Analysis of somatic mutation and class switching in naive and memory B cells generating adoptive primary and secondary responses

Clonal progeny of naive B cells (producing a primary antibody response) and of memory B cells (producing a secondary response) were identified in a cell transfer system. Primary response clones are typically derived from IgM precursors and express unmutated V regions. Multiple isotype switches occur in these clones. Secondary response clones derive from IgG1 precursors and express highly mutated V regions. Additional switches do not occur. With one exception, there was no evidence for somatic mutation during clonal expansion. The generation of mutated memory cells may thus represent a distinct differentiation pathway. Evidence is presented that, in this pathway, mutants that have lost antigen binding specificity but that remain available for stimulation by a different antigen arise upon antigenic stimulation.     

Molecules that inhibit T-cell functions: cytochemical localization and shuttling

Adaptive immune responses to antigens are mediated by specific receptors expressed on B cells (BCR's) and T cells (TCR's). Effector cells and memory cells are produced following a proliferative wave that accounts for clonal expansion. If not down-regulated, clonal expansion might lead to uncontrolled lymphoproliferation that would be harmful for the organism. Several mechanisms that account for the down-sizing of activated lymphocyte clones are briefly reviewed here. We next consider in detail one such mechanism that deals with the functional characterization and the immunocytochemical localization of two T-cell inhibitory molecules, namely the Cytotoxic T Lymphocyte Antigen-4 (CTLA-4) and the HP-F1 antigen, both present in all T lymphocytes. CTLA-4 and HP-F1 inhibit CD4+ T-helper cell proliferation and the lytic ability of CD8+ T-cytotoxic cells in non-specific and in antigen-specific cytolytic assays. Interestingly, a clonal distribution exists as for the ability of CTLA-4 and HP-F1 to inhibit T-cell functions. In resting and activated T cells, both molecules are largely confined in the endosomal compartment, as shown by immunofluorescence analyses. However, upon interaction of T cells with Antigen-Presenting Cells (APC's) or with target cells that must be killed, CTLA-4 molecules are transported to the plasma membrane, at the site of cell-to-cell contact where, following interaction with ligands, they trigger inhibitory signals.     

Mathematical models of antibody response

An antigen triggers the clonal expansion of B lymphocytes accompanied by antibody production. This paper presents and compares the basic ideas of three mathematical models of B cell differentiation and proliferation.     

Carrier-induced epitopic suppression is initiated through clonal dominance

Injection of mice with an immunogenic dose of carrier followed by immunization with hapten-carrier conjugate selectively suppresses anti-hapten antibody response. Previous studies have proposed that this epitopic suppression is related to the induction of carrier-specific Ts cells which in turn could inhibit selectively anti-hapten response. In the present study, we propose that the epitopic suppression is in fact due to clonal dominance. Immunization with a carrier such as tetanus toxoid induces a clonal expansion of carrier-specific B cells, thus decreasing the probability of hapten-specific B cells to react with the Ag. Increasing the density of the TNP-hapten on the conjugate has totally prevented the induction of the epitopic suppression. Moreover, using low hapten-carrier concentrations to challenge carrier-primed mice has enhanced the induction of the suppression. Finally, priming hapten-specific B cells before carrier/hapten-carrier immunization has also abrogated the suppression. The results of these experiments support the view that epitopic suppression is induced through the expansion of the clones specific for the carrier epitopes and resulted from intra-molecular antigenic competition between hapten and carrier epitopes. Based on these findings a regulatory role is proposed for B cells, where through their capacity to process and present antigen, they would exercise a strong influence on the selection of immune responses.     

Antigen-binding lymphocytes in guinea pigs. I.B cell expansion to the monovalent antigen L-tyrosine-p-azophenyl trimethylammonium (tyr(TMA)) in the absence of antibody production.

The monofunctional antigen L-tyrosine-p-azophenyltrimethylammonium chloride, tyr(TMA), and the polyfunctional antigen, TMA-human gamma-globulin (TMA-HGG), were used to investigate the antigen structural requirements necessary for clonal proliferation of B cells. This clonal expansion was characterized with respect to receptor immunoglobulin class and affinity maturation. Antigen-binding analysis revealed that inoculation of tyr(TMA), although only of m.w. 344, triggers clonal expansion of B lymphocytes 9-fold in the absence of any apparent antibody production. There does not appear to be any maturation with respect to antibody class since greater than 90% of the tyr(TMA)-specific B cells bear the micron receptor in the nonimmune and immune state. However, the average avidity of the B cells for this antigen increases with time after immunization. In contrast, immunization with TMA-HGG results in an 18-fold increase in B lymphocytes with significant amounts of anti-TMA antibody production. With time after immunization, both maturation of average avidity and class of Ig receptor (micron leads to gamma shift) occur. These findings indicate that the functionally T cell-specific antigen tyr(TMA) can trigger clonal B cell expansion and affinity maturation at the receptor level in the absence of detectable antibody production.     

