CD28, IL-2-independent costimulatory pathways for CD8 T lymphocyte activation.

We investigate, here, the mechanism of the costimulatory signals for CD8 T cell activation and confirm that costimulation signals via CD28 do not appear to be required to initiate proliferation, but provide survival signals for CD8 T cells activated by TCR ligation. We show also that IL-6 and TNF-alpha can provide alternative costimulatory survival signals. IL-6 and TNF-alpha costimulate naive CD8 T cells cultured on plate-bound anti-CD3 in the absence of CD28 ligation. They act directly on sorted CD8-positive T cells. They also costimulate naive CD8 T cells from Rag-2-deficient mice, bearing transgenic TCRs for HY, which lack memory cells, a potential source of IL-2 secretion upon activation. IL-6 and TNF-alpha provide costimulation to naive CD8 T cells from CD28, IL-2, or IL-2Ralpha-deficient mice, and thus function in the absence of the B7-CD28 and IL-2 costimulatory pathways. The CD8 T cell generated via the anti-CD3 plus IL-6 and TNF-alpha pathway have effector function in that they express strong cytolytic activity on Ag-specific targets. They secrete only very small amounts of any of the cytokines tested upon restimulation with peptide-loaded APC. The ability of the naive CD8 T cells to respond to TCR ligation and costimulatory signals from IL-6 and TNF-alpha provides a novel pathway that can substitute for signals from CD4 helper cells or professional APC. This may be significant in the response to viral Ags, which can be potentially expressed on the surface of any class I MHC-expressing cell.     

Differential regulatory effects of intercellular adhesion molecule-1 on costimulation by the CD28 counter-receptor B7.

Although ligation of the CD3/TCR complex initiates an activation signal in T cells, additional costimulatory signals generated during cell-to-cell interactions with APC transduced via ligation of CD11a/CD18 and CD28 by their specific counter-receptor intercellular adhesion molecule (ICAM)-1 and B7, respectively, are required for optimal T cell proliferation and cytokine synthesis. Using soluble IgC gamma 1 fusion proteins of these costimulatory counter-receptors, we have recently shown that unactivated resting CD4+ T cells and Ag-primed CD4+ T cells differ in their response to the costimulation by ICAM-1 and B7. Preferential proliferative responses of resting T and Ag-primed T cells to ICAM-1 and B7, respectively, prompted us to speculate that ICAM-1-induced signals may regulate coupling of the CD28 signaling pathway. Furthermore, both B7 and ICAM-1 are co-expressed on APC and thus, may co-regulate activation-driven maturation of T cells. In this study, we have examined regulatory effects of IgC gamma 1 fusion proteins of B7, ICAM-1, and ICAM-2 (a homologue of ICAM-1) on each other's costimulation. We first demonstrate that TCR-directed costimulation of resting CD4+ T cells with ICAM-1 (ICAM-1 priming) but not ICAM-2 induces increased responsiveness to B7. Priming of CD4+ T cells with ICAM-1 induced higher expression of both CD18 and CD28 than that with either B7 or ICAM-2. Cross-linking of CD28 induced faster and significantly higher cytoplasmic free calcium mobilization response in ICAM-1-primed CD4+ T cells than in resting, B7-primed, or ICAM-2-primed CD4+ T cells. B7 synergized with ICAM-1 but not ICAM-2 to augment proliferative responses of not only resting CD4+ T cells but also those that had been primed with either ICAM. Unlike resting or ICAM-2-primed CD4+ T cells, ICAM-1-primed CD4+ T cells efficiently proliferated in response to the synergistic costimulation of B7 and ICAM-2. In contrast, both ICAM-1 and ICAM-2 inhibit B7-driven proliferation of Ag-primed CD4+ T cells. Thus, B7 and ICAM-1 exert contrasting regulatory effects on the proliferation of CD4+ T cells depending on their state of activation-induced maturation.     

