Similarities and distinctions between murine natural killer cells and lymphokine-activated killer cells

Pretreatment of mice with rabbit anti-asialo GM1 removes both natural killer (NK) effector cells and NK cells responsive to interleukin 2 (IL-2). Spleen cells from these mice do possess normal lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) activity. Young mice (less than 3 weeks of age) do not have NK activity and do not possess IL-2-inducible NK effector cells. Similarly to anti-asialo GM1-treated mice, LAK cells can be generated from these mice. While these experiments indicate clear distinctions between a certain level of NK and LAK precursors, the distinctions are not as clear when analyzing mice congenitally deficient in NK cells. Beige mice which lack NK effector cells and IL-2-inducible NK cells also lack the ability to generate LAK cells. The relationships and differences between NK- and LAK-cell precursors and effectors are discussed.     

Generation and characterization of purified adherent lymphokine-activated killer cells in mice

During the incubation of murine spleen, lymph node, or bone marrow cells with IL-2 (1000 U/ml) a small percentage of cells became adherent to the surface of plastic tissue culture flasks. After removal of the non-adherent lymphoid cells, plastic adherent lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells could be efficiently expanded in the presence of IL-2. Plastic adherent-derived A-LAK cells were characterized by high rates of proliferation and their cytotoxic activity was more than 10 fold higher than LAK cells generated in the bulk (unfractionated) spleen cell cultures. A-LAK cells could be continuously generated from the non-adherent cell population. Using multiple transfers (every 1 to 2 days) of non-adherent LAK cells into new flasks, new rounds of plastic adherent cells were generated with high expansion capability and high levels of cytotoxic activity. Morphologically, A-LAK cells were large granular lymphocyte and phenotypically expressed markers characteristic of NK cells (asialo GM1+, NK1.1+, Qa5+, Ly-6.2+, Thy-1.2+, but negative for Lyt-2.2 and L3T4). A-LAK cells generated from mice of different strains expressing low and high levels of NK cell activity were equally highly cytotoxic. However, A-LAK cells obtained from nude or beige mice had relatively lower levels of cytotoxicity. Stimulation of NK cell activity by poly I:C or inhibition by in vivo or in vitro treatment with anti-asialo GM1 serum did not affect the generation of A-LAK cells. A-LAK cells derived from spleen or bone marrow of C57BL/6 or nude mice treated with anti-asialo GM1 serum were found to be asialo GM1+ suggesting that A-LAK cell could be generated from the asialo GM1- precursor cells. Expansion of plastic adherent A-LAK cells in the presence of IL-2 could provide large numbers of highly purified cytotoxic A-LAK cells suitable for cancer immunotherapy.     

High expression of NKR-P1 is not an absolute requirement for natural killer activity in BDIX rats

 NKR-P1 has been identified as a triggering structure selectively expressed on rat natural killer (NK) cells and adherent lymphokine-activated killer (A-LAK) cells. In vivo treatment with anti-NKR-P1 monoclonal antibody (mAb 3.2.3) was shown to induce complete inhibition of NK cytotoxicity and elimination of LAK cell precursors in Lewis and Fisher rat strains. We investigated the effects of mAb 3.2.3 in a colon tumor model in BDIX rats. Inoculation of animals with mAb 3.2.3 even at very high doses induced a strong but incomplete inhibition of NK cytotoxicity in nylon-wool-non-adherent spleen and peripheral blood cells. Generation of adherent A-LAK cells from their spleen precursors was also strongly but not fully inhibited. We also investigated the effect of treatment with mAb 3.2.3 on the tumorigenicity of the NK-sensitive REGb cell line. When subcutaneously inoculated in syngeneic animals, REGb cells induce tumors that first grow for 2 weeks, then spontaneously regress and disappear. In contrast with previous results using anti-asialoGM1, no significant difference in tumor growth was observed between rats treated with mAb 3.2.3 and control animals, even with a long-term treatment. In vitro, mAb 3.2.3 exhibited the same incomplete efficiency. Nylon-wool-non-adherent spleen cells treated with mAb 3.2.3 plus complement were completely free of 3.2.3^bright cells, but retained a substantial NK activity and generated LAK cells after culture with IL-2. After an overnight incubation in standard medium of 3.2.3-depleted spleen cells, 3.2.3^bright cells were partially recovered and the NK cytotoxic activity, as well as the generation of LAK cells, was significantly enhanced. These results suggest that a strong expression of NKR-P1 is not required for BDIX mononuclear cells to exhibit NK function and generate LAK cells under IL-2 activation. Received: 11 July 1995 / Accepted: 16 November 1995     

