Genetic analysis of the recF pathway to genetic recombination in Escherichia coli k12: Isolation and characterization of mutants

A recombination proficient strain ofEscherichia coli which is recB^? recC^? sbcB^? has been subjected to mutagenesis by nitrosoguanidine. Among the recombination deficient mutants isolated one was sbcB⁺, three were recA^～ and 11 were mutants in at least four newrec genes: recF, recJ, recK and recL. recF143 and recL152 are cotransducible with ilv but they lie on opposite sides of the ilv operons as determined by F$\text{\$}\text{?}$studies. recF, recL and recK are not involved in the RecBC pathway of recombination since a recB⁺recC⁺sbcB^? strain carrying a mutation in one of these genes is recombination proficient. Hence the hypothesis that a RecF pathway of recombination can operate as a partially independent substitute for the RecBC pathway of recombination is supported. recF^?recB⁺ and recF⁺recB^? single mutants are sensitive to u.v. irradiation while the recF^?recB^? double mutant is more sensitive than either single mutant. The sensitivity of the recB^?recC^?sbcB^?recF^? strain approaches the sensitivity of a recA^? single mutant. This is interpreted to mean that there are partially independent RecF and RecBC pathways for the repair of u.v. damage. recJ and mutations were not mapped precisely; hence the mutant properties they confer can not be stated conclusively.     

Red-mediated recombination of phage lambda in a recA? recB?host

Summary The lambda Red recombination system works poorly among unreplicated gam ⁺ lambda chromosomes in recA ^- cells compared to recA ⁺ cells. Recombination is not enhanced in recA ^- recB^-cells. Thus, the inability of Red to promote recombination in recA ^- replication-blocked cross is not due to the hypothetical destruction of recombination intermediates by the recB nuclease. This conclusion strengthens previous proposals that the products of the red genes can operate upon recombinational intermediates which require recA activity for their formation.     

Interaction of the exrA mutation with rec mutants of Escherichia coli K12

Mutants of Escherichia coli K₁₂ were constructed which carry the exrA mutation addition to the various recombination deficient mutations recA recB and recC. The double mutant containing the exrA recA genotype is found to be slightly more sensitive to UV irradiation at very low doses of UV but essentially is very similar to the exrA + recA at the high UV doses. The recombination deficiency, λ induction and DNA degradation of the exrA recA shows a slight increase in the defectiveness of each of these functions. The double mutants of exrA recB and exrA recC show an increase in UV sensitivity and recombination deficiency and λ induction. The DNA degradation following UV-irradiation of these mutants is more characteristic of the recB and recC mutant alone.These results give further support to the theory that exrA and lex are probably mutants within the same cistron and also suggest that exrA, lex and recA are involved in a common DNA repair pathway and that the gene products of all three functions are required to regulate recB+ and recC+ endonuclease induced DNA degradation.     

Derivation of the absorvance by circularly symmetrical assembly of chromophores viewed through limited apertures

The recombination of two plasmids, pRDK101 and pACYC184, was examined in wild-type Escherichia coli and in various E. coli strains containing different recombination-deficient mutations. Recombination-induced oligomer formation from monomeric plasmids was found to be dependent on the functions of the recA, recB, recC and recFgenes. Intramolecular recombination of tetrameric plasmids to form lower-order oligomers and monomers also required the functions of the recA and recF genes but did not require the function of the recB and recC genes. In all cases where recA, recB, recC and recF mutations appeared to block the formation or reduction of plasmid circular oligomers, these effects could be reversed by the presence of an sbcA mutation.Further studies on recombination in vivo were carried out utilizing two tetracycline-sensitive derivatives of the compatible plasmids pACYC184 and pBR322. Recombination events between these two plasmids could be quantitated by measuring the production of tetracycline-resistant cells during the growth of transformants. Plasmid recombination was found to be reduced by recA and recF mutations, and the effect of these two mutations was reversed by the presence of an sbcA mutation. Plasmid recombination measured by this genetic assay was stimulated by recBrecC mutations, and electrophoretic analysis of the recombination products demonstrated that they were primarily circular monomers. A role for the recBrecC gene product, exonuclease V, in the resolution of recombination intermediates is discussed.     