Somatic mutation, affinity maturation and the antibody repertoire: a computer model

Somatic mutation has been implicated as a significant and possibly primary factor in the maturation of antibody affinity in the humoral immune response. B cells stimulated by antigen experience a hyper-mutation in the gene segments that code for the antigen-binding site of the antibody, creating antibody specificities that did not exist at the time of immunization. Although most of the mutations are likely to be disadvantageous, new specificities with a higher affinity for the antigen are sometimes created. These higher-affinity cells are preferentially selected for proliferation and eventual antibody secretion, resulting in a progressively higher average affinity over time. In this paper we present the results of an investigation of somatic mutation through the use of a computer model. At the basis of the model is a large repertoire of discrete antibodies and antigens, having three-dimensional structures, that exhibit properties similar to those of the real populations. The key factor is that the binding strength between any antibody/antigen pair can be calculated as a function of the complementarity of the (a) size, (b) shape and (c) functional groups that comprise the two structures. The created repertoires are imbedded in a dynamical system model of the immune response to directly evaluate the affect of somatic mutation on affinity maturation. We also present an expanded hypothesis of clonal selection and development to explain how the mutational restrictions imposed by the genetic code and the structure of the antibody repertoire, along with antigen concentration, affinity, and probabilistic factors may interact and contribute to the expansion of specific clones as the response develops over time.     

A polyclonal assay for T helper function involving T-B cell contact mediated by L3T4 molecules

In the presence of pokeweed mitogen (PWM), T helper (TH) cell clones can induce differentiation of a very high proportion of normal B lymphocytes into plasmocytes. This property can be used to test TH cell function regardless of clonal specificity. We have investigated the role of L3T4 surface antigen in this new assay. Only TH cell clones expressing the L3T4 antigen have effector activity in this PWM-dependent helper assay; L3T4- TH cell variants are inactive. The involvement of L3T4 antigen is further shown by the ability of anti-L3T4 monoclonal antibody to inhibit the PWM-dependent polyclonal B cell differentiation induced by L3T4+ TH cell clones. This inhibition is not the consequence of arrested TH cell activation, nor of a lack of appropriate B cell stimulation by TH cell lymphokines. We show that PWM focuses TH cells on the B cell hybridoma LB15-13, and that anti-L3T4 mAb prevents the T-B cell clustering mediated by PWM. Thus, by a mechanism comparable with the one described for concanavalin A in the cytotoxicity assay, PWM acts by bridging TH cells and B cells; the T cell surface antigen L3T4 is involved in this process.     

Differential regulation of activation, clonal expansion, and antibody secretion in human B cells

Limiting dilution analysis, hemolytic plaque assay, and ELISA procedures were used to study the recruitment, clonal expansion, and antibody secretion in human TNP-specific B cells activated in the presence of TNP-ovalbumin (TNP-OA), pokeweed mitogen (PWM), or regulatory T cells. TNP-OA-responsive, hapten-specific PFC precursor cells occupy approximately 0.5% of all sIgM+/sIgD+ B cells in cord blood, bone marrow, peripheral blood, and tonsil. The PWM-responsive, hapten-specific PFC precursor pool is 70 to 90% smaller and does not express sIgD. Antigen-reactive B cells go through a minimum of three divisions in culture (six to nine PFC per clone), and antibody secretory rates of about 10(4) molecules IgM/cell/hr are achieved. In contrast, PWM-induced clone sizes were at least 60 PFC per clone, with antibody secretory rates of approximately 6 to 7 X 10(4) molecules IgM/cell/hr. Addition of high-dose carrier-primed suppressor T cells to limit dilution cultures reduced PFC precursor cell recruitment by up to 99%. However, in the few clones escaping from suppression, both clonal expansion and antibody secretory rates were much higher than in suppressor cell-free cultures, generating 30 to 60% of the antibody secreted in controls but with consequently much more restricted clonal diversity. When limiting dilution cultures were compared with standard microcultures of 2 X 10(5) cells, both clonal expansion and antibody secretory rates were much lower than expected, with a culture efficiency calculated to be 10 to 20% of that in low-density cultures. Our data suggest that the B cell subsets activated by antigen and by mitogen differ in their abilities for clonal expansion and antibody secretion. The hapten-specific and -responsive B cell family is expressed early in ontogeny, and in adults it is distributed evenly throughout the body. These limiting dilution experiments revealed that the primary effect of regulatory T cells is a drastic reduction in clonal diversity, and much less a mere reduction in overall response magnitude.     

