for the autosomes.     

Cytogenetic analysis of Q-banded pronuclear chromosomes in fertilized Syrian hamster eggs

The frequency and type of chromosome abnormalities were analyzed in 917 female pronuclei in Syrian hamster eggs fertilized by human sperm. Analysis at this stage allows detection of errors which have occurred during meiosis I and II. The chromosomes were Q-banded to identify individual chromosomes and detect subtle alterations. Thirty-three (3.6%) of the hamster egg complements were abnormal: 19 (2.1%) were hypohaploid, seven (0.76%) were hyperhaploid, two (0.2%) had double aneuploidy, and five (0.5%) had a structural chromosome abnormality. Since there were significantly more hypohaploid than hyperhaploid complements, a conservative estimate of aneuploidy can be derived by doubling the frequency of hyperhaploid complements. Thus a minimal estimate of aneuploidy (single, 1.5%, and double, 0.2%) is 1.7% and a minimal estimate of the total frequency of abnormalities is 2.2%. All chromosome groups were represented among the aneuploid complements suggesting that all chromosomes are susceptible to non-disjunction.     

The chromosome constitution of 1000 human spermatozoa

Summary Chromosomal analysis of 1000 spermatozoa from 33 normal men was performed using in vitro fertilization of zonafree golden hamster eggs. The frequency of abnormal sperm complements was 8.5%: 5.2% were aneuploid and 3.3% had a structural chromosome abnormality. The frequencies of hyperhaploid (2.4%) and hypohaploid (2.7%) sperm complements were not significantly different and all chromosome groups were represented among the aneuploid complements. The majority (22/33) of structurally abnormal complements had a chromosome break. The percentages of X and Y-bearing sperm were 53.9% and 46.1%, which is significantly different from the expected one to one ratio.     

Chromosomal analysis of unfertilized human oocytes

Unfertilized human oocytes were obtained from women in an in-vitro fertilization programme. The women had a mean age of 29.4 years (range 24-35 years). Chromosomal complements could be analysed in 50 oocytes. Q-banding of the chromosomes facilitated identification of individual chromosomes: 34 oocytes (68%) had the normal haploid chromosomal complement, 14 complements were hypohaploid (28%), 1 complement was hyperhaploid (2%) and 2 had structural abnormalities (4%). (One oocyte had numerical and structural abnormalities). The 16 abnormal oocytes were obtained from 15 different women. A conservative estimate of aneuploidy in this sample is 4%; however, the frequency of aneuploidy may be higher if there is a predisposition to chromosome loss during oogenesis. This study provides information on the largest series of karyotyped unfertilized human oocytes published to date.     

An increased frequency of human sperm chromosomal abnormalities after radiotherapy

13 cancer patients were studied before radiotherapy (RT) and at regular intervals after RT to determine the effect of RT on chromosomal abnormalities in sperm. The men were 19-47 years old and received testicular radiation doses of 0.4-5.0 Gray. Human pronuclear sperm chromosomes were analysed after penetration of zona-pellucida-free hamster eggs. Unfortunately the hamster egg penetration rates were exceedingly low, both before and after RT and this limited the number of sperm chromosome complements which could be analysed. Before RT, the frequency of abnormal sperm chromosome complements was 0% (0/9). After RT, the majority of men were azoospermic for 24 months but complements could be analysed from 4 men. In the first 12 months the frequency of abnormalities was 13% (1/8) and at 24 months it was 13% (7/55). By 36 months after RT, most men had recovered sperm production and the frequency of abnormalities in 8 men was 21% (18/86), which is significantly higher than the rate in control donors (8.5%). For individual men the range was 6-67%, and there was a significant correlation between testicular radiation dose and the frequency of sperm chromosomal abnormalities. The frequencies of both numerical and structural abnormalities were significantly increased after RT. This is the first evidence that radiation may increase the frequency of chromosomal abnormalities in human gametes.     

A cytogenetic investigation of the effects of cryopreservation on human sperm.