Recombination and Annealing Pathways Compete for Substrates in Making rrn Duplications in Salmonella enterica

Tandem genetic duplications arise frequently between the seven directly repeated 5.5-kb rrn loci that encode ribosomal RNAs in Salmonella enterica. The closest rrn genes, rrnB and rrnE, flank a 40-kb region that includes the purHD operon. Duplications of purHD arise by exchanges between rrn loci and form at a high rate (10⁻³/cell/division) that remains high in strains blocked for early steps in recombination (recA, recB, and/or recF), but drops 30-fold in mutants blocked for later Holliday junction resolution (ruvC recG). The duplication defect of a ruvC recG mutant was fully corrected by an added mutation in any one of the recA, recB, or recF genes. To explain these results, we propose that early recombination defects activate an alternative single-strand annealing pathway for duplication formation. In wild-type cells, rrn duplications form primarily by the action of RecFORA on single-strand gaps. Double-strand breaks cannot initiate rrn duplications because rrn loci lack Chi sites, which are essential for recombination between two separated rrn sequences. A recA or recF mutation allows unrepaired gaps to accumulate such that different rrn loci can provide single-strand rrn sequences that lack the RecA coating that normally inhibits annealing. A recB mutation activates annealing by allowing double-strand ends within rrn to avoid digestion by RecBCD and provide a new source of rrn ends for use in annealing. The equivalent high rates of rrn duplication by recombination and annealing pathways may reflect a limiting economy of gaps and breaks arising in heavily transcribed, palindrome-rich rrn sequences.     

The dependence of postreplication repair on uvrB in a recF mutant of Escherichia coli K-12.

Summary Mutants carrying recF143 or recF144 show wild type levels of host cell reactivation of UV-irradiated vir and wild type rates of excision gap closure in repairing UV damage to their own DNA. The same mutants showed reduced rates of postreplication repair strand joining. When uvrA ^- recF^- or uvrB ^- recF^- strains are tested, postreplication repair strand joining is incomplete or does not occur at fluences above 1 J/m². We suggest that there may be a UvrAB and a RecF pathway of postreplication repair or that the repair functions controlled or determined by uvrA uvrB and by recF may be similar. An intermediate in postreplication repair may accumulate in the uvr ^- recF^- strain.     

Induction of E. coli recA protein via recBC and alternate pathways: quantitation by enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA)

Summary An enzyme-linked immunosorbent assay (ELISA) has been adapted to measure E. coli recA protein in the 1 to 10 ng range in whole-cell sonicates, membrane extracts, and osmotic shock fluid from 2x10⁸ cells. The specific activity of recA protein is maintained at a relatively constant basal level (800 to 1,200 molecules per cell for wild-type E. coli in L-broth, salt-depleted broth and minimal media) during early-log and mid-log phase growth, but it increases by two- to ten-fold as the culture approaches saturation density. Nalidixate-induced levels are 20- to 50-fold higher, and 100-fold higher in a constitutive tif ^- spr ^-mutant.Induction of recA protein synthesis by nalidixic acid, which normally requires functional recBC enzyme, also occurs in recB ^-and recC ^-cells by pathways activated by mutation in the sbcA and sbcB indirect suppressors. In recB ^- sbcA ^-mutants, exonuclease VIII, the recE gene product, is required for induction of recA protein. Abolition of exonuclease I activity by mutation in sbcB allows induction of recA protein by nalidixate in recB ^-and recC ^-cells. Mutation in recF does not affect induction by nalidixate in RecBC⁺ cells, but it enables induction to occur in RecBC^- cells, suggesting that recF gene product is involved in regulation of recA protein.     

