Structure determination and analysis of yeast iso-2-cytochrome c and a composite mutant protein.

As part of a study of protein folding and stability, the three-dimensional structures of yeast iso-2-cytochrome c and a composite protein (B-2036) composed of primary sequences of both iso-1 and iso-2-cytochromes c have been solved to 1.9 A and 1.95 A resolutions, respectively, using X-ray diffraction techniques. The sequences of iso-1 and iso-2-cytochrome c share approximately 84% identity and the B-2036 composite protein has residues 15 to 63 from iso-2-cytochrome c with the rest being derived form the iso-1 protein. Comparison of these structures reveals that amino acid substitutions result in alterations in the details of intramolecular interactions. Specifically, the substitution Leu98Met results in the filling of an internal cavity present in iso-1-cytochrome c. Further substitutions of Val20Ile and Cys102Ala alter the packing of secondary structure elements in the iso-2 protein. Blending the isozymic amino acid sequences in this latter area results in the expansion of the volume of an internal cavity in the B-2036 structure to relieve a steric clash between Ile20 and Cys102. Modification of hydrogen bonding and protein packing without disrupting the protein fold is illustrated by the His26Asn and Asn63Ser substitutions between iso-1 and iso-2-cytochromes c. Alternatively, a change in main-chain fold is observed at Gly37 apparently due to a remote amino acid substitution. Further structural changes occur at Phe82 and the amino terminus where a four residue extension is present in yeast iso-2-cytochrome c. An additional comparison with all other eukaryotic cytochrome c structures determined to date is presented, along with an analysis of conserved water molecules. Also determined are the midpoint reduction potentials of iso-2 and B-2036 cytochromes c using direct electrochemistry. The values obtained are 286 and 288 mV, respectively, indicating that the amino acid substitutions present have had only a small impact on the heme reduction potential in comparison to iso-1-cytochrome c, which has a reduction potential of 290 mV.     

Genetic analysis of yeast iso-1-cytochrome c structural requirements: suppression of Gly6 replacements by an Asn52----Ile replacement.

Gly6 (vertebrate numbering system) is an evolutionarily invariant amino acid located in an electron-dense region of cytochrome c. Serine, cysteine, and aspartic acid replacements of Gly6 abolished yeast iso-1-cytochrome c function, presumably by destabilizing the mature forms of the altered proteins (1). Here we report that genetic reversion analysis of these mutants has uncovered a single base-pair substitution, encoding an Asn52----Ile replacement, that suppresses all three position 6 defects, as well as a Gly6....Gly29----Ser6....Ser29 double replacement. In each case the suppressor restored at least partial function to the altered iso-1-cytochromes c, with the Sera6....Ile52 protein being nearly indistinguishable from the normal protein. The suppressor also affected otherwise normal iso-1-cytochrome c, enhancing the in vivo amount of the protein by about 20%. While this work was in progress, Das et al. (1989, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 86, 496-499) uncovered Ile52 as a suppressor of single Gly29 and His33 replacements in iso-1-cytochrome c. The ability of Ile52 to suppress amino acid replacements at three different sites, and its effect in isolation from the primary mutations, defines Ile52 as a global suppressor of specific iso-1-cytochrome c structural defects. These data suggest that position 52 plays a critical role in the folding and/or stability of iso-1-cytochrome c.     

Substitutions of proline 76 in yeast iso-1-cytochrome c. Analysis of residues compatible and incompatible with folding requirements