The effects of cryopreservation on the frequency and type of chromosome abnormalities in human sperm have been investigated for the first time. With a technique which enables direct visualization of human sperm chromosomes following in vitro penetration of hamster oocytes, sperm samples from 13 normal men were examined before and after being frozen in liquid nitrogen. The overall abnormality frequencies of 17.8% for fresh semen and 13.4% for previously frozen semen were not significantly different (chi 2(1) df = 3.04, p = 0.08). When specific abnormality types were analyzed, only the category of hypohaploidy was significantly different (chi 2(1) df = 6.75, p = 0.009) before (7.5%) and after (3.4%) freezing. Hypohaploidy was significantly higher than hyperhaploidy both prefreeze and postfreeze, and chromosome loss was random. Because the observed excess of hypohaploid cells may be attributable to technical artifact, the aneuploidy levels were estimated by doubling the number of hyperhaploid cells. Neither the adjusted numerical abnormality frequencies (1% prefreeze vs. 0% postfreeze) nor the overall abnormality frequencies (11.8% prefreeze vs. 10.4% postfreeze) were significantly different. The types and distributions of karyotypically abnormal sperm complements (numerical, structural, or combined) observed before and after freezing were not different. Interdonor variability in sperm chromosome abnormality frequencies and a possible donor-dependent response to cryopreservation were suggested by the data. The sex ratios were not affected by cryopreservation and did not differ significantly from the theoretical 50%. It is concluded that cryopreservation does not affect the type or frequencies of chromosome abnormalities or alter the sex ratio in human sperm.     

Chromosome aberrations in 450 sperm complements from eight controls and lack of increase after chemotherapy in two patients

Summary Four hundred fifty sperm complements from eight controls were analyzed. A conservative estimate of aneuploidy was 1.8% with a hyperhaploid rate of 0.9% (4/450). The overall frequency of structural aberrations was 8.9% (40/450). The proportion of X-bearing (47.5%) and Y-bearing (52.5%) sperm did not differ significantly. Sperm complements were analyzed from a cancer patient 9 months after poly chemotherapy (n = 63) and from a patient being treated with Imurek (azathioprine) (n = 30). There was no significant increase in the incidence of numerical and structural chromosome aberrations in the sperm of either patient. The percentages of X-bearing and Y-bearing sperm were not significantly different from the expected 50%.     

A study of paternal age and sex ratio in sperm chromosome complements.

There is conflicting evidence as to whether the secondary sex ratio in humans decreases with paternal age. Such an age effect could be caused by an altered frequency in the production of X-chromosome and Y-chromosome-bearing sperm as a man ages. To study this possibility we analysed 9,225 sperm karyotypes from 143 men aged 21-55 years. Human pronuclear sperm chromosome complements were obtained after fusion with golden hamster oocytes. The percentage of X- and Y-chromosome complements was not significantly related to donor age.     

Analysis of the chromosome complement in outbred mouse sperm fertilizing in vitro

The chromosome complements in a population of mouse sperm from random-bred ICR donors were analyzed at first-cleavage metaphase after in vitro fertilization (IVF) of oocytes from females of the same strain. The sperm were aged as donations occurred within an average of 31 days, either since last mating or at arrival at the animal facility in the case of virgin males. Of a total of 598 sperm complements studied from 22 sexually mature males aged 10–26 weeks old, there was one diploid complement (0.17%). The frequencies of hyperhaploidy and structural aberrations that were studied in 338 complements were 4.4% and 3.6%, respectively, giving an overall frequency of 8.0%. The hyperhaploid complements consisted of n + 1, n + 2, n + 3, and n + 7 counts, while the structural abnormalities were of the chromosome type and included large and small fragments and a possible translocation. This is the highest frequency of sperm chromosome abnormalities reported for mouse sperm obtained from males under physiological conditions and fertilized in vitro or in vivo. Sperm aging, strain, and/or technique differences are among the factors that may be responsible for this high frequency. Since the 8.0% frequency of hyperhaploidy and structural abnormalities is similar to the frequency reported for human sperm after IVF, the outbred murine in vitro fertilization system may be a useful model to study the origin of human sperm chromosome abnormalities.     

The relationship between sperm chromosomal abnormalities and sperm morphology in humans

It has been suggested that an assay for sperm morphology might prove useful as an initial screen in evaluating men at risk for an increased frequency of sperm chromosomal abnormalities. In this study, the technique for analysis of human sperm chromosomes after penetration of hamster eggs was employed to determine whether there is an association between the frequency of chromosomally and morphologically abnormal sperm. 30 healthy men of proven fertility were studied. The ages of the donors ranged from 22 to 55 years. The analysis was performed "blindly" so that the technician analysing the chromosome spreads had no knowledge of the age of the donors or of the individual frequencies of morphologically abnormal sperm. There was no significant relationship between the proportion of morphologically abnormal sperm and the proportion of chromosomally abnormal sperm when controlled for age. This was true for the total frequency of chromosomal abnormalities and also for numerical and structural chromosomal abnormalities. These results suggest that an assay of morphology is not a good indication of chromosomal normality in human sperm.     