Genetic analysis of constitutive stable DNA replication in rnh mutants of Escherichia coli K12

Summary Escherichia coli rnh mutants deficient in ribonuclease H (RNase H) are capable of DNA replication in the absence of protein synthesis. This constitutive stable DNA replication (SDR) is dependent upon the recA ⁺ gene product. The requirement of SDR for recA ⁺ can be suppressed by rin mutations (for recA⁺-independent), or by lexA(Def) mutations which inactivate the LexA repressor. Thus, there are at least three genetically distinct types of SDR in rnh mutants: recA ⁺-dependent SDR seen in rnh ^- rin⁺ lexA⁺ strains, recA ⁺-independent in rnh ^- rin^- lexA⁺, and recA ⁺-independent in rnh ^- rin⁺ lexA(Def). The expression of SDR in rin ^- and lexA(Def) mutants demonstrated a requirement for RNA synthesis and for the absence of RNase H. The suppression of the recA ⁺ requirement by rin mutations was shown to depend on some new function of the recF ⁺ gene product. In contrast, the suppression by lexA-(Def) mutations was not dependent on recF ⁺. The lexA3 mutation inhibited recA ⁺-dependent SDR via reducing the amount of recA ⁺ activity available, and was suppressed by the recAo254 mutation. The SDR in rnh ^- rin^- cells was also inhibited by the lexA3 mutation, but the inhibition was not reversed by the recAo254 mutation, indicating a requirement for some other lexA ⁺-regulated gene product in the recA ⁺-independent SDR process. A model is presented for the regulation of the expression of these three types of SDR by the products of the lexA ⁺, rin⁺ and recF ⁺ genes.     

Excision Repair Properties of Isogenic rec− Mutants of Escherichia coli K-12

We have examined the excision repair properties of isogenic rec⁻ and uvr⁻ strains of Escherichia coli K-12. A recB⁻recC⁻ strain excises dimers at a rate nearly that of the rec⁺ parent, reaching the same extent of excision after a 1-hr postirradiation incubation. recA⁻ and recA⁻recB⁻ strains excise 75 to 80% of the dimers excised by their rec⁺ parent, whereas a uvrB⁻ strain excises no dimers during a 1-hr incubation. The doses of ultraviolet light (254 nm) required to reduce survival to 37% of the original population are 8 ergs/mm² for recA or recA recB mutants, 5 ergs/mm² for the uvrB⁻ strain, 30 ergs/mm² for the recB recC mutant, and 230 ergs/mm² for the wild-type parent. From these data one cannot account for the ultraviolet light sensitivity of rec⁻ strains on the basis of their excision repair properties. We conclude that rec gene products play no significant role in the early steps of excision repair. The assay we have used for excision of thymine dimers is a modification of the Carrier-Setlow technique, and is described in detail in the Appendix to this paper. To show the properties and validity of this method, results of experiments with thymine dimers formed in vitro and in vivo in E. coli K-12 are presented. These results show our method to be reproducible and sensitive to 0.005% of the total radioactive thymine present in thymine-containing dimers.     

Effects of growth phase and repair capacity on rejoining of ethyl methanesulfonate-induced DNA breaks in Escherichia coli

The effects of growth phase and DNA repair capacity on the production and rejoining of ethyl methanesulfonate (EMS)-induced single-strand breaks were studied in 4 strains of E. coli. DNAs from logarithmic and stationary phase cells of the DNA polymerase I deficient mutant, P₃₄₇8 polA, a recombination deficient mutant, DZ₄₁₇recA, and from the respective parental strains, W₃₁₁₀pol⁺ and AB₂₅₃rec⁺ were examined by sedimentation in alkaline sucrose gradients.In both parental strains, stationary phase cells exhibited enhanced strand rejoining. In the mutants, alkylated DNA was repaired to some extent in both growth phases, but it contained a greater proportion of small DNA fragments compared to the parental strains. Some DNA breakdown occured in all four strains but this was most extensive in stationary phase cells of the repair-deficient mutants.These results indicate that the four strains can rejoin EMS-induced DNA strand breaks with varying efficiency depending on the physiological state and the genetic capacity for repair.     

