Forced expression of desmin and desmin mutants in cultured cells: impact of myopathic missense mutations in the central coiled-coil domain on network formation

We recently demonstrated that inherited disease-causing mutations clustered in the alpha-helical coiled-coil "rod" domain of the muscle-specific intermediate filament (IF) protein desmin display a wide range of inhibitory effects on regular in vitro assembly. In these studies, we showed that individual mutations exhibited phenotypes that were not, with respect to the severity of interference, predictable by our current knowledge of the structural design of IF proteins. Moreover, the behavior of some mutated proteins in a standard tissue culture cell expression system was found to be even more complex. Here, we systematically investigate the behavior of these disease mutants in four different cell types: three not containing desmin or the related IF protein vimentin and the standard fibroblast line 3T3, which has an extensive vimentin system. The ability of the mutants to form filaments in the vimentin-free cells varies considerably, and only the mutants forming IFs in vitro generate extended filamentous networks. Furthermore, these latter mutants integrate into the 3T3 vimentin network but all the others do not. Instead, they cause the endogenous network of 3T3 vimentin to reorganize into perinuclear bundles. In addition, most of these assembly-deficient mutant desmins completely segregate from the vimentin system. Instead, the small round to fibrillar particles formed distribute independently throughout the cytoplasm as well as between the collapsed vimentin filament arrays in the perinuclear area.     

Molecular and biophysical characterization of assembly-starter units of human vimentin

We have developed an assembly protocol for the intermediate filament (IF) protein vimentin based on a phosphate buffer system, which enables the dynamic formation of authentic IFs. The advantage of this physiological buffer is that analysis of the subunit interactions by chemical cross-linking of internal lysine residues becomes feasible. By this system, we have analyzed the potential interactions of the coiled-coil rod domains with one another, which are assumed to make a crucial contribution to IF formation and stability. We show that headless vimentin, which dimerizes under low salt conditions, associates into tetramers of the A(22)-type configuration under assembly conditions, indicating that one of the effects of increasing the ionic strength is to favor coil 2-coil 2 interactions. Furthermore, in order to obtain insight into the molecular interactions that occur during the first phase of assembly of full-length vimentin, we employed a temperature-sensitive variant of human vimentin, which is arrested at the "unit-length filament" (ULF) state at room temperature, but starts to elongate upon raising the temperature to 37 degrees C. Most importantly, we demonstrate by cross-linking analysis that ULF formation predominantly involves A(11)-type dimer-dimer interactions. The presence of A(22) and A(12) cross-linking products in mature IFs, however, indicates that major rearrangements do occur during the longitudinal annealing and radial compaction steps of IF assembly.     

Characterization of structural changes in vimentin bearing an epidermolysis bullosa simplex-like mutation using site-directed spin labeling and electron paramagnetic resonance

Mutations in intermediate filament protein genes are responsible for a number of inherited genetic diseases including skin blistering diseases, corneal opacities, and neurological degenerations. Mutation of the arginine (Arg) residue of the highly conserved LNDR motif has been shown to be causative in inherited disorders in at least four different intermediate filament (IF) proteins found in skin, cornea, and the central nervous system. Thus this residue appears to be broadly important to IF assembly and/or function. While the genetic basis for these diseases has been clearly defined, the inability to determine crystal structure for IFs has precluded a determination of how these mutations affect assembly/structure/function of IFs. To investigate the impact of mutation at this site in IFs, we have mutated the LNDR to LNDS in vimentin, a Type III intermediate filament protein, and have examined the impact of this change on assembly using electron paramagnetic resonance. Compared with wild type vimentin, the mutant shows normal formation of the coiled coil dimer, with a slight reduction in the stability of the dimer in rod domain 1. Probing the dimer-dimer interactions shows the formation of normal dimer centered on residue 191 but a failure of dimerization at residue 348 in rod domain 2. These data point toward a specific stage of assembly at which a common disease-causing mutation in IF proteins interrupts assembly.     