CD28 costimulation induces delta opioid receptor expression during anti-CD3 activation of T cells

Previous studies have demonstrated that naive splenic mouse T cells express no or only very low levels of the delta-type opioid receptor (delta OR), but stimulation of mouse splenocytes with Con A results in induction of delta OR mRNA and protein. In this report we have shown that stimulation of highly purified populations of naive mouse T cells with anti-CD3 mAb alone results in T cell activation, as evidenced by sustained IL-2 secretion and cell proliferation, but fails to elicit delta OR expression. However, delta OR expression is induced by costimulation of these very pure T cells with anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 mAbs. The delta OR induction by anti-CD3 and anti-CD28 costimulation was completely blocked by inhibition of phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase with wortmannin. Because phosphatidylinositol 3-kinase activation in T cells is linked to costimulation, these results suggest that induction of delta OR expression during T cell activation is strictly dependent on costimulation. It also appears that costimulatory receptors other than CD28 can provide the signaling required for delta OR expression because delta OR mRNA was induced by Con A stimulation of splenocytes from CD28-deficient mice.     

A diabetogenic gene prevents T cells from receiving costimulatory signals.

T cell fate following antigen encounter is determined by several intracellular signals generated by the interaction of the T cell with an antigen-presenting cell. In the periphery activation requires T cell receptor signaling (signal one) in combination with costimulatory signals (signal two), usually provided through the cognate interaction of CD28 and B7 molecules. Provision of signal one alone to purified murine peripheral T cells in vitro induces apoptosis or anergy rather than promoting activation. These T cells can be rescued from apoptosis if they are provided with costimulation supplied, for example, by engaging the CD28 co-receptor with an anti-CD28 monoclonal antibody or by adding an exogenous source of interleukin-2. However, a majority of peripheral T cells from autoimmune, diabetes-prone Biobreeding (BB) rats exhibited different responses to these stimuli. T cells from these rats could not be rescued from apoptosis by costimulation. This was not due to the inability of BB-DP T cells to upregulate CD28 and the IL-2 receptor in response to TCR crosslinking. The failure of these costimulatory interactions to rescue BB-DP T cells segregated with the diabetes-susceptibility gene iddm1. Iddm1 in the rat causes peripheral T cell lymphopenia, which is associated with a dramatically shortened peripheral T cell life span. Our results indicate that a diabetogenic gene may contribute to autoimmunity by negating costimulatory signals important for the survival of long-lived peripheral T cells.     

4-1BB is superior to CD28 costimulation for generating CD8+ cytotoxic lymphocytes for adoptive immunotherapy

Artificial APCs (aAPCs) genetically modified to express selective costimulatory molecules provide a reproducible, cost-effective, and convenient method for polyclonal and Ag-specific expansion of human T cells for adoptive immunotherapy. Among the variety of aAPCs that have been studied, acellular beads expressing anti-CD3/anti-CD28 efficiently expand CD4+ cells, but not CD8+ T cells. Cell-based aAPCs can effectively expand cytolytic CD8+ cells, but optimal costimulatory signals have not been defined. 4-1BB, a costimulatory molecule expressed by a minority of resting CD8+ T cells, is transiently up-regulated by all CD8+ T cells following activation. We compared expansion of human cytolytic CD8+ T cells using cell-based aAPCs providing costimulation via 4-1BB vs CD28. Whereas anti-CD3/anti-CD28 aAPCs mostly expand naive cells, anti-CD3/4-1BBL aAPCs preferentially expand memory cells, resulting in superior enrichment of Ag-reactive T cells which recognize previously primed Ags and efficient expansion of electronically sorted CD8+ populations reactive toward viral or self-Ags. Using HLA-A2-Fc fusion proteins linked to 4-1BBL aAPCs, 3-log expansion of Ag-specific CD8+ CTL was induced over 14 days, whereas similar Ag-specific CD8+ T cell expansion did not occur using HLA-A2-Fc/anti-CD28 aAPCs. Furthermore, when compared with cytolytic T cells expanded using CD28 costimulation, CTL expanded using 4-1BB costimulation mediate enhanced cytolytic capacity due, in part, to NKG2D up-regulation. These results demonstrate that 4-1BB costimulation is essential for expanding memory CD8+ T cells ex vivo and is superior to CD28 costimulation for generating Ag-specific products for adoptive cell therapy.     

