Mutational analysis of S12 protein and implications for the accuracy of decoding by the ribosome

The fidelity of aminoacyl-tRNA selection by the ribosome depends on a conformational switch in the decoding center of the small ribosomal subunit induced by cognate but not by near-cognate aminoacyl-tRNA. The aminoglycosides paromomycin and streptomycin bind to the decoding center and induce related structural rearrangements that explain their observed effects on miscoding. Structural and biochemical studies have identified ribosomal protein S12 (as well as specific nucleotides in 16S ribosomal RNA) as a critical molecular contributor in distinguishing between cognate and near-cognate tRNA species as well as in promoting more global rearrangements in the small subunit, referred to as “closure.” Here we use a mutational approach to define contributions made by two highly conserved loops in S12 to the process of tRNA selection. Most S12 variant ribosomes tested display increased levels of fidelity (a “restrictive” phenotype). Interestingly, several variants, K42A and R53A, were substantially resistant to the miscoding effects of paromomycin. Further characterization of the compromised paromomycin response identified a probable second, fidelity-modulating binding site for paromomycin in the 16S ribosomal RNA that facilitates closure of the small subunit and compensates for defects associated with the S12 mutations.     

The ubiquitin ligase Rsp5 is required for ribosome stability in Saccharomyces cerevisiae

Rsp5p is a conserved HECT-domain ubiquitin ligase with diverse roles in cellular physiology. Here we report a previously unknown role of Rsp5p in facilitating the stability of the cytoplasmic ribosome pool in budding yeast. Yeast strains carrying temperature-sensitive mutations in RSP5 showed a progressive decline in levels of 18S and 25S rRNAs and accumulation of rRNA decay fragments when cells grown in rich medium were shifted to restrictive temperature. This was accompanied by a decreased number of translating ribosomes and the appearance of ribosomal subunits with an abnormally low sedimentation rate in polysome analysis. Abrogating Rsp5p function affected stability of other tested noncoding RNA species (tRNA and snoRNA), but to a lower extent than that of rRNA, and also inhibited processing of rRNA and tRNA precursors, in agreement with previous studies. The breakdown of cellular ribosomes was not affected by deletion of key genes involved in autophagy, previously implicated in ribosome turnover upon starvation. Our results suggest that functional Rsp5p is required to maintain the integrity of cytoplasmic ribosomes under rich nutrient conditions.     

Topography of 5.8 S rRNA in rat liver ribosomes. Identification of diethyl pyrocarbonate-reactive sites

The topography of 5.8 rRNA in rat liver ribosomes has been examined by comparing diethyl pyrocarbonate-reactive sites in free 5.8 S RNA, the 5.8 S-28 rRNA complex, 60 S subunits, and whole ribosomes. The ribosomal components were treated with diethyl pyrocarbonate under salt and temperature conditions which allow cell-free protein synthesis; the 5.8 S rRNA was extracted, labeled in vitro, chemically cleaved with aniline, and the fragments were analyzed by rapid gel-sequencing techniques. Differences in the cleavage patterns of free and 28 S or ribosome-associated 5.8 S rRNA suggest that conformational changes occur when this molecule is assembled into ribosomes. In whole ribosomes, the reactive sites were largely restricted to the "AU-rich" stem and an increased reactivity at some of the nucleotides suggested that a major change occurs in this region when the RNA interacts with ribosomal proteins. The reactivity was generally much less restricted in 60 S subunits but increased reactivity in some residues was also observed. The results further indicate that in rat ribosomes, the two -G-A-A-C- sequences, putative binding sites for tRNA, are accessible in 60 S subunits but not in whole ribosomes and suggest that part of the molecule may be located in the ribosomal interface. When compared to 5 S rRNA, the free 5.8 S RNA molecule appears to be generally more reactive with diethyl pyrocarbonate and the cleavage patterns suggest that the 5 S RNA molecule is completely restricted or buried in whole ribosomes.     