Studies on radiation-sensitive mutants of E. coli. II. Breakage and repair of ultraviolet irradiated intracellular DNA of phage lambda

Summary It has been shown that linear DNA molecules of phage are converted to the twisted circular structure (species I) by covalent closure of the both strands at the cohesive ends after infection to the immune bacteria and that the twisted circular molecules are transformed to the circular form (species II) by a single-strand break in one of the strands of their DNA. This system offers a very sensitive method to study on the strand breaks or their repair. For characterization of the defects of ultraviolet sensitive strains, the structural changes of ultraviolet irradiated DNA in these strains were studied.Ultraviolet irradiation to phage greatly reduced the extent of conversion of the molecules to the species I in the uvrD mutant while the irradiation showed little effect on the conversion in the uvrA, B and C mutants. When infected bacteria carrying species I molecules were irradiated, the species I molecules in the uvrD mutant were disrupted while most of the molecules in the uvrA, B and C mutants kept the structure. These results indicate that in the irradiated DNA strand breaks are rarely introduced or, if introduced, repaired rapidly in the uvrA, B and C mutants and they are introduced in the uvrD mutant leading to the degradation of the DNA. These results provide a firm evidence that the defect of the uvrD mutant is different from other Her^- mutants and in the process of repair synthesis.Ultraviolet irradiation to the uvrD mutants promote the formation of the species I molecules from the infected irradiated -DNA.Such effect was not observed with the uvrA mutant. Since the uvrD mutant has UV reactivation capacity and the uvrA mutant has not, the above phenomenon is probably caused by UV reactivation and may provide a more direct method to study the mechanisms of UV reactivation than the plaque assay.Abbreviations used UV Ultraviolet light - UVr Ultraviolet light reactivation This work was aided in part by a research grant GM 08384 from the United States Public Health Service.     

Genetic recombination in Bacillus subtilis 168: effect of recN,recF, recH and addAB mutations on DNA repair and recombination

A recN ^? (recN1) strain of Bacillus subtilis was constructed. The effects of this and recF, recH and addAB mutations on recombination proficiency were tested. Mutations in the recN, recF recH and addAB genes, when present in an otherwise Rec⁺ B. subtilis strain, did not affect genetic exchange. Strains carrying different combinations of mutations in these genes were constructed and examined for their sensitivity to 4-nitroquinoline1-oxide (4NQO) and recombination proficiency. The recH mutation did not affect the 4NQO sensitivity of recN and recF cells and it only marginally affected that of addA addB cells. However, it reduced genetic recombination in these cells 10²- to 10⁴-fold. The addA addB mutations increased the 4NQO sensitivity of recF and recN cells, but completely blocked genetic recombination of recF cells and marginally affected recombination in recN cells. The recN mutation did not affect the recombinational capacity of recF cells. These data indicate that the recN gene product is required for, DNA repair and recombination and that the recF, recH and addAB genes provide overlapping activities that compensate for the effects of single mutants proficiency. We proposed that the recF, recH, recB and addA gene products define four different epistatic groups.     

Nucleotide excision repair and recombination are engaged in repair of trans-4-hydroxy-2-nonenal adducts to DNA bases in Escherichia coli