Cutting edge: regulation of T cell activation threshold by CD28 costimulation through targeting Cbl-b for ubiquitination

Optimal T cell activation requires signaling through the TCR and CD28 costimulatory receptor. CD28 costimulation is believed to set the threshold for T cell activation. Recently, Cbl-b, a ubiquitin ligase, has been shown to negatively regulate CD28-dependent T cell activation. In this report, we show that CD28 costimulation selectively induces greater ubiquitination and degradation of Cbl-b in wild-type T cells than CD3 stimulation alone, and TCR-induced Cbl-b ubiquitination and degradation are significantly reduced in CD28-deficient T cells. Stimulation of CD28-deficient T cells with higher doses of anti-CD3 results in increased ubiquitination of Cbl-b, which correlates with enhanced T cell responses. Our results demonstrate that CD28 costimulation regulates the threshold for T cell activation, at least in part, by promoting Cbl-b ubiquitination and degradation.     

Resting B lymphocytes as APC for naive T lymphocytes: dependence on CD40 ligand/CD40

Although resting B cells as APC are tolerogenic for naive T cells in vivo, we show here that they can provide all the costimulatory signals necessary for naive T cell proliferation in vivo and in vitro. In the absence of an activating signal through the B cell Ag receptor, T cell proliferation after Ag recognition on resting B cells depends on CD40 expression on the B cells, implying that naive T cells use the membrane-bound cytokine, CD40 ligand (CD154), to induce the costimulatory signals that they need. Induction of B7-1 (CD80) and increased or sustained expression of CD44H, ICAM-1 (CD54), and B7-2 (CD86) are dependent on the interaction of CD40 ligand with CD40. Transient expression (12 h) of B7-2 is T cell- and peptide Ag-dependent, but CD40-independent. Only sustained (>/=24 h) expression of B7-2 and perhaps increased expression of ICAM-1 could be shown to be functionally important in this system. T cells cultured with CD40-deficient B cells and peptide remain about as responsive as fresh naive cells upon secondary culture with whole splenic APC. Therefore, B cells, and perhaps other APC, may be tolerogenic not because they fail to provide sufficient costimulation for T cell proliferation, but because they are deficient in some later functions necessary for a productive T cell response.     

Choice of resident costimulatory molecule can influence cell fate in human naïve CD4+ T cell differentiation

With antigen stimulation, naïve CD4+ T cells differentiate to several effector or memory cell populations, and cytokines contribute to differentiation outcome. Several proteins on these cells receive costimulatory signals, but a systematic comparison of their differential effects on naïve T cell differentiation has not been conducted. Two costimulatory proteins, CD28 and ICAM-1, resident on human naïve CD4+ T cells were compared for participation in differentiation. Under controlled conditions, and with no added cytokines, costimulation through either CD3+CD28 or CD3+CAM-1 induced differentiation to T effector and T memory cells. In contrast, costimulation through CD3+ICAM-1 induced differentiation to Treg cells whereas costimulation through CD3+CD28 did not.     

CD28 costimulation is crucial for the development of spontaneous autoimmune encephalomyelitis

Multiple sclerosis (MS) is a severe central nervous system disease. Experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE) mimics MS in mice. We report that spontaneous development of EAE in RAG-1-deficient mice transgenic for a myelin basic protein (MBP)-specific TCR (TgMBP+/RAG-1-/-) requires expression of the T cell costimulatory molecule CD28. Surprisingly, T cells from CD28-/-TgMBP+/RAG-1-/- mice proliferate and produce IL-2 in response to MBP1-17 peptide in vitro, excluding clonal anergy as the mechanism of CD28-regulated pathogenesis. Proliferation of autoaggressive T cells was dependent on the concentration of the MBP peptide, as was the development of MBP-induced EAE in CD28-deficient PL/J mice. These results provide the first genetic evidence that CD28 costimulation is crucial for MBP-specific T cell activation in vivo and the initiation of spontaneous EAE.     

