Novel resistances to four potyviruses in tuber-bearing potato species, and temperature-sensitive expression of hypersensitive resistance to potato virus Y

Novel potyvirus resistance specificities were found in eight tested wild potato species (clones): hypersensitive resistance (HR) to potato Y potyvirus (PVY) strain groups PVY^O in Solanum megistacrolobum and S. polyadenium and PVY^N in S. stoloniferum; HR to potato V potyvirus (PW) in S. maglia, S. polyadenium, S. stoloniferum, S. sparsipilum and S. sucrense, HR to potato A potyvirus (PVA) strain group 1 in S. sucrense, and extreme resistance (ER) to PVA in S. polyadenium. S. commersonii and S. stoloniferum expressed HR to tobacco etch potyvirus (TEV) which has not been reported previously in potato species. The studied clone of S. stoloniferum expressed HR to all potyviruses and potyvirus strains tested. The clone of S. stoloniferum (2n = 48; nuclear DNA content (2C) = 3.6 pg) and S. chacoense (2n = 24; 2C=1.9 pg) were crossed and one hybrid (2n = 36; 2C = 2.9 pg) was obtained. The hybrid expressed HR to all tested potyviruses except PVA, which indicated that HR to PVA was controlled by a gene which is different from the genes (or gene) controlling HR to PVY^O, PVY^N, PVV and TEV in S. stoloniferum. On the other hand, S. chacoense and the hybrid expressed ER to cucumber mosaic cucumovirus (CMV), whereas S. stoloniferum was susceptible to CMV. All tested wild species and the six tested potato cultivars (S. tuberosum subsp. tuberosum) expressed HR to PVV. Expression of HR following infection with PVY^N induced systemic acquired resistance (SAR) in S. chacoense. HR to PVY^N in S. sparsipilum and S. sucrense and to PVY^O in potato cv. Pito was efficiently expressed at lower temperatures (16/18°C) indicated by the development of distinct necrotic lesions and/or vein necrosis in inoculated leaves, whereas the HR was rendered less effective at higher temperatures (19/24°C) which was indicated by the development of systemic infection with leaf-drop and mosaic symptoms.     

RNA-Dependent RNA Polymerase (NIb) of the Potyviruses Is an Avirulence Factor for the Broad-Spectrum Resistance Gene Pvr4 in Capsicum annuum cv. CM334

Potyviruses are one of the most destructive viral pathogens of Solanaceae plants. In Capsicum annuum landrace CM334, a broad-spectrum gene, Pvr4 is known to be involved in resistance against multiple potyviruses, including Pepper mottle virus (PepMoV), Pepper severe mosaic virus (PepSMV), and Potato virus Y (PVY). However, a potyvirus avirulence factor against Pvr4 has not been identified. To identify the avirulence factor corresponding to Pvr4 in potyviruses, we performed Agrobacterium-mediated transient expressions of potyvirus protein coding regions in potyvirus-resistant (Pvr4) and -susceptible (pvr4) pepper plants. Hypersensitive response (HR) was observed only when a RNA-dependent RNA polymerase (NIb) of PepMoV, PepSMV, or PVY was expressed in Pvr4-bearing pepper leaves in a genotype-specific manner. In contrast, HR was not observed when the NIb of Tobacco etch virus (TEV), a virulent potyvirus, was expressed in Pvr4-bearing pepper leaves. Our results clearly demonstrate that NIbs of PepMoV, PepSMV, and PVY serve as avirulence factors for Pvr4 in pepper plants.     

Transfer of resistance to potato leafroll virus, potato virus Y and potato virus X from Solarium brevidens to S. tuberosum through symmetric and designed asymmetric somatic hybridisation