Fine-structure genetic mapping previously revealed numerous nonfunctional cyc1 mutations having alterations at or near the site corresponding to amino acid position 76 of iso-1-cytochrome c from the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. DNA sequencing of the alterations in four of these cyc1 mutations indicated that the normal Pro-76 was replaced by Leu-76. Revertants containing at least partially functional iso-1-cytochromes c were isolated, and the alterations were analyzed by DNA sequencing and protein analysis. Specific activities of the altered iso-1-cytochromes c were estimated in vivo by growth of the strains in lactate medium; compared to normal iso-1-cytochrome c with Pro-76, the following activities were associated with the following replacements: approximately 90% for Val-76, approximately 60% for Thr-76, approximately 30% for Ser-76, approximately 20% for Ile-76, and 0% for Leu-76. In order to develop an understanding of the factors that determine whether or not an altered iso-1-cytochrome c will function, we undertook a theoretical analysis which led to the conclusion that the activity of the proteins was dependent on both short- and long-range interactions. Short-range interactions were estimated from studies on known protein structures which gave the likelihood that various amino acids would be found in a local backbone configuration similar to the native protein; long-range interactions with the rest of the molecule were analyzed by considering the size of the side chain. We believe this approach can be used to analyze a wide variety of mutant proteins.     

Replacement of cysteine-107 of Saccharomyces cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c with threonine: improved stability of the mutant protein

Site-directed mutagenesis has been used to change the codon for cysteine-107 of Saccharomyces cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c to a threonine codon. The resulting protein is active in vivo, is methylated as in the wild-type protein and has optical properties indistinguishable from those of the wild-type protein. The threonine-107 iso-1-cytochrome c demonstrated fully reversible electrochemical behaviour and a mid-point reduction potential of 272 mV versus NHE. In addition, this mutant does not demonstrate a tendency to autoreduce or to dimerize as does the wild-type protein. These properties of the threonine-107 mutant establish that it will provide a useful background in which to make subsequent mutations for mechanistic and physical studies of yeast iso-1-cytochrome c.     

Mutants of Yeast Defective in Iso-1-Cytochrome c

A medium containing chlorolactate has been devised to enrich for mutants that are unable to utilize lactate for growth, and therefore that may be defective in cytochrome c. Complementation tests of 6,520 chlorolactate-resistant mutants that were obtained spontaneously or induced with UV, ICR-170, or nitrosoimidazolidone resulted in the identification of 195 mutations at the cyc1 locus, which controls the primary structure of iso-1-cytochrome c. These 195 mutants, with 16 cyc1 mutants previously isolated, were examined for total cytochrome c by spectroscopic methods, growth on lactate medium, suppressibility by defined nonsense suppressors, mutational sites by x-ray-induced recombination, ability to revert, and in 86 cases, whether intragenic revertants contain altered iso-1-cytochrome c. Except for the deletion mutant cyc1-1, all of the mutants appeared to contain single-site mutations that could be assigned to at least 35 different sites within the gene. The cyc1 mutants either completely lacked iso-1-cytochrome c or contained iso-1- cytochromes c that were completely or partially nonfunctional. In spite of the fact that the cyc1 mutants obtained by the chlorolactate procedure were selected on the basis of defective function, 68% appeared to completely lack iso-1-cytochrome c. The remaining cyc1 mutants contained below normal amounts of iso-1-cytochromes c. Studies at several incubation temperatures indicated that these nonfunctional iso-1-cytochromes c were thermolabile. It is suggested that the predominant means for abolishing iso-1-cytochrome c by mutations are either through a complete loss, such as produced by chain terminating codons, or impairments through drastic changes of tertiary structure which lead to instability and thermolability.     

Altered absorption spectra of iso-1-cytochromes c from mutants of yeast.

Low temperature (-190 degrees) spectrophotometric recordings were made of mutant strains of the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae containing various altered sequences of iso-1-cytochromes c. All mutants with replacements of the tryptophan 64 residue had abnormal Calpha-bands, in which the alpha2-peaks were accentuated to various degrees by being more separated from the major alpha1-peaks and by making up a larger portion of the total Calpha-peak. The altered iso-1-cytochromes c included those having the normal tryptophan 64 replaced by phenylalanine, leucine, tyrosine, cysteine, serine, or glycine as well as those having replacements at position 64 and additional replacements at other sites. Tryptophan 64 in iso-1-cytochrome c, which corresponds to tryptophan 59 in vertebrate cytochromes c, appears to be an important residue for preserving the electronic environment of the heme group. It is uncertain, however, whether altered spectra are due specifically to the abnormal residues at position 64 or due to distorted tertiary structures caused by the replacements.     