Blockade of costimulation through B7/CD28 inhibits experimental autoimmune uveoretinitis, but does not induce long-term tolerance

It has been reported that costimulation blockade can result in T cell anergy. We investigated the effects of blocking costimulatory molecules in vivo on the development of experimental autoimmune uveoretinitis (EAU), a model for autoimmune uveitis in humans that is induced in mice by immunization with the retinal Ag interphotoreceptor retinoid binding protein. B10.A mice immunized with a uveitogenic regimen of interphotoreceptor retinoid-binding protein were treated with Abs to B7.1 and B7.2 for 2 wk. Evaluation of EAU and immunological responses 1 wk later showed that disease had been abrogated, and cellular responses were suppressed. To determine whether the costimulation blockade resulted in tolerance, adult-thymectomized mice immunized for uveitis and treated with anti-B7 or anti-CD28 were rechallenged for uveitis induction 5 wk after the initial immunization. Although confirmed to be disease free after the initial immunization, both anti-B7- and anti-CD28-treated mice developed severe EAU and elevated cellular responses after the rechallenge, equivalent to those of control mice. We conclude that in this model costimulatory blockade in vivo prevents the development of autoimmune disease, but does not result in long-term tolerance. The data are compatible with the interpretation that B7/CD28 blockade prevents generation of effector, but not of memory, T cells.     

Signals from CD28 induce stable epigenetic modification of the IL-2 promoter

CD28 costimulation controls multiple aspects of T cell function, including the expression of proinflammatory cytokine genes. One of these genes encodes IL-2, a growth factor that influences T cell proliferation, survival, and differentiation. Antigenic signaling in the absence of CD28 costimulation leads to anergy, a mechanism of tolerance that renders CD4+ T cells unable to produce IL-2. The molecular mechanisms by which CD28 costimulatory signals induce gene expression are not fully understood. In eukaryotic cells, the expression of many genes is influenced by their physical structure at the level of DNA methylation and local chromatin remodeling. To address whether these epigenetic mechanisms are operative during CD28-dependent gene expression in CD4+ T cells, we compared cytosine methylation and chromatin structure at the IL-2 locus in fully activated CD4+ effector T cells and CD4+ T cells rendered anergic by TCR ligation in the absence of CD28 costimulation. Costimulation through CD28 led to marked, stable histone acetylation and loss of cytosine methylation at the IL-2 promoter/enhancer. This was accompanied by extensive remodeling of the chromatin in this region to a structure highly accessible to DNA binding proteins. Conversely, TCR activation in the absence of CD28 costimulation was not sufficient to promote histone acetylation or cytosine demethylation, and the IL-2 promoter/enhancer in anergic cells remained completely inaccessible. These data suggest that CD28 may function through epigenetic mechanisms to promote CD4+ T cell responses.     

Incomplete activation of CD4 T cells by antigen-presenting transitional immature B cells: implications for peripheral B and T cell responsiveness

B cells leave the bone marrow as transitional B cells. Transitional B cells represent a target of negative selection and peripheral tolerance, both of which are abrogated in vitro by mediators of T cell help. In vitro, transitional and mature B cells differ in their responses to B cell receptor ligation. Whereas mature B cells up-regulate the T cell costimulatory molecule CD86 (B7.2) and are activated, transitional B cells do not and undergo apoptosis. The ability of transitional B cells to process and present Ag to CD4 T cells and to elicit protective signals in the absence of CD86 up-regulation was investigated. We report that transitional B cells can process and present Ag as peptide:MHC class II complexes. However, their ability to activate T cells and elicit help signals from CD4-expressing Th cells was compromised compared with mature B cells, unless exogenous T cell costimulation was provided. A stringent requirement for CD28 costimulation was not evident in interactions between transitional B cells and preactivated CD4-expressing T cells, indicating that T cells involved in vivo in an ongoing immune response might rescue Ag-specific transitional B cells from negative selection. These data suggest that during an immune response, immature B cells may be able to sustain the responses of preactivated CD4(+) T cells, while being unable to initiate activation of naive T cells. Furthermore, the ability of preactivated, but not naive T cells to provide survival signals to B cell receptor-engaged transitional immature B cells argues that these B cells may be directed toward activation rather than negative selection when encountering Ag in the context of a pre-existing immune response.     