Antigen-specific CD4 effector T cells: Analysis of factors regulating clonal expansion and cytokine production: Clonal expansion and cytokine production by CD4 effector T cells

In order to fully understand T cell-mediated immunity, the mechanisms that regulate clonal expansion and cytokine production by CD4⁺ antigen-specific effector T cells in response to a wide range of antigenic stimulation needs clarification. For this purpose, panels of antigen-specific CD4⁺ T cell clones with different thresholds for antigen-induced proliferation were generated by repeated stimulation with high- or low-dose antigen. Differences in antigen sensitivities did not correlate with expression of TCR, CD4, adhesion or costimulatory molecules. There was no significant difference in antigen-dependent cytokine production by TG40 cells transfected with TCR obtained from either high- or low-dose-responding T cell clones, suggesting that the affinity of TCRs for their ligands is not primary determinant of T cell antigen reactivity. The proliferative responses of all T cell clones to both peptide stimulation and to TCRβ crosslinking revealed parallel dose-response curves. These results suggest that the TCR signal strength of effector T cells and threshold of antigen reactivity is determined by an intrinsic property, such as the TCR signalosome and/or intracellular signaling machinery. Finally, the antigen responses of high- and low-peptide-responding T cell clones reveal that clonal expansion and cytokine production of effector T cells occur independently of antigen concentration. Based on these results, the mechanisms underlying selection of high “avidity” effector and memory T cells in response to pathogen are discussed.     

Key determinants in the occurrence of clonal variation in humanized antibody expression of cho cells during dihydrofolate reductase mediated gene amplification

Recombinant Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) parental clones expressing a humanized antibody against S surface antigen of hepatitis B virus were obtained by cotransfection of heavy chain (HC) and light chain (LC) cDNA expression vectors into dihydrofolate reductase (DHFR)-deficient CHO cells. When 23 representative parental clones were subjected to stepwise selection for increasing methotrexate (MTX) resistance, such as 0.02, 0.08, 0.32, and 1.0 microM, their clonal variations in regard to antibody expression were found to be significant. Among 23 parental clones, only one clone (hu17) showed the significant increment of specific antibody productivity (q(Ab)) with increasing MTX concentration up to 0.32 microM. Compared with the parental clone (hu17), the q(Ab) of hu17 resistant at 0.32 microM MTX (hu17-0.32) was enhanced approximately 12.5-fold. To clarify the reason for the occurrence of clonal variations, Southern blot analyses of chromosomal DNAs derived from each amplified clone at 0.32 microM MTX were performed. Only the hu17-0.32 clone did not experience severe genetic rearrangement during gene amplification, and it had only one 49-kb amplification unit including the LC and HC cDNAs. A fluorescent MTX competition assay showed that the resistance against MTX toxicity of the other clones without enhanced q(Ab) at 0.32 microM MTX was obtained by mechanisms such as an impaired MTX transport system. Taken together, the data obtained here show that clonal variations in regard to antibody expression are found to be significant because clones can acquire MTX resistance by mechanisms other than DHFR-mediated gene amplification despite the stepwise selection.     

Germinal center dynamics revealed by multiphoton microscopy with a photoactivatable fluorescent reporter

The germinal center (GC) reaction produces high-affinity antibodies by random mutation and selective clonal expansion of B cells with high-affinity receptors. The mechanism by which B cells are selected remains unclear, as does the role of the two anatomically defined areas of the GC, light zone (LZ) and dark zone (DZ). We combined a transgenic photoactivatable fluorescent protein tracer with multiphoton laser-scanning microscopy and flow cytometry to examine anatomically defined LZ and DZ B cells and GC selection. We find that B cell division is restricted to the DZ, with a net vector of B cell movement from the DZ to the LZ. The decision to return to the DZ and undergo clonal expansion is controlled by T helper cells in the GC LZ, which discern between LZ B cells based on the amount of antigen captured and presented. Thus, T cell help, and not direct competition for antigen, is the limiting factor in GC selection.     