Resistance to potato leafroll virus (PLRV), potato virus Y (PVY^o) and potato virus X (PVX) was studied in symmetric and asymmetric somatic hybrids produced by electrofusion between Solanum brevidens (2n=2×=24) and dihaploid S. tuberosum (2n=2×=24), and also in regenerants (B-hybrids) derived through protoplast culture from a single somatic hybrid (chromosome number 48). All of the somatic hybrids between 5. brevidens and the two dihaploid lines of potato cv. Pito were extremely resistant to PLRV and PVY^oand moderately resistant to PVX, irrespective of their chromosome number and ploidy level (tetraploid or hexaploid). Most (56%) of the asymmetric hybrids of irradiated S. brevidens and the dihaploid line of potato cv. Pentland Crown (PDH40) had high titres of PVY^osimilar to those of PDH40, whereas the rest of the hybrids had PVY^otitres less than a tenth of those in PDH40. Three B-hybrids had a highly reduced chromosome number (27, 30 and 34), but were however as resistant to PLRV, PVY^oand PVX as 5. brevidens. Two asymmetric hybrids and one B-hybrid were extremely resistant to PLRV but susceptible to both PVY and PVX. The results suggested that resistance to PLRV in 5. brevidens is controlled by a gene or genes different from those controlling resistance to PVY and PVX, and the gene(s) for resistance to PVY and PVX are linked in S. brevidens.     

Interactions of the Solanum spp. of the Etuberosa group and nine potato-infecting viruses and a viroid

All 26 accessions of Solanum brevidens, one accession of S. etuberosum and one accession of S. fernandezianum tested were all extremely resistant to potato leafroll virus (PLRV) and potato viruses Y (PVY) and A (PVA). S. brevidens and S. etuberosum were also resistant to Andean potato mottle virus (APMV) and moderately resistant to potato virus X (PVX), whereas S. fernandezianum was susceptible to these viruses. Additionally, S. brevidens was resistant to sap-inoculated potato viruses M (PVM) and S (PVS). All the Etuberosa accessions were susceptible by graft-inoculation to PVM, PVS, potato virus T (PVT) and Andean potato latent virus (APLV). Infections by the above mentioned viruses were symptomless in all of the Etuberosa spp. S. etuberosum and S. fernandezianum were infected by mechanical inoculation with potato spindle tuber viroid, S. etuberosum developing severe stunting and leaf-curl symptoms, but S. brevidens was infected only by graft-inoculation. The genes conferring resistance to PVY and PVX in S. brevidens and S. etuberosum appeared to be different from those currently utilised by plant breeders.     

Expression of the PVYO coat protein (CP) under the control of the PVX CP gene leader sequence: protection under greenhouse and field conditions against PVYO and PVYN infection in three potato cultivars

Coat protein-mediated resistance (CPMR), resistance conferred as a result of the expression of viral coat proteins in transgenic plants, has been illustrated to be an effective way of protecting plants against several plant viruses. Nonetheless, consistent protection has not been achieved for transgenic plants expressing the coat protein of potato virus Y (PVY), the type member of the potyvirus family. In this report, three different potato cultivars were transformed with a chimeric construct consisting of the capsid protein (CP) coding sequences of PVY flanked by the AUG codon and the translational enhancer from the coat protein gene of potato virus X (PVX). These cultivars were shown to express high levels of PVY CP and confer a high degree of protection against PVY^o and PVY^N under both greenhouse and field conditions. In addition, transgenic plants infected with potato virus A (PVA), a related potyvirus, exhibited a delay in virus accumulation, which could be easily overcome with increasing virus concentrations. Received: 26 October 1995 / Accepted: 14 June 1996     

An Ry-mediated resistance response in potato requires the intact active site of the NIa proteinase from potato virus Y

Ry confers extreme resistance to all strains of potato virus Y (PVY). To identify the elicitor of the Ry-mediated resistance against PVY in potato, we expressed each of the PVY-encoded proteins in leaves of PVY-resistant (Ry) and -susceptible (ry) plants. For most of the proteins tested, there was no evident response. However, when the NIa proteinase was expressed in leaves of Ry plants, there was a hypersensitive response (HR). Proteinase active site mutants failed to induce the Ry-mediated response. The HR was also induced by the NIa proteinase from pepper mottle virus (PepMoV), which has the same cleavage specificity as the PVY enzyme, but not by the tobacco etch virus (TEV) or the potato virus A (PVA) proteinases that cleave different peptide motifs. Based on these results, we propose that Ry-mediated resistance requires the intact active site of the NIa proteinase. Although the structure of the active proteinase could have elicitor activity, it is possible that this proteinase releases an elicitor by cleavage of a host-encoded protein. Alternatively, the proteinase could inactivate a negative regulator of the Ry-mediated resistance response.     

Isolation and viral infection of Capsicum leaf protoplasts

Summary A protocol for protoplast isolation was developed and tested with five Capsicum genotypes representing two cultivated species, C. annuum and C. chinense. Key variables included growth conditions for source plants and the concentration of mannitol used as osmoticum. Protoplasts isolated from each of the genotypes became infected when inoculated via electroporation with viral RNA from either pepper mottle potyvirus, tobacco etch potyvirus or cucumber mosaic cucumovirus.     