Role of lymphokine-activated killer cells as mediators of veto and natural suppression

Fresh bone marrow cells have veto activity but little if any NK activity. By contrast, lymphokine-activated bone marrow cells have potent natural suppressor as well as veto activity, and also have cytolytic activity characteristic of lymphokine-activated killer cells. Veto activity of fresh bone marrow cells is eliminated by 9 Gy irradiation and by depletion of cells expressing Qa-2, but is unaffected by removal of cells expressing Thy-1, Qa-5, Ly-5, or asialo GM1. By contrast, the veto and NS activities of lymphokine-activated bone marrow cells are both abrogated by C lysis depletion of cells expressing Qa-2, Qa-5, Thy-1, asialo GM1, NK1, and Ly-11, but are unaffected by depletion of cells expressing Ly-2. Bone marrow cells depleted of Qa2+ cells fail to generate veto or natural suppressor activity when cultured in Con A-conditioned medium, unlike bone marrow cells depleted of mature NK1.1+ NK cells. Cloned NK cell line F8 is able to mediate both natural suppression and veto. These findings indicate that bone marrow veto and natural suppression are not mediated by T or NK cells present de novo in the bone marrow, but are dependent on proliferating cells that phenotypically resemble pre-NK cells. The progeny of these cells have the phenotype and functional activity of lymphokine-activated killer cells, and are capable of directly mediating both veto and natural suppression.     

Lymphokine-activated killer cells are rejected in vivo by activated natural killer cells

A 4-h in vivo cytotoxicity assay was used to study the fate of implanted IL-2-generated, lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells in mice undergoing an activated NK cell response. 125Iododeoxyuridine-labeled LAK cells were rejected from selected organs of C57BL/6 mice infected with lymphocytic choriomeningitis virus or treated with IL-2 or the IFN inducer poly I:C. This rejection was abrogated by the selective depletion of NK cells with antibodies to asialo-GM1 and NK1.1 Ag. Similar results were noted when LAK cells were generated from the spleens of B and T cell-deficient severe combined immunodeficiency mice and when LAK cells were implanted into severe combined immunodeficiency mice. These data indicate that NK cells activated by virus infections or by IL-2 infusions directly or indirectly eliminate implanted LAK cells. Because LAK cells are used in the treatment of certain human cancers, the strategy of accompanying this therapy with IL-2 infusions should be reassessed in light of these results.     

Lymphokine-activated killer cells in rats: generation of natural killer cells and lymphokine-activated killer cells from bone marrow progenitor cells

The coculture of rat bone marrow cells with recombinant interleukin-2 induced the generation of cells mediating natural killer (NK) activity and subsequent lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) activity depending upon the dose of IL-2 and time of culture. NK activity was detected as early as 4 to 5 days after the addition of IL-2 and could be evoked with as little as 5 to 50 U/ml. The induced NK cells had large granular lymphocyte (LGL) morphology and expressed 0X8 and asialo GM1 surface markers but did not express 0X19 or W3/25 markers. LAK activity was detected only after 5 days of culture, and required above 100 U/ml IL-2. Cells mediating LAK activity also expressed 0X8 and asialo GM1 but not 0X19. The generation of detectable NK and subsequent LAK activity was due to induction of early progenitor cells and not contaminating mature LGL/NK cells within the bone marrow population since of removal of such mature NK cells with L-leucine methyl ester (L-LME) did not affect the subsequent generation of either activity. Moreover, the removal of actively dividing cells as well as mature NK cells from the bone marrow by treatment with 5-fluorouracil (5-FU) in vivo enriched the remaining bone marrow population for both NK and LAK progenitor cells. The phenotype of the L-LME- and 5-FU-resistant NK and LAK progenitor cells within populations of bone marrow was determined by antibody plus complement depletion analysis. Although treatment of normal bone marrow with anti-asialo GM1 + C reduced the induction of NK and LAK activity in 5-day cultures, treatment of 5-FU marrow with anti-asialo GM1 + C did not affect either activity. Treatment with a pan-T cell antibody + C did not affect the development of NK or LAK activity under any conditions. Thus, the 5-FU-resistant NK/LAK progenitors were asialo GM1 negative but became asialo GM1+ after induction by IL-2. Finally, evidence that bone marrow-derived LAK cells were generated directly from the IL-2-induced NK cells was obtained by treating the IL-2-induced LGL/NK cells with L-LME.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 400 WORDS)     