Ubiquitin conjugation to cytochromes c. Structure of the yeast iso-1 conjugate and possible recognition determinants.

Saccharomyces cerevisiae iso-1-cytochrome c was conjugated with ubiquitin (Ub) in vitro in a rabbit reticulocyte extract (Fraction II). By N-terminal protein sequencing, it was found for both the mono- and diubiquitinated products that the major Ub attachment site is on Lys4 (residue 9) of the cytochrome c. Thus, the residue ubiquitinated in iso-1-cytochrome c is identical with that previously determined for the yeast iso-2 form (Sokolik, C. W., and Cohen, R. E. (1991) J. Biol. Chem. 266, 9100-9107). For both cytochromes c, the proportions of diubiquitinated and higher order conjugates are drastically reduced when Ub is replaced with a Lys48----Arg variant, suggesting that the Ub-Ub moieties are linked predominantly through Lys48. Despite close similarities in structure and ubiquitination sites, conjugation to iso-2-cytochrome c is approximately 5-fold faster than for the iso-1 form; vertebrate cytochromes c are even poorer substrates, being ubiquitinated at only approximately 5% of the rate of the iso-2 protein. Comparison of several cytochrome c variants excludes alpha-N-acetylation or the identity of the N-terminal amino acid as the important recognition determinants in these reactions. The results, which include the finding that ferro and ferri-iso-2-cytochromes c are ubiquitinated equally, also are evidence against a simple correlation between ubiquitination efficiency and thermodynamic stability. Rather, the presence of a pair of lysines (Lys4-Lys5) within the relatively unstructured N-terminal extension of the yeast cytochromes c may be responsible for their preferential ubiquitination.     

Role of phenylalanine-82 in yeast iso-1-cytochrome c and remote conformational changes induced by a serine residue at this position

A three-dimensional structural analysis of the reduced form of the Ser-82 mutant protein of yeast iso-1-cytochrome c has been completed to 2.8-A resolution. Replacement of Phe-82 with a serine residue results in conformational changes both near and remote from the mutation site. Those groups undergoing positional shifts near Ser-82 include Arg-13, Gly-83 and -84, and the CBB methyl of the heme group. Remote shifts are centered about the propionate of pyrrole ring A and principally involve Asn-52, Trp-59, and an internally buried water molecule, WAT-166. Placement of a serine side chain at position 82 also leads to the formation of a large solvent channel which substantially increases the solvent accessibility of the heme group. This would appear to account for the much lower reduction potential observed for this protein. The detrimental effect of Ser-82 on both the steady-state activity and the rate of electron transfer in complexation with cytochrome c peroxidase can also be interpreted in terms of the modified character of the region about the mutation site. The remote conformational changes observed appear to represent the equivalent of the initial conformational changes occurring as yeast iso-1-cytochrome c is converted to the fully oxidized state during an electron-transfer event. These results agree well with the proposal [Moore, G. R. (1983) FEBS Lett. 161, 171-175] that the trigger for conformational changes between oxidation states resides in the nature of the interactions between the heme iron atom and the pyrrole ring A propionate group.     

Rational design of a more stable yeast iso-1-cytochrome c.

Yeast iso-1-cytochrome c is one of the least stable mitochondrial cytochromes c. We have used a coordinated approach, combining the known functional and structural properties of cytochromes c, to engineer mutations into yeast iso-1-cytochrome c with the goal of selectively increasing the stability of the protein. The two redox forms of the native protein and six different mutant forms of yeast iso-1-cytochrome c were analyzed by differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). The relative stability, expressed as the difference in the Gibb's free energy of denaturation at a given temperature between the native and mutant forms (DeltaDeltaG(Tref)), was determined for each of the proteins. In both oxidation states, the mutant proteins C102T, T69E/C102T, T96A/C102T, and T69E/T96A/C102T were more stable than the wild-type protein, respectively. The increased stability of the mutant proteins is proposed to be due to the removal of a rare surface cysteine and the stabilization of two distorted alpha-helices.     