Genetic variability of Potato virus Y (PVY) and Tobacco etch virus (TEV) from naturally infected pepper fields in the Hatay region of Turkey

The genetic structure of Potato virus Y (PVY) and Tobacco etch virus (TEV) (Potyvirus) populations was investigated in pepper fields in two regions in Turkey. The diversity of PVY and TEV populations according to coat protein (CP) and VPg coding regions showed some similarity. All the isolates built a monophyletic group due to a single introduction event or multiple introductions of genetically similar isolates. All the isolates of both viruses showed evidence to the diversification for a long time. Based on VPg and CP sequences, all PVY isolates corresponded to clade C1. Turkish potyvirus isolates were only able to break the pvr2¹ resistance allele and therefore belonged to pathotype (0,?1). The Pvr4 dominant gene was found to be efficient and durable against PVY but not at all efficient against TEV. Consequently, the pvr2² resistance allele, efficient resistance against PVY and TEV pathotype (0,?1) isolates, would be the most suitable strategy to control potyviruses.     

Aphid Transmission of Potato aucuba mosaic virus Strains Mediated by Different Strains of Potato virus Y

Three British strains of potato aucuba mosaic virus (PAMV) were tested for transmissibility by the aphid Myzus persicae. None was aphid transmissible on its own but all three were transmitted in the nonpersistent manner by aphids that had previously been fed on a source of the potyvirus potato virus Y (PVY). Different PVY strains mediated PAMV transmission from Nicotiana clevelandii to Capsicum annuum to different degrees, and different PAMV strains were transmitted at different frequencies when assisted by the same PVY strain. These results are compatible with the idea that subtle differences in the PAMV coat protein and in the PVY helper component are responsible for diffrences in frequencies of transmission of PAMV, without however, excluding the possibility of effects of other undefined factors. Transmission of PAMV was no less frequent when mediated by a PVY strain that was unable to infect C. annuum than when a C. annuum‐infecting PVY strain was used.     

Molecular examination of a chromosome region that controls resistance to potato Y and A potyviruses in potato

 The gene Ry _adg that confers resistance to potato Y potyvirus (PVY) in the cultivated potato [Solanum tuberosum subsp. andigena, line 2x(v-2)7] is located on chromosome XI in a segment that contains three other known resistance genes in other syntenic solanaceous species. One of them is the gene N that controls resistance to tobacco mosaic tobamovirus in tobacco and has previously been isolated and sequenced. Three sequence-related, resistance gene-like (RGL) DNA fragments (354–369 bp) highly homologous to the gene N were PCR-amplified from the potato line 2x(v-2)7. Two RGL fragments (79 and 81% homologous to the N gene) co-segregated with Ry _adg among the 77 F1 progeny tested. These RGLs may originate from a resistance gene family on chromosome XI. The potato line 2x(v-2)7 also expressed resistance to potato A potyvirus (PVA), which was controlled by another locus on chromosome XI mapped ca. 6.8 cM distal to Ry _adg . Received: 18 December 1997 / Accepted: 30 December 1997     

Strong resistance to potato tuber necrotic ringspot disease in potato induced by transformation with coat protein gene sequences from an NTN isolate of Potato virus Y

The potato cv. Igor is susceptible to infection with Potato virus Y (PVY) and in Slovenia it has been so severely affected with NTN isolates of PVY causing potato tuber necrotic ringspot disease (PTNRD) that its cultivation has ceased. Plants of cv. Igor were transformed with two transgenes that contained coat protein gene sequence of PVY^NTN. Both transgenes used PVY sequence in a sense (+) orientation, one in native translational context (N‐CP), and one with a frame‐shift mutation (FS‐CP). Although most transgenic lines were susceptible to infection with PVY^NTN and PVY^O, several lines showed resistance that could be classified into two types. Following manual or graft inoculation, plants of partially resistant lines developed some symptoms in foliage and tubers, and virus titre in the foliage, estimated by ELISA, was low or undetectable. In highly resistant (R) lines, symptoms did not develop in foliage and on tubers, and virus could not be detected in foliage by ELISA or infectivity assay. Four lines from 34 tested (two N‐CP and two FS‐CP) were R to PVY^NTN and PVY^O and one additional line was R to PVY^O. When cv. Spey was transformed with the same constructs, they did not confer strong resistance to PVY^O.     