Chromosome analysis of human sperm

Summary A modified technique has been developed for the visualization of the chromosomes in human sperm. The cytogenetic analysis of 129 G-banded human sperm metaphases of 6 normal donors showed an incidence of structural and numerical chromosome abnormalities of 7.8%. Two out of 129 spermatozoa were aneuploid (1.6%). The frequency of sperms with chromatid-type aberrations was 2.3% (3/129). Chromosome-type aberrations were found in 5 out of 129 (3.9%) spermatozoa. X to Y ratio did not differ significantly from the expected one-to-one ratio. Twenty-six sperm complements from a patient 18–20 months after testes exposure to 30 Gy were examined. A significant increase of numerical and structural chromosome abnormalities was not observed. Chromatidtype aberrations were found in two sperm complements (7.7%) and chromosome-type aberrations in one sperm complement (3.9%). The cytogenetic analysis of 15 human sperms from a cancer patient 26 months after chemotherapy showed an increased frequency of aberrant sperm complements (33.4%). One chromatid-type (6.7%), three chromosometype aberrations (20.0%) and one (6.7%) hyperploid sperm complement could be observed. The sample size is still too small to answer the question whether chemical mutagens may increase the frequency of chromosomal abnormalities in human sperm.     

Absence of age effect on meiotic recombination between human X and Y chromosomes

Recombination between the X and Y chromosomes is limited to the pseudoautosomal region and is necessary for proper segregation of the sex chromosomes during spermatogenesis. Failure of the sex chromosomes to disjoin properly during meiosis can result in individuals with a 47,XXY constitution, and approximately one-half of these result from paternal nondisjunction at meiosis I. Analysis of individuals with paternally derived 47,XXY has shown that the majority are the result of meiosis in which the X and Y chromosomes have failed to recombine. Our studies of sperm have demonstrated that aneuploid 24,XY sperm have a decreased recombination frequency, compared with that of normal sperm. Some studies have indicated a relationship of increased paternal age with 47,XXY offspring and with the production of XY disomic sperm, whereas others have failed to find such relationships. To determine whether there is a relationship between paternal age and recombination in the pseudoautosomal region, single-sperm genotyping was performed to measure the frequency of recombination between a sex-specific locus, STS/STS pseudogene, and a pseudoautosomal locus, DXYS15, in younger men (age < or =30 years) compared with older men (age > or =50 years). A total of 2,329 sperm cells were typed by single-sperm PCR in 20 men who were heterozygous for the DXYS15 locus (1,014 sperm from 10 younger men and 1,315 sperm from 10 older men). The mean recombination frequency was 39.2% in the younger men and 37.8% in the older men. There was no heterogeneity in the frequency of recombination rates. There was no significant difference between the recombination frequencies among the younger men and those among the older men, when analyzed by the clustered binomial Z test (Z=.69, P=.49). This result suggests that paternal age has no effect on the recombination frequency in the pseudoautosomal region.     

Chromosomal breakage in human spermatozoa, a heterozygous effect of the Bloom syndrome mutation.

The chromosome complements of 662 spermatozoa produced by the three fathers of individuals with Bloom syndrome (BS) were analyzed to determine whether the BS mutation could affect chromosome segregation and the frequency of aneuploidy in sperm. The frequency of numerical abnormalities was not significantly different from that in normal controls studied in our laboratory, but the frequencies of structural abnormalities were significantly increased in two of the men, 14.3% and 15.9%, versus 8.6% in controls. More striking was the increase in these two men of cells with multiple structural abnormalities: 8.1% and 6.7% with multiple abnormalities, versus 2.3% in controls.     

A comparison of chromosomal aberrations induced by in vivo radiotherapy in human sperm and lymphocytes