Defining the structural requirements for a helix in 23 S ribosomal RNA that confers erythromycin resistance

The helix spanning nucleotides 1198 to 1247 (helix 1200-1250) in Escherichia coli 23 S ribosomal RNA (rRNA) is functionally important in protein synthesis, and deletions in this region confer erythromycin resistance. In order to define the structural requirements for resistance, we have dissected this region using in vitro mutagenesis. Erythromycin resistance is established after a minimal deletion of three bases, CAU1231 or AUG1232. The maximum deletion observed to confer resistance is 25 bases. The level of erythromycin resistance conferred by intermediate sized deletions is variable and some deletion mutants show a sensitive phenotype. Deletions that extend into the base-pairing between GCC1208 and GGU1240 result in non-functional 23 S RNAs, which consequently do not confer resistance. A number of phylogenetically conserved nucleotides have been shown to be non-essential for 23 S RNA function. However, removal of either these or non-conserved nucleotides from helix 1200-1250 measurably reduces the efficiency of 23 S RNA in forming functional ribosomes. We have used chemical probing and a modified primer extension method to investigate erythromycin binding to wild-type and resistant ribosomes with a 12-base deletion in 23 S RNA. Erythromycin interacts as strongly with mutant 23 S RNA as with wild-type 23 S RNA. Deletions in the 1200-1250 helix do not therefore confer resistance by reducing erythromycin binding, but by suppressing the effects of the drug at the level of its mechanism of action.     

On the accessibility and selection of the initiator site of mRNA in protein synthesis.

The specificity of the cell-free system of Escherichia coli for mRNA was examined, and the "accessibility" of some natural and synthetic RNAs to the ribosomes was determined by measurement of AcPhe-tRNA and fMet-tRNA binding, AcPhe-puromycin and fMet-puromycin formation, and polypeptide synthesis. The E. coli system effectively initiates the translation of various synthetic RNAs with AcPhe-tRNA or fMet-tRNA under conditions optimal for the translation of viral RNA. Poly(A,G,U) is accessible to the ribosomes according to all of the above criteria. Poly(A,C,G,U), 23 S rRNA, R17 RNA, and MS2 RNA, on the other hand, show limited accessibility when tested for initiator tRNA binding, or for AcPhe-puromycin and fMet-puromycin formation. MS2 and R17 RNA, but not poly(A,C,G,U) and 23 S rRNA, show accessibility when measured by polypeptide synthesis. The results suggest that, except at initiator sites of natural mRNA, an RNA containing about equal amounts of all four bases is inaccessible to E. coli ribosomes for polypeptide synthesis. Rate constants obtained for fMet-tRNA binding with MS2 RNA, poly(A,G,U), and poly(C,G,U) indicate that the ribosomes do not have any special affinity for the viral RNA. Thus, the selection of the initiator site in protein synthesis may be critically determined more by the accessibility of the initiator codon than by ribosomal recognition of the site.     

Magic Spot Metabolism in an Escherichia coli Mutant Temperature Sensitive in Elongation Factor Ts

A temperature-sensitive mutant of Escherichia coli HAK88 which has been shown to have a lesion in elongation factor Ts (EFTs) was studied with repsect to its metabolism of guanosine 5′-diphosphate, 2′(3′)-diphosphate (ppGpp) and the associated failure of ribosomal ribonucleic acid (rRNA) accumulation at the nonpermissive temperature. Results reported here show that (i) when EFTs is nonfunctional, a full complement of charged transfer RNA (tRNA) cannot prevent accumulation of ppGpp (magic spot) and the stringent failure of rRNA accumulation; (ii) chloramphenicol prevents magic spot (MS) formation and the stringent response not by increasing the percentage of charged tRNA, but possibly by somehow interfering directly with the synthesis of MS; and (iii) tetracycline can lead to MS disappearance without resumption of RNA synthesis. Thus, the absence of MS and the presence of a functional RNA polymerase and charged tRNA are not sufficient to support rRNA accumulation in vivo. An additional element in the regulatory system is suggested.     

A human autoantibody specific for a unique conserved region of 28 S ribosomal RNA inhibits the interaction of elongation factors 1 alpha and 2 with ribosomes

An autoantibody reactive with a conserved sequence of 28 S rRNA (anti-28 S) was identified in serum from a patient with systemic lupus erythematosus. Anti-28 S protected a unique 59-nucleotide fragment synthesized in vitro against RNase T1 digestion. RNA sequence analysis revealed that it corresponded to residues 1944-2002 in human 28 S rRNA and 1767-1825 in mouse 28 S rRNA. These sequences are identical and highly conserved throughout all known eukaryotic 28 S rRNAs. In addition, this fragment is homologous to residues 1052-1110 of Escherichia coli 23 S rRNA that lies within the GTP hydrolysis center of the 50 S ribosomal subunit. Anti-28 S and its Fab fragments strongly inhibited poly(U)-directed polyphenylalanine synthesis, but had no effect on ribosomal peptidyltransferase activity. This effect resulted from inhibition of the binding of elongation factors EF-1 alpha and EF-2 to ribosomes and of the associated GTP hydrolysis. The inhibitory effect was almost completely suppressed by preincubation of anti-28 S with 28 S rRNA or in vitro synthesized RNA fragments containing the immunoreactive region. These results show that the immunoreactive conserved region of 28 S rRNA participates in the interaction of ribosomes with the two elongation factors in protein synthesis.     