A novel bispecific tetravalent antibody fusion protein to target costimulatory activity for T-cell activation to tumor cells overexpressing ErbB2/HER2

Persistent activation of T-lymphocytes requires two signals: one is initiated by T-cell receptor binding to antigenic peptide presented by MHC molecules. In addition, binding of the B7 family members CD80 or CD86 on professional antigen presenting cells to CD28 on T cells is considered to provide an important costimulatory signal. Activation without costimulation induces T-cell unresponsiveness or anergy. To selectively localize costimulatory activity to the surface of tumor cells and enhance activation of tumor-specific T cells, we have developed a novel molecular design for bispecific costimulatory proteins with antibody-like structure. Within a single polypeptide chain we have assembled the IgV-like, CD28-binding domain of human CD86 (CD86(111)) together with hinge, CH2 and CH3 domains of human IgG1, and the scFv(FRP5) antibody fragment which recognizes the ErbB2 (HER2) protooncogene present at high levels on the surface of many human tumor cells. Upon expression in the yeast Pichia pastoris, the resulting CD86(111)-IgG-scFv(FRP5) protein could be purified as a homodimeric, tetravalent molecule from culture supernatants using single-step affinity chromatography. Bispecific binding of the molecule to ErbB2 on the surface of tumor cells and to the B7 counter receptor CTLA-4 was demonstrated by FACS analysis. Potent costimulatory activity of chimeric CD86(111)-IgG-scFv(FRP5) was confirmed by its ability to stimulate the proliferation of primary human lymphocytes pre-activated by low concentrations of anti-CD3 antibody. Our results suggest that such multivalent soluble proteins which combine specific targeting to tumor cells with costimulatory activity may become useful tools to elicit and/or improve T-cell mediated, tumor-specific immune responses.     

A critical role for B7/CD28 costimulation in experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis: a comparative study using costimulatory molecule-deficient mice and monoclonal antibody blockade

The B7/CD28 pathway provides critical costimulatory signals required for complete T cell activation and has served as a potential target for immunotherapeutic strategies designed to regulate autoimmune diseases. This study was designed to examine the roles of CD28 and its individual ligands, B7-1 and B7-2, in experimental autoimmune encephalomyelitis (EAE), a Th1-mediated inflammatory disease of the CNS. EAE induction in CD28- or B7-deficient nonobese diabetic (NOD) mice was compared with the effects of B7/CD28 blockade using Abs in wild-type NOD mice. Disease severity was significantly reduced in CD28-deficient as well as anti-B7-1/B7-2-treated NOD mice. B7-2 appeared to play the more dominant role as there was a moderate decrease in disease incidence and severity in B7-2-deficient animals. EAE resistance was not due to the lack of effective priming of the myelin peptide-specific T cells in vivo. T cells isolated from CD28-deficient animals produced equivalent amounts of IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha in response to the immunogen, proteolipid protein 56-70. In fact, IFN-gamma and TNF-alpha production by Ag-specific T cells was enhanced in both the B7-1 and B7-2-deficient NOD mice. In contrast, peptide-specific delayed-type hypersensitivity responses in these animals were significantly decreased, suggesting a critical role for CD28 costimulation in in vivo trafficking and systemic immunity. Collectively, these results support a critical role for CD28 costimulation in EAE induction.     

Costimulation requirements of induced murine systemic autoimmune disease

Costimulation between T cells and APC is required for productive immune responses. A number of receptor/ligand pairs have been shown to mediate costimulation, including CD28/B7 molecules (CD80 and CD86), CD40/CD40 ligand (CD40L, CD154), and LFA-1 (CD18)/ICAM-1 (CD54). T-B cell costimulation also plays a significant role in autoimmune diseases such as systemic lupus erythematosus. Murine HgCl2-induced autoimmunity (mHgIA) is a T cell-dependent systemic autoimmune disease that shares a number of common pathogenic mechanisms with idiopathic lupus. In this report, the significance of costimulation in mHgIA is examined by attempting to induce disease in mice deficient in either CD40L, CD28, or ICAM-1. Unlike absence of ICAM-1, homozygous deficiencies in either CD40L or CD28 significantly reduced the development of mHgIA. CD40L displayed a gene dosage effect as heterozygous mice also showed reduction of autoantibody responses and immunopathology. Markers of T cell activation such as CD44 and CTLA-4 were associated with disease expression in wild-type and ICAM-1-deficient mice but not in CD40L- or CD28-deficient mice. Absence of CTLA-4 expression in CD40L-/- mice suggests that signaling via both CD28 and CD40L is important for T cell activation and subsequent autoimmunity in mHgIA. Attempts to circumvent the absence of CD40L by increasing CD28 signaling via agonistic Ab failed to elicit CTLA-4 expression. These findings indicate that breaking of self-tolerance in mHgIA requires signaling via both the CD28/B7 and CD40/CD40L pathways.     