One of the major products of lipid peroxidation is trans-4-hydroxy-2-nonenal (HNE). HNE forms highly mutagenic and genotoxic adducts to all DNA bases. Using M13 phage lacZ system, we studied the mutagenesis and repair of HNE treated phage DNA in E. coli wild-type or uvrA, recA, and mutL mutants. These studies revealed that: (i) nucleotide excision and recombination, but not mismatch repair, are engaged in repair of HNE adducts when present in phage DNA replicating in E. coli strains; (ii) in the single uvrA mutant, phage survival was drastically decreased while mutation frequency increased, and recombination events constituted 48 % of all mutations; (iii) in the single recA mutant, the survival and mutation frequency of HNE-modified M13 phage was slightly elevated in comparison to that in the wild-type bacteria. The majority of mutations in recA^- strain were G:C → T:A transversions, occurring within the sequence which in recA⁺ strains underwent RecA-mediated recombination, and the entire sequence was deleted; (iv) in the double uvrA recA mutant, phage survival was the same as in the wild-type although the mutation frequency was higher than in the wild-type and recA single mutant, but lower than in the single uvrA mutant. The majority of mutations found in the latter strain were base substitutions, with G:C → A:T transitions prevailing. These transitions could have resulted from high reactivity of HNE with G and C, and induction of SOS-independent mutations.     

Role for the RecBCD recombination pathway for pilE gene variation in repair-proficient Neisseria gonorrhoeae

The role of the RecBCD recombination pathway in PilE antigenic variation in Neisseria gonorrhoeae is contentious and appears to be strain dependent. In this study, N. gonorrhoeae strain MS11 recB mutants were assessed for recombination/repair. MS11 recB mutants were found to be highly susceptible to DNA treatments that caused double-chain breaks and were severely impaired for growth; recB growth suppressor mutants arose at high frequencies. When the recombination/repair capacity of strain MS11 was compared to that of strains FA1090 and P9, innate differences were observed between the strains, with FA1090 and P9 rec⁺ bacteria presenting pronounced recombination/repair defects. Consequently, MS11 recB mutants present a more robust phenotype than the other strains that were tested. In addition, MS11 recB mutants are also shown to be defective for pilE/pilS recombination. Moreover, pilE/pilS recombination is shown to proceed with gonococci that carry inverted pilE loci. Consequently, a novel RecBCD-mediated double-chain-break repair model for PilE antigenic variation is proposed.     

Genetic control of damage-inducible restriction alleviation in Escherichia coli K12: an SOS function not repressed by lexA

Summary The alleviation of K-specific DNA restriction after treatment of cells by UV or nalidixic acid has been studied in mutants with various alleles of recA and lexA and combinations of these alleles and with recB and recF mutations. The studies show that induction of restriction alleviation by UV or nalidixic acid is abolished in mutants in which the recA protein is defective (recA13, recA56), its protease activity is altered (recA430) or in which it cannot be efficiently activated (recA142). Thermoinduction of restriction alleviation was observed in tif mutant (recA441). In lexA amber mutants restriction alleviation is not constitutive but is still inducible. In a lexA3 mutant restriction alleviation is inducible by nalidixic acid provided that recA protein is overproduced as a result of a recA operator mutation. Induction by UV depends on the recF function and an unidentified function (Y) which is controlled by the lexA protein. The recBC enzyme is necessary for induction by UV or by nalidixic acid. Temperature shift experiments with a thermosensitive recB mutant indicate that the recBC enzyme functions in an early step during UV-induction. It is concluded that the damage-inducible function which alleviates restriction is similar to other damage inducible repair (SOS) functions in the dependence on activated recA protease for induction, but that it differs from these functions by the absence of a direct control through the lexA repressor.     

Construction of a recF deletion mutant of Azotobacter vinelandii and its characterization

A deletion was engineered in the cloned recF gene by digestion with suitable restriction endonucleases and a tetracycline resistance gene cartridge was inserted. The mutation was subsequently transferred to the Azotobacter vinelandii chromosome by double cross-over under pressure of tetracycline selection. A recF recA mutant was also constructed in a similar manner. The mutations were found to be stable and mutation of the wild-type recF gene was confirmed by Southern blot hybridization. Both the mutants were UV sensitive and recombination deficient. Mutations in genes involved in nitrogen fixation in A. vinelandii are rather frequent and obtained comparatively easily despite of the presence of multiple identical chromosomes in A. vinelandii. It has been speculated that some kind of `homogenotization' process operates which is responsible for the `transmission' of mutation from one chromosome to all the chromosomes. This process is not affected by a mutation in recF or recA or in both recF and recA.     