Involvement of the 55- and 75-kDa tumor necrosis factor receptors in the generation of lymphokine-activated killer cell activity and proliferation of natural killer cells.

In this study we investigated the expression of the 55 kDa (p55) and the 75 kDa (p75) TNF receptors in CD56+ NK cells and their role in NK and lymphokine-activated killer cells cell functions. By using mAb against the p55 and p75 TNF-R, NK cells were found to express both p55 and p75 upon activation, and both receptors were involved in the generation of lymphokine-activated killer cells activity. Proliferative activity of IL-2 stimulated NK cells was inhibited by anti-TNF-alpha mAb, indicating that endogenously produced TNF-alpha is important for optimal proliferation of NK cells. Furthermore, addition of rTNF-alpha increased the IL-2-induced proliferation of NK cells. mAb to p55 and p75 inhibited the IL-2-induced proliferation indicating that both TNF-R are involved in mediating this effect.     

Accessory cells, dendritic cells, or monocytes, are required for the lymphokine-activated killer cell induction from resting T cell but not from natural killer cell precursors

In this study we have investigated the role of accessory cells in the development of lymphokine-activated killer cells (LAK) from highly purified human NK and small resting T cell progenitors. As accessory cells we used autologous, as well as allogeneic, monocytes, and dendritic cell enriched cells. Both NK and T cells were able to generate LAK activity, but their activation requirements were different. NK cells were activated merely by IL-2, and accessory cells did not enhance their lytic activity in the presence or absence of IL-2. Conversely, T cells were practically unresponsive to even high concentrations of IL-2 having a strict requirement for accessory cells for the development of lytic activity and proliferation. Accessory cells differed in their ability to activate T cells presumably depending on their ability to induce IL-2 synthesis, allogeneic dendritic cells being the most effective accessory cells and IL-2 synthesis stimulators. Allogeneic accessory cells could induce lytic activity in T cells even in the absence of exogenous IL-2. Thus, accessory cells play a central role in expanding the LAK effector cell population.     

Expression and function of TNF-related apoptosis-inducing ligand on murine activated NK cells.

TNF-related apoptosis-inducing ligand (TRAIL), a new member of TNF family, induces apoptotic cell death of various tumor cells. We recently showed that TRAIL mediates perforin- and Fas ligand (FasL)-independent cytotoxic activity of human CD4+ T cell clones. In the present study, we investigated the expression and function of TRAIL on murine lymphocytes by using newly generated anti-murine TRAIL mAbs. Although freshly isolated T, B, or NK cells did not express a detectable level of TRAIL on their surface, a remarkable level of TRAIL expression was induced preferentially on CD3- NK1.1+ NK cells after stimulation with IL-2 or IL-15. In contrast, TRAIL expression was not induced by IL-18, whereas it efficiently potentiated lymphokine-activated killer activity of NK cells. In addition to perforin inactivation and neutralization of FasL by anti-FasL mAb, neutralization of TRAIL by anti-TRAIL mAb was needed for the complete inhibition of IL-2- or IL-15-activated NK cell cytotoxicity against mouse fibrosarcoma L929 target cells, which were susceptible to both FasL and TRAIL. These results indicated preferential expression of TRAIL on IL-2- or IL-15-activated NK cells and its potential involvement in lymphokine-activated killer activity.     