Unbalanced rRNA gene dosage and its effects on rRNA and ribosomal-protein synthesis.

The synthesis of rRNA was unbalanced by the introduction of plasmids containing rRNA operons with large internal deletions. Significant unbalanced synthesis was achieved only when the deletions affected both 16S and 23S RNA genes or when the deletions affected the 23S RNA gene alone. Although large imbalances in rRNA synthesis resulted from deletions affecting 16S and 23S RNA genes or only 23S RNA genes, excess 16S RNA and defective rRNA species were rapidly degraded. Large imbalances in the synthesis of regions of rRNA did not result in significantly unbalanced synthesis of ribosomal proteins. It therefore is probable that excess intact 16S RNA is degraded because ribosomal proteins are not available for packaging the RNA into ribosomes. Defective RNA species also may be degraded for this reason or because proper ribosome assembly is prevented by the defects in RNA structure. We propose two possible explanations for the finding that unbalanced overproduction of binding sites for feedback ribosomal protein does not result in significant unbalanced translational feedback depression of ribosomal protein mRNAs.     

Guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate levels, carbon source, and ribonucleic acid synthesis in a mutant strain of Escherichia coli

We have previously described a mutant strain of Escherichia coli (2S142) which shows a specific inhibition of stable RNA synthesis at 42 degrees C. The temperature-sensitive lesion mimics a carbon source downshift (diauxie lag). We therefore measured RNA synthesis and levels of ppGpp (guanosine 5'-diphosphate 3'-diphosphate) on a number of different carbon sources. There is a 6-fold variation in ppGpp levels at 42 degrees C, depending on the carbon source present. Much of the variation in ppGpp levels at 42 degrees C can be explained by variations in the decay rate of ppGpp at 42 degrees C. The rates of ribosomal RNA and total RNA synthesis also vary with the carbon source at 42 degrees C. Linear regression analysis shows only a moderately good correlation (correlation coefficient = 0.62, P = 0.0001) between the ppGpp level at 42 degrees C and the rate of rRNA synthesis at 42 degrees C. In fact, ppGpp levels are a slightly better predictor of the rate of total RNA synthesis (correlation coefficient = 0.69, P = 0.0001) at 42 degrees C. Other variables such as rate of carbon source uptake appear to have very little, if any, relationship to the rate of rRNA synthesis on the different carbon sources. Segmented linear regression analysis indicates that ppGpp levels and rates of RNA synthesis correlate best when the carbon sources are divided into two groups: 6- and 12-carbon sugars and other carbon sources. The rate of rRNA synthesis in 2S142 at 42 degrees C appears to be relatively insensitive to ppGpp levels with 6- and 12-carbon sugars as the carbon source. These data raise the possibility that carbon source may affect rRNA synthesis in a manner that is at least partially unrelated to ppGpp levels.     

The mechanism of action of ppGpp on rRNA synthesis in vitro.

We have studied the mechanism of the specific inhibition of ribosomal RNA synthesis by ppGpp in a purified system using as templates E. coli DNA and DNA from lambdad5ilv, which carries a rRNA cistron from E. coli. Ribosomal RNA synthesis, as well as its inhibition by ppGpp, are critically salt-dependent. Of a number of guanosine phosphates tested, only pppGpp (MS II) mimicked the action of ppGpp, establishing the specificity of ppGpp. The two templates gave similar results for rRNA synthesis in all experiments. By using the initiation inhibitor rifampicin, we could show that the specific inhibition of rRNA synthesis by ppGpp is due to its effect on rRNA initiation. The somewhat variable inhibition of RNA synthesis in general by ppGpp is mainly or wholly a consequence of premature chain termination. We propose that ppGpp specifically inhibits rRNA synthesis by acting on the formation of the so-called "closed-promoter complex".     