RecBCD- RecFOR-independent pathway of homologous recombination in Escherichia coli

The RecA protein is a key bacterial recombination enzyme that catalyzes pairing and strand exchange between homologous DNA duplexes. In Escherichia coli, RecA protein assembly on DNA is mediated either by the RecBCD or RecFOR protein complexes. Correspondingly, two recombination pathways, RecBCD and RecF (or RecFOR), are distinguished in E. coli. Inactivation of both pathways in recB(CD) recF(OR) mutants results in severe recombination deficiency. Here we describe a novel, RecBCD- RecFOR-independent (RecBFI) recombination pathway that is active in ΔrecBCD sbcB15 sbcC(D) ΔrecF(OR) mutants of E. coli. In transductional crosses, these mutants show only four-fold decrease of recombination frequency relative to the wild-type strain. At the same time they recombine 40- to 90-fold better than their sbcB⁺ sbcC⁺ and ΔsbcB sbcC counterparts. The RecBFI pathway strongly depends on recA, recJ and recQ gene functions, and moderately depends on recG and lexA functions. Inactivation of dinI, helD, recX, recN, radA, ruvABC and uvrD genes has a slight effect on RecBFI recombination. After exposure to UV and gamma irradiation, the ΔrecBCD sbcB15 sbcC ΔrecF mutants show moderately increased DNA repair proficiency relative to their sbcB⁺ sbcC⁺ and ΔsbcB sbcC counterparts. However, introduction of recA730 allele (encoding RecA protein with enhanced DNA binding properties) completely restores repair proficiency to ΔrecBCD sbcB15 sbcC ΔrecF mutants, but not to their sbcB⁺ sbcC⁺ and ΔsbcB sbcC derivatives. Fluorescence microscopy with UV-irradiated recA-gfp fusion mutants suggests that the kinetics of RecA filament formation might be slowed down in the RecBFI pathway. Inactivation of 3′-5′ exonucleases ExoVII, ExoIX and ExoX cannot activate the RecBFI pathway in ΔrecBCD ΔsbcB sbcC ΔrecF mutants. Taken together, our results show that the product of the sbcB15 allele is crucial for RecBFI pathway. Besides protecting 3′ overhangs, SbcB15 protein might play an additional, more active role in formation of the RecA filament.     

Stimulation of recombination between homologous sequences on carcinogen-treated plasmid DNA and chromosomal DNA by induction of the SOS response in Escherichia coli K12

Summary Previous studies have shown that transformation of Escherichia coli by plasmid DNA modified in vitro by carcinogens leads to RecA-dependant recombination between homologous plasmid and chromosomal DNA sequences. The mechanism of this recombination has now been studied using recombination-deficient mutants, and the influence of induction of the SOS response on the level of recombination investigated. Plasmid pNO1523, containing the str ⁺ operon (Sm^s), has been modified in vitro by either irradiation with UV light, or by reaction with (±) trans-benzo(a)pyrene-7,8-dihydrodiol-9,10-epoxide (BPDE) and used to transform streptomycin-resistant hosts. The formation of Amp^r transformants which also carry streptomycin resistance was used as a measure of the level of recombination between plasmid and chromosomal DNA. Transformation of recB and recC mutants produced no change in the level of recombination while in the recF mutant a significant decrease was observed compared to the wild type host. Thermal induction of the SOS response in tif-1 and tif-1 umuC mutants followed by transformation led to a four-fold increase in recombination in both cases. The results suggest that the streptomycin-resistant transformants arise exclusively via a recombinational pathway which is largely dependant on the recF gene product, and that this pathway is influenced by induction of the SOS response. These results are discussed in terms of the mechanism of this recombination.