Clonal anergy is maintained independently of T cell proliferation

Ag encounter in the absence of proliferation results in the establishment of T cell unresponsiveness, also known as T cell clonal anergy. Anergic T cells fail to proliferate upon restimulation because of the inability to produce IL-2 and to properly regulate the G(1) cell cycle checkpoint. Because optimal TCR and CD28 engagement can elicit IL-2-independent cell cycle progression, we investigated whether CD3/CD28-mediated activation of anergic T cells could overcome G(1) cell cycle block, drive T cell proliferation, and thus reverse clonal anergy. We show here that although antigenic stimulation fails to elicit G(1)-to-S transition, anti-CD3/CD28 mAbs allow proper cell cycle progression and proliferation of anergic T cells. However, CD3/CD28-mediated cell division does not restore Ag responsiveness. Our data instead indicate that reversal of clonal anergy specifically requires an IL-2-dependent, rapamycin-sensitive signal, which is delivered independently of cell proliferation. Thus, by tracing proliferation and Ag responsiveness of individual cells, we show that whereas both TCR/CD28 and IL-2-generated signals can drive T cell proliferation, only IL-2/IL-2R interaction regulates Ag responsiveness, indicating that proliferation and clonal anergy can be independently regulated.     

CD28-specific antibody prevents graft-versus-host disease in mice

The costimulatory molecules B7-1 and B7-2 regulate T cell activation by delivering activation signals through CD28 and inhibitory signals through CTLA4. Graft-vs-host disease (GVHD) is caused by activated donor T cells. Previously, we showed that CD28-deficient donor T cells induced less-severe GVHD than wild-type donor T cells, suggesting that CD28 signals exacerbate GVHD. In this paper we demonstrate that CTLA4 signals attenuate the severity of GVHD. Targeting the CD28 receptor with a specific mAb modulates the receptor in vivo, inhibits donor T cell expansion, and prevents GVHD. CTLA4 signaling was necessary for this effect because treatment with a soluble ligand that blocks binding of B7 to both CD28 and CTLA4 did not prevent GVHD as effectively as anti-CD28 mAb. These results support the current model of T cell costimulation in which CD28 signals amplify GVHD while CTLA4 signals inhibit GVHD, providing evidence that selective targeting of CD28 might be a better therapeutic strategy for inducing immunological tolerance than blocking the ligands for both CD28 and CTLA4.     

OX40-mediated differentiation to effector function requires IL-2 receptor signaling but not CD28, CD40, IL-12Rbeta2, or T-bet

Ag-specific CD4 T cells transferred into unirradiated Ag-bearing recipients proliferate, but survival and accumulation of proliferating cells is not extensive and the donor cells do not acquire effector functions. We previously showed that a single costimulatory signal delivered by an agonist Ab to OX40 (CD134) promotes accumulation of proliferating cells and promotes differentiation to effector CD4 T cells capable of secreting IFN-gamma. In this study, we determined whether OX40 costimulation requires supporting costimulatory or differentiation signals to drive acquisition of effector T cell function. We report that OX40 engagement drives effector T cell differentiation in the absence of CD28 and CD40 signals. Two important regulators of Th1 differentiation, IL-12R and T-bet, also are not required for acquisition of effector function in CD4 T cells responsive to OX40 stimulation. Finally, we show that CD25-deficient CD4 T cells produce little IFN-gamma in the presence of OX40 costimulation compared with wild type, suggesting that IL-2R signaling is required for efficient OX40-mediated differentiation to IFN-gamma secretion.