G1401: a keystone nucleotide at the decoding site of Escherichia coli 30S ribosomes.

16S ribosomal RNA contains three highly conserved single-stranded regions. Centrally located in one of these regions is the C1400 residue. Zero-length cross-linking of this residue to the anticodon of ribosome-bound tRNA showed that it was at or near the ribosomal decoding site [Ehresmann, C., Ehresmann, B., Millon, R., Ebel, J-P., Nurse, K., & Ofengand, J. (1984) Biochemistry 23, 429-437]. To assess the functional significance of sequence conservation of rRNA in the vicinity of this functionally important site, a series of site-directed mutations in this region were constructed and the effects of these mutations on the partial reactions of protein synthesis determined. Mutation of C1400 or C1402 to any other base only moderately affected a set of in vitro protein synthesis partial reactions. However, any base change from the normal G1401 residue blocked all of the tested ribosomal functions. This was also true for the deletion of G1401. Deletion of C1400 or C1402 had more complex effects. Whereas subunit association was hardly affected, 30S initiation complex formation was blocked by deletion of C1400 but much less so by deletion of C1402. Alternatively, tRNA binding to the ribosomal A site was more strongly affected by deletion of C1402 than by deletion of C1400. P site binding was inhibited by either deletion. HPLC analysis of the in vitro reconstituted mutant ribosomes showed that none of the functional effects were due to the absence or gross reduction in amount of any ribosomal protein.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)     

Base-pairing between 23S rRNA and tRNA in the ribosomal A site

The aminoacyl (A site) tRNA analog 4-thio-dT-p-C-p-puromycin (s4TCPm) photochemically cross-links with high efficiency and specificity to G2553 of 23S rRNA and is peptidyl transferase reactive in its cross-linked state, establishing proximity between the highly conserved 2555 loop in domain V of 23S rRNA and the universally conserved CCA end of tRNA. To test for base-pairing interactions between 23S rRNA and aminoacyl tRNA, site-directed mutations were made at the universally conserved nucleotides U2552 and G2553 of 23S rRNA in both E. coli and B. stearothermophilus ribosomal RNA and incorporated into ribosomes. Mutations at G2553 resulted in dominant growth defects in E. coli and in decreased levels of peptidyl transferase activity in vitro. Genetic analysis in vitro of U2552 and G2553 mutant ribosomes and CCA end mutant tRNA substrates identified a base-pairing interaction between C75 of aminoacyl tRNA and G2553 of 23S rRNA.     

Dissection of the mechanism for the stringent factor RelA

During conditions of nutrient deprivation, ribosomes are blocked by uncharged tRNA at the A site. The stringent factor RelA binds to blocked ribosomes and catalyzes synthesis of (p)ppGpp, a secondary messenger that induces the stringent response. We demonstrate that binding of RelA and (p)ppGpp synthesis are inversely coupled, i.e., (p)ppGpp synthesis decreases the affinity of RelA for the ribosome. RelA binding to ribosomes is governed primarily by mRNA, but independently of ribosomal protein L11, while (p)ppGpp synthesis strictly requires uncharged tRNA at the A site and the presence of L11. A model is proposed whereby RelA hops between blocked ribosomes, providing an explanation for how low intracellular concentrations of RelA (1/200 ribosomes) can synthesize (p)ppGpp at levels that accurately reflect the starved ribosome population.     

Mapping the ribosomal RNA neighborhood of protein L11 by directed hydroxyl radical probing.

Ribosomal protein L11 is a highly conserved protein that has been implicated in binding of elongation factors to ribosomes and associated GTP hydrolysis. Here, we have analyzed the ribosomal RNA neighborhood of Escherichia coli L11 in 50 S subunits by directed hydroxyl radical probing from Fe(II) tethered to five engineered cysteine residues at positions 19, 84, 85, 92 and 116 via the linker 1-(p -bromoacetamidobenzyl)-EDTA. Correct assembly of the L11 derivatives was analyzed by incorporating the modified proteins into 50 S subunits isolated from an E. coli strain that lacks L11 and testing for previously characterized L11-dependent footprints in domain II of 23 S rRNA. Hydroxyl radicals were generated from Fe(II) tethered to L11 and sites of cleavage in the ribosomal RNA were detected by primer extension. Strong cleavages were detected within the previously described binding site of L11, in the 1100 region of 23 S rRNA. Moreover, Fe(II) tethered to position 19 in L11 targeted the backbone of the sarcin loop in domain VI while probing from position 92 cleaved the backbone around bases 900 and 2470 in domains II and V, respectively. Fe(II) tethered to positions 84, 85 and 92 also generated cleavages in 5 S rRNA around helix II. These data provide new information about the positions of specific features of 23 S rRNA and 5 S rRNA relative to protein L11 in the 50 S subunit and show that L11 is near highly conserved elements of the rRNA that have been implicated in binding of tRNA and elongation factors to the ribosome.     