IFN-beta 2/IL-6 augments the activity of human natural killer cells

MHC nonrestricted cytotoxic cells play an important role in the killing of tumor cells in vitro and potentially in vivo. The activity of these cells is regulated by several cytokines such as IL-2 and IFN. In the present study we provide first evidence that IL-6 significantly augments the cytotoxic activity of human NK cells. IL-6 is produced by many different cells and is also known as IFN-beta 2, B cell stimulatory factor 2, hybridoma growth factor, hepatocyte-stimulating factor, and 26 kDa protein. IL-6 stimulates the activity of human CD3- NK cells but not that of CD3+ non-MHC-restricted cytotoxic T lymphocytes. As is the case with IL-2, the IL-6-mediated augmented cytotoxicity was a result of a more efficient lysis, but was not caused by an increased effector to target cell binding. Moreover, the effect of IL-6 on NK cell activity was blocked by a mAb directed against IL-2, and IL-6 itself was found to be a potent inducer of IL-2 production in cultured human PBMC. Thus it may be concluded that IL-6 enhances the cytotoxic activity of NK cells via IL-2. This newly recognized property of IL-6, which is produced by almost any cell, may be of importance in host defense against microbes and malignancies and therefore could contribute to improve the adoptive immunotherapy by using lymphokine-activated killer cells.     

Generation of lymphokine-activated killer cell activity from non-NK precursor cells

It is possible to generate high levels of lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) activity in short-term culture from cells enriched for natural killer (NK) activity. To determine whether LAK activity can also be generated from non-NK cells, we have depleted peripheral blood lymphocytes (PBL) of NK cells prior to culture with IL-2. NK activity in PBL is correlated with the intensity of staining with the lysosomotropic vital dye quinacrine. Quinacrine dim PBL, which are devoid of lytic NK cells, are capable of developing LAK activity following culture with IL-2. We have also separated PBL using the NK-associated NKH-1 marker. Depleting NKH-1+ cells eliminates NK activity but the ability to develop LAK activity is retained. NKH-1-depleted cells generate less LAK activity than unseparated or NKH-1-positive cells and do not proliferate as well as unseparated cells to IL-2. When NK-depleted cells are subsequently examined for the expression of the NKH-1 antigen, this marker is absent from most cells at Day 3 of IL-1 culture, but is expressed on an increasing number of cells by Days 6-8. These results suggest that LAK derived from non-NK cells is functionally and phenotypically similar to LAK from PBL-containing NK cells, and may be the result of the activation of an NK precursor population.     

Interleukin-10 suppresses natural killer cell but not natural killer T cell activation during bacterial infection

Interleukin (IL)-10 is an anti-inflammatory cytokine known to modulate the outcome of sepsis by decreasing pro-inflammatory cytokine production, including IL-12, a main activator of natural killer (NK) cells. We hypothesized that neutralization of IL-10 would increase NK and natural killer T (NKT) cell activation through increased IL-12 in a mouse model of bacterial peritonitis. NK and NKT cell activations were measured by CD69 expression on NK1.1+/CD3- and NK1.1+/CD3+ cells after cecal ligation and puncture (CLP). NK cells were significantly more activated in mice treated with anti-IL-10 antibodies, whereas no such effect was observed in NKT cells. Similarly, intracellular interferon gamma (IFN-gamma) levels were increased in NK cells of anti-IL-10-treated mice, but not in NKT cells. IL-12 and IL-18 levels were increased in both CLP groups, but in anti-IL-10-treated mice, early IL-12 and late IL-18 levels were significantly higher than in controls. Survival at 18 h after CLP was lower in anti-IL-10 mice, which was associated with increased liver neutrophil accumulation. In summary, these data show an activating effect of IL-10 on NK, but not on NKT cells after CLP, which corresponded with decreased survival, higher IFN-gamma production, and increased remote organ neutrophil accumulation. These effects were not mediated by IL-12 and IL-18 alone, and reinforce a role for NK cells in remote organ dysfunction following peritonitis.     

Heterogeneity of human natural killer cell populations.