Plasticin, a type III neuronal intermediate filament protein, assembles as an obligate heteropolymer: implications for axonal flexibility

The assembly characteristics of the neuronal intermediate filament protein plasticin were studied in SW13 cells in the presence and absence of a cytoplasmic filament network. Full-length plasticin cannot polymerize into homopolymers in filament-less SW13c1.2Vim(-) cells but efficiently coassembles with vimentin in SW13c1.1Vim(-) cells. By cotransfecting plasticin and vimentin in SW13c1.1Vim(-) cells, we show that plasticin assembly requires vimentin in noncatalytic amounts. Differing effects on assembly were seen with point mutations of plasticin monomers that were analogous to the keratin mutations that cause epidermolysis bullosa simplex (EBS). In particular, plasticin monomers with point mutations analogous to those in EBS do not uniformly inhibit neurofilament (NF) network formation. A point mutation in the helix termination sequence resulted in complete filament aggregation when coexpressed with vimentin but showed limited coassembly with low- and medium-molecular-weight NF proteins (NF-L and NF-M, respectively). In transfected SW13c1.1Vim(+) cells, a point mutation in the first heptad of the alpha-helical coil region formed equal amounts of filaments, aggregates, and a mixture of filaments and aggregates. Furthermore, coexpression of this point mutation with NF-L and NF-M was associated with a shift toward increased numbers of aggregates. These results suggest that there are important structural differences in assembly properties between homologous fish and mammalian intermediate filament proteins. These structural differences may contribute to the distinctive growth characteristics of the teleost visual pathway.     

Assembly of amino-terminally deleted desmin in vimentin-free cells

To study the role of the amino-terminal domain of the desmin subunit in intermediate filament (IF) formation, several deletions in the sequence encoding this domain were made. The deleted hamster desmin genes were fused to the RSV promoter. Expression of such constructs in vimentin- free MCF-7 cells as well as in vimentin-containing HeLa cells, resulted in the synthesis of mutant proteins of the expected size. Single- and double-label immunofluorescence assays of transfected cells showed that in the absence of vimentin, desmin subunits missing amino acids 4-13 are still capable of filament formation, although in addition to filaments large numbers of desmin dots are present. Mutant desmin subunits missing larger portions of their amino terminus cannot form filaments on their own. It may be concluded that the amino-terminal region comprising amino acids 7-17 contains residues indispensable for desmin filament formation in vivo. Furthermore it was shown that the endogenous vimentin IF network in HeLa cells masks the effects of mutant desmin on IF assembly. Intact and mutant desmin colocalized completely with endogenous vimentin in HeLa cells. Surprisingly, in these cells endogenous keratin also seemed to colocalize with endogenous vimentin, even if the endogenous vimentin filaments were disturbed after expression of some of the mutant desmin proteins. In MCF-7 cells some overlap between endogenous keratin and intact exogenous desmin filaments was also observed, but mutant desmin proteins did not affect the keratin IF structures. In the absence of vimentin networks (MCF-7 cells), the initiation of desmin filament formation seems to start on the preexisting keratin filaments. However, in the presence of vimentin (HeLa cells) a gradual integration of desmin in the preexisting vimentin filaments apparently takes place.     

Ultrastructural Studies of Carboxyl-Terminal Truncation Mutants of the Neuronal Intermediate Filament Protein Peripherin

Abstract: We have prepared carboxyl-terminal truncation mutants of the neuronal intermediate filament (IF) protein peripherin and examined the assembly characteristics of these mutant proteins in SW13 cells in the presence and absence of vimentin. In the absence of vimentin, tailless peripherin protein (Per-C424) self-assembles into bundles and clumps as observed by immunofluorescence, whereas a peripherin mutant that is missing the tail as well as a small portion of the rod (Per-C356) appears as spherical aggregates. Similar phenotypes are observed when vimentin-positive cells are transfected with Per-C424 or Per-C356. In these cells, the entire IF network is disrupted, and vimentin colocalizes with the mutant peripherin proteins. To examine the morphology of the bundles and clumps formed by Per-C424 at the electron microscopic level, we prepared stable cell lines expressing different levels of this mutant protein. By immunofluorescence, Per-C424 appears as either clumps or bundles of filaments depending on the expression level of the mutant protein. However, under electron microscopy, it is apparent that both clumps and bundles are composed of tightly packed IFs. We were unable to obtain stable cell lines expressing Per-C356, indicating that this mutant may prevent cell proliferation. Using a vector containing an internal ribosomal entry site, we prepared a construct that expresses Per-C356 and green fluorescent protein as a single mRNA, and we were able to isolate cells that expressed Per-C356 by fluorescence-activated cell sorting. Electron microscopic analysis of these cells showed that these aggregates are solid and contain no obvious filamentous structures.     