Deletions and replacements of omega loops in yeast iso-1-cytochrome c

omega (omega)-loops are protein secondary structural elements having small distances between segment termini. It should be possible to delete or replace certain of these omega-loops without greatly distorting the overall structure of the remaining portion of the molecule. Functional requirements of regions of iso-1-cytochrome c from the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae were investigated by determining the biosynthesis and activity in vivo of mutant forms in which four different omega-loops were individually deleted, or in which one omega-loop was replaced with five different segments. Deletions encompassing amino acid positions 27-33 and 79-83 either prevented synthesis of the holoprotein, or produced highly labile iso-1-cytochromes c, whereas deletions encompassing positions 42-45 and 48-55 allowed partial synthesis and activity. These two latter regions, therefore, are not absolutely required for any biosynthetic process such as heme attachment, mitochondrial import, or for enzymatic interactions. All replacements in Loop A (residue positions 24-33) with same size (10 amino acid residues), longer (13 and 15 amino acid residues), or shorter segments (6 amino acid residues), resulted in strains having at least partial levels of iso-1-cytochrome c; however, the relative activities ranged from zero to almost the normal level. Thus, Loop A does not appear to be essential for such biosynthetic steps as heme attachment and mitochondrial import. In contrast, the full range of relative activities suggest that this region interacts with physiological partners to carry out efficient electron transport.     

Direct electrochemistry of proteins. Investigations of yeast cytochrome c mutants and their complexes with cytochrome b5.

Direct electrochemistry of site-specific mutants of yeast iso-1-cytochrome c (cyt c) and their complexes with bovine cytochrome b5 (cyt b5) has been investigated at edge-plane pyrolytic graphite (EPG) and bis(4-pyridyl)-disulphide-modified gold electrodes. Structure/function relationships have been investigated with the particular aim of clarifying the factors controlling the interactions of proteins at electrode/electrolyte interfaces and the determinants for direct electrochemistry in ternary protein/protein/electrode adducts, e.g. cyt c/cyt b5/EPG. Investigations of the cyt c mutants alone revealed a variety of electrochemical responses: all the mutants show similar voltammetric reversibility at modified gold electrodes, whereas at EPG electrodes the reversibility follows the order: Asn52Ile-Cys102Thr greater than Cys102Thr greater than Asn52Ala-Cys102Thr. Mid-point potentials follow the order: Arg13Ile (+60 +/- 5 mV vs. standard calomel electrode) greater than Cys102Thr (+40 +/- 5 mV) greater than Lys27Gln (+30 +/- 5 mV) approximately Lys72Asp (+30 +/- 5 mV) greater than Asn52Ala-Cys102Thr (+15 +/- 5 mV) greater than Asn52Ile-Cys102Thr (-10 +/- 5 mV). The structural basis for these differences is briefly discussed. When these mutants are bound to cyt b5, the differences in electrochemical response are greatly enhanced in the ternary cyt c/cyt b5/EPG adducts. A minimal analysis of these differences supports a model of multiple overlapping binding and recognition domains on cyt c which may be finely tuned to allow ternary complex formation so that a single-site variation could modify or abolish direct electrochemistry in the ternary adduct.     