Chromosomal aberrations in human sperm and lymphocytes were compared before and after in vivo radiation treatment of 13 cancer patients. The times of analyses after radiotherapy (RT) were 1, 3, 12, 24, 36, 48 and 60 months. The median total radiation dose was 30 Gy and the testicular dose varied from 0.4 to 5.0 Gy. Human sperm chromosome complements were analysed after fusion with golden hamster eggs. There were no abnormalities in sperm or lymphocytes before RT. Following RT there was an increase in the frequency of numerical and structural chromosomal abnormalities in both lymphocytes and sperm. For structural abnormalities there were more rejoined lesions (dicentrics, rings) in lymphocytes and more unrejoined lesions (chromosome breaks, fragments) in sperm. After RT there was a dramatic increase in the frequency of chromosomal abnormalities in lymphocytes: at 1 mo. the frequency was 42%, at 3 mo. 25%, at 12 mo. 14%, at 24 mo. 11%, at 36 mo. 9%, at 48 mo. 7% and at 6 mo. 4%. Since the majority of men were azoospermic after RT, there is little data on sperm chromosome complements before the analyses performed at 24 mo. post-RT. At 24 mo. the frequency of abnormalities was 13%, followed by 21% at 36 mo., 12% at 48 mo. and 22% at 60 mo. Thus it appears that the frequency of lymphocyte chromosomal abnormalities had an initial marked increase after RT followed by a gradual decrease with time whereas the frequency of sperm chromosomal abnormalities was elevated when sperm production recovered and remained elevated from 24 to 60 mo. post-RT. This difference in the effect of time makes it very difficult to compare abnormality rates in lymphocytes and sperm and to use analysis of induced damage in somatic cells as surrogates for germ cells since the ratio between sperm and lymphocytes varied from 1:1 (at 24 mo. post-RT) to 5:1 (at 60 mo. post-RT).     

An analysis of structural aberrations in human sperm chromosomes

We have analyzed structural aberrations in 5,000 sperm chromosome complements obtained from 20 men over a 5-yr period by fusion of human sperm with hamster eggs. Detailed data are presented on 366 abnormal cells with 379 analyzable breakpoints. The frequency of cells with structural aberrations ranged from 1.9% to 14.5% among donors; this interindividual variability was statistically significant (p less than 0.0001). In contrast, repeat samples from individual men showed no significant variation over time. The number of sperm chromosome sets processed per hamster egg had no effect on the frequency with which structural aberrations occurred, nor were sperm chromosome abnormalities altered by varying capacitation or culture conditions. The spectrum of structural aberrations observed in human sperm chromosomes and a chi-square analysis of breakpoints based on DNA content are presented. Although human sperm chromosome abnormalities were visualized with a cross-species system, we believe that they represent an inherent, biologically significant phenomenon.     

Human sperm aneuploidy after exposure to pesticides

This study examined the effect of paternal environmental exposure to pesticides on the frequency of aneuploidy in human sperm. To determine if the chromosome number in germ cells was altered by paternal exposure, multicolor fluorescence in situ hybridization (FISH) analysis was utilized to measure aneuploidy frequencies in the sperm of 40 men (20 exposed, 20 controls). Samples were coded for "blind analysis" to eliminate scorer bias. Aneuploidy and diploidy frequencies were assessed for chromosomes 13, 21, X, and Y. A minimum of 10,000 sperm was scored per donor per chromosome probe with a total of 809,935 sperm scored. Hybridization efficiency was 99%. There were no significant differences in aneuploidy or diploidy frequencies between exposed and control groups, suggesting that the pesticides did not increase the risk of numerical chromosomal abnormalities in these men.     

The relationship between paternal age, sex ratios, and aneuploidy frequencies in human sperm, as assessed by multicolor FISH.

We studied the frequencies of X- and Y-chromosome-bearing sperm, diploidy and disomy for chromosomes 1, 12, X, and Y in sperm from 10 normal men aged 21-52 years, to determine whether there was any relationship between donor age and any of these variables. Multicolor FISH was used to control for lack of probe hybridization and to distinguish diploid sperm from disomic sperm. A minimum of 10,000 sperm per donor was evaluated for each chromosome, for a total of 225,846 sperm studied. Sperm were considered disomic if two fluorescent signals were separated by a minimal distance of one signal domain. The mean frequencies of X- and Y-bearing sperm were 50.1% and 49.0%, respectively; not significantly different from 50%. There was no correlation between paternal age and "sex ratio" in sperm. Similarly, there was no association between the frequency of diploid sperm (mean, .16%; range, .06-.42%) and donor age. For disomy frequencies, there was no relationship between donor age and disomy 12 (mean, .16%; range, .10%-.25%), XX (mean, .07%; range, .03%-.17%), and XY sperm (mean, .16%; range, .08%-.24%). There was a significant increase in the frequency of YY sperm (P = .04; mean, .18%; range, .10%-.43%) and disomy 1 sperm (P = .01; mean, .11%; range, .05%-.18%) with donor age. In summary, our results do not support a correlation between paternal age and sex ratio or diploidy.