Demonstration of T-cell-dependent and T-cell-independent components of 8-mercaptoguanosine-mediated adjuvanticity

The contribution of T cells to potentiation of humoral immunity by the C8-substituted guanine ribonucleosides and the origin of the increased numbers of antigen-responsive B cells generated consequent to their action have been investigated. Augmentation of the antigen-specific antibody response by these nucleosides, exemplified by 8-mercaptoguanosine (8MGuo), can be separated into T-cell-dependent and T-cell-independent components, both by use of the T-cell tropic immunosuppressive agent, cyclosporin A, and by experiments using separated populations of T and B cells. Augmentation of adjuvanticity by T cells is hypothesized to involve a B-cell subpopulation not otherwise subject to the action of 8MGuo. This subpopulation could potentially arise by either of two mechanisms, one whereby preexisting antigen-specific B cells undergo clonal expansion, and one in which cells not normally participating in the response are recruited in the absence of clonal expansion. Although the former mechanism makes a minor contribution to adjuvanticity, the latter mechanism appears to be the dominant one, insofar as models in which 8MGuo-induced proliferation fails to occur (such as after irradiation, or in the SJL mouse) nonetheless exhibit strong adjuvant effects. Analysis of precursor frequency of antigen-specific B cells indicates that for each mature, antigen-responsive B cell present in adult murine spleen, an average of four additional cells can be recruited by the conjoint actions of antigen and 8MGuo. One group subject to such recruitment is the immature antigen-specific B cell, whose degree of functional maturity is accelerated in the presence of antigen and 8MGuo.     

Clonal analysis of B cell growth and differentiation activities induced from T lymphocytes upon triggering of T3-Ti and T11 pathways

The cellular origin of B cell growth factors (BCGF) and differentiation factors (BCDF) was investigated in the present study. For this purpose, T4+ and T8+ T cell clones were obtained from human peripheral blood, activated via stimulation of either the antigen/MHC receptor (T3-Ti molecular complex) or the antigen-independent alternative pathway (T11 molecule), and subsequently examined for their capacity to induce B cell proliferation and immunoglobulin production. The results showed that 1) BCGF is produced by both T4+ and T8+ T cells at the population level as well as at the clonal level; 2) BCDF activity, in contrast, is largely but not exclusively restricted to the T4+ subset; and 3) both the T3-Ti and T11 pathways activate individual clonal T cell populations to promote B cell growth and differentiation.     

Disparate functional properties of two interleukin 1-responsive Ly-1+2- T cell clones: distinction of T cell growth factor and T cell-replacing factor activities

We describe the properties of two Ly-1+2- T cell clones (Ly-1.14 and Ly-1.21), which are maintained in long-term culture in the absence of other cell types. The clones require media containing a source of interleukin 1 as well as interleukin 2. They retain physiologic responses to interleukin 1, which is required for optimal production of T cell lymphokines by these clones in response to concanavalin A (Con A). The two Ly-1+2- T cell clones differ in their production of lymphokines after stimulation by Con A. The supernatant of clone Ly-1.21 promotes the proliferation of T cells maintained in long-term culture, induces antibody synthesis in cultures of B cells and antigen, and induces the differentiation of cytolytic cells in cultures of thymocytes and antigen; these assays define the properties of T cell growth factor (TCGF), T cell-replacing factor for B cells (TRF-B), and T cell-replacing factor for cytolytic cells (TRF-C), respectively. In contrast, the supernatant of clone Ly-1.14 contains only TCGF activity and does not promote antibody synthesis by B cells or differentiation of cytolytic cells from thymocytes. The results indicates that TCGF and TRF activities reside on independent, although perhaps related, molecules.     

Antibody V(h) repertoire differences between resolving and chronically evolving hepatitis C virus infections