Yeast iso-1-cytochrome c: genetic analysis of structural requirements

We describe the use of classical and molecular genetic techniques to investigate the folding, stability, and enzymatic requirements of iso-1-cytochrome c from the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Interpretation of the defects associated with an extensive series of altered forms of iso-1-cytochrome c was facilitated by the recently resolved three dimensional structure of iso-1-cytochrome c [(1987) J. Mol. Biol. 199, 295-314], and by comparison with the phylogenetic series of eukaryotic cytochromes c. Residue replacements that abolish iso-1-cytochrome c function appear to do so by affecting either heme attachment or protein stability; no replacements that abolish electron transfer function without affecting protein structure were uncovered. Most nonfunctional forms retained at least partial covalent attachment to the heme moiety; heme attachment was abolished only by replacements of Cys19 and Cys22, which are required for thioether linkage, and His23, a heme ligand. Replacements were uncovered that retain function at varying levels, including replacements at evolutionarily conserved positions, some of which were structurally and functionally indistinguishable from wild type iso-1-cytochrome c.     

Genes Affecting the Expression of Cytochrome c in Yeast: Genetic Mapping and Genetic Interactions

The four mutant genes, cyc2, cyc3, cyc8 and cyc9, that affect the levels of the two iso-cytochromes c in the yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae have been characterized and mapped. Both cyc2 and cyc3 lower the amount of iso-1-cytochrome c and iso-2-cytochrome c; whereas, cyc8 and cyc9 increase the amount of iso-2-cytochrome c. The cyc2, cyc3, cyc8 and cyc9 genes are located, respectively, on chromosomes XV, I, II and III, and are, therefore, unlinked to each other and unlinked to CYC1, the structural gene of iso-1-cytochrome c and to CYC7, the structural gene of iso-2-cytochrome c. While some cyc3 mutants are completely or almost completely deficient in cyotchromes c, none of the cyc2 mutants contained less than 10% of parental level of cytochrome c even though over one-half of the mutants contain UAA or UAG nonsense mutations. Thus, it appears as if a complete block of the cyc2 gene product still allows the formation of a residual fraction of cytochrome c. The cyc2 and cyc3 mutant genes cause deficiencies even in the presence of CYC7, cyc8 and cyc9, which normally cause overproduction of iso-2-cytochrome c. We suggest that cyc2 and cyc3 may be involved with the regulation or maturation of the iso-cytochromes c. In addition to having high levels of iso-2-cytochromes c, the cyc8 and cyc9 mutants are associated with flocculent cells and other abnormal phenotypes. The cyc9 mutant was shown to be allelic with the tup1 mutant and to share its properties, which include the ability to utilize exogenous dTMP, a characteristic flocculent morphology, the lack of sporulation of homozygous diploids and low frequency of mating and abnormally shaped cells of alpha strains. The diverse abnormalities suggest that cyc8 and cyc9 are not simple regulatory mutants controlling iso-2-cytochrome c.     

Role of hydrogen bond networks and dynamics in positive and negative cooperative stabilization of a protein

Cooperativity mediated through hydrogen bond networks in yeast iso-1-cytochrome c was studied using a thermodynamic triple mutant cycle. Three known stabilizing mutations, Asn 26 to His, Asn 52 to Ile, and Tyr 67 to Phe, were used to construct the triple mutant cycle. The side chain of His 26, a wild-type residue, forms two hydrogen bonds that bridge two substructures of the wild-type protein, and Tyr 67 and Asn 52 are part of an extensive buried hydrogen bond network. The stabilities of all variants in the triple mutant cycle were determined by guanidine hydrochloride denaturation methods and used to determine the pairwise, Delta(2)G(int), and triple interaction energies. His 26 and Ile 52 interact cooperatively (Delta(2)G(int) is 1-2 kcal/mol), whereas the two other pairs of mutations interact anticooperatively (Delta(2)G(int) is -0.5 to -1.5 kcal/mol). Previously reported structural data for iso-1-cytochrome c variants containing these mutations show that changes in the strength of the His 26 to Glu 44 hydrogen bond, apparently caused by changes in main chain dynamics, provide a mechanism for the long distance (His 26 to Phe 67 and His 26 to Ile 52) propagation of pairwise interaction energies. Opposing changes in the strength of the His 26 to Glu 44 hydrogen bond caused by the N52I and Y67F mutations generate a negative triple interaction energy (-0.9 +/-0.7 kcal/mol) that combined with cancellation of cooperative and anticooperative pairwise interactions produce apparent additivity for the stabilizing effects of the single mutations in the triple mutant variant.     