The biology of desmin filaments: how do mutations affect their structure, assembly, and organisation?

Desmin, the major intermediate filament (IF) protein of muscle, is evolutionarily highly conserved from shark to man. Recently, an increasing number of mutations of the desmin gene has been described to be associated with human diseases such as certain skeletal and cardiac myopathies. These diseases are histologically characterised by intracellular aggregates containing desmin and various associated proteins. Although there is progress regarding our knowledge on the cellular function of desmin within the cytoskeleton, the impact of each distinct mutation is currently not understood at all. In order to get insight into how such mutations affect filament assembly and their integration into the cytoskeleton we need to establish IF structure at atomic detail. Recent progress in determining the dimer structure of the desmin-related IF-protein vimentin allows us to assess how such mutations may affect desmin filament architecture.     

Electron paramagnetic resonance analysis of the vimentin tail domain reveals points of order in a largely disordered region and conformational adaptation upon filament assembly

Very little data have been reported that describe the structure of the tail domain of any cytoplasmic intermediate filament (IF) protein. We report here the results of studies using site directed spin labeling and electron paramagnetic resonance (SDSL‐EPR) to explore the structure and dynamics of the tail domain of human vimentin in tetramers (protofilaments) and filaments. The data demonstrate that in contrast to the vimentin head and rod domains, the tail domains are not closely apposed in protofilaments. However, upon assembly into intact IFs, several sites, including positions 445, 446, 451, and 452, the conserved “beta‐site,” become closely apposed, indicating dynamic changes in tail domain structure that accompany filament elongation. No evidence is seen for coiled‐coil structure within the region studied, in either protofilaments or assembled filaments. EPR analysis also establishes that more than half of the tail domain is very flexible in both the assembly intermediate and the intact IF. However, by positioning the spin label at distinct sites, EPR is able to identify both the rod proximal region and sites flanking the beta‐site motif as rigid locations within the tail. The rod proximal region is well assembled at the tetramer stage with only slight changes occurring during filament elongation. In contrast, at the beta site, the polypeptide backbone transitions from flexible in the assembly intermediate to much more rigid in the intact IF. These data support a model in which the distal tail domain structure undergoes significant conformational change during filament elongation and final assembly.     

Characterization of dominant and recessive assembly-defective mutations in mouse neurofilament NF-M

We have generated a set of amino- and carboxy-terminal deletions of the neurofilament NF-M gene and determined the molecular consequences of forced expression of these mutant constructs in mouse fibroblasts. To follow the expression of mutant NF-M subunits in transfected cells, a 12 amino acid epitope (from the human c-myc protein) was expressed at the carboxy terminus of each mutant. We show that NF-M molecules missing up to 90 or 70% of the nonhelical carboxy-terminal tail or amino-terminal head domains, respectively, incorporate readily into an intermediate filament network comprised either of vimentin or NF-L, whereas deletions into either the amino- or carboxy-terminal alpha- helical rod region generate assembly-incompetent polypeptides. Carboxy- terminal deletions into the rod domain invariably yield dominant mutants which rapidly disrupt the array of filaments comprised of NF-L or vimentin. Accumulation of these mutant NF-M subunits disrupts vimentin filament arrays even when present at approximately 1% the level of the wild-type subunits. In contrast, the amino-terminal deletions into the rod produce pseudo-recessive mutants that perturb the wild-type NF-L or vimentin arrays only modestly. The inability of such amino-terminal mutants to disrupt wild-type subunits defines a region near the amino-terminal alpha-helical rod domain (residues 75- 126) that is required for the earliest steps in filament assembly.     