Interactions between pepper ringspot virus and cylindrical inclusions of two potyviruses

Immunoelectron microscopy showed that cylindrical inclusions (CI) of the potyvirus potato virus Y (PVY) bound in addition to their homologous virions those of a co-infecting rod-shaped virus, pepper ringspot virus (PRV), in infected Nicotiana benthamiana leaf cells. The latter virus does not code for cylindrical inclusions and is cl assified as a Tobravirus. Virions of PRV were scattered throughout the cell cytoplasm and not associated with mitochondria in PVY + PRV double infections. Binding of PRV to mitochondria was disrupted in PVY + PRV infected cells. In double infections with a second potyvirus, tobacco etch virus (TEV), and PRV in N. benthamiana cells, TEV-CI bound homologous TEV virions but did not bind PRV. In contrast to PVY + PRV infections, virions of PRV attached end-on to mitochondrial limiting membranes in PRV-only and in TEV + PRV double infections. The results are interpreted to mean that there are differences in the PRV virion binding sites of PVY-CI and TEV-CI. In previous reports, potyviral CI have been nondiscriminating in binding virions or capsid proteins of other co-infecting rod-shaped viruses.     

The novel gene Ny-1 on potato chromosome IX confers hypersensitive resistance to Potato virus Y and is an alternative to Ry genes in potato breeding for PVY resistance

Hypersensitive resistance (HR) is an efficient defense strategy in plants that restricts pathogen growth and can be activated during host as well as non-host interactions. HR involves programmed cell death and manifests itself in tissue collapse at the site of pathogen attack. A novel hypersensitivity gene, Ny-1, for resistance to Potato virus Y (PVY) was revealed in potato cultivar Rywal. This is the first gene that confers HR in potato plants both to common and necrotic strains of PVY. The locus Ny-1 mapped on the short arm of potato chromosome IX, where various resistance genes are clustered in Solanaceous genomes. Expression of HR was temperature-dependent in cv. Rywal. Strains PVY^O and PVY^N, including subgroups PVY^NW and PVY^NTN, were effectively localized when plants were grown at 20°C. At 28°C, plants were systemically infected but no symptoms were observed. In field trials, PVY was restricted to the inoculated leaves and PVY-free tubers were produced. Therefore, the gene Ny-1 can be useful for potato breeding as an alternative donor of PVY resistance, because it is efficacious in practice-like resistance conferred by Ry genes.     

The role of volunteer potatoes in the spread of potato virus YN in ware crops of cv. Record

Surveys were made for the presence of potato virus Y (PVY) in the planted seed and harvested tubers in ware potato crops of cv. Record grown at three sites in England in 1994 (survey 1) and seven sites in 1995 (survey 2). PVY was not found in samples of planted seed, but high levels of infection were found in many, but not all, harvested crops. However, plants of volunteer potatoes (VP) (i.e. plants arising from tubers or true seed derived from previous crops and surviving in the soil) were frequently found to be infected. Infection in tubers harvested from crops in the first survey ranged from 2–52%. In 1995, VP were collected from two of the three English sites where potato crops had been grown the previous season and also from a site in Scotland where PVY infection in an experimental crop of cv. Record had been monitored in 1994. The percentages of infected VP ranged from 2–54%. PVY^N was the predominant strain found in sampled VP, with only two plants (out of 300 infected) containing PVY^O. In the second survey, VP were assessed within the 1995 ware crops and were found at four sites, at which they comprised between 4–8% of emerged potato plants. Between 31–93% of VP were infected. Again, PVY^N was the predominant strain with one plant containing PVY^O and another PVY^C (out of 189 infected). A sample of harvested tubers from each site was also tested for PVY. At those sites which had many infected VP, the harvested crop contained a large percentage of infected tubers, ranging from 60–97%. Two sites which had not previously been used for cropping potatoes had no VP and a very low incidence of PVY infection in the harvested tubers (1% and 2%). However, although no VP were found at one site, 31% of harvested tubers were infected, suggesting that alternative inoculum sources may be important.     