Natural killing (NK) in human donors was determined by the ability of peripheral blood subpopulations to lyse the myeloid target, K562, in a 2 to 4 hr ⁵¹Cr release assay. The most active cell was a non-T cell which passed through nylon columns (representing 10 to 25% of column passed cells). A second column passed cell population, with characteristics of T lymphocytes (75 to 90% of column passed cells), was also capable of mediating natural killing. Non-T cells which were retained by the nylon columns (45 to 55% of adherent cells) lacked NK activity. However, nylon adherent T cells (45 to 55% of adherent cells) were consistently active in NK assays, illustrating an important subset of NK effector cell often overlooked. Both column passed and adherent T cells were further separated according to their ability to bind IgG or IgM immune complexes, showing that those mediating NK have receptors for IgG (Tγ+) but not for IgM (Tμ+).     

Association of decreased natural and antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxicity and production of natural killer cytotoxic factor and interferon in neonates

Cord blood lymphocytes (CBL) were compared with adult peripheral blood lymphocytes (a-PBL) for their: (i) natural killer (NK) and antibody-dependent cellular cytotoxic (ADCC) activities, (ii) target-binding capacity, (iii) ability to induce soluble natural killer cytotoxic factor (NKCF), (iv) interferon (IFN)-, interleukin 2 (IL-2)-, and lectin-induced augmentation of NK activity, and (v) ability to produce IFN against tumor targets in vitro. CBL depleted of adherent cells and Percoll-separated, NK-enriched subpopulations demonstrated significantly lower NK, ADCC, and target-binding activities compared to a-PBL. CBL produced significantly lower levels of NKCF directed against K562 tumor targets in comparison with a-PBL. Although the NK activity of CBL was not stimulated by either IFN or IL-2 to the same levels shown by a-PBL, the percentage enhancement of cytotoxicity of CBL by IFN and IL-2 was greater than that of a-PBL. Lectin-induced enhancement of cytotoxicity was significantly greater for CBL in comparison with a-PBL. Further, the ability of CBL lymphocytes to produce IFN-gamma in vitro against K562 target cells was significantly lower than that of adult PBL. These studies suggest an association between decreased NK, ADCC, and target-binding activities, induction of NKCF and IFN production by CBL, and increased susceptibility of neonates to infection.     

Natural killer (NK) and lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cell functions from healthy dogs and 29 dogs with a variety of spontaneous neoplasms

To investigate natural killer (NK) and lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cell functions from 10 healthy dogs and 29 dogs with a variety of spontaneous neoplasms, large granular lymphocytes (LGLs) from blood samples were separated by a 58.5% Percoll density gradient. LGLs were stimulated with a low dose of recombinant human interleukin 2 (rhIL-2) for 7 days. Cytotoxicity of effector cells against the susceptible CTAC cell line was measured before and after stimulation. Compared with those before stimulation, the percentage of LGLs after stimulation with rhIL-2 was found to be significantly increased (P<0.01) in both dogs with tumors and controls. However, the increase was significantly higher in control animals, indicating a defect in proliferation ability of NK cells in canine tumor patients. After stimulation with rhIL-2, lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cell activity in dogs with tumors was significantly lower (P<0.01) when compared with controls. Reduced cytotoxicity of rhIL-2–activated NK cells in dogs with tumors seems to be attributable to the presence of a diminished proliferative capacity of NK cells and a decreased ability of LAK cells to lyse target cells. Further knowledge of the precise function of IL-2–activated NK cells in dogs with tumors may help to optimize new and therapeutically beneficial treatment strategies in canine and human cancer patients. Our findings suggest that the dog could also serve as a relevant large animal model for cancer immunotherapy with IL-2.     

Lack of spontaneous and inducible natural killer cell activity in human bone marrow: presence of adherent suppressor cells

Human bone marrow cells collected from ribs of patients undergoing thoracotomy had low or no natural killer (NK) cell activity against K562 in a 4-hour chromium release assay. In vitro overnight treatment with interferon or interleukin 2 of bone marrow cells resulted in no induction or augmentation of NK cell activity. In the presence of adherent bone marrow cells interferon was unable to enhance NK cell activity of blood lymphocytes, although the baseline level of NK cell activity was not suppressed. These results suggest that adherent bone marrow cells regulate the development of active NK cells and that bone marrow components do not provide a favorable environment for the functional differentiation of NK cells.     