Recent insight into intermediate filament structure

Intermediate filaments (IFs) are key players in multiple cellular processes throughout human tissues. Their biochemical and structural properties are important for understanding filament assembly mechanisms, for interactions between IFs and binding partners, and for developing pharmacological agents that target IFs. IF proteins share a conserved coiled-coil central-rod domain flanked by variable N-terminal ‘head’ and C-terminal ‘tail’ domains. There have been several recent advances in our understanding of IF structure from the study of keratins, glial fibrillary acidic protein, and lamin. These include discoveries of (i) a knob–pocket tetramer assembly mechanism in coil 1B; (ii) a lamin-specific coil 1B insert providing a one-half superhelix turn; (iii) helical, yet flexible, linkers within the rod domain; and (iv) the identification of coil 2B residues required for mature filament assembly. Furthermore, the head and tail domains of some IFs contain low-complexity aromatic-rich kinked segments, and structures of IFs with binding partners show electrostatic surfaces are a major contributor to complex formation. These new data advance the connection between IF structure, pathologic mutations, and clinical diseases in humans.     

Role of the aromatic residues in the near-amino terminal motif of vimentin in intermediate filament assembly in vitro

Type III and IV intermediate filament (IF) proteins share a conserved sequence motif of -Tyr-Arg-Arg-X-Phe- at the near-amino termini. To characterize significance of the aromatic residues in the motif, we prepared vimentin mutants in which Tyr-10 and Phe-14 are substituted with Asn and Ser (Vim[Y10N], Vim[F14S] and Vim[Y10N, F14S]), and examined assembly properties in vitro by electron microscopy and viscosity measurements. At 2 s after initiation of assembly reaction at pH 7.2 and 150 mM NaCl, all the vimentin mutants formed so-called unit-length filaments (ULFs) that were slightly larger than ULFs of wild-type vimentin. In following filament elongation, Vim[Y10N, F14S] and Vim[Y10N] performed longitudinal annealing of ULFs very rapidly and formed IFs within only 2.5 and 5 min, respectively, while Vim[F14S] and wild-type vimentin gave IFs by 40-60 min. The IFs of Vim[Y10N, F14S] and Vim[Y10N], however, tended to intertwine each other and formed bundles in parts of the specimens. The intertwinements decreased as the salt concentration decreased, and optimal salt concentration for the two mutants to form normal IFs was 50 mM. These results suggest that the aromatic residues, especially Tyr-10, in the motif have a role in controlling intermolecular interactions involved in IF assembly in vitro and suppress undesirable filament intertwinements at physiological ionic strength.     

Describing the structure and assembly of protein filaments by EPR spectroscopy of spin-labeled side chains

In this review we summarize our approach to the study of Intermediate Filament (IF) structure and assembly by electron paramagnetic resonance (EPR) spectroscopy of site-directed spin labels. Using vimentin, a homopolymeric type III IF protein, we demonstrate that this approach serves as a general paradigm for studying protein filament structure and assembly. These strategies will be useful in exploring the structure and assembly properties of other filamentous or aggregation-prone systems.     

Vimentin Coil 1A—A Molecular Switch Involved in the Initiation of Filament Elongation

Interestingly, our previously published structure of the coil 1A fragment of the human intermediate filament protein vimentin turned out to be a monomeric α-helical coil instead of the expected dimeric coiled coil. However, the 39-amino-acid-long helix had an intrinsic curvature compatible with a coiled coil. We have now designed four mutants of vimentin coil 1A, modifying key a and d positions in the heptad repeat pattern, with the aim of investigating the molecular criteria that are needed to stabilize a dimeric coiled-coil structure. We have analysed the biophysical properties of the mutants by circular dichroism spectroscopy, analytical ultracentrifugation and X-ray crystallography. All four mutants exhibited an increased stability over the wild type as indicated by a rise in the melting temperature (T_m). At a concentration of 0.1 mg/ml, the T_m of the peptide with the single point mutation Y117L increased dramatically by 46 °C compared with the wild-type peptide. In general, the introduction of a single stabilizing point mutation at an a or a d position did induce the formation of a stable dimer as demonstrated by sedimentation equilibrium experiments. The dimeric oligomerisation state of the Y117L peptide was furthermore confirmed by X-ray crystallography, which yielded a structure with a genuine coiled-coil geometry. Most notably, when this mutation was introduced into full-length vimentin, filament assembly was completely arrested at the unit-length filament (ULF) level, both in vitro and in cDNA-transfected cultured cells. Therefore, the low propensity of the wild-type coil 1A to form a stable two-stranded coiled coil is most likely a prerequisite for the end-to-end annealing of ULFs into filaments. Accordingly, the coil 1A domains might “switch” from a dimeric α-helical coiled coil into a more open structure, thus mediating, within the ULFs, the conformational rearrangements of the tetrameric subunits that are needed for the intermediate filament elongation reaction.     