Recombination of strain O segments to HCpro‐encoding sequence of strain N of Potato virus Y modulates necrosis induced in tobacco and in potatoes carrying resistance genes Ny or Nc

Hypersensitive resistance (HR) to strains O and C of Potato virus Y (PVY, genus Potyvirus) is conferred by potato genes Ny_tbr and Nc_tbr, respectively; however, PVY N strains overcome these resistance genes. The viral helper component proteinases (HCpro, 456 amino acids) from PVY^N and PVY^O are distinguished by an eight‐amino‐acid signature sequence, causing HCpro to fold into alternative conformations. Substitution of only two residues (K269R and R270K) of the eight‐amino‐acid signature in PVY^N HCpro was needed to convert the three‐dimensional (3D) model of PVY^N HCpro to a PVY^O‐like conformation and render PVY^N avirulent in the presence of Ny_tbr, whereas four amino acid substitutions were necessary to change PVY^O HCpro to a PVY^N‐like conformation. Hence, the HCpro conformation rather than other features ascribed to the sequence were essential for recognition by Ny_tbr. The 3D model of PVY^C HCpro closely resembled PVY^O, but differed from PVY^N HCpro. HCpro of all strains was structurally similar to β‐catenin. Sixteen PVY^N605‐based chimeras were inoculated to potato cv. Pentland Crown (Ny_tbr), King Edward (Nc_tbr) and Pentland Ivory (Ny_tbr/Nc_tbr). Eleven chimeras induced necrotic local lesions and caused no systemic infection, and thus differed from both parental viruses that infected King Edward systemically, and from PVY^N605 that infected Pentland Crown and Pentland Ivory systemically. These 11 chimeras triggered both Ny_tbr and Nc_tbr and, in addition, six induced veinal necrosis in tobacco. Further, specific amino acid residues were found to have an additive impact on necrosis. These results shed new light on the causes of PVY‐related necrotic symptoms in potato.     

Both common and specific genetic factors are involved in polygenic resistance of pepper to several potyviruses

Absolute resistance to potato virus Y pathotype 0 (PVY 0), potyvirus E and chili veinal mottle virus (CVMV) and a partial resistance to potato virus Y pathotype 1,2 (PVY 1,2) were found in an Indian pepper line, Perennial. In the doubled haploid (DH) progeny from the F₁ of a cross Perennial by Yolo Wonder, resistance to CVMV was confered by two independent genes, one with a clear dominant effect. Resistance to PVY and potyvirus E was quantitatively expressed and controlled by several recessive genetic factors. Genetic analysis showed that fewer resistance factors were necessary to explain resistance to PVY (0) and potyvirus E than resistance to PVY(1,2). Genetic correlations between resistances to the different potyviruses in the DH progeny showed that most of genetic factors involved in PVY(0) resistance appear to be also involved in potyvirus E resistance, and some of these polyvalent factors may be also involved in PVY(1,2) resistance but, in this case, additional specific genes were necessary. One of the two CVMV resistance genes seems to be implicated in potyvirus E resistance. Thus, the polygenic resistance of Perennial to these potyviruses was due both to polyvalent genetic factors, i.e. factors that apparently interact with several viruses, and strain-specific genetic factors.     

Comparison of transmission efficiency of various isolates of Potato virus Y among three aphid vectors

Potato virus Y (PVY) strains are transmitted by different aphid species in a non‐persistent, non‐circulative manner. Green peach aphid (GPA), Myzus persicae Sulzer, is the most efficient vector in laboratory studies, but potato aphid (PA), Macrosiphum euphorbiae Thomas (both Hemiptera: Aphididae, Macrosiphini), and bird cherry‐oat aphid (BCOA), Rhopalosiphum padi L. (Hemiptera: Aphididae, Aphidini), also contribute to PVY transmission. Studies were conducted with GPA, PA, and BCOA to assess PVY transmission efficiency for various isolates of the same strain. Treatments included three PVY strains (PVY^O, PVY^N:O, PVY^NTN) and two isolates of each strain (Oz and NY090031 for PVY^O; Alt and NY090004 for PVY^N:O; N4 and NY090029 for PVY^NTN), using each of three aphid species as well as a sham inoculation. Virus‐free tissue‐cultured plantlets of potato cv. Russet Burbank were used as virus source and recipient plants. Five weeks post inoculation, recipient plants were tested with quantitative DAS‐ELISA to assess infection percentage and virus titer. ELISA‐positive recipient plants were assayed with RT‐PCR to confirm presence of the expected strains. Transmission efficiency (percentage infection of plants) was highest for GPA, intermediate for BCOA, and lowest for PA. For all aphid species, transmission efficiency did not differ significantly between isolates within each strain. No correlations were found among source plant titer, infection percentage, and recipient plant titer. For both GPA and BCOA, isolates of PVY^NTN were transmitted with greatest efficiency followed by isolates of PVY^O and PVY^N:O, which might help explain the increasing prevalence of necrotic strains in potato‐growing regions. Bird cherry‐oat aphid transmitted PVY with higher efficiency than previously reported, suggesting that this species is more important to PVY epidemiology than has been considered.     