Control of rRNA synthesis in Escherichia coli at increased rrn gene dosage. Role of guanosine tetraphosphate and ribosome feedback.

The effects of extra, plasmid-borne rRNA genes on the synthesis rate of rRNA in Escherichia coli were examined by measuring the fraction of total RNA synthesis that is rRNA and tRNA (rs/rt), the cytoplasmic concentration of guanosine tetraphosphate (ppGpp), and the absolute rates of RNA and protein synthesis. Experiments were carried out in different growth media and with two different strains of E. coli, B/r and K-12. The results indicated: 1) increased rrn gene dosage from either intact or defective rrn genes reduced bacterial growth rates and ribosome activity (protein synthesis rate/average ribosome), and increased rs/rt. 2) Extra intact, but not extra defective, plasmid-borne rrn genes caused the level of ppGpp to be increased in comparison to the pBR322-carrying control strain. 3) As a function of ppGpp, rs/rt was increased with either intact or defective rrn genes. 4) The rRNA synthesis rate/rrn gene was reduced in the presence of extra rrn genes; this reduction in gene activity was greater with intact than with defective rrn genes. An analysis of these results showed that they are consistent with the ppGpp hypothesis of rRNA control but not with a feedback effector role of translating ribosomes.     

Selective inhibition of tRNATyr transcription by guanosine 3'-diphosphate 5'-diphosphate.

Guanosine 3'-diphosphate 5'-diphosphate (ppGpp) selectively reduces the synthesis of su+III tRNA from omega 80 psu+III DNA relative to the synthesis of omega 80 RNA in a system in vitro containing DNA and Escherichia coli RNA polymerase holoenzyme as the sole macromolecular components. The response of su+III tRNA synthesis to increasing salt and to temperature in the presence of ppGpp suggests that the nucleotide may reduce the affinity of the enzyme for su+III promoters. The Ki for the selective inhibition of tRNA synthesis by ppGpp is 4 muM in contrast to the value of 150 muM for the inhibition of rRNA synthesis.     

Interaction of unfolded tRNA with the 3''-terminal region of E. coli 16S ribosomal RNA.

Fragments of tRNA possessing a free TpsiC-loop or a free D-loop form stable complexes with the colicin fragment (1494-1542) of 16S ribosomal RNA from E. coli. The colicin fragment does not bind to tRNA in which the T-loop and the D-loop are involved in tertiary interactions. Colicin cleavage of the 16S rRNA from E. coli is inhibited by aminoacyl-tRNA or tRNA fragments, indicating that a similar interaction may take place on the intact 70S ribosomes. The oligonucleotide d(G-T-T-C-G-A)homologous to the conserved sequence G-T-psi-C-Pu-(m1)A in the TpsiC-region of many elongator tRNAs binds to the conserved sequence U-C-G-mU-A-A-C (1495-1501) of the 16S rRNA. It is suggested that the 3'-end of the 16S rRNA may provide the part of the binding site for the elongator tRNAs on bacterial ribosomes.     

Activation of transcription by guanosine 5'-diphosphate,3'-diphosphate, transfer ribonucleic acid, and novel protein from Escherichia coli.

A protein factor TFms) that is required for ppGpp to stimulate RNA synthesis has been purified from an eluate of crude ribosomes. TFms also has the capacity to stimulate RNA synthesis without ppGpp present. Under standard conditions the action TFms and ppGpp requires uncharged tRNA. TFms and ppGpp act at inhibition to promote the formation of rifampicin-resistant or polytrI)-resistant preinitiation complexes. In the presence of rifampicin or poly(rI), tRNA is no longer required. With lambdah80dlacPs DNA as template, ppGpp together with TFms stimulated gal RNA synthesis to a much greater extent than total RNA synthesis. The stimulation of both lac and gel RNA synthesis was increased in the presence of cyclic AMP receptor and cyclic AMP.