Do the ends justify the mean? Proline mutations at the ends of the keratin coiled-coil rod segment are more disruptive than internal mutations

Intermediate filament (IF) assembly is remarkable, in that it appears to be self-driven by the primary sequence of IF proteins, a family (40-220 kd) with diverse sequences, but similar secondary structures. Each IF polypeptide has a central 310 amino acid residue alpha-helical rod domain, involved in coiled-coil dinner formation. Two short (approximately 10 amino acid residue) stretches at the ends of this rod are more highly conserved than the rest, although the molecular basis for this is unknown. In addition, the rod is segmented by three short nonhelical linkers of conserved location, but not sequence. To examine the degree to which different conserved helical and nonhelical rod sequences contribute to dimer, tetramer, and higher ordered interactions, we introduced proline mutations in residues throughout the rod of a type I keratin, and we removed existing proline residues from the linker regions. To further probe the role of the rod ends, we introduced more subtle mutations near the COOH-terminus. We examined the consequences of these mutations on (a) IF network formation in vivo, and (b) 10-nm filament assembly in vitro. Surprisingly, all proline mutations located deep in the coiled-coil rod segment showed rather modest effects on filament network formation and 10-nm filament assembly. In addition, removing the existing proline residues was without apparent effect in vivo, and in vitro, these mutants assembled into 10-nm filaments with a tendency to aggregate, but with otherwise normal appearance. The most striking effects on filament network formation and IF assembly were observed with mutations at the very ends of the rod. These data indicate that sequences throughout the rod are not equal with respect to their role in filament network formation and in 10-nm filament assembly. Specifically, while the internal rod segments seem able to tolerate considerable changes in alpha-helical conformation, the conserved ends seem to be essential for creating a very specific structure, in which even small perturbations can lead to loss of IF stability and disruption of normal cellular interactions. These findings have important implications for the disease Epidermolysis Bullosa Simplex, arising from point mutations in keratins K5 or K14.     

Characterization of the nucleic acid binding region of the intermediate filament protein vimentin by fluorescence polarization

Employing deletion mutant proteins and fluorescein-labeled oligodeoxyribonucleotides in a fluorescence polarization assay, the nucleic acid binding site of the intermediate filament (IF) subunit protein vimentin was localized to the middle of the arginine-rich, non-alpha-helical, N-terminal head domain. While deletion of the first few N-terminal residues (up to amino acid 17) had almost no effect, deletions of residues 25-64 or 25-68 essentially abolished the binding of nucleic acids by the respective proteins. Proteins with smaller deletions, of residues 25-39 or 43-68, were still able to bind nucleic acids quite well at low ionic strength, but only the proteins containing the first DNA-binding wing (residues 27-39) retained the ability to stably bind nucleic acids at physiological ionic strength. These results were confirmed by data obtained with two synthetic peptides whose sequences correspond to the smaller deletions. Nitration experiments showed that one or more of the tyrosines in the head domain are responsible for the stable binding by intercalation. Interestingly, the residues responsible for binding nucleic acids can be deleted without major influence on the in vivo polymerization properties of the mutant proteins. Only the protein with the largest internal deletion, of residues 25-68, failed to form filaments in vivo. Since the N-terminal head domains of IF proteins are largely exposed on the filament surface, but nevertheless essential for filament assembly, these results support the model that the middle of the head domain of vimentin may loop out from the filament surface and thus be available for interactions with other cellular structures or molecules.     