Strain group specific and virus specific hypersensitive reactions to infection with potyviruses in potato cultivars

When 12 potato cultivars were inoculated with isolates (one each) of potato virus Y (PVY) ordinary (Y^o), C (Y^c) and tobacco veinal necrosis (Yⁿ) strain groups, potato virus A (PVA) and potato virus V (PVV), none of them responded hypersensitively to Yⁿ. However, with Y^o, Y^c, PVA and PW specific hypersensitive reactions developed depending on isolate-cultivar combination which were all independent of each other. When field isolates of PVY thought to be Y^oor Y^cwere inoculated to the same 12 cultivars, two did not fit into either strain group giving hypersensitive reactions in only two cultivars instead of seven with Y^oor eight with Y^c. These two isolates may represent a previously unreported PVY strain group (Y^z). When Y^owas graft-inoculated to seedlings of the cross Desiree × Maris Piper (hypersensitive × non-hypersensitive for Y^o), the segregation ratio obtained for non-hypersensitive:hypersensitive reactions was close to 1:1 suggesting that a single dominant gene (Ny_tbr) determining Y^ospecific hypersensitivity may be present in cv. Desiree (simplex condition). In tests using PVV and Desiree × Maris Piper (non-hypersensitive × hypersensitive for PVV) seedlings, the segregation ratio obtained was close to 1:5 indicating that a single dominant gene (Nv) determining PVV specific hypersensitivity may be present in cv. Maris Piper (duplex condition). Cultivars Corine, Pirola and clone G5457(4) which each carry one of the extreme resistance genes (Ry) from Solanum stoloniferum were graft-inoculated with Yⁿ, Y^o, Y^c, PVV and PVA. G5457(4) gave a strong localised hypersensitive reaction in all instances, while cv. Pirola did so with all except PVA to which it was immune. In cv. Corine a severe localised hypersensitive reaction developed with PVA, generalised hypersensitivity with PVV but an immune response with the three PVY strain groups. Large-scale grafting of Yⁿto plants of cvs Corine and Pirola gave no evidence of selection of a strain which overcomes Ry genes.     

The recessive potyvirus resistance gene <Emphasis Type="Italic">pot-1</Emphasis> is the tomato orthologue of the pepper <Emphasis Type="Italic">pvr2-eIF4E</Emphasis> gene

The translation initiation factor 4E (eIF4E) has been implicated in naturally occurring resistance to Potato virus Y (PVY) determined by the pvr2 locus in pepper (Capsicum annuum). Here, the molecular basis of the recessive resistance to PVY and Tobacco etch virus (TEV) controlled by the pot-1 locus in tomato (Lycopersicon esculentum; now Solanum lycopersicum) was investigated. On the basis of genetic mapping data that indicated that pot-1 and pvr2 are located in syntenic regions of the tomato and pepper genomes, the possible involvement of eIF4E in pot-1-mediated resistance was assessed. Genetic mapping of members of the eIF4E multigenic family in tomato introgression lines revealed that an eIF4E locus indeed maps in the same genomic region as pot-1. By comparing eIF4E coding sequences between resistant and susceptible Lycopersicon genotypes, a small number of polymorphisms that co-segregate with the pot-1 locus were identified, suggesting that this gene could be involved in resistance to potyviruses. Functional complementation experiments using Potato virus X-mediated transient expression of eIF4E from a susceptible genotype in a resistant pepper genotype confirmed that a small number of amino acid substitutions in the eIF4E protein indeed account for resistance/susceptibility to both the PVY and TEV, and consequently that pot-1 and pvr2 are orthologues. Taken together, these results support the role of this eIF4E gene as a key component of recessive resistance to potyviruses, and validate the comparative genomic approach for the molecular characterization of recessive resistance genes.