Mutation of asparagine 52 to glycine promotes the alkaline form of iso-1-cytochrome c and causes loss of cooperativity in acid unfolding

The kinetics and thermodynamics of the alkaline and acid conformational transitions of a Lys 79 --> Ala/Asn 52 --> Gly (A79G52) variant of iso-1-cytochrome c are studied. The Lys 79 --> Ala mutation is designed to limit heme ligation in the alkaline conformer to Lys 73. The Asn 52 --> Gly mutation is intended to shift the population of the alkaline conformer to physiological pH based on the hierarchical nature of the cooperative substructures of this protein. The midpoint pH for formation of the alkaline conformer is approximately 7.45. The kinetics for the alkaline conformational transition of the A79G52 variant are consistent with the ionization constant, pK(H), for the trigger group controlling formation of the alkaline conformer being approximately 9.5. This pK(H) is low for alkaline conformers involving lysine-heme ligation but is consistent with the pK(a) of the highest of three ionizable groups which modulate formation of the histidine-heme alkaline conformer of a His 73 variant of iso-1-cytochrome c [Martinez, R. E., and Bowler, B. E. (2004) J. Am. Chem. Soc. 126, 6751-6758]. The acid transition of the A79G52 variant is split into two phases. Both the Lys 79 --> Ala and Asn 52 --> Gly mutations are expected to affect the buried hydrogen bond network of cytochrome c, suggesting that this network is an important modulator of the acid unfolding of cytochrome c.     

A polypeptide chain-refolding event occurs in the Gly82 variant of yeast iso-1-cytochrome c

The replacement of Phe82 in yeast iso-1-cytochrome c by a glycine residue substantially alters both the tertiary structure and electron transfer properties of this protein. The largest structural change involves a polypeptide chain refolding of residues 79 through 85. Refolding places glycines 82, 83 and 84 immediately adjacent to the plane of the heme group in a spatial positioning comparable to that of the phenyl ring of Phe82 in the wild-type protein. Despite this perturbation in structure, solvent accessibility computations show that heme solvent exposure has not increased in the Gly82 variant protein. However, refolding does result in the introduction of a number of polar groups into the hydrophobic heme pocket. This appears to be responsible for the decreased reduction potential of the heme in this protein. The present study, along with that of the Ser82 variant protein (Louie et al., 1988b), clearly establishes the link between dielectric constant within the heme crevice and reduction potential. The further anomalously low electron transfer activity of the Gly82 variant protein would appear to arise from two factors. First, the polypeptide chain medium now adjacent to the heme is unable to facilitate electron transfer in a manner similar to that of the aromatic side-chain of Phe82. Second, polypeptide chain refolding significantly alters the surface contour of the Gly82 protein rendering it less suitable to interact with the corresponding complementary surfaces of redox partners. Our data support the conclusion that Phe82 plays a number of roles in the electron transfer process mediated by yeast iso-1-cytochrome c. These include the maintenance of the heme environment, provision of an optimal medium along the path of electron transfer and formation of interactions at the contact interface in complexes with redox partners.     

Crystallization and preliminary diffraction data for iso-1-cytochrome c from yeast

Deep red crystals of the electron transfer protein, iso-1-cytochrome c from yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae), have been obtained from a 90% saturated solution of (NH4)2SO4 containing 2 mg protein/ml, 0.1 M-sodium phosphate and adjusted to pH 6.7. The space group is P4(1)2(1)2 (or P4(3)2(1)2) with a = b = 36.4 A, c = 136.8 A and Z = 8. Crystals are stable for at least ten days in the X-ray beam and diffract to better than 2.0 A resolution. Comparable and morphologically similar crystal forms of three iso-1-cytochrome c mutants at Phe87, a pivotal residue in the electron transport chain, have also been obtained.