Unusual ultrastructures of the Branchiostoma IF protein C2 containing heptads in the tail

Branchiostoma intermediate filament (IF) protein C2 contains a long tail domain consisting of several degenerate repeats which display a heptad repeat pattern. This unique tail sequence is predicted to constitute a long coiled coil domain in C2, which is separated from the rod by a glycine-rich linker L3. The recombinant IF protein C2 shows, in electron microscopy (EM), parallel rodlike dimers of 66.7 nm decorated by a larger globule on one side and a smaller globule on the other side. In contrast, the length of the tailless C2 dimers, decorated by only one small globule, is about 26 nm shorter. These results indicate that both the rod domain and the newly predicted coiled coil segment 3 participate in the formation of a double-stranded coiled coil dimer. Moreover, the two to four C2 dimers are able to associate via their globular tail domain into multiarm oligomers, an ability not seen by the tailless C2 mutant or the other currently known protostomic and vertebrate IFs.     

Assembly defects of desmin disease mutants carrying deletions in the alpha-helical rod domain are rescued by wild type protein

Most mutations of desmin that cause severe autosomal dominant forms of myofibrillar myopathy are point mutations and locate in the central alpha-helical coiled-coil rod domain. Recently, two in-frame deletions of one and three amino acids, respectively, in the alpha-helix have been described and discussed to drastically interfere with the architecture of the desmin dimer and possibly also the formation of tetramers and higher order complexes [Kaminska, A., Strelkov, S.V., Goudeau, B., Olive, M., Dagvadorj, A., Fidzianska, A., Simon-Casteras, M., Shatunov, A., Dalakas, M.C., Ferrer, I., Kwiecinski, H., Vicart, P., Goldfarb, L.G., 2004. Small deletions disturb desmin architecture leading to breakdown of muscle cells and development of skeletal or cardioskeletal myopathy. Hum. Genet. 114, 306-313.]. Therefore, it was proposed that they may poison intermediate filament (IF) assembly. We have now recombinantly synthesized both mutant proteins and subjected them to comprehensive in vitro assembly experiments. While exhibiting assembly defects when analyzed on their own, both one-to-one mixtures of the respective mutant protein with wild type desmin facilitated proper filament formation. Transient transfection studies complemented this fundamental finding by demonstrating that wild type desmin is also rescuing these assembly defects in vivo. In summary, our findings strongly question the previous hypothesis that it is assembly incompetence due to molecular rearrangements caused by the mutations, which triggers the development of disease. As an alternative, we propose that these mutations cause subtle age-dependent structural alterations of desmin IFs that eventually lead to disease.     

The roles of the rod end and the tail in vimentin IF assembly and IF network formation

Using mutagenesis, we investigated the importance of two vimentin domains: (a) a highly conserved segment near the carboxy end of the alpha-helical rod, and (b) the tail, with which the rod end is known to interact. As judged by in vitro filament assembly and expression in transiently transfected cells lacking an endogenous vimentin network, the rod-tail interaction is not essential for 10 nm filament structure in vitro or for formation of fibrous arrays in culture. However, when mutated, amino acid residues within the rod and the tail segments can cause perturbations in IF assembly and in IF network formation. Finally, our studies show that the vimentin tail seems to play a role both in thermodynamically stabilizing IF structure in vitro and in establishing proper IF networks in vivo.     

Self-assembly incompetence of synemin is related to the property of its head and rod domains

The mechanisms regulating the intermediate filament (IF) protein assembly are complex and not yet fully understood. All vertebrate cytoplasmic IF proteins have a central alpha-helical rod domain flanked by variable head and tail domains. The IF protein synemin cannot homopolymerize to form filament networks; it needs an appropriate copolymerization partner. To elucidate the roles of the vimentin head domain, the TAAL motif in the 2A region, and the TYRKLLEGEE motif in the 2B region of the rod domain in synemin filament formation, we have prepared a series of synemin constructs by site-directed mutagenesis and chimeric synemins having the vimentin head domain. The assembly properties of synemin constructs were assessed by the immunofluorescence of transient transfection into cultured SW13 cells without endogenous IFs. Our data showed that the formation of a filamentous network required at least the vimentin-like head domain and both the 2A and 2B regions of the rod domain.