Differential sensitivity of cytotoxic T lymphocytes and lymphokine-activated killer cells to inhibition by L-ornithine

The selective inhibition of murine cytotoxic T lymphocyte (CTL) differentiation in C57B1/6 (B6) anti-DBA/2 mixed leukocyte cultures (MLC) by the amino acid L-ornithine (Orn) could not be reversed by addition of up to 1000 U/ml IL-2. Analysis of the effects of Orn on induction of lymphokine-activated killer (LAK cells), using dosages of IL-2 from 10-1000 U/ml and measuring cytolytic activity against two tumor targets (P815 and YAC-1) over the course of 5 days, indicated that LAK cells were not suppressed by Orn. LAK precursors and effector cells were CD8- and ASGM1+, indicating that they were derived from natural killer (NK) cells. We also found that the growth and maintenance of cloned CTL lines were not sensitive to inhibition by Orn; nor was their acquisition of nonspecific cytolytic activity in the presence of high lymphokine concentrations. Thus, induction of naive CTL shows differential susceptibility to Orn inhibition relative to LAK and LAK-like activities by NK and cloned CTL lines in response to IL-2.     

Interleukin 3 is a major negative regulator of the generation of natural killer cells from bone marrow precursors

We have established a bone marrow culture system in which mature natural killer (NK) cells can be generated from inactive precursors by interleukin 2. Recombinant interleukin 3 (IL 3) almost completely blocked the induction of NK cells in this culture system as judged by cytotoxic activity, as well as appearance of cells with NK phenotype. The dose-response curve for inhibition of the generation of NK activity with IL 3 parallelled the growth promoting activity on the strictly IL 3-dependent cell line L/B. The effect of IL 3 was selective for the precursor stage of the NK cell, because mature NK cells were not affected by culture with IL 3 for the same period of time. Moreover, the effect of IL 3 was confined to the first 24 hr of culture, indicating an effect on an early stage of NK cell differentiation. IL 3 did not increase the small normally occurring NK-sensitive population in bone marrow, and did not affect the activity of a variant cytotoxic cell with specificity for adherent target cells, the natural cytotoxic cell. Concomitantly with downregulation of NK cell generation, IL 3 induced strong proliferation in the bone marrow cultures and an increase in the percentage of cells expressing the T cell marker Thy-1. A model for regulation of NK cells based on competition of growth factors for target cells with a common progenitor is discussed.     

Immunologic and clinical aspects of natural killer cells in human leukemia

We have studied peripheral-blood, splenic and bone marrow natural killer (NK) activity in patients with leukemia. These studies demonstrated that leukemic patients displayed defective NK activity in all of these tissues. However, NK defect could be corrected by culture of effector cells with interleukin-2 (IL-2). The phenotypic analysis of IL-2 cultures showed clearly the heterogeneity of lymphocyte subsets. The characterization studies demonstrated that CD56+, CD3- NK cells manifested most potent lysis of leukemia, CD56+, CD3+ T cells mediated some, but low, antileukemia activity and CD56-, CD3+ T lymphocytes were devoid of cytotoxicity.     

Modulation of perforin, granzyme A, and granzyme B in murine natural killer (NK), IL2 stimulated NK, and lymphokine-activated killer cells by alcohol consumption.

Alcohol consumption in mice suppresses the cytolytic activity of natural killer (NK) and lymphokine-activated killer (LAK) cells through unknown mechanisms. Herein, we found that alcohol consumption decreased target cell-induced release of granzyme A activity in freshly isolated splenic NK cells, in NK cells stimulated for 18 h with 1000 IU/ml of interleukin 2, and in LAK cells. The total activity and protein expression of granzymes A and B also were lower in these cells than in cells isolated from water-drinking mice. Interleukin 2 increased granzyme A protein expression independent of alcohol consumption; however, this increase was associated with decreased enzyme activity. In contrast, granzyme B protein expression and enzymatic activity increased in response to interleukin 2. Perforin activity and protein expression were reduced in LAK cells generated from alcohol-consuming mice. We conclude that the mechanism underlying the suppression of NK and LAK cytolytic activity by alcohol consumption involves the collective reduction of target-induced release, activity, and expression of perforin and granular proteases.