Despite the production of neutralizing antibodies to hepatitis C virus (HCV), many patients fail to clear the virus and instead develop chronic infection and long-term complications. To understand how HCV infection perturbs the antibody repertoire and to identify molecular features of antibody genes associated with either viral clearance or chronic infection, we sequenced the V(D)J region of naïve and memory B cells of 6 persons who spontaneously resolved an HCV infection (SR), 9 patients with a newly diagnosed chronically evolving infection (CE), and 7 healthy donors. In both naïve and memory B cells, the frequency of use of particular antibody gene subfamilies and segments varied among the three clinical groups, especially between SR and CE. Compared to CE, SR antibody genes used fewer VH, D and JH gene segments in naïve B cells and fewer VH segments in memory B cells. SR and CE groups significantly differed in the frequency of use of 7 gene segments in naïve B cell clones and 3 gene segments in memory clones. The nucleotide mutation rates were similar among groups, but the pattern of replacement and silent mutations in memory B cell clones indicated greater antigen selection in SR than CE. Greater clonal evolution of SR than CE memory B cells was revealed by analysis of phylogenetic trees and CDR3 lengths. Pauciclonality of the peripheral memory B cell population is a distinguishing feature of persons who spontaneously resolved an HCV infection. This finding, previously considered characteristic only of patients with HCV-associated lymphoproliferative disorders, suggests that the B cell clones potentially involved in clearance of the virus may also be those susceptible to abnormal expansion.     

Novartis Medal Lecture. Antibodies: a paradigm for the evolution of molecular recognition

Novel proteins have been elaborated over evolutionary time by an iterative alternation of mutation and selection. In a similar way, the humoral immune system also uses an iterative alternation of mutation and selection to generate novel antibodies that display a high affinity for their cognate antigen -- but this is achieved in a matter of a days. Gene rearrangement is used to produce a primary repertoire of antibodies and, on entering the body, antigen triggers the clonal expansion of those B lymphocytes that express a cognate antibody, albeit one of low affinity. Rapid and specific affinity maturation is then achieved by subjecting the immunoglobulin genes in the rapidly expanding B cells to a period of intense mutation. The intensity of this mutational assault is tolerated because it is targeted specifically to the immunoglobulin genes, causing relatively little damage to other loci. Antigen-mediated selection then allows the preferential expansion of those mutants expressing antibodies displaying improved binding characteristics. Here, studies are described that have been performed to glean insight into the mechanisms of the hypermutation and selection processes. Experiments are also described in which an attempt has been made to recapitulate aspects of physiological antibody generation in vitro, allowing the development of novel approaches to the generation of proteins with high-affinity binding sites.     

Aberrant maturational characteristics of the immune responses of NZB mice to autologous and heterologous erythrocyte antigens

The maturational characteristics of the humoral immune responses of C3H and NZB mice to autologous and heterologous erythrocyte antigens were investigated. Clonal selection of antibody-secreting B lymphocytes was examined at the plaque-forming cell level of analysis of changes in mean antibody affinity and the heterogeneity of binding affinities. The primary immune response of C3H mice to SRBC exhibited a progressive temporal increase in mean relative antibody affinity and a concomitant restriction in the heterogeneity of binding affinities consistent with clonal selection and restriction of B lymphocytes to high affinity antibody-secreting cells. By contrast, the anti-SRBC immune response of NZB mice displayed aberrant maturational characteristics with a progressive decrease in mean relative antibody affinity but also clonal restriction with selection of clones of cells secreting low affinity antibodies. The spontaneous autoimmune responses of NZB mice to autologous erythrocyte surface autoantigens X and HB were different from the response to heterologous erythrocytes in that there was neither a progressive change in mean relative binding affinity nor evidence of progressive clonal restriction. Although the precise mechanisms responsible for the aberrant selection and derepression of B lymphocyte clones in NZB mice have not been identified, the very nature of the aberration suggests the existence of one or more defects which may be intrinsic to the B lymphocytes of NZB mice.     

Induction of IgG and IgE synthesis in normal B cells by autoreactive T cell clones

During the course of generating tetanus toxoid (TT)-specific T cell clones frm an HLA-DR2,7 donor, four clones were obtained which proliferated in the presence of autologous monocytes alone without the addition of TT antigen. This proliferation was specifically inhibited by anti-HLA-DR framework mouse monoclonal antibody, and appeared to be HLA-DR-restricted. Two of the clones proliferated in response to HLA-DR2-bearing monocytes, and the other two clones proliferated in response to HLA-DR7-bearing monocytes. The capacity of these four autoreactive human T cell helper clones to induce IgE synthesis in B cells was studied. All four clones stimulated autologous peripheral blood B cells to synthesize IgE and IgG antibody. Induction of IgE synthesis in B cells by the autoreactive T cell clones followed the same pattern of HLA-DR restriction which governed the proliferative response of these clones. These results suggest that the interaction of autoreactive helper T cells with B cell HLA-DR antigens may be important in the activation of IgE